Skip to main content

Frame from "Whittier City Council Regular Meeting" · Photo source

Whittier council votes 4-2 to hear city manager's chosen mentor after mayor objects

by Walter AlaskaNews(57m ago)
2 min readWhittier, Alaska

The Whittier City Council voted 4-2 Tuesday to let a mentor picked by City Manager Jackie C. Wilde finish speaking, after Mayor Tom Wagner cut him off mid-presentation. The clash came before Wilde's annual performance review, which ran late into the night and showed a council split over her leadership.

Wilde introduced the candidate, Tim Dillon, during her report. She said she had offered at the October meetings to work with a mentor. Dillon, who joined by phone, said he is a past city manager and has mentored city managers around the state.

Wagner stopped him. He said Wilde gave him Dillon's name the day before, but he had not agreed that she would pick her own mentor. "I think it's inappropriate," he said.

Council Member Victor Shen objected. "I honestly think that our response here to this gentleman's short presentation quite rude," Shen said. The council then voted to let Dillon continue, with Wagner and Council Member David Pinquoch voting no.

The mentor question grew out of the council's Oct. 13 special meeting, where members voted 4-3 to discuss firing Wilde privately and adjourned without acting. Wagner said Wilde had promised to take on a mentor.

A summary of council evaluations prepared by the city's outside human resources provider found Wilde needed improvement in governance alignment, communication and stakeholder engagement, and rated her council relationships inconsistent. It rated her strong in external relations, project delivery, financial stewardship, strategic leadership and operational performance.

Shen praised Wilde's grant work, including about $51 million in federal money for the DeLong Dock replacement, and urged her to fill staff vacancies.

Pinquoch was blunt. "I'm the one that said that you're an excellent employee in the wrong job," he said. He said council members "got mailed threats from city, city employees that, that they would quit if we fired you." Wagner rated Wilde's performance as needing improvement.

Wilde pushed back. She said some members do not answer her requests to meet. "But I can't fix it if you guys don't help me fix it," she said.

Wagner had moved to make the city's consultant, Winfluence Strategies, her mentor. Chuck Cobb of the firm said it would "prefer not to be involved with anything related with ... coaching or mentorship of the city manager," because of its broad consulting work for the city.

Residents who spoke mostly backed Wilde. One city employee said she was the hardest working of 22 city managers that employee had served under. The employee said a comment that may have been taken as a threat to quit meant only that the team's momentum would suffer if Wilde left.

The council took no action on a mentor. Wagner said the coaching question still needs another meeting. The city attorney suggested the Alaska Municipal League could supply candidates with city manager experience.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byLucas Brown

This article is based on a public meeting of City of Whittier — Whittier City Council Regular Meeting.

Sources

Based on: View Transcript

This article cites 1374 chunks.