27th Session of the IPHC Research Advisory Board, Day 1 Part 1
Alaska News • • 178 min
Articles from this transcript
Halibut commission scientist questions dogfish study built partly on its survey data
The halibut commission's stock scientist says a dogfish study didn't properly correct its survey data. Two B.C. fishermen questioned the alarm itself.

Yeah, I'm Alex, uh, commercial fishing, very small scale, out of Homer. Merchant Marine for 40 years.
I'm Bruce Hale. I'm down here from Canada. I've got a charter, do the charters. I grew up fishing halibut, started fishing in 1974, and I'm also a fish buyer in Canada.
Ray Webster, a statistician with the IPHC.
All right, thank you very much. We also have a couple of RAB members online, so if we could just get Scott and Angus to test your microphone.
Yeah, can you hear me okay? Yes, no problem.
And this is Scott. You guys picking me up? Perfect, thank you very much. Just quickly highlight where you're from because we do have a couple of new people in the room. Scott Mazzoni from Area 2A, Kwinault Indian Nation.
Yeah, Angus Groat, Area 2B, commercial halibut fisherman for the last 30 years.
Awesome. Well, thank you very much, everybody. We didn't miss anybody. William, do you want to just quickly introduce yourself?
And William's going to give us a short presentation a little bit later this morning just on some of the work he's been doing with us. Okay, well, not seeing any other Participants joined the meeting while we were going around the table. Yeah, I think— can we just have the agenda brought up online, please?
Okay. So just, just a reminder, this meeting is specifically to review the work that we've been undertaking here at the IPHC and develop a series of recommendations, hopefully, or requests for modification to those activities and potentially new ideas as well. And those would go to the, the scientific review board who will meet again next year. But also the report gets provided to the Commission itself in January 2027. Over the next day and a half, we're going to cover off on the typical topics that we cover each, each RAB meeting.
We're particularly interested in hearing from you about your season highlights, what's happened this year, and we'll cover those off under agenda item 4. You'll receive some pretty general updates on actions arising in just a moment before we step into a lot of the detailed presentation of research that the team has been undertaking over the past year, and Giuseppe's going to primarily lead all of that this afternoon. You'll also be hearing from the FIS team on updates on activities and the Fishery Independence Satellite Survey this year. And then we're going to reserve most of tomorrow morning for sort of general discussion. And this is something that we introduced, I think, 2 years ago, the additional half day for the RAB.
And that allows you all to engage with staff this evening during the function, which is just at a brewery just down the road here, where you hopefully you'll be able to discuss some of the research activities that are being undertaken and then come back tomorrow morning afresh with some additional ideas on what we could potentially modify in the way we're undertaking our research.
And that'll wrap us up probably by about lunchtime tomorrow. Any particular requests for additional items to be added to the agenda, or are you pretty happy with a casual approach for this meeting?
Yeah, sounds good. Okay, well, let's jump straight in then. If we could have paper 3 on the screen, please. So this is the update— updates on actions arising from the last RAB.
Okay, just noting we have, as I said, a couple of new people in the room. I'm not going to go into too much detail in this paper. It is just all of the requests and recommendations for action arising from the the previous meeting provided Appendix A of the paper. All of them we will step through throughout the course of the meeting, whether it's from a particular presenter, we'll highlight the current status, whether it's in progress, completed, or ongoing over a number of years. And so just, just stay tuned for those.
No audio detected at 4:40
It really is just a reference document. If you do have any questions at any time and receiving some updates and I know particularly requests or recommendation rather, 2 on the screen, where the RAB had recommended that the Secretariat or the IPHC in general undertake a number of data collection activities related to the trawl fleet. As you can see there, the Commission did consider this very specifically along with the Council and have provided very specific text for inclusion in this update on actions arising. And so we do just ask that you, you take note of that, and the Commission has indicated they would not like us to continue to look into this topic at this time. Any questions?
If you have had— I'm hoping you've had the time to review it, but as I said, if not, each of the presenters are going to provide particular presentations that will address some of these, or all of these rather, actions arising from, from the previous meeting. So I'll just pause there, see if there's any questions.
Yeah, go ahead, Lando.
Um, that last one there, that, um, separately the council received an application for exempted fishing permit from Seashare and Glacier Fish Company. So did that get approved or did that go through or what? It is still being processed, but Bush is keeping a very close finger on the pulse. So to speak. So I'm going to pass to Basia.
Do we have a spare microphone that we can leave down the end of the table? If not, just grab one. Kevin, could I just ask you to pop in as well and see if there's a spare one in the storeroom?
Yes. So the exam fishing permit is part of the council process. So in order for this to go through, the council would have to approve this permit in order for the— and this is very limited application of that— using the, the bycatch of Pacific halibut for donations. Separately, this also requires a change in the IPHC regulations, and we have received the indication that NOAA Fisheries would like to have this considered at the IPHC annual meeting as a regulatory proposal. So this would require two separate actions.
One action by the council approving the exempt fishing permit, and then second, the change in IPHC regulations allowing donation from the trawl under the exempt fishing permit.
That answering the full question?
So yeah, so they're asking for one specific vessel to donate, to be able to donate bay catch for the like food banks and meals separately. This is currently allowed under IPHC regulations, but not, not from the trawl fleet. This is the first trawl application for allowing that for the trawl fleet to do it. Separately from all the other gear, bycatch can be under NOAA fisheries donated to the food programs and the donation program. And that is already in the APHC regulation as approved and like allowed action.
Any more questions or comments on any of the actions arising from the last RAB?
Okay, not seeing any. Let's close that agenda item and bring up Paper 04, please.
So Paper 04, again, this is sort of our standing agenda item just to bring forward any actions arising from the Commission meeting, the most recent Commission meeting itself, which occurred in January earlier this year. And so we provide again as a reference document all of the actions arising relevant to the Research Advisory Board discussions, particularly at this meeting. There were no specific recommendations in that regard coming out of the Commission meeting in relation to the RABS mandate. However, there were a number of other actions, requests specifically to forward the proposal C1 and C3 for Council awareness. And again, Basra, I'm just going to quickly pass to you to provide an update on how they handled those two proposals which came from RAB members.
So we followed the recommendation and we forwarded the information about those proposals to the Council, noting that this is not part of what IPHC considers its own kind of area of responsibility. This is more of a domestic regulation, and we do continue to include, but we do continue to include the unguided sector data and updates to that data in our stock assessment. Uh, currently there's no further action as far as I know at the Council, but this is the ongoing discussions and the concern at the Council. So I just recommend stay tuned, but there's nothing specific to, to report at this time.
Okay, thanks very much. If we can get rid of this from the screen. In terms of other actions arising, there was discussion about the pelagic pollock catcher vessel in the electronic monitoring program, and then we've also listed just for quick, easy reference all of the fishery regulations that were adopted at the last annual meeting. And so provided in the document is the appendix. You can click on these links— excuse me— and it will take you directly to the proposal that was eventually adopted.
Any question on any of those actions arising?
Okay. Not seeing any. Well, let's close that agenda item and then we can move on to the RAB member updates, which is probably one of the most interesting aspects of the next day and a half. Who would like to kick off? Just go around table, Cody.
Just to give you an idea, is that each RAB meeting we just go around the table and everybody provides an update on how their season's gone, any particular anomalies or whether it's gone well or poorly. And then it's also an opportunity for you to interact with other RAB members to see if they're encountering the same challenges or successes. So it's just a good opportunity to sort of get that out in the open. Then we can incorporate that into discussions, particularly about some of the potential research projects that we might wish to undertake over the coming year. Who'd like to go first?
Perfect.
Hi, this year went a little—. I caught my quota a little quicker than last year, like it went a little more smoothly. There was— I was catching less big fish than I expected, more, more smaller fish, and there was a lot more gear on the grounds, like where, where I usually fish, than I was expecting. Um, like a lot more competition with a lot more other boats fishing the same areas, like including some like big boats that I would expect to be much farther offshore. So I was, I was curious if maybe the fishing wasn't good out there, or they were just catching too many smalls, or the weather was pretty bad, so that might, that might be the reason.
Um, Yeah, that's my update.
Again, I'm addressing the Newport Area 2A in the salmon troll industry pretty much predominantly. I kind of noticed a trend. I did a little bit of research about— from the internet, of course, so you got to trust what you get, right? So on from the 2024 to the 2026 season, the incidentally caught halibut, which I'm addressing for the salmon troll industry, Chignik, Alaska. Kind of noticing a trend of declining catch rates.
It was 69% attained of the quota in 2024 of the amount of incidental halibut that are allowed to be caught by the salmon trollers. In 2025, it was at 67%, and this year in 2026, clear down to 42% was attained. Of course, there's a lot of factors, as we know, incidentally on halibut for us salmon trawlers. And I think a lot of it has to do with the salmon fishery this year. The majority of our salmon caught are usually for Chignik industry in the, in the early season.
We're fishing down on the bottom, um, in 30 to 50 fathoms. This year the fish were not in that zone. They were up in the upper, uh, 10, 12, 13 fathom zone. And we don't know if it's maybe there's a hypoxia thing going on in the ocean or whatever because they're not able to breathe down there. But most of the fish were caught up high, therefore your rate of incidental halibut is going to go way down not being down on the bottom.
Um, I did catch a couple halibut this year, incidentally. Also, in, in with that, um, I talked with the directed fishery people, the 2A. Of course, we know that incidental troll is if we catch a halibut salmon fishing, we get to keep it if we have our license. Directed fishery is allowed, depending on your vessel length, so many halibut, uh, for the opener. And we have an opener, we don't have an all-out, you can go fish anytime you want.
So boats are limited by weather, which is a big factor for a lot of our boats in the fleet, which Cody will probably address too as we're talking. Um, but a trend in this, uh, in 2024, in order to get 95% of the 2A And that's a large area, as we know. So I'm just kind of— I think it's— if we did this for just Newport, it would be a lot more drastic. They had to have 5 openers to catch their allowed amount. 2025, They had 3 openers.
But this year in 2026, they had to have 6 openers. And in those 6 openers, they're showing they attained 97% of the allowable tonnage. But I think in Newport that would be drastically disputed. The guys were really struggling, especially some of the boats did okay, but the quality of the fish were a lot less and the boats were struggling to get their quota. A lot of black cod was sustaining them.
So it's about all I have.
Um, great at talking here, but, uh, yeah, we fished— so last year we fished 3 openers and we have 3-day openers now. Um, this year, 2026, we had 6 openers and fishing was overall slow with a high price. Um, fish were average. There was a bit of black cod caught with it. Some guys stuck with it, some guys didn't.
Um, we fished all 6 and overall did—. It was a great opportunity overall, but, um, slow fishing.
But yeah, um, I have 3A, 3B, and 4B. I don't have very much 3A. It just takes me a couple of days. Um, it was about the same as last year. I do that pretty late.
Um, hard to notice anything there personally. Um, In 3B, that's the majority of my fish, and I would say it was a lot scratchier than it's traditionally been for me. It's not unheard of for me to be able to get 40,000 pounds in 5 days or so, and I didn't get anywhere close to a trip like that this year. Um, took me like 3 trips to catch about 50. And, um, I know I'd be curious to hear if, um, how people are doing that have a different gear type than me.
I have traditional halibut gear, it's 18-foot stuck, so I end up covering a lot of ground. I feel like kind of the law of averages maybe helped me always get a little bit but maybe not hit the jackpot. So I'd be curious to hear if people that had closer stuck gear, if they were, you know, putting everything on their favorite spot and then there was nothing there and they were striking out, or if they were coming in with really good trips. I'd just curious to hear about that. Um, I end up hauling quite a bit of gear and, uh, I did not have a, a great trip, not through lack of trying.
So, um, yeah, it was a bit of a grind. And then, um, in Area 4B, it was, uh, it was okay for me. I ended up doing 2 trips out there and, um, same thing. I feel like being able to cover a lot of ground really helps me out personally, and that might, uh, put someone kind of pigeonhole somebody else. But I also, um, I heard of some guys having good trips.
I heard of some guys just striking out. So overall, maybe it just felt like it was a little bit harder this year than other years.
Steve Daniels here. Um, So my halibut operation looks like this. We have 8 to 10 boats with 4 to 6 guests, charter fishing, guided, and we fish in area bordering 2C and 3A at Cross Sound. These boats are highly mobile. We fish the same area due to the fact that we're tethered to a little town of Pelican, the same area every year for the past 25 years.
So the change from this year from past years would be that there are areas that we reliably fish if we have a slot limit. So if the slot limit says you can only keep a halibut under, say, 38 inches and over 80 inches, For the most part, our guys are going for that halibut that's closest to 38 inches. I don't even know what the actual limitation was this year as I don't fish anymore myself.
So they could reliably do that for 4 or 6 guests in, you know, probably an hour in the same place year after year after year. And Often, you know, after they've each guessed after a 4-day trip, after a couple days, you know, my guides will say, would you like to go set for a bigger fish? And then they'll look for a gaff fish, you know, that's 100 pounds that we utilize by leasing commercial quota from a commercial fisherman. So the big change is that Over the past few years, the area in 380 that we fished offshore about 20 miles was after years and years and years of excellent fishing, went really dry for the past 4 or 5 years, which as I've reported before, that area has somewhat come back and we've had some, you know, okay fishing there and it's kind of surprising. Oftentimes that area is just inundated with, you know, salmon sharks.
So, you know, we're not— dogfish, I should say. And so we can't— you can't hardly catch anything anyway. But the other big change is this area in Tucsy that we fish about 5 miles offshore. It—. We struggle to catch much of anything there.
Guys can sit for a couple hours and instead of wading through some smaller fish to get a 38-inch fish, They sit there and sit there and sometimes they're lucky to catch one keeper. And so I guess my take is, is that having fished the same area year after year after year with, you know, again, if you went back in time when we only had 6 boats, but, you know, 8 to 10 boats that are highly mobile, there's places that just don't hold the fish that they have in the past. And I, I couldn't say why. Naturally, you fish between June, July, and August. That's the limitation of our fishing.
