Skip to main content

27th Session of the IPHC Research Advisory Board, Day 2

Alaska News • • 169 min

Articles from this transcript

IPHC advisers' report finds a poor halibut season as prices hit a 20-year high

IPHC advisers call 2026 halibut fishing poor and uneven, with too many undersized fish and prices at a 20 year high. The report follows 2025 cuts that pushed Alaska quotas to a 40 year low.

Cover image for article: IPHC advisers' report finds a poor halibut season as prices hit a 20-year high

Halibut advisers ask commission to study rental-boat rules across its waters

Halibut commission advisers want a study of rental boat rules after Alaska's unguided catch estimate jumped 50% to 1.445 million pounds in 2025.

Cover image for article: Halibut advisers ask commission to study rental-boat rules across its waters
0:00
Jim

About the resources last year, I felt like we bottomed out and maybe upticking a little bit. And I, I still feel that way from what I saw in 3A and 3B and also Southeast. Even though I don't have quota in Southeast, one of the guys fishing with me has a little bit. And actually we did quite well there in Southeast, and, um, that was in mid-September. We only needed 4,500 pounds, ended up shaking about 6,000.

0:31
Jim

So it was a pretty decent day. But anyway, so I— and but I also saw— I know we were talking about sand fleas last year and everything, and we saw, you know, we, we did see that too, but it seems like they come and go in different areas and also different times of the year in that regard too, but But by and large, and people I talk to that cover other areas that I don't typically fish, that I trust what they tell me, like 4A is probably a little better, 4B is maybe a little better. And, but also what I saw in, in my fishing was two, two different year classes that appeared. We had size grade of 24 to 26 inches, quite a bit of that, and then we also saw a lot of 30 to 31.5 inchers, just undersized in both 3B and 3A. And, um, to the point, you know, I would move away from spots because I just didn't want to shake those fish.

1:37
Jim

I'd rather have slower fishing rather than cycle through the little ones. So, but otherwise, I don't know, I'm looking at Brian while I'm talking because he covers some of the area too, but I don't know what your thoughts were, but that was— I wasn't here to hear everybody else's thoughts, but that was what I saw and the guys that I trust, you know, as far as feedback.

2:04
Josep Planas

So anybody would like to add to Jim's comments?

2:10
Josep Planas

I think from my notes, you know, one of the recurring themes yesterday from that roundtable of the season overview was that there were predominance of smaller fish. A number of you guys talked about encountering a large number of undersized, underage fish, very few big fish in some areas. I think the only one that actually mentioned big fish was Steve, if I recall correctly, but most of you, from my understanding, indicated that, you know, there's still a lot of young fish out there, small fish, that the fishing was, was kind of slow. I think that was my general take from yesterday, kind of slow overall, patchy. So I mean, that means variable geographically, areas where you fished in the past, uh, there was really nothing there.

3:07
Josep Planas

And then, uh, so it was a little unpredictable in terms of the locations of fishing. That's, that's my take, so please correct me about that if I didn't get it correctly. Those were the two— I think those were the two main takes that I gathered from yesterday's discussion. But please, please add.

3:28
Brian

Yeah, I think that was kind of my take too. I, I just thought it was interesting that, um, You know, Angus seemed pretty pleased with his season, but maybe one of the reasons it was good for him is because he adopted like a, you know, a different strategy, you know, basically getting halibut as bycatch while he was doing something else worked really good for him. And, um, yeah, for me, I think the, the size of the fish was down a little bit in an area that I have a lot of experience in. I'm usually getting 27 to 30 pound fish on average So if I'm catching 100 fish, you know, that's the total average of the fish is about 27 to 30 pounds. And that was more like 22 to 23 pounds this year, uh, over the course of 3 trips there.

4:12
Brian

So yeah, a little bit smaller. They're usually really fat for their size there, and I never really saw that happen. Maybe the last trip I saw a couple more that were starting to look like the ones I'm used to seeing there as I got into July, but Um, yeah, I feel like usually they were a little bit fatter there. Saw a lot of small fish as well this year, which is promising, you know, ones that we just let go like Jim's talking about. I'm impressed that you were able to pick up on two distinct size groups.

4:39
Brian

I, I don't pay— no, not that I didn't see it, it's like I'm just letting it go. I, I wasn't clocking that, but that's interesting. So that'll be maybe curious to see if that shows up in our in our survey. Yeah, that would be cool if there was a nice class coming in. The other thing too is, um, talking to some of the charter operators, they were seeing a lot of small, small fish.

5:05
Jim

I mean, it's kind of sad because I kind of was ribbing one of them. He ties across the dock from me and it's like, God, what do you bring that little one in? I mean, we're talking, we don't even see them on a halibut hook and And he goes, well, the client wanted it. I tried to talk him out of it, but so there's nothing to eat there. But that was sad to see that going on.

5:26
Josep Planas

But I don't know, I don't know if it's better to see them take those and then they're done fishing or what. But it's— I look at it from a food standpoint, it's really not much there. So yeah, any issues with, um, I mean, we mentioned a couple of things yesterday. One was, uh, perhaps a lower incidence of the sand fleas. You mentioned sand fleas, right?

5:52
Josep Planas

We—. Basia did a presentation yesterday on sand fleas, and the document is posted on our website, so if you're interested.

6:01
Jim

But I didn't quite get what you mentioned about sand fleas. You said that you encountered sand fleas, or there was less than previous years? Yeah, it was interesting though, because one of the areas I fished, we did not have sand fleas, and I expected them. Because we'd had them last year and the previous year. And then this year we didn't have it.

6:18
Jim

And then later on in the season, a friend of mine was working that area and it was so hot that he couldn't set before daylight in the morning because the bait would be gone and any halibut that was caught was being worked on. So of course, with fall coming on, your daylight hours get shorter. So he was down to only running maybe 35, 36 gates a day. By the time he got the gear in the water and started getting it back, because by dark he was wasting his time. But, um, and that was— that surprised me.

6:49
Jim

Where was that, Jim? Do you remember? That was up in 3A, up out of— outside of Prince William Sound. And that was— that surprised me that it was that hot. But I've seen that before, you know, not quite that hot, but, but 3 months earlier I didn't see us— I was night soaking there without any issues.

7:07
Jim

So But they come and go, kind of like dogfish, you know, they move around too. And I don't know, probably deeper than 80 fathoms.

7:16
Jim

Um, yeah, actually there's some other areas too that if we— like if I stayed up inside 15 fathoms shallow and the fish were up there, yeah, there was no sand fleas up there. You could night soak and everything up there. But if you got below 20, 20 to 80 or so, it was real more sand fleas. Then you get below that No, so a lot of times it was depth related too. So you just got to experiment and see what goes on if you want to.

7:42
Jim

You know, I think a lot of guys get stuck in a routine and we set up 4 in the morning, we'd start this and we do that. And I think that goes against you. You got to be open-minded, I think. So, right. I guess I have a question about, um, about sand fleas, how it's recorded in the logbook.

8:00
Brian

And how it affects quota. So if I write down damage from sand fleas, let's say, you know, there was 2 fish that were over, you know, they were 10-pound fish, they were legal fish, I record that in my logbook, does that come off my quota? Does anyone know about that?

8:26
Basia

That information from the logbook is not used for any quota accounting, right? So this is the information that the IPHC started collecting this year in order to exactly facilitate the questions from the research advisory board regarding the hotspots of prevalence. And as I said yesterday, the problem of sand fleas is known to the fishermen, but it's not well documented in terms of like proper research and proper analysis of the data. That's why we embark on trying to collect the data. And I would be really curious to hear from you whether you think it's worth— because we can hear that this is a kind of coming and going problem.

9:05
Basia

As I said, last year we heard it as a substantial problem, we started data collection, but this year there seemed to be— this is less of a problem. But we would be really interested in hearing from you whether you endorse continuation of collecting that data. I think that would be a very helpful potentially recommendation from the RAP, and also recommendation whether you think the protocol for reporting this could be changed and refined, whether there's something that would be more informative in order to— for us to provide the analysis for you. Maybe something simplified as presence absence, it's, it's simple to record, and, and something that we can provide you analysis based on. So those are the kind of questions that I had based on them.

9:54
Basia

The— Jim, for you, so yesterday I made a presentation that was a presentation based on the research project by an intern who worked on sand fleas during the summer, summer that he spent here with the IPHC, and he looked at both the FIS data but also the, the data that we collected in 2026 as a part of a trial. But I think we encountered some challenges that fishermen have. It was difficult to put the number, like how many sand fleas you have, because it's, it's a little bit of a spectrum, right? It's, it's not very clear because some fish are badly damaged, some are just partially damaged, still marketable. So if you have a recommendation for us how to better account for it in order for us to summarize that information for you to have better understanding how this problem kind of changes from year to year, I guess, and whether there are specific areas that this is affecting.

10:52
Basia

So again, this, this data collection was driven by the RAP request, and we want to provide you that information, but we would really appreciate the feedback. What is the kind of more sensible way to ask fishermen about this problem? How to ask about allow it. Okay, I'm still not sure if it's gonna come off my quota. So like, if you—.

11:22
Basia

So in terms of regulations, the fish that are in, in general, you are not supposed to discard sanfli fish, and all the fish that is delivered is coming out of your quota. So you're not supposed to discard a fish?

11:43
Brian

The discarding of sand fleas fish is only allowed in British Columbia, and this is accounted for fully in their logbooks. So if you get a bag of bones, essentially, let's say you got a 10-pound fish and all that's left is skin and bones, you're bringing that in?

12:03
Jim

According to the regulation, that is the case. Okay, these are federal regulations, but this is not the requirement. It comes out of your fish holder's web. Okay, but what do you do with an observer board? I, I'm—.

12:21
Brian

I was asking this question because I've never gotten the same answer out of any two people, so I was just wondering if this was the right place to ask the question. I'm also thinking about if fishermen don't know, maybe they're going to be a little guarded in the information that they give because they don't want to get in trouble. So I was just— it's going to be hard to get information if people aren't sure what information they're allowed to give. That's why we kept this, the current trial, pretty flexible. We just asked about the number of fish damaged.

12:57
Basia

We didn't ask whether that— what happened to that fish. But yeah, maybe a simplified way that is more informative and less controversial to report is to, to have a question whether on each set there was fish affected by sand fleas. And then we can maybe refine that more specifically to some sort of cutoff, maybe fish that are losing market value, that's the cutoff. And I don't know, Ian, maybe you have something to add, like, as we've been working on— we've been trying to think what's the best way to ask about this problem, noting the challenges of—. I think in the past, I'm more— I'll be more open in an IPHC logbook than I would be in a NIMS logbook.

13:53
Jim

So because I've always looked on the data in the IPHC logbook, we've had more of a cooperative, less, I mean, like management and the industries together at this level. But when you get over to the NIMP side, I'd say it's a little different. So I mean, if I make a note in a halibut log, I don't, I just assume it's not going any further than the staff here. Yeah, it's a pretty, it's just a, it's a really, it's a tough issue to kind of wrap my head around in terms of how to avoid them because there's so many different variables involved in terms of the terrain that's down there, the depth. Like I said, often you can go into shallow water and you're gonna avoid them, and then as you get a little bit deeper, you're gonna have trouble.

14:45
Brian

Especially later in the day. But then the time of year matters. When you get into September, there's areas I fish in the Schoonigans where I can fish there, I can haul those things up at 4 in the morning with just a couple of sand fleas on some stuff. But then you could run into that in September, and, and at 8 PM and on, you, you're not going to get a single thing back. It's not— I'm not— there's nothing to discard.

15:09
Brian

It's all gone. So it's like, wow, 8 PM, that's pretty early, feels like. And then, you know, you notice when you're fishing black cod right around, I don't know, 180 to 220, you can't let those soak too long, otherwise there's not going to be anything left in those pots. So if you're going to go to town and let your gear soak for a couple days, you know, put it outside of 250 or outside of 270. So it's like they get worse up to a certain depth and then you know, they got like a range that they're sitting in, and then that also changes.

15:43
Brian

I've been on the Black Cod Edge where I've been fishing, and, uh, one trip it was just absolutely great fishing, 2,000 to 3,000 pounds a set. And then I moved 1 mile to the east on the next set, and it was nothing but sand fleas all the way out to 350. I'm like, okay, well, I think I'll avoid that spot. And then I look at it over the years, and it's one of my uncle's cousin's favorite spot. I'm like, well, I know he wouldn't sit here and fish hooks with sand fleas.

16:11
Brian

So it's just sometimes it's a local issue at the time of year, and you just have to go, okay, I guess they're right there, I guess I'll go that way. Um, and just recently when I was fishing halibut, I, uh, there's a kind of a new spot that I've been trying out because everyone's always at my other spot. So it's like, okay, there's less people over here, I'll go over here. It's a nice edge from like, uh, 130 out to 170, which is a little bit deeper than I typically fish for halibut that time of year, but, um, it was really good. And then I'm going, ooh, the edge above me is even steeper.

16:47
Brian

I guess they're on kind of a steeper slope right here. Let's try that out. Nothing but sand fleas on the steep slope. So it's like, okay, I guess right here— it's such an issue that's like you're never really sure which variable is the important one which is the one that's triggering the SAM fleas. So yeah, gathering information would be useful, but I think it's going to be really hard to pinpoint.

17:08
Basia

Well, so that's why we were thinking the logbooks is because the FIS data is so standardized and so narrow in terms of certain parameters, we cannot really investigate more of a wider range of parameters that affect the prevalence of SAM fleas. That's why I thought if we record that information in the logbook, we can have that wide range and we can at least see on average among the fleet what are the key parameters, or whether we can at all find the significant parameters in that relationship. So that's why the idea was to look at the data. As I said, uh, in Will's work, he looked at some of that, um, from as recorded in the logbooks in 2026, but it was just not enough data just yet. And then we had the challenge of kind of correctly reporting the absence and making sure to understand whether the absences there were no sand fleas, or somebody said— did not tell us whether there were sand fleas or not.

18:06
Basia

So we had this challenge of fully understanding the, the absence versus not, not reported to us.

18:14
Brian

That's why, again, trying to get some hints of what do you think based on your experience is kind of the best question for us to ask on a larger scale to maybe embark on providing you more information about, you know, in general, in the whole fleet, what is affecting the probability. I still think the most interesting variable to look at would be bottom hardness, which is, um, and I think that the FIS is probably best suited for evaluating this issue because of the reliability of the information that you get. I mean, you can also get really specific information on exactly where the middle of the set was. I think you'll have a better— it'll be easier for you to maybe pinpoint if there are local issues in terms of like, okay, on the Chignik Strait, there's sand fleas. You know, you'll be able to pick up on that sort of thing.

