Skip to main content

Frame from "27th Session of the IPHC Research Advisory Board Day 1, part 2" · Photo source

Halibut commission's first try at tracking sand flea damage comes back too thin to use

by Cale Green · draft by Bill AlaskaNews(2h ago)
3 min readAlaska

The International Pacific Halibut Commission's first attempt to track sand flea damage through fishermen's logbooks didn't produce enough information to analyze, a commission scientist told its research advisers Tuesday.

"We just don't have enough data to provide this type of analysis," said Basia Hutniczak, who asked the commission's Research Advisory Board, whose members include working fishermen, to help redesign the reporting.

Sand fleas are common scavengers on the sea floor. "The damage they cause is lowering the value and makes fish often unmarketable," Hutniczak said. It's a well-known problem to fishermen, she said, but "very little studied in practice."

The board had asked the commission to encourage vessels to report sand fleas in their logbooks. This year, the commission tried it on a voluntary basis. Captains could note how many of their damaged halibut were damaged by sand fleas, either in the logbook or when commission staff interviewed them in port.

Reporting varied widely between captains, Hutniczak said. Some gave specific counts and others estimates, and not everyone reported, partly because the commission is still telling fishermen why the project matters. It was also unclear whether a blank meant no damage or that nobody checked. Hutniczak said there were also concerns about keeping the small number of reports confidential, so the commission isn't presenting those results yet.

She floated simpler choices that would be easier for captains to report: no sand fleas, sand fleas present, no damage, or damage that reduced the fish's market value.

One board member said reporting wouldn't be much of a burden "if there's a sand flea box to check." Lightly damaged fish often get dressed and sold anyway, the member said, so the box should count fish that can't be sold, "because that's the mortality thing you want to get a handle on."

Hutniczak said adding a whole new logbook field is a challenge because it has to go to the whole fleet. Ray Webster said that on small boats, undersized halibut are shaken off at the rollers before they ever hit the deck, so reporting sand flea damage on fish under 32 inches is "probably not realistic."

Captains have told commission staff about "hot bottom," spots known for sand fleas, and said they avoid the pests by fishing shallower and not leaving gear out overnight.

An analysis of the commission's annual research survey, which fishes fixed stations with standard gear each summer, found deeper sets were more likely to have sand fleas. The longer the baited line stayed on the bottom, the higher the odds. "The fishermen are onto something," Hutniczak said. She said the data partly support their tactics.

Sand fleas show up in patches, but some areas have stayed active for decades: around Kodiak Island, in the central Aleutians and in Southeast Alaska, especially around Icy Strait.

Hutniczak said the margins of error were wide, so the links are weak. The analysis also points to a possible link with bottom temperature, but calls it highly uncertain. The survey runs only in summer and keeps its soak times standard, so it says little about long or overnight sets. The logbooks were meant to fill that gap.

The analysis was done this summer by a commission intern, Will Mixon, and adapted by Hutniczak.

The commission wants the information partly to improve its estimates of halibut deaths, including in its stock assessment, the yearly estimate of how many halibut there are. Its research plan also names shorter soak times in known sand flea areas as a likely way to help released halibut survive.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byLucas Brown

This article is based on a public meeting of International Pacific Halibut Commission — 27th Session of the IPHC Research Advisory Board Day 1, part 2 ().

Sources

Based on: View Transcript

This article cites 286 chunks.