Skip to main content

Frame from "Whittier: 11.17.2026 City Council Special Meeting" · Photo source

Attorney says Whittier can't include the man it's suing in a closed session on his case

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews(3h ago)
3 min readWhittier, Alaska

Whittier's mayor tried Tuesday to bring the man the city is suing into a closed-door council meeting about his case. The city attorney said the council couldn't do that.

Mayor Tom Wagner moved to take the council into executive session on the city's enforcement actions against property owner Eric Fleming. "I would like to invite Eric Fleming to the executive session," he said.

"The purpose of the executive session cannot be to remove the public from the conversation. It has to be to remove a party from the conversation," said City Attorney Holly Wells. With Fleming in the room, "the only person left out of that conversation is the public." The council could discuss the case in public instead, with Fleming taking part, she said.

Wagner said he had heard only the city's side. "I do not know how this got to the point where it has," he said. "I am curious to hear the other side, but … I'm not willing to violate the law."

The council then met privately for about 45 minutes with its attorney, the finance and public works directors, the assistant city manager and the police chief. It took no action on the Fleming matter afterward.

The city sued Fleming in September 2024 over a culvert he installed in a city drainage easement without a permit. A judge ruled for the city in August 2025. The city has sought no fines, only an order that Fleming follow city code and part of its legal costs. Fleming had filed at least seven motions asking the court to reconsider, all denied, and in April filed a notice of appeal to the Alaska Supreme Court, according to a memo from the city's attorneys read at an Oct. 13 council meeting.

At the council's Oct. 20 meeting, Fleming said the lawsuit had cost more than $100,000 in public money and accused City Manager Jackie Wilde of keeping case details from the council. A letter from Fleming, read by City Clerk Shelby Carlson, said he had asked for an open meeting on the lawsuit at two council meetings in July and got no response from the administration. The council agreed that night to take up the case in closed session; Wagner, elected mayor earlier that evening, said he would make the motion.

On Tuesday, Fleming told the council the two-year dispute "has come to a close" and that he was waiting on the city's response. He asked members to read the pleadings and recent motions. "I want to make it clear that I was forced into defending myself," he said.

He also said some of his October public records requests were answered just before the meeting, and he asked for faster responses because the case could "quite possibly" be reviewed in federal court.

Wells said the court case, in which the city asked a judge to order Fleming to comply with city code, is separate from the council's role. Separately, the city issued Fleming a use permit with conditions and later a notice of deficiency, but it hasn't revoked the permit and is trying to get him to comply, she said.

If the city does revoke it, Fleming can appeal to the council sitting as the Board of Adjustment, where members act much like judges. In that role, they couldn't talk privately with Fleming or the city administration, and the city would get them independent legal counsel because her firm has worked on the case, Wells said.

The council also postponed a second closed session, on the city's plan to buy about 85 acres from the Alaska Railroad, to the regular meeting that followed.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byWalter AlaskaNews

This article is based on a public meeting of City of Whittier — Whittier: 11.17.2026 City Council Special Meeting.

Sources

Based on: View Transcript

This article cites 128 chunks.