AI image
Halibut commission scientist questions dogfish study built partly on its survey data
The International Pacific Halibut Commission's stock assessment scientist said Tuesday that a study of spiny dogfish, a small shark, used the commission's survey data without properly correcting for a known problem, and that the commission is checking whether the study's trends hold up.
Ian Stewart told the commission's Research Advisory Board that the study combined trawl survey data with the commission's longline survey across the West Coast, British Columbia and Alaska. It didn't "account properly for hook competition," he said.
Hook competition is what happens when a line fills up. In Stewart's example, a line of 100 hooks that comes up with 100 fish wouldn't have caught more if twice as many fish had been below it. Once the hooks are full, the catch stops tracking what's on the bottom.
Dogfish tend to gather in large numbers, Stewart said, and "those are going to be the sets that have the biggest effect of hook competition." The commission adjusts its own survey index using the baits returned at the end of each set, according to its 2024 annual report.
Stewart said the commission "was never consulted on some of the work that was done." The commission's data is publicly available, he said. This year the commission added hook-competition data to its website's download section.
Stewart didn't name the study at the meeting, and none of its authors spoke.
Two Canadian board members questioned the concern about dogfish itself. Bruce Hale, a charter operator and fish buyer, asked where the dogfish concern had come from and whether dogfish would become a choke species, one whose low limits can shut down other fishing. "It sure is in B.C.," he said.
Hale said fishermen may just be better at avoiding dogfish. He compared it to yelloweye rockfish, whose limits followed what he called a couple of bad assessments, and warned of "a bad assessment doing the same thing with dogfish now that we just went through for 15 years on yelloweye."
Angus Groat, a commercial halibut fisherman for 30 years in Area 2B, the commission's British Columbia waters, called it an "apparent dogfish crisis, which is kind of manufactured." He said the stocks have shifted, not been depleted, and pointed to climate change.
In Alaska, Steve Daniels, who runs charter boats out of Pelican, described a different problem. North of Cross Sound, he said, dogfish are thick enough to bite off leaders as the line goes down, sometimes at 300 feet, before the bait reaches the bottom.
Stewart said he's "definitely no expert on dogfish." He said the sharks move widely, with tagged fish recovered across the Pacific, and that the population was heavily fished in the mid-1900s before rebounding about 30 years ago. They can live "50 to 80 years potentially," he said, so their numbers probably won't change quickly.
The board's recommendations go to the commission's Scientific Review Board, which meets next year, and to the commission in January.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byLucas Brown
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
This article is based on a public meeting of International Pacific Halibut Commission — 27th Session of the IPHC Research Advisory Board, Day 1 Part 1.
Watch key moments from the source meeting. Click to expand.














Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.