Skip to main content

Whittier: 11.17.2026 City Council Special Meeting

Alaska News • • 66 min

Articles from this transcript

Attorney says Whittier can't include the man it's suing in a closed session on his case

Whittier's mayor wanted to invite the man the city is suing into its closed-door talk on the case. The city attorney said that defeats the point of closing it.

Cover image for article: Attorney says Whittier can't include the man it's suing in a closed session on his case
0:10
Speaker A

Interesting. The snow. I said there's snow. It's been— I mean, they've been talking about all the snow here and it's like, huh. Yeah, fingers crossed.

0:24
0:30
Speaker B

What's that?

0:34
Speaker B

Oh yeah, so could be eradicated in 2 years if everything went right.

0:42
Tom Wagner

I'm sorry, I call to order the November 17th, 2026 special meeting of the Whittier City Council at 6:02 PM.

0:55
Tom Wagner

Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.

1:01
Tom Wagner

Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

1:19
Speaker D

Madam Clerk, roll call please. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Mrs. Borg, here.

1:25
Speaker D

Mr. Shen, here. Mr. Macaltao, absent. Mr. Peter Denmark, Mrs. Loan, here. Mayor Wagner, Here you have a quorum.

1:48
Tom Wagner

Citizens' comments. Citizens' comments on any agenda item except those scheduled for public hearing are welcome at this time. Those who have not signed in will be given the first opportunity— I'm sorry, those who have signed in will be given the first opportunity to speak. Please note, this is not time for dialogue, is a time for you to speak and the council to listen. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed in for citizen comments?

2:14
Tom Wagner

No one has signed in. Thank you. Is there anyone present who would like to speak on an agenda item at this time?

2:25
Tom Wagner

Eric Fleming.

2:36
Eric Fleming

Uh, hello, can you hear me? Can hear you. Um, I'm not sure if, uh, Miss Carlson, were you able to get the, the letters out to everybody along with the, um, attachment? I CC'd you on that email. No, no, but in the meeting, were you able to, to print them out?

2:53
Eric Fleming

And, uh, no, I was not. Okay, I, I've got them here. I can go ahead and do that.

3:13
Speaker D

For the record, Mr. Macaltao joined us at 6:04 PM.

No audio detected at 3:20

3:52
Tom Wagner

Eric, I just— I didn't say it when I first invite you up to the podium, but it is limited to 2 minutes. Limited? Say that again. 2 Minutes. 2 Minutes.

4:05
Eric Fleming

Okay. Can I ask for an extra minute to talk since it is— it's a session involving me? An extra minute? You need 3? Yeah, just so I'm not rushing.

4:19
Tom Wagner

Do I need to take a vote on this?

4:23
Eric Fleming

Hello, and that's okay. Well, thank you for allowing me to speak. As you all know, I've been in a situation for the past 2 years involving a legal dispute, which has come to a close, and we are currently waiting on a response from the city involving that dispute. Uh, I, um, have spoken to several council members, and it appears that they haven't read one, uh, document from within the lawsuit, which I kind of find, um, different and non-transparent. So I ask that you do that, you look into the pleadings, and if anything, the last motion or the last couple motions of the lawsuit, just to give you a clear understanding of the resident side of the situation, which would be my side of the, the, the dispute.

5:21
Eric Fleming

I asked the council members, uh, uphold their ethical and fiduciary duties as council members, the, um, duties that lie within the seat itself as a council member. I asked that you, um, you leave politics aside and you look at the situation, look at the details, and determine for yourselves if This was the outcome that you want for a small activity, a land dispute activity within your community.

5:59
Eric Fleming

Uh, I ask that you reflect along upon this, the approach to the situation and how aggressive it was, and if it was intended to be that aggressive. And if not, why it played out the way it did. I ask that you approach and reflect upon the type of governance you want within the community when it involves land activities.

6:30
Eric Fleming

As you can see in the letter, that there was a switch in stance halfway through the lawsuit, which um, should be addressed to, um, at least to the minimal standards of why that was. Um, I also would like, um, I, I, I realize that some of my public records requests got answered just today, um, just before the meeting. Um, those were requests from the beginning of October to mid-October. Um, so I thank you for having done that. I appreciate that.

7:12
Eric Fleming

I would like a little sooner, if can be, some sooner response to such a thing since it is going to be reviewed in the federal courts quite possibly. So we'll hope not. Like I said, I wanted to communicate, I wanted to resolve this issue from the very beginning. I asked to have a conversation with your office. Um, I was— I want to make it clear that I was forced into defending myself.

7:46
Eric Fleming

I didn't willingly want to go to the legal, um, through the legal system to do that. I really did try to communicate and resolve this, the issue. Um, I responded in the best manner I was able to, um, through the letters that I received. And I hope that you look at those letters, you look at my responses, and, um, determine for yourselves if, um, I seem to be a compliant individual or not, and, and, and proceed forward with however you see fit on going from here. That's pretty much all I have to say.

