Whittier City Council Regular Meeting
Alaska News • • 283 min
Articles from this transcript
Whittier council accepts $4.07 million federal grant to design DeLong Dock replacement
Whittier council accepted $4.07 million in federal money, plus about $1 million in city funds, to design a new DeLong Dock.

Whittier council votes 4-2 to hear city manager's chosen mentor after mayor objects
Whittier council voted 4-2 to let city manager Jackie Wilde's chosen mentor keep speaking after Mayor Tom Wagner cut him off during her review.

I call to order the November 17th, 2026 regular meeting of Whittier City Council at 7:09 PM. Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
The United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Before we begin tonight's meeting, please note that digital copies of the packet are available on our website at www.whittieralaska.gov/meetings.
A QR code is provided just outside that door. Open your phone camera to scan the code and access the packet. Madam Clerk, roll call please. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Mrs. Borg.
Here. Mr. Shen. Here. Mr. Macaltao. Here.
Mr. Pinquoch. Here. Mr. Denmark. Here. Mrs. Loan.
Here. Mayor Wagner. Here. You have a quorum.
Okay, citizen comments. Uh, citizens' comments on any agenda item except those scheduled for public hearing are welcome at this time. Those who have signed in will be given the first opportunity to speak. Please note, this is not a time for dialogue. It is a time for you to speak and the council to listen.
Madam Clerk, is anyone signed in for citizen comments at this time?
Yes, first on the list is Mr. Benjamin Durting.
Good evening. Um, my name is Benjamin Durting. I'm a Whittier resident and a BTI homeowner. A couple years ago, the BTI board fired our manager. In much the same way that the council is approaching our manager for the city now.
Project stalled, his replacements didn't know the building history, and we're still in limbo today. Please don't repeat this at the city level where the stakes are much higher. The DeLong Dock replacement, um, is in design, um, and it supports such a large part of our budget. Our well field is being upgraded and the railroad land purchase is in the, in the running. Um, Shotgun Cove Road is being extended and the Buckner Building cleanup is about to start.
None of this happened by accident. Jackie knows where every project stands. She knows our relationships with the railroad. She has a working relationship at the state and federal agencies with Senator Murkowski and Sullivan. For our town, our size, that access is rare.
Um, with Chris, Scott, and Dave, she's leading a team that's finally working well. And I'll be honest, I don't always agree with Jackie. I disagree with the way the city handled leases and the triangle parking, but I didn't always agree with our building manager either. And, um, but I knew he was committed to our building. Jackie is committed to Whittier.
Long-term future and the big picture. She knows what she's doing. A new manager would need months to learn where things stand and years to rebuild those relationships. Grants deadlines don't always wait. Uh, we have someone who knows the history and has the trust of our partners in Juneau and Washington.
Why would you get rid of that now? Thank you.
Next on the list is Natalie Knight.
Hello, my name is Natalie Knight. I am an Alaska resident all my life. I have been living in Whittier since September 20— No, September 2014. Um, I am here to request that people start following codes of conduct, codes of ethics. Um, nepotism needs to come to a stop, and drug and alcohol tests, alcohol consumptions.
The police department sees people who are drinking all the time and driving, and they do not get DUIs or any punishment for their wrongdoing. So I'm here to ask that.
Okay, thank you. Thank you.
No one else has signed in.
Sorry, is there anyone present in the audience that wishes to speak?
Let me rephrase that. Is there anyone present in the audience that wishes to speak on any agenda item at this time? I'm not sure that's on the agenda, Mr. Fleming.
Uh, that speaks on the agenda. Is that what she said? Yeah, you were on the last agenda. Yeah, no, I was just wanting to express my, just my thoughts on things. I mean, I heard the speaker before me express their thoughts, so I thought maybe I could do that.
Just, um, I can give you 2 minutes. Yeah, um, basically, uh, just to go off what the last speaker said, I agree. I think if we all come to communicate more, be willing to pick up the phone when the time comes or the need comes to do that, I think that would allow a community to congel and to look at each other with greater respect and open arms as far as friendship and to move things forward, be it projects or conflicts or whatever it may be. But yeah, I just wanted to express those thoughts, and I look forward to continuing coming to these council meetings and listening in on what the community has in store next. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Fleming. Is there anyone else that wishes to speak?
Good evening, Mayor and members of the council. I am here tonight to address comments made by Councilmember Peter Denmark during October 20th meeting.
On two separate occasions, he referred to recent meetings as a circus, first describing the circus that we have witnessed over the last few weeks, and later referring to the previous week's meeting as a circus meeting.
I found those comments deeply disappointing. My husband and I were amongst the residents who attended that meeting. We were there to create— we weren't there to create a spectacle.
We were there because we care about this community and believe strongly enough in something to stand up and have our voices heard. That meeting was not a circus to us. What troubles me the most is that during the very same October 20th meeting, council discussed ways to encourage our community participation. Yet when residents actually showed up and expressed their opinions, that meeting was described as a circus. How can we encourage our community members to be involved while making them feel like they're being ridiculed?
I understand that people disagree. And I don't expect everyone on this council to share my opinions, but disagreement should never come at the expense of respect. You don't have to agree with us, but you do have a responsibility to represent us, and that includes residents who support the city manager, those who oppose her, and everyone in between. I love this community. My husband and I live here, we work here, and we raise our family here.
Whoo! The decisions made in these chambers affect our lives too. We are the community. I'm not here expecting an apology. I'm trying to— I'm not trying to change anyone's personal opinion, but I'm here because I believe that silence in the face of disrespect only allows it to continue.
I hope this community and council remembers that public participation should be welcomed and not belittled. You were elected to serve this community, not just those who agree with you. You serve all of us, and all of us deserve dignity and respect. Thank you.
Is there anyone else in the audience that wishes to speak?
Good evening, Mr. Mayor, City Councilors, Whittier community and officials. My name is Sean Marks, Whittier resident, Operations Manager at Cliffside Marina. I would just like to take a moment, having reviewed the agenda for tonight, to commend the City Councilors and City Manager on all the work that was done to bring forward the grant programs that we will be learning more about and to commend everybody for all that hard work. And having now had our midterm elections, would encourage City Councilors and the community as a whole to reach out to our elected officials, state and federal partners to continue the great work to continue, uh, bringing grants into Whittier, uh, to make Whittier better. So thank you for all the hard work, and just, uh, hoping and encouraging everybody to reach out to your partners at the state and federal levels, uh, to continue, uh, the good work being done.
Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Marks. Is there anyone else?
Mr. Mayor, may I respond to Aniva's comment? Yes.
Aniva, I would like to apologize for, um, offering offense, um, with the use of my verb, uh, with the use of my, um, uh, but that meeting, uh, did seem, um, to be a political rally that was organized ahead of time. So I would apologize for my verbiage. I did not mean to offer offense to any individual. Thank you.
Okay, moving on. Before we get to the approval of the agenda and consent agenda, I would like to request a motion to move the executive session, uh, to the front of this meeting rather than the rear. I know as sure as I'm sitting here that this meeting is going to be a marathon. We have a lot of things on the agenda, and I want to get through the executive session dealing with the Alaska Railroad and, um, uh, City Manager's evaluation first. If we run out of time we're not running out of time before the executive session.
Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to move the city manager evaluation to another date. Um, in the two prior meetings, I had commented that given the circumstances of the October meetings that were just discussed Um, that the issues that are perceived, the divisiveness that has occurred, is not going to be well served by the pro forma city manager evaluation form that we've been asked to fill out. So, um, I don't see a hurry here. Um, I would like to get to an objective productive city manager evaluation that will be universally beneficial. Um, I think that given the tools we've given to work with, with this evaluation, we're not going to get there.
Thank you. So I would like a motion to postpone the city manager's eval to a future date.
When an appropriate process can be determined.
I need some guidance here. We have two motions on the floor. I didn't catch the first motion. Oh, I just wanted to move the executive session forward so we're not stuck at 10:30 at night, um, arguing about getting new executive session like we always are. Okay, so To address your motion first, there wasn't a second yet.
So I might need an at ease to look up Robert's Rules regarding a motion that hasn't yet been seconded.
Neither of the motions have been seconded, so it might help if somebody would second one of the two motions. How about this? How about I—. Whittier's motion. I was going to withdraw my motion because then Peter's concern can be addressed.
I'm just going to have one more clarifying question regarding your motion, Mr. Denmark. There's two options. You could postpone it indefinitely or postpone it to a date certain. Postponing it indefinitely essentially kills the motion, but it kills the agenda item.
January meeting to allow more appropriate process to be formatted. I'll second that.
Thank you.
Discussion? Mayor, I just have a few questions. So one of the things, if you have— I think, I believe in the past, wasn't your evaluation process something that was determined by council. Is that correct? Yes, and it is also listed in my current contract.
Okay, so I think that's— we just want to make sure if we need to have, for example, you may need— and maybe if you do January, that'll be fine. It may need to come back to council. We'll look at the contract, but it might need to come back to council for council to identify the process, or maybe appoint certain council members to come up with a proposal, you know, it's— so we— it'll just need that. And maybe you weren't anticipating that, Council Member Denmark. I just wanted to raise that piece.
So if you're postponing it to January, that means that by December a proposal needs to come before council on how to conduct— if the evaluation— if it's going to be different, if you have a different process for evaluating. So I just want to make sure that if that's enough time, or if you needed to do February, or if you wanted— I mean, you can use special meetings too. I just wanted to make sure you're having this discussion.
Okay, so I have some questions before we go. Well, I guess it could be in, uh, council discussion, but, uh, I do remember when I put out an email basically wanting to change the formulation on how the evaluation was, the form itself. Um, there was objection, and I'm not saying that it wasn't valid, um, regarding Jackie's contract and when the evaluation had to happen.
Where are we with that if we postpone this? I mean, basically the evaluation's already been done. Um, uh, I need some clarification on this. Um, I think what my proposal and, um, Councilman Denmark's proposal are completely different.
Um, so I need some help here.
And the other thing is, if you, if you're postponing it to January and you're not changing the format of how you're processing through the evaluation, that's one thing. And, and maybe that's a decision you can make in January too. So you can just, obviously you have, you can just postpone it. But I was, I think, Mayor, I was in some ways anticipating that the postponement was to sort of move to the process you proposed in yours, and I just didn't want— if that was the case, I didn't want to miss that. Miss— I want to make sure you guys talked about it.
I'm not going to speak for, uh, Mr. Denmark, but I'll let him talk. That may be the reason, I'm not sure.
To clarify, um, I think the question, um, posed right now is whether or not we're postponing the evaluation to, for lack of a better word, redo it.
What, what is the reason for the postpone— the postponement?
My initial comment was to find a more appropriate format to discuss the perceived issues that are not readily addressed in our current forum that we're being offered.
You know, we can use that forum and get there. I did mine and it's there, but I think that more intelligent conversations can come from a different format rather than a Um, uh, you know, uh, a quantified rating system.
The issues are more nuanced than that.
Mr. Mayor?
Yes, go ahead. Yeah, and another, another thing, our last evaluation, I was part of it, the, a committee of the council members reviewed and, and conglomerated the, the, uh, um, each, each council member's submission. This year it was sent to HR. I don't believe there was any discussion by council about making that change. I think that was done by the administration.
Administration shouldn't be in charge of their own evaluation process. That's why I seconded this.
Okay, um, I'm not going to disagree with that. However, I still think we should move forward with the current evaluation and discuss this in executive session.
Also, I believe that there's probably legal implications due to Jackie's contract.
I don't know what off the top of my head how the provision applies to an evaluation process, but I certainly think it's well within council's authority to come up with its own evaluation process. And so, um, one of the things we can do is look at it. What a lot of communities will do in this situation, I mean, it's somewhat unusual to change gears at this stage, but I think it's within your authority. So what would happen is maybe a motion to instruct the mayor or a council member to work with legal to prepare a proposed review process. That's one thing that you can do, and then you can bring that process back in front of the council.
And council can decide how they want to proceed. I think that's one of the things that, um, your— the city manager was trying to do is just to make sure council is deciding both when and how the evaluation process goes forward. So you've had a pretty standard process that council had approved and developed, and so it's— if you're going to change that, I think that's okay. I just need to look— there's timing— evaluation process is addressed in the contract. So I just need to look at that provision.
I can't pull it up right now, so I just— that's one thing I would want to check. But that, you know, you have—. Well, when I tried to put a stop on this, I was told that it had to go through in November per the city manager's contract. I did not question it. I was not trying to make any more waves that were already flowing out there, so I just went with it.
Right, that your evaluation period— I'm sure the contract says something like the city manager is reviewed in November of each year or something. I'm guessing it says something like that. So, but the council doesn't have an ability to review the city manager anytime, right? And I don't disagree, but that was correct. That was accurate information that you were given.
