Seward: PACAB 11/18/2026
Alaska News • • 94 min
Articles from this transcript
Seward port board backs $50 missed-filing fee and about 14% boat lift fee increase
Seward's harbor board backed doubling a missed-filing fee to $50 and raising boat lift fees about 14%, headed to city council Dec. 14.

Seward's New Year's fireworks are moving to January, and some locals aren't happy
Seward's chamber moved the New Year's Eve fireworks to Polar Bear Jump weekend. Some locals want their midnight back, and a city board will tell the council.

No audio detected at 1:45
No audio detected at 2:15
No audio detected at 4:15
No audio detected at 6:15
No audio detected at 6:45
Okay, ready when you are. Okay, call to order.
Very good. So we'll call to order the Port and Commerce Advisory Board meeting for Wednesday, November 18th. And seeing that we now have a quorum And, uh, Member Draper, would you mind leading us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Sure.
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you.
And I believe we're ready for the roll call.
Roll call for today's meeting. Draper. Here. Groom is excused. Dunn.
Here. Pickett. Here. Regis is excused. And Vice Chair Atwood?
Here. You have a quorum.
All right, very good.
So, uh, next item 4 on the agenda, we could move on to citizen comments on any subject. Do we have citizen comments? Great, come forward please.
Mark Clemens, Outside City Limits. Um, this is not on your agenda, but I just want to put it on public that, you know, the fireworks being moved to the Polar Bear Jump, we're not on the traditional date of what they should be, for our locals. I'm not in favor of— we keep taking things away from our locals and transitioning to giving it to seasonal out-of-town people, trying to make some events bigger. This is a local event. Kids look forward to it.
It breaks up everything. It is done on the day it's supposed to be. We're not going to move July 4th to the 2nd or 5th or 6th because it's on a weekend. We might get more people, I would hope. And the same scenario, I mean, let's do fireworks as scheduled.
I mean, it didn't come out from the chamber until just recently this, this was going on or transpiring, that the board made a decision on the chamber that they were going to take and go this way and You can see Facebook's lit up. There's not a lot of people all for that. We all understand making event bigger, you know, the Polar Bear Jump bigger, etc., but at the expense of taking another thing away from us that are here, it's just— I don't know, it's not the right move. I don't know the monetary amounts, but I don't think that local businesses should have to cough up to make all this happen when it's already done. You know, Chamber gets $400-some thousand through this you know, the bed tax.
Let's use that money for some locals. That's my thought on it. Just want to say as a businessman and a dad and a grandpa, et cetera, been here for 59 years, that this needs to stick around. Okay. Thank you.
Does anyone have questions following up to the comments? Did you receive any comment, any hear anything about it before it was a done deal? Nothing. Any input from the public requested? I didn't see anything as a chamber member.
And you're a chamber member? I'm a chamber member. I've heard, I've heard a lot of complaints about this myself.
You're not in— you're not opposed to also having fireworks for the Polar Bear Chop, right? Let's double down,. Right? Yeah, no, no, nothing, nothing opposed on that. That seems like the way to go to me.
I don't know. I don't mean, I guess it's a funding issue. But well, if it's a funding issue, we should stay at the norm of what we do. Right. I mean, yes, there's, there's people that come and spend the night ahead of the time for the Polar Bear Jump.
Not as many spend the night after the Polar Bear Jump, I would say, because festivities are over. Right. So I don't know how much you'd gain. That's, that's not my purview on, on that. I mean, I know the restaurants, bars, there's, there's traffic in town for the event, but at the expense of us, right?
Yeah, I don't— I just don't understand why it has to be an either-or, you know. That's funny, what they're saying, I guess. Yeah, and there again, I don't know the dollar— excuse me— the dollar amount that the fireworks are. Yeah, but still, that doesn't really matter, right? Okay, my thoughts.
Okay, thank you. Thank you for those comments.
Well, should I say my two cents worth too?
Yeah. Coris Nelson, City Limits, and I will just like to veto the Polar Bear Jump fire anyway, because the weather's worse on the Polar Bear Jump than it ever is during the New Year's. It's cold and clear usually on New Year's except for wind blows. And it's a waste of money because they're only what, 15 minutes? That's a lot of money.
And then what happens with money when they change it out into Polar Bear Jump and it's all weathered out? I mean, I've worked a lot of Polar Bear Jumps. And it was really brutal, wet all the time. So that's my two cents worth. And I'm tired of being treated over— under the tourists all the time.
There's nothing open here in town half the time for tourists. The doors slam so hard you can feel the wind when the trains go away.
So tourism is not my high point right at the moment. Thank you. Yeah, thank you for that comment as well. Any follow-up? No, I just like to thank both of them for coming in and saying that because I've received a lot of public comment on this breaking this tradition.
All right, thank you. Seeing no other citizens who wish to comment— thank you— then we'll go on to approval of the agenda and the consent agenda. And I don't know that we have any amendments to the agenda. Anyone? No.
And then—. We get a motion and a second to approve that, and then I'll do a roll call vote. Sounds good. I'll make a motion to approve the agenda. Second that.
Hearing are no— Changes, voting on the approval of today's agenda and consent agenda. Pickett? Yes. Draper? Yes.
Dunn? Yes. And Vice Chair Atwood? Yes. Your agenda and consent agenda have been approved, and that includes the April 15th, 2026 PAC-CAB meeting minutes.
Very good, thank you. So moving on now, we have Item 6, special orders, presentations, and reports. I believe no proclamations and awards, so we'll go on to the city administration report. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
It's nice to see some old faces and some new faces to the board. Um, just a quick update over the summer hiatus. We had some busy big things come up for Seward, and I'll just highlight 3 of those for you guys today. In June, the Coast Guard announced we were chosen to homeport an Arctic Security Cutter, and with the tentative plan of receiving that vessel in early 2030. So we're still a few years out, but, um, we're on the board, which is nice.