19:17
Brian

Or over by, you know, south of Yakutat Valley, there's sand fleas. But, uh, I still think if you guys could get a survey where someone's giving you bottom data— and I do apologize, I have been really bad about getting you guys bottom data when I've done surveys because I couldn't take it away. I couldn't because of how old my software is on the boat. I couldn't get my information away from FIS information. That being said, I have a new program now, so if I do a charter in the future, I will record all the bottom information for every single set I do, and you'll have it in a nice little package.

19:53
Brian

But I don't have the capability doing bottom hardness, not— at least not in a quantitative number. And I think that would be probably the most useful thing to look at. But there's a lot of boats that don't have that capability. And if you're going to get shared bottom information from someone else, it's not often not coming with bottom hardness. Like, I just bought Olex this last year and I got some information on the bottom it was like just kind of broad strokes around the area.

20:21
Brian

It wasn't, wasn't very in-depth. And then the bottom hardness I got was pretty clearly from like one boat that just was transiting. So it's like, okay, it's kind of interesting to look at that. I would like to be able to see that everywhere, but I don't have the capability of doing it on my boat. And guys usually aren't giving each other all their bottom information unless they're real tight, or business partners.

20:47
Jim

But if you had a survey boat doing it and they had that capability, that would be a huge bonus for you in terms of looking at this issue potentially. But that bottom hardness thing too, though, comes down to how the equipment's set up on the boat. So it's, uh, you know, you can— like, you look at your sounder like I look at mine, and we can judge by the band of how solid is the red or whatever, or how many echoes. And that's how we do it. And then these guys got the fancier software, but it still comes down to who set it up.

21:22
Jim

You mean how they set it up in as like a—. Well, they have to have a defining point of what's, you know, then what's soft or hard or harder or whatever from there. Does anyone set it up so that they see sort of a quantitative value? Or is it always just a visual thing? Oh no, I don't know.

21:40
Jim

I don't, I don't know. I've seen the systems and, and my judgment of the hardness was totally different than what that program was showing. So I know what works for me, I guess, based on my equipment. So I don't know.

22:03
Josep Planas

Right, Lando, can you use your microphone?

22:08
Basia

Yeah, microphone, microphone.

22:17
Brian

And go with what he's talking about. Yeah, yeah, I can look at it, but my, my software can't record it for looking at later. Well, you got an Olax, it's just reading your sounder. Information. My, my Olex will not record.

22:30
Jim

You just, you need another, you need a little bit more in it. You need another module in it, I think. But I don't have it on my—. I bought the module. Oh, you did?

22:37
Brian

I did. And I'm being told that MySounder is a really great sounder, but not for that. Yeah, MySounder, the one sounder I have doesn't work on it either, and the other one doesn't work. So I can, I can see echoes, I can see the, you know, the how, how red it is, right? And that's— and I can also see if I got a lot of little Oh, that looks like a bunch of rocks.

22:56
Brian

Okay, it's probably pretty hard. Um, but when I can turn on that module and I can look at bottom hardness that's been recorded by a survey boat, and it has a, it has a color range that's recorded on the chart. Yeah, and I think it might have a quantitative number as well. Somebody set that up though. Yeah, and it comes down to how they set it up.

23:21
Alex

I mean, I do know that the research fleet does that everywhere it goes. If there's a research boat for any of the universities transiting, it's recording bottom hardness. How you get that data, I'm not sure, but it's been recorded for a great part of the ocean.

23:43
Josep Planas

Can you guys hear me? A hand up. Angus, do you have a question? Or comment? A comment, yeah.

23:49
Angus

The hand's been up for a while, uh, so I just wanted to— I'm sorry, yeah, clarify a bit. The, um, for the, um, fishing in 2B, yeah, the, um, you, you know, yeah, I, I had good fishing, but I also network with, you know, a dozen other boats that fish in the Hecate Straits in the summer. I can't go in there with the licenses we have on the boat. And yeah, the— it was kind of average fishing in July, but August cranked on, and I was getting reports of the best fishing we've seen in years. Um, and yeah, I think I also mentioned, yeah, led to a real shortage of quotas, um, or of quota being around.

24:31
Angus

Companies are really scrambling right now. It— yeah, so the, the reports overwhelmingly, and I talked to other people that fish elsewhere too, is it was much better than last year.

24:45
Angus

In terms of the WASP, we have a WASP on our boat, and I haven't seen numeric values. Maybe I could find it, but to me, it does a great job of defining bottom hardness. But I've found lice in really hard bottom, and I found lice in soft bottom.

25:06
Josep Planas

Thanks, Angus. Sorry for keeping you waiting.

25:13
Basia

I will certainly— we can look into adding additional variables to, to the modeling exercise. And I guess the, the bottom part, we'll need to see what, how, what kind of information we could use for that. Maybe there's some research survey. And because that's— I think that the one thing is this is not something that is changing throughout the season, so this would be something that is associated with spatial coordinates and it's not kind of fluctuating from, from, but I think still that there might be a worth of information from logbooks to see at the other components that might be affected at things like, again, temperature at the time in the area, maybe soak time, the some of the components that we looked at. So again, not to keep this the like discussion too long, but if you're interested in continuing collection of that data, just please let us know, and we'll be trying to look into, into this and trying to inform you about how this problem looks like on more of a general scale.

26:13
Basia

Okay, you know, going from more of anecdotal, from person-to-person information to something more general that we see at the fleet level. Thank you.

26:31
Josep Planas

Jim, any other comments that you want to make from last season or this current season? Anything?

26:42
Jim

No? No, I don't think so. I think it's just interesting to hear the discussion go around about things. Yeah. Okay.

26:51
Josep Planas

So, we have a little under an hour for continuing the discussion. So, let's open up the floor for Any ideas that any of the RAB members want to bring up?

27:04
Kevin

Yeah, Kevin. So I was thinking last night about our— this is my 6th year, I think, coming up to RAB or being on the RAB board, and observations I've kind of made is that when I first started the board, we had some pretty good excitement, for lack of better words, on the research end of it. We had the pop-up um, senders for the migration of the fish, I believe. And then we had the shuttle device. We had— I believe we even talked about the, um, habitats as far as where the fish were actually— the larvae were actually being raised and where they were, where the fish were doing their thing.

27:42
Kevin

And, and is it specific to certain areas? And, and then we came across COVID, and then we end up with our funding issues to where we decreased our surveys, or we started looking more at the economics of the, of the process, and kind of in a survival mode. Um, and it, and it, and then this seems to me that we've kind of reached that plateau on the research end of what in the past we've talked about on the board. Um, and those have come to either fruition, or the theory is either proven or not proven and we've kind of plateaued. I don't know if that's a good assessment or if that makes sense or not from the outside looking into you, you, Job.

28:27
Kevin

So in our meeting last night, I kind of thought, well, I wonder if in a perfect world what you as researchers would like to see from the RAB approved in the future. I mean, obviously you can't come up with that today, but what does the future look like for research for the RAB and the Secretariat? And where do we need to start? If we start getting funding, where do we need to prioritize? And is there some new ideas?

28:55
Kevin

Um, are we— do we need to look outside the box? Do we need— and I'm way out of my food chain here, so bear with me, but do we need to, um, you know, something kind of hit me yesterday was when we talked about the bait used for the surveys, or the— where the halibut were kind of like your cat, you know, one day they like the kibble, the other day they They don't like the soft food, you know. And so is there something to be looking at in the, uh, food chain of these halibut as to what are they really eating, what do they prefer? Is there a correlation between the ecosystem of their food source compared to their populations? That's just some ideas I was thinking.

29:37
Kevin

I haven't really heard research about that, and it might be one of those things, well, you know, it's really impossible to figure out. But is there research to be gained on the cleaning of the fish and the, and the, and the, in the research of the food source of our halibut. Is there a correlation between those, those food sources and our population size and everything? And then I appreciate all the work everybody's done, and I, I almost don't want the scientists to be feeling as hopeless because we don't have any money. I think at some point everything's cyclic, and at some point we're going to be really hopefully wealthy and, uh, and have more than just neutral revenue.

30:21
Kevin

So I just think it— I would challenge the scientists to come up with some, some proposals for the next RAB or the RABs in the future. That if— I think that I posed to a couple of your researchers last night, if you had your wish, no bars, no no restrictions. What would you like to see? What would you like to research? What would— what do you think we could do?

30:44
Kevin

Because I think we've kind of plateaued, um, from what I'm hearing, and maybe that's what we need to be. I don't know if that's the goal, um, but, but then I want to thank you for all your hard work. Um, it's obviously way beyond my ability or our ability, but, uh, don't get discouraged, and thank you for the opportunity to be part of it.

31:08
Brian Ritchie

So anybody would like to comment? Brian? Uh, somewhat unrelated, I guess I'm wondering, maybe a question for you, just what, what are the limitations of what RAB members can, can ask for? Um, I'm thinking about this through the perspective of, uh, you know, a council member and some of the things that we're looking to do there and what might be low-hanging fruit maybe here, I'm not sure because I don't know what the limitations are, but things that are like, you know, they feel like pretty Herculean efforts to get done at the council, even to get an analysis started. You know, uh, things like, things I want to know just as a pragmatist, like what in, in Canada, you know, I would love to see on paper what, how do they manage rental boats?

31:55
Brian Ritchie

What's the registration requirements look like there? How does it look in Oregon, Washington, California, other states? What are models that the state of Alaska can base that on. Just things that are big issues for halibut fishermen in United States right now. I know that this isn't something that's immediately going to help Canada, but issues that we see and have identified as fishermen here.

32:19
Brian Ritchie

I'd like to see, you know, more information or maybe another iteration of Dr. Stewart's paper on the fully subscribed, maybe something that's a little more specific to the Gulf of Alaska and the removals that we're seeing there and prohibited species catch from the, from the trawl fleet. Um, I think that information would be extremely helpful to get some things off the ground in the council process that I think halibut fishermen are— honestly, I think halibut fishermen are owed. Um, yeah, so I just I wonder if low-hanging fruit like that is something that, you know, it's something that's more like analysis. Is that something that the RAB can recommend?

33:03
Josep Planas

Just give you a chance to speak to that. Yeah, thanks. I'll address Brian's comments first. Yeah, I think the RAB can play an important role there in recommending certain actions from the Secretariat. Those are— those recommendations are brought in front of the commissioners and, you know, the RAB report is written— is read at the annual meeting and taken into consideration.

33:26
Josep Planas

Together with other reports from other subsidiary bodies. So whatever the RAP feels that is important to bring in front of commissioners, the report is really the place to push those ideas. So, you know, the process is the RAP can actually issue recommendations, can issue requests. The recommendations are the ones that go in front of the commissioners. The requests are more technical issues that the Secretariat is asked to do and to respond to the RAP at the next meeting.

34:01
Josep Planas

But the recommendation is something that the Commissioners see and debate on. Whether it's, you know, information on whatever, or embarking on new projects, or continuing projects, or stopping work on certain projects. So the recommendation is really the way to go.

34:25
Kevin

Just one follow-up and not go down the rabbit hole of the sand flea again, but when we were all talking about that, the big question that came to my mind is, is there any predation of the sand flea? What eats the sand fleas? Is there a depletion of their natural predators, or do we even have any idea of what is feeding or what feeds on the sand flea? Or can you interview one of them, ask them what's, what's chasing them.

34:53
Josep Planas

I know, unfortunately we don't have any, uh, sand flea experts here in the house. Um, I don't know if there's a huge amount of knowledge out there on what could be regulating the sand fleas, what could be eating sand fleas. So I'm not sure, does anybody around the table know Something that is worth bringing up regarding samphlies?

35:21
Kevin

I know that there's some reports written, but there's really not a whole lot of literature in terms of samphlies. You know, we just see them on the, you know, as a parasite, but, you know, in terms of their ecological role, I'm really, I'm really not sure. Yeah, and that's kind of what I, you know, if your research or your data shows that, you know, it's really going to be an industry problem, you know, maybe to get ahead of the, the curve. I don't know, maybe there's a project there to be looked at. And I don't know, I just, that was kind of the good idea fairy struck me there when I was listening to all that.

36:01
Jim

What eats them? Is there a depletion of their natural predation? I don't know if anybody knows that, but they, uh, the more sand fleas doesn't mean there's less fish in the area either though. So I think the fish probably feed on them as well. But I was thinking about what Brian was talking about on, uh, last year.

36:23
Jim

I guess we kind of kicked loose a firestorm a little bit last year when we brought up the unguided sector, and then I think Sean or Seattle Vessel Owners, put a proposal into at the annual meeting, which kicked loose another firestorm. And, and that's a can of worms that has no end as far as I'm concerned, because I didn't realize how bad it was in the unguided sector. I mean, I knew how bad it was in Southeast because you see it firsthand all the time, but you don't have a handle on all the removals going on. It's— everybody wants to point finger at the trawl sector, and I don't think any of us around the table are a big fan of the trawl sector. However, there's a huge— far more removals going on with the unguided sector.

37:14
Jim

I mean, out of Seward alone, I was talking to some of the charter guys, and they said, well, there's 90 licenses out of Seward, but there's 120 unguided operations. And they said that's just the tip of the iceberg. Yeah. And so, you know, that's a— I don't know what— obviously I didn't hear a single organization speak out when they took away 9% from Southeast and gave it to the unguided sector. And, uh, I didn't hear anybody complain about it.

37:44
Jim

I was shocked because if I'd had a quota in that area, I would have been I would have definitely said something, but no organization spoke out about it. And, and yet it's not just a Southeast issue, it's in Canada and everywhere from what I understand. And as well as 3A, and makes going west kind of nice because at least you get away from that side of it. But, but anyway, I don't know, there's a political factor involved there too that kind of you know, gets in the way of the science side too, so. Yeah, we did have a little bit of discussion yesterday on that topic, so I think it was general that the WRAP considered that there was a need to improve the information on catch reporting, particularly the reporting in the different recreational sectors, so that's something that, you know, you could highlight in the report.

38:41
Steve Daniels

Could I speak to that? So more broadly, I don't know if after 100 years that we've reached a plateau. I sort of doubt that.

38:53
Steve Daniels

Kevin, no offense to you, but I've only been here 13 years, which is twice as long, and I thought about not coming back last year. And then we had a very interesting meeting and I thought it was productive. This year, I saw, I think, the fulfillment of my wish to check on the study, the mortality rate of catch and release, you know, charter halibut fishing. And some of you commercial guys were saying, are you out of your mind, Daniels? That's a business you're in.