Also, no single council member, the mayor has the ability to change the process. So the city, the entire evaluation process evaluation process was, was designed to make sure that council went through the process in compliance with the contract, but also in compliance with what council had laid out as the process previously. So if you don't evaluate the city manager and at this meeting, you know, I mean, I guess then evaluating the city manager at a different time. I think the one thing I'd want to check in the contract is the implications if you postpone it, the implications on any sort of salary or other information that is informed by the evaluation. So I mean, we could take a recess, and I can take a look at the contract, and we can decide, or I can kind of move forward on that, and we can, we can address it later.
I just need to get a copy of the contract. Hold up. Okay, so right out of the gate, you know, one of my issues here is moving the evaluation to January. Nothing's changed. We still have the same criteria that we're basing this on.
So if the motion is to come up with a different form of evaluation Okay, that's what I tried to do before, and it wasn't, you know, solely based on my interest. There was other input that did not go over well, and hence we are here now. So what has changed? What is going to change between now and January, I guess, that's going to validate waiting. I, I don't know.
I mean, I guess if the motion was that we are going to sit down and come up with a new form, uh, that would make sense to me. But that was the intention 2 weeks ago, and it absolutely blew up. So I don't, I don't, I don't know how we're moving forward here.
Hi. All right, there we go. Sorry. All right, to come up with a new evaluation process, all of council, even if there's input, and I don't want to, of course, I, I know that there was not enough input to constitute council action because that would be an Open Meetings Act violation, and I know what this council will not do that. So I think that you're right.
If, if you're going to go and change the evaluation process and get council to vote on a different process, that is going to take a little time because you need meetings. You can use special meetings to do that, but given that, if the provision in the contract provides for a November evaluation process. Legally speaking, you're in a better position to go forward with the evaluation process, and if you cannot complete it, then come out and go for a motion, you know, and pass a motion continuing the evaluation process. Okay, I have no, no problem with, with Peter's motion. Okay, um, I just— maybe we should take a recess so you can look at it versus versus— not the right word, but, you know, looking at Jackie's contract.
Either way, it doesn't matter. I think the general consensus is, after the last meeting, there was a comment made by Mr. Denmark that— and this had to do with the, uh, council packet— that he had an issue with, uh, the evaluation process. I respected what he said, and I was trying to work out something to bring to the council at this meeting regarding changes. But I'm going to summarize this and keep it short. I was basically told, oh no, this has to happen in November, you're too late, shame on you.
Here we are. So now we're talking about putting it in January, which completely violates what was originally told to me 2 weeks ago. So I'm very confused about what we're doing here. Um, anyway, yeah, please, uh, please check it out, make sure that we're not, uh, treading on thin water as far as legal. And, uh, we can take a short recess so you can take it, you know, check it.
No audio detected at 29:30
No audio detected at 30:00
No audio detected at 30:30
No audio detected at 32:30
No audio detected at 34:30
No audio detected at 35:00
No audio detected at 37:00
No audio detected at 37:30
I would like to call the meeting back to order at this time.
Mr. Mayor, I'd like to withdraw my motion.
And I am also going to withdraw my motion. We will proceed, um, with the council meeting. Could we confirm with the second that he agrees? I didn't even realize we had a second. Mr. Pinquoch seconded Mr. Denmark's motion.
Mr. Pinquoch, do you agree? I have a question. I have a question for legal. Um, if I understood it correctly, Holly, you said that changing the process would require a council of the whole. This process was changed, I assume, by administration rather than a committee of the council reviewing the applications and come and putting it into a consensus.
If you, you want me to answer that? Yes. Yeah. Uh, back previous to the previous city manager, it was worked out with legal at one point because they also created the legal review. And that was used from that point forward.
It was a joint— like, it was at one point, I think it was that it was like, we don't like this form. We need to be able to, you know, have something behind the scenes or have it calculated. So it's not just one council member being like, you're doing this type thing, because it did happen with the previous city manager. And it was created, and then we've used it since I've been the city manager. Okay.
And that— so if that— I remember that process, I think, in part pulled together a bunch of different communities, or when— and council adopted that process. That's what I thought, that with that's the valuation process council has been using. So I don't— so Councilmember Pincush, if, if that process that has been used has been changed by administration. I think council can, you know, if they don't want to use that, but I think it's consistent. So I wouldn't— I think your process is consistent.
If you want to change the process and change the evaluation process, one thing I— so I was able to look at the provisions in the contract. The council is mandated to conduct a formal annual review prior to adoption of the budget. That's the language. So it doesn't specifically say November, but this is the meeting that would allow you to do that. And so that's one of the— now, but it also says, and just a reminder, and I think Council knows this, we've seen, you know, you can evaluate the city manager whenever you so choose.
And so to the extent Council Member Pincush, you want to develop— and Mayor, you want to develop a different process, I think you can do that later, and you can do that outside the evaluation process and have that apply the upcoming year too, or just at a different evaluation date. The only thing I would say is I would caution council against a continuous and unending evaluation of the city manager. That does not usually afford good governance, right? It do have a start and end to the evaluation process. And if I might follow up, what you had showed me, Holly, was, uh, that the evaluation has to occur before the budget is approved.
So we are Uh, we are relegated to doing, to doing this now. Exactly.
Okay, well, I was unaware that there was a second. I know there was a second on, um, uh, uh, Councilman Denmark's, uh, motion. But anyway, um, who was my second? You did not have a second, so technically the motion dies for lack of second. So at this time, you could entertain a motion to approve the agenda and consent agenda.
Can I please get a motion to approve the agenda and the sec— uh, I'm sorry, the, uh, consent agenda? Mr. Mayor, I'd like to remove item number 11 off of the consent agenda, ordinance, uh, introduction of ordinance 26011. Mr. Denmark, do you make the motion to approve the agenda first? First we have to approve the— make a motion and second it so that we are all on the same page that we are— it's worth discussing. Thing, and then we do the removals of the consent agenda items.
Apologies. So which motion would you like? Are you making a motion to approve the agenda? Sure. Okay, thank you.
I'll second. Thank you. And then I have noted that Mr. Denmark is removing item 11 from the consent agenda.
Okay, motion has been made to— motion has been made and seconded to approve the agenda and consent agenda. Is there any discussion?
Anybody online?
Okay, hearing none, uh, will the clerk please, uh, call the roll? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Voting on the motion to approve the agenda and consent agenda: Mr. Denmark. Yes. Mr. Shen.
Yes. Mrs. Borg. Yes. Mr. Macaltao. Yes.
Mr. Pinquoch. Yes. Mrs. Loan. Yes. Mayor Wagner.
Yes. The motion passes, and tonight's agenda and consent agenda are approved. On tonight's consent agenda is Resolution 2026-055, authorizing participation in the State of Alaska Community Development Block Grant, CDBG program. Resolution 2026-056, authorizing the city manager to accept grant funds in the amount of $4,074,520 from the United States Department of Transportation Maritime Administration Port Infrastructure Development Program for the purpose of planning, designing, and permitting for a port facility to replace the DeLong Dock, appropriating matching funds in the amount of $1,028,640, and authorizing total project spending in the amount of $5,103,160.
Resolution 2026-057, adopting the safety action plan funded by the Safe Streets for All grant, approval of the October 13th, 2026 at 7:00 PM special meeting minutes, approval of the October 13th, 2026 at 7:30 PM special meeting minutes, approval of the October 20th, 2026 regular meeting minutes, and the commissioner appointments of Jeffrey Edwards to Planning and Zoning Commission seat F, Ross Carlson to Planning and Zoning Commission seat G, and Jeffrey Edwards to Porton Harbor Advisory Commission seat B.
I don't know if I skipped over this about the conflict of interest. No, we're good.
Yeah, at this time, does anyone wish to declare conflict of interest in any matter appearing on this agenda?
Okay, hearing none.
Sorry, I'm lost here.
What's up? We're at the presentation and reports section. If you would like, I can, can start that for you, Mayor.
Okay, well, I don't have anything to report in this meeting. Um, Mayor, we need to do presentations. They're the first on the list. Your presentation and reports. We have presentations and appreciation.
Presentations. If you would like, we can take that over. This isn't helping me. Yes, go ahead. Okay, um, first I would like to, um, ask harbormaster Borg to come up and read a citation into the record for a Harbor Assistant of the Year.
Miss Aniba, if you could please come upstairs, up to the dais. Test, test.
She didn't know this was coming, so come on up. Stand beside me. So it gives me great pleasure to be able to do this. We recently had the Alaska Harbor Masters Association Port Administrator meeting in October in Valdez. And, uh, I want to read this.
Miss Regina Aniva Turi Turi is Whittier Harbor's 2026 Employee of the Year. Joining the harbor team a little over a year ago during peak season, she quickly mastered the harbor's financial operations and earned the trust required to manage substantial receipts, sensitive records, and complex financial data. Her sound judgment, initiative, and clear communications have strengthened daily operations over the past year. Aniva led the migration of two major computer systems, MarinaGo and QuickBooks, from an aged desktop platform to the more modern, secure cloud-based platforms. Aniva created a test environment in less than 3 months to safeguard that accuracy between both systems.
She collaborates effectively with technical support, identifies practical improvements, and traced a significant proration discrepancy flagged by auditors, enabling the Harbor to resolve it. Customers constantly commend Aniva's professionalism and clear communication in supervising 2 long-serving employees She respects institutional knowledge, welcomes input, and fosters productive working relationships. She reinforces consistent policies while broadening her expertise in the Title 12 code, PCI compliance, the Whittier Harbor Phase 3 rebuild, and multiple computer system upgrades. Through her dedication, technical expertise, and exceptional customer service and strong leadership, Anita— Aniva has elevated the standard of service at Whittier Harbor. It is a great pride that we recognize Aniva as Whittier Harbor's 2026 Employee of the Year.
A well-deserved honor reflecting her exemplary service and unwavering commitment to the harbor. Thank you.
Thank you. Keep up the good work. And we have one more set of appreciation awards. I would like to have Fire Chief Mathis please come up to present.
As you're aware, on September 14th, we had the fire at Glacier Creek, which took quite a bit of time, about 13.5 hours or so to put out, and I wanted to recognize these gentlemen who were there for the entire timeframe, more or less. So what I have here is the Whittier Fire Department Chief's Award is being presented to recognize members of the department for performance beyond that that is normally expected of a member. This award is proudly presented to each one of these individuals in recognition of your outstanding steadfast efforts during the Glacier Creek Terminal Dock Fire on September 14th, 2026, awarded today. By me. So thank you very much for your, um, dedication to the city of Whittier and to helping out to make sure that this is a safe place to live.
So, and I'll get to see Okay, as I stated earlier, I do not have a mayor's report for this meeting. It's going to have to wait. There's things I need to vet out in executive session before we can talk about them concerning, uh, well, the Alaska Railroad. I thought that was going to happen last meeting, but it didn't, so I'm gonna move on. Um, uh, Vice Mayor Loan, do you have anything?
No audio detected at 55:00
I just have a few things. Excuse me, I'm sorry I can't be there this evening. Um, we have our, um, weekly yoga back for winter for our community health initiative. Um, I requested something— it's on the agenda— for a student representative from the Whittier School, which I will talk about, I guess, a little more in depth later. And then I just wanted to also say, you know, thank you to everyone involved in Friendsgiving.
It was a huge success, um, you know, just to see everybody out all together sharing and at ease with each other and just enjoying each other's company was really great. So I wanted to say thank you to everyone that showed up and everyone that made that happen.
Okay, thank you, Vice Mayor Lumm. Um, City Manager's report. Thank you, Mayor and Council. Uh, we've had a lot going on over the last 6 weeks. Uh, we, as everybody hopefully knows by now, we were awarded a $51 million grant by MARAD for the DeLong Dock replacement.
That's a huge improvement for and movement for the community and even for the state of Alaska at this point. I would like to address the council at this time. I've heard you, I have spoke to some of you individually as meetings have allowed. I, at the October 13th meeting and again at the October 20th meeting, I did address the council and the community I stand by what I've said and what I have done and how I am and how I apply myself to the community. I did also state that I would be willing and able to contact a mentor and ask a mentor to work with myself and even Council to see how we can come to a, you know, common ground and working cohesive relationship.
And I would like to take a moment to introduce you to Tim Dillon. He is on the line, and I would like to have him give you a brief update about who he is. And I had spoke to the mayor at that yesterday about bringing this forward. So, Mr. Dillon, if you wouldn't mind. Good evening.
Can you hear me?
Yes. Perfect. My name is Tim Dillon, and I appreciate having the opportunity to address you all and to see some faces that I actually know and have gotten to know over the years, whether it be people in the audience or people up there on the dais. I'm a semi-retired executive. I'm a past city manager, past president of all the city managers for 2 years.