In July, Orion Construction out of Wasilla was awarded the contract to build the housing and support building for the Frederick Mann, which is the FRC that will be homeported here and stationed over at the SMIC Basin, within the SMIC Basin. And that contract includes 6 housing units, 4 4-bedroom units and then 2 3-bedroom units plus a support building for an approximate total of $9.8 million. And then in July, We— this summer we put out an RFP for the construction and design and construction of a new harbormaster facility building. In July, we chose Cornerstone for that project, and we've been working with them since then on that design. As a lot of you guys have probably noticed, we've drove a pile, a test piling, maybe 3 weeks ago on the uplands, and we're— we got— we just got those results back here a couple maybe a week, 10 days ago, and we're hoping to move forward.
We're currently sitting at 65% design, hopefully move forward to 100% here pretty soon.
Any questions for me?
Yes, I heard a rumor and I think you're just going to squash it, that the test pilings are because you plan on putting the pilings out and put retail spaces out on the water on pilings. You're correct, we're going to squash that. Okay, thank you. I'm glad. Yeah, no, the test file—.
File was 100% for the, the new building. That's what I—. This is where the Mariners Memorial is, in that area? Correct. It'll be, um, as you make that approach to them going up the uplands, immediately to the north as you go up the hill right there.
Yeah, yeah, this is very exciting. It is. Yes. It will be nice to see those buildings. We have been talking about abandoning that building for quite a while.
Get away from the asbestos.
Yeah. Very good. And I just had one follow-up question. So the housing for the fast response cutter crew and families, is that primarily up in the hilltops? Subdivision, is that where that— Yeah, correct.
Yep, those are the lots that they purchased up on Hilltop 2 years ago. Okay, it may have even been like a year and a half ago, but yeah, yeah, but correct. Okay, yeah, very good.
All right, any more, any more questions for administration?
Okay, moving on to see other reports and announcements. We have the Alaska Railroad report, which I would be happy to give. Now, if that's okay. Um, I do have, uh, some handouts here. I just, uh, bulletized some— pass those down there.
Going this way.
And let's see, so we look at this quickly. As in Tony's case, it's been a while since I've given a report. So, um, anyway, we concluded our 26th cruise ship season We currently are working to, you know, complete our cruise dock. We had finished the season with a temporary trussle in place, and so that permanent trussle is being installed. We have the passenger numbers for the season.
The takeaway for cruise ship season is that we will see an increase in the number of ships. This coming summer. And that number is currently a little bit in flux. We're still waiting as that schedule settles.
And part of that has to do with the damaged floating dock in Whittier. And, you know, our current port traffic, we've had, you know, 159 cruise dockings and We have a cargo vessel scheduled for, in notes here, November 24th. It's actually now November 25th. And then another pipe ship in mid-December.
And so, going on, I guess I would mention that we did have a ribbon-cutting ceremony for the new terminal building, which is, you know, Got used through the summer and it's 99% complete. And anyway, the facility was named the DLR&Carroll& Lindsay Alaska Railroad Terminal. And of course locals here know the significance of the Lindsay family. And so currently we are preparing— so as we conclude our cruise dock project, we're preparing for the start of our freight dock extension project. And so they're kind of overlapping a little bit right now.
And to be brief, we're planning to start construction of that freight dock extension, that easternmost dock, in January. We'll begin, you know, driving pile and we have a substantial amount of aggregate stored on our uplands. And so we're excited about that going forward. If we can keep on schedule, we could have a basic footprint for the dock by May. So we'll see how that goes.
If you just sort of flip this and look, there's a couple of images on the other side. One of them, the second photo below, shows those concrete— items that are on the, on the bed of a trailer there. Those were the reef balls that were installed as part of a mitigation project having to do with the freight dock extension. So now there's an artificial reef just offshore down by the Sea Life Center. And that project was taken care of fairly rapidly.
And another little project that we're essentially done with is the third photo. We had the former coal facility conveyor going underneath Port Avenue, and we removed the conveyor and we've installed an asphalt path. And so now we essentially have a pedestrian path that goes under the road, which will allow people to get from our terminal building to the sidewalk on the north side of Port Avenue without having necessarily to cross the surface of the road. They can go under the road, which is a little safer. And then, you know, proceed.
So we're kind of— it's a— it was a— it was a fun little project, and I'm glad we got that, uh, got that done. These photos are clearly before we had the most recent snow. Um, let's see. Uh, oh, another project that we got taken care of was, um, we have, uh, some power lines in the north rail yard, and they were undergrounded. And that's part of our plan to have more lay-down space and to facilitate storage— loading to train, stored items to train.
And so having overhead power lines is not great. And so we're happy to get that work done as well. And anyway, that's a brief summary of some of the things that we took care of and we're heading into next. And I'll field any questions if you have any. How many ships were there this year?
63 Were scheduled. The first 3, I believe, were diverted because we were trying to prepare as rapidly as possible. So we did manage to handle the bulk of them. Bulk of the vessels. And, and the season went well considering the, the stage of completion we were at.
So if you had 63 scheduled, you, you threw out a 159 number. What was that? That was the, the dockings, or the— did that count? 159? Yeah, I wrote down 159.
I don't know. Oh yeah, no, we're— so we have, uh, planned, um, It looks as though we have in the range of about 87 ships coming. But like I said, the schedule's in flux. So we'll see how the schedule shapes up. Okay, so we had 63 last year and we'll have approximately 87 this year?
That's what it's looking like at the moment, yeah. And of course, you know, ship sizes vary, so. We'll see what that ends up. We had just over 150,000 passengers this last season. And so this last summer was a little down because of the construction?
Oh, a little bit because we had 3 ships that were diverted to Whittier. So yeah, that,. Uh, but,. Um, in a normal year prior to last— prior to this summer, what have— haven't the numbers been more like in the Yeah, so they've—. They correct.
Yeah, yeah. So we're back on— we're back. Up, we're getting back on track. Yes, ma'am. It's just now we can take the bigger vessels.
We do, we do have, um, larger, uh, vessels in the schedule, um, a larger vessel in the schedule again every other Friday. And then in line with the— you brought up the cruise ships and the power lines. The backup battery system, do you know, do you have an ETA on that so that they can do ship-to-shore? So originally we were thinking that, and administration can speak to this, but we were originally thinking that the shore power would quickly follow the cruise dock completion. I believe that may be off by a year approximately.