39:24
Steve Daniels

Why would you do that? Well, because that's why we're here, is to question assumptions and to think ahead. And had we thought ahead, we would've changed the regulations for the charter fisheries decades ago, but we didn't and it took forever. And next thing you knew, huge portions of the commercial quota was reallocated to the charter fishermen in the catch sharing plan. So now I obviously, I own quota, I'm a commercial fisherman.

39:59
Steve Daniels

That's where I started 30, 30 years, 40 years of that, and I'm still involved in that. Someone catches my quota, but I also have millions of dollars invested in a charter fishing lodge and now $3 million invested in a self-guided lodge, which I have big doubts about me wanting to be into that business. But if we're talking about sand fleas, maybe we have plateaued. Maybe that's, you know, to me, I'm just me, is like, seriously? We're gonna try to think about the— no offense, Kevin— but the, the predators for sand fleas.

40:33
Steve Daniels

These are things that I don't get it. And maybe if that's the case, this could be my last meeting because I don't really think that's helpful. But, and again, I'm not trying to offend anybody, but one of the things about this meeting 13 years ago, 10 years ago, there was people were Weren't afraid to disagree. We didn't need a consensus. I like to stir up shit.

40:58
Steve Daniels

That's just who I am. As I explained to you on the trip over here, sometimes you stir up shit and you get into trouble. Well, I'm not particularly worried about getting in trouble or people liking me, and I would like to stir up some shit here. So, Jim, absolutely. I came here thinking this morning, yesterday I was a little brain dead at the end of the session 'cause I just kind of got, I don't know, tired or something 'cause I'm getting old or something.

41:26
Steve Daniels

But maybe we talked about SAMHSA too long. But this self-guided, so-called self-guided thing, I, we, the RAB asked IPHC to try to get a handle on how much are these removals, how are they being reported? 'Cause we have no idea. This is a big sinkhole for us. Never mind San Feliz.

41:52
Steve Daniels

We need to really get a grip on this because by the time you study it and figure out what they're taking away, then you've got just grown by 200 or 300, 400%. And you know what? You're not, once they take it away from you, you're not getting it back. And so that's what kind of my impassioned plea for us to review RAB's recommendation that we figure out how they are accounting for these— are they accounting for these, uh, removals, uh, due to the so-called self-guided businesses? And if that puts me in a bad position with other self-guided businesses, I don't care.

42:30
Brian

On that note, I watched a video at— because there was a lot of comments after, um, after FVOA you know, put that proposal together. And a lot of the narrative was, you know, the people in Seattle are going to tell Alaskans what to do, and that's a bunch of BS. And, um, I, I thought that our focus was, uh, we don't want to tell Alaskans how many fish they can take, but we don't want people, you know, manipulating the loophole. When you got people potentially getting on a boat with spots on it, being told where to go, and then now they're allowed to take 2 compared to someone who's going to pay for a guide service that can only take 1. I mean, I think that's BS, you know.

43:12
Brian

They're small fish, right? They're circumventing the, um, you know, the regulations. And, and as far as getting accurate catch reporting numbers, I mean, that's paramount to understanding what's actually coming out of the fishery. But maybe that proposal would have been received better if some Alaskans had put it together because they did not like the fact that it looked like Seattle was telling Alaskans what they can or can't take. So, um, I actually responded to a video and I was like, well, I'm from Seattle and, uh, I don't think our intention was to tell you what to do.

43:48
Brian

I don't think anyone has a problem with a sport fisherman that's going to take his boat out there and go catch 2 halibut. You know, he lives there, that's his resource, and he should be able to do that. But, um, I don't know if you're happy with people from Omaha, Nebraska flying in and getting on, you know, an unguided boat and getting to take 2 fish just because they're using a loophole. And he was like, oh, I didn't really know that's what the issue was. So I just thought that was, um, that was interesting how it kind of became a political issue.

44:20
Jim

It did. Yeah, it did become political in a hurry, and it was unfortunate. And I think maybe you're right, Brian, that it's maybe too bad that FVOA is the one to put the proposal out there. But it was interesting because I brought it up last year and Sean ran with it, which I thought was awesome. But it got flipped into a political thing.

44:42
Jim

Oh, it's those Seattle guys are trying to do this. And now, but look what's going on. I mean, look at this last election. I I mean, there's been so much garbage floating around Alaska. It's probably the laughingstock of the nation for an election process now.

44:58
Jim

But, but, um, the, uh, I had a friend that was in a lodge. He was comped into a lodge down by Craig, and he's got his own little commercial thing going, but he also retired from a much bigger thing, so he was comped there. It was a $3,000 a day lodge, I guess. And he was just appalled at what he saw going on. 28 Boats operating out of that lodge, unguided.

45:25
Jim

28 Times 6 a day. And he said, just throwing fish away, rockfish floating all over and everything else, and they're not touched. And because they're in a lodge like that, they're not monitored at all at the lodge either. And of course, when— like Steve last year You know, we brought it up last year and he said, well, let's look at the numbers. And you laughed at the numbers.

45:49
Jim

And 'cause you said just in your area, you know, you were just going, what a joke. And I thought that was one of the biggest affirmations of the problem is when Steve last year said, this is ridiculous. But what'd they do? All of a sudden you got an attorney standing there that says, I represent this sector. That supposedly isn't— doesn't exist.

46:15
Jim

Obviously it exists really well everywhere. I didn't, I didn't have a clue what was going on on a sewer till the charter guys there told me about it. But they won't speak out either. As I've got frustrated with that, I said, why don't you guys speak out on it? Because it's cutting your throat too.

46:30
Jim

I thought it was a good proposal. Everybody gets treated the same. But as a commercial fisherman, I'm looking at I mean, what's our cap this year? 68,000 Pounds. That's nothing as a commercial operation.

46:43
Jim

You're providing a living for a crew of guys. You know, we're doing 280 to 300,000. That was, you know, you know, even at that rate, we didn't put in much time fishing halibut. I might have been a little much, but it was fun at the time. But, but still, you know, 68,000 pounds is not making a living.

47:05
Jim

And anybody that's kidding themselves if they think they can make a living— well, you can if your mom and dad out there catching your 20,000. It's a lifestyle fishery. But if you're providing a living for your crew and everything, you got to catch fish. And I don't see the resource. I think we're— I personally think we're kind of plateaued, maybe creeping up a little bit, but in my— I'm at the dip.

47:29
Jim

At the downhill side of my career, probably. But I don't expect to see that come back in my time. I think it will come back eventually, and probably not because the management so much as maybe environmental conditions or whatever else is— probably has— plays a bigger part. I think sometimes we accidentally get it right. I mean, like the black cod, I think we raised quotas too fast on black cod before, and I think we got dodged a bullet on that.

47:55
Jim

Now they want to cut the quotas when What's the point? The resource, you know, in my opinion, I've been fishing black cod for 52 years, so I think I know something about it. And now they want to cut it. I don't think they'll cut it that far, but, but where's your scientific rationalization for that too? I don't see it.

48:16
Jim

But, and I think halibut and black cod have a lot of parallels in management as well, so, because the resources are both long-lived. And slower growing everything too.

48:28
Josep Planas

So I think it's important to point out what, what Pasha just sent me is that the unguided sector accounting is responsibility of ADF&G in Alaska and that any issues regarding that have to go to the North Pacific Fisheries Management Council. So there's the IPHC really is this a little bit outside of the realm of the IPHC. But in any case, I mean, the issue is of concern, and if the WRAP feels like it, making a comment in the report, of course, you're most welcome to. Kevin. To stir the poop, we'll hear a little bit more from Steve here, but I guess to give you a little bit more of my mindset on that is that as a charter fishery, probably isn't as affected, I would imagine, by the sand fleas as from what we're hearing from the commercial side of it, because the commercial side is losing bait and losing sets, given the area.

49:21
Kevin

That's why I felt that, and it was a part of our board meeting last year, that there was a concern. And that's why we are having these sand flea discussions. Not that it needs to be the main, main focus of our group. I just think it's important that— and I can see Steve's point that, yeah, the self-guidance affected me a whole lot more than sand fleas because I think the style of fishing is, is different. I think if you were charter fishing and your charter client saying, hey, I'm just not bringing nothing up but bones, then it would be a different issue.

49:57
Kevin

It'd be more of a concern for the charters. But it doesn't affect me in the salmon troll because we don't have the predation. But Cody, I don't know if they're experiencing any sand fleas down in the 2A, but Anyway, that's what was my— give a little bit more insight as to why I felt, you know, that in equality, so to speak, if it's really affecting where you're losing an entire set or skate of bait and not— then maybe it's something in the future if we have the money we need to look at. So yeah, Kevin, I think that the main thing is for these meetings is you should be able to bring up anything that what concerns you. And even if I bring something up and I don't know really, I haven't done my homework, like somebody was saying the other day, like, oh, you know, when you come to these meetings, some of these young guys, you know, they're intimidated because they don't, you know, they don't know anything and they just do all the studying before you come to the meetings.

50:58
Steve Daniels

It's, you know, like, no, I don't, I don't study everything that the Haliburton Commission puts out. I am ignorant about a lot of things, but I bring a, a, a fresh perspective as should, as you do and everyone else. And what we should be looking for is, you know, allotting our time and our resources on things that actually would impact our ability to bring the stocks back. So sand fleas or sand fleas or sand fleas, they're gonna be here everywhere. And no, charter guys, I don't just think about things from the standpoint of does it affect me as a business owner?

51:34
Steve Daniels

And likewise, I don't think that, you know, you guys that commercial fish should think about, well, let's talk about sand fleas 'cause it cuts into my profit 'cause it takes my bait or I waste my time fishing in a spot that's hot and all that. But reporting the losses of sand fleas and getting a good handle on that, if you don't know how many halibut are being taken by the self-guided, so-called self-guided fleet, It can be an immense number and it's growing, it's going crazy fast. Sand fleas aren't proliferating and we can't stop 'em if they were. So to me it's like, it's, it's, it's a non-issue. But again, I'm not trying to put anybody down, but what we do need to think about is I'll call out my own business.

52:21
Steve Daniels

I own a self-guided business now and I don't care if they shut me down tomorrow, I won't be self-guided then, but If you don't get a handle on how many fish these self-guided businesses are taking, they're gonna continue to grow because it's a business model that obviously works for people. And if you, if they, if it keeps working, they'll keep proliferating. And pretty soon there won't, you know, there's this big sinkhole where all the halibut are going. So that's why I can speak passionately about that and I can equally be passionate about, I don't care about sand fleas. No offense to anybody.

52:59
Josep Planas

We have questions from Angus and Scott. Let's give them a chance. Scott, do you have a question or a comment?

53:10
Scott

Yes, I have a comment on a completely different issue, so if we're done talking about this, I'd like to bring something up. Go ahead. You know, we're getting ready, we got about 15 minutes left, we're going to start working on the report. For this session of the RAB. And one thing I'd like to bring up that hopefully gets included in the, in the report is every year at the annual meeting we're talking about the FIS, and they're, you know, they're always trying to do revenue neutral, and they're always discussing what to cut to make sure we get revenue neutral on the FIS study.

53:45
Scott

And one thing that always comes up is the, the water profiler that they, they drop down at each of the stations they're fishing. In Area 2A, that's really important to us when they do do the fish down in our area because we do have hypoxia events and they're getting more frequent and they're getting larger and larger. And depending on how everyone else feels, I'd like to see in the report for this session that the RAB urges the Secretariat and the Commissioners to take cutting the profiler off the chopping block in discussions regarding how to make the FIS revenue neutral in the next annual meeting and future annual meetings. Thank you.

54:29
Angus

Thank you, Scott. I think Angus also had a question or a comment. Go ahead, Angus. Yeah, just regarding the previous discussion there, I'm all for supporting anything that leads to better accounting of removals, as well, it'd be helpful, like, I know what our monitoring situation is in British Columbia here. You can't go fish halibut, sablefish, rockfish without cameras on your boat and the footage being reviewed afterwards.

55:01
Angus

What's the state of that in Alaska?

55:08
Loren

I don't have the answer, but I would say that ties directly to what Brian was saying about if NIMS can't— if the council can't get a recommend or get an analysis started of how it's done in other places, but that's needed, maybe this body— and this body can't recommend that the staff put time into the numbers because that's Fish and Games.

55:34
Loren

Place, maybe this body can request this— the IPHC staff to do an analysis of how regulations are set for that sector in British Columbia, Washington, and Oregon. And I would go further than just an analysis of those regulations, but also analysis of enforcement.

56:01
Angus

And if we can, if that's something that's appropriate for us to do, I would like second that motion that Brian kind of put forward and register, yeah, the registration of how those boats, yeah, how can they, how are they registered. So that would be basically just requesting that the IPHD do an analysis paper for, say, Angus. Does the guided sector and sports sector in Canada have cameras and monitoring? No, I was speaking of commercial, and they do have their own reporting requirements, and we would love for them to be more stringent. I think they're— yeah, the guided sector is definitely more monitored, I think, in that regard, but I— it's not my cup of tea, but I was curious about your directed longline fisheries as well.

56:58
Jim

What monitoring standard do you guys have? Well, well, if you draw an observer, you carry an observer, or you can go electronic where they— if you draw an observer there, then you turn on the cameras and they run cameras. So, but, um, yeah, because I raised a question with some of the charter operations about, well, how about if you guys are monitored like we are? And that's just totally dead on arrival. So the state of Alaska doesn't do anything to, to help the commercial side or the monitoring side at all.

57:36
Jim

Actually, it's kind of a running joke up there. Just so I'm clear, so there is either 100% cameras or an observer on your directed fishery? No, no, we— every trip we make, we have to, we have to, uh, call in or, or email in that we're going to make a trip and the time we want to leave port. And then they tell us if we have to either run camera— if, if we're part of the electronic monitoring, then we have to turn the cameras on, or we have to carry an observer in person if they assign us one for that trip. But we don't know until we actually file for the trip.

58:17
Brian

And there's a distinction between the Bering Sea and the Gulf of Alaska. There's a higher chance of getting an observer if you're going to be fishing in the Bering Sea or the Aleutians. So I think it's closer to 40% or 35% out there. I'm unclear what the numbers are, but, you know, I had an observer for a month straight when I was out in the Aleutians this year, which is, um, you know, I've— I don't do this. I have heard of people saying, okay, I got an observer, I'm going to go out, I'm going to make a set, and I'm going to come around and sell.