I was on the AML board, the AML JIA board, the past CEO for the Kenai Peninsula Economic Development District. I've got a master's degree that's a combination of law, accounting, and marketing. I've mentored a variety of city managers around the state, especially in the areas of communication and decision-making, stakeholder management, and conflict resolution. Over the last couple of weeks, I've been reviewing past meeting minutes, and then today City Manager Wilds performance evaluation that I received. I see a variety of things that I can assist with, starting with visiting with the council members and community members to understand specific concerns and positive activities.
We need to remember that communication is a two-way street, but having said that, the manager and staff works for the community and must adjust when needed. If we aren't communicating effectively, the positive things that are happening go unrecognized. When I got to Seldovia as the city manager back in 2008, they had had over 10 city managers in less than 5 years. I quickly realized that the trust had eroded because communication wasn't effective. A lot of times we believe We are communicating, but unfortunately everyone doesn't communicate the same way.
Think of it this way: the city manager is like an orchestra leader. Every one of the different pieces of music, whether it be brass, percussion, strings, woodwinds, they all have a different sheet of music. And that's the way your community is set up. Everybody comes to this with a different sheet of music.
Tim, I'm sorry, um, and I, I, I didn't catch your last name. I, I apologize. Um, Dylan, D-I-L-L-O-N. Okay, Mr. Dillon, um, I was not aware of this presentation. Um, at this point in time, um, I'm just going to say that I think it's inappropriate.
We may invite you into executive session later on, um, and I'm sorry, I mean no offense, but at this point in time, uh, yes, Jackie C. Wilde, the city manager, did inform me. She did give me your name yesterday, but I did not say that we would entertain the city manager picking her own mentor, so Um, please put a pause in it for right now. Thank you. Yes, sir. Thank you.
And I'd like to follow up with a point of order. This is— this conversation should be had as a function of a completed city manager evaluation, not a proactive presentation by the city manager prior to her presentation. And this is the kind of stuff that's going to come up in the review. Why do you keep doing stuff like this? This is not appropriate.
I apologize, and I, um, was just— as I had spoke to the mayor even yesterday and he said, I expect you to follow through with getting a mentor, I figured that this would be a great opportunity to introduce you to someone and, and let you know that I stand by, you know, what I had offered. Um, I apologize, Mr. Dillon. I apologize, Council, and I no longer have a city manager's report.
Go ahead, Victor. Well, you know, like we asked— that Council asked for, um, our city manager to find a mentor or mechanisms for improvement and stuff. And here, okay, we did not ask the city man. We have, we have, we have talked about this. We— and this gentleman here, we're going to have a mentor.
Actually, it was Jackie that—. Hold on, excuse me, let me finish.
So, you know, Miss Wilde has invited this gentleman here to speak, and he has not spoken on anyone's behalf. And I I honestly think that our response here to this gentleman's short presentation quite rude, and I'm a little ashamed to be up here on the dais here with you guys with a response to a guest to our council chambers, whether it's digital or in person. And I would like to hear the rest of his little— his presentation.
Well, unless you make a motion and a second, it's not happening.
I'd like to make a motion that we hear this gentleman out.
A second.
Discussion? I'm all for it after a review, if it is determined that is a matter— if a mentor is appropriate. That has yet to be determined by counsel.
Didn't we ask her? We told her. Yeah, I would say told, not asked. Um, however, it was never stipulated that she would pick her own mentor, and we haven't even made that determination yet. We're— the cart's a bit in front of the horse here, I guess, is the Exactly.
And here we are out in public with our butts hanging out again. Um, this should not have happened. This is entirely inappropriate. And apologies. Um, I, I said we can just— he can come back on board in executive session.
This should not have happened this way. This really upsets me.
We have a motion and a second to hear him.
Any further discussion?
Madam Clerk, call for the vote, please. Voting on the motion to allow Mr. Dillons to complete his presentation. Mrs. Borg. Yes. Mr. Shen?
Yes. Mr. Denmark? Mr. Pinquoch? No. Mr. Macaltao?
Yes. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. Mayor?
No. The motion passes, and Mr. Dillon is allowed to complete his presentation.
I only had a couple more things I was going to say. I apologize.
To assist you, I, I believe I can make the city manager and council comfortable with adjustments, but I promise it won't always be comforting, as in warm and fuzzy. Jackie is taking this development opportunity seriously. And I hope you will support me in continuing to assist. Thank you for your consideration. I apologize that I was off base there, and I look forward to answering your questions at the appropriate time.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Mr. Wagner, would you like the city attorney to give her report?
I do believe, uh, the city manager said you're done with your report. Yes, ma'am. Okay, moving on to the attorney's report.
I have no— I mean, I have a written report that Council has seen, and I can answer questions on that report. I have nothing to add to that report at this time. I do— I mean, I guess one thing I would say is we have had a lot of Council attorney contacts in different— regarding different matters this year. So at some point that might be something that we're going to want to talk about and just make sure that we have it budgeted, or that if we don't have it budgeted, we have a process so that council feels like they are getting what they need from that, from those conversations, but also that those discussions aren't running away with legal fees, right? Because I think there was some We get several inquiries saying, well, what if— what's the access to the city attorney?
And how much is that costing? And what does that look like? And so what I can say is Whittier has the most liberal access to the city attorneys on behalf of council from any of the clients that I have currently or have had in the past. And that's great, you know, if it works and if the dollar amount is is something that the council is comfortable with. Another way to deal with it is to have a, a process that usually goes through the mayor and has sort of a request for council advice or assistance on various projects.
So something to think about. I just want to plant that seed so we can talk about it later, if that's something that council members would like.
Is that it, Holly? Thank you.
Okay, moving on to public hearings.
Um, Madam Clerk, can you read this for me please? If there's no one— yeah, well, either way you can do it. Thank you. Yes, thank you.
Non-code ordinance 2026-007, approving the 2027 operating budget and related revenues, expenditures, expenses, and interfund transfers. Amending the pay scale and appropriating funds.
I'm opening public hearing for non-code ordinance 2026-007 at this time. Madam Clerk, is anyone signed in to speak?
No one is signed in. Is there anyone present who would like to speak at this time on this ordinance?
If there is no further public comment, the public hearing for Non-Code Ordinance 2026-007 is closed at this time.
Is there a motion and second to adopt Non-Code Ordinance, Non-Code Ordinance 2026-007?
So moved. Second.
Motion has been made and seconded to adopt the code 2026-007. Is there any discussion?
Mayor, if I may, just to offer Kudos to all staff involved in preparing the budget for a job well done and another biannual budget that is comprehensible and looks very productive. So thank you to all and any—.
Any further discussion.
Hearing none, Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll? Voting on the motion to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-007, approving the 2027 operating budget and related revenues, expenditures, expenses, and interfund transfers, amending the pay scale and appropriating funds. Mr. Denmark. Yes. Mr. McAlto.
Yes. Mrs. Sloan. Yes. Mr. Pinquoch. Yes.
Mr. Shen. Yes. Mrs. Borg. Yes. Mayor Wagner.
Yes. The motion passes, and Non-Code Ordinance 2026-007 is adopted. Next on the agenda is Non-Code Ordinance 2026-008, approving the 2028 operating budget and related revenues, expenditures, expenses, and interfund transfers, amending the pay scale, and appropriating funds.
I am opening the public hearing for Non-Code Ordinance 2026-008 at this time. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed in? No one has signed in. Is there anyone present who would like to speak at this time on Non-Code Ordinance 2026-008?
If there is no further public comment, the public hearing on Non-Code Ordinance 2026-008 is closed at this time. Is there a motion and a second to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-008?
I'll make that motion.
Second. Is there any discussion?
Same accolades as before to all involved in preparing our budget and budgets.
Any further discussion?
Hearing none, will the clerk please call the roll? Voting on the motion to adopt non-code ordinance 2026-008, approving the 2028 operating budget and related revenues, expenditures, expenses and inter-fund transfers, amending the pay scale, and appropriating funds. Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Denmark?
Yes. Mr. Shen? Yes. Mrs. Loan? Yes.
Mr. McAlto? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mayor Wagner?
Yes. The motion passes. A non-code ordinance 2026-008 is adopted.
Next on the agenda is Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009, approving the updated Whittier fee schedule to include a fee for certified mailings.
I am opening the public hearing for Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009 at this time. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed in to speak at this time? No one has signed in. Is there anyone present who would like to speak at this time on Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009?
-009. There is no further public comment. The public hearing for Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009 is closed at this time. Is there a motion and second to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009?
I'll make that motion.
I'll second. Is there any discussion?
Hearing none, will the clerk please call the roll? Voting on the motion to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009, approving the updated Whittier fee schedule to include a fee for certified mailings. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. McAlto?
Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mr. Denmark? Mr. Shen?
Yes. Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Mayor? Yes.
The motion passes and Non-Code Ordinance 2026-009 is adopted. Next on the agenda is Non-Code Ordinance 2026-010, authorizing the sale of and setting a hidden reserve for surplus public works heavy equipment by competitive sealed bid in accordance with Whittier Municipal Code 3.36.410.
I am opening the public hearing for non-code ordinance 2026-010 at this time. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed in to speak? No one has signed in.
Is there anyone present who would like to speak at this time? Uh, on non-code ordinance 2026-010.
If there is no further public comment, the public hearing for Non-Code Ordinance 2026-010 is closed at this time. Is there a motion and a second to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-010?
I'll make the motion. I'll second.
Any discussion?
I have a question. Um, so who is going to be handling this, uh, auction? Who's, who's leading the charge here?
Is this Public Works? Uh, Mr. Mayor, uh, the clerk's office has been handling the surplus sale for the past several years and intends to do so again this year. Okay.
Um, is there going to be a reserve? That is correct.
Okay, that's all I got.
Any further discussion?
Okay, hearing none, will the clerk please call the roll? Voting on the motion to adopt Non-Code Ordinance 2026-010, authorizing the sale of and setting a hidden reserve for surplus public works heavy equipment by competitive sealed bid in accordance with Whittier Municipal Code 3.36.410.
Mrs. Loan?
Yes. Mr. Shen? Yes. Mr. Denmark? Yes.
Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Macaltao? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch?
Yes. Mr. Mayor? Yes. The motion passes, and Non-Code Ordinance 2026-010 is adopted.
Would you like me to read this one too? Yes, please. Next on the agenda is the introduction of Ordinance 2026-011, repealing Whittier Municipal Code Chapter 2.06, Elections, and adopting Title 4, Elections, updating Whittier's election procedures to ensure maximum participation and access to Whittier elections, and to update election procedures to adopt clear guidelines and procedures and set for public hearing at the following regular meeting.
Is there a motion, a second to introduce Ordinance 2026-011 and set for public hearing at the, uh, following regular meeting? Mr. Mayor, I would like to make a motion to postpone this introduction.
Um, it is a significant rewrite of a significant ordinance, um, with 20, 30 pages here. It's much easier to digest this if we have a redline version of the changes, which we did not receive.
Mr. Denmark, can I clarify? Uh, you made a motion, or you're asking to make a motion to postpone. Are you postponing indefinitely or to a date certain? I would like to postpone it until we can see a redline version at whenever meeting that is convenient. So would you like me to say the next meeting, December regular meeting?
That's fine. Okay, Mayor. Can I speak to this one? Just, I think it might be worthwhile. The redline versions on these are not very user-friendly, so I wonder if it wouldn't be beneficial to, even if you postpone it to next meeting, we sort of break it down and go through it.
Also, I think Councilmember Pincush put in some proposed changes. No. Okay, so just to make sure that you're looking at the redline and going through the section sort of in a way that you can actually go through and review the changes as opposed to a mess of redline. Because the way we create redlines for contracts like this is using a comparison feature on a Word doc. There's no other real way to do it when you're rewriting an entire revision.
So the other way we do it is we put them in by hand. To each section. So with the comparison version where the computer generates the red line, it's messy. So that's all I'm saying is you may want to plan on going through the red line sort of for half of it and then the red line for the other half. We'll give you the whole comparison-generated red line.
I'm just saying that you may want the time. So that's all. Yeah, whatever makes sense is, is it Is it possible to format a side-by-side?
I think a side-by-side is going to work great for some of the provisions. And then do you mean sort of just one section with the other section on the next page or next to it on a sort of— and just do that for each code provision? I think so. I think we can try to do that. And then you won't see— that might be more productive than a redline.
Just because they're completely rearranged, right? So you're going to have—. Trying to find whatever nuance might be there is very difficult. Okay, so we'll provide the redline, and what we can try to do too, what we often do for large rewrites like we did on Title 12, for example, is we give you a memo that has the comparison that talks about the differences. And so it's just a summary of the substantial changes.
So we'll have that, then we can do a side-by-side, and I'll work with the clerk to do that, and then we'll have the red line. So you'll have the red line as a backup. It's not to prevent you from having the red line, it's just to ensure that there's more useful tools. Okay.
I would just like to point out that, Holly, you did do the definitions and terminology showing that practical is on in your report on page 17. You did do that.
Thank you. It's a little embarrassing, but thank you.