8:25
Tom Wagner

Thank you, Mr. Thank you.

8:39
Tom Wagner

Is there anyone else that wishes to speak that's in the audience?

8:48
Tom Wagner

Seeing none, is there a motion and second to approve this meeting's special agenda?

8:56
Speaker G

Make that motion. A second.

9:04
Tom Wagner

We have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion?

9:17
Speaker D

Hearing none, Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Voting on the motion to approve tonight's special meeting agenda. Mrs. Borg? Yes.

9:28
Speaker D

Mr. Macaltao? Yes. Mr. Shen? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch?

9:35
Speaker D

Yes. Mr. Denmark? Yeah. Mrs. Loan? Yes.

9:41
Speaker D

Mayor Wagner? Yes. The motion passes, and tonight's special meeting agenda is approved.

9:48
Tom Wagner

At this time, does anyone wish to declare a substantial financial interest in a matter appearing on the agenda?

10:08
Tom Wagner

Hearing none, uh, council comments.

10:22
Tom Wagner

Hearing none, moving on to citizens discussion.

10:27
Tom Wagner

Time is limited to 5 minutes per speaker on any subject over which the council has control. Again, this is not a time for dialogue. Rather, it is a time to allow citizens to speak and the council to listen. Madam Clerk, is there anyone signed in for citizen discussion? No one has signed in.

10:48
Tom Wagner

Is there anyone out there in the audience present that wishes to, uh, speak at this time?

11:15
Tom Wagner

So on our agenda, the next thing is council and administrator response.

11:24
Tom Wagner

Um, council, any response?

11:33
Tom Wagner

Can't respond to nothing.

11:37
Tom Wagner

Okay, um, executive session. Is there a motion— uh, sorry, a motion and a second to enter executive session to discuss— this would help— enforcement actions regarding Eric Fleming as per Whittier— I'm sorry, WMC 2.08.040C, to discuss legal matters or receive legal advice from an attorney. I'll make the motion. I'll second.

12:24
Tom Wagner

I would like to invite Eric Fleming to the executive session.

12:33
Holly

If you want to talk to Eric Fleming, that is totally appropriate. But this is similar to when you go in for like a contract and we go in for financial matters. And I say, when you go into executive session, the purpose of the executive session cannot be to remove the public from the conversation. It has to be to remove a party from the conversation, right? So one of the things that clients will— or cities will try to do is go in with the other party to a contract and say, we'll all go into executive session together.

No audio detected at 12:40

13:05
Holly

And that is not appropriate because really the only person left out of that conversation is the public. So if you want to involve— if you want to have the conversation in the public session so Mr. Fleming can be a part of that conversation, you can absolutely do that, you know, and just hold it in public. But we cannot go into executive session with Mr. Fleming. Understood. I kind of had a feeling that's what was going to happen, but I didn't have a minute to, uh, talk about this.

13:36
Holly

Well, and I guess one thing I would ask is, what would be the purpose of going into a confidential conversation with Mr. Fleming? I mean, what's the purpose of counsel? Because maybe— I mean, maybe I'm jumping— that is just sort of my standard advice, so maybe I'm, you know, missing something. Okay, so this has been going on for a while.

13:58
Tom Wagner

Um, to summarize it, I've heard one side of the story, and that is the city side of the story. I do not know how this got to the point where it has.

14:11
Tom Wagner

I should probably stop there because the rest of that sentence should be in executive session. But anyway, um, I am curious to hear the other side, but so I'm not willing to violate the law, so we will just move into executive session. And, uh, well, and I want to— I will remind the council, so council sits as two bodies, right? You often set a city council, that's the role we're most familiar with, but there are opportunities in which you're called upon to sit as a board of adjustment. That's when you put your judge hat on and you are sitting as a quasi-judicial body.

14:53
Holly

So when the notice of violation was filed, that was an opportunity in which you would have been called upon. If that was appealed, you would have been called upon to sit as a board of adjustment, right? The injunction process, that's a court process that does not put counsel in that position. That's really just the city saying, hey, we asked you to stop and you won't stop. And so we don't— we're not going to walk in there and, and, you know, put cuffs on you and make you stop for a land use violation.

15:21
Holly

We're going to go to a court and have the court tell you to stop. And that's really all the injunction is. So the other process— so the city issued a use permit for the property, and so right now, and that use permit had conditions. And so at the end of the day, if the parties are not able to get those conditions met, or the city feels that Mr. Fleming does not— has not complied with those conditions, so a notice of deficiency has been issued now, but the city has not revoked that permit. It has basically just been trying to get compliance.

15:56
Holly

Compliance with those conditions. If the city ultimately says, hey, we've given you a chance to comply, you haven't complied, it will revoke the permit. And when it revokes the permit, Mr. Fleming will have an opportunity to appeal that to the Board of Adjustment. And that is your role at that point. And that's one of the reasons why we're constantly trying to figure out how much information council can have and in what way council can get information, which you've been given the letters, I believe, and Brian, correct me if I'm wrong, or the city.