58:51
Brian

I think that's BS because I think it's all of our responsibility to keep the science moving forward. There's a reason why we're observed. It is a hardship to have them on board the boat, but that's just the way it is. So I, yeah, I took an observer for a month when I was in the Bering Sea this year. But then if I'm in the Gulf, it's just kind of— I think it's like closer to maybe 18% or 20%.

59:15
Brian

I'm not exactly certain on that number either, but I definitely draw an observer less in the Gulf of Alaska. As far as the process, you can log 3 trips. So you can say on April 1st, I plan on departing Kodiak I plan on returning to Kodiak, um, on the 10th, and then I plan on leaving on the 11th on another trip. And things change, so you can go— at least now you can go in and you can update that system. You can say, you know, I, I am no longer returning to Kodiak, I'm actually going to take this to Sandpoint.

59:51
Brian

And then you can say, and my next trip I'm planning on leaving on the— you can, you can curtail when you planned on arriving in Kodiak. I planned on arriving in Kodiak on the 10th, they said, well, now I'm going to Sandpoint on 8th, as soon as you adjust that trip, you can then adjust the next trip to say I'll be leaving Sandpoint on the 9th. And, and so you can make adjustments, and you, you declare where you're intending to be, what you're intending to do. You, um, you attest that you're not lying, these are actually my intentions, with the understanding that things do change. And then you can do 3 of those.

1:00:26
Brian

As soon as you sell your fish, you can close that trip You can enter in the fish ticket information. I offloaded at Alaska Pacific Seafoods on this date. And then now NIMS has an idea of which fish ticket to look for. And then if you have an observer, they close the trip for you. Anyway, you can do 3 trips and it overlaps with sablefish.

1:00:49
Brian

It used to be separate. But now I'll declare I'm going to do a pot trip for sablefish, and after that I'm going to do a halibut trip. And then, um, you can do things out of order, you know, if something comes up or something changes, as long as you're not like, as long as they don't think you're entering in fake trips to manipulate where you get coverage or whatnot. I don't really worry about that because if I get an observer, I take an observer. If you don't draw an observer, even if you said you were gonna leave on the 10th and you're in town on the 8th and you wanna leave town, you can leave whenever you want because you're, you know, you don't have an observer.

1:01:30
Brian

If you have an observer and you say, I'm leaving on the 10th, and you want to leave on the 8th, you can't leave unless they can get you an observer in time. So you can leave early as long as the observer's there, but if they say, sorry, we can't fly an observer until the 10th, you got to sit there and wait. So it does take a little bit of planning ahead, but that's just kind of the nature of it. Everyone deals with it, and As you get more experience in it, you learn to plan ahead. Well, thanks for your clarification on that.

1:01:59
Angus

If I had one recommendation to you guys, and it is a pain in the ass and there's expenses, but go 100% cameras because partial observer coverage, partial camera coverage is almost worse than no coverage. Behavior changes, maybe not with you, there's lots of honest people out there too, but I mean, that's what allowed us to stay ahead of the NGOs, allowed us to put the boots to trawl is clean up your own sector and then go after the ones that aren't doing it as good.

1:02:31
Steve Daniels

So if I could speak to, I suppose, enforcement of regulations for the charter fishing. I'm in probably one of the most remote places you could charter fish in the ocean. Pelican, Alaska, and that area. And, you know, when I started 25 years ago, there was, there was nothing. Nobody's looking at anything.

1:02:56
Steve Daniels

But, you know, we have electronic logbooks. We have a boat go out a day. Uh, we have port, not port samplers, but, you know, troopers fishing game, uh, from Sitka. National Marine Fisheries Service. I commercial fished actively for probably 30 years, and I have charter fished on a boat, you know, maybe 90 days out of the season for 15 years, and I've been boarded and observed and checked at least 2 to 1, maybe 3 to 1, even though There was no enforcement at all in my area in the first, you know, 5, 6 years.

1:03:46
Steve Daniels

So there is, you know, accurate accounting for the withdrawals, I believe, in the guided charter sector. And the guided charter sector should be, they're the most threatened by the unguided sector because, you know, I have people, there's a guy that fishes out of Pelican on a boat called, oh, shall I say the name of the boat? But, um, he's been done, been doing it for years and he takes people out and he guides them, but he claims that he's unguided. They keep 2 halibut a day. Some of the clients, at least one of his clients was one of my clients that paid me, you know, $5,000, $6,000 to take him out for 5 days to fish.

1:04:35
Steve Daniels

But when the regulations changed where you, you know, it was hard without paying for a gaffish to keep a big fish, he went to this guy. And I saw him last year and I said, you should be ashamed of yourself. You know, and I know that you're guided. This guy takes every single day, he has people on his boat, 4 or 5 people. They show up at my bar in Pelican and Like, hey, what brings you to town?

1:04:59
Steve Daniels

Oh, we're, we're, uh, we're fishing with our, our friend. Yeah. What's his name? What's our friend's name again? Oh yeah.

1:05:05
Steve Daniels

Yeah. Yeah. That guy we're fishing with that guy. Yeah. We're just friends, you know?

1:05:10
Steve Daniels

And it's like, these are, I won't rent this outfit a room. I won't let him, I kicked him out of my bar. I told him right to his face is I'm not going to turn you in, but I won't do any business whatsoever with you. And so he's gone beyond the so-called self-guided where people really are on the boats by themselves. But this guy literally takes people out every day.

1:05:34
Steve Daniels

He's been doing it for 10 years. And if you're listening, you should be ashamed of yourself. And it doesn't threaten my business because I'm well established, but anybody wants to get started in the charter fishing business, you got to go buy a license for $100 grand. Right, Brian? And if it's Southeast Alaska, it's probably $200,000 to buy the rights to go take 6 people out charter fishing for one boat.

1:06:00
Steve Daniels

Exactly right. So this is a really a big deal. So I know there's, you know, what happened between the longliners and the charter fishermen. Yeah, it's really unfortunate. I don't think it was fair, but that's the way it turned out.

1:06:16
Steve Daniels

And so the next thing that's going to happen It's gonna be the so-called self-guided business gonna proliferate. We have no idea how many fish they're taking cuz the reporting sucks. It's, it's unreliable. And at least we know those people are mostly incompetent and that helps, but they're also gonna get themselves killed. I think, uh, uh, Bruce had, uh, his hands raised for a little while.

1:06:41
Bruce

Bruce, do you have a question or a comment? Yeah. Um, Let's just go back to 40,000 feet for a minute.

1:06:50
Bruce

Um, this is the RAB research advisory. We've got all the IPHC scientists and biologists and technical people here patiently listening to us talk about having an argument with a guy on a dock catching a couple fish who actually even works for you. So it's— I mean, If, if this is a meeting where we just come and talk about whatever's on our mind, mostly what's on our mind, as my thing is, is political stuff. And if we're going to talk about sector conflicts and reporting and stuff like that, um, is that fit in the parameters of this thing? I guess, is it a free-for-all?

1:07:37
Bruce

Do I say what's on your mind, or is it we supposed to? Anyways, that, that's something to think about. I mean, for me as a commercial processor and fisherman, I got, I got 3 issues that we hit in January last year, and they're typically the same ones. I mean, we— I don't want to lose access to the fishery, to the sports sector. I don't give a shit whether you're guided or unguided.

1:08:04
Bruce

I want your reporting better and you can handle your own internal politics yourself, right? It's nothing to do with IPHC. And the Canada-US thing is always an arm wrestling fight and we always fight over that. I think it's a bit of a distraction. It hasn't changed that much over the last few years.

1:08:22
Bruce

We had some crazy event happen last year with some guy fell out of the sky on Wednesday night and turned the whole thing upside down after the processors board. I'm the chair of the processors board. We had already voted, we were finished, we were on our way wondering what we were going to have for dinner when this whole thing came unraveled. It made me really question what we've been doing there. It's the whole processing board's job only to argue over opening and closing dates, and nobody listened to a goddamn word we said last year.

1:08:52
Bruce

So that was a little bit frustrating. So that's the thing that's a little more important, you know. And you can sit here and say, I don't give a shit about sand plays. I don't give a shit about you talking to your guy on the dock who catches 2 fish a day and you don't like them. That's interesting, but I don't want to hear it at this meeting, Steve, you know, honestly.

1:09:09
Bruce

And the other thing that we don't talk about is trawl bycatch, you know, this Amendment 80 and trawling on nursery grounds and the impact on and the science around that. Those are big things, you know, losing access to halibut to the sports sector. Is a big concern. It's well-funded, well-organized, and they lobby to get more of my fish. That's something I want to know more about, and I want their reporting scrutinized.

1:09:40
Bruce

And losing access to the trawl sector— those are the three big things I see, you know. And the science people are working on whale deprivation, and they've got some amazing genetic and DNA stuff they're doing. It was amazing to hear about that, and I think that it goes to aging and it it goes to, you know, we've got some weak classes. We've been just praying to see a juvenile class come into maturity. We've been kind of fooling ourselves up.

1:10:07
Bruce

Now, Dr. Stewart should talk about this a bit. We, 5 years ago, we were like, well, the quota should go on, but I think I saw some, you know, we think we saw some. And then we said, well, let's just leave it the same. Then the next year, well, we think we saw some. We We didn't really stay with the scientists.

1:10:24
Bruce

We were kind of optimistic that we saw some juveniles coming in. So we sort of rode that for 4 or 5 years. And then we realized, you know what, they're not coming in that much. And so we started lowering the quota. And that's the kind of stuff that I expect to learn more about at this session.

1:10:42
Bruce

So I don't know, I'll shut up. But I mean, is this a political thing? I wish Dr.— I wish David Wilson was here and could referee this thing. I can—. What are we here for?

1:10:52
Josep Planas

Sure, I can speak to that. I mean, I think your point is really well taken. The purpose of this board meeting is really to provide advice on IPHC research activities. We obviously like to hear anything that's on your mind. That's really where the, you know, where the session overview comes into place.

1:11:18
Josep Planas

But really, this session, this section here, what we did yesterday and today, should be really devoted to discussing research activities, providing input into our current or suggesting further research activities. So your point is extremely well taken. And I would like to address before I finish, and I'll let Brian speak right now, but after Brian, I would like to respond to Kevin's comments, which are also highly appreciated. Brian? Oh, I'm going to take a cue from Bruce here, and there's just been an issue that got brought up a couple years ago.

1:11:52
Brian

We had some Norwegian scientists talk to us at FVOA about a whale deterrent device, and I asked about it at one point last year, but I didn't have anything specific. And I wanted to know if you guys have heard about and know anything about targeted acoustic startle technology I'm looking at an article right now. Targeted acoustic startle technology keeps killer whales away from fishing boats, and it was developed for the salmon fishery in Norway. And it kind of works on the flinch response instead of just a set— like you have— what's your device called, Jim?

1:12:30
Brian

An orca— what? Okay. And it's just— it makes a bunch of basically like really annoying constant noise, correct? No. No, it's got different frequencies and different, um, okay, um, kilohertz sweeps.

1:12:43
Brian

Okay, yeah, different sweeps, and then it, it's random and cycles through them. Okay, this is a supposedly a little bit different in that I think it's potentially less predictable for the killer whales, and it gets them to just go, I don't like that, I'm going away. And, um, when he was talking to us about it, it was specifically for for use in the black cod fishery. Um, and then we informed him that, like, you have any idea how deep we actually fish for black cod? And do you know what the currents are like down there?

1:13:15
Brian

And he was like, oh no, I was not aware of that at all, because he was talking about salmon seining. But it strikes me that, you know, halibut is typically a lot shallower. And it— I'm looking here, they say it's, it's good down to 50 meters. So I don't know if that means you lower it 50 meters or what, but I could see that maybe being relevant for the halibut fishery. And I would love to see this used in an environment I know more about, like the FIS.

1:13:44
Brian

So if there's any way we can contact this guy and see if he's interested in loaning us one of his devices for use on a FIS survey, I think that would be super interesting.

1:13:58
Claude

So, yeah, we've been in discussion with the guys who make TAST, and it's, it's tactile acoustic startle technology. And it, as you alluded to, it focuses on kind of an ingrained behavior where you startle and flinch and don't like that sort of activation. And it The way they market it is that it's something that you don't habituate to. So, with the OrcaSphere, if you keep using the same frequency all the time, at some point it often becomes a dinner bell. And, people have tried pingers and other sound-making devices to limited success.

1:14:37
Claude

Often initially it's novel and they're cautious about it, and so you have a couple good sets. The OrcaSphere now is tunable, so you can change it and have it more random and random lengths and those sorts of things. So, it's been a little more functional to my understanding. But, in our discussions with them, they were being advised by bankers who were really involved in the marketing side of things. And, they wanted a lot of free access to our science and our platforms without putting a lot of skin in the game themselves.

1:15:15
Claude

And we had some concerns about what happens if there is some sort of habituation that does happen over time with a response that the animal inherently has in it, probably from a safety perspective historically that they've learned. You know, like we have an aversion to snakes typically. Well, the whale has an aversion to this sound and responds to it for a reason. If it gets perceived at all by NGOs or the public that in some way there's harassment going on of these whales, that that could very quickly paint your fishery in a way that you don't want. So we've approached that one with caution.

1:15:53
Claude

We've watched the development of it. It's been very effective at places just like even right down the road here at the, at the locks where there's a fish ladder and there's pinnipeds actively feeding on salmon coming by. When they use the TAS technology, they are very effective at scaring those animals away, except for often there's a couple that don't. And that often has to do with an acoustic dead spot where they just can't hear the sound effectively, or they're hard of hearing and they just don't pick up on it. And they, you know, they're the one that hops into the fish ladder and it's like, God, this is great.

1:16:29
Claude

There's no competition today. Right. But it's been very effective on that front for pinnipeds, for aquaculture. Things like that. In our discussions with those guys, we had discussed having some sort of pod on the long line that would cover kind of 50-meter sections.

1:16:47
Claude

And so, you'd have a constant ability to kind of have a, I don't know, a ring of protection around your gear, right? And that maybe to save battery life on them, you would use AI that would listen for the sounds of depredating whales because certainly the sperm whales make a very distinct noise when they're actively feeding with clicks, um, that you could have the device turning on randomly when it gets triggered by the clicks that it's hearing just to save battery, right? Um, those are things that have been discussed with them. They didn't have developed yet, um, and we have not heard of any further work with longline gear from them, although I do keep tabs kind of on the company and where they are. Right now, it seems like they're currently focusing on aquaculture.