However, there's— we're still catching large fish when we take the time to target the large fish. And, uh, also there seems to be more fish that are, I don't know, 40, 50, 60, 70 pounds that people aren't willing to pay for as a gas gaff fish, but they're there and we see nicer and bigger fish that aren't actually being caught because there's no incentive to pay $500 to $700 for that fish. And in fact, we don't even allow people to keep fish, uh, even if they say, yeah, I don't— I'll spend, I'll spend $700 for a 50-pound fish. We, we really try to dissuade them from doing that because there's a limit to how many gaff fish that are available. So, and we want everyone to have an opportunity to keep a fish of any size should they come upon that 100-pound or 200-pound fish.
So to sum up, uh, one area gets better, uh, slowly over time. Other area this year rather dramatically after two decades of having solid fish in there for the smaller type fish just seems to have dried up. And what that means to, you know, you research biologists, you know, if that's meaningful, I hope that it is. That's my report.
Well, Um, let's see, 3A was, uh, where I start, usually pretty close to the opener. I was a week late or so this year, so by the time— and I usually go Eastern, Eastern Gulf, um, which is a long run to go, but, uh, typically last decade or so get a lot nicer grade over there. And so when I got over there, there was a lot more boats because I was a week late, so my normal spots were already set down, to my disappointment. And, um, so I kept going east, uh, and the weather was coming up, so I went to the beach sort of and fished. Normally don't fish real shallow that time of year, but, uh, was in the teens and had the best trip I've had in probably a decade for grade and, uh, the number of fish.
The definitely the best sets I've had, um, for a long time. And so that was the first trip. And then, uh, the second trip I didn't go— I didn't have that much left, so I didn't go back all the way out there. And then we started fishing in areas where normal depth we fish in and ran across a lot of small fish. And, um, and then pretty much we did an early shipyard this year.
We had some repairs to do and stuff, so we just did a couple of— oh, we did, we did do one 3B trip that was pretty scratchy, just right at the line there around the Trinity and stuff. And I don't know, we probably fished 3 days for 5,000 pounds or something up shallow. Weather was bad. And so then we went to shipyard, then we started doing the surveys. And, uh, you know what happened on the surveys.
There was lots of In Gore Point and Chignik, the two areas we did in the Gulf there, there was a lot of small fish but not nearly as bad as out west. And yeah, there was a lot of— I mean, I don't have the numbers right off the top of my head, but I don't think Gore Point and Chignik were too far off the mark, but they definitely didn't exceed your expectations. And, um, and then we went out west to do 4A. I think we did some of our quota first before we started fishing the charters, and it was real scratchy. Uh, weather was real marginal.
So I think, uh, yeah, we ended up circumnavigating the damn island there. Or this would have been, what, late July or something like that, I think. June, July, yeah, late July, middle of July. And yeah, it was really scratchy and a lot of whale interaction. Last year I complained about sand fleas a lot.
This year I sort of modified how long I would leave stuff on the bottom. So I guess maybe that helped a little bit. There were still sand fleas issues, but, um, not as bad as last year. And, uh, so that first foray trip was, was pretty marginal, and we went all the way down to Four Mountains and then all the way back to, uh, Unimak. And, um, I can't remember what, what we caught, but it wasn't a lot.
And then we did the foray survey in basically the same area And there were some, there were some, well, yeah, there was a hell of a lot of small fish. Like, I think overall through however many stations there were, we probably landed, I don't know, 16,000 pounds of fish for, I don't know how many stations there were. But 12,000 of it was undersized fish. And, you know, they were able to sell them and stuff, but I'd never seen so many small fish. And we're talking baby fish, like tiny fish.
I don't even know how they got on the hook. Some of them didn't. They were just sort of like, you know, hooked in the body or something. But anyway, a lot of small fish out there, and, um, And we got finished with that. And then, you know, with the fuel prices and stuff, uh, it just didn't really punch out to go try to do any Fort B.
And I heard you were out there not doing that great. And the weather was crappy out there too, wasn't it? I was actually okay with the weather. When were you fishing?
Um, all of August and, uh, a good 15 days in September. I did 2 10-day trips. Yeah. Yeah, so, um, so yeah, then we finished up our, our 4A quota after, uh, the 4B charter, 4A charter. And it, and it got better, um, it got better on the south end of the island and over toward, uh, of course it helped, it helped doing the survey there because there was a few spots I don't normally fish that pop pretty good, and there were some nice-grade fish.
These were over toward Unimak and, you know, south of Akutan and stuff in the passes there and stuff. And, uh, so we, we went back to those, and they weren't as good as the survey ones, but then the spots I normally fish got better. It got really good there at the end. And then we went back, um, 2-3B, and as Brian said, it was pretty scratchy. And I don't run a lot of gear, near as much gear as I used to.
I run conventional gear too, just like Brian, at 18-foot. A lot of guys run 9-foot gear. And so Doug, uh, Doug Lyle on the, uh, I guess he's running the Dream now. He was him and I both ended up in 3B about the same time in about the same area. And, uh, there at Sandman Reefs.
And, and so I had a couple of decent sets and then the whale showed up and I moved on and Doug sort of stuck around there and he, he pretty much doubled me every day, but then he was running twice the gear I was running. And and then he has— then he had the, uh, closer spacing too. So when you look at, uh, catch per unit effort, they weren't that dissimilar, but he's just running a lot more gear and a lot more hooks. So, and then the whales in 3B were— I don't know if you, if you had much there, but we, uh, every— seemed like every place we went we got whales. Not in Sandman's, but, um, but every other place closer to Sand Point and then past Sand Point.
And then finally we just went over to the line there and had some pretty decent fishing south of the Trinity, south of Kodiak there in 3B, and fleas, but still pretty decent fishing. So all in all, it was a pretty good year. Price-wise sort of mitigated the fuel prices. Um, yeah, and, um, I think it— I think, uh, yeah, fished a lot of places I never— I don't normally fish, like in bays, a lot of shallow fishing there toward the end just to stay away from whales, and, and, uh, it turned out okay.
It's still a scratch.
Yeah, it's— yeah, there's not a lot of fish. That's all I got. What are the whales you're seeing? Both, but mainly killer whales out west and then in 3B. Uh, the sperm whales, we usually— they're usually like over in the Gulf that we run into them.
We don't fish real deep out west, but, um, which is where you tend to find those guys. But I saw a dead humpback at Turnover, the tongue ripped out. Yeah, I, I, there was a dead whale south of Umnak. Um, actually, I don't know if it was dead or not. It looked like an orca ate it or something.
Yeah, yeah. It was really weird. I think— what was that, this year or the year before? Yeah, I think I saw that one 2 years ago.
I think both. I think we're going to hear a little more. You want to make a quick comment on that, Claude? Yeah, the excluder is designed for either species and it's effective for either species. Yeah.
The other thing about, um, the whales too, um, I've never really had much issue with them up shallow, say like in 30 fathoms and up. But, uh, the Sunward was fishing in the teens down around the Trinity in the south end of Kodiak and had orcas come strip their fish. The orcas were really active with them and further east with black cod pots this year. Yeah, in the Gulf. Yeah, yeah, ripping pots open.
So they're getting pretty good, way smarter than we are.
So I haven't been on a hell of a trip since I was like 30, um, but, um, little kids, um, but my husband is Fishes and my brother and a lot of— most of our friends. So my kind of assessment is like a conglomeration of like maybe 10 families in Sitka.
Tusi was mostly pretty scratchy or scratchier than last year, but the beginning of the season was okay. It just—. It got worse. More quickly.
3A was— it was okay at the beginning, but it was spotty. Like, there was a few good spots, but kind of the same, I guess, as last year. Dogfish were still a problem, but it seemed like not as bad this year as last year.
And then, yeah, killer whales more in 3A than in the past for a lot of folks.
Let me see, is that everything?
Yeah, it seemed like the big thing this year was that 2C was not as— was like way more scratchy than usual. Um, and then, yeah, but the beginning of the season was better for people that were fishing. Like, my husband fishes at the beginning, and then my brother doesn't fish till a little bit later, and there was like a big difference between them. So yeah, that's us.
Thanks. Um, yeah, just to preface, there are boats that I'm, I'm running and booking our charter boats, so we're limited in range. Mostly we're fishing um, all day trips. So they're, uh, from Kalgon Island and Cook Inlet down to Shuyak some days and over to Gore Point if somebody's really stretching their legs. So that's, that's mostly the range I'm talking about here.
Um, early season was— the spots filled in with fish quicker than they normally do, I thought, which I was surprised by because it was, it was a cold year. It's a really cold spring for us. Um, there was a lot of peacock around, but there was a lot of halibut mixed in too, which was surprising. Uh, smaller fish than normal, definitely considerably smaller fish, I thought. Um, and then yeah, once— like, we had a good start to the season, and then the weather was just, uh, brutal, which it was consistently brutal for a solid, like, 2 months there, which when you're running— I have a 53-foot boat and trying to keep people from puking all day long on it.
Yeah, after like the first 2 weeks I got tired of it, so people just puked a lot.
But I was surprised with how many fish there were, like, in— because we were limited in range when the weather's bad in Cook Inlet. It's a— it's like properly bad, especially when you're trying to keep people from dying. So yeah, fishing a lot in Kachemak Bay and in shallower spots, and I was surprised by how many fish there were in shallow. Small fish, you know, 32 inches and less, but there was an awful lot of them. And to be able to consistently get, you know, 40 to 50 fish off of spots like that day after day is, for us, that means it's pretty good fishing.
Yeah, and then there was a little bit later in the season, we fish, uh, kind of pinnacles a little bit further south, and there were spots that were holding an awful, awful lot of small fish. Again, no big fish, but like, you know, we'd have 7 or 8 inspected boats lined up, and same reports, everybody, you can feel the lines, you know, bonking off the fish on the way down. So just tons of little fish on these pinnacles, uh, probably for maybe like 3 weeks of a really consistent fishing on, on spots like that. But yeah, that's the report for me, basically. Just limited range this year, but lots of, lots of small fish, uh, no big fish.
Yeah, we fished pretty early Area D out in front of Montague. Prince William Sound. And, uh, I think all the whales were inside the sound because we didn't see one, which is really nice. No sand flea activity whatsoever, and the average was, uh, pretty good. The average size was actually the best we've had in years, uh, and a little less effort than normal.
Um, but then we're fishing, uh, Snap-On gear, uh, pretty 2 sets, 2.5 sets a day, and we were done in, I don't know, 10,000 pounds in 5 days, which was pretty unusual. Usually that takes 2 trips for a 34-footer. So we're really happy to get it done. It was—. The weather was okay.
It was, uh, mid-May when we fished, so not bad.
I'll go back.
Alex, I'm sorry, when— where did you fish? Out in front of Prince William Sound, Montague Island.
Pretty deep there? Uh, yeah, we started off shallow, worked deep, and ended up about midway, probably 70 fathoms, something like that. Be on the outside?
Yeah, yeah, out, out in the Gulf.
Yeah, it was a, it was a funny year in BC. I mean, we're notorious for everybody doing this year what worked last year, so then it doesn't work this year, so then we do that all next year. There's times when everybody floods out on the opening to try and get the early big price. And then we flood the market and screw that up. And my trick has always been to take our boat out right at the very end when the weather's just shit and there's no fish on the market and do it the ugly way.
But that didn't work this year either. The price fell off at the end. So the boys got the shit beat out of them and didn't get any money either. So that's what we're trying to deal with right now. But it's a funny year.
I end up with way more questions than answers this year. It'd be interesting to hear what you guys say about the fish in some of the other areas. We only did the one charter in Goose Island this year. Fishing was, I guess it was so-so. It was okay.
It seems like it's really hard to rely on these numbers because During the season, there's times when the fishing was okay, and then there's times when it was terrible. And it was— there was no pattern to it. It—. There'd be a couple good trips, and we kind of all communicate now because there's, there's, there's less and less boats fishing, more and more quota in BC, and we're not fighting with each other very much. So we're all worried about fuel, and we're all worried about time and crew and all that stuff, probably way more than ever.
So we're trying to be We try and get ahead of it and communicate and say, you know, I was here, don't go here, go over there, we just cleaned out this spot, or I'm going to be here, I'm going in to deliver on Friday. And so, okay, we'll leave and I'll move out there. Better cooperation probably than we've ever had between the boats, but still long periods of real shit fishing this year, you know. And if you just happen to do a fish charter in that spot at that time, you got diddly, you know. Anytime the fishing got good, the fishing was small, you know, the fish was small.
We got periods where we had, you know, we get 1,500 fish on a string and discard 80% of them, you know.
And yeah, we all got the same whale problems. I can't figure it out. Like I said, I got so many questions. Where the yelloweye has been a problem in BC, being a choke species, trying to get away from it. We used to go out into the deep and get to try and get a bit of black cod bycatch a little bit.
You can get out of the yelloweye. They're deeper now. We go up in the shallows and try and get out of them. They're shallower now. They're spreading out all over the place.
So I think the yelloweye quota is kind of recovering from a couple bad assessments that put just a shit limit on yelloweye when we all figured there was a lot more than they said. But they had a couple bad surveys that We probably paid for that for 10 years, you know, but it is rebuilding. But while it's rebuilding, we can't get away from them. You know, when we were worried about them and they were a real choke and they were really shutting us down, we could always kind of get away from them. Now we're allowed to catch a little bit more, but we can't get away from them.
So that, that's a problem that I don't really know the answer to. Now all of a sudden we've got this big hysteria about dogfish. Is dogfish going to be a choke species now? It sure is in BC. There's a whole lot of people talking about it and there's a whole lot of attention on it.
I don't really understand where that came from because we see lots of dogfish, you know, different times and on the moon and different times of year. We can't get away from them yet. You know, everybody out there fishing does anything they can to move away from them. So we don't catch them. So then they say there is none.
Well, maybe we're just better at staying away from them and they're out there anyways. That's what I think. But we're at risk of a bad assessment doing the same thing with dogfish now that we just went through for 15 years on yelloweye. So that's a concern too. What other things we got going here?
Your assessment on dogfish, is that just based on I don't know, maybe Dr. Stewart can talk to this dogfish thing. I—. It's kind of blindsided me, and, and I'm sort of in the mode of, where the fuck did this come from? You know, like, we just finished— we're getting tortured by yelloweye.