16:29
Holly

I think the council's been given correspondence and documentation and updates on the case, and the purpose of the executive session was to provide even greater information on the case, correct, Brian? I believe that's correct, yes. Okay, so that will be, you know, that's one step. That's the lawsuit, and that lawsuit really deals with, from the city's perspective, just trying to stop action that was taken in violation of its code. And so that's that.

17:00
Holly

There's the permit process. When counsel is sitting in that role, you don't want to have— at that point, counsel will not be able to have ex parte communications with either, you know, with either Mr. Fleming or with the city administration. Actually, that's when, when that is filed, if that's filed, if Mr. Fleming is like, hey, I don't think this is right, and I want the council to review it sort of as a judge role. We will get you independent legal counsel since our firm has been engaged in all of these things. And Mayor, I think that is a time where you will be able to have a quasi-judicial proceeding in front of you where Mr. Fleming is putting on his, you know, case, so to speak, specifically to council and the Council sitting as the Board of Adjustment can go into executive session with legal counsel and talk about what they think about that revocation of the permit, if that makes sense.

18:01
Holly

But right now, council's acting as—. It does, Holly. Thank you. Sorry, you know, it's a lot of— it's fine. Um, but, but we can talk about it in public, and that allows Mr. Fleming to be part of that conversation.

18:15
Holly

And then you have your public comments at the end of the meeting. As well, um, so he can, you know, and I think he did provide a couple letters, so there is a lot of opportunity to hear what he has to say in that sense. He's just not in executive session. I understand. So we will enter this executive session and revisit this per your instructions later.

18:42
Tom Wagner

Um, thank you. We have actually obviously 2 executive sessions to cover, um, in a very short period of time. So as far as my previous misstatement, administration, um, who do we want in here? Um, obviously we have, uh, Brian on, um Zoom or whatever. Mayor, I would, uh, recommend that of course all council members, your legal counsel, the finance director, and at least the public works director to be in the— and myself and the assistant city manager.

19:26
Speaker D

Okay, thank you. I apologize. And also, um, Police Chief Ache. Understood. Do I need to call the roll, Mr. Mayor?

19:40
Speaker D

Yes, please. Voting on the motion to enter into executive session to discuss enforcement actions regarding Eric Fleming as per Whittier Municipal Code 2.08.040, to discuss legal matters or receive legal advice from an attorney. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. Macaltao?

19:58
Speaker D

Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mr. Denmark. Mr. Shen.

20:04
Speaker D

Yes. Mrs. Borg. Yes. Mayor Wagner. Yes.

20:10
Speaker D

The motion passes, and council enters into executive session at 6:21 PM. Brian and Mrs. Loan and Mr. Pinkrish, I'm going to move us all into a breakout room, so if you see a pop-up, please accept it.

20:28
Speaker D

Goodness, I can't even see him. So— A motion has been made by Mrs. Borg and seconded by Mr. Shen to exit executive session.

No audio detected at 21:00

No audio detected at 23:00

No audio detected at 25:00

No audio detected at 27:00

No audio detected at 29:00

No audio detected at 31:00

No audio detected at 33:00

No audio detected at 35:00

No audio detected at 37:00

No audio detected at 39:00

No audio detected at 41:00

No audio detected at 43:00

No audio detected at 45:00

No audio detected at 47:00

No audio detected at 49:00

No audio detected at 51:00

No audio detected at 53:00

No audio detected at 55:00

No audio detected at 57:00

No audio detected at 59:00

No audio detected at 1:01:00

No audio detected at 1:03:00

1:03:28
Holly

Oh, right.

1:03:37
Holly

Jackie, it's okay for Brian to jump off, right? Just is 11 PM there. Brian, you can jump off. Thank you very much. Okay, thank you everyone.

1:03:47
Brian Gerd

Thank you for letting me, you know, participate.

1:03:52
Speaker D

Okay, voting on the motion to exit executive session. Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Shen? Yes.

1:04:02
Speaker D

Mr. Macaltao? Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mrs. Loan? Yes.

1:04:12
Speaker D

Mr. Denmark? Mr. Denmark has stepped down from the dais. Yes, Mayor Wagner. Yes, the motion passes and council exits executive session at 7:05 PM. Is there a motion and a second to postpone the second executive session to the regular meeting?

1:04:32
Holly

I'll make the motion. I'll second it.

1:04:38
Speaker D

Mr. Mayor, may I call the roll? Yes. Voting on the motion to postpone the second executive session to the regular meeting. Mrs. Loan? Yes.

1:04:50
Speaker D

Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mr. Macaltao?

1:04:57
Speaker D

Mr. Denmark?

1:05:00
Speaker D

No, not at the dais. Mr. Shen? Yes. Mayor Wagner? Yes.

1:05:07
Speaker D

The motion passes, and the second executive session is postponed to the next regular meeting, uh, to the regular meeting.

1:05:40
Tom Wagner

Being that there is no further business, this meeting is adjourned at 7:07 PM.

Speakers in this transcript