1:17:33
Claude

So, we're aware of it. We're interested in it. It's not gone further than that. The bankers didn't like our questions about the potential of habituating an animal to the never cry wolf scenario and that when the wolf then does show up, they don't respond to it because they've been hearing it elsewhere, things like that. And, they they kind of quickly stopped having discussions with us over some of those issues.

1:17:57
Claude

But it's not that it's not without potential. And I think if you get the original developer behind it, he's pretty passionate and excited about opportunities. And I think he's kind of being held back a little bit by the— at that time anyways— by the banking group that he had behind him.

1:18:16
Josep Planas

We have 4 minutes before the break. Are there any other pressing issues or quick comments? Alex?

1:18:25
Alex

Yes, something that Kevin brought up, and I've been thinking about it since I remembered I was coming here a couple of days, weeks, months ago. We were talking years ago, and I keep bringing it up because I'm interested in it, the larval stages and their nursery grounds and what have you. I think our last recommendation was if we could find a grad student or somebody like that to just do a literature search on possible encounters either through NOAA or NIMPS or somebody like that who's done some plankton trawls, maybe we can get some information on where the juveniles are staged and do we need to start worrying about protecting those areas, the nurseries? I don't think there was any or very little information about any of that stuff. And I think that's— sorry folks— research that needs to be done.

1:19:26
Josep Planas

So just bringing that up. Yeah, you're correct, Alex. This was a recommendation from the WRAP, I think from 2 years ago, if I'm not mistaken. We did have an intern work on during the summer of that year on that kind of project focused on well-known nursery areas in the Gulf of Alaska. I think it was in IPHC Regulatory Area 3A and looked at presence absence of juvenile Pacific halibut from historical data, not from IPHC data, but from data that we got from the University of Alaska Fairbanks.

1:20:09
Josep Planas

And also the co-occurrence of Pacific halibut juveniles with those of other species like northern rock sole, etc. So that work was contemplated a couple years ago. We have not had the chance to continue it, but that's really on our minds. So we take note of that and we'll definitely continue working In the last couple of minutes, if you allow me, I'd like to really respond to Kevin's comments, which are really on the dot, because I think you accurately saw a little bit where we are in terms of our research projects. I mean, you mentioned specifically that you had the idea that we kind of reached a plateau.

1:20:53
Josep Planas

I'd like to put it slightly different. I think we are actually at a turning point. Where for the last several years we've actually ground truth quite a few of the pressing issues in terms of the Pacific halibut biology. You know, namely population structure, that's resolved, and that was a huge question in terms of management. Maturity has also been reevaluated.

1:21:21
Josep Planas

We've established DMRs, experimentally from in the longline as well as in the commercial fishery that was not done before. So we reached in 2025, 2026, we actually provided really important inputs for stock assessment.

1:21:40
Josep Planas

And, you know, we're continuing to do some of that work, but now we're at a point where that's where I like to refer to that more of as a turning point. Now, really, we need to start thinking about what's next. And I think you hit the mark in that we're actually considering— and we had a— for the last two scientific review board meetings, which are held in June and September, and we held those this year, the highlight was really to come up with new ideas. So we're— I should indicate that We are now in that process. One of the things that we have not discussed here is the issue of size at age.

1:22:22
Josep Planas

And that's now becoming one of our big topics for discussion internally to determine, you know, what are the possible drivers of those historical changes in size at age that we've seen over the last, not only during the last 40 years, but during the last 80 years, because, you know, Ian Stewart always in his stock assessments presentation that weighted age has not just been decreasing, it was actually low in the 1940s, '50s, increased, and then is now down. So the causes for that are just not fishing. There's— it's probably a very complicated question in terms of the influence of environment, fishing, a lot of combinations, other species, etc. So to summarize, we're actually in the process of really thinking and putting a lot of emphasis on environmental inputs. What's the environment— what's the environment's role in shaping a lot of the responses that we're seeing?

1:23:25
Josep Planas

Maturity, the spatial changes in maturity, and other things. So I appreciate that comment because that reflects really where we are right now. I hope that in the next RAB meeting, we're actually going to be able to present you with what we're doing next in a different— in several different research areas.

1:23:50
Bruce

Yeah, Loren, and then—. I was talking about the same thing about Ian yesterday, that we've got 2 years of this super El Niño coming up. And you guys have any comments on that? We're all obviously curious what your input scientific improvements on that? Yeah, well, you know, the consequences of that, of the current El Niño are to be seen.

1:24:11
Josep Planas

What we have is information on previous extreme marine events, the ones that happened in the mid-2010s, 2014, 2016. In fact, you know, what we're looking at is, you know, the possible, that possible change in maturity that we saw in the age of maturity that may have been driven by high temperature events. So that's something that we're investigating right now. So we're gonna keep track of, you know, the development of those, you know, water temperatures and extreme heat events in our research moving forward. Lauren.

1:24:52
Loren

With respect to the environmental stuff, I talk to a lot of folks in Sitka before I came down here, and overwhelmingly a lot of them were interested in more research on habitat and what is critical habitat or essential habitat or whatever for halibut. And it's kind of seems like there's not a lot known about what exactly characterizes essential habitat for halibut.

1:25:18
Josep Planas

So yeah, so maybe that would be one thing to add. Yeah, that links very well with what Alex was referring to before.

1:25:30
Ian Stewart

Ian? Maybe just a quick comment. Well, first one is that the intern that Josette mentioned that was working on these juvenile larval stage, that was actually William from 3 summers ago. So it's kind of cool that you can see him. We got him so interested that he's back doing a whole project on halibut.

1:25:48
Ian Stewart

And then maybe getting to Brian's question about task stuff, and just sort of stepping back from that a little bit, I just wanted to kind of mention that the Commission has a really long history of looking at fishing technology. Over the years, we've looked—. We looked at the transition from J to circle hooks, we've looked at bait size and type, we've looked at hook spacing, we've looked at bycatch reduction, we've looked at the use of pots for habitat, and for bycatch reduction, we've looked at things like putting metals on hooks to discourage dogfish, these appendage work that Claude's talked about. And then most recently, we've been more focused on whale depredation and the shuttle and the shrouds and things, perhaps, you know, and we did explore, we've explored this TAS technology a bit as well. But I think as Josep mentioned, as we're kind of at a where are we going next phase in our research, this might be a really helpful time for the RAB to comment on should we continue this legacy of having fishing technology as part of our research quiver?

1:26:47
Ian Stewart

And if so, even if we don't— can't name specific projects, just, you know, is there continued interest, say, in whale depredation reduction devices and/or other things? Even though you might think it's kind of a no-brainer, it would be helpful if the RAB— whatever the RAB's opinion— to have that in the report. I think, I think we should definitely keep that in the quiver, and I know exploring the tasks, I think, would be a really neat way to go. And I've talked to the guys that work on it, and maybe I could just put them in touch with you.

1:27:26
Loren

Yeah.

1:27:30
Josep Planas

All right, I think, I think it's time for a break. Let's take a— it's now 10:35, just 5 minutes before Behind schedule. Let's get back at— in about an hour and 5 minutes to complete the last 2 sections. The first one is other business. This is just to go around the room to see if there's any issues regarding the type of meeting that we're hosting since the last 2 meetings.

1:28:05
Josep Planas

Meaning that, you know, we're doing a full day of presentations and then we end up with a discussion, and then we have half a day on day 2 of continued discussions and then going over the report. Is everybody happy with this kind of setup? Yes. And also, you know, a few years ago we also tried to move the RAB meeting closer to the Pacific Marine Expo so that— because we were aware that some of you are actually participating in that as well, so we try to set the dates right before the, the, uh, the PME every year. Uh, does that work also for you?

1:28:41
Josep Planas

Yep. Okay, perfect. So let's, let's move on to the, uh, report. Well, I will share my screen and, and we're going to go over that document.

1:29:17
Josep Planas

Okay, we should be seeing it on screen pretty soon. Let's make this a little bigger.

1:29:34
Jim

This one, hold on.

1:29:43
Josep Planas

Okay, so this is the, this is the document that we're gonna take a look, so.

1:29:53
Josep Planas

Let's see. Okay. We're gonna go through the table of contents.

1:29:59
Ian Stewart

So yeah.

1:30:07
Josep Planas

So we're gonna start with the IPHC process. This is just 3.1 is— I'm sorry. Am I— I don't think I'm showing. Oh, yeah. Here we go.

1:30:17
Josep Planas

So this is just the noting that paper RAP 2703 provided an opportunity to consider the progress made during the intersessional period in relation to the recommendations and requests of the previous RAP meeting.

1:30:39
Josep Planas

We note that there were two actions that remained in progress and 2 other pending, and that will be reported in the next, uh, following meeting. Uh, so there were a few recommendations from RAP 26, uh, that, uh, will be addressed in the following, uh, RAP 28 meeting, uh, in 2027. Um, the RAP agreed to consider the actions arising from RAP 026 and revise as necessary And then we move on into the season overview. So this is a summary of some of the key points that were raised yesterday in the season overview. So under point 8, the RAB noted the following key 2026 fishery updates provided by RAB members: A, whale depredation, primarily orcas and sperm whales, a) Marine mammals remained an issue coastwide.

No audio detected at 1:30:40

1:31:40
Josep Planas

B) Dogfish were a continued problem in 2026 with high catches reported in IPHC regulatory areas 2B, 2C, and 3A.

1:31:52
Josep Planas

Point c) The discrepancy observed between low dogfish abundance estimates in IPHC regulatory area 2B and actual high fishery encounters remains a source of concern.

1:32:10
Josep Planas

D, sand fleas were anecdotally reported as less of a problem in 2026 compared to 2025 in most areas. Improved reporting coastwide remained important to better understand the issue long-term.

1:32:26
Josep Planas

E, fish prices were substantially higher that was a 20-year high in 2026 compared to 2024 and 2025, and remained so for the entire fishing period.

1:32:40
Josep Planas

F, small fish under 32 inches were being seen in high numbers in most IPHC regulatory areas.

1:32:51
Josep Planas

G, Pacific halibut fishing was generally poor and geographically variable in most IPHC regulatory areas compared to previous years.

1:33:01
Josep Planas

H, a high yelloweye rockfish bycatch was a source of concern coastwide. And I, lower levels of incidental catch of Pacific halibut by the salmon troll fishery were observed in IPHC regulatory area 2A.

1:33:22
Josep Planas

Removing the salmon?

1:33:27
1:33:31
Josep Planas

Okay, all right, all right. So let's—.

1:33:55
Josep Planas

Like this? Yeah. Yeah. It's attributed to salmon species moving higher in the water column. Are there any comments?

1:34:12
Josep Planas

My inference is, I don't know, consensus of the Senate votes, but it just seems that the Senate, especially those that are older, older folks, they look to— You're all okay about leaving the second part of that sentence?

1:34:43
Brian Ritchie

Yeah, any other comments? Under F, I think, yeah, that aligns with what we heard, but I think also some people said that there were just, maybe I'm just thinking of what I was saying, but I thought I heard other people say there was, it seemed like there were just less big fish. You know, it's always going to feel like there's more small fish when there's less big fish. But I definitely noticed less big fish.

1:35:10
Josep Planas

Is that a common sentiment? Yeah. Okay, so, so that would be Would this be appropriate? Small fish were being seen in high numbers and big fish were seen, were being seen.

1:35:46
Brian Ritchie

I think that captures it. I mean, not necessarily like O32, I just mean like I saw, I don't know if I spoke to it. I think that probably captures it just fine though. Right, so removing, removing the O32.

1:36:08
Josep Planas

So we remove the O32, that would cover it.

1:36:13
Josep Planas

Okay, any other comments here?

1:36:20
Josep Planas

If not, we move to 5. So that's just to the RAP to note the paper that describes the draft IPHC integrated research and monitoring plan.

1:36:34
Josep Planas

And then 10 is that the RAP noted the presentation of Mr. William Le from the University of Washington. That was yesterday. That provided an update on a project that aims to describe the RAP and the MSAB processes and the role of participants. To produce a synthesis of participant perspectives on benefits and costs of participation, strength of the process, and areas for improvement. And finally, to identify opportunities for improving collaborative research to support Pacific halibut fisheries.

1:37:05
Josep Planas

The main objective of this project is to determine how successful the collaboration between fishers and scientists is for the participants. Mr. Lei also called for additional participation for from RAB members.

1:37:22
Jim

If there are no comments, I'll move on to—. Can I make one comment? Yeah, yeah, please. I was thinking about the makeup of the RAB. In, you know, in the past it was active fishermen and processors, active processor representation from both countries, and it was about a dozen from each country.

1:37:44
Jim

And we don't— I think our— the type of participation has changed on the RAB from what it was. I'm thinking back because I think I've been here for 23 or 24 years now, and, and it seems like a little different makeup of participation. So, and that, of course, maybe— I don't know, maybe it changes perspectives more, maybe, or or less. I don't know, but it's— I just wonder.

1:38:14
Jim

I don't know.

1:38:19
Jim

Well, and I'd like to see more Canadians here, but things change, you know, the whole situation in Canada. And like Bruce says, you know, for the fishermen are being put out of business. So, you know, so many guys that are used to be here and had great input too. And, uh, just tremendous input. But when you can't make a living, they're gone.

1:38:39
Jim

And, and age—. We're kind of aging out too, I guess, for some of us. But yeah, anyway, I just thought I'd bring that up a little bit. Right. Yeah, that is, uh, yeah, thanks for, uh, I don't know, for that.

1:38:51
Josep Planas

Wrong, Jim. I think we've, uh, in the, in the past, uh, we've actually been, um, trying to recruit additional Canadian members. Uh, last year we had We're fortunate enough to bring Bruce along with Jason Roberts. Tiara Boyce, unfortunately, she resigned from the RAP, but Angus is still a member, so there's a total of 3. We hope to increase that number.

1:39:13
Bruce

So to our Canadian participants, if you know of any other potential individuals that could participate in the RAP, just feel free to push those names. It's tough because even Brian made the same observation. Angus, one of the main contributors here, he's using halibut as a supplement to a different target fishery, right? I mean, if a block of halibut for a boat's 35,000 pounds a year, pretty hard to get a guy to take a week or two out of his schedule and go to these meetings and stuff, you know. And like, like Jim said, they're aging out too, right?

1:39:53
Bruce

These guys are, you know, anyways, yeah, it's hard to get the young guys in. I think what William, if we'd put in a science glossary symposium and try and soften the technical landing for some of these young guys, it's intimidating for sure, that science, especially at the January meeting. Holy cow, you know? Yep. Yeah.