I haven't talked about dogfish for 25 years. All of a sudden I'm worried about them. Like, I'd like to hear the origins of this a little bit more. I don't even know how to challenge it because I don't even understand it. But we're going to everybody saying, make sure you say you catch lots of dogfish because suddenly we're worried about them.
You know, it's sort of a whole new thing to me. Maybe we could shed— people here could shed some more light on that too. Anyways, that's a lot of talk about no real conclusions on anything, you know. It was funny to see the market drop in the last 30 days here. You know, that's the last thing on earth I thought would happen.
We got some huge prices in the middle of the season. When we didn't expect that either. You know, I mean, I think in May on one of the charter trips, we got like $16 Canadian a pound for our fish. It was unbelievable. I never seen anything like it in my life.
And then we go out in the fall when there's frickin hurricanes and everybody's flying all over the place and we got $13 or $12 for some of it, you know, and a real drop in a real big difference in 10/20 prices are low. And, you know, On a good trip, 65% of our fish is minus 20 on a good trip. So if you're, if you're 10-20 prices in the dump, you know, 80-90% of your prices in the low ones, you know. So that's an issue too. Anyways, I'll quit whining, but that's— it's been just a year that brought up way more questions than answers for me.
I, I hope learn a little bit about it. I'd like to hear more about the FIS distribution too. Nice, thanks.
Quickly before you respond, we do have a couple people listening online. And so unless we're using the microphones, they won't hear very well. So if you could respond, that'd be great.
Yeah, I don't, I don't understand it. The, the most of the Canadian fish is marketed fresh into the U.S., you know, I mean, a little bit into Vancouver, a little bit back east, but all the east from Denver west, uh, east is, is getting East Coast fish and Norway fish still. Seems like. A lot of the fish we used to fly east doesn't go east anymore. It's up and down the West Coast.
And, you know, the, the, the— I think the U.S. mafia is a little stronger than the Canadian mafia, and there's a little more competition up there. But they constantly use your fish. Oh, sorry, the price dropped $2 a pound. The market's just flooded with, uh, with it, with a West Coast opener. And I'm like, Maybe, maybe not, but it's a lever for them to drop it down.
You know, Seattle's full of fish, they're offering fish out of blah, blah, blah. We hear that BS all the time too. So it's kind of a strange shenanigan. But I mean, a lot of times when you got the big prices, a couple of the buyers in Vancouver went down there and fought for it. But we all got problems with less buyers now than we used to, less competition.
Competition. Just to follow up question on that, a couple of years ago, particularly through the processor advisory board, there was discussion and highlighting of a lot of Atlantic halibut coming this way. Is that pretty much ceased? It sounds like it has from your description. Atlantic halibut coming this direction versus Pacific halibut going that direction.
Well, that's a phenomenon. I mean, I don't think that's the new the last couple years. I think it's evolved up over over the last 5 years that, you know, the East Coast, Canadian East Coast quota is going up every year significantly. And, and that fish is well marketed. I mean, we used to— first it took out like Boston and took out Chicago, and now it's taken out, you know, Denver and, and Las Vegas a little bit.
And some of the, you know, it's, it's, it's common west. And maybe it's just a lever, it's easier, you know. So sometimes these buyers, like, there's way less buyers now. Maybe it's easier for them to pay their fishermen less there than it is here. It's easier for the buyers to pay Washington, Oregon guys less than it is in BC.
I don't think the leases in BC push the buyer's price up much. You know, the buyer just tries to gauge how little you'll fish for and then go out and fight over quota. You know, 2 or 5 years ago, we were fishing— what, you got to push it all the way down to $2 and You know, then $2 delta between, you know, we don't care what the lease is. I think the leases were around $8.50 this year, plus or minus. And I mean, that's up quite a bit, but it followed the market up quite a bit.
So, you know, the fishermen on BC are fishing for $3, $4, and, you know, some of them are going, oh well, at least it's not $2. And we're all going, yeah, but we're leaving $8 on the table here. You know, it's a big problem and we're, we're struggling with how to deal with that. But I don't think it— maybe it pushes the buyers to market better than just steal them like they do down here.
Again, more questions than answers. I'm sorry, I don't have a good answer for you. I had an old man moment. I, I— it was 12 for us down here, so I just checked the fish ticket. So that's not as big a disparity between the two.
So yeah, yeah, it was 12 for— or yeah. I'm just curious, what about— have you noticed any trends in terms of the, the people that are leasing you the fish? Have, have you had any success in getting their number down? Because I think there's been a lot more of that in the U.S., at least in Alaska, over the last 10 years. Used to be pretty common that if someone was leasing their fish to you they were going to take 50, maybe even 60% off the top.
And I think it took enough people just saying, oh yeah, why don't you find someone else to fish it then, because I don't want to do it. You know, I'd rather go home than go out and make a bunch of money for you. And I think that there, most of the people that are leasing fish, you know, they can't find that, that 50% off the top number anymore, at least for halibut. Black Cod's gone a similar way, but it's even more in the boat's favor. Than the leaser's favorite.
But have you noticed any of that? Oh, for sure. You know, black cod's more in the boat's favor in Canada too, because there's not that many. It's a smaller club in Canada as well. But on the halibut, um, we've got a real issue.
Like, each boat in Canada is allowed to fish a block, and a block is 1% of the TAC. So a block this year was 35,000 pounds. So you got a bunch of guys running around trying to catch 35,000 pounds, and you get, you get pushed into these different fisheries. You know, the prawn season's good, there's not much salmon's good. Sometimes guys will fish more— there's more guys looking for halibut quota than other years.
And as some of these other fisheries kind of decline, it's pushing more people into trying to push maybe fisheries that they might not typically focus on a bit. Plus we've got In Canada, there's this Pikfii groups, which is the First Nations groups that are funded by the government to buy quotas. So if I'm trying to buy quota, I'm competing with the government and they've got kind of this thing like, "Oh, let's buy. I've got $300,000." Like they're getting tens of millions of dollars and it's difficult. Fundamentally, you can agree with it, Functionally, it's difficult because you'll— they'll say, okay, I've got— let's buy a geoduck license.
Oh, I can't find one. Oh, let's buy an urchin license. Oh, I can't buy one. Well, let's— and they work their way down what their favorite thing is. Right now they like halibut, and then they'll work them away.
And I think maybe black cod and salmon and herring license are kind of lower on their priority. But if I don't spend it on something, I'm not going to get it back. So if I want to buy 10,000 pounds of halibut right now, it's, it's $1.3 million, $130 a pound. So I'm really— to buy halibut for me, 10,000 pounds cost me $1.3 million. I can catch it in one day.
What do you do for the rest of the year, you know? And, and it's, it's challenging. So So what do we do? The buyers go out and fight for leases and try and figure out if they can trick some idiot like me to go fish it for fuck all, you know. I mean, that's, that's what they do.
And they're like, hmm, I think I can get $14 a pound for this, so maybe, maybe Bruce will go fish for, you know, maybe I can push that lease up to 11. The buyers are leasing the quota. I can't I can't put out $400,000 to lease a block of halibut for my boat this year, so the buyers put it out. So then they're fighting over it. And you got buyers that are really good at marketing, but they don't have a good lease trap line.
So you get a really good price from them, but you gotta— they have to pay a high lease because they can't get the attention, you know. And then some people have some strong traditional— we used to have that sort of a leasing pool, if you will, that You know, Joel gives me his license every year and I'm always competitive and we got a bit of this going on. So those lease pools are atrophying as the First Nations buy more and more of it and it's moving quota around. So maybe we're fighting over 60% as much quota as we used to. That's pushing the lines up.
And anyway, so it's— you're kind of in the squeezer right now for some reason. Maybe what we're running out of now is guys that'll go out on a boat and catch fish. We've got captains now that go out and fish 4 or 5 blocks of fish for 4 or 5 different boats because this year a block, when it first went quota, a block was 120,000 pounds. So that's quite a bit. This year was 35,000 pounds.
You go out and fish 35,000 pounds of halibut, you get in there, you're lucky you get in a week and get in, you know. So you go through all this rigmarole and you work for nothing and you're paying for fuel and you're working around weather and you're working around whales and you're fighting for the leases to go make fuck all and you only catch £35,000 and that's your season over. It's a challenge for sure. It's certainly not something that becomes the focal point of your year, you know. Anyways, that's a long-winded answer.
I hope it helps. That's what we're dealing with.
We do have two RAB members online. No, no, it's good. Angus, if you could go through your season update and then we'll move on to Scott. Yeah, can you hear me okay? Yeah, no worries.
Okay, perfect. Yeah, we had a great season. I mean, we're doing a little different style than we've traditionally done. We're dual hailed and fishing sablefish and taking our halibut kind of as bycatch, but we could usually get, you know, the 6,000 pounds we needed in a day or two. And yeah, it was, we spent a lot more time kind of on the Vancouver Island side of things just to try and cut down on fuel.
We like to deliver into Port Hardy. And so, you know, it was, we weren't necessarily targeting the highest density places. On a note, yeah, Triangle Island again this year, the water was really, really cold, like 4 or 5 degrees colder than normal, which yeah, I found, was, was interesting. But yeah, but really no complaints and lots of small fish around, which I was really encouraged to see. And, um, you know, I keep in touch with about 25 other fishermen, and the reports I had were all really positive.
Um, the Hecate Straits was on fire from some people I heard, best fishing they'd seen in years. Um, I think dogfish in the latter part of the season on the West side of Haida Gwaii is problematic. And yeah, people are having to wade through those despite our apparent dogfish crisis, which is kind of manufactured. I do have a little info on that in terms of, yeah, the surveys that they take the data from isn't actually, you know, one of them's from our hard bottom longline survey, which isn't really intended to catch dogfish. And the others from, I think it's a shrimp survey.
So it's, yeah, we're not real pleased with the science going on there. And we're not sort of following DFO's story that I think rather than these things being depleted or fished out, they've changed. And why wouldn't they? Climate change is a thing and ocean conditions change and they're a hypermobile species. But yeah, overall, the reports I heard from the fishermen I'm in touch with and and my buyer were, you know, yeah, fishing was really good and consequently kōraka being very difficult to find, especially in the latter part of the season.
Yeah, any questions? I'll mute myself now.
How does that compare for you, Bruce, in terms of 2B?
Is that pretty comparable to some of the aspects that you've just recited? Yeah, it's, it's a, it's a good snapshot. You see a little bit more effort focused on the west coast of Vancouver Island. I think we're worried about fuel and, and, you know, there's historically there's 4 or 5 spots, if you will, that a majority of the fleet tries to kind of focus on, get on the highway and avoid the bycatch. But you see a lot more guys doing what Angus did there.
Trying to focus on black cod and using halibut, just metering out your halibut. You know, you bring in 5,000 or 10,000 pounds fresh, you're going to get the top of that market hopefully, you know, and that helps cover off your lease better than bringing in a 30,000-pound trip. Yeah, no, Angus is a good fisherman and he's a good communicator and he talks to a lot of people. He knows what's going on out there. For sure.
There's no other follow-up questions. Scott. Yeah, Scott, can you hear me? Yes, Norris. Good.
Scott from Quinault Indian Nation. We fish in Area 2A. We are one of 13 treaty tribes. In the past, the way our fishery has been structured is we usually have a derby fishery out front, and that's usually about 55 hours. All you can catch, and after that a restricted fishery for anywhere from 500 up to a couple thousand pounds per trip per boat, and then followed up by a big huge mop-up fishery, either unrestricted or restricted depending on how much fish is left.
This past season, the tribes got together beforehand and decided they wanted to try something new, and the way the season was structured was it was a restricted fishery throughout the entire season, 5,000 pounds per boat per day. And as they were saying about 2B, you know, we started out slow. Our boats started going out there fishing late April, early May, and there wasn't a lot of halibut on the grounds. They made intermittent trips every now and then, still nothing. And then come June, that's when the halibut started showing up, and that's when they started having great success.
Some things from the coastal tribes further north, The inside tribes inside the Salish Sea, Puget Sound, they were actually caught more fish than they've had in previous years, but they're still very concerned about the state of the population inside the Salish Sea and if it's in a sustainable area. So I'm sure you'll hear more from them coming up at the annual meeting. And I think that's all I've got to report.
So maybe that's an opportunity. Questions on any topic, whether it be from staff as well. If you have particular questions from any of the updates that were provided, might be a good time to ask those.
I'm actually curious, Ian, sorry to put you on the spot, if you have heard anything more about dogfish in particular in 2B and the assessment. Yeah, we've looked into that just a little bit. Definitely no expert on dogfish. As was mentioned, dogfish are kind of an interesting species. They are highly mobile.
They move up and down the coast across national boundaries at will. In fact, there's some tag recoveries that have actually crossed the Pacific. Historically, there was a huge fishery for dogfish around World War II and even in, in beyond. And that the, the understanding is that though they're fairly long-lived and they were fished down pretty far in the middle of last century, history, low in the '60s and '70s, maybe even into the '80s, and then rebounding 30 years ago. And so what, you know, people's baseline may not— may be very dependent on the history of, of where that stock has been.
And I don't actually know in BC where they're— what years they're starting the assessment. And I know on the West Coast they've, they've tried to go all the way back and reconstruct those catches from the middle of the century. That was primarily a liver fishery. They were, they were making, I forget, vitamin A or D, probably knows, out of the livers. A. Yeah.
The, there's been some collaborative work up and down the coast using trawl surveys, which aren't perfect for catching dogfish because dogfish can be schooling in area, you know, up off the bottom and not available necessarily completely to trawls. We did note there was a publication where there was some collaboration looking at West Coast, B.C., and Alaska. They stitched together some trawl survey data and they also used our IPHC longline survey. And we, we do have some concerns with that because they didn't account properly for hook competition, which particularly if they're focusing on a species that tends to aggregate heavily, those are going to be the sets that have the biggest effect of hook competition. We, we actually— I mean, we, we account for hook competition when we calculate all of our indices.
So we do have some concerns about that, and we're doing a little more investigation into whether the trends that they were getting from our data actually seem like they're reasonable if you do correct for hook competition.