I don't know, Tony, if you have any additional information. I don't have any current update— I couldn't update to provide for that right now. Yeah, but so I, I think it, I think it is off by, um, uh, about— it's gonna tail the cruise, cruise dock project by, by about a year. Oh, it'll be done a year after the cruise ship project finishes? Yeah, it's all— it's all— it's ongoing currently, and it is a municipal project, but Of course, we're, you know, working with the city for that.
Anything else? Thank you. Okay. Yes. Very good.
Okay. Nice pictures. Thank you. Presentations? None, I'm assuming.
Unfinished business, item 7. I believe there are none. New business, what do we have? So, under other new business, we do have the discussion of the harbor tariffs.
I guess Administration could lead us into that. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So, in years past, we can throw this out, we can go section by section, or we can just skip ahead to the major ones. Everyone's a little new to this, maybe with Board Member Dunn and Draper. What would work best for you guys? Do you want to just go section by section and skip along, or—. Section by section.
Does that work best for you? Okay. Okay, if everyone would like to proceed to page— let's start on page 1, section 100.
Pretty general, just starts off— let's just skip up to the good stuff here, how about that? Okay. Unless you guys have anything for Section 100.
Sorry, I said we'll go section by section, but it starts off with definitions and— Definitions. Yeah. We aren't changing any definition. No, currently nothing, unless there's something that you guys would like us to, you know, anything for housekeeping or change.
Nope. All right, no changes for Section 100? No. Okay, Section 105, page 2.
Not hearing any changes or questions from— I'm sorry. I'll just sort of drive this then. If you guys have anything, how about that? Then— No, if I could, maybe I'll make one suggestion. I'm assuming that everyone here is familiar with what a tariff document is and what it dictates.
If you might just provide just a little bit of background. So this is just sort of the document that we use to set harbor rates and sort of rules that we operate by day to day. As far as the rate, we'll get further into this in Section 200, is passenger fees and boat lift fees and stuff like that as well too. And that's our rate schedule that we operate day-to-day business with.
Are these currently changing? So every, every year we go through the tariff and make any changes. And good question, I was going to touch on this as we get further in there, but there is— it's set to change rates. Mortgage rates change every year by follow CPI, and then every other year we go through and adjust warpage rates, and we do a running 5-year average for those.
Great. Thank you for that explanation. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Not hearing any changes.
Section 115 and 120 on page 3.
Did everybody have a moment to run through this before?
No? Okay. So if you need a little extra time, just— Please say so.
Well, when we get to 215, I have a question.
Okay, page 4, Section 125.
So the city is not liable for negligence, uh, is that what I'm reading here? As far as, um, does that include city employees? Um, Section 125C.
Correct, we remove ourselves from as much as we can. How about that? Yeah, yeah, I see that. Yeah.
Okay, not seeing any other questions. Section 130 on page 5.
I should clarify, starting on page 5 and continuing through— Page 7.
Vice Chair Atwood, do you have any questions or any changes for cargo operations that you see? No, no, none. I'm just sort of reviewing here. Imagining that your birth application process on the cargo side, how does that work generally?
So application process on who, how we schedule that out is your question? Yeah, so I'm a customer and I'm coming with cargo, and generally you're getting applications submitted ahead of time. If you, uh, want, you request the manifest in advance,. Correct? Yeah,.
Yep. Um, manifest and terminal use permit, it all— identify all that too. Sort of dates requested, if there's any conflict with other vendors or users on the dock as well too. So obviously we have a couple vendors that are scheduling out currently for the '27 season, and even on occasion that the following year out as well too. So we just have running dates as people call in.
Yeah, right. I don't want to get too far afield here, but I'm just curious, how do you communicate your calendar to potential users of your dock? Great question. And this is a fairly new process for us. And I say new by the last, say, 4 years.
It's just kind of starting to get a little busier over currently as it stands, it's a lot of phone calls. Yeah. And a lot of back and forth between vendors, especially in June and July when it gets busy. And it's definitely a lot of— a big time sink on some, some weeks for sure, as you probably experience yourself. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
Absolutely. Yeah, sorry, I didn't mean to talk inside shop here, but no, no, that's a great—. That's a great question. People should realize that. So I'll put that in the city manager report.
Call ahead of time because we're trying to mitigate all those— any conflicts that do arise. And as you are well aware of, any— you could be a month late, and we've seen that happen where you're scheduled for May 15th and we'll see them on June 20th. But so far, all of our vendors, we all play really well together and make it work. So—.
So changes to, um, I, I guess rates are addressed annually, is that correct? Rates are annual, correct. Oh, I'm sorry, wharfage rates are every other year, so basically every even— or yeah, every even year. We just did it last year in 23-26,. Right?
So just the high notes, um, what changes were you looking to make in this, in this document? Um, in Section— I believe it's 215 under some passenger fee stuff and just some additions to that. I think it was 215. I'm sorry, Section 230.
Would you like to just skip ahead to that? I believe that's the first change within the document. Mortgage rates, okay, is where the first rate change I see. Okay, yeah, and in mortgages every year as well too. So that's kind of a standing, just a standard blanket change that we do.
This year we'll see an increase by CPI. Like I said earlier, it's a running average of the last 5 years, and this year is an increase of 3.76%. Can you just clarify, um, and it just might be my eyes, but, um The transient guest annual rate. What is, what is that supposed to be?
$694.13. Is that right?
Oh, it's on page 11 under Section C. Is that correct? Yeah. So I. See I.
Uh, the city clerk and I went back and forth on this. I tried to show what the changes were to show what it was, what it's going through, so you guys could see all my red line changes. Um, it will be $69.13, so $69. It was $60, you can see the crossout, so it's $64, now it's $69. Okay, really it's $69.13.
Correct. Okay, because it— the 4 is not struck out in my—. The strikethrough goes right through that. It looks like it's—. Yeah, I apologize, you guys got a better color, a little easier to read under this, under these lights too.
Okay, so I guess with our, our aging board, we'll have to fix that for next year. I'll get bigger font for all of us. How do we determine— so the— in the paragraph above, in the C paragraph, it goes from 88 cents to 94 cents, so a 6 cents— how do you arrive at a 6 cent increase? How is that calculated? That is the running average that we do.