1:40:23
Josep Planas

Yeah, no, that point is definitely well taken.

1:40:32
Josep Planas

Um, that is something that we could, uh, Indeed, place, you know, maybe not in this section because this section is really on the integrated research and monitoring plan, but maybe on— I mean, maybe on the IPHC process, maybe that would be a section that would be a little more appropriate. What about the Canadians that do the FIS? I mean, that seems like the perfect sort of applicant. They're already maybe a little bit more involved in the fishery than others because, you know, they're like— I know, what is it, Star Wars typically does a survey, right? What about the skipper of the Star Wars, for instance?

1:41:25
Brian

Maybe some pleas could be made. That's you? I was—. Wasn't there a younger guy that was— yeah, I was, I was thinking about him. I didn't know the Star Wars was your boat, but Yeah, apologies.

1:41:47
Brian

I'm glad one skipper of the Star Wars is here. Let's get both of them.

1:41:54
Jim

So I was thinking of some of those guys like David Bays and everything. We had tremendous, uh, depth, but they're actively fishing, but they also had the science depth and everything too, and it was— I learned a lot from people that were both hands-on as well as not, and from the staff. It was—. It's been a good experience overall.

1:42:19
Josep Planas

So, uh, if, if the RAP, uh, feels so, uh, we could actually include, uh, either a recommendation— a recommendation again goes to the commissioners, a request is directly a request to the Secretariat. Um, so, um, it's It's up to the RAP whether you want to elevate that to a recommendation so that the commissioners see that the RAP as a body promotes the incorporation of additional profiles or individuals, or whether it's just a request for us to expand, you know, and continue our efforts to recruit additional members. That's really up to the RAP. Either way. Well, would a recommendation carry more weight, Juan, and get a little more energy pointed in that direction?

1:43:08
Josep Planas

Recommendation does carry more weight. Yeah. So is a recommendation what the RAP would prefer rather than a request?

1:43:18
Josep Planas

Yeah. Yes.

1:43:23
1:43:25
Josep Planas

OK, so the rep recommended that the Secretariat— and I think we have somebody online, I see a hand raised, I can't see who is it, but please go ahead and speak.

1:43:49
Josep Planas

I gave a thumbs up there, but— I never raised my hand. Oh, okay. Sorry. I, you know, I can't see the hand raised or— Would a request or recommendation to include further Canadian members?

1:44:37
Jim

Some of us are kind of aging out too, so— Pass recommendations on to you, Joseph. I'm sorry, pass recommendations as someone like you to you, Joseph, for different potential members? Yes, yeah, yeah, me or Dave Wilson. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so this would read, uh, the IPHC— I'm sorry, the RAB recommended that the IPHC Secretariat expand its efforts to incorporate additional members to the RAB, particularly Canadian potential members.

1:45:10
Kevin

Does that read okay? Yep, I think it sounds good. Okay, so let's go back to 5.

1:45:25
Josep Planas

So we did, um, 10, 11, let's go to 12. So now we're in research, uh, the Number 12 is that the RAP notes the paper, RAP 02706, that provides a description of the biological and ecosystem science research projects. 13, That the RAP notes that the main objectives of the biological and ecosystem science research at the IPHC is A, B, and C. And now into the specifics of the different sections that were discussed yesterday.

1:46:16
Brian

Yeah, I don't know if this is the right place for it, but I was, um, I was talking with Ian Stewart about, um, making sure that out of this paper we stress that we think, um, fishing technology, us researching fishing technology is useful. Not necessarily just to like do it for the sake of doing it. And again, this might come at a later point, but I thought I'd jump in here. Um, we don't want them just doing it just because they got to fill their time, but we want to make sure that this body is open to doing research when the right research projects come along, and that we stress that we think that's valuable and important. Because we have the perfect platform for doing it in the FIS.

1:46:55
Brian

It's just such an awesome opportunity to test something in as a controlled environment as you can. Um, if I, I think I've heard maybe some people at the annual meeting saying, why are we spending our time on that? And I just want to make sure that this body, at least I think so, I think it's useful to, uh, be open to researching fishing technology when the right opportunity arises. Yeah, yeah, thanks, Brian. Uh, you'll see that, uh, uh, I think it's I think it's number 20, there's a line item that addresses that.

1:47:27
Josep Planas

And we can revise the text so that it fits more or less what you have in mind.

1:47:35
Josep Planas

So going into the specific sections, the first one is delineating the genetic population structure of Pacific halibut throughout convention waters. 14, The RAB noted the paper that described the outcomes of a recent study completed by the IPHC Secretariat. On delineating Pacific halibut population structure and that reported on the lack of discrete genetic groups within IPHC conventional waters, supporting current IPHC assessment practices that model the Pacific halibut population as a single coast-wide stock.

1:48:13
Josep Planas

Is everybody okay with that statement?

1:48:16
Josep Planas

Next will be the development of the genetic-based method for estimating age of Pacific halibut. That's number 15. The RAB noted paper, the paper that provided the description of the studies designed to develop a genetic-based method of aging Pacific halibut using fin clips. Non-lethal genetic samples already used for genetic sexing and genetic population analysis.

1:48:41
Josep Planas

Is the WRAP okay with that statement?

1:48:45
Josep Planas

Okay. Then moving on into the reproductive assessment of the Pacific halibut population, the WRAP noted the paper that provided the description of the study's design to update maturity schedules and estimate fecundity in female Pacific halibut. Number 17, that's a little bit of a long one. The WRAP noted the comparative analysis of coast-wide histological, that is microscopic, and visual, that is macroscopic, maturity ogives generated from data collected in the FIS during the period 2022 to 2024, and the development of a calibration that was applied to re-estimate, that is to calibrate, historical visual maturity data collected in the FIS during the period 2002 to 2024. The RAP also noted the shift in the age of 50% maturity, that's that A50 value, during the period before and after 2016.

1:49:43
Josep Planas

From a gradual increase in A50 values, that is an increase in the age at 50% maturity until 2016, and a subsequent sharp decrease in A50 values, that is a decrease in the age of, at 50% maturity, until approximately 2022.

1:50:04
Brian

I'd just like to point out that Bruce brought up an interesting question about if the relative population in an area of females versus males potentially had any correspondence to that shift, if you remember that. Yeah, just, just, we were interested in if female maturity at the age at which they became mature had any correspondence to the, the weighted population of males or females in an area. And I remember the scientist being like, oh yeah, we don't know. That's interesting. So it'd be interesting to pursue that too.

1:50:51
Josep Planas

Yeah, um, right, we, we can potentially add this here.

1:50:59
Josep Planas

Um, I think, I think you could add that as a request. Yeah, yeah, I think, I think you should probably add that, uh, as a separate request. So that would go something like this, the wrap The rap, yes, thank you.

1:51:42
Josep Planas

Between spatial differences and between—. Oh yeah.

1:52:12
Josep Planas

Would this reflect the idea that was just discussed? So that would read, the RAP requested the IPC Secretariat investigate possible links between sex ratios and maturity at age of female Pacific halibut? Okay.

1:52:32
Josep Planas

So then we move on to 19. That's the WRAP noted the revised calibrated coast-wide maturity ogive with an A50 value of 11 years of age that has replaced the previous maturity ogive since the 2025 stock assessment.

1:52:53
Josep Planas

Next one is 20. The WRAP noted the collection of ovarian samples for fecundity during during the period of 2023 to 2026 over a broad range of female sizes and ages, and the choice of the autodiometric method for fecundity estimations.

1:53:14
Josep Planas

And then 21, the WRAP recommended prioritizing fecundity estimations to determine the relationship between Pacific halibut female weight and total egg production. Is the RAP okay with this last statement, 21?

1:53:33
Josep Planas

Okay, then we move to the section on discard mortality rates. So discard mortality rates of Pacific halibut in the charter recreational fishery. 22, The RAP noted that the paper that provided the description of the completed results of the study designed to provide direct estimates of discard mortality in the Pacific Halibut Charter Recreational Fishery that could be used to update currently applied estimates in management?

1:54:06
Alex

Would this be where we could ask that we let ADFNG and people like that know that we think that more information is needed? They need to do a better job of recording that data, or is that something beyond our capabilities?

1:54:26
Josep Planas

I'm not entirely sure because this really relates directly and only to the charter recreational fishery. So— For the charter guided. Guided, yeah, we're looking for unguided charter activity more than guided. Right, so the results of our paper relate to the DMR estimates in the guided charter recreational fishery alone. Yeah.

1:55:01
Josep Planas

Masha, did you have something to say?

1:55:05
Basia

I guess if you want to add anything on the unguided sector, it would be most appropriate to to add it in the monitoring section, and— but that I do suggest that will be something more of an IPHC requesting additional information from the ADFNG. Please do note that we do not conduct this analysis ourselves. This— we do rely on the annual report that the ADFNG is supplying to the IPHC because the unguided estimates are based on a statewide harvest survey that is run by the ADFNG, and we do not have access access to, to that data at all. So we, we do not have the capacity to, to conduct any analysis of that. So the only thing we can do is relay the, you know, your concerns to the ADFNG.

1:55:54
Basia

Um, I will also note that I just want to provide maybe a clarification that I understand there are some concerns regarding the increasing unguided sector mortality and accounting of that in the stock assessment. But do please know that typically the current year unguided mortality is a projection. We— the, the data for the unguided sectors typically with, uh, coming to us with a year lag, and the current year is a projection based on the previous year. So really, the more reliable information is when you look at the, your prior information that was updated each year. So for the 2026 information, 2026 is projections based on the previous year, and what you more reliable information for comparison you should be looking is the updated 2025 information.

1:56:55
Basia

Go ahead, Brian. In this case, what you're talking about, am I correct in remembering that It was estimated to be £0.9 million, and then we found out it was £1.4 million. Last year there was that really large revision, and this year that there, there was also a revision, not of that magnitude, but there's also a revision. So I just want to stress that, that we do get those revisions into the stock assessment, just typically with a 1-year lag. So the current year, it will be the kind of straightforward projection based on last year.

1:57:29
Basia

And if the statewide harvest survey indicates an increase that would— in 2026, that will be typically reflected in the 2027 survey. And I will just note that we do annually get the letter from the ADFNG specifying the estimates, including projection for current year and updates for the previous year, together with the note on the methodology. And that information is also, uh, as a requestable by the Commission, um, and as to be included in the annual report of the contracting parties to the APHC. So some of this additional information, especially on the revised estimates, that was something that was of interest, and that was specifically added based on the request to the national report from the United States. So You can also look for, for that for the last year in that paper, and that would be likely part of the national report from the US for the annual meeting this year, or for 2026 and 2027, January.

1:58:32
Brian

Okay. I just, um, it seems like sometimes when we're talking about, um, this issue, and it seems like sometimes there's a couple other issues that are closely related to this where we're like, okay, I guess that's not in the purview of IPHC, and there seems to be a lot of sensitivity about not overstepping and trying to do someone else's job, but I'm just wondering if it's okay for us to be blunt in asking the IPHC to address it at the annual meeting and for them to be blunt in telling ADF&G, this is really important to us, we realize it's not our job, but we want you to do your job better. Because I got a 10%, I'm allowed to catch 10% over or 10% under, and essentially it doesn't affect my quota. But to go— for us to estimate 0.9 million pounds and then for it to be 50% higher, that just seems like someone needs to do a better job there. And it's not— apparently it's not our job, so it's not our fault.

No audio detected at 1:59:00

1:59:31
Brian

But let's ask them, be very blunt in saying that's unacceptable.

1:59:41
Jim

Yeah, the problem is everything runs downhill to the commercial sector and we're left with the leftovers, because that's where we're at, we're at the bottom of the ladder. Yeah, there will be a comment later on addressing this issue.

1:59:57
Josep Planas

So yeah, this is not part of the research discussion, this will be addressed later. I suggest we move on. The next item is the whale depredation mitigation strategies that were presented yesterday. So the WRAP, under line 23, the WRAP notes the paper that provided the description of a study design to evaluate the efficacy of a catch protection shuttle device to reduce killer whale depredation in the Pacific halibut online fishery. Under 24, the WRAP noted the preliminary results from this study indicating that the shuttle can be safely deployed avoid and retrieve by fishing vessels with the picking boom, and that it has good protection of Pacific halibut.

2:00:41
Josep Planas

So this concludes Section 5.1 regarding the research. Any comments?

2:00:51
Lando

No? Yeah, can we— at the end of the whale depredation one, can we recommend that the RAB or the Commission Secretariat look at the efficacy of a hunting season for killer whales?

2:01:11
Lando

No, can't do that. Can we tag them? Put pinnipeds in a cage. Actually, we, yeah, I'm, I think we need to do I mean, you're doing a great job, Claude, and all your tentacles out there, uh, keeping your finger on the pulse of the latest. But they're way ahead of our curve, and, and they're taking a lot of fish.

2:01:40
Lando

We can't even, we can't even quantify how much fish they're taking. And, um, just from my fishing out west and every other place, they're getting, they're getting better at it, and there's a lot more of them now than there used to be. So, um, yeah, and the shuttle is a good thing, but it doesn't really work at scale for the fleet. Um, so yeah, either hunt them, or— which isn't— which is impossible— but, uh, tagging them. And we have— we do have data where we can— there's definitely spots where they always are.

2:02:18
Lando

And that should be in the logbook data, right? So we can take that data and maybe, um, figure out a way to tag them. Like Jim said, they've been tagged in Southeast before. And so then we'd have a database of where they are and they move around a lot. But if they're tagged, then yeah.

2:02:40
Lando

So anyway, I think, yeah, I'm just joking about hunting them, but, uh, Seriously, but tagging them seriously might be, uh, something that we could pursue down the line somewhere. And, uh, you know, technology is rapidly developing. We could use drones to tag them, and maybe the tags we put on them could be, you know, uh, transponders or something where if you know where they're at and you have a I mean, a receiver type tag. Yeah, it's gonna shock the hell out of them. Huh?

2:03:19
Lando

It's gonna tell you not to fish in 4A. Yeah, or 4B, or 4D, or 4C, or the Gulf. Anyway, we have tried tagging them.

2:03:29
Loren

With killer whales, it gets a little bit harder than with sperm whales because the tags don't stay on very long. They're really expensive. They are increasing the technology to be able to tag from drones. Which makes it a little bit easier, but they had this issue where they tagged a killer whale, one of the southern resident killer whales down in Washington, and it got like an infection and died. And then they just put a whole cut.

