Skip to main content

AI image

Nearly half of Alaska's criminal cases ended with all charges dropped last year

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews
4 min readAlaska

Nearly half of the criminal cases that closed in Alaska courts last year ended with every charge dropped, a state commission reported to the Legislature and Gov. Mike Dunleavy last month.

That's about 9,000 cases, and a bigger share than before the pandemic. In 2019, about 37% of cases ended in dismissal.

Since the pandemic, the share has stayed above 40%, and in recent years quarterly dismissals have "almost equaled" quarterly convictions, according to the Alaska Criminal Justice Data Analysis Commission's annual report.

Last year, 45% of cases were dismissed and 54% ended in a conviction.

The number of dismissals hasn't changed much: courts recorded about 9,800 in 2019 and about 9,000 last year.

Convictions fell much further, from about 16,900 to about 10,700. Fewer cases are coming in, too. Criminal filings dropped 38% from 2019 to 2024 before rising 5% last year.

Charges get dropped for different reasons, the report says. Prosecutors may decide they can't prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt.

A defendant with several pending cases may resolve one at trial or with a plea deal, and prosecutors drop the rest. A judge may throw out a case over a legal flaw. The report doesn't say how often each happens.

The report does put numbers on one reason: competency.

Some defendants are found incompetent to stand trial, meaning a court finds they can't understand the case against them or help in their own defense. They can't be tried unless treatment restores their competency.

Alaska has one place that provides that treatment in a hospital: the forensic unit at the Alaska Psychiatric Institute in Anchorage, which holds at most 10 people.

On Sept. 30, 49 people were waiting for a bed. Those admitted in the state's last fiscal year had waited 327 days, up from 194 days in fiscal 2022.

Requests for evaluations are growing, too; courts ordered competency evaluations in 665 cases last fiscal year, up from 485 the year before.

The law also limits how long that can take. Courts have held that an incompetent defendant can't be held longer than reasonably needed to see whether they'll regain competency.

Under state law, restoration treatment can last 90 days, and a court can order another 90. If the defendant still can't stand trial, the court must dismiss the charges. The exception is a crime involving force against a person, when a judge finds the defendant dangerous and likely to regain competency; then the court can order up to six more months.

Those limits, "combined with lengthy waitlists for restoration admission result in many dismissals of misdemeanor and lower-level felony competency cases by prosecutors," the report says.

About 111 cases were dismissed last fiscal year while the defendant waited for a bed, up from about 95 the year before.

Most who got a bed weren't restored. Of the 44 people the hospital admitted, 13 were restored to competency and 27 were not.

Two programs meant to ease the bed shortage see little use. Of 53 defendants offered treatment in jail, 26 took part.

Of 11 offered outpatient treatment in Anchorage, 7 did; the hospital offers free bus passes but says a lack of money for housing and other transportation is a barrier for many who are eligible.

A law that took effect in January 2025 added a step. Before dropping charges against an incompetent defendant accused of a felony against a person or felony arson, prosecutors must now ask a court to evaluate the person for involuntary civil commitment.

The Department of Law filed 64 of those petitions in 2025 and 58 through late September. Most were granted. But fewer than half of those people were moved to the state hospital, often because the Department of Corrections had already released them or the petition had expired, the report says.

The commission has also started looking at staffing across the justice system and how it relates to how long cases take. It has collected staffing levels from 2020 to 2025 from four of the five major criminal justice agencies.

Among its questions: how the number of cases charged compares with staffing at police departments, prosecutors' offices, defense attorneys' offices, the courts and corrections. It hasn't reported answers yet.

Cases are moving faster than they were a few years ago but still take longer than they did in 2019, the report says.

It suggests the improvement may come from fewer cases being filed and from efforts to clear the oldest pending cases.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: Alaska Judicial Council, Alaska courts dismissed 45% of criminal cases in 2025, and incompetent defendants waited 327 days for a state hospital bed, commission tells Legislature.