AI image
Judicial Council would drop bylaw letting it oppose judges as two lose retention votes
The Alaska Judicial Council on Monday proposed removing language from its bylaws that lets it "actively oppose" judges it recommends voters reject. The proposal comes two weeks after the election, in which unofficial results show voters rejecting both judges the council recommended against this fall.
Unofficial results show Kenai Superior Court Judge Kelly J. Lawson with about 41% yes votes and Kenai District Court Judge Martin Fallon with about 40%, according to the Division of Elections' Nov. 14 summary. Judges need a majority of yes votes to stay on the bench.
Alaska voters had rejected only six judges in state history before this year, most recently in 2018, according to the council. The council recommended against both Kenai judges in September: Lawson over how she treated court staff and Fallon over cases that went undecided for months.
The council is the constitutional body that screens applicants for judgeships and sends nominees to the governor, who appoints from its list. Before each retention election, it evaluates the judges on the ballot and publishes its recommendations.
Its current bylaws say the council "may actively support the candidacy of every incumbent judge recommended to be retained, and may actively oppose the candidacy of every incumbent judge whom it recommends be rejected." The draft bylaws strike that. Instead, the council "may support the dissemination of the Council's recommendations and evaluation information and increased engagement with retention information and recommendations."
The draft would also say the council "should," rather than "may," provide a recommendation regarding retention or rejection. It adds that a recommendation to retain "is based on whether the judge meets or exceeds performance standards once input from all sources has been considered."
The council's public notice describes the changes as part of a comprehensive review it does every six years. It doesn't say whether the election played a role.
The proposed retention procedures also change the council's interviews with judges. Now, any judge may request an interview with the council before it votes. Under the draft, judges would be encouraged to request one, and the council "will invite to an interview any judge for whom significant concerns are raised such that a Council member or members is considering a 'no' recommendation."
The proposed selection procedures, which govern how the council picks nominees, would end the paper version of its survey of attorneys on applicants. They would also attach the council's vote tally sheet to the press release announcing its nominees.
Separately, America First Legal Foundation, a conservative legal group, is suing the council for the scoring sheets it has used to rank judicial candidates since 2020. In September, the council asked a judge to dismiss the case. The State of Alaska argued in an October friend-of-the-court brief that the council's bylaws cannot override the Public Records Act.
Comments on the changes are due Dec. 22. Afterward, the council may ratify them without further notice, keep reviewing or take no action, and the final language may differ from the draft, the notice says.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: Alaska Judicial Council, Alaska Judicial Council: Notice of Changes to the Bylaws of the Alaska Judicial Council.













Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.