We average out the previous 5 years. I believe it breaks it down for you under Section B if you'd like to sort of follow along. So an example would be The 27 rates would be from 2021 through 2025. Oh, I see. Okay.
Yeah. And then we average out those 5 years. Got it. So you want— the intent was to keep like the wild fluctuations out of like, say, a 15% increase one year. Right.
Because maybe the previous year, maybe you saw a downturn in CPI. Makes sense.
Yep. So that was sort of the major— then the first change is that Section 205. If we wanted to, you know, skip ahead, this is all You will see the same thing in Section 225 under our electric rates, calculated the same way. That'll be page 15 if you'd like to follow along on that.
I do like the change from bow to stem. Yep, a little, little more accurate, I guess, in description. Intent is the same, a little more professional. Um, under Section 225. Um, oh gosh, we have Section E or page 17.
We added some, just some work under Section C, I believe I said, under NCIP Part 3. Just added some more clarification on charges for tampering with meters and, and what that fee is. So if you were to cut in and cut a tag, and/or theft of services, there's a $525 charge for that. That's what you'll see there is that power connection or breaking meter, um, for whatever reason. If maybe there wasn't a tag on there for whatever reason, right, or someone ran a cord further down the line, there's a lot of small nuances there.
That's what that intent is there for. And then moving on to Section 230. Do you guys— I'm sorry, do you guys have any questions up to that point before we get into the next section? Now, this, this— my— I guess I'm just curious, this tampering, is that something that's occurred, or is this just something you're—. It has.
Yeah. Yeah, it's not, it's not often, but it does happen. Um, sometimes it's something as simple as just miscommunication, and we, we have reverse those charges for people in those cases, make a written request, and we take everything under consideration. And basically you get a kind of get-out-of-jail-free card once, right? Yeah, understood.
Yeah.
Okay, Section 230. There's a few changes in this section that I'd like to have some input back. I'll let you know As you can see under whether it's blue or red on your forms, we've added some verbiage of what kind of who's targeted for that section. We added rental vessels. We have seen a handful of— just wanted to highlight that in the tariff.
So whether you're renting the vessel or you're going out for hire and you have a captain-run vessel, or you're running the boat yourself. We just want to have a little more clarification on what that is. So that's that first one under Subpart A.
B, of course, moves into filling out forms and payment of fees.
We'll come back to that one. C is failure to file. And then with this year, we added We're looking to add a Section D and E, which will be— we'd like to have the ability to audit these returns, and then also, that would go in conjunction with that, records retention of how long those forms are to be kept. And so, what we're looking to do here is basically just request a manifest or ship log or whatever that may be to make sure that we're receiving accurate numbers on our passenger fees for, for vessels. And then what I'm asking then from you guys today would be maybe do we could set or look for some guidance on a, a fee for that failure to report, if you guys would have had any input on that.
Oh, a failure to —report or an underreport. And whether that could be a— maybe a failure to report. I think currently it sets it at $25 for a misfiling.
I'm going to ask you for some guidance here as well. But it takes a lot of manpower to follow up and have someone— to get someone to report. It's several phone calls. Currently, as it stands now, Crystal does a fantastic job of sending out emails and reminder calls. She emails and calls that are reported to remind people that reports are due, so it's very labor-intensive as well.
And then of course, if you don't send your report, there's a follow-up with that as well too. So I'd like to see that, whatever that number is and whatever that feels— what feels fair. But I would— I feel confident saying there's at least a man hour to— with all that, um, all those phone calls to go into it. So I'd like to see that at least be reflected in, in that fee. And then, and then to your failure to report or underreport, maybe whatever that percentage is, maybe it's based on a percentage of— I believe it has to have enough teeth to where people are following through with their reports and getting them in on time.
But maybe not so much to where it's just unrealistic as well, too. There's a fine balance. What would you say is a good starting point for the fee? $100? I mean, where are we?
I know. It's $25 now. I think, honestly, I think that's fair. So what if it were to ramp up? So the initial fee is $25 for, for, for not filing.
And then if you're a month late, it goes up to $50. Or if you're 6 weeks late, you know, I don't know, or a percent. Of the delinquent part. I see where you go with that. But also something that's, I think, a flat rate would— it's just easy to administer then too.
You're not having to go through and get into— want to build in that urgency on their part to get it done, right? So how do you, how do you accomplish that at the same time? Yeah, I think off the cuff, I think a flat rate how it stands now, but just an increased rate would be easier to administer too. I don't want to get where it gets too wordy and hard to follow, and we have to revisit this next year because it's just that. Let's keep it, keep it simple.
Um, but I do like the creativity. I appreciate that.
Like, like the borough, they, um, you get 5% off if you file early, and if you file late, you get a penalty of like 5% of the amount that you owe. So like the amount that they're underpaying, they get a percentage. And that might be a fair way to structure it too, so you're not penalizing a small operator. You know, obviously if you're a single, a single boat, you're We're not trying to make it more difficult for someone to operate a business in Seward, but also to, to impress the urgency of this too, also. So that might be a fair way to do it as well, if that's— everyone is— everyone's in agreement with that.
So, uh, a percentage then, is that—.
Yeah, if we can work Yeah, if that's what the board would like to see happen, I think that sounds fair. So just thinking about structuring this, I mean, clearly we want compliance. That's what you're seeking. And then the calculations themselves, I mean, if that becomes complicated, then that's more work as well.
So, yeah, so, yeah,. If it's something that you got to keep up on and check tabs on, and somebody's got to do some work to enforce this thing, it's like, man, keep it real simple. Yeah, yes. And that's kind of the intent. We're not trying to create more work here, but we're also— but if it's not high enough too, then it may be— it could be a sort of a lesser of two evils for some operators, right?
Just be like, I'll take my fine and move on. It's not worth my time to do it as well too. How big of a problem is this of people not paying up? Oh, you know, honestly, I don't think it's a problem. We just want the ability to just make sure that— I think, just the ability just to go through, go through Brooks' audit and just make sure that everyone is on the up and up with this too.
This is a heavy— so we're using this, these fees to pay for a revenue bond. So it is, it's a serious part of our budget. So,.