But they're a tough species, and like I said, they do actually live quite a long time. So as Bruce mentioned, I think if there are concerns with that assessment, don't wait to get on them, because if it gets in place, they're not—. It's—. They're kind of like yellow— they're not as long-lived as yelloweye, but they're longer-lived than you might think, like 50 to 80 years potentially, so it's— the dynamics probably aren't going to change quickly. So definitely something to watch out for, but we're doing a little more investigation, and we're certainly amenable to helping scientists use our data properly, but we were never consulted on some of the work that was done.
Our data is publicly available, so we didn't have the opportunity to comment and suggest to them that they account for hook competition. So that, that appears to be the weak spot in at least the material that I've seen so far for dogfish.
Maybe we should encourage our— whoever's behind the scenes on this, I wish I knew a little bit more about it— if they're going to use your data, phone and ask about it. It's not like you're going to keep it a secret, right? And, you know, statistics lie, you know, quite easily if you need them to. It's interesting they didn't even ask you. Yeah, I mean, we make our data available and there are organizations that just download it automatically as soon as it becomes available.
So we don't necessarily have a personal contact there. We are always available. We have actually this year added Hook Competition to the data download section. So if somebody's getting our data now, they should actually be getting that because we want them to use it. It's the right way to use longline data.
I mean, the issue basically is if you think about a longline, if you imagine 100 hooks, if you put them down and you bring them back up out and you caught 100 fish on 100 hooks, if there were twice as many fish there, would you have caught more fish? No, you would have caught the same number of fish that you caught, right? So at some point, long lines, what you call saturate— gear saturation— and you can't— your, your catch rate is no longer proportional to the fish that are down there. And so we monitor that. It's part of the reason why we do at least 4 to 8 skates, because we want enough down there that we still have some fishing power left at the end of the set.
And we do occasionally get sets where we're filling most of the hooks. And by filling, I mean we've lost the baits. So baits that come back missing also count as an occupied hook because something ate that bait during the, during the fishing of the hook. But that's partly why we fish as much gear as we did. If we went out and we only put 10 hooks down every time we did a set, well, we'd fill those a lot of the time, and then we'd have no power to detect what was going on with with the population.
So hook competition is a, is a big deal. There have been several different efforts by different groups of scientists to come up with corrections for it, and the one that we use is actually quite consistent with the one that's— the ones that are used in other places. There are different methods to get there, but the basic assumption is that everything's competing for those hooks, and you need to have some measure at the end of the set of how many— how much fishing power you had left after after the catch that you got. So it is, it is definitely an important component, and we highly encourage people that are using our data to account for oak competition. I think everybody here knows that you get, especially around the full moon, you get dogfish up in the water column.
We've all been places where you're getting dogfish on every hook, and you know there's halibut under there, and they love squid, right? And the fish isn't— hooks aren't even getting to to the bottom, you pound on the dogfish for a couple days, and then you get the fish, right? I mean, we— I think most people have done that in the past. And how do you quantify that as a stock assessment, or for, for either species, is super challenging. It really is.
And we rely on having enough sets where we don't fully saturate the gear. So if the gear— if 100% of those hooks are taken up, we can't really correct for it. But as long as we have some fishing power left, we can make that correction. So that's really why we try to get enough skates in the water, that that's a pretty rare occurrence when we actually have, you know, close to zero baits back. I don't—.
Ray would know if we have any true zeros, but most of the time, even when we're in a place where we're catching a lot of dogfish, or sometimes sublegal halibut, or, you know, there are other— there are other— there are other species that can fill up the hooks, but we almost always have a little bit of fishing power left to be able to estimate what that correction should be.
I don't know if this is helpful or not, but you know, charter fishing— I don't know what it's like around Homer, but I was mentioning 3A, the dogfish is so bad that as you let the line down, you know, lead's going down as fast as you can get it to the bottom, and we're fishing 300 feet. And when you get to about 200 feet, you— it starts either one, it just goes slack because they bite the line. They bite— there's so many fish down there that you— the whole, the whole leader is gone. It's, it's bitten off and there's no lead. There's nothing there.
And you can also feel it hitting the backs of fish, which you've mentioned, people mentioned before. And then when you're reeling up, if you do have a lead and you got a halibut by chance, you'll have several 5, 6, 7 dogfish following at 300 feet up from the bottom, and they've taken bites, so many bites out of the halibut, the halibut's 50, sometimes 50% gone. So there's no way of knowing at certain times whether— I mean, there could be tons of halibut at the bottom, but you would never know because it's never going to get down to the bottom. And that's something we observe in real time all the time in the, the very lowest part of 3A, just on the northern side of Cross Sound over the past 10 years, or no, I say 5, 6 years. It's been pretty, pretty horrible.
And again, we don't, we don't even go there hardly, maybe 3 times a year, 4 times a year now, because I mean, this year has been better, but past few years, like every time I go there, I see the same story. It's dogfish and or there just aren't any halibut there. But I don't know how you account for competition. I don't even know what the formula would look like. I can't even imagine it.
Well, I think that can be pretty frustrating if you're on a charter and, you know, you're at a traditionally, let's say, a pretty good spot. Yakutat Valley is pretty really good in 3A, for instance, but that's also where I've seen more dogfish than anywhere else. But you have to fish that spot. So are there any halibut there? You don't know, you just went through dogfish.
Well, if I do a day of dogfish there, I'm going to run 30 miles, I'm gonna go somewhere else. And then if I got dogfish there, which I've had that happen— I was on one side of the valley and now I'm on the other— I'm going to run another 30 miles until I get out of dogfish, because I'm not just going to sit there over and over again because I don't have that much to catch. I just want to find a place where there isn't anything. But on the charters, obviously you could get some really crappy luck, and then you could get a survey back that says there's no fish in 3A, which would be a bummer. So that's what happened when we did Yakutat a few years ago.
Yeah, 10 miles and there's more dogfish.
You got to shake everyone too.
Yeah.
Hey, sorry to interject. I've got my hand raised. I'm not sure whether you can see it. No, go ahead. Yeah, I was just curious.
I think it was maybe Per who I was talking to about this last year at RAB, like for us, the behavior of the dogfish kind of changed around 2012, 2013, where we'd start to see them a lot more here in the fall. But, you know, he said it seemed about that time that they really started showing up in Alaska. I think he mentioned Yakutat or in that area. And I'm just wondering whether that's the experience of anyone else on the RAB on the commercial side or whether I'm way off base there.
I fish Yakutat Valley every single year for my 3A, and there's always been dogfish there. But 3 years, for whatever— 3 years ago, for whatever reason, I didn't catch a single one in 3 days of fishing. And then the next year I had 10,000 pounds of dogfish one day, I moved, and then I had about 6,000 pounds the next day, and then I moved. And then I had nothing. It's just kind of, I don't know, dumb luck for me is my experience, whether or not they're there.
Gotcha. Idiosyncratic. Fair enough. Thank you. Uh, we'll see them longlining black cod, um, off of Oregon.
We'll see them more in the fall. Um, almost—. You can almost count on it. Um, we haven't seen them yet this year, which is interesting, but, um Mostly they'll show up in the fall and you'll see very few before that.
Any final questions or comments in this section?
Not seeing any, then it's 10:31. It's a good time to take a 15-minute break and we'll come back and we'll jump into Okay, we're going to jump into agenda item 5 at this point, and this is where we step through all of the research and monitoring activities the Secretary has been undertaking over the last, last year since previous RAB. Provided more as reference is Paper 05, which is the 5-year program of integrated research and monitoring that was adopted or implemented in March of this year. I'm not going to go through that in detail. It's really just there as a reference document, but it's structured exactly how we have the agenda items 5.1 and 5.2 on the screen.
So we're going to step through some research activities, and Dr. Planas and his team are going to lead us through that, and then also our monitoring activities, and specifically if there's any fishery-dependent data, verbal updates. We don't have a paper or a particular presentation for, for that agenda item, but then also the fishery-independent data, and that's where we're going to step through the 2026 fish season update and then also the design and implementation for the coming years. As part of that, just before we jump into it, we're also going to hear from Will about a project that, as we mentioned at the start, he's going to work upon. And Basia, you wanted to make a quick comment?
Just a quick update under the fishery-dependent data. We'll just provide a presentation on one of the RABs' requests on sand fleas prevalence. Thanks very much. Yes. And so if you cast your mind back, as one of those actions from the last meeting, you specifically asked the Secretary to undertake some research.
So we appreciate that. Okay, well, with that said, Will, you have the floor.
It says you're a presenter, so you should be able to— yeah, check, but I'll just stop sharing from here. I think—.
There we go. Try it now.
Perfect. All right, there we are. All right, um, yeah, thank you to Dr. Wilson, Dr. Panas, for giving us the time. We won't take too much time here. So for those who do not know me or Anne, I'm a graduate student at the University of Washington School of Marine Affairs.
Me, under Dr. Bedreau, have been for the past year or so have been undertaking this project about characterizing the role of participatory science in Pacific halibut fisheries management. Yeah, I'm just going to get right into it. So what we see in fisheries management throughout the US and Canada is that there's increasing number of collaboration between fishers and scientists. And in a lot of research and a lot of literature, these have been commonly attested to as beneficial for the science and beneficial for participants in the fishery as well, not just from a scientific standpoint, but also a relational standpoint between various management agencies and the fishing community. But the underlying question when we look at all of these collaborations is how successful actually are they?
Are they doing anything tangible for the science? Are they doing any tangible— anything tangible for participants? So that's kind of the goal of our research here, is that we're looking into the MSAB, as well as the WRAP here today, processes and analyzing the role of participants. Through this research, we hope to synthesize participant perspectives on various things such as benefits, costs of participation, strengths of the process, and other personal perspectives and opinions on it. And then Among aggregating all of those perspectives, we're looking to identify various opportunities to improve collaborative research here at the IPHC.
And to do this, we are taking an interview approach in that, for those who have, who know or have participated already, we're doing a number of interviews with the MSAB, the other board, as well as the RAB members here to gather various perspectives on the activities and outcomes of these scientific advisory boards and bodies. We're looking to hear— we've been trying to investigate various perspectives from all over the— what IPH considers the halibut community. So things like people like fishers, managers, scientists, other industry members and representatives. We're looking to hear from them and see what does this process, in this case the RAB, what does that mean for them and what, what costs does it entail and how do they benefit and other questions like that. And from those interviews, we did what is effectively a qualitative analysis of interviews with a framework focusing on participation.
Basically what that means is we're investigating the text, we're investigating what people said and looking for salient themes that are apparent across multiple people and kind of what they see, in this case, is the value or other aspects of the RAP. And so this research has been going on since, I believe, about August of last year. And so in that time, we've done quite a bit, but I just want to share some preliminary results today. This project is by no means done, but yeah, just share some preliminary results. Thus far, we've interviewed a total of 16 folks, 12 of which represent the MSAB and 4 of the RAB.
In terms of kind of where people are calling in from, we have a pretty healthy diversity, but of course, a bit more US-focused, US-dominated in terms of the people who are willing to talk to us. As for kind of who our sample is thus far, we have kind of a healthy mix of different sectors and different areas. This pie chart here just represents what people kind of put them down, put themselves down as for when they kind of sign up for these meetings. But some additional notes of the people we've talked to, about 6 of 16 we've interviewed are active halibut fishers. And people we found often carry multiple identities.
So for example, we've had people who are scientists, but they fish for halibut in the past. Or maybe that's a hobby of theirs. So there's a lot of different— these groups that we see here are not hard and cut different sectors, in that people often wear different hats and represent different things at different times in different settings.
So when we look at— when I looked at kind of what we asked about the interview and kind of got based on the responses we got, we developed a framework to look at the different aspects of why people are participating, what are the features of it. And we've kind of developed this different framework of various aspects. So things like participant ID, who are they, accessibility of the meetings, what's accessible and what's not about the meetings, value, technical considerations with things like data collection, modeling, relationality, how is these— how do these meetings influence your relationship the IPHC as well as with each other as well, because we understand this is quite a diverse group from all over the coast, all the different sectors. For the sake of brevity, we're going to go over only one of these, uh, different aspects, which is value. And when we think about value, it's— we didn't want to impress on people we interviewed what we thought value should be for participating in the RAB or the MSAB or the Halibut Process in general.
No audio detected at 1:23:00
We wanted to hear from them. What do they find valuable and important to being part of this process? And so we've kind of divided, kind of found 3 different kind of big groups of value, first of which is relationships, second of which is kind of influence and information with the HALU process, and third is scientific improvement. And I'm just going to go over a few select quotes from some folks we talked to from both the MSAB and the RAB, kind of highlighting some of these salient themes of value and different types of value. So first, when it comes to relationships, we find that participating in these boards has been really beneficial for the various kinds of relationships people have, not just with the IPHC or with the management necessarily, but also with with each other.
So I'll just read this quote here from a commercial fisher out in Alaska. I love the science and having a deeper understanding of the science of fisheries management. I also really like having fishermen involved in the process, being able to translate the science for our fishermen, but also bringing the perspective of people on the water into decision-making. And I think that's, that's as we've seen today with the roundtable, which is a really core component of the RAP, that kind of local knowledge has really come through, and that contribution is really valuable, not just for the management but also for people, people contributing. We then look at, found something on influence and information, and this is a bit more, I would say, political in some ways, in the sense that people are here to gain an understanding of what goes on in the halibut process, not just all of the different sciences in the RAP, but also a broader look into the IPHC in general as kind of this management apparatus.
So this quote by a fishery scientist out in Washington said, "I can say that for the Research Advisory Board, I really like participating in the process because we get a chance to listen to what the Commission is planning on doing. They can really delve into it and we can ask a lot of questions." So it's really about learning for and kind of educating themselves in kind of what is the halibut process doing so that's not so much of a black box and it's not so much of a confusing and uncertain endeavor. And this last point, scientific value, improving not just the process but also the outcomes of the— of not just the RAP but the halibut process as a whole. This quote by commercial fisherman in Alaska is, "I think that by requiring the science to be that much more transparent and not act arrogant, it leads not only to better science, but also it rightly shifts some of the responsibility for that projecting and decision-making off the scientists and onto the policymakers." So it's not just scientific benefit where we have all these different, say, with the modeling or data collection, but also how does that translate into management decisions, management outcomes. And that kind of transition between science and management with the Commission in particular has really come through as a point of interest.
