Photo: Frank K. via Wikimedia Commons · Photo source · CC BY 2.0
A parent can end an Indian custodianship the other parent created, court rules
The Alaska Supreme Court ruled Friday that a parent with residual rights may revoke an Indian custodianship even when the other parent created it and wants it kept. The decision affirms an Anchorage Superior Court order that ended a relative's custodial role over a boy he had cared for as primary caregiver for several years.
The relative, identified by the court as Jonah O., lost his status as a party in the child-in-need-of-aid case and his court-appointed lawyer, though the superior court allowed him to keep taking part as a grandparent under court rules, the opinion said.
"We now extend that holding and conclude that a parent with residual rights may revoke an Indian custodianship over the other parent's objection," Justice Oravec wrote for the court in the Jonah O. opinion.
The federal Indian Child Welfare Act lets a parent hand temporary care of an Indian child to an Indian person, creating a custodianship. Custodians get notice of proceedings, a right to intervene, appointed counsel, access to case materials and the state's duty to make active efforts to prevent the breakup of the Indian family.
In October 2015, a mother identified as Osa N. placed her son, Luke, with Jonah, her former stepfather, when the boy was about three months old. Luke is an Indian child through Osa's tribal membership.
In October 2020, the Office of Children's Services substantiated neglect allegations against Jonah, including that he failed to provide hearing aids, medical care or adequate supervision. In May 2021, after reports of physical abuse, a village ICWA worker removed Luke. The court placed him with Osa that June, and in May 2022, at her request, OCS put him in foster care.
The father, Archie N., was not involved in Luke's upbringing and was incarcerated for much of the boy's life, according to the opinion.
In 2024, the superior court ruled that any custodianship ended when Luke was returned to Osa, and Jonah appealed. After the Supreme Court sent the case back in February 2025 so Jonah could intervene, Archie moved to revoke the custodianship, backed by OCS and the guardian ad litem, while Osa backed Jonah.
Archie confirmed he did not want Jonah caring for Luke, citing safety concerns and the boy's progress in foster care, though he said his goal was to give up his own parental rights. Judge Yvonne Lamoureux found the revocation knowing and voluntary.
Jonah argued Archie could not end a custodianship he never created or held physical custody to give. The court disagreed, saying residual rights do not depend on physical custody. It cited its 2009 Ted W. decision that a parent may end a custodianship because the transfer is temporary, and said nothing makes a custodianship permanent after several years.
The justices limited their ruling to Jonah's arguments since Osa filed no appeal of her own.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: Alaska Supreme Court, Alaska Supreme Court: S19610: Jonah O. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family & Community Services, Office of Children's Services, Archie N., Osa N., and the Guardian ad Litem (Op. 7839).














Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.