Mr. Mayor, you have a motion on the floor, but no second yet to postpone the introduction of Ordinance 2026-011 to the December regular meeting.
Can I get a second, please?
Sorry, Mr. Denmark, you made the motion. Uh, second. Discussion?
Hearing none, uh, Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll? Putting on the motion to postpone the introduction of Ordinance 2026-011 to the December regular meeting. Mr. Denmark. No. Mr. Macalto.
Yes. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes.
Mr. Shen? Yes. Mrs. Borg? No. Mr. Mayor?
Yes. The motion passes, and Ordinance 2026— uh, sorry, the introduction of Ordinance 2026-011 is postponed to the December regular meeting.
Okay, moving on to resolutions. Um, Madam Clerk, can you please read? Certainly. Resolution 2026-052, establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 federal legislative priorities.
Is there a motion and a second to approve Resolution 2026-052?
I'll make a motion to approve Resolution 2026-052. I'll second that. Okay, a motion has been made and a second to approve Resolution 2026-052. Is there a staff report?
Is there any discussion?
One small thing.
My understanding is the order in which these are listed indicate a statement of priority to some degree.
I—. Councilmember Denmark, through the mayor— when, when discussing them, yes, it does. You know, it's— it is when there are numbers next to them. It is extremely difficult to, you know, go, go in front of someone and say, yeah, we really want to, you know, receive a grant or get money for number 7 on our list. And I mean, it's just one of those type of things that the numbering portion is, you know, not normally requested.
Thank you. There have been times that I've just said, let's put them in alphabetical order.
Any further discussion?
Hearing none, will the clerk please call the roll? Voting on the motion to approve Resolution 2026-052, establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 federal legislative priorities. Mr. Shin? Yes. Mrs. Borg?
Yes. Mrs. Loan?
Yes. Mr. Denmark? Yes. Mr. Macaltao? Yes.
Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mr. Mayor? Yes. The motion passes, and Resolution 2026-052 is approved.
Next on the agenda is Resolution 2026-053, Establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 state legislative priorities. Is there a motion and second to approve Resolution 2026-053?
I'll make a motion.
I'll second.
Motion has been made and seconded. Is there a staff report?
Is there any discussion?
Hearing none, uh, Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll? Voting on the motion to approve Resolution 2026-053, establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 state legislative priorities. Mr. Shen. Yes. Mrs. Loan.
Yes. Mr. Denmark. Mr. Pincush. Yes. Mrs. Borg.
Yes. Mr. Macaltao. Yes. Mr. Mayor. Yes.
The motion passes, and Resolution 2026-053 is approved. Next on the agenda is Resolution 2026-054, establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 local legislative priorities.
I'll make a motion to approve.
I'll second.
A motion has been made and seconded to approve Resolution 2026-054.
Is there a staff report?
Is there any discussion?
Hearing none, uh, Madam Clerk, can you please call the roll? Voting on the motion to approve Resolution 2026-054, establishing the City of Whittier's calendar year 2027 local legislative priorities. Mr. Shen? Yes. Mr. Macaltao?
Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? Yes. Mr. Denmark? Yes.
Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Mayor?
Yes. The motion passes and Resolution 2026-054 is approved.
Okay, on to other new business.
Do I need to read this out, Madam Clerk, as far as Alaska Municipal League Annual Government Conference?
Do I want to take them one at a time? I'm sorry. Yes, please. Okay. Well, it's not giving me any direction after that.
Mayor, we can go ahead. We will—. Administration can reference what, what the— why this is under new business. Okay, if you'd like, reference away. The Alaska Municipal League, uh, annual government conference is happening, and, uh, registration has— um, in the past we've always, um, at least pre-registered for the early bird for 2 council as well as administration.
This is a really great opportunity for council to meet and administration to meet with peers. There is a mayor's conference. There is a— the— sorry, the Alaska Municipal League General Conference. And then there's also a clerk's conference and a newly elected conference. It's from December 6th to December 11th.
And we just wanted to put it out and see if there were at least 2 people, if not more, that would like to attend on the council.
I would be interested in attending if there's, if there's room. I might not be able to go all of the 4 or 5 days, but I would be interested in learning. Yeah.
Sign me up, Mayor. Um, would you also like us to sign you up for the mayor's conference? Yeah, we talked about it. Yeah, okay, thank you. Thank you.
Okay, next under other new business is student representative, uh, and this was requested by, uh, uh Council Member Loan. Um, yeah, I guess I'll just give like a super quick overview of what I was thinking. Um, it's something I've been thinking about for a while. I know Victor and I have spoken about it before, just as like an idea. I did talk to some of the school teachers and to administration about it, but I was thinking that Whittier could have a sort student council representative.
And I haven't, you know, I just kind of wanted to put the idea out there before I ironed out all the details. But, you know, the students could elect or sign up to be the rep, and they could attend some meetings and just kind of learn how processes of getting something on an agenda works, or, you know, attend some sort of Parks and Rec service project that we do in the winter. And it's also kind of thinking that the students could come up with their own initiative or project that they would like to see done by summer, and maybe just show them like how they can work on that and realize that, and how, um, you know, just kind of learn the entire process and their rights as citizens. And I was just kind of wondering if other council members would be open to that. Um, it wouldn't require a specific council member mentor or anything like that, but I know there's a handful of us that would be happy to kind of take a student under our wing, you know, especially in different meetings like Parks and Rec and Planning and Zoning and things like that.
No audio detected at 1:35:00
Um, I know Jackie had a couple of additional thoughts maybe when I brought to administration. But so if you have anything to add, Jackie, please do.
I just would like to add that, you know, I think it is a great opportunity to incorporate, you know, local young youth to participate in how municipal government works and how, you know, the processes, whether it's in the administration world or the the political world and the planning and zoning world. And I just— it was a pleasure a couple years ago to attend the student council meetings that they were having at the school. They were very organized, and it was just really great to see, you know, kids want to be involved in the community and their school. And I just think it is a great opportunity if the council so sees it.
Yeah, yeah, so I'd support this idea. Um, you know, growing up here, I had the opportunity to serve on student council at the school, and I thought it was a is a really good experience for me. I encourage, um, any interested youth and council members to, um, participate in something like this. This would be a great way to create cross-generational opportunity for us.
I agree. Any other comments?
Okay, the, uh, next item on the list under other new business is—. Yeah, could we request that council votes on this just because it's an investment of time?
Do you have the the, the verbiage. Uh, how about a motion to direct administration to work with members of council to establish a student representative position?
Can I get a motion and a second? Actually, I'm sorry, can we remove the part that says work with council? I mean, only for purposes of the Open Meetings Act. The motion— well, they'll develop a student representative proposal, they'll bring it back to council, and that'll be the working with council part. If that works for council, that, that's more compliant with law.
Okay, so then direct administration to establish a student representative program.
Can I get a motion for council approval? Oh, for council approval. There we go. Perfect. Thank you.
I'll make that motion.
Second.
I'll second.
Discussion. Hearing none, Madam Clerk, can you call the roll? Voting on the motion to direct administration to establish a student representative program for council approval. Mrs. Borg. Yes.
Mr. Macaltao. Yes. Mr. Shen. Yes. Mr. Pinquoch.
Yes. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. Denmark? Yes.
Mr. Mayor? Yes. The motion passes and administration is so directed.
Okay, next on the list is, uh, item 23, City Manager review. Mayor, this is an opportunity for, um, the, the council if wish is to discuss the current evaluation in public and then possibly proceed to it in an executive session at a later— at the end of the meeting. But this gives the ability for you as council to discuss the— for the public's review, the inner— the actual reserve— or sorry, the evaluation that is presented to you by the third-party HR.
Go ahead, Peter.
I don't get it. I don't either. There's two opportunities, right? This is just providing an opportunity for the public to hear some of the concerns, but it also provides an opportunity to then possibly move into an executive session to do the, the evaluation. But it is an evaluation for the document itself is something that if you would want to address any of the issues in it so that the public knows some of the concerns that were addressed and/or the ability to know some of the results of that evaluation.
That's all.
I'm completely lost here. I, I thought this was confidential.
And what, what—.
May I go? No, I guess. All right, so I have some, some positive feedback for Miss Wilde here. Is that, um, is that what you're looking for? Like All right, so positive feedback from myself for Ms. Wilde is that she is— she's hitting these goals that we have established as a council.
Um, we wanted to, you know, repair, replace, rebuild, redesign the DeLong Dock. Here we are, $50 million grant later, it's here. Um, that's big. That's really big. The Shocking Cove Road, you know, we've advanced that road another mile, um, just finished up that project, wrapped up this year.
Um, a well field project, you know, we, we want to update our infrastructure. Well field, our water wastewater system is a major part of our city's infrastructure that we don't see, and maybe it's probably maybe a little underappreciated, but nonetheless super important for us. And here we are We got the pump house. Yeah, I think that's dried in and they're doing something inside there and I imagine it's like getting pretty close to turnkey ready. No?
Okay. Don't know. I don't know what's going on in there. I mean, it looks— I mean, there's a building and you see the wells.
No, just to name a few there.
And she's also, you know, she's advanced. There's a city park behind the BTI. Um, I know that there, you know, I was personally, you know, it, it is disturbing to see like lots of trees mowed down. I got a lot of comments about that, but, um, you know, in order to build infrastructure or parks and stuff, kind of have to start at the bottom up. Um, and we can't If you think about those trees that were cut down, they were not there when the military left.
And the military, Department of Defense, when they left, they left us many surprises in this little town. And those things need to be dealt with. And, you know, hence a lot of the clearing and groundwork that needs to be done.
And unless that's moving forward, and in our budget we are slating to complete major components of that park, you know, with a water sewer extension, a pavilion. Um, we have, um, oh yeah, I'm just working off top of my head here. Um, our harbor rebuild, we have another large project. You know, we had docks that were literally like dangerous to step on. Like, I would not step on them myself.
Like, fingers that looked like they were just ready to flip over as soon as you stepped on them. They're gone. They're like— if you go to the head of the bay where they're gone, I mean, you saw the barge. They load them on a barge and they're gone, and we have a new harbor. Um, so, you know, we're hitting, we're hitting our goals here.
Um, some constructive feedback I have is, um, Jackie, you will, um, sometimes you just, you take on a lot, and I feel that it is, uh, while we accomplish a lot, we're with an under, um, without a full staff there. And I would like to see like our city administration and our departments fully staffed out so that we we can go, we can go farther. You know, I know you think that maybe you're Superwoman or something, but I mean, you're human. Sorry. Um, and so I think there are some things that, um, that can be improved there.
You know, we have had some challenges with meetings where we required a city clerk and we didn't, and you were, you were the city manager and the acting city clerk at the same time there, and that caused some, um, uh, just, just didn't— things were not working out when that— when we were in that kind of situation. So we'd like to see our staff fully staffed out. Um, we had some conflicts and friction in the community with the way, you know, testimonies from people saying um, interactions with the city staff. And while I was not personally there to see it, um, I can't discount it. And so I think that you being the face of our city administration and our representative for many of our activities, you know, I think is something worth checking into, whether it's with a mentor, a consultation firm, um, someone they'll choose, or someone you, you choose, something, a third party of some sort.
Thank you.
This is highly irregular. So we have the city's manager review on an agenda point where we're at right now, also in executive session. We've done this a couple times in the past. It's always set up to be done in an executive session, and you have both times chosen to do it in public.
This, this is the kind of stuff, Jackie— there's the— there's— this seems a manipulation of the agenda. I don't understand what we're supposed to be doing here when all we have to do is get to that executive session, and then you can tell us whether you want to do it in open session or you want to do it in the executive session. And this review is supposed to be held as a function of the review forms that we were given. So I'm not understanding seeing the— this on the agenda at this point and what you are aspiring to from us, or what you would have us as counselors do at this point of the agenda. Well, I'm just gonna, um, jump in here because one of the things— putting it on new business isn't uncommon, and I think you usually do have a public and a executive session.
So I mean, I've represented you guys for 10 years. I've seen it done like this numerous times. There is— I think the memorable part is often the executive session when a city manager chooses to do it in public, because they generally do not choose to do it in public. But I think with City Manager Jim Hunt, we started to see a shift. He always asked to have it in public, or I think he did his last evaluation.
What are we doing here? My point is, The point is, but Council Member Denmark, the good news is you have a lot of flexibility. It's just the evaluation of the city manager, and I say that not to be contrite, but what I'm saying is you can go into executive session after having this discussion, but it is a new business. It is a point of new business, right? So city manager evaluation is something you did not— that is appearing on the agenda for the first time.
It is often, and this is— you see this a lot because you might want to say things about the city manager presuming she does not want to have an executive session in public at the end of the meeting, right? So it allows you to do exactly what Council Member Shen did. It allows you to say, boy, we have these concerns and they are X, Y, and Z, and I want to make sure that we're raising that. And you're evaluating the city manager because you are elected by the people of the city, and you're not pushing that off to the very last thing on an agenda at 11 o'clock at night when lots of people want to go home and go to bed. Read.
