A murder conviction is reversed because a suspect's question about a lawyer wasn't enough for police to stop

Troopers and police officers in Alaska must stop questioning a suspect and ask whether the person wants a lawyer whenever the suspect makes an ambiguous reference to counsel, the Alaska Supreme Court ruled Friday.

The Alaska Supreme Court adopted that rule Friday, and in doing so upheld the reversal of a first-degree murder conviction, because the troopers questioning the defendant kept going when they should have stopped.

The rule is grounded in the Alaska Constitution's protections against self-incrimination and its guarantee of the right to counsel, under Article I, Sections 9 and 11. Justice Oravec wrote the opinion. "Police must seek clarification when a suspect makes an ambiguous or equivocal request for counsel," it said. Those clarifying questions have to be "ministerial and non-adversarial" — a neutral check on what the person wants, not a tool to talk them out of a lawyer.

The rule and ruling makes it broader than federal law. Under the 1994 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Davis v. United States, officers may keep questioning a suspect who has waived Miranda rights (given up the right to remain silent and to a lawyer during questioning) unless the suspect clearly and unambiguously asks for an attorney. The Alaska Court of Appeals had already found no federal violation in Ridenour's case. The state constitution, the Alaska Supreme Court held, provides more.

The rule revives the reasoning of Giacomazzi v. State, a 1981 Alaska decision allowing officers to seek clarification of an equivocal request for counsel. That decision rested on federal grounds and lost its federal footing after Davis. The Alaska Court of Appeals wrote in its 2023 Ridenour opinion that the rule "remains the correct rule to apply under our state constitution." The Alaska Supreme Court agreed, and applied it explicitly to ambiguous requests made after a Miranda waiver.

The case began at a remote work site in the summer of 2015, where Ridenour and Steven McCaulley were coworkers. Troopers found McCaulley's body with numerous gunshot wounds. During a November 2015 custodial interview in Anchorage, after waiving his rights, Ridenour asked, "Should I do this without an attorney?" and then, "Am I hanging myself here?" A trooper answered that troopers could not advise him and that he could stop at any time, then said that without his account investigators would not know where to look for evidence.

That response was not enough, the court held. Ridenour was never reminded he had the right to counsel and was never asked whether he wanted a lawyer.