It's kind of where this is going. As I mentioned, this process, this research has been going for about a year now. We're looking to have more interviews, and I'll go into that in a little bit, as well as analysis of the interviews that we already have. We also intend to follow up with preliminary results with participants, like I am doing right now for those who have participated in this process. And then, um, I'm doing this research as part of my master's thesis at University of Washington, so there is a lot of manuscript writing and hopefully, fingers crossed, eventual publication of this research, uh, later down the line.
I anticipate probably mid-next year. And, uh, going back to my first point on interviews, as you might have seen from the earlier pie chart, we only have, uh, MSAB members make up the majority of the people we've talked to, and that's been great and very insightful for that board. But the final gap in data that we have right now is BRAB members. So if you would like to be part of this process, if you're interested in participating in an interview or just talking to me or Anne, who's in the back over there, about kind of your relationship with the halibut process, your relationship with the RAB, how this experience has been for you, please talk to us anytime today. Give us a call, email, whatever works best for you.
We are happy to accommodate. And I would just like to say to wrap up, I'm really grateful for the support that the Commission has given for this research, as well as a lot of the members of the of the RAB and MSAP who've been very enthusiastic and very insightful and have taught me and Anne things about halibut fisheries that have been invaluable to this research. So I just want to give a quick thanks to everyone who's participated thus far, and thanks for the opportunity to share this with all of you today. Thank you. And do we have time for a couple questions, or?
Yeah. Yeah. Thanks very much, William. That was very interesting. Anybody from the board would have any comments or questions for William?
Yeah, Ian. Sorry, I'm not on the board, but I do have a question for you. It's really interesting stuff. I'm looking forward to see what you find. I'm wondering, in doing the background, have you found other examples of places where people participating directly in the fishery have access to informing the research planning for that fishery?
I can't think of an example right off the top of my head, but there's been plenty. It's kind of the thing about participatory science is that there's no two processes that look alike. And I think with even between the RAB and the MSAP, these are very different boards with very different processes. That's pretty— that's come pretty apparent. And so what that actually looks like, it really depends.
Like, for example, would Some people would consider the— I don't know if Anne has a specific example, but the testimony and public comment systems of the North Pacific Council, for example, would that be considered participatory? Some people would say yes, some people would say no. It really depends on how participatory you want to look at. But as far as like this specific where you have a group of knowledgeable and knowledgeable folks out in the water, I can't think of anything on top of my head, but maybe Anne can. But I would say that when I did the literature review, actually what's interesting is that a lot of these processes that we see actually come from water rights and water disputes and water allocation.
So that is— that partially informed my literature review. And it would be— it's kind of interesting that there's some parallels with that and what's here on the RAV and what's here in other fishery systems.
Hi everyone. Yeah, I agree with everything you said, William, and I also think that one of the things that got me interested in this is that this could be a model for other management bodies. I know a lot of you are involved in different levels of fisheries management, And from what we've learned so far, there's a lot of strength in this process and in the MSAB that could be sort of transportable to other management systems.
Bruce, I think you had a— did you have a question? Yeah. I don't know if this interfaces perfectly with what you're doing, but I mean, as far as communicating between IPHC and the real world.
All the boards that we're on right now, we're struggling to get young people to engage and to come to these meetings, you know, and we finally get some of the young guys in there and they are just overwhelmed by all the science data and what the charts mean and what MSBC means and all that stuff. They're completely intimidated by it. They sit there at a meeting I still don't understand all of it in these meetings. Even if we had a precursor in the annual meeting where we just had, you know, Glossary 101, I mean, there is a huge gap. These young guys come in, it is so intimidating.
I'm still intimidated to ask dumb questions. And these guys come in, they spend about halfway in a meeting, their eyes roll back in their head, they walk out of there and never come back. And it is really hard to engage these people. And it's like talking to an advanced computer guy where he's talking about mega, giga, jiga, giga. You guys talk a language, and so the nomenclature is so familiar and so part of everyday life.
These guys have never heard one bit of that, and they don't understand any of the charts. They don't understand any of the tables, and they just think, well, I hope all these old guys are figuring it out and representing me well because I don't get it. And, and we have a huge gap, you know. There's a, there's a, there's a guys in BC, there's a, the Young Fishermen's whatever it's called guild or something. And do you know what the cutoff to get in the Young Fishermen's Guild is?
55. Okay, that's ridiculous, you know, but Anyways, there's a, there's a massive disconnect between the young people that don't understand the nomenclature of the science of what we're doing here, and they would love to learn more about it but scared to ask. Yeah, thank you, Bruce. You raise a really interesting, a really excellent point, and that's something we've actually come across a lot, not just from younger folks but also older folks kind of reflecting on their experience. And, you know, like we often, like especially in the MSAB when it comes to MSE, that's not especially on the US side, that's not as familiar for a lot of folks.
And even the language of the IPHC too, with kind of— it's very much different from even if you're very knowledgeable about the US system or the DFO process, it might— it does take some time to kind of adjust to the IPHC language. And I think one interesting thing we're thinking about is even from older folks who are still kind of— some of them are still kind of struggling with these things. How do you, how do you bridge that gap, especially for a new member? How do you introduce them to all these concepts? I mean, there's ample amount of literature and a lot of like, a lot of things you can read online about these things, but that can only go so far for a lot of people, young or old, and that these things do take time.
The question is, how can you— what's the best way to bring up, bring people up to speed or keep people engaged? Because you have a year between these RAB meetings How do you keep people— how do you keep these things kind of fresh in people's minds? And I think we've heard from a number of people kind of different ideas on how to address that, at least in this board, if not beyond. So, really excellent point, Bruce. Thank you for bringing that up.
So, I work for the University of Alaska Southeast in Sitka, and one of the things— we've talked about this a lot— and one of the things we're we've been doing for the past 10 or so years is we run this Fisheries Policy Practicum class. It's an undergraduate-level class, and we work with dual enrollment high school students as well.
And each year we rotate between taking students to the subsistence board, the Board of Fish Council meetings, and it's It's the idea is sort of to address that. We bring kids to meetings and we teach them about the process, how those policy entities work, how people get on those entities and boards, and then they, we have them like follow some of the proposals through the process. They, they, we bring them to the meetings, we have them testify, just at least introduce themselves, or as instructors will introduce them and say that we're there. We've had like overwhelmingly positive feedback from that. From council members, from SSC members, from Alaska Board of Fish, and from subsistence board, to the point where there's now youth non-voting seats on the federal subsistence board because of a lot of these policy classes we've been running.
There's another co-instructor that teaches a lot of them out of Sitka, Heather Bauscher, and she's been really active in getting students to those meetings. So Maybe if we could get some, you know, a lot more of that participation. It does, because the kids come back from it and they're like really excited about the fact that they understand. Now we don't cover a lot of the acronyms and stuff as much as we probably should. I mean, we go through acronyms, but there's so many different ones.
It really like, but what's nice is that we're there, we're all together there for like 3 or 4 days. We meet with some at times, like we'll know people on the council or the AP or something or the board. Of fish, and we'll have them sneak away our research advisory, the regional advisory councils, and we'll pull them away to meet with the kids and kind of talk to them about what they're hearing about and break things down. And I think that's like maybe a step in the right direction, but we could be doing more of that.
I'd just like to comment on what Bruce was saying. I remember feeling pretty overwhelmed when I got involved in the process. I was battling, wondering if my opinion was really worth sharing when I had maybe 1 year of experience running a boat, someone else had 50. So you're already kind of dealing with that, wondering, you know, am I going to feel foolish saying this? Turns out everybody already knows that and I'm just coming up with this idea.
There's that. And then there's the fact that the jargon can be difficult to keep up with if it's your first time. If you miss when they explain that acronym at the very beginning of the paper, it's a scientific paper, so they wanna— if they used every acronym, if they spelled out every acronym every single time, the paper would be huge. So, but if you miss it, now you're wondering, crap, you know, I remember seeing that yesterday and now they're only using this acronym over and over and over again. And you guys do have a glossary, and I've actually brought this up before, but sometimes for whatever reason, I can find something really closely related to what we're talking about, but not the way it's being used in that paper.
So now you're like, well, I don't want to be the one guy that doesn't know what we're talking about. I think I'll just keep my mouth shut. But yeah, it's— that is a barrier as well. As far as accessibility, this is an incredibly accessible science because you guys publish everything on your website, but it can be difficult to come up to speed in terms of understanding what the words mean.
Um, it's a question about the project. I don't know if you covered it or not, but, um, I think, uh, I'm, I'm just thinking about other bodies like kind of like the RAB, I guess, that are, that are focused on educating people, um, in the U.S. Probably Canada could use something like this, but, uh, we have Marine Resource Education Program, which is great for educating fishermen and getting them up to speed on the science and things, but the amount of time and work it takes for agencies, commissions like the IPHC, and just volunteers to go into it. It's, it's a lot of work, and maybe at some point there's diminishing returns for agencies. And I'm wondering if your work's gonna get— is that gonna be part of what you're looking at?
Is, is where, where is the value for groups like the IPHC in participating? And is there— are you going to have any information about like the tradeoffs of running groups like the MSAP? Yeah, we've heard a number of different things about different types of costs. So for some people it's, you know, financial costs to go to all these meetings. Some people it's time, and that not just the time being here and getting here, but also the time out of meeting to kind of read all the things, read all the literature, to kind of get up to speed.
And, you know, a lot for— especially for a lot of folks here who are out fishing for half the year, do— is that something that you really have, really have the time for if you're, if you're, you're busy with your occupation, your business? Is that something that is accessible to you? Is that something that you have the opportunity to do? So I think there— yeah, there we look at kind of different costs, different reasons why people can and can't participate or participate in person versus online. There's a lot of different trade-offs that people talk about, but I think for the, for the most part, people want to be here.
People who we talk to want to be here, be part of this process. It's just even on the administrative side with, you know, cost of the budget and time for the IPHC to say, you know, develop a more layman document for members to kind of, as a kind of educational piece. Is that something that the Commission has the time or resources to invest in? And that's, yeah, that's kind of, I don't know if that answers your question, but there is a lot of trade-offs both on kind of the personal side but as well as the systematic and administrative side as to how can we best help people with the resources we have. So that's kind of, yeah, there's, yeah.
I think you're probably trying to get us to move along, right? But yeah, and just on that note, the, one of the things that universities can do and, and, you know, in our program having students who are interested in this is help to provide those supports. So William is going to be graduating, but there are more students in our program who are really interested in helping with that translational communication piece of it. And so if there's ideas that come out of this about, you know, onboarding and like what kinds of documents would be helpful for people coming into this new, then we can actually help develop those. And so I'm hoping that this is a continuing collaboration with all of you and with IPUC.
And we're here if you want to do an interview with us today. We're ready.
And I understand you'll also be at the function this evening, potentially. Yeah. That's also a good time. Yes, just real quickly, I think the, the low-hanging fruit and the missing point here is, is— and I think you're on track real well on the interview process— but I think that something that has to be the elephant in the room for a lot of us old guys is if I have to go online to find the information, I'm not going to do that. And if you come to my boat in the middle of a halibut season or a salmon fishery, I'm going to be less inclined to be interviewed than I am in December when I'm sitting back drinking a cup of coffee wishing I was fishing.
Um, so I think your timing of your interviews is, it should be, you're probably looking at that, but if you aren't, and the availability to kind of the low-hanging fruit for us old guys is if you gimme a piece of paper, if it's in my helm when I'm traveling for 8 hours, I'm probably gonna read that and look at it, but I'm not gonna be able to get online to answer any questions or or participate in any program. So it's almost like we have to get away from these things because so much of— and you can't do anything without your phone, right? If I feel sorry for an old person, hey, sign up on the internet. Well, they don't know how to do that. And I got guys I fish with that don't even know how to text.
So, um, third grade is as hard as 4 years of our lives. So anyway, just for input for you, I think you're Yeah, thanks, Kevin. Um, just really quick to address that. Yeah, first of all, um, timing has been a big thing. That's kind of the reason why you look at the pie chart of people we talked to, we've talked to a lot of government folks so far because those people, at least I did a lot of my interviews during the summer, uh, that's when all y'all are out fishing.
So, um, that's when it was more accessible. But as we kind of, as kind of the year winds down, season winds down, I'm hoping, we're hoping to hear from more fisher folk who have a bit more bandwidth right now.
As to physical media, yeah, I totally understand. I'm starting to realize that now too. I can't read things on the screen without getting sidetracked or distracted, so I definitely see the value of physical media. It's just a question of, you know, how do we get that to people in kind of what format too. Yeah, I'll just chime in, just two quick things.
First, I would encourage you to consider this evening, maybe right at the start of the function, not at the end, is potentially line up a couple of interviews to add to the data you have. And then second of all, and quite excitingly, we've been starting to develop a whole range of AI tools that would potentially assist with this type of information synthesis and communication. And it's our hope that a lot of the information that you have talked about and you value that's on the IPHC website that we share can be reduced down into a very digestible format. And so you can expect to see a lot more of that over hopefully the coming months, but certainly over the coming years, so that it's a lot more digestible. Um, just that.
Yeah, I just had, um, be a comment for, uh, William. Maybe you want to share, um, you know, the length, the type of interviews that you're conducting, some very brief details so that people are aware of what's entailed with an interview of this nature. Yeah, so typically we've been doing these interviews online, but if we have people here, that'd be great to do it in person too. These are kind of semi-structured interviews. They ask about your, not just your experience with Halibut, but also your experience with and perspectives on, in this case, the RAP.
They usually take about an hour, although in person we can We can be flexible with however much time you have or feel like you can speak to. So we're no more than an hour, but we can be flexible as to the exact timing of how much you want to spend talking about the Halibut process.