So I see the concerned look on your face, Mayor, but I'm saying that is what this allows you to avoid. So you can go into executive session now, or you can go into executive session later. But I guess the question is, I think this is fine, this is benign, and I'm not sure why you're looking at me like that. Are you thinking it's not benign? Well, I keep hearing this If, or maybe we're going to go into executive session, we are going to—.
You don't have— you don't control that executive session under the, under the, under the law. The only reasons why we go into executive session are the reasons stated in the Open Meetings Act. There are specific exemptions, right? When you're doing an evaluation, we also have court cases on this because city manager evaluations are actually something that have gotten discussed. When you're going into evaluation, you're going to go in under the provision that exempts those discussions from open session because they discuss character and reputation.
Discussions which— what do you—. I have no idea what's going on. Okay, the Open Meetings Act, right? The way we get into executive session is City Council, right? The only way you get to have a private discussion ever as city council, ever, is if you meet one of the criteria expressly laid out in the Open Meetings Act under Alaska statute, right?
And the reasons why you get to go in— and I'm going to paraphrase because I can't remember the exact language—. No, don't paraphrase. We have any— it's on the agenda. Are we having an executive session or not? So the answer to the question is there are 4 criteria.
One of those criteria No, I— so you don't understand. Are we having an executive session or not? Your choice. You get to put an executive session on the agenda. I didn't put it on the agenda.
It's already on there, right? But the thing about that executive session, the character and reputation— by the way, this has been the same every year for the 10 years that I have been here, right? So you put that on there for your evaluation process. It's never changed. We did—.
The city manager is already on there. Right, okay, so the city administration or the clerk, when it is time for the evaluation of the city manager, places on the agenda an executive session. That executive session puts the public on notice that there may or may not be an executive session. Fun point: you can call an executive session for anything on the agenda. Agenda, so long as you can get to one of the criteria that allows you to have an executive session, right?
Anytime. It does not have to be on your agenda. Your motion has to be stated with specificity. So you have an executive session on your agenda. However, the criteria that we are under, the evaluation of somebody that may— that the matters of which tend to impugn the reputation and character of a Right?
The Open Meetings Act expressly requires you to allow the person who is the point of that discussion to have the session in open session. This is exactly what I'm talking about. Why does everybody assume this is going to be negative? Oh no, it may not be negative because I thought we were going to executive session again. I didn't ask for it on the agenda.
It was there. Was to discuss the results of the evaluation.
Right, so what you're saying, we can go in, but then you have no basis to have it in executive session. I didn't ask for it. I know, and you don't— so you don't have to have an executive session. What council can do if they don't want— but this is the standard for a decade. So that's what I'm saying right now.
Council getting frustrated because there's an executive session on the agenda for city manager evaluation is confusing me. So I'm trying to understand why are we—. This meeting alone has given me cause for an executive session. This meeting? This meeting alone.
Oh, and that might, that might be true, Mayor. Like, I'm not saying that you don't have— what I'm saying is the city manager evaluation process is pretty consistently laid out, and it has been done for about a decade. And I would turn to other city council members who have been on the council, including— but this is the process now. So it may or may not end up in an executive session based on what the city manager says about the executive session. We are always welcome to have it in public.
So I'm not sure, and this just gives you 2 points to do it, so you can summarize what you want to say early on and then save the executive session, or you can make a motion to go into executive session. Mr. Mayor, if I may. Go ahead, but I'm going to make a motion for a recess here in a minute.
Okay, so this, this seems irregular, but if we are going to go into the city manager review evaluation right now, I would ask that the review forms They were— they've been compiled and synopsized by somebody used to be the clerk. Now it was a human resources director.
Yes, ma'am. I almost called you Vice Mayor. I'm sorry, Council Member Denmark. And it was tallied by your third party, the city's third party HR. Okay.
And so what I would like to see is at least that tally be presented and then allow us as counselors to respond to it. It will be a tally of each review. I don't think it will be a verbatim repetition of those. I would be happy to read mine verbatim. And if you have, have seen it, I mean, I've The issue— I don't want to impugn reputation or character, but there's going to be some conversations about truthfulness, for one thing.
So if you consider that an impugnment, we should take— you know, I should take it to executive session. I am happy I have submitted this to Human Resources or to whoever. I'm happy to read it verbatim in public.
It's up to you if that is an impugnement or not. Well, I think that's a perfect way to address the discussion issue if you have, because what you're doing is saying there may be some issues in there that you may find, you know, impugn your reputation and character. They are that, you know, I anticipate talking about truthfulness. And that gives, um, you know, I think that the, the question is, should we go into executive session so that you can— we can determine if that is reputation and character? Not up to us.
That should be up to the HR director who is tallying or in charge of this process for the first time in our history. No, I think it is up to you, and I think that, that having an HR person tally it instead of an employee that is under the supervision of the city manager makes a lot of sense. So justifiable, I understand. Yes, but nobody— but then nobody knows what is in there, what's in that tally, or whether it needs to be expanded or expounded upon. So, but a starting point for a review should be a synopsis of those reviews, which has been our standard typical process, which I understand not all counselors filled out either.
So did the, did the council not get a synopsis of the, of the—. So I would like to answer number 1, um, Council Member Denmark. I have not seen your personal synop— your personal review. What I did receive, and I I believe counsel also received was a copy of said synopsis from— from— I never saw HR. Nope, I never got one.
You welcome. I just—. So there is a synopsis, um, but I was under the impression it was sent to you today. You want to make publicly that you feel very comfortable making publicly, and then a council member move to go into executive session. If you want to hold off on executive session till the end of the meeting, that's appropriate.
If you want to call an executive session because this topic is on the agenda, you can do that No, you have either option. That's most— most communities will talk about that person in public, then they will go into executive session to have a more detailed discussion regarding things that may impugn their reputation and character.
So I mean, that is— that is the process that I see very regularly. I'd recommend it. If your city manager says no, I would prefer you to have that conversation in public, then I do not think you need to worry about whether or not what you have to say impugns their reputation and character. Is a risk that she has undertaken.
Okay, I'm, I'm requesting a 15-minute recess. I am absolutely blown away by this development. Um, so that— I just want to understand, what, what is the development that is blowing you away? You better give me 15 minutes before I get into it. All Yes, sir.
Ooh.
Sorry, did I miss her?
No audio detected at 2:01:30
No audio detected at 2:03:30
No audio detected at 2:05:30
No audio detected at 2:07:30
No audio detected at 2:09:30
No audio detected at 2:11:30
No audio detected at 2:13:30
No audio detected at 2:15:30
No audio detected at 2:16:00
No audio detected at 2:16:30
No audio detected at 2:18:30
No audio detected at 2:20:00
Like to call the meeting back to order, please.
I can't, I can't, I can't get it. Yeah.
Okay, um, moving forward, I still believe we're on, uh, city manager evaluation. Under new business.
It— at this point in time, I guess I'm going to defer to the city manager about the, uh, next 30 minutes moving forward. Um, I thought this whole process was rather innocuous. I saw that we had the city manager evaluation on the agenda for special— for the, I'm sorry, executive session. And I was confused about, uh, the fact that we are, well, what I perceive to be discussing it twice. Are we not going into executive session?
Are you saying that you don't want this evaluation? You don't want us to discuss what we wrote down? Okay, let me interrupt here because that's not her choice. I mean, so asking her— so the city manager evaluation has to happen by the contract, and, and city council needs to go through that process. So it's not up to the city manager whether or not she's evaluated.
However, you have a choice. You can go into executive session right now if you wanted to because you're talking about this item on the agenda, or You can finish having a public discussion of the city manager evaluation, and you can say city council will, you know, will entertain a motion from city council for an executive session when it appears on the agenda as number 9, item number 29. That's after citizen comments. That's after everybody leaves. So that often is when city council does their executive sessions, right?
Just so that you're not clearing the room and then calling everyone back. Back in. So you have a choice with the city— about the city— the evaluation of the city manager is one that makes sense to be on new business. If you want to go into executive session right now, then you could go. You can say, man, you know, can I get a motion to go into executive session?
You have the executive session provision. It would be the same as 29, and then you could go in now. If you want to wait until the public— until at the close of comments and do it after the fact, that's okay too. You know, this was just a time to talk about it publicly. Yes, and I would like to continue on with the public discussion, but I did not know that it was going to exclude the executive session discussion.
I thought there were two different things. I think they are— the executive session discussion is a time where you are going to talk about the things that you think could impugn the character reputation of the city manager, and I would say apply it in your opinion. It's not for somebody to tell you what does that, you know, it's for you to— you're providing that time because you don't know where that evaluation discussion is going to go. You know, I often have clients who actually have glowing reviews, and because it's their process, they have the executive session on the agenda and they go in, and that's when, when there's these glowing reviews and nothing at all is being said that could possibly impugn reputation and character, I will sometimes tell them to get out of executive session because there does not appear to be any discussion of anything that could be seen as even critical, you know, but the, the cases have acknowledged that an evaluation process can involve discussions that tend to impugn reputation and character. So it is an accepted basis for executive session.
Under reputation and character.
Okay, so coming into this meeting, um, since we're talking about this in public, I'm just going to say this, um, and the city manager and I discussed this.
We had a long talk yesterday, but it was about multiple topics, um, The last evaluation that we had, she basically made a promise to the Council that she would take on mentorship.
And I sent an email the next day, basically, I'll shorten it and just say, well, thank you. That was a very good speech. I see a path forward here and— but I am going to hold you to the mentorship.
I'm going to skip the rest of it. The only one at this point in time that I feel comfortable coming on board as a mentor is WinFluence. And I certainly never entertained that Jackie would pick her own mentor.
Maybe if I had thought about that 2 weeks ago, I don't think my mind would have changed anyway. But anyway, I did not know until yesterday that she had, um, sought somebody else out.
At this point in time, I am just going to move forward and make a motion to bring WindFluence on board as Jackie's mentor. Wait, Mayor, can I ask you a question? Sure. So there are city people, and WindFluence is wonderful, but I— you're looking for a mentor for Jackie as a city manager. So I think one thing, I believe it may be appropriate for council to look at people who have served as a city manager.
For more than— because I believe— and I'm just saying, and again, I understand. Okay, so that might be where— I mean, what I would recommend, given the tension, that you look at Alaska Municipal League and maybe reach out to them and ask them. So I'm just throwing that out there because Alaska Municipal League has people who have experience serving as city managers for long periods of time, longer than the tenure of your existing city manager. That's all I'm saying. And that is not to, to interfere with your selection of Windfluence, but I worry that if you hire somebody who has not served as a city manager for more than a year, you will not be accomplishing your goals of mentorship.
And then we're going to be back in the same place. So I'll leave that to you. But AML, does have— I think that you can call them and get names, and maybe WinFluence is on there, you know, but at least you're starting with an objective basis.
Okay, um, I understand your point.
Um, my motion stands.
Go ahead. Hi, I'm— we seem to be ahead of ourselves here. We were in the midst of a review, and the reasons for a need for mentorship have yet to be established, though it may be— that may be the case. Um, no other counselors have spoken here. I am one who would like to speak.
And you'd like to give everybody else an opportunity as well.
Councilor Shen has spoken, and I think whoever else is inclined to speak should be allowed to do so.
I agree, that's not going to stop. But my I'm just stating that part of my evaluation, um, which I have not decided whether or not I'm going to read because it would probably take an hour, um, involves her promise to this counsel that she would take on a mentor. Okay, that's— I am not privy to that conversation.
She said it to us. When we had her previous evaluation in her speech.
Senility may be encroaching here. Which evaluation was that, Mr. Mayor? They want to give me a date? Mayor, can I, um, just, uh, help for a moment? It was not an evaluation.
You had a special meeting on the 13th and again on the 20th for possible termination, and at that point I was able to read in because I was not present, into record, you know, some of the things that the community had, you know, reached out and council members had reached out prior to the possible termination. Okay, so hang on a second. I'm sorry. Um, first of all, I want to clarify something because this has gone on way too far. The only reason why possible termination was in there is because legal had us put it in there.
That should not have been in there. And that basically got us to where we are right now. Every time we turn a corner, someone is thinking that there's something nefarious going on. It's not. Anyway, my only thing tonight was the fact that, yes, Jackie, you did say that you would take on a mentor.
You promised.
Mayor, if I may.
She—. Sorry, I'm not sure if anyone can hear me, if I'm interrupting, but I mean, she did do some legwork and try to introduce the gentleman earlier in the meeting, and you said you didn't want to hear from him. So no, no, it was highly inappropriate. Again, this goes back to— okay, so as far as me, you don't—. I wasn't finished, but, um, I, I would— I'm kind of— I mean, I know I'm not in there in the room, I'm just watching this, and I, I just— I guess I'm confused because I feel like it's almost that old adage of like first raising thieves and then punishing them.
