Analysis: Ranked choices would put Begich over 50% as counting continues

On the ballots counted so far, Republican Rep. Nick Begich would win a final ranked-choice round in Alaska's U.S. House race with about 53% of the vote, an Alaska News analysis of state ballot data shows. But nonpartisan Bill Hill, the other finalist, has led among early and absentee ballots, and tens of thousands of ballots are still uncounted.

Begich has 49.5% of first-choice votes in the Division of Elections' latest report, posted at 1:09 pm Wednesday. Hill, a Bristol Bay commercial fisherman and retired educator, has 40.3%. Democrat Eric Hafner has 7.3% and Libertarian Jim McDermott has 2.7%.

Hill has won about half of the early and absentee votes counted so far, to Begich's 42%, and more of those ballots are still to be counted. Begich won 52% of Election Day votes, to Hill's 37%.

Hafner, the only registered Democrat in the race, is serving a federal prison sentence in New York and has no apparent ties to Alaska, The Associated Press reported last month. The Alaska Democratic Party endorsed Hill.

The division also posted a ballot-level file early Wednesday, which records how each ballot was marked without identifying voters and covers most, but not all, of the ballots counted so far. In it, 94% of the ballots that ranked Hafner first ranked Democrat Mary Peltola first for Senate, and 92% ranked Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins first for governor, about the same as ballots that ranked Hill first. About one in seven ballots that ranked Peltola first for Senate ranked Hafner first for the House.

Hafner's voters were more likely than the front-runners' to use their backup choices. About 45% of the ballots that ranked him first marked no other choice, compared with nearly 60% of those that ranked Hill first and more than three-quarters of those that ranked Begich first. Most of Hafner's voters who did rank someone else picked Hill next.

Alaska News ran the ranked-choice rounds on that file and, using the same method as its analyses of the Senate and governor's races, applied voters' rankings to the full preliminary count. McDermott, in last place, would be eliminated after write-ins, and his ballots would split almost evenly: about 28% would move to Begich, 28% to Hill and 12% to Hafner, and about a third would stop counting.

That would give Begich about 50.8% of the votes still counting. Because no candidate won a majority of first choices, the count would continue until two candidates remain, under state law.

Hafner would be eliminated next. About 45% of the ballots that ranked him first would end up with Hill and 6% with Begich, and the rest would stop counting. On the current count, that would give Begich about 53% in the final round against Hill.

That is not a final result. The division plans to count early votes cast from Oct. 30 on and questioned ballots starting Nov. 10, and absentee ballots postmarked by Election Day can arrive through Nov. 13 from inside the U.S. and through Nov. 18 from overseas.

By Alaska News' math, Begich would clear 50% outright, with no ranked-choice count, if he wins about 51% of the votes still to be counted. That's more than his share of early and absentee votes so far but less than his Election Day share. The mark shifts by only a point or two whether 50,000 or 100,000 ballots remain.

Below it, the count would go to ranked-choice rounds and end in the final round against Hill. Hill would finish ahead in that round only if Begich won less than about a third to two-fifths of the votes still to be counted, depending on how many ballots remain. That's lower than his share of the early, absentee or Election Day votes counted so far.

If the uncounted ballots vote like the early and absentee ballots counted so far, Begich would lead that final round by roughly 4,000 to 8,500 votes. The ballots still to be counted include early votes cast later in the campaign, absentee ballots and questioned ballots, a different mix than the ballots counted so far.

The ballot-level file doesn't include ballots counted only by hand, the division says, which leaves out Election Day ballots from many rural precincts. Those voters favored Hill on first choices. The file covers 204,530 of the 215,906 ballots cast in the House race, and applying its rankings to the full count assumes voters missing from it ranked the candidates the same way.

Across the file, about two-thirds of House ballots marked just one candidate, and about 1 in 10 ranked all four.

The ranked-choice count for races without a majority is scheduled for Nov. 18. Two years ago, Begich won the seat in a ranked-choice count. He had 48.4% of first-choice votes and finished with 51.2% after Hafner and Alaskan Independence Party candidate John Wayne Howe were eliminated.

Correction: An earlier version of this story said Alaska's ranked-choice count would stop once Begich passed 50% after McDermott's ballots moved. Under state law, unless a candidate wins a majority of first-choice votes, the count continues until two candidates remain.