Yeah, and these are informal interviews. We're going to ask some questions, but we're not sticking to a strict interview guide or interview list of questions. Figure out how to have conversations and discussions about things, um, however you really want to take it. Um, so yeah, we really appreciate if you, um, if you consider a bit of your time either later today or this evening, um, to talk to us if you're so inclined. Hey, this is Scott online.
Go ahead, Scott. Yes, I've participated in one of the email, uh, interviews and it was pretty smooth. Uh, they, you know, they prompted me with couple questions, and it was basically like we were having a conversation. All in all, I thought it was really good, and, uh, it was, uh, you know, the, the information that we conveyed was, I think, is meaningful, and I'm, I'm glad I took part in it.
Yeah, thank you, thank you for your vote of confidence, Scott.
Bruce, here's a little look at what you're dealing with in some quadrants. My, my dad's an old halibut head, and I was talking to one of his old buddies, Halibut Head, and he goes, Bruce, what is app? That's his technological thing. And I said, well, it's a little hard to explain, Carson. And he says, well, he was talking about my dad, I'm pretty sure Mike Hale doesn't use app.
I'm like, well, actually he does use app, you know, but this is the technological grasp of some of the people you're gonna be dealing with. There. So I think in person is probably— you can try and batch up a few people in one place and move around a little bit and do that on some of these guys and actually talk to them because you have to know what app is, right? So yeah, that's been, that's been a, a point. You know, we've been doing a lot of these over Zoom, uh, for the sake of recording, but we're— we've also accommodated for, um, people over the phone as well.
If that's more accessible. But if we have people in person here, that's even better.
Any more questions or comments? If not, let's move on. And if the secretary can bring up the presentation, that would be— Presentation 5.1.
No audio detected at 1:49:00
No audio detected at 1:49:20
Okay. Well, we're happy to provide you with a report on some of the activities that we've been doing over the last few years in terms of biological and ecosystem science. You know, with what we just discussed, you know, if there's any any concepts that are not clear, please raise your hand and let's discuss them as we go. Don't wait until the end to clarify some of the issues that may not be clear enough from our side. So what we're going to do is we're going to just give you a brief update on mostly 4 projects that we've been working on in this last year, and they encompass 4 of the 5 main research areas that are contemplated in that research and monitoring plan that IPHC has currently.
The first one is a research area entitled migration and population dynamics. And in this area, I'm just going to mention a couple of things, but I'm going to focus on probably the newest aspect that is a new project for us. I don't think this was mentioned in the last RAB meeting last year, and it's the development of an alternative method for aging. So you will know that traditionally we've been aging otoliths by the typical break 'em bake method, in which, you know, we count the otolith rings and then we determine the age of the individual based on the hard structure, the otolith. This is a method that that relies on genetic samples that can be taken from a fish that's still alive.
So it's a— I'll describe that in a minute. I'm not going to provide a whole lot of details because this project is underway, but it's worth mentioning. The second area, and this is probably one of the areas where we've done most progress this last year, is our work on the reproductive biology. Biology, basically revising female maturity schedules. And we've done quite a bit of work over the last 4 years in revising, you know, the age at which females start to mature.
We have some new data. That new data has been incorporated into the stock assessments back in 2025, and it's continuing, and it's been an important an important input into stock assessment. And I'll also mention the plant studies that we're preparing for estimating fecundity. So that work has not started yet, but you'll see that we've been collecting over the last 4 years the type of samples that are suitable for estimating fecundity in an accurate manner. The third area, research area, is mortality and survival assessment.
And here we'll discuss the finalized project on estimating discard mortality rates in the recreational fishery and how this may lead into a potential revision of the DMRs that are going to be— that are being applied in that particular fishery in Alaska. And lastly, the area of fishing technology, we're just going to make a mention on the updates on the project that is looking at reducing whale depredation by protecting longline catches by those catch protection device that you've seen already. So let me just go through the first area. And this complicated size, I just want to— slide— I just want you focus on that red box there. And that's the Part of the research area that we're looking at, population structure, basically.
So population structure was one of the main objectives of our research program for a number of years. That was to determine whether there was a need for separate assessments for certain components of the stock, if there was structure within the population. Because that would lead into a potential revision of structure in future stock assessments. So this project is now completed and the results from this study is that we do not find any genetic diversity among the samples that we had within IPHC conventional waters. So this means that our conclusion from this study and that included samples west in Haida Gwaii, north and south of Haida Gwaii, central Gulf of Alaska, the Portlock region, the Bering Sea, as well as central and western Aleutians, is the— our conclusion is that there is really a single genetic group in IPHC conventional waters.
No audio detected at 1:53:40
And this aligns well with the way that the stock assessment is being conducted as a single stock. So genetically speaking, we cannot really find any different— any signs of differentiation within this stuff.
And current work is really to wrap this, this, this complex study into a peer-reviewed publication.
So moving forward, one of the new— as I mentioned, one of the new projects that we started last year in 2025 was the development of this alternative method for aging. And this is called an epigenetic clock. So this is a way of aging fish based on a genetic sample. And you'll see that our genetic sample there are the fin clips that we routinely collect. But first, what is, what is this epigenetic clock?
You may see this term or terminology show up in the literature a little more often, and even in the news. An epigenetic clock is basically an alternative method of aging using genetics, and it uses non-lethal samples. So one of the most easy accessible genetic sample is a fin clip. These fin clips are routinely used collected in our commercial landings. We do that for sexing.
We started this genetic sexing program back in 2017, and we've been continuing ever since. But we also collect fin clips from all the fish that we encounter in our fish that are being released. So in fact, this would actually be a manner, a way of aging fish that are actually being tagged and released. You don't have to sacrifice the animal, you don't have to extract the otolith. So that's one of the main advantages of this method.
So you can age fish that are still alive.
So this, going into a little bit of detail, an epigenetic clock is a genetic-based clock, but it's not based on the actual gene sequences. It's just based on the methylation patterns of DNA. And methylation is just a chemical modification of the DNA. There's methyl groups that are added on the DNA. There's no change in— required change of sequence.
It's just a chemical transformation of DNA. And the important things to remember is that this DNA methylation pattern, which is a normal process, change predictively with age. So then you can actually identify how age changes related to that methylation pattern. And the other thing to remember is that DNA methylation can be quantified by sequencing. So we can actually measure the amount of DNA methylation and then relate the amount of DNA methylation with specific age.
So for that, really what's required is a good collection of fin clips from fish that are well-aged. And luckily we have extremely good ages at IPHC that support our stock assessment. So we have fin clips from fish that have aged twice so that they are double-checked. So we have a good collection of samples. The collection of samples that we're using for this project were derived from the FIS, and what we've done is we've got 10 double-aged fish from ages 6 to ages 30.
So that brings up to a total of close to 250 samples that we're, you know, processing for this project. So those are fin clips from fish from ages 6 to age 30. And these samples have been already collected. These samples are are spatially distributed. You can't really tell the colors apart, but this is all the dots on that map are the locations where those fin clips were collected from.
So they're representative of the entire stock. And those samples, I'm not going to go into these details, those samples are actually processed for sequencing. So this sequencing part where you actually quantify the level of methylation that part is already done. And this is followed by basically a predictive model that you relate the amount of methylation with the chronological age, and then you can use that as your epigenetic clock. Okay?
No audio detected at 1:59:00
So this is where we are. Yeah, Steve. I feel like a school kid. I just can't help myself here. No, no.
I'm sorry. If you want to sample older halibut, bigger halibut, the Guided Angler Fish Program, you have to clip the fins off each one of these fish to mark them. And they're documented as to the length. Yep. And reported every night, every day.
You know, there's a, have to get it done by midnight that night. And I'm just thinking it might be a great source. I don't know how, I think it'd be as reliable as just any other method other than doing it yourself. So yeah, I want to mention that. Well, I was thinking—.
No, that's the, the idea behind this project is that to make this accessible. And then, you know, fin clips are really easy to collect, they're easy to store. You know, we usually collect them and we cut them and then we stick them on paper. As long as they're dry and they're not wet, those fin clips will last for quite a long time. We have a huge collection.
We have thousands of fin clips that are stored in binders with desiccant packages so that we keep them dry. That's the only thing. So that DNA that you can extract from a fin clip is perfectly good for conducting this type of analysis. I mean, we use the same fin clips for sexing, and we use the same fin clips for the genetic analysis that I showed you, that population structure. Work was done with fin clips that were collected, you know, as recently as 2020 by Lando at the Western Aleutians.
And we also have fin clips dating back from 1999 that were included in that study. Those fin clips are good enough. Yeah, Bruce. Sorry, are you using otoliths? Otoliths for comparison?
Right, those fin clips are from fish that were aged through the traditional method. Do you have a harder time aging older fish?
Or the parameters could be a 50, 60, 70-year-old fish, is that harder than the young ones? You mean through the conventional aging method? Yeah. It does get a little harder, but most of our fish are 30 years or younger. So those ages are actually quite accurate.
As accurate as we can get them. The oldest fish that we've ever aged, I think it was 55 years old.
Could you go back to the map that had the distribution of where the samples came from? Yep. Sorry.
What are your thoughts about how heavy 2C and 2B are and how few are coming from out west? Yeah, this is, you know, the— this is for the development of the method alone, okay? So most of the samples that we have are usually from the best fished areas in the fish, but we wanted to make at least all the different regions slightly representative. Once this method is developed, then one of the validation aspects, which is not incorporated here, this is the is this is the next step, is to really see whether this method that you develop with these samples is applicable to all different areas. So if the method that is heavy on, you know, 2B, 2C, and 3A will work equally for samples that are from 4B when we have, you know, let's say 100 samples from 4B.
So that spatial validation is, is the next step after the development of this method. So, you know, the samples are really just for the development of the method, but then there's going to be a spatial validation, basically determining whether this method works equally well for all samples that come from anywhere, any region, and from any years. Because these samples, as you can see, were collected from 2021 to 2024. One of the things that we want to validate is, Well, is this method going to be good for aging samples that are collected this year in 2026? Or was this method good enough for aging samples that were collected in 2019?
So this is part of the validation that will be the next step after the development of the method.
I got one more question about the genetics thing. I was talking with a fisherman down in Monterey last week, and he said that the halibut they get down there are different than the ones they get in BC and Alaska. Is there a genetic variation down there? I mean, there could be also, it could be California halibut, which is a completely different species. Oh, well, that's what I was asking.
You said in all the IPHC areas, California is also an IPHC area. No, California halibut is, in California and south of California, but that's a completely different species. Doesn't hybridize with the Pacific halibut that we know, but maybe they are talking about—. That's what he was—. The California halibut.
I guess so. That's all right. But when you said they're all the same genome, yeah, that's Pacific halibut, you know. And, you know, unfortunately for that study, we did not have samples from 2A. Because those samples were collected from spawning populations and we did not have samples, winter samples, from spawning fish in 2A.
This is something that we've actually been trying to determine, whether they're spawning in 2A so that we could collect samples. But yeah, those samples are from Pacific halibut at the time of spawning. Yeah.
Yeah, Brian. I realize you're saying that they're all the same species, but, um, just— I've always just been curious, you know, the further west you go, typically the larger the sex organs are and the easier they come out. Um, you guys are aware of that, right? What's the—. Well, you'll hear about this, uh, from, uh, Colin in a little bit, uh, in a little bit.
But, um, yeah, I mean, it's obviously— it's obviously the same species. We cannot tell genetically apart a fish from 4B, then a fish from 2B with high confidence. That's one of the things, one of the unfortunate findings.
We hope that through genetics we could actually determine the origin of the fish like you do in salmon. This is not possible with Pacific halibut. The level of certainty of where those fish come from is not high enough to assign a fish to a particular responding group. But we do find some, you know, we call, you know, life history differences between fish in 4B. Reproductively speaking, we find females at more advanced stages of ovarian development.
What you say, larger ovaries, eggs at a more advanced stage than anywhere So one of our suspicions is that, you know, maturity does not— the time of maturity does not happen exactly the same time everywhere. And we find that in the, in the West, particularly in 4B and 4A, fish are starting to mature earlier than in other places. And I think Collin has some data to show that. Yeah.
I was curious, like, in the future, is the goal to move completely away from traditional otolith aging? I just, I know otolith aging is pretty time and labor intensive, and is this method a little, a little less so, sequencing? You know, this is one of several methods. In fact, you know, Basia has been working on for the last few years on artificial intelligence-based method for aging. So we're developing at the same time two different alternative methods for aging.
This is not a— it's not a replacement for aging, but, but the idea is to complement it. We're always going to be needing real ages based on the traditional aging method, but we're finding, you know, how this alternative methods for aging could complement the traditional aging. This one has the advantage that you don't need to sacrifice a fish. The AI-based aging models are based on otolith images. You still have to extract the otolith.
The advantage of this method is that this is biological. What you're looking at is something that happens biologically. This change in DNA is a biological process, and you may learn something else about the biology of the fish by looking at this process. For instance, senescence, how long can halibut live, the rate of aging, which could be a response to environmental stress. So there's a potential window of looking into a little more into the biology of Pacific halibut by using this method as well.
But this is not to— this is not designed really to replace completely the autolith-based aging at all.
Any other questions about this part?
So yeah, I'll just conclude that, uh, that basically, um, we're, uh, complete We're done with the sequencing, so all that DNA methylation analysis is done. And now we're developing the clock, which is really just the relationship between the chronological age and the predicted age based on this DNA methylation process.
So hopefully, the next year we'll be able to tell you whether this method actually works for aging, and hopefully whether that this method works for aging fish from different areas and from different years.
So with that, we'll move on to the next section, and I'll let Colin speak to that. So go ahead, Colin.
Yeah, thanks a lot. I'll just make a quick comment about what Brian just mentioned regarding larger gonads. Out in 4B. Actually, some of the samples that you collected in 2025 FIS out in 4B, I just recently was able to complete those, looking at them histologically, histology under the microscope. I'm not going to be presenting any of that data today, but we did have a couple of samples, what was it, late July, early August when you caught them.
They were, females were already in what's called the perio-ovulatory phase, which is a fully hydrated you can actually see fully hydrated cells, and those were late July, early August, which could potentially be an indicator of earlier spawning out west. We obviously need a larger sample size, but that's just something to, to take note of. So we definitely are seeing more fully developed females out west than compared to like the Gulf or Southeast Alaska. Chignik, Alaska. So just something to keep in mind.