Like, you asked her, she promised to get a mentor we were happy with that. That was something that everybody seemed to agree on. And then in— it's only been— hasn't even been a month. She did some legwork, found somebody, and then you didn't want him to speak. And then you just looked at her and said, you promised.
So I, I guess I'm just confused as to where you're, you're coming from.
Yeah, would— are we gonna— are we all doing offering our review comments here at this time? Is that what we're—. Yeah, we can, we can move into that. Um, who, who would like to go?
I'll do it.
Okay, I'll try to offer some, some substance here. Um, I had a chance to glean the, the tally or the synopsis of the city manager evaluations, and I'm seeing none of which I put in my review in here. And I'm also, um, the overall evaluation distribution. Is there anybody at the table that can tell me how many people filled out the this review form?
5 People? Yep, I think on the email it says there's 5 people. Okay, was— what was mine, one of them that was included in the tally? Councilmember Denmark, I was not— I'm not privy to who did and who didn't. In the email, it literally from your HR stated that 5 people had participated in the evaluation.
So Once again, since I see nothing of what I put in there, I'm going to take a couple minutes and run through mine. And one of the things that I asked the HR coordinator to do in my review, um, this was on the review forum, a function of the summary comments I wrote to the human resources consultant. Please include the WinFluence Strategies confidential personnel report of 8/15/24 in its entirety with this review to reflect my summary comments. And I emailed her a report to Jennifer Ramos at her email address. This document was presented at City Manager Wilde's initial hiring, and it was also presented at her first review.
Um, to which she did not respond well. Um, and as a city councilor, I have been following this report and the issues that were presented at that time. My perception is they still exist to this day. As the human resources consultant did not forward a copy of this report to the council, I would like to distribute a copy of that to the council here, if I may, for their reference. Legal.
This was put into the public domain at Jackie's pre-hire meeting. You can check the record. I put it on the table and her response was not— it was an open session. And she said put it on the table. So you—.
So this has been made public? Is this like— I know there was a public report and there was a confidential report. Confidentiality will likely stand on its own. I'm just trying to understand. Yeah, so this one was the confidential report but was somehow made public at some point?
That is my contention. Okay, well, we don't need it to be made. So one thing I will say is we don't need it to be made public for you to share it with the council members. If it's confidential and it went to the council members, it's okay to distribute it. I'm just trying to get my— I'm trying to wrap my head around what the situation is.
I think if you have copies, you can hand it out, but it doesn't turn it into a public document. When we have a document, we look at the Public Records Act and we'll look at privilege and confidentiality in that way. So just go ahead and hand it out, but that does not mean that this is a document to distribute. But it sounds like you're saying it was made public. I would rather have time to digest, to look into that before you make it public.
I had requested this document be given to the council as a, uh, in my review, and it was not done. So I— is it okay if I just give this to the councilors sitting at the table at this time? It was distributed to them, to the council, in the first place. Yes, it is okay. All right.
But it in no way makes that document a public document. That people who are getting access to this document are within a control group that has a right to see that document.
There's 4. Jackie, Shelby, you want one? No, Shelby does not want one. Peter, can I—. Is not within that—.
Sorry, let her hear that. Need to catch the tunnel. They want to speak before they leave. Is that okay? Just for a couple minutes, can we relax the rules in the middle of a city manager review?
Yeah. Um, As you wish, Mr. Mayor.
You would want to ask, is there any objection from the council to relax the rules to allow—. Yeah, is there any objection? Well, and who are you allowing to speak? Is this—. Are we opening for those comments?
Can we open for just one individual? I'll take any and all. But, um, again, this is what I thought was going to— I wish somebody had told me in the very beginning of this meeting that when I asked to move the executive session, that that was not even a given, a given thing. Um, anyway, Mayor, you for executive session? I'm, I'm confused.
I am, I am confused as to what is happening. An executive session to complete character computation. Has always been subject to a request to have it open. You have not had a request to have it open. No one has.
No one from the council has moved for an executive session. If you want an executive session and you feel like that is where you want to be having a lot of this discussion, just move for an executive session. At this point in time, I don't care about the executive session anymore. Okay, well, if anyone else cares on the council about an executive session, move for executive session, and we can move into executive session. Unless you're a city manager.
You know, does anyone have a problem with WindFluence speaking before they leave? They've been here for the entire meeting.
Hearing none.
Thank you, Councilor.
Uh, Chuck Cobb for the record, WindFluent Strategies. I just want to say I heard our, our business name get brought up earlier, and, um, just speaking on behalf of our team, given our ongoing work with the city, you all know the last 3 years, the many things we've done, we believe an independent, uh, coach would give Jackie and the council a better chance of making the process work that's being suggested. Um, we recommend the council finish the annual review give Jackie whatever specific recommendations you have and a clear path to make progress. But we believe, again, that an independent coach outside of us in our consulting role is a better path forward for that process to be successful. If improvement is needed and whether the Council believes that that's possible, that's all the Council's decision.
No audio detected at 2:40:30
But we we prefer not to be involved with anything related with, uh, uh, coaching or mentorship of the city manager, given our ongoing, uh, broad consulting work with the city. And we want that to be an independent approach. So I just wanted to get that on the record so nobody got hijacked on that discussion further tonight. And I, I appreciate, uh, Mayor, the, uh, the grace you've shown to allow me to come and just get that. I didn't, didn't want to get deep into the night and and, and have the council think that that was an option.
And I pretty— I'm pretty sure I knew where this conversation was going. Um, however, I, I may have to consult with you at a later time as we move down this road, but I will, I will discuss that later. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, council.
Thank you. Thank you.
Okay, so Given, just to reiterate, since that report was not included in this review process, we have 5 counselors, only 5 people contributed to this. The synopsis report is— there, there's some commonsensical stuff in there, But I don't really think it gets to the meat of any issue at all. Um, as Councilor Shen pointed out, the synopsis also points out Jackie has done a good job in a number of arenas, but there are some shortfalls in interpersonal relationships which I believe is the essence of a lot of the angst here.
I had one counselor tell me she's an excellent employee, but she's in the wrong job.
That rang a bell. But I— so since none of my review was included in that synopsis, I am going to read some parts of it here. This will only take a couple of minutes. And it will offer some meat for conversation, I'm sure. Um, one of the questions was, um, um, what comments might I have on leadership and management, uh, on Jackie's leadership and management?
And my comments were, uh, that I perceive a culture of fear has led to some toxicity in the workplace environment. Issues of truthfulness have arisen. Bullying has been observed, and the city manager's methodology often lacks adequate diplomacy.
Uh, regarding policy implementation and council relations, uh, council relations have been damaged due to breaches of truthfulness. Um, An example would be implementation and compliance effort with the release ordinance led to more angst than it was absolutely necessary. It was artlessly forwarded. These are my opinions. I know, and Councilmember Denmark, so you have hit the one place.
So if you're going to talk, and I let you finish your sentence because I don't think I want to say for the record that it impugns reputation and character. However, if you're going, if your comments are going to accuse or to suggest that there's been a lack of truthfulness by the city manager, that should be discussed in executive session. Okay, now unless she decides to— and we haven't put that in front of her to decide to have it—. I put this in front of Jackie before this, and she— this— none of this will be— well, it may have been a surprise 10 minutes ago, but shouldn't be a surprise now. No, but that doesn't want to go to executive session to discuss it.
We certainly can. These are—. I think that's— I think that's what you say. I'm going to talk about truthfulness. I'd like a, um, you know, I would like I'm going to make a motion for it to go into executive session if need be.
Does the city manager want— you know, that— would she request that that be done in public? You kind of pre—. Going no further with that comment. Okay, then I would just say this to the city manager: if there are additional discussions regarding truthfulness, so would you prefer to have that in executive session?
I truly believe that the public needs to hear certain things, um, but I, in a form of an opinion and a, a perception, and I, I understand that there are, uh, people in the community that only reach out to the counselors, and the only way that I can, um, either, you know, progress and, and get better is by hearing it. And, and I don't think that the commission or the council is comfortable in saying it in public. I'm okay with us going into executive session discuss, uh, the, the perceptions of truthfulness or not. But I do also— I will say, you know, we may go into executive session, but I may want to come out of executive session so that it is public and it is record for the community. Because I do believe that while I work for 7 of you, the 7 of you also work for the community, and they should know how you feel.
And that's why I said to Mr. Denmark, you know, please just, you know, go ahead, I have no problem with it. You know, I'm a big girl. But just to be— so make sure we're on the same page, which I think this is helpful. If the council does go then into executive session though, and there are things that are said in executive session that you feel should be expressed in public, those things are confidential. So it will be up to council whether or not— and that's— that'll be difficult because once those things are said in executive session, they are bound by the confidentiality of executive session, and it may be that they can be said again, but they aren't things—.
They—. Nothing that's discussed in executive session. And I don't think that's what you're saying. I think you're saying you want an opportunity in both, you know, to— so council has executive session and public. I just want to be clear, once you go into executive session, that creates a, you know, a confidential discussion.
And I just want to add, because Holly, you are the city attorney, but at the same time I have studied this and I will continue stating this. It would be different if the executive session stuff stayed in executive session. And while you love to say that it does, it doesn't in this community. And so that is another portion of why I really want the public to hear it and/or not hear it. But if it's going to be an executive session, then the council needs to leave it in executive session.
Because that is a huge issue in this community and with the council.
I'm council and the administration that you have code provisions that require it to be confidential, which means it's a violation of law if you share it. And if council really wants to make sure that is enforced, it may be something that you want to start enforcing. And, you know, and that is a discussion we can sort of have a We can talk about that at another time, but there should be a presumption and an assumption that all laws will be followed and nobody will break the law. And discussing confidentiality, confidential things outside of executive session, or what was discussed in executive session, is illegal. And that is— so I will say that, and I am confident that everybody will follow the law.
Right. Yes, and there is a recent example of that very thing.
All right. On the notion of financial management, I offered exceptional marks. As I said earlier in the meeting, kudos to all involved in managing and presenting a sensible and comprehensible short and long-term budget. Regarding community and intergovernmental relations, though intergovernmental, governmental, state, federal relations seem effective, significant discord has developed in some quarters of the community. An unfriendly public-city interface has— perception of an unfriendly public-city interface has developed due to a focus on low, uh, lack of focus on some local priorities, uh, and perceived selective enforcement on other issues.
Um, regarding organizational development and human resources, I go back to one of my initial comments that a culture of fear has led to perception of toxicity in the work environment. Uh, In large part, in part due to organizationally, we, systemic checks and balances are inadequate.
Then planning and project management.
It goes back to lack of checks and balances are evident in our planning process. Processes with the city manager being integral, setting the agenda for both the city council and the Planning and Zoning Commission. Um, and, uh, on the category of communication, my comments went to effective communication requires truthfulness, effective communication requires transit transparency, city manager's application of both can improve. Um, innovation and problem solving, um, the city manager does well.
I gave an overall performance rating due to these more subjective issues as needing improvement And my summary comment is essentially a more diplomatic consensus building and less conflict, conflict-focused leadership approach to employees, citizens, and counselors is necessary.
And once again, none of that was even insinuated in the synopsis of the City Manager's, uh, review, Telly. And Mr. Mayor, City Manager, that's what I got. Thank you.
I guess I should go next. Um, for my review, um, I recognize Jackie's work in helping secure, um, the money for the long dock, uh, replacement project for the Buckner Building. Um, this is an important accomplishment for Whittier, and I appreciate her effort alongside city staff and our partners. But at the same time, I believe there is room for improvement in communication, working with the full council, and building trust with residents and local businesses. Following the rules is important, and, and so is listening, explaining decisions, and treating people with fairness and empathy.
This review reflects my own observation and the concerns shared with me. I want Jackie to succeed, and I wanna— I want us to establish clear goals and follow up on progress. My responsibility is to recognize good work, raise concern respectfully, and keep the best interest of Whittier at the center of my decision. That's it. Victor, are you done?
Well, I guess if you're entertained, I have additional things. I know I went first, but I guess I have something else I want to offer if it's of any substance. And it's not necessarily in our review, but it's maybe another perspective that not many of us have gotten to see. So I traveled to— with Jackie C. Wilde to Washington, D.C. on a lobbyist trip. And, you know, we talk about that in our meetings, but not many people get to, like, see what happens during those trips.
During those trips, we visit our delegation, our senators, our representatives, you know, heads and leadership in many of our federal agencies that— for our country, like NOAA, Department of Transportation, the Forest Service, Department of the Interior. And, you know, when I'm— when I went on those trips with, um, our group from the city, you know, Jackie C. Wilde, she represented— I was proud of the way she represented Whittier. She was proud of Whittier. You know, I don't think we see her every day, but in those meetings, she is so proud of this little town.
