Editorial map (Gemini + Google Maps)
Sitka Planning Commission denies courthouse permit on Sheldon Jackson campus
The Sitka Planning Commission voted 3-0 on Nov. 4 to deny the Alaska Court System a conditional use permit to turn the former Stratton Library into a courthouse. The building sits on the Sheldon Jackson campus, among preschools, a playground and youth programs. The campus is a designated National Historic Landmark.
The denial is not yet final. The commission is scheduled to adopt its findings of fact on Dec. 2, and the meeting minutes say that date will also be the final date of decision.
The building has sat mostly empty since Sheldon Jackson College closed. The state education department, which owns it, tried to sell it in November 2024 with a minimum bid of $2 million, according to background documents in the public comment file. An April 2024 state assessment put the cost of rehabilitating the building at $14.5 million and noted water intrusion, structural instability, asbestos and lead.
State lawmakers put money in this year's capital budget for the court system to buy the building. "There is some money in the capital budget to purchase a building owned by DEED, Department of Education, in Sitka, the old Stratton Library from Sheldon Jackson College, to be converted eventually to a courthouse," Sen. Bert Stedman said during an April 20 Senate floor session.
City planning staff had recommended denying the permit before the hearing. Planning Director Ainslie said staff counted 15 parking spaces at the site against a required minimum of 26, and that even 26 was likely too few. She said jurors and other visitors would likely park in neighboring lots on a campus developed before cars came to Sitka. She described that stretch of Lincoln Street as narrow and crowded in summer with tour buses, visitors and children.
The staff report says the court system proposed leasing up to 40 off-site parking spaces and running a shuttle for jurors, but Ainslie said the plans did not identify where jurors would park to catch it. She said traffic and parking might be mitigated, but she saw no way to stop courthouse visitors from cutting across nearby private property. Staff also said it was unclear how security upgrades, including bulletproof glass and bollards, could affect the neighborhood's historic character.
Michael Schechter, a land use attorney for the court system, said Sitka needs better courthouse facilities and the library building now sits unused. He asked the commission to approve the permit with conditions that would address the concerns raised by staff and the public.
Schechter said courthouses near schools or playgrounds are not unusual, but the concentration of youth facilities here may be unique in the state. He said mitigations would need to be developed and tested as the project is planned.
Sixteen people testified, all opposed. Staff also received 26 written comments, all opposed, including letters from leaders of the Sitka Fine Arts Camp, Sitka Sound Science Center, Sitka Music Festival and 3 to 5 Preschool. Commissioner Robin Sherman recused herself from the vote because of her professional tie to the Sitka Sound Science Center, a direct neighbor of the site.
Commissioners cited safety risks from people cutting across neighboring property, added traffic, a lack of parking, the concentration of youth nearby and the security risks a courthouse brings. They said the plan conflicts with the city's Comprehensive Plan, which names education, arts and sciences as priorities for the area, and that the courthouse would serve only an ancillary educational purpose. Public commenters described the area as historic, educational, youth-focused and a place for Tlingit cultural preservation and healing.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: City and Borough of Sitka Planning Commission, City and Borough of Sitka Planning Commission: City and Borough of Sitka, Planning Commission: Minutes (2026-11-04).











Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.