So there's not a lot of people that aren't paying? I don't, I don't think so. I mean, I think it's a— I think everyone's is fairly honest and moving forward. I'm not structuring this on like on one person in particular, it's just more of a— the ability to do it, and then we'll roll out on how that, how that looks. Also, I'm not— my goal is not to go through everyone's books and create more work, but just the ability to have that as an option to do.
Um, it'd be interesting you did a report in a couple of years after you do this to see how many weren't compliant.
Well, I might be surprised. Maybe. I mean, you can do— right, you can look at quick math too. I mean, if your boat only holds 6 people, you're only going to get 6 people. Yep,.
Right? I mean, you're both holding holds. You can only do so much work in a day, so you can only pump out so many cups of coffee out of a coffee machine, right? It only works so fast. Yeah, that's true.
So, um, back to the fee.
Do you guys want maybe a minute to digest that section before we move on?
Yeah, let's think about it out loud for a moment here. So, right now, there is failure to file, a missed filing fee, $25 for each missed filing.
Okay,. So if you had multiple boats, it'd be just $25 per vessel, which to me feels a little light.
So with that, maybe we'll start there. What would be a fair rate in your— from the board, what do you guys feel? I wouldn't like to see it go over $25 a boat. I would like it to stay at that. I wouldn't want it to be higher.
I would not want it to be. Hired. Okay. And keep in mind that that does— there's a lot of— there's some time that goes into sort of the follow-up reminder calls as well too.
I think we should double it.
I think it should be $50. Okay,. Because that'll incentivize them. And that's— that is the intent, right? So currently it doesn't cost them anything, they just do it.
Yeah, and currently it does stand. We do, we do our due diligence to remind people each month to, to get that in if we haven't seen it. So we're already being proactive. That's personnel time. That's that.
And what, what do we think that is in an hourly rate? I mean, that's close to $30 an hour anyway, right? What that indirect cost Yeah, honestly, I—. It's between $30 and $50 because you've got benefits. There's all kinds of stuff that goes into an employee's hour.
And that, that's a great question for finance to get that exact number. But even, I mean, I think you could throw $75 at that as well too. Well, I think $50 would be a place to start. Just, just one follow-up question. So a return must be filed every period.
Which is monthly. Okay, so that clarifies that. So then potentially you could miss a period, experience a, a $50 charge, miss a period, experience a $50 charge. So I mean, this could happen up to 12 times a year for somebody who's terrible at reporting. Sure.
And most of these vessels are running seasonally. Exactly. Got you. Um, we do require there is a, you know, you do a, you can pre-file, so if you're not running, say, for the months of October, November, December, you would just pre-file those 4, or those 3, fill out your zeros, move it on. Yeah, so I would agree with the suggestion to $50, if that's going to facilitate compliance.
If there isn't, I, if, you know, if you do have an issue, and your staff is putting in significant time.
Yeah, I don't know that— yeah, I guess that's where my comfort level would be. I wouldn't want to go—. Do they have any grace period so that before they get slapped down $50, they have like a week or 10 days? Because it feels kind of unfair that the person that gets 20 calls gets the same be that the person that gets one call, a reminder. Yeah, we do.
I'm drawing a blank on what that grace period is, say if it falls on us on a, on a day. We do offer like a, you know, a day here and there too. Or if it's— I believe honestly off top my head, if it's— if we haven't closed out the period yet, so there's some wiggle room in there.
And maybe that's an addition that needs to happen here, a grace period of 5 days. I'm trying to think of if we use the borough sales tax as our benchmark, and there's really no grace period there, right? Oh, they give you over the weekend, right? If it falls on a Sunday, you have to the Monday. Saturday or Sunday, you have to the following Monday.
I wouldn't be inclined to publish the grace period, I would be inclined to just operate under that but not necessarily publicize it. Yeah, I mean, and most of the year, or a portion of the year, we're open 7 days a week as well too, right? So access to the office and manpower is— we are accessible. Reporting is done electronically, on paper, paper, both? Paper.
Oh, okay. Yeah, maybe, maybe one day we'll move into electronic submissions, but currently, yeah, it's a very simple form, 1 through 31, number of passengers. There's a section at the bottom for tallying it out, and very simple. So the paragraph at the very top of page 18 The second line that says failure to file a return is subject to missed filing fee of $25 for each missed filing. Do we need to add per vessel?
That's a good point. No. I mean, is it clear somewhere else? But if that's, if that's a sticking point, you know, that could be, we could clarify that with a per vessel in That's—. I just don't know if it's clear.
It's a lot of print here.
If it's clearly stated somewhere, then we don't—. Each vessel may be stated in there. Each vessel has to file a return, and then maybe that sort of bakes in that that's its own return, if you will, and would be a different fee associated with that.
So that may be sort of covered in Section A if we want to go back to that.
So each vessel is already currently doing that, so I think it's kind of covered. No, kind of.
So that second part of B, how do you guys, how do you guys feel on the 10% of the amount owed, not to exceed $500? Do you like the percentage and the fee total, or would you like to see that based on maybe just a percentage so it's more in line with, say, the size return that you would be filing? So you're not— so a larger operator then is being charged accordingly, a smaller operator, it's a little more like fair and even across the board.
Going— so, Just, just to follow, the 10%, is that, is that how you think it should be implemented? You know, I'm not sure. I'm just looking for some guidance on it. I think the percent, because the small guy isn't— $25 or $50 means a lot to them, but a big guy that has 24 people on their vessel or 50, that's not going to mean nothing to them. So I kind of like the percentage thing?
Well, I think the percent is— I mean, if I'm out on Good Times— I'm sorry if I can't remember the name of your vessel, Dwayne. All right, good life.
And we're having a great time out there fishing. There's just 4 of us, you know, we catch our limit. Um, to me that seems that, you know, 25% is 25%, right? And, and maybe the $500 to a single operator with, again, with just a small number of people operating or able to go out on the vessel, that's a much larger impact, right, on your, on your revenue than if you're hauling 200 passengers or 150 or whatever that number might be.
So, and the bigger they are though, the better they should be able to pay the stuff on time. Yeah, they have somebody paid to do that, right?
I mean, you think.
