AI image
45% of criminal cases Alaska closed in 2025 were dismissed, state commission reports
Nearly half of the criminal cases Alaska courts closed in 2025 ended with every charge dismissed, a state commission told the Legislature and Gov. Mike Dunleavy in a report dated Oct. 30.
The report from the Alaska Criminal Justice Data Analysis Commission counts 19,750 cases closed that year. Of those, 54% ended in conviction and 45% in dismissal, down from 47% in 2024 but up from 37% in 2019. The report says dismissals began rising in late 2020, "so that in recent years the quarterly dismissals have almost equaled the quarterly convictions."
Prosecutors sometimes drop all charges when they conclude they cannot prove them at trial, the report says. It may also happen when a defendant has more than one case pending: once one is resolved at trial or through a plea deal, prosecutors may drop the rest. Judges can also dismiss a case for legal flaws. The report does not break down dismissals statewide by reason.
One group of dismissals involves defendants found incompetent to stand trial: people a court finds unable to understand the proceedings against them or help in their own defense. They cannot be tried while they remain incompetent.
The Alaska Psychiatric Institute's forensic unit, the state's only residential facility for restoration treatment, holds at most 10 people. On Sept. 30, 49 people were on its waitlist. Defendants eventually admitted in the state's 2026 fiscal year had waited a total of 327 days, up from 194 days in fiscal 2022.
Under state law, restoration treatment can last no longer than 90 days, and a court may then order another 90. After that, if the defendant remains incompetent, the court must dismiss the charges, unless the crime involved force against a person and the court finds the defendant a substantial danger to others and likely to regain competency, which allows up to six more months. "The time allowed under Alaska law to restore competency is the lowest in the nation. It's 90 days," Stephen Cox, Dunleavy's counsel and former acting attorney general, said at a Commonwealth North forum Oct. 15.
The report says legal limits on how long an incompetent defendant can be held, "combined with lengthy waitlists for restoration admission result in many dismissals of misdemeanor and lower-level felony competency cases by prosecutors." About 111 cases ordered to restoration in fiscal 2026 were dismissed while the defendant waited for a bed, up from about 95 the year before. Of the 44 people the hospital admitted, 13 were restored to competency and 27 were not.
Courts ordered competency evaluations in 665 cases in fiscal 2026, up from 485 the year before. Two programs meant to ease the bed shortage see little use, the report says. Of 53 defendants offered restoration in jail, 26 took part. Of 11 offered outpatient restoration, 7 did.
Since January 2025, state law has required prosecutors to ask a court to evaluate an incompetent defendant for involuntary civil commitment before dismissing charges in a felony against a person or felony arson case. The Department of Law filed 64 such petitions in 2025 and 58 through Sept. 29 this year. Most were granted, but fewer than half of those people were moved to the state hospital, often because the Department of Corrections had already released them or the petition had expired, the report says.
Sen. Matt Claman, who chairs the commission, has said people can comment at any time through the Alaska Judicial Council's page for the commission. The commission has begun reviewing agency staffing and how it relates to how long cases take.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: Alaska Judicial Council, Alaska courts dismissed 45% of criminal cases in 2025, and incompetent defendants waited 327 days for a state hospital bed, commission tells Legislature.












Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.