2:03:54
Loren

So then they, then they just like outlawed tagging on killer whales for a while. But I think to your point, like maybe asking the IPHC to investigate other measures, like maybe putting more energy into investigating investigating the TAST because that is showing promise with killer whales in Norway. Um, and maybe if they can work with those developers to make it suitable for longline boats, um, that would be like another good step in the right direction. Because I think, I think the guys that make that thing really think it would work for us. Um, it took me a while And he's had limited success, but he's like the only one.

2:04:38
Loren

And he's put a lot of time and energy into making it work. So yeah. When we've told them that and all of our concerns about habituation and all of that, and they've said like, we really think this is not like the orcasphere. This is very different and yada yada. So maybe it's worth just trying it.

2:04:55
Loren

Yeah, I agree. I think anything that, uh, any avenue, I'm just bringing up tagging because You know, it seems like we're sort of at a, not a dead end, but the problem's getting worse and everything we've done doesn't work. In Southeast with the sperm whales, we tried this thing called an avoidance network where we did a combination of tagging a whole bunch of sperm whales and having people report twice a day, like instead of their actual area, the actual place they were fishing, because that people like to keep that private, we kind of broke it into like little chunks. And they checked in twice a day with one of our people on the ground. And so then she would report out twice a day where, yeah, what zones, we called them, were reporting and how many whales were in each of those zones and where tagged whales were.

2:05:46
Loren

So you could make an informed decision about, okay, well, this is where the zones are reporting at night. You can decide where you're going the next day or if you were gonna move or whatever. And it didn't really work that well because people didn't really wanna report when they didn't have whales they didn't want people moving into that area.

2:06:03
Loren

It was like, can we make collaborative fishing happen? And the answer was kind of like, no. But we, because we thought, well, we can't tag all the sperm whales, so we have to do something else in addition to just tagging to let people know where they are. But that didn't work. But anyway, there's—.

2:06:18
Josep Planas

Yeah, so maybe the recommendation should just be, keep doing what you're doing, 'cause you're doing a great job, do more of it and figure out something quicker. Yeah, you will see that there's a comment later on. We'll address that, and we can revise it if you feel that the language doesn't incorporate all your thoughts. Bruce, I think you had a question. I got a couple things to add to that, Lando.

2:06:45
Bruce

I mean, maybe Claude could put like a little hand grenade on his shuttle that they could trigger remotely, and that would help. And we should also experiment with them as an alternate bait, killer whale bait would be good too. Use 'em for bait and see how that works. And let's do some real studying on killer whales. It's a great idea.

2:07:06
Bruce

Anyways, one other thing that's real interesting, you remind me of, through the fall here, sort of from September on, there's been a group of 5 orcas in Dixon Entrance there, and they kind of start around Butterworth Celestial, which is the kind of reef sort of on the mainland side, outside of Prince Rupert. There's— they circle up past Chignik and they circle out to Mazón and they turn back down towards Langara and then they come across the top of the Haida Gwaii there and they're just going around in circles. And they, on our last trip, they followed the boat all the way into Prince Rupert Harbor, all the way to the dock. We got videos of them all going under the dock. They weren't any farther away than that, but they— this same group, it's just wreaking havoc with everybody and they're just going around and they got a circuit in there and they're just messing with everybody.

No audio detected at 2:07:20

2:07:53
Bruce

It's pretty, pretty— when you can even— there was one male, two females, and two juveniles, and everybody saw them. There was five of them. They were just going around just causing crap with everyone. So that was— anyways, I got one actually serious point that I know it's way too late to bring up something to, to add to this, but let's maybe just think about it, is like We, when we do these charters, we do that CCAT thing, and it, and, and we get a lot of data from that. We spend a lot of time.

2:08:21
Bruce

It's a real headache to deal with it sometimes. And we get that bottom data, and we're doing turbidity and all the data they get from that, you know. And Angus brought up, you know, the most movements of hypoxia growing or moving or shifting down there. And we're, I mean, it probably relates to my favorite subject, which is sand fleas, of course, but maybe there's a relationship to that. But maybe we can start to map some trends or some data or quantify some of the results we get from that thing, because I mean, we're using it a lot of places and we're gathering a lot of data.

2:08:55
Bruce

I never really hear anything back about that. So maybe there's something we could get some reporting on that, if there's any patterns or shifts, or especially with this El Niño coming up. And I am pretty kind of interesting. It's right in these guys' wheelhouse.

2:09:13
Jim

Along that line too, Bruce, I was approached a couple days ago, and I haven't talked to them again. They sent me an email that they wanted me to ask if I'd be willing to be involved in a study where we put different units on the ground line so they can get salinities and water temperatures and all kinds of data. From the ocean floor wherever we're fishing this year. And I don't know, I haven't talked to him about it yet, but I was just approached in an email a couple days ago. I'd have to look it up.

2:09:48
Josep Planas

But anyway, they're some agency. Somehow they got my name and that I was more open to—. They heard I was open to doing projects, so So Bruce's, uh, Bruce's comment could actually be incorporated, uh, in a comment that, um, was written to address Scott's request to maintain the use of the CCAPs. So maybe we could actually expand that and incorporate, uh, Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, we can discuss that, uh, in, in the next—.

2:10:40
Bruce

The only time we really hear a lot about it is when we lose one. Yeah, they're nuts. Yeah, very popular that day. Yeah.

2:10:51
Jim

Good day.

2:10:54
Josep Planas

Yeah. So moving on to monitoring, knowing that we've got another 20 minutes left, we should be able to complete the report by then. But under 5.2.1, that's the fishery-dependent data. Line 25 indicates that the WRAP notes the paper that provided an update on work aimed at addressing the request from WRAP 26 that was to set up efforts to increase documentation of cyanobacteria occurrence during commercial fishing activities. So we've heard quite a bit of that.

2:11:30
Josep Planas

Is this— and there's again, later on, there's another specific comment addressing the revised discussion on that topic. So you'll see that in a minute.

2:11:45
Josep Planas

5.22, That's the fishery independent data. So the first is the 2020, and this should be 2026 fish season.

2:11:59
Josep Planas

So the WRAP notes the paper that provided an overview of the IPHC fishery independent satellite survey design and implementation in 2026. The WRAP discussed the 2026 fish activities and generally confirmed confirm trends in catch rates and fish prices.

2:12:18
Josep Planas

Moving on to the 2027-2029 FIS design evaluations, line number 28, the WRAP noted the paper that provided— sorry, proposed designs. Just back one if we could. Did we confirm trends in catch rates of the FIS?

2:12:40
Angus

Like, were we presented with what the catch was in the FIS?

2:12:50
Josep Planas

Yeah, and probably Ray did not either.

2:13:01
Basia

Yeah, we do have the updated FIS and other research catches in the Fishery Data Overview paper. So it is available there if you would like to see. We can certainly pull that document if you would like to, but these data are available on our website.

2:13:22
Josep Planas

Right. So maybe we should remove that because it was not actually discussed here. Maybe we should just remove this and just Leave it as discuss the 2026 fish activities and fish prices. I think there was a discussion on fish prices yesterday. Um, and unsuccessful— that would be inside the fish activities.

2:13:57
Josep Planas

Yeah. Are you okay with leaving line 27 as is? Discuss the 2026 FIS activities and FIS prices? Okay. Yeah.

2:14:08
Josep Planas

All right, perfect. Let's move on to the line 28. That's the WRAP notes, the paper that provides the proposed designs for IPHC's FIS for the 2027-2029 period and and, and evaluation of those designs. Uh, 29, the WRAP supported an annual phys design with sufficient coverage across all biological regions, and that the IPHC Secretariat continue its efforts to obtain supplementary funding for phys activities that would support this goal, including through direct increases in contracting party contributions.

2:14:49
Josep Planas

So RAP okay with this statement?

2:14:53
Josep Planas

Okay. Then we move on to the last meaty section of the report, and that's the guidance on and discussion of other potential applied research projects. So the first one under 30 is that RAP noted the use of chum salmon as standardized bait in the FIS and discussed possible alternatives for bait, for example, other salmon species, hatchery discards, etc.

2:15:24
Josep Planas

Under 31, the RAP noted the importance of catch reporting from the various recreational Pacific halibut fisheries sectors.

2:15:36
Brian

I just wondered if my comment about potentially leveraging the sale of fish against plants putting up salmon for you in the future is relevant, if we should put that in here. Like, I don't even know if processors are really aware, like, how important the bait is and how it could potentially have an effect on our— like, it's had an effect on my ability to— my confidence in going out to an area and having a good trip because I don't know if I'm gonna have bait to do it. I, I realize that they're trying to sell a product for, you know, for food, and they're making more money doing that, but it could potentially have an effect on our ability to deliver fish to them. So I think it's relevant to try to leverage the sale of a trip with, hey, you know, I'm gonna, I'm gonna sell you this fish, but I need you to do me a favor. Is—.

2:16:30
Brian

Can we include that somewhere? Is that relevant, or, or what?

2:16:44
Jim

Well, your bait—. Your bait contract's separate from your, uh, the sale of the fish. So whoever put the bait up might not even bid on the halibut at all. The other problem too with the bait issue is depending on what the market is, sales— like last year, chums were a hot commodity. So you're probably getting number 4s or 5s for bait is what I'm afraid of, because they were getting $1.75 for black chums, right?

2:17:11
Brian

I got, uh, False Pass to put up 6,000 pounds of bright chums for me because I sold them a black cod trip. I'm not saying anything's going to come from it, but if you're selling them fish, why not ask them, can you put up some salmon for me? Because if it's a tie between Westward and False Pass, and False Pass is going, we'll give you the same price as Westward and we'll put up 10,000 pounds of chums for you. Decision made, go to False Pass and deliver. Yeah, because you're doing that as an individual for yourself.

2:17:40
Speaker P

I had to because I couldn't get any chance, right? I know, and we do those things too, but as far as the organization, I don't know, we, we've got Just to add, that makes a lot of sense for you as you're fishing for yourself, but I would anticipate even just your example, myself and my team having issues rationalizing that to a captain who has no incentive to do that. I'm looking at the two captains that I would probably be talking to about this option. Like if I give you a call and be like, hey, you were planning to go to westward, but actually now I need you to fall Falls Pass because I'm gonna get a better deal and that's not going to make benefit you in any way possible. I just, I have to be honest and say that that could propose some logistical issues for us.

2:18:34
Brian

Okay, say it was between Sandpoint and Falls Pass. I mean, and you're doing the Schoonigan Charter. No, I'm just saying it doesn't hurt to ask. I don't know if anything's going to come from it, but you're definitely not going to get them to put up any bait for you out of the kindness of their heart. And if you can include it as, hey, we'd also like you to, to do this, would you be willing?

2:18:52
Brian

And if they say yes, great. Let's say they put the bait up for you and then you get Coastal to ship it to Dutch where you need it. I don't know.

2:19:01
Lando

There, then there's the whole logistical deal of not having your bait before you, you know what I mean? What about the chums don't show up? You need to buy it preseason or have commitments preseason for, for this whole thing to work. We ran into that problem in Yakutat and Prince William Sound the other year. They didn't have the bait.

2:19:23
Bruce

They were promised the bait and then they didn't have it. Yeah, it's definitely a problem you have to approach a year in advance. Yeah, there's two sides to that. Like, once in certain times of this season, like when maybe you're distracted with other stuff, middle of salmon, holy cow. We were in Seward once, we— it took us 4 days for them to even go in the freezer and take it out and give it to us.

2:19:46
Bruce

They didn't even want to do that, never mind have bait or put it up. And, and then, and there's been some buyers that have really stepped up. Like, a couple times Tyler Besseker stepped up and just bought our fish when nobody else even was interested in halibut and couldn't get a plant to do it. You know, even Dutch and fishermen are walking down the dock saying, hey, is there anything I can do to help you guys? I want you to be successful.

2:20:10
Bruce

And like, there's a lot of support for the charters. But then sometimes the processors, when they got 10 million pounds of pink sitting at the dock and they don't want you around— I mean, one of the worst prices we ever get is in Ketchikan. One, you know, in '22 we got the same price in Dutch Harbor as we got in Ketchikan, right? I mean, so if you've got a buyer who put up 1,000 pounds of chums for you and then he, he gives you 50 cents less from his thing because he's already— for his— your halibut— because he's got it locked ahead of time. It kind of— it's a real yin and yang, you know.

2:20:42
Bruce

You— there's some advantages there, but then, you know, a preseason commitment, maybe it reduces competitiveness for the fish. And there really is weeks when nobody wants that fish, and they buy it coming in there because it's IPHC, and everyone prioritizes it above their core business at that time. You know, it's a tough one. Yeah, this next year is going to be real interesting because it's going to be a big pink year. Talking $67 million in Southeast and probably that much in the Sound.

2:21:10
Bruce

And you're not going to be looking for halibut and black cod for about 6 weeks here, probably. They'd rather not see us, probably. I mean, that year we bid on the charter, we're sitting at the dock paying the guys by the day. We've delivered, scrubbed up, ready to go, sit at the dock for 3 days waiting to go fishing again because they wouldn't even go in freezer and take out 2 totes of chums. You know, that's, that's a shit deal for me.

2:21:37
Bruce

And we bid on that charter in February and sat there in Seward in the middle of July, right? So it's, it's an up and down thing some places at different times, you know.

2:21:54
Speaker P

Overall, I like— I, in theory, I like the idea that you propose. I just I just don't know about the feasibility of it, particularly in the position that we're in where there's a lot of— I don't want to use the word fairness. We just have to make sure we're not favoring anybody. And there's just a lot of nuance, a lot of things that we have to be careful with that I'm just not sure if that sort of deal would work. But there's some strong guys in the room like Brian or Lando or Jim or me could go to a processor right now and say, hey, you know what, you need to put up 4,000 pounds of chums just to help IPHC.

2:22:31
Bruce

Yeah, I think you'd get a— I think you could get some traction with doing that. Just do it, just do it because it's what we need and it's the right thing to do, help the charters out. Maybe not tied to some performance by us or them. I, I think there's— we could, uh, maybe, you know, try it. I don't know, have to be this time of year though.

2:22:52
Angus

Yeah.

2:22:57
Brian

I, I know, uh, Sandpoint is aware of the fact that they probably didn't get a lot of fish last year. They probably would have gotten more fish if they'd had some bait. I, I notified them that they lost out on a trip in my Western Gulf because False Pass was going to put up bait for me. So they, at one point, they were unhappy with the amount of money they were giving up and putting up bait for us. And then last year they saw the repercussions of not having any bait going, hmm, maybe we, maybe this is important.