There may be someone on staff. I'm not, I'm not sure. I like, I like the percentage. I really want to operate— I, I was just looking for some guidance on that from you guys, if that's—. Do you need a motion if we wanted to change this $25 to $50?
$1,000. Do we need a motion? No, I believe we can. What's the motive to change it, to up it? I mean,.
It's just the time that we're spending. I know that we do spend some time. We make every reasonable effort to remind a lot of. People not doing it. Is that—.
There's just a handful of people that, that we do really sort of always remind them.
So, but being a good, you know, just being a good neighbor, we go through the list, follow up, call.
So this does read the fee of $25 for each missing filing and a penalty in the amount of 10% of the amount owed, not to exceed $5,000.
$500. I kind of like the way it's written.
Plus interest charge, that's a good point too, that adds up. Yeah, I think, you know, if we're going to raise it up to $50, just leave the 10% the way it is and, you know, that's that.
Okay, leave the rest all in, all in place. Okay. All right, let's start there. Up the fee and hopefully you get more people to comply.
Okay, sounds, sounds fair. Okay, and as far as the Section D and C, any, any changes or clarification on that, or any changes you would like to see in there, or pretty straightforward? I'm fine with that.
Okay. Like, that's a good addition.
Really, no other— the next major change, and it's very similar to that one, is Section 270, the crane fee, use fee. Under Section 6, we we've changed that from $5 per card for replacement to $50. And they're, you know, just similar. We felt like $5 was, again, not worth our time. So there's some cost to goods with that as well, too, plus our time.
Okay. $50 Seems to be a theme. Yes, sir. Um, again, Section 295, Wharfage, that will, that will change next year.
And that, um, that's pretty much our— that takes us to the end of the tariff.
Very good. Do we have some other comments, suggestions, questions?
The Warfords rates on page 26, have they changed at all? Is that what they were?
Yep, they were— they changed by resolution done in 2007.
8, Possibly. Don't quote me on that. And that's done biennially.
So every other, every other year, basically, that will change next year by CPI. So I'm just looking at the diesel rate and thinking about diesel costs.
Our rates are a lot better than Anchorage.
And you'd like to raise it?
You know, that's interesting. I wonder, and maybe The clerk can speak to this. If it's done by resolution already, can we change it in an off year?
Like with the annual fee schedule? So under the wharfage rate, since that's changed by a past resolution and it's done every other year, are we able to change it in a non— I guess in a non-year.
Yeah, I'm sorry there, Board Member Kidd. I don't have an exact answer for you. If I—. We may not—. If I had to provide you an answer, I would say that since that's set by a resolution, that we're sort of locked into that.
Okay,.
Thank you.
Well, that brings me to another question, which would be, should we have in the tariff a clause that allows you to charge a fuel surcharge based on market prices?
So the wharfage itself is for product crossing the dock, right? Correct. So it's very similar to per gallon. Um, so I can— I guess I could understand. I mean, if the commodity was suddenly more expensive, you know, maybe you would feel like you were undercharging, but I don't know that that's the case really.
I mean, the time involved, uh, it's. I almost— I'm trying to wrap my head around what you're suggesting, how that would look on the back end of—. Yeah.
I don't— again, I appreciate where you're going in sort of any creativity, but not create more work. Right. That's hard to—. That's just an accounting nightmare. Yeah.
Right? 2 Cents is very easy. I get it. Or whatever that number is, 3 cents. Or same thing.
I'd rather just leave it. I would. I know that it will change next year. And just to let you know, next year I was proposing that that be raised to 3 cents, only because the last time it was done, if you add up all, all the CPI from that time, it would go to 3 cents. But it's such a small amount at every change, you never— if you only go by that,.
You'd be at a fraction. It's a fraction of a penny. You never actually see see that go up to 3 cents unless you go back in time to see when it was last changed. So that's a little—. It sounds like there's a systematic approach in place already.
Yeah. So now I guess we've moved into 2027 tariff, and that's what we'll be talking about next year.
So go a little faster. Very good. And then on the back, I'll just make, make mention of— if you guys are—. We don't have that. Oh, I'll get you a copy of that if you'd like, but we just have some legislative history that goes back of when some of this stuff was all put in place.
It's kind of just a fun little quick read, if you will, and a little history of the tariff. Goes back to 1990.
Yeah, I can, I can send that out. Yeah. And then whenever we do just a change, we, we haven't had really any major changes here in a few years. It's been sort of status quo.
But I will look for— I will look into— if you'd like to go back to that, the Diesel Wharfage question there, what would you propose? Just upping it like Like I said, maybe a penny to 3?
Yeah. That's fair. Gas as well? Sure. Kind of walked right into that one, didn't I?
Any other questions? In terms of our involvement today and what we've discussed in taking this walk through the tariff.
Do you need anything additional from us? Do we need to have this on the agenda again? Do you have what you need?
Um, no, I don't need anything else. I'm really, really small changes from you guys. I guess kind of set it on me. No, I said, Seward, did you change? And I will take that to council on the 14th for approval.
Any further discussion?
All right, seeing none, thank you.
And we'll go to the next, next item. Number 2, elect a new chair. And I guess the clerk can instruct us on the process. Thank you, Vice Chair Atwood. So currently the seat of chair is vacant, and to start this process, we would need a nomination for someone to be chair and for that person to accept the nomination.
And. I'd like to nominate Mr. Atwood.
Does Vice Chair Atwood accept the nomination? Yes, I will. And of course, we'll open it to others who might be interested. Any other nominations?
Any objections?
Okay, congratulations. PACAB has a new chair. All right, thank you. And then with that promotion on the agenda, there is Selection of the vice chair as needed, which is now needed.
Is there a nomination for vice chair? Do they have to be here to nominate them? They do not have to be present to be nominated. Yeah, we could pick on Norm. I would say Chair Scudder.
Scudder is no longer on the board.
Board member Jesse Groom and Norm Regis are not here tonight or today. Let's nominate Norm.
If I may add, board member Regis does not plan to run again in January. Okay,. Fair,. Right? So he'd only be vice for December,.
Correct?
I would say nominate him anyway because we're going to fill an empty seat and then a couple other ones and then we can go through this again. Or we could just— I nominate Chair Groom. How about that? So nomination for Aurigis and for Groom? Or was—.
