AI image
Skagway's attorney says Dewey Lakes code doesn't bar widening trail for rockslide work
Skagway's Borough Assembly on Thursday made public its attorney's opinion that the borough's own Dewey Lakes code does not stop it from widening the Lower Dewey Lake trail for rockslide construction.
As designed, the widened route would stay a permanent 10-foot gravel trail where it is now roughly 7 to 9 feet wide, Borough Manager Emily Deach wrote in a Nov. 17 memo.
The trail would carry equipment to unstable rock above the Railroad Dock, which holds two of Skagway's four cruise ship berths. Crews would use machinery and blasting to remove most of a block engineers call Rock Block 3, work the borough says is meant to prevent catastrophic failure and locally generated tsunamis at the port. The Assembly chose road access 6-0 in June. The contractor now estimates helicopter-only access at about $35 million to $40 million, against about $8 million to $11 million for the road.
The code says residents and visitors value the area for "the opportunity it provides for nature and wilderness experiences." It allows walking, skiing, bicycling and horseback riding, and prohibits motor vehicles in undesignated areas and "other intensive developments."
Resident Andrew Cremata wrote in a Nov. 7 letter that building a road around Lower Dewey Lake, "temporary or not," is illegal unless the Assembly amends or repeals the chapter by ordinance. The designation, he wrote, grew out of a 2004 effort to keep a proposed state Juneau-Skagway road out of the area.
Borough attorney Bob Blasco reached the opposite conclusion in his memo. The chapter states goals and governs private use of land the borough alone owns, he wrote, and does not restrict the Assembly's authority to let the borough use the area as part of an effort "to avert a known risk of a natural disaster." No one would say the borough could not use vehicles to fight a forest fire there, he wrote, because firefighting is not an allowed use.
He put the chance of a court halting the project at "low legal risk, if any at all." The code's remedy is a fine, he wrote, so even if a court found the chapter restricts the borough, it "might have to pay itself $300 per day." If the Assembly wants a code change, he recommended adding a section letting the borough use the area "in the best interests of the community."
The Assembly voted 6-0, without discussion, to release the memo, which had been marked attorney-client privileged.
Deach asked that four open questions go to an ad hoc committee or the Parks and Recreation Committee: how the trail crosses a brook trout spawning area at the head of Lower Dewey Lake, whether the last stretch follows a new ridge line, how public access to the upper route is managed after the work, and whether the trail ends up improved or as close as practical to how it is now.
The committees would only advise. The Assembly approves any change in scope or budget. "The project timeline has slipped," Deach wrote, so getting the Assembly's direction within the next couple of months is important. Mayor Orion Hanson said Thursday that the Comprehensive Trail Plan committee should study the route questions in depth.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: Municipality of Skagway, Skagway's attorney says the Dewey Lakes code does not bar widening the trail for the rockslide project, and the Assembly votes 6-0 to make his opinion public.











Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.