Yeah, so this section is kind of broken down into two components. The first is our revision of our maturity estimates for the annual stock assessment. And then the second component is what we're doing to gear up for looking at fecundity estimation as well. So I presented a lot of this information last year at the RAB, but this is just kind of a kind of an update on, on what's ultimately been put into the assessment last year in 2025. So what we did was we had 3 years of histological data from 2022 to 2024, and those same fish that also got a histology sample also were visually estimated on the fish, looking at their gonads in the field, And so what we were doing is we were able to estimate a new maturity ogive, or curve, that you see here on the figure on the right.
And this just shows what those look like comparing across each other. So the red line was our previous maturity estimate for the stock assessment, and this data was dated back to, I think, 2002 and 2003, and the curve was developed in 2007. '06, So it was almost a 20-year-old curve, but something to keep in mind was that data was only from 2B and 3A fish females, and they estimated an A50, or age at 50% maturity, at 11.6 years old. So our more recent data histologically actually shifted that curve to the left to 9.8 years, but then our visual estimates estimated it at 10.3. So both the histology and the visual shifted to earlier maturing females, but the histology shifted a little bit farther left.
So with that new information, if you recall, we do have 4 stages of visual, and these are just pictures depicting what those are. So stage 1 in the top left there is an a fully immature female, bottom left is a developing female where you can like physically see the eggs in the gonad. Stage 3 is actual like basically precursor to spawning where the actual eggs are basically falling off of the gonad tissue, and then Stage 4 is what we call resting or regression of a fish that probably is a previous spawner and is looking to redevelop into the next annual reproductive cycle. And these are some pictures of what those might look like under the microscope. So you can see in the top left, you have very small immature cells.
No audio detected at 2:13:20
Bottom left is what we would call the vitellogenic stage. So those are just progressing into lipids, oil droplets or lipids that are progressing towards the center of the, of the oocyte. And then stage 3 is an example of what I just described earlier as perioovulatory. So that's a fully hydrated oocyte that is basically ready to be expelled into the water column. And then stage 4, I don't have a thing here, but you can look and see the differences between stage 4 and stage 1.
So Stage 4, there you can actually see post-ovulatory follicles, which is basically what, what is what remains after Stage 3 is expelled out of the gonad. And so that's how you can see a lot of the differences between an immature and a mature fish and why sometimes that staging in the field visually can be hard to classify depending on when that sample is taken.
Um, but then using the, the difference between the curves, um, histologically and visually, we were able to, uh, create a calibration factor between the two, uh, methodologies. And so what you see here on the figure on the right is it's broken down by region, and if the, if the line is moving upwards, it means that there's been a shift in the calibration towards, uh, more older maturing fish and a shift down is younger maturing fish, and you can see that we've created a calibration regionally. And so then building off of this calibration, what we did was, what we wanted to do was create a historical time series of maturity estimates, and our time series goes back all the way to 2002, and the reason why we chose that particular year was because that was when the IPHC changed from mostly surface age reading to the break-and-bake method, which provides a more precise and accurate and unbiased estimate of aging. And as you, as you can see here, so the darker lines are more earlier in the time series and the lighter colors are more recent years. And rather than kind of looking you can see that there's been two different shifts in this time series.
No audio detected at 2:15:20
So more in the early 2000s, you can see that there was a shift to older maturing females, or, or a shift to the right of the curves. But then in more recent years, there's been a, a more dramatic shift to younger maturing females.
And to look at this a little bit more closely, we created this figure, which is our A50 values by year, or A50 once again is age at 50% maturity, or what we predict to be females reaching 50% of the population at what age are they mature. And you can see here the— so if you just look at the raw visual data without the calibration, that is your solid black line, or sorry, the dotted line. And then using the calibration of of the visual data from the histology, that's the, the solid black line. And you can see here, once again, you can see that there's those two distinct temporal shifts in the time series. So from about 2002 to 2016, we saw a slight increase annually in it with an increase in the A50 value from a little over 11 years to almost 12 years.
Old. And then from 2016 to about 2022, there was a sharp decrease, um, in the A50 value of, of mature females, going down almost to about 9.7 years old. So there was about almost a 2.5-year-old drop from 2016 to 2022. And then in more recent years, it's, it's sort of leveled off. And so we've recently had some discussions with our scientific review board, and one thing that we're going to be looking at here more closely is potentially what biological as well as environmental variables could be potentially driving these differences that we see in our 850 values over time.
One thing to note is, you know, that there has been some warm blob events in the Gulf, in the North Pacific and potentially these large regime shifts in temperature, ocean temperatures could be driving some of these. Also potentially looking at changes in size at age and whether or not that impacts maturity of females. And these are definitely things we'll be looking at more closely.
And so in conclusion for this section, what we did was we, with all of those curves, we then averaged our time series from 2002 to 2024, creating an average calibrated coast-wide O Drive. And so that's what you see here in the green line on the figure on the right. And so once again, our previous estimate was 11.6 for A50. Our new estimate that went into the 2025 stock assessment was an A50 of 11.0, So there has been a slight shift to the left, indicating about a 0.6-year-old average of mature females, a little bit younger than our previous estimate. We also truncated this curve to zero at age 7.
No audio detected at 2:19:20
So basically any female less than the age of 7, we consider them all to be immature. The reason for that is during this time series, no histological data showed any female that was mature under the age of 7. And our previous estimate actually truncated at age 8, but we do actually see, have seen some females that are mature at the age of 7.
Yeah, go ahead. And years ago in meetings, we spoke about the efficiency of the reproductiveness of the older fish compared to what's the premium spawner, for lack of better words, in the halibut? And does this research have any concerns, I guess, as far as you're showing a halibut younger at maturity opposed to— I think where our discussions in the past have correct me, the other board members, was that the old, old halibut, that the large, large halibut weren't as efficient in the reproductiveness and that their ovulation or the amount of eggs they're producing declines as they get older. Am I correct on that? Well, this is a good precursor to the next section of my presentation, which is the fecundity side of things.
No audio detected at 2:20:40
And I was just— not to interrupt you, because I'll just— one other follow-up question is, is there concern on the— is there an overlap between the research advisory board meetings and the regulatory meetings where this information may be going to structure seasons or, or poundage or tonnage?
That I don't—.
Yeah. Well, I mean, the direct overlap is just through the stock assessment. So we did this research and that informed us about the maturity schedule. And then we included that in the stock assessment. We did have a small effect in the stock assessment.
Go ahead, Norris. Is there a relationship to this, to the gender mix, male-female ratio? No, so we, current maturity estimates for the stock assessment are based solely on females. The current assumption right now is there are enough males in the population to provide output for reproduction. I guess what I was asking is, is the female maturity lower when the male ratio is higher or lower?
Is there any relationship to when it's apply to what the ratio is? That's a very good question. I don't think we actually have looked at that. So that's something we can take note of. That is a good point.
One other thing we've seen in the last, probably longer than you think, 10 or 15 years is the weighted age has gone way down on halibut.
We use the old charts from the IPHC from the '70s and '80s, those fish aren't even close to the weights of those lengths that we used to use. And maybe the female productivity has gone down, the fish just aren't healthy, right? The halibut just aren't as healthy as they used to be. That's my conclusion. Do you see anything like that?
Yeah, I mean, that's— it's the biggest question out there right now for us, especially when it comes to the assessment, right? So we We don't know if larger females proportionally produce more reproductive output compared to smaller ones. Right now, the assumption is that there's what's called an isometric relationship, or— and I'll touch on this in a few slides in a minute— but that basically if you take a 30-kilogram female how it would take 15 2-kilogram females to match that same output of that female, right? We don't know if that bigger female is disproportionately producing more. And that's, that's really the, the big question that we're trying to answer next.
No audio detected at 2:24:00
Now that we have the maturity estimates updated, which is from a curve that was almost 20 years old, now that's been officially updated. Now the next driver is really to determining whether or not reproductive output has changed through time and also whether or not the biggest females are producing disproportionately more than the smaller females. We, we don't know that.
Yeah, so just to wrap this part up is that this was all inputted into the 2025 stock assessment last year, and I'll move on to fecundity estimation. Now. So we started collecting samples for fecundity in 2023 on the FIS, and we've been doing so ever since. So just so everybody gets an idea of what, what, what do we mean by fecundity? So fecundity is the number of eggs an individual female produces per spawning event or, or season.
And so we know that Pacific halibut have an annual reproductive cycle, and so they develop their oocytes, and then expel eggs into the water column one time a year.
So why is this, why is fecundity important? Well, because it really is the true measure of reproductive potential. So what is an individual female producing? Like, what is their actual output based on body size, potentially age, and whether or not that differs through time or potentially regionally as well.
So just to kind of give an example here of what, of what I've talked about already is basically the driving question that we're trying to answer is, is female Pacific halibut fecundity proportional to body weight? And there's two different ways to look at this. So our current assumption is basically an isometric scaling, or it basically follows the same length-weight curve. So if you look at body, body size to length of a, of a female Pacific halibut. It's got basically what they would consider to be kind of a cubic function.
It's not just a straight line. So basically what we're trying to answer is whether or not that reproductive output for those bigger females is even more disproportionately more than, than it would be for just the regular length-weight curve, which is what the assumption is currently in the stock assessment. So this example on the right was actually a paper that was published in Science looking at Atlantic cod. And so if you look at the isometric scaling, basically what I said earlier was they were, they were assuming that basically 15 2-kilogram females is the same reproductive output as one 30-kilogram female. But what they found was actually what they call a hyperallometric scaling, which is actually that one 30-kilogram female was actually producing the same reproductive output as 37 2-kilogram Atlantic cod.
And so that's the same type of question that we're trying to answer here with Pacific halibut.
And to do that, the method that we're going to be using is what's called the autodiometric fecundity estimation method, And not to go too much into this diagram, we've been doing some collaboration with people at the Northeast Fishery Science Center that have done this work on a lot of flatfish species in the northeast, in the northeast U.S. And so basically what this is, and this is stuff we've been doing on the fish, is that you take a fresh ovary weight at sea, you preserve a subsample of that in formalin, It gets brought back to the lab. Then you take a weighed subsample from the preserved sample and you basically using image analysis on the computer, you can look at mean oocyte, mean oocyte diameter for that subsample. And then that's what that figure is on the right. That's what's called an autodiametric curve. Curve.
It allows you to build an X, the X-axis is mean oocyte diameter and the Y-axis is oocyte density. And so previous studies here at the IPHC have already looked at different oocyte staging and the size of Pacific halibut eggs. And so you see here on the figure, this was published in 2020 by Fish at all, you can see as the oocyte develops, the eggs, you know, obviously are getting bigger and bigger, and once you reach about the beginning of vitellogenesis, or what we consider to be a mature female, the egg is about 500 microns, or about half a millimeter, and eggs can actually get all the way up to about 2,000 microns, or 2 millimeters in size, so Pacific halibut actually have pretty large eggs. In order to build this curve, we need a large distribution of egg sizes to be able to build out this autodiametric curve. And then once we have the samples in place, we can then extrapolate that information out to potential annual fecundity for each individual female that we collect the data from, which is basically the total number of oocytes that they would spawn for that any given year.
And then once we have that information, the next thing is to be able to collect samples across a large size or age of Pacific halibut to look at, to be able to see whether or not those larger females are producing more egg output. And then this is what that might look like with hypothetical modeling, so this is actually a tape this is a paper taken from, I believe, summer flounder in the Northwest Atlantic Ocean. And what they did was they looked at different regional scaling to look at potential annual fecundity of summer flounder. And this is the similar type of modeling that we can do here at the IPHC, looking at our— across our 4 biological regions to see whether or not fecundity could differ regionally as well as coastwide.
And then really the most important aspect of this methodology is once we are able to build out the autodiametric curve, it will allow us to process samples a lot quicker because you'll be able to just look at, you'll be able to just take a subsample of about 250 to 300 oocytes per, per preserved subsample in formalin, and then be able to extrapolate out to oocyte density, um, using the curve that you built. And you'll be able to process samples a lot faster in the lab.
Um, so as I mentioned earlier, we started collecting, uh, fecundity samples on the FIS starting in 2023. Um, that was just in biological region 3, or basically the central and western Gulf of Alaska. Uh, then in 2024, we expanded that out to Regions 2 and 4. Um, in 2025, we were able to collect, uh, fecundity samples across all 4 biological regions, which is the only year we've been able to do that. Um, and then this year, we collected samples in Regions 2, 3, and 4.
Um, and then I'll also make note that the last 3 years, we've also been conducting a special collection of fecundity samples that were taken outside of the FIS timeline. And the reason why we wanted to do that was we wanted to make sure that we were collecting later developing females so that we get those later stage development to be able to build out the autodiometric curve properly and then be able to look at potential anaphycosity across all different types of oocyte development. As well. And so 2024 and 2025, that was targeted in biological region 2, or Northern 2B, and then this year we collected those samples in region 2 as well as in the Central Gulf of Alaska as well. And a lot of those samples were collected from about mid-September through late October, which gives us a really good distribution of sample collection through time.
So now we have kind of these samples that were basically from June through October, which is really good because that'll cover most of the oocyte development that we need. And for this entire time, if you just look at the females that were classified visually as girl 2s or G2s, which are the developing females, which are the ones we need to basically do fecundity estimation. We have over 1,600 samples in the lab, so I have a lot of work cut out for me in the coming years. So it'll be fun, and we'll be getting going on these early next year to build out this autodiametric curve. And just to give you some— a quick look at what the, the size and age distribution of the those samples look like.
No audio detected at 2:33:40
We see here we have ages that run anywhere from about 7 years old, and I think the oldest female that we caught for fecundity was 38 years old. So there's a really wide distribution of age, and then also weight as well. We've, we've caught some females that weigh like 90 kilograms, so there's a large distribution of weight and size for females as well.
And just to kind of do a, a quick snapshot rather than— one thing that we can look at is what's called gonad somatic index, or GSI. And what GSI is, is the ratio of gonad weight to total body weight of the female. And this potentially can be used as a proxy for reproductive output. In, in females. And what you see here on the right is 4 graphs that are depicted based on 4 different developmental stages for females.