I wish we could ask them who wanted Has either one of them been chair or vice chair before? I don't believe so. Yeah, right. Seems how Norm's going to be gone very soon. If we can nominate somebody that's going to stick around, we won't have to do this again.
True. When's Jesse's seat up? They were appointed the same day. Since the board does this annually, we'll be doing this again in January no matter what happens. Oh.
Think of December, basically.
I have a quarter. I can give you an update. Norm may run again.
Okay. I apologize. Okay, so we have Regis as a nomination.
Okay, I think, I think that's on the table. Okay, and Regis is not here to decline the nomination, so no objections. Perfect. Okay, so Regis will be vice chair. Now I know I did attend every meeting.
Excuse me, Mr. Clerk, do we need to vote on the approval of this. Uh, no approval needed. At this point. It sounded like you're going to incorporate the changes into the version that's going before Seward.
Oh, they— you— the, the board does not need to vote though after that change? I gotcha. All right, thank you. I just need some clarification on that.
Does that conclude the election portion of the agenda? It does. Great. Thank you, Chair Atwood. Item 9, informational items and reports.
Um, we have a reminder of meetings, regular meeting on December 16th. Will that be the next meeting? I believe Checking calendars, thinking. Chris? Let's see, so as we get closer to the holidays, I know attendance gets a little tricky.
See, December 16th, Wednesday, would be the last regular PACAP meeting of the year. Does anyone know ahead of time time if they can't make it. I will be here. I'll be here as well. I'll be here.
Very good. I think we may have enough people to hold a meeting. Good. There's also— so on Monday's agenda for council, are there 2 more people that are put in? There are 2 more.
Applicants for the last remaining vacancy, John Weisel and Victoria Provenza. So we might have a full board. Very nice.
So we're set on the date, um, and moving to the next item, uh, 10, citizens' comments. We have a citizen. Do we have comments? I was thinking of it all when you guys were talking, and now that I don't have anything in my head. All right,.
Um, except for the tariff, is that for leisure boats also, and, or just, is it, and it's for the fishing, the private fishing, but not the private, but the Marshall,. Every, every user within. The harbor.
I apologize, can we go back? We open it back up and open back up the tariff. We skipped over one section that I wanted to make mention of on 50-ton travel. So it'd be Section 255. We tried to speed up there just a little bit.
We went straight to wharfage. So Section 255. And 265, the proposals this year for those two.
So this year, the, um, our proposal is to raise those 10% plus CPI for each of those lifts, um, just due to the rising costs of maintenance on those machines. How much of that is CPI?
Again, it's 3.76%. So 10% plus 3.76%. I may not be reading these right, but I think that the words don't match the numbers.
Oh, good catch. When they're spelled out in all caps, they don't reflect the changes of the numbers. Okay. So like under Lyft fee B1, it says $300, but then don't the dollars say $350? Correct.
Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So the previous—. It will— easy change.
Thank you for that. I'm glad we went back. Yeah, I got a little anxious there. Instead of going section by section, we're getting near the end. So thank you for allowing that.
Yeah, all of that whole section, every one of them is— the words are wrong. Right, right, very good. So, that housekeeping change, thank you.
Good.
But your primary question goes to any input we have on the suggested increase. Correct.
Yeah, so the effective increase is 13.76%. Does that— is that right? Did you say a 10% increase with less CPI? Correct. Yeah, so basically.
Just a little south of.
14%. Yeah. And, uh, when was the last increase? Was this—. That is a fantastic question.
It has been several years since we've seen an increase. I almost want to say 2016. Oh, sure. Yeah, it's been a bit. Um,.
Well, what about That's enough information knowing that, you know, you're reaching for this increase over a decade. If you had just a moment, I could look in my legislative history. That was my question too, because that seems like 20% is a big jump.
And I may have gone back a little too far, but it has been several years since we've seen an increase on that.
And again, it's, it's really just to sort of keep up with or make an attempt to keep up with maintenance fees on these, on each of these machines. Especially the 300-ton, we're just, I use this example all the time, but we replace the cable on that machine, it's, it's gone from $10,000 to $13,000. And every 3 years, or when we do that cable change, to at last check last year, at the end of the year, it was $35,000.
So, and that's just with all parts. Sure, sure. On the machine, whatever we're buying. So just in, if I may, just in broad strokes, are you seeing an increase in the number of lifts that are done seasonally? Is the, is the.
Business That's another fantastic question. We— this last year we saw a slight decrease in lifts, and that could be just a number of factors. Just with rising fuel prices, sometimes they'll opt to skip a year to pull out and do maintenance on their boat. It's, um— I've talked to some vessel, some fishermen within Seward, as they've learned the hard way, you don't really save any money doing that. Prolongs the, the pain, really, like, like boiler maintenance.
Well, I'm not speaking for the entire body here, but I don't have any issues with this level of increase, given that it's been a number of years and you expressing this increased maintenance cost, which seems substantial. And also to just the number of people it takes to— we can use the 50-ton for an example. It's, you know, it's 2 men, 2 people working. Each lift is about— is an hour. It's rare that it goes over an hour, but it does happen on occasion.
And then a piece of equipment. So if you break it down, um, cost per person plus whatever that cost for the equipment is, it's still, I think, very reasonable. And then you can add same thing on the on the other side with a larger lift. Typically we will add a third person may go over and help depending on what the, what that lift entails. If there's a lot of factors, of course, of, you know, wind and what the size vessel, it's nice to have an extra hand there just for safety.
And then they can break away once it's in position. But a lot of times there's really just 3 guys that whole lift. To keep it running smoothly.
Any additional comments, suggestions? No, I don't have a problem with the rates either. Okay, could we raise it not quite as much and then raise it again, like the additional— raise it 8% instead of 10, and then in 2 years raise it 2% or something?
I think this is fair if that's the direction that the board would like to go. I mean, I'm open, but I think 10 is a very easy number plus CPI. Since it's been so many years, yeah. Yeah, I wish I had that exact number for you of when it was last changed.