And, you know, I have— like, it's really hard to see somebody so proud of our town. There is, you know, we have a stigma about Whittier, but she transcends that. And she's, you know, she speaks so highly of Whittier. She embraces all her quirks, and she talks about the potential that our town has and the possibilities, and conveys these ideas and dreams to these folks in DC. And that, you know, that passion, that energy, that sense of pride for our community, that ownership she takes in her care— she takes in our community, you know, it's it comes— if it's like transitions fruition— excuse me, um, transcends into reality with all these grants we get.
You know, it's— yeah, sure, it's paperwork we do, but she gets out there and she walks miles and miles through DC knocking on doors, literally talking to, you know, people out there. And with Gustavo, you know, she doesn't skip a beat. She gets there, she gets the paper put down on the table, and we sit there with, you know, whether it's Sullivan or Baggage or Murkowski or— I'm sorry, I don't remember the people at DOT and Forest Service— about all our plans and our goals and that this council lays out. And she, yeah, she does that. It's, you know, I think we watching that, I think truly think we have, we have, you know, we're very lucky.
We're very fortunate to have her. And then this team here, like everyone up here at this table here, you know, these guys, these guys are proud. They have pride in our community, you know, and whenever I talk with them, they have, you know, they You know, they— many of you, all of you have been transplants into Whittier, but you are, you know, you take Whittier on as your own. And you guys, you know, she has helped build and maintains that team. And we got something really special.
We have something really special, this team.
And I know it's not perfect.
Um, I think we need to remember to really provide that positive support and that positive feedback for them, because I don't think we— I don't know how to thank these guys enough for what they have done so far in the past, um, 4 to 5 years. So that's my extra feedback. That's my insight that I've seen from my personal observations of our city manager. Okay.
Thank you.
These aren't easy things to fill out.
These aren't easy things to fill out.
I enjoy Jackie's management skills. Um, I've only been a council member for a year, but if I have a problem, I could go in and have a meeting with her. I can call her, I can email her. She doesn't always get back right away, but I understand that there are other business dealings going on in the city, so I give her a few days and she gets back to me. Um, I—.
We—. All of us on the council run in different circles, so I'm not hearing, you know, what everybody— I mean, the communication problem and everything, because when I call it might take a couple days, but I, I get an answer back, and I, and I appreciate that with everything that's going on in the city, all of the projects she has going on. She does make time for everyone on our council. Um, like Victor, you're not Superwoman, you can't do everything, and I'm hoping with a bigger city staff that projects and things like that can be dispersed, you know, a little more equally, and, um, we can get even more things done. Um, I don't really have anything bad to say about our city manager.
Um, I'm just excited to see what the next couple years— next couple years bring to the city for our residents. Um, and that's all I have to say.
Mr. Mayor, if I could share. Yeah, I was just going to call on you. Thank you. Um, I won't— excuse me— I won't go too much into things already discussed, you know, but same, same kind of line of thought. I see amazing projects being undertaken and moved forward and completed.
Um, I do hope that our city staff can get filled out and we can get a couple more people to fill the positions that we need so that there can be some delegation and so that things don't have to just be a constant grind. Um, and, uh, something I, you know, that really influenced one of the questions on my review was that October 13th meeting. Um, you know, I've only been in Whittier just under 8 years, and, you know, there's ups and downs in community and social circles. And I know that there's been, you know, there's been hurt and there's been upset in our community. And looking at the city staff and the community showing up the last few months.
We're so lucky that we have a diverse community and a diverse staff, and to see all of them, you know, like Victor Shen, proud and excited to be part of this team and to be part of Whittier, and also community members, same thing. I feel like while there could have been angst or upset or division in the past that It feels like, and it looks like to me that the city is moving in the right direction, like both with the leadership of the city manager and our community members. It's just, it's—. I'm hopeful that it continues in that direction.
Councilman Pinquoch.
So we're not going into executive session, I assume? Just—. Which is fine, but, uh, we, we can, we can call for executive session. I think it's, it's fair though to let, uh, um, people speak out in public, um, you know, and, and given I want a fair shake, that, you know, obviously it's important that, uh people get to hear the positive things.
So, um, mine's in the middle. Not sure if I want to go into executive session or not.
Um, I'm good either way. It's up to you. I'll just, I'll just speak. I'm good. So start on the positive.
I'm the one that said that you're an excellent employee in the wrong job, and that comes, that comes down to Being a city manager is not a black and white job, but you operate in a black and white world, and it causes problems that don't need to be there.
You have to win all the time, and that gets in the way. There's a time to be humble, and you don't seem to be able to do that. You know, multiple people have said you have to win all the time, and you know, the election was stated it was a referendum. Basically on, on you to a point. And the, the people that voted for me, they want change.
They don't like what's going on. It, you know, the people in your clique think everything is great, but it's not on the other side. The human, the human currency that in this town that is being affected is, is— it hasn't been spoken about, but it's important and it needs to, and it needs to be addressed. Um, and it, it, you know, you can see it on social media, but I give it— to give a little example of, um, probably the best example of how things are is during the period of time when we had the, we had the city manager review for possible termination. City council members got mailed threats from city, city employees that, that they would quit if we fired you.
And beyond that, they disparaged people in this community and people that used to be in this community in those, in those, uh, communications. And the worst one probably of all, another city employee actually went on, um, social media and called certain members— didn't name them, but certain members of the council— garbage people. That's coming from people that work for you. That's all directly on you. And my— you're the head of the ship, you're the captain of the ship, and that's what's coming from, from people And it's unacceptable, and that kind of stuff shouldn't happen.
Another example that has been brought up already is the lease code. You know, the lease code— this council asked for a very simple thing. We wanted the lot lines fixed, and we wanted a standard form so that— and the purpose of that was so when a leaseholder wanted to sell, sell their property, the city wouldn't get in the way. We actually— some people lost the sale because we were— because the lot lines weren't right and at least the paperwork was wrong. That's what we wanted fixed.
What did we get? We got— went from 3 pages to 16 pages of code, and we can all see how that's been used. We just basically made bigger government and it made it even worse. And it— I regret being working on that. As far as I was concerned, I was completely manipulated in that thing, is we asked for something and you took and ran with it in the wrong direction.
And then the other— and the very reason I didn't want to run for council is because most of the time, most of the meetings, it's adversarial between council and you, and it's because you have to win. And you say one thing, and then we get to council meeting, you do exactly the opposite. It. Those are the concerns that I have. I did—.
And a good example of that tonight too, I didn't— I'm one of the two that didn't turn in a job review. I didn't do that because someone in administration changed the procedure, you know, and I tried to get counsel, our legal counsel, to address that, and they— and Holly, you keep avoiding that, you know. You said it's good to not have city employees doing the review and you know, combining all the information. And it wasn't— it was council members who did it, and I was one of those last time. And, and this time it's done by HR, and, and obviously, you know, it's out of town, and, and information was left out that should have been in there.
Um, manipulation, manipulation, manipulation over and over again.
Dave, did we lose you? I lost you. Oh yeah, I'm done.
Mr. Pencush, it looks like you might be hitting the mute button because on our side you are muted.
Well, I couldn't hear you guys.
Can you hear me? We were being quiet. Oh, okay. Well, I was finished.
Okay, I guess I'll go. I've got a lot other than my actual evaluation, which I did do, um, and it says right at the top it took me 102 hours to complete it.
I'm going to back up and just I guess, shoot from the hip for right now and talk about how I think we got where we are.
So I want to go back to, I guess, what started my original friction, um, with myself and Jackie C. Wilde. I have said since I got on the council that my primary focuses in this town were, um, businesses and family. Um, I wanted to see alternate housing options for people in this town. Um, I wanted to see business development, and I wanted to see things that actually benefited the people that live here.
And this is where things started going sideways. Yes, I understand that the Buckner Building and Shotgun Cove Road bathrooms, the harbor, uh, the long dock— these are all great things.
But I don't see how they actually help the people that live here year-round, the 280 people that are here.
I am not trying to diminish what Jackie has done and her staff. They're amazing. I just perceived that there was a shift moving away from helping the people in this town.
I talked to Jackie about it more than once.
I guess that segued into— there was supposed to be a— apparently the city found out that we had owned some land that they didn't know about. I don't want to get into specifics, but I was told that there was going to be a land auction offered up to, um, well, I hoped it would be the citizens of Whittier, um, on April 1st. Funny date to pick.
Up until that day, I had been talking to Jackie C. Wilde about this, and I found out in the council meeting, and anybody can go back and look at the, the expression on my face when instead of auctioning that land off, it got roped into— was it Mountain Goat Court? I can't remember the name of that subdivision. And then it subsequently may have even been roped into Shotgun Cove Road.
I'm sorry, but I'll be dead and my kids will have moved away by the time we have a house built and utilities on that road.
I don't know how I can even get into this without saying anything derogatory about the other housing in this town, but it's awful, and people should not be forced to live in these conditions. Moving along, so that never happened. The auction didn't happen. The whole thing changed in the last minute, and I was Upset. I was upset.
I think the next thing was when I went on a road tour, um, we went around town and we discussed all the leaseholders that were, for lack of a better word, on the chopping block. Um, it was explained to me what the problems were, what the issues were, and I was all in on it. I thought, yep, yep, this isn't right, can't do this, can't do that.
Well, some of the information I got was not correct.
I was willing to move past that. When counsel gave administration instructions on go ahead, take care of these things, especially with one leaseholder, I thought that meant work out something to get this thing fixed, not take away their entire livelihood.
That upset me.
Moving on, I, I think probably the next thing that put a spur in me was when the USS Ted Stevens commissioning was here and we were literally trying to force them to take money. Oh no, no, no, I forgot. I guess in between all that was, um, paving the road down to, uh, the RV park there and, uh, and getting the, the playground started. I don't know if any of you remember, but I actually had a conniption fit in here, and I told administration and the rest of the council that I would vote no on everything that cost more than $1 until they built that park.
I was furious.
It finally got done, and thank you, by the way.
So that's where all this started. I was upset.
Then we had a city employee who was dismissed.
That was not my issue. It was an issue with a lot of other people.
And so basically how this all came to be— how long ago was this? A month ago when we— I tried to call for the original meeting to have the sit-down, September 11th.
Every one of us had a separate issue. None of them were the same.
I had my issue. Peter, Dave, Renner, they're all different. What we wanted was an executive session with Jackie to discuss this. There was no termination on the table. The first meeting that was supposed to happen We couldn't do it because we didn't have a city clerk, and Jackie couldn't run the whole meeting and do everything on herself and still be on the hot seat.
So we moved the meeting ahead, and I think there was something that happened in between on that meeting that we had to reschedule that. But finally we got to a meeting, we went into executive session, nobody was happy.
And in the meeting, in the executive session, we were basically told— I'm not going to say what was said. I'm just going to say that what was basically said either—. Do not disclose anything discussed. And, and we came out because right now I have to listen to you comment about the legal advice that you got, and I do not have the ability to share the legal advice that you got because I need to respect attorney-client privilege. I was literally trying to avoid all that.
I didn't say anything about legal advice. You have literally said that the reason why we had this meeting, legal, and now you're going into the conversation from the executive session. So I'm just saying, be careful. This is appropriate discussion. Just save this part for the executive session.
That's, that's all I— or just say, just kind of do a dot dot dot for the executive session discussion. Okay, but don't say what you were basically told. So basically told, dot dot dot, move on. You cannot summarize what you were told in executive session, if that is— makes sense.
That is my legal advice. You cannot summarize what you were told in executive session. How do I just say that it was a waste of time? You can say that. Okay, I'm just going to say that it was wasted time.
Just say it's a waste of time. That, that's an opinion. That's not a summary of a discussion. We didn't find out it was a waste of time until we were in the meeting. It should have never happened.
We just shouldn't, shouldn't have had the meeting.
And then, and I don't know how to phrase this one, so we had to redo the meeting. Now this is getting nuts. We had to have another meeting, and then we were told that we had to put termination on the agenda.
Why? I can't even—. Would you like— wait, attorney-client privilege, and I can, I can answer that question. It doesn't even matter. But I'm not sure why we're talking about the attorney-client privilege advice.
So anyway, it should have never happened. Um, we should have— if we had a time machine and could go back, we just should— we maybe we should have just had a what do you call it, a town hall meeting or a work session or something. It was never supposed to turn into this.
I don't even have a word for it.
But from then, it just kept snowballing. It kept snowballing all the way up until right what happened now. I had no idea coming in this meeting that this was going to happen.
I thought the review is already done. I thought we were just going to discuss the review, and I don't understand what the harm in talking. I mean, I, I don't know.
I had said a while ago that my original reasons— and I, I told you this, Jackie— that my original reasons for having a meeting didn't even matter anymore because it was all the stuff that happened between me asking to have a meeting and then that I did not believe were warranted. It split the council, it split the community.
And it should have never happened. It should have never happened.
I don't know. I don't know what to say anymore. Going back, I guess, to the mentorship thing. Yeah, I can't believe you don't remember this, Peter.