So the top left is VTG1, or early vitellogenesis. Top right is the next stage in vitellogenesis, VTG2. So as you can see in the pictures, the oil globules start moving towards the center of the oocyte. And then the bottom left is VTG3, or late vitellogenesis. And then the one on the bottom right is what's called germinal vesicle migration.
And you can see in that picture that the nuclei of the cell is starting to move towards the edge, and that's when the female starts hydrating the cell, getting ready for expel into the water column. And basically what we did here was what we wanted to look at to see whether or not, as you progress through the female developmental cycle, whether or not GSI is basically disproportionately increasing as you get bigger, bigger females. And you can see from the data, we're not seeing that with GSI. So this is, this is an early look at potentially an indication of no hyperallemetric a relationship with weight because you would assume that especially as you get into the later ones on the bottom like VTG3 and GVM, when you get to like a 50 or 60 kilogram female, you would assume that the GSI would be disproportionately bigger because you would think that if it's going to be producing more eggs, that gonad has to be getting bigger and bigger and bigger as the body size of that female is getting bigger. And we're just not seeing that in the data that we have.
So this is just kind of an early snapshot of what, what we think might be to come for our fecundity estimation, but we won't really know until we actually start producing some data.
So just quickly, in conclusion, we have new calibrated coast-wide maturity ojives from 2002 to 2024. We saw an increase in the A50 from 2002 to 2016. Then there was a sharp decline from 2017 to 2022. And the IPHC Secretariat is going to be looking into the potential drivers of those temporal changes and also be able to see whether or not those, those changes continue as we collect more years and more years of data. And in regards to fecundity, overall, we collected the type of ovarian samples, the large range in oocyte development needed, required for the development of our autodiametric method.
And then once that method is developed, this ultimately will be applied to ask the question, is female Pacific halibut fecundity proportionally or disproportionately proportionally related to body weight.
And currently what we see is that GSI versus weight shows no indication of hyperallometric relationship. And I think that's all I have. Go ahead, Brian.
When you say you got 1,645 samples in the lab, how long does it take you to process? Like, let's say, What can you get done in a day or in a month? I'm just curious, like, how much work that is. Yeah, it's, it's a lot. The reality is we are there.
I would say a large, a good number of those 1,600 females probably won't actually end up being used because the reality is, is that you have to be able to separate the eggs from the gonad wall. Or the tissue even within the sample preserved in the lab. And a lot of these, uh, G2 females that they are classified in the field, they're still not developed far enough along to be able to do that in the lab. And so those samples won't be able to be used. Um, rough estimations, what I have heard from people that have done this methodology, and they have a lot of experience doing it, like decades of doing this methodology, they can do— if they do it like all day and that's all they're doing, they can probably do like 10 to 15 samples a day.
So it, it is a lot of work. But the nice thing, though, is that once the autodiametric curve is built, the samples, it— the samples can be produced a lot faster because it you don't have to reweigh the samples, you don't have to reweigh the subsample to get, you know, the density of oocytes per gram of tissue that, that's already built into the curve. So now you can literally just take— you can basically just separate the cells, take images, and then use imaging analysis that does really quick math to be able to calculate an average mean oocyte diameter per, per each sample. And then you'll be able to extrapolate that out to oocyte density. It's way faster.
Yeah, go ahead. Uh, the other question is, um, and this might be prohibitive, you might not be able to do this because of— you said you started this whole process in 2002, at least this curve you were showing, because you maybe switched methodologies or sampling methods or something changed at that point. Um, So I don't know if you can go back further, but I think it would be really interesting to see if this change that we saw from 2002 to 2016 that went to the right, and now it's coming back to the left, it'd be really interesting to see if it was an oscillatory pattern over a much longer time period. Is it— is that something where you can look back at previous data and go, yeah, it looks like maybe it was, or the method in which you use to get that data in the past just prohibits you from making any sort of good estimate on that.
Um, I guess a couple of things, and then Ian might have a comment too. Um, we definitely could go back. The, the IPHC has visual maturity data that dates back decades, at least '50s and '60s, because there's been previous work done on that. Um, Now, obviously, the, the ages that are used for that, a lot of that was, um, I don't know what a point it was that they historically were using length. Yeah, yeah, pre-1991 they were using, um, size of otoliths, um, as a predictor of age, um, and we found out that that's not obviously not accurate.
Um, so we could definitely produce a a larger historical time series, but it wouldn't— the aging data wouldn't be as accurate or precise. And also, we wouldn't— we would probably have— be less inclined to use a calibration with the histology data also going back that far in time. One thing that we don't know is whether or not that calibration changes through time. We're currently assuming that it doesn't. So we'd be less inclined to probably use that, but we definitely have data that we could— we could create maturity curves dating back to like the '50s and '60s if we wanted to, but it wouldn't be as accurate information as we have now.
Just one last thing. What Bruce brought up, I thought was really interesting. Like if the ratio between males and females in a certain population, like you got trends up there for 4B and other areas, it would be really, really interesting to follow that thread. Yeah, that's, it brings up a great point. We do know that the male distribution does differ regionally.
As we know, the the proportion of males is greater out west in 4B, especially our catch on the FIS shows like 70% male, so that incorporating that information could be interesting to see whether or not that changes female maturity.
So when you're building this graph out and stuff, it's mainly The fecundity is the volume of eggs that a fish is producing at a certain age. So is anything in the analysis, is there any way to pinpoint the viability of those eggs? I mean, just because a huge fish is putting out gazillions of eggs, are they as viable as a younger fish's eggs? Yeah, that's a great question. I would say that might be Phase 3.
Of our research here. So, one thing to think about is let's say we don't see hyperallometric relationship or that bigger females are producing more eggs. What if bigger older females are producing higher quality eggs and that their viability is better? That is something that people have looked at before. And, it's something that could be looked at down in the future.
I don't know the specifics, but you can look at potential, like, lipid content of, of the eggs. We have tons of preserved egg specimens now from this fecundity data, so it's definitely something that could should be pursued.
All right, I'm going to move into the next section here. Again, my name is Claude Dykstra, and so the Alberta Commission has been doing a bunch of work on mortality and survival assessment. Most recently, in the early 2020s, we were revisiting using new technology with satellite pop-off tags, revisiting discard mortality in the commercial fleet, the longline fleet, and some of the papers that have been produced on that are listed in with those blue links at the bottom of this slide. Today I'm going to talk about some work that we've been doing to look at discard mortality rates in the charter recreational fishery.
Okay, here we go. So in 2021, we did some field work out of the ports of Sitka and Seward. We used two different hook sizes, 12/0 and 16/0 hooks. These were the result of some survey work that we had done regarding kind of common practices in the charter fishery. We caught a total of 361 fish that were sampled, at the sites shown in the map on the right.
These were done on charter recreational vessels with volunteer fishers. All the fish were tagged. 80 Of the fish out of the Seward sites were tagged with survival pop-up tags. These are electronic tags that are attached to the fish and they measure knockdowns, so the number of times that the fish is moving. And then if they stay on the fish the whole time, they burn a little pin, they go up to the surface, and they broadcast their location and all the data.
And I get an email that says, you know, tag XYZ just came off this fish. I know when it was applied, and we can do the analysis from that.
The majority of fish that were caught and released in this study were all in excellent condition. There was only 11 out of the 361 that were not in excellent. 9 Of those were in what we would call moderate viability and 2 were in poor viability.
So overall, we saw that the 16/0 circle hooks caught larger Pacific halibut, both by length and weight. So that's displayed with the fork length on the upper right. That was a significant relationship. The only hooks that reduced viability were the 12/0 hooks, so those are the smaller hooks, and the biggest contributor there to reduced viability was hook swallowing. So these smaller hooks were more likely to be swallowed, although again, not a large amount of them were.
There was, you know, a small amount out of the whole population that we sampled. We did take blood samples from the fish and looked at stress markers, and longer fight times did result in higher stress, but it was not predictive of fish survival. We saw much lower stress levels than we saw in commercially caught fish that had been on the line for up to 6 hours, and capture depth, temperature exposures, those sorts of things were not predictive of fish survival.
So moving on to survival estimation with the pop-off tags, Again, these were all on excellent viability classification fish. Upper left picture there shows one of those tags. It's about a little bit bigger than your thumb. It has a float with it, a special attachment, and then a computer inside that measures those knockdowns.
And these were all released from the Seward sites. We got 76 back that gave us usable data. Analyzing that data, we found a mortality rate of 1.35%, so the majority of those fish survive, with confidence bounds of between 0 and roughly 4%. This compares to the assumed rate of 3.5% for circle hooks that is currently used when ADF&G is estimating how many fish die due to capture and release.
No audio detected at 2:49:20
So moving on to that management applied discard mortality rates are based on a calculated value, which is the kind of the third row there, and it uses a combination— up to date, it's used a combination of commercially caught discard mortality rates seen in the commercial fishery for Pacific halibut or other marine recreational species, and particularly for non-circle hooks, there's not a lot of information out there on non-circle hooks for halibut, and that amount is 3.5% for the circle hook and 10% for non-circle hooks.
When you take our new 1.35% estimate on excellent viability fish and you calculate it out against the number of fish in each viability category, as well as the different proportions of hooks seen in the fishery, when the, the middle row there was found it, you come out with the new row there that's calculated from this study. And the first number is the calculated rate, and then in the brackets are the 95% confidence intervals. You end up with values that are anywhere from 11 to 22% less than what's currently being used for, or was currently calculated. And then what's actually used in management is the bottom row. So in 2C, for instance, DMR rate of 6% is assumed.
That's accounting for both the ratio of circle hooks to non-circle hooks, as well as to assuming that there's going to be different ratios on that from year to year. There's going to be variability in that, and that there's some level of mortality associated with multiple recaptures, because some of these fish tend to get recaptured.
And so the savings rates there are anywhere from 22% to 40% compared to the calculated management rate. So those are the kind of what the new values are expected to be. This work's being written up and will be put to peer-reviewed journal, and then the various state management agencies will be able to determine how they want to use those numbers. So again, in conclusion, larger hooks catch larger fish. The smaller hooks had more gut swallowing, leading to poor survival outcomes, There's lower stress responses being observed over the shorter duration of capture events in the Rec fishery, higher rates of survival when those fish are handled and released properly, and then the new calculation results in reduction in overall mortality rates, both by the calculated and the actual applied management DMRs.
No audio detected at 2:51:40
I'll stop here because I'm going to move into a different topic area next. So any questions on this particular work?
No? All right. So next, I'm going to move into phishing technology. The IPHC has been involved in various projects involving phishing technology over the years. In particular, I'm going to focus in on using shuttles to reduce depredation in the longline fleet.
Some other work that we've been involved with in recent years has included some work on modified hooks called appendage hooks that have been used to reduce, or attempted to use to reduce yelloweye bycatch or dogfish bycatch, which was a topic earlier today.
There's 3 papers out now on this, on whether they work, on what angle works best, and on what appendage length works best. And so the one that you see as H3 here has an appendage that's 7.6 centimeters long, and it's at a 45-degree angle to the shank of the hook. That has been shown to maintain Pacific halibut catch. While reducing yelloweye bycatch by up to 45%. Those tests were done off Oregon, and they showed reductions in dogfish catch somewhere on the magnitude of 20%, so not as, not as much, but they're still having an effect there.
I'm going to pass this around while I'm talking, but this is an example of an appendage hook. This one's actually at 90 degrees. It wasn't as effective, so picture the hook appendage going out at a 45-degree angle more towards the point. This blocky device at the front of it is a hook timer, and that was something that we were looking at to see when the fish takes on the gear. It pops out a little magnet that initiates a clock that's inside this device.
I'm passing it around more for view of the appendage hook, but everybody wants to know what that device is because it looks cool. So I'm just going to pass that around so people can take a look at it. It's certainly a relevant topic for those of you who are encountering choke species. And we are interested in doing further tests of those hooks. Particularly, we'd like to see higher levels of yelloweye bycatch, larger specimens of yelloweye, and more higher quantities of dogfish, which sounds like a funny thing to do, but of course, when you go to study these things, you can't find a dogfish, right?
So we are applying for various grants. We just submitted one yesterday in British Columbia, trying to get more replications in areas that have higher quantities of yelloweye and dogfish so we can see how they work. Yeah. When you conduct that sort of study, are you guys planning on selling the fish and keeping the income from the fish, or can you tag along on somebody else's IFQ?
Great question. So the work that we proposed right now that went in yesterday works under a different model because in Canada we're not able to sell the bycatch specimens that way. And so I don't know if we were to get funded, we'd have to look at that. There are situations where we can get exempted fishing permits to go out and try something like that. And because you're still using a hook and not something completely novel to catch the fish, I think it would be be fairly easy to get some sort of experimental permission both from NMFS and from the IPHC to conduct that sort of work on a commercial fishing trip.
I, I was— it was kind of a leading question because I know personally, like, I— Kayla talked to me about the fecundity study this year, and I was like, yeah, come on, come aboard, I don't mind having a scientist on board the boat. But then she was like, well, you know, you'll get 10% of the I was like, oh, okay, no, I'm catching my own fish. If you guys want to come along and do some science, you can have a bunk. That's sort of what I was thinking. But, and I'd be— you'd be happy to come along for my 3A trip, for instance, where I usually have dogfish and some yelloweye.
So that's kind of what I was thinking is if you guys can come aboard, you're welcome to. But as far as me like going out and doing a trip just for this. Like, it just doesn't really— it doesn't pay well enough for me to act. I'd rather go home, you know, at that point in the year typically. No, I appreciate that.
It's certainly a model we could look at and have some discussions about. We've done ride-along work before where we collected specific project data. In this one, we'd have to bring our hooks along with us and, you know, set an extra skate or something that that has that on it, but I think we could discuss that.
So moving back into the—. Oh yeah, excuse me, it's 12:35. I think we should probably break for lunch because lunch is here, and then we'll continue with the rest of the presentation after lunch, if that's okay. That sounds good. I think everybody's hungry.