And while we move on to board comments, I can try to source that out for you really quickly if I can. But it has been, it has been a handful of years though since it's been done. But I think if we hadn't seen such a large increase on, on cost of expenses, on the expense side, I don't think we'd be looking at this either. It would just stay status quo. So it's, I think we're just kind of in line with just trying to play catch up.
And we may even be a little low as well too. So we'll look at to get next year.
Okay, very good. So returning to our place on the agenda, Board and Administration comments and responses to citizen comments.
I believe we received a little bit of citizen comment. And— Yes, please. On the tariff thing, I was— because I'm new to tariff things. It does that. Do you do it on every single, like, the tour boats, the big tour, the big boats, the ships, the cargo ships?
Is that all? Everybody gets tariffs on them, just different categories? Every— yeah, correct. If I understand you quick, does this apply to every vessel within the harbor? Yeah.
Yes, it does. And including pleasure boats and everything else. Correct. Okay. Pleasure boats don't have to file those monthly reports.
No, that would just be a— if you— unless you haul or carry passengers,. Right? But if you're just a personal pleasure boat, correct? Yeah, this is just that $3.50 head fee for tours, fishing. Yeah.
Okay, very good. Um, any follow-up to citizen comments? Well, um, so my question is going back to the earlier comment about the fireworks. Um, does this board want to convey that information to council prior to, um, January so that they at least get the feedback that people are not happy. Because the chamber gets an awful lot of money from the city, and that decision got made without the participation of the city.
It only, from what I understand, was made by the board of the chamber. And they're— I mean, I think they're using city funds for those fireworks. So I feel like it's on us to convey back to them, hey, there's a lot of unhappiness about this decision. And we'd like the council to weigh in on it and possibly allocate take funding for January fireworks or do a, you know, a drive in the community to get funds for it. I don't know what to do.
I agree with Linda that the council needs to at least be aware that the public's unhappy about that because we're the advisory board for the board of chamber, basically. So we need to let them know that it's been conveyed to us. And I'd also like to point out that Mark owns multiple charter boats, and, um, I am new to Tariffs, and I called him about, you know, this, and that is what he chose to spoke— speak about. And many other people, but a lot of people are working during, during the day, so.
Right. So we have citizens' comments reflected in our record. If we want to go further than that, I would imagine we could, we could as a body make a suggestion, but I'm not quite sure what that looks like.
Yeah, we can put something together, like for an upcoming Council meeting, recommendation from the board, I can work with you on that. Okay. Do we have time to do that before this next meeting? Unfortunately, probably wouldn't make the cut for this. But it could make the cut for the first January—.
For the first December meeting. December 14th meeting. Yeah, okay. It's cutting it a little close, but I think we should do that. Are we in agreement?
Does the other member members of the board feel the same way? Do you? Yeah, I think the chamber should know how the community feels about it. I agree. They didn't ask for anybody's opinion, but we'll give it to them.
I agree, a lot of people were blindsided by that. I mean, it's tradition. Okay. And just Returning the question back to the clerk, what would you— what would be required on our part? Some verbiage reflecting essentially what we've discussed?
Yeah, exactly. It would just be like a written letter of recommendation and about how the board feels. It sounds like the board's in agreement, so there's It'll be pretty easy to put something together.
Okay. And then at least one of us should plan on being at the— what did you say, December 14th? December 14th meeting.
I can put that on my agenda. Make sure I'm there. Thanks, Linda. Okay, good.
Further discussion on that? We— no. Okay, let me give one question as long as I'm here. Where does the money for the fireworks go if they get canceled because of the weather? Does it go back into the— back into— does it accumulate in a fireworks fund for the next time, or what?
No. Good question. I don't have an answer. Has it ever been canceled? Oh,.
It was canceled last New Year's. Last New Year's it was.
They do get canceled a lot, but not that much. You can still go out in very cold. There's not a lot of wind. But, but it's a lot of money because I know that I can't remember, we used to have a lot of cancellations and I never thought of, where does the money go then? If they're canceled, like, for the weather?
Can you carry it over for the next Fourth of July or something like that, or what? It seems to me that some people donate for this firework fund. Mm-hmm. Right. We can get clarity on that.
I assume administration could help us.
Good question though. Because I agree, and the polar bear jump-off is nastier weather than the New Year's generally.
Higher chance of it. When that snow was all piled in the middle of the street with the heavy rain and all this stuff, this is way back when the guy Tom used to come around and videotape it every year. Every single year and give everybody videos for it. I have one of those. And it's pretty unmaskable.
We also had a lot more participants.
All right, thank you. And back to board and administration comments. I guess we'll start with— Administration? No further comments, Chair. Okay, then we'll begin with board comments.
Board Member Dunn? Yeah, I'd just like to thank the public for showing up and Tony for putting this together and getting it done now instead of right after the— before the holidays.
Thank you. Oh, and thank you for running in here. I'm sorry for being late. Board Member Draper? Mark some alerts on my phone from here on out.
But yeah, no further comment. Great. Board Member Paquette. Thank you to everybody being here and to the public that came and spoke.
I'm returning to PACAB after having been on previously, and when I learned that we're down to one meeting a month, I was really very disappointed because I really believe in this board. And I think this board has a lot of potential to really help the city grow and gather input from the community and be that funnel to the council. And So I'm, I'm really looking to start having some really, some serious conversations. There's some things that are really troubling to me on the horizon. I heard the Coast Guard's bringing 500 people in.
I heard JAG's bringing 500 people in. That's 1,000 people. We need to revisit our septic systems and make sure that we're on track for being able to accommodate that number of people. That's one thing that I have on my mind. I don't know how we go about doing that, but, um, but I'd like to see us be more productive.
I'd like to see us have work sessions. I'd like to see us meet twice a week, that would— or twice a month. That's what I committed to, and that's what I'm committed to, to doing. So, um, if you don't want to do that, let me know, because I'm kind of cranked up. I really want us to, to be more involved in what's happening.
Over. Great. Thank you. I appreciate your enthusiasm. Um, and, uh, yeah, so here, here we are today.
Um, As you can see, you know, decisions are made by the people who show up. So, even at the level today, we got, you know, important comment. And so, I would agree with Board Member Pickett that, yeah, we have work to do and having.