2:23:26
Brian

And supposedly, you know, each, each and every person that I talked to was talking to their boss and they're going to talk to another person, but they were getting the no, don't put up bait. That's not in our best interest from the higher-ups. And I think now they're being told, well, maybe we should put up some, but yeah, that is a, turns out it's a complex issue.

2:23:47
Josep Planas

So in this case, would the WRAP like to just leave that line 30 as is or add a continuation of that sentence to reflect some of this?

2:24:03
Josep Planas

Yeah, I think maybe just leave it and everyone just kind of keep thinking on the issue. Okay. In that case, let's move on to the next one, the 31. The WRAP noted the importance importance of catch reporting from the various recreational Pacific halibut fishery sectors.

2:24:28
Josep Planas

We could add, yeah, we could add something to that note. So what is the suggestion?

2:24:44
Brian Ritchie

ADFNG is working on that right now though. I think maybe just language like that, you know, the RAB looks forward to seeing an update on, you know, the new— I don't know what the name of their survey is, but they're implementing it in 2028 and Yeah, something like about, you know, RAB looks forward to— but we're not going to receive an update on like Rapid from National Marine Fisheries Service or from Fish and Game, but just, I don't know, acknowledges that there's increased efforts by Alaska Department of Fish and Game and I don't know, I don't quite know that. All aspects of the recreational fishery, including the unguided, uh, fishery and guided sport fish, or however that's sold.

No audio detected at 2:25:20

2:25:52
Jim

I think the statement's pretty well there. I mean, there's a lot that's outside of our control in that area, so I think it's I think it pretty well covers it. So 931 as is?

2:26:05
Basia

I think so. Maybe I'll just add, thanks, Bernd, for reminding us. And maybe it's worth noting that, again, as requested by the Commission, we did have a comment from the ADFNG provided in our annual contracting party report, and it does specifically say about the efforts towards the improvements and that the Statewide Harvest Survey, SWHS, is undergoing considerable changes and it will be moving to the electronic format that is expected to improve reporting and accuracy of reporting more. Up-to-date reporting in year starting from 2028.

2:27:04
Loren

So can we just add at the end of the sentence, and looks forward to that improved data collection by ADF&G, or reporting on the improved data collection by ADF&G?

2:27:26
Basia

Would that reflect— would look forward to improve data collection efforts by ADFNG? Maybe expected in 2028 would be good to just keep people reminded that it is a lengthy process.

2:27:41
Basia

So just Expected in 2028.

2:27:48
Josep Planas

So the RAB noted the importance of catch reporting from the various recreational Pacific halibut fishery sectors and looks forward to improved data collection efforts by ADF&G expected in 2028. Okay, seeing no comments, let's move on to 32. 2, The RAP requested that the IPHC Secretariat collect information on catch rates during openers of the Pacific halibut directed fishery in IPHC Regulatory Area 2A in relation to previous trawling activities in Pacific halibut fishing grounds.

2:28:27
Josep Planas

And I think that this is—. Double L?

2:28:34
Josep Planas

Oh, that was fine?

2:28:38
Basia

Okay. I will just note, uh, just for RAB information, this request will depend on the access to, to the trawling data activity. So we will look into alternative sources. Currently, we only found, again, sources that are year-based that are not really fully matching the scale and the granularity that will be required to fully address this request. But we'll look into the this request and based on other data sources, but it will— any reporting will depend on what we can access.

2:29:13
Basia

You could say acknowledges, maybe something acknowledging uncertain about the access to relevant data.

2:29:36
Loren

If you had an intern that was working on it specifically, would that help?

2:29:41
Basia

I think it's more about the— so there would be two components, so that the resources available to analyze the data and just access to the data itself. We, we just need to see, because we don't collect troll data, so we would need to see what can be made available to us, because it's a completely different sector. It's not the Pacific halibut fishing. So, so two components: the resources available to us, and this could be certainly an interim project in 2027, um, but we would need to have also data available to conduct that analysis. So in that sentence under, uh, 32, uh, the last portion of the, the sentence is and acknowledge difficulties in accessing the data.

2:30:24
Basia

Maybe not difficulties, but uncertainty. We need to research a little bit more what else is there available and what could be made available to us potentially from other sources. Is the RAP okay with this statement? Yeah. Okay, so let's move on to 33.

2:30:46
Josep Planas

We just got, uh, 5 more. So the WRAP requested that the IPHC Secretariat continue to collaborate with industry on a range of research projects, noting the recent successful collaborations involving the catch protection study and bycatch reduction studies. This could include facilitating the application and further innovation of catch protection devices by the commercial fishery. Is there anything else that the WRAP would like to add here? Or—.

2:31:13
Josep Planas

Or modifications of this sentence?

2:31:20
Josep Planas

I'm sorry. I apologize. I was seeing it on my screen. That's number 33. I'll read that again.

2:31:28
Josep Planas

The RAB requested that the IPHC Secretariat continue to collaborate with industry on a range of research projects, noting the recent successful collaborations involving the catch protection study and bycatch reduction studies. This could include facilitating the application and further innovation of catch protection devices by the commercial fishery.

2:32:01
Basia

Giuseppe, just on 32, maybe just adding accessing the relevant data.

2:32:09
Basia

Thank you.

2:32:12
Josep Planas

Regarding 33, the only comment that I have for the RAP is because I heard the word recommendation before, whether you want to escalate this as a recommendation or just as a request.

2:32:30
Brian

Recommendation makes sense.

2:32:34
Brian

Just maybe sure— make sure it's understood that our stance is that it's in our purview, that it's, it's part of our, uh, we think it is an acceptable use of our scientists' time to pursue that, because I, I guess it's been questioned at the annual meeting before. So we think it's relevant. We have the best platform for conducting research in the FIS. If any opportunities arise we think it's a good idea to pursue them.

2:33:03
Claude

I think then we're maybe talking about a recommendation rather than a request. So, Brian, just to clarify, it doesn't always happen on the FIS. We often do one-off contracts for specialized projects as well. So yeah, that's great. We want to be just restricted to the FIS because they have their own priorities and secondary objectives and things that sometimes don't align for these kind of projects.

2:33:27
Brian

Okay, that's a good point. Maybe don't get too specific, but just say, uh, um, we don't want to be discouraged off, uh, research opportunities in terms of like specifically, I guess, with fishing technology is what I was talking about.

2:33:45
Ian Stewart

Okay, I wish I had, uh, maybe Ian, do you have any suggestions in terms of how best to put that per our earlier conversation? Yeah, I think just adding the term fishing technology might be helpful. That way it aligns with one of our four research avenues, and it's very clearly in support of that. That'd be great.

2:34:08
Josep Planas

So yeah, this would read the— sorry, recommended that the IPHC Secretary continue to collaborate with industry on a range of research projects in the in the fishing technology area, noting the recent successful collaborations, et cetera, et cetera.

2:34:29
Josep Planas

Would that be sufficient?

2:34:32
Kevin

Yeah?

2:34:35
Josep Planas

Okay. Then moving on to 34, the RAB recommended that the IPHC continues— that the IPHC— this should be the IPHC Secretariat— continues efforts to collect data on sand flea occurrence during commercial fishing activities and noted—. Sorry—. And noted the importance of including information on environmental, for example, bottom characteristics, temperature, and fishery-related aspects, for example, soak time.

2:35:17
Josep Planas

Is the RAP okay with this statement?

2:35:23
Basia

Okay, moving on to 35. The RAP requested that the IPHC Secretariat conduct an analysis on how regulations are set for the various recreational fishery sectors in British Columbia, Washington, and Oregon, how this— and how these regulations enforced. Maybe I would appreciate clarification on that, because if it, if it comes to what regulations are in place, this is annual report in the Contracting Party Report. If it comes to monitoring and data collection, this is partially— the methods are described in the Contracting Party Report. Reports and the results, the data resulting from that is part of the fisheries data overview paper.

2:36:14
Basia

Enforcement, we are not directly responsible for enforcement, but there is enforcement report also always included in the contracting party report as a part of annual reporting to the IPHC that is available to all stakeholders. So I think if this remains a request, I think it would have to be really narrowed down for us to, to understand what is exactly RAP's interest.

2:36:44
Brian Ritchie

I think that the, the interest, at least on, on my part speaking for myself, was more just in, um, registration requirements, but, you know, between the US, um, states that the commission has jurisdiction over for how— but well, I guess it doesn't have jurisdiction over, but the various councils do. But just like Washington, Oregon, California, Alaska registration requirements for rental boats specifically, and then the same for Canada, just very specific to the registration requirements. That's mostly what I'm curious about. So from what I'm hearing, I think it may be appropriate to change the request to a note from the RAP indicating its interest in understanding how regulations are set, how the regulations are enforced, and maybe a comment following registration of the vessels. I think requested works.

2:37:53
Brian Ritchie

I think that it would just be maybe like the, the IPHC Secretariat conduct an analysis on registration requirements for rental boats in British Columbia, Washington, Oregon, and California.

2:38:07
Angus

Currently we have no registration requirements in Alaska, I guess, so we could leave that one out. I'm not even sure Maybe Bruce could chime in on this, or Jason, but how much rental boats are even a thing in British Columbia?

2:38:25
Bruce

Virtually none. There's, there's self-owned and there's charter, and there's not much— I don't know much rental boats. It's certainly not a factor in anything. Yeah.

2:38:40
Bruce

No, they're, they're basically don't get any attention. They're too small to be on the radar for anybody right now.

2:38:49
Bruce

There's strict reporting requirements on personal licenses and, you know, logbooks and online stuff and everything for self-owned guys. And then the charter guys have the same stuff with their personal licenses. It's all through the personal licenses.

2:39:08
Brian Ritchie

I mean, I think that I wouldn't— it sounds like there probably isn't a registration requirement in British Columbia then, but, um, Ian Stewart.

2:39:48
Brian Ritchie

I guess just responding here, the avenue that people have looked at so far in Alaska is looking into potentially, you know, the value of a a logbook program for rental boats, which would mean that we would need a registration requirement because we'd have to have a logbook program for vessels that we've identified as being of a, you know, certain sector. So, um, yeah, I, I think given the uncertainty that we have in this survey that we have for unguided anglers, the logbook program is, is the— I believe it's the way to go. So I think the first, the first move that you would make would be establishing registration requirements, and you'd want to mirror something that a successful program in another, in another state. I also just would point out that I don't think that it's unprecedented that IPHC look at things like this. I mean, IPHC has done things like this in the past, you know, looked at issues that were more up to domestic management.

2:40:51
Brian Ritchie

And brought that forward to the council, whether it's the Pacific Fisheries Management Council or the North Pacific Council. That has happened in the past. So this isn't outside the bounds of the RAB to recommend.

2:41:10
Brian Ritchie

So I guess the language—. What is the suggested change in language? I would just say the RAB requested that the IPHC secretary conduct an analysis On registration requirements for rental boats in British Columbia, Washington, Oregon.

2:42:37
Brian Ritchie

Sounds like, yeah, like we're kind of behind the curve in Alaska on reporting here. So maybe having that in a paper isn't the worst thing in the world.

2:42:50
Josep Planas

So does this statement need to be modified?

2:42:55
Basia

So perhaps maybe just in all IPHC regulatory areas.

2:43:12
Josep Planas

So does this part of the sentence apply now on how these regulations are enforced?

2:43:21
Josep Planas

Okay, all right. So is the WRAP, um, satisfied with this request? Okay, then we move on to 36. The WRAP recommended that the deployment of water profilers is ensured in annual FIS designs, particularly in IPHC regulatory area 2A. I'd just like to say I understand Scott's point about it potentially being really important in 2A because of hypoxia events, but personally I don't want to see it cut in any area.

2:43:50
Brian

We're already asking for money to keep this survey going, so we think that's very important. Let's just— we don't want to see it cut. So in all IPD regulatory areas? Yeah, I agree. I think you should just put a period right after designs and get rid of everything else.

2:44:11
Josep Planas

If others find this information that's derived from the water profile useful, then it should go for all areas. So the sentence as it reads, the WRAP recommended that the deployment of water profilers is ensured in Annual FIS designs without this section here.

2:44:33
Speaker Q

Okay, then we move on to the last one, the wrap—. Going back to 36, just is that where we would add something about like making that data, historical data, available to fishermen? Someone mentioned Wanting to see the water profile data from the FIS? Well, that water profile data is available now. Okay.

2:44:56
Josep Planas

Right. It is available online. Yeah. Yeah.

2:45:01
Josep Planas

So, and on the 37, that's the last one. The RAP requested that the IPH Secretariat continue investigations on Pacific halibut larval and juvenile stages, including the mapping of essential juvenile habitat throughout IPHC conventional waters. Does the RAP agree with this statement? Okay. So I think we're done in terms of the—.

2:45:28
Speaker Q

I would be interested in adding a recommendation or request acknowledging, encouraging the importance of the size at age research that you guys are exploring for future endeavors. It sounds like the IPHC has—. We've—. It's been a topic we've talked about, and it sounds like the IPHC has acknowledged it's really important, and you guys are going to continue exploring that, and I just want to make sure we support that.

2:46:00
Speaker Q

It just continues exploring research avenues related to size-at-age trends especially environmental drivers.

2:46:31
Josep Planas

Something like this. The RAB requested that the IPHC Secretariat continue exploring research avenues involving size and age and possible environmental drivers.

2:46:50
Ian Stewart

Yep. All right. Thank you.

2:46:56
Josep Planas

Okay. And then we move on to— Just last before the adoption, that's the meeting calendar. Under 39, the RAB agreed that the placement of the RAB meeting in November before the Pacific Marine Expo and prior to the interim meeting, meeting over 1.5 days, is optimal and to continue this meeting format moving forward.

2:47:24
Josep Planas

Well, and then just the last thing is just to agree on the adoption of the report. Does the WRAP agree?

2:47:37
Josep Planas

Yes? Okay. So report is adopted. Thank you very much. So this concludes our WRAP meeting.

2:47:45
Josep Planas

Thank you, all of you, so much for coming and for your contributions. It's highly appreciated. This gives us a lot of food for thought for the next year, and hopefully in WRAP 28 next November we can provide you with some additional ideas for, you know, for vetting in this— against this board and continue providing you with some interesting information regarding, you know, our work related to research and monitoring. Thank you very much.

2:48:22
Brian

Thank you.

2:48:25
Josep Planas

So we should have lunch— probably lunch is set up in the boardroom. I haven't checked, but they should be here, so please stick around and enjoy lunch. Thanks.

Speakers in this transcript