Skip to main content

Photo: Barek via Wikimedia Commons · Photo source · Public domain

Ketchikan can't spend cruise money on homelessness grants, city and cruise lines say

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews(1h ago)
3 min readKetchikan, Alaska

Ketchikan can't use its cruise money to pay for homelessness and humanitarian grants, the cruise industry's trade group and the city's staff told the City Council on Tuesday.

Council members Abby Bradberry and Judy Zenge had asked in September for the city to seek the association's OK to pay for those grants from its share of the state's cruise passenger tax instead of the General Fund, the city's main account for everyday services.

Both kinds of cruise money the city collects are limited to things like port facilities and services to the ships, and community grants don't qualify under either, city staff concluded in their presentation at a joint work session with the Cruise Lines International Association.

The association agreed in a written statement. "Humanitarian and homelessness assistance programs, while undoubtedly important community priorities, do not meet that nexus requirement," it said. It supports projects with a direct tie to cruise visits, it said, such as public restrooms, pedestrian safety and crowd management.

Two sources of cruise money were at issue.

The state taxes each cruise passenger and sends $5 a head to each of a ship's first seven Alaska ports of call. Ketchikan splits its $5 with the borough. The city's share came to about $24.5 million over the 10 fiscal years through 2025, according to a state Commerce Department report.

The city also charges its own fee, called wharfage, for each arriving cruise passenger. If passenger numbers hold steady, staff expect it to bring in about $25 million in 2029, up from about $15.6 million this year, as the fee for passengers off a docked ship rises from $13 to $21 and the fee for those brought ashore by small boat, or tender, rises from $10 to $17. That's before the city pays for operations, debt and lease payments for Berth IV.

The two come with different rules. State law says the passenger tax must go to port facilities, harbor infrastructure and services to ships and their passengers. The wharfage fee is limited by the U.S. Constitution's Tonnage Clause, which restricts charges on ships, and by a five-year agreement with the cruise association that took effect Oct. 6. Under the agreement, the fees can pay for costs that directly benefit ships' marine operations, such as passenger and crew safety, shore power and restrooms and shelter for passengers.

Staff trace that standard to a December 2018 federal court ruling in a lawsuit the cruise industry brought against Juneau, which, staff wrote, allows such fees to pay for services to the vessel but not tourism services that benefit only passengers.

Under the agreement, the association is consulted only on wharfage. The agreement doesn't cover the state tax, so the city doesn't need the association's consent to spend that money, staff noted. Even for wharfage, the agreement leaves spending decisions to the city.

Staff gave the council four options: keep paying for the grants from the General Fund; move ship- and passenger-related costs the General Fund now covers to the state tax account, which would free General Fund money for grants, though that account already has other requests; seek state, federal and foundation grants; or invite cruise lines to give voluntarily, outside the agreement.

The question comes as the Ketchikan Indian Community plans a permanent shelter on Tongass Avenue. KIC says it has run the town's cold-weather shelter for two winters, since First City Homeless Services closed.

The city will report the association's position to the council as its answer to the September request. Staff aim to bring a five-year port capital plan to the next joint meeting with the cruise lines, planned for April 20 or 21, 2027.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: City of Ketchikan.