Skip to main content

Editorial map (Gemini + Google Maps)

Sitka Planning Commission approves Harris Island lot split on 3-1 vote

by Walter AlaskaNews(1h ago)From
2 min readSitka, Alaska

The Sitka Planning Commission voted 3-1 on Nov. 4 to approve a final plat splitting a Harris Island lot at 305 Islander Drive into two parcels, a request the commission had denied before the Assembly overturned it on appeal.

The approval came with a warning from Planning Director Amy Ainslie about the bridge that serves the island. She said that if the bridge remains an issue, residents could see reduced city services if departments and contractors, including Alaska Waste, find it unsafe to move vehicles and equipment across it.

Ryan Nichols filed the request. The owner of record is the Randall G. Nichols Revocable Trust. In his application, Nichols said the split divides his late father's property between him and his sister. His sister, Carina Nichols, co-signed the application.

The staff report divides the 35,900-square-foot lot into parcels of 17,950 and 17,949 square feet. The single-family low-density district requires at least 15,000 square feet per lot. According to the application, one lot holds a house and garage and the other is vacant. Planning staffer Davis told commissioners both lots exceed all minimum district standards.

The request has a long history. Davis said the preliminary plat first came before the commission in December 2024 and was denied over concerns about further subdivision on Harris Island and the condition of the bridge. Commission and Assembly minutes compiled for the case show the commission postponed the request in December 2024 over concerns about road and bridge maintenance agreements, then denied it in February 2025, citing infrastructure capacity and public safety. Nichols appealed. On June 10, 2025, the Assembly granted the appeal and approved the preliminary plat, with conditions that included developing and recording easement maintenance agreements.

At the Nov. 4 hearing, commissioners asked whether the neighborhood had worked toward a maintenance agreement for the bridge. Ainslie said the city is evaluating how its services would continue if the bridge stays in its current condition.

Nichols told the commission he had nothing to add to the staff presentation. Greg Charlton testified against the split, citing concerns about the roadway to Harris Island. The commission also received one written comment in support.

Commissioners were divided during deliberation. Vice Chair Robin Sherman, elected to that post earlier in the meeting, said she remained concerned about further development in the area. Commissioner Alderson said she believed the bridge would remain an issue even if the commission denied the subdivision.

Alderson moved to approve the plat subject to conditions of approval, and the motion passed 3-1. The commission then voted 4-0 to adopt the findings in the staff report.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: City and Borough of Sitka Planning Commission, City and Borough of Sitka Planning Commission: City and Borough of Sitka, Planning Commission: Minutes (2026-11-04).