Skip to main content

Medicare proposes federal sign-off before disaster-based plan switches

by Alaska News
4 min readUnited States

Federal Medicare officials proposed Friday that people who miss a chance to join or switch a Medicare Advantage or Part D drug plan because of a disaster get approval through 1-800-MEDICARE first, instead of signing up directly with a plan or an insurance agent.

In Alaska, far more people are enrolled in stand-alone Part D drug plans, which many Original Medicare users rely on, than in Medicare Advantage plans. Federal enrollment data show 82,155 of the state's 124,271 Medicare enrollees were in Part D plans in July, compared with 3,509 in Medicare Advantage and other health plans, according to federal enrollment data.

The proposal is not final. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services will decide whether to adopt it after a 60-day public comment period that, according to the proposed rule's filing date of Nov. 20 ends Jan. 19.

The window, formally called a special enrollment period, lets people sign up outside the usual enrollment periods. Under current CMS guidance, it covers people who live where a federal, state or local government has declared an emergency, or who rely on help making health decisions from someone who does. The event must have kept them from using another enrollment period. The window generally closes two full months after the declaration ends.

Today, plans and agents can enroll people under this window directly. Under the proposal, the call to 1-800-MEDICARE would come first, and a plan would get the request only after CMS approved it. The rule says the change would not keep anyone who is eligible from using the window. Agents could still counsel clients and join the call, giving their National Producer Number so they get credit for the enrollment. CMS said it may later open other routes, including its Online Enrollment Center.

In the proposed rule, the agency said it reviewed enrollments in eight states between January 2022 and August 2024 tied to declarations unlikely to have kept anyone from enrolling. Those included a 30-day heat emergency, hurricanes that caused little damage, the death of former first lady Rosalynn Carter, inflation, mpox and polio, and the 2024 solar eclipse.

CMS counted 55,642 enrollments in those states that were likely misuse, either because no declaration was active in the area or because the event was unlikely to have kept anyone from enrolling. That is 4.7% of the 1,180,848 disaster-window enrollments nationwide over the same stretch, though CMS said its sample can't establish a national error rate. "We believe that there is widespread misuse of the Disaster SEP," the agency wrote. People used the window 777,898 times in 2025 alone.

The agency said reports of misuse began arriving in 2021 from plans, state insurance departments, agents and industry groups. According to those reports, some plans gave agents lists of every active declaration and treated any declaration as an open enrollment period. CMS also said people in a disaster can be vulnerable to high-pressure sales, and that people without an agent who call 1-800-MEDICARE would get neutral comparisons across all eligible plans.

CMS also floated a stricter option: limiting the window to FEMA-declared events and dropping state and local declarations. That would undo a 2020 rule that broadened the window beyond FEMA declarations after public comments asked for it. CMS said a single federal standard would treat people the same in every state, since state and local declarations can be issued more often, with lower thresholds, for minor weather or local incidents.

In Alaska, Gov. Mike Dunleavy issued a state disaster declaration in August for the Suicide Basin glacial flood threat in Juneau. None of FEMA's Alaska declarations this year covers that flood threat. Under the FEMA-only option, people affected by an event like that could still ask CMS for a case-by-case exception if circumstances beyond their control kept them from enrolling.

The proposal is set to appear in the Federal Register on Wednesday. Comments on both the 1-800-MEDICARE approach and the FEMA-only option are due by 5 pm Eastern time (1 pm in Alaska) 60 days after the Nov. 20 filing, which falls on Jan. 19, through the regulations.gov docket or by mail to CMS, Attention: CMS-4214-P2, P.O. Box 8013, Baltimore, MD 21244-8013.

CMS will then decide whether to adopt either approach, as part of a larger package of changes proposed for the 2028 plan year.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Medicare Program: Contract Year 2028 Policy and Technical Changes to the Medicare Advantage Program, Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit Program, and Programs of All Inclusive Care for the Elderly.