I thought your speech was very good, you know, when we did have that meeting. Um, you did, you did promise to take on a mentor. I, I don't agree that you should be able to pick your own. Um, I think what should have happened, and I don't— I thought this was going to happen executive session, that we were going to come out and probably have WinFluence find somebody But I thought we discussed that in executive session. I don't think that you should pick your own mentor.
I think the council should pick it.
And that's, I guess, my only input on that.
Mayor, will there be an opportunity for me to possibly respond to the council right now? Yeah, just, um, if you are— I mean, I don't want to take everybody's time here, but, um, that was just my from-the-hip talk. Did you want me to read the actual evaluation?
Again, I, I didn't, I didn't want to do this in public.
And again, if council members want to go into executive session, you absolutely can. Just use a motion. I think that was anticipated based on that. You're—. I think this is causing more of a rift, and that I don't want that.
I am literally trying to put things back together. And somehow this devolved into more craziness. Yeah, and now you can call a motion for— you can do a motion for executive session for all of the comments, Mayor. I mean, that is okay.
I don't think there's anything in here that's detrimental. What's the word?
Okay, so number 1, under leadership and management, I wrote: the city of Whittier— sorry— benefits from a capable and dedicated staff, and I recognize— this is not going to work— I recognize the contributions made by our employees, department heads, However, the effectiveness of the city manager must be evaluated independently of accompli— accomplishments by those employees. My primary concern is the deterioration of the working relationship between the city manager and members of council. Effective leadership requires the ability to work professionally with all elected officials, including, including those who question administrative decisions or disagree with recommendations. Disagreements between council members is normal in municipal government. However, the level of division that currently exists is concerning and has negatively, negatively affected our ability to conduct the city's business effectively.
The city manager should be a stabilizing influence within the organization, encouraging constructive communication, accountability, and mutual respect. I would like to see meaningful improvements in these areas, particularly in the city manager's willingness to accept constructive criticism acknowledge concerns, and work cooperatively with the entire city council rather than allowing disagreements to become ongoing conflicts. Leadership should be measured not simply by the number of projects underway, but by the ability to maintain an effective organization, implement council direction, and build confidence in the administration. Under policy implementation and council relations, I wrote, this is my area of greatest concern. The City Council is the governing body of Whittier.
The city manager is responsible for implementing council policies and direction while providing professional advice and administrative leadership. City manager must remain accountable to the council as a whole regardless of the differences in individual council members' opinion. Unfortunately, I believe this relationship has deteriorated significantly. A recent special council meeting intended to address concerns regarding the city manager's performance illustrates the difficulties we experiencing. The purpose of that meeting was to provide an opportunity for the council to address management concerns and determine an appropriate path forward.
Instead, the meeting became a highly contentious public event. City employees, family members, children from the community attended, with some displaying banners expressing their support for the city manager. Employees and residents certainly have the right to vote their opinions and express their opinions. However, I believe the circumstance created an atmosphere that was counterproductive to council's ability to address legitimate management concerns. There were also significant disagreements regarding the executive session process and in a manner which we could proceed.
Regardless of the legal procedure questions involved, the outcome was unsuccessful. The attempt to address serious concerns, uh, concerns in a constructive manner failed. The city manager should recognize that an evaluation or discussion of management performance is a normal responsibility of the government body. Not necessarily an attempt to terminate employment. A similar problem has arisen within the current evaluation process.
Our following— following our most recent council meeting, the possibility of revising the city manager's evaluation process was raised. This was a legitimate governance issue and should have been discussed and decided by the council. Instead, the proposed changes were characterized in subsequent communications as another attempt to remove the city manager. Whittier, which by the way was absolutely insane.
The substantial number of critical emails followed, dividing the council further and complicating the evaluation process. The city manager also cited provisions of her employment agreement requiring evaluation in November. I recognize that the city must honor the contractual obligations. However, the timing of the evaluation and the council's authority to review and impose evaluation procedures were separate issues. The council should have been afforded the opportunity to discuss proposed changes and make its own determination.
Instead, the issue remained unresolved, and some council members reportedly declined to complete the evaluation. Now here we are, and obviously that came to fruition. This is not a productive or sustainable working relationship.
Regarding the city's election code, I'm going to skip forward because there's just too much here. I'm sorry. Um, I, I was unable to attend the workshop and remain hopeful that proposed changes will address legitimate concerns and improve our election process. However, I have a specific concern regarding the possibility of moving from individual seat elections to at-large election system. I do not support the change.
I'm sorry, I'm not going to go into the explanation on that. It doesn't matter.
I'm sorry everybody, I'm trying to skip to the end here. This is just way too long. Oh.
I'm just going to go summary, uh, content summary. My overall assessment is that the city manager's performance needs improvement. I recognize the city continues to operate, that capable employees are performing important work, and that several worthwhile projects are moving forward. These accomplishments, these accomplishments should be acknowledged. However, I do not believe they adequately address the concerns surrounding executive leadership, accountability, communication, and the relationship between the city manager and the city council.
The city manager serves at the direction of the elected government body. The ability to work professionally with all council members, accept constructive criticism, implement council decisions, and maintain a productive relationship within the government body is fundamental to that position. In my opinion, the current level of division and dysfunction is unacceptable. Events surrounding the recent special council meeting, the unresolved, um, commitment to professional mentorship, and the controversy involving current evaluation processes illustrates recurring problems that need to be addressed.
Well, I support the city's responsibility to enforce its code and protect municipal interests, I believe the manner in which certain lease matters were handled demonstrated insufficient consideration for the people and businesses affected. Some of these individuals devoted decades to building Whittier's economy. At least in one instance, a leaseholder lost their livelihood. These circumstances raise significant concerns about whether the administration adequately, adequately considered reasonable alternatives, the economic consequences of its actions, and the importance of treating established community members with fairness and respect.
Moving forward, I expect meaningful improvements in leadership, communication, accountability, professional development, and the respect for the— the council's governing responsibilities. I want the city manager to succeed.
However, success must be demonstrated through the measurable improvements and performance and a restored working relationship with the entire council. I apologize, I skipped through about 90% of that, so if it didn't make any sense—.
Thank you, Mayor and Council. Is it okay if I respond? Are you okay with that? Um, first I'd like to address Councilmember Pencush because, um, I believe that since I started for the city, um, that has always been, you know, how I have, um, alluded to my— how I act, um, or how I conduct business. I am a Black and white person.
I am a, a I'm a person that follows code and helps. I come from a background that does, I've always believed that code isn't written in stone and that my goal and duty is to maybe not always help the person exactly the way that they want, and not say you can't do this, but here's how we can do it within the confinements of code. I am a code person. I've always said that. But I, I just would like to express to all of you, um, that while I hear what you are saying, I need you to hear what I have to say too.
I am your city manager. I work for all 7 of you, and when 4 of you vote for something, even if 2 or 3 of you don't want that something, I am obligated to do what you've asked as a body as a whole. At that point, you are considered a body, a whole, you know, 4 voted for it. That sometimes comes off as, you know, administration is being too forceful, or administration— and, and when I say administration, I am meaning me, um, but it is extremely difficult to sit here and to hear at multiple levels, um, after reading even my evaluation, and, you know, for, for to hear someone say there's a lack of communication, we need better transparency with the council. There are certain things that the administration, especially when it comes to legal activities, um, I can't discuss it because it is supposed to be handled in the administration world and possibly brought forward to the council world.
Um, at the same time, I also cannot communicate with you if you will not respond to me, you will not answer me. I have left for the last 4 years— actually, I would say the last 6 years— I have always told every single person, even when I was the assistant city manager on council, I'm here, you know, do you want to talk, do you want to meet, do you— and I've always opened that door But I don't know what avenue I can do to, to get you to even meet with me at this point, because I can tell you that even in the last 2 years, I have scheduled meetings multiple, multiple, multiple times with either no response or, yeah, I don't need to talk to you, or I come and talk to you, I, I ask, you know, I, I do this with every council member that does want to speak with me, you know, is, do you have any concerns about the packet? Do you have any concerns about what's going on? And you may say, yep, I have a concern, and I answer. And I know that I am a quick answer to a lot of things, but at the same time, and then you turn around and you come onto the camera, and it seems like an administration council fight.
And, and I, I honestly believe that the, the respect and communication needs to go both ways. And, and to, to say that I have a clique, Councilmember Pencush, to say that I don't meet the— with the community, if I don't know that there is a problem I can't fix it or even offer to, to ask how to fix it. And, and it is a, it's a standing thing with almost every single one of you as council. I have an issue, somebody in the community has an issue. Well, I'm not going to tell you who has the issue, I just want you to fix it.
I can't fix something if you don't tell me. Like, okay, we have a problem with the leases. Council Member Pankush, I'm not going to say you again. That lease code administration had nothing to do with that lease code. Nothing.
That lease code was drafted by your legal after a commission, a group of you as council. We sat in that. Each one of your meetings, the finance director, myself, the previous city mayor. And at the end of the day, we've sat multiple times and said, your code, you know, we're going to enforce it and it might hurt. But I, you know, to have it be it is the administration's fault or it is the city manager's fault that we're not complying with code or that we have to enforce code is unachievable for me.
I can't wrap my head around it because at the end of the day, I do what I'm directed to do. And sometimes, you know, and I know I can come off, and I've said this to many, many people, my tone changes, and it is because I've reached a point where I've, I've explained it because the code says it. I've explained it how, and I, at the end of the day, I wait for you to tell me. And when I first started here, you did not have transparency. You had 5-page packets that didn't provide you anything.
And, and my goal was to make sure that you as a council had all of the information, the public has all of the information. But again, I, I hear your reviews, I hear your concerns, but I'm going to say, Mr. Denmark, I have tried to reach out to you in the last 6 weeks multiple times with, with continuous requests for meetings. Mr. McAlto, I have not talked to you in one meeting since you have been put on that seat. Mr. Wagner, I have, and I've said this with every single council member, I have been available to you 24/7. I have been available to meet when you needed.
No audio detected at 3:37:30
I have sat with previous mayors every Monday from 5 PM to 9 PM. I have worked every schedule that could work for you. I've offered to meet you wherever you need to be. And the— it needs to go to me. Like, you need to say, okay, here's the communication problem.
For you to tell me that I have a communication problem is extremely hard for me to take because I feel that we have a communication problem because I don't know how to get you to even come and talk to me. I've opened up, uh, city staff meetings that we have every Tuesday. I've said it multiple, multiple times Please, Council, please feel free to attend. Some of you have attended. Community members have attended.
It tells you what we're working on and how we're working on it and how projects are moving forward. And, um, you know, I can't— I can give you the water. I can't make you drink it. I can't— I can't— I don't know how to fix that. I can, you know, have multiple abilities to have public work sessions, but then I'm like, why are you scheduling public work sessions?
So there, there is a municipality side of things and there is a political side of things. And I am— I ethically and morally have to follow what you as a whole say. Code is code. It can be changed. When we change it, you don't like it, then we go back and say, okay, then let's change it again.
But at the same time, we— I'm obligated to to enforce the code. And if I didn't enforce the code, then we would be exactly back to where, you know, when I first got here. Jackie, take care of the leases. Okay, we're, we're taking care of the leases. No, we don't want you to take care of the leases like that.
So I just, I hear what you're asking of me. I hear what you are saying, but at the same time, I believe that I've given you the respect. I've given you the grace. I've asked for the same thing and I don't get it.
My review and my evaluation, I, you know, I honestly provided my own self-evaluation and I find it very interesting that the evaluation itself, the HR said, you know, it's really interesting, both council and administration have said there's a communication problem and it happens in governance, right? I'm like, you're right. We both said it in a different way, right? You don't think I communicate with you or the public, and I don't think there's a way for me to communicate with you because you won't. And I look at the review and I hear it and I've read it and I'm like, okay, transparency.
Hey, give me an example. Tell me how you would like me to be more transparent. But my annual review gave me a score of 3.88. My overall performance was, I believe, I don't have it because I gave it to you, Mr. Denmark, you know, was in the 80 percentile. I, but I also made recommendations of goals for me, and the goals for me are to have the council literally have the ability to say, okay, this is what we really need to work on over the next year.
Here's a goal that I would like, and it's not just the priorities, it's here's a goal that we as a council really want to see in you. Jackie, we want you to get a mentor. What do I do? I exactly do what you asked me to do and what I promised to do. I understand that you don't— maybe you don't like that mentor, but at the same time, I need a mentor that is in municipal government, that has a municipal administration background, not a mentor that, you know, you just think that is a— that should be a mentor for me.
It would be the same as me saying, you know, I really believe every single one of you need a mentor and I'm going to pick them.
Would you take it?
So I, um, at the end of the day, executive session or not, I also would like to point out that over this evening it's been said multiple times that, you know, you just didn't like what happened. That was none of my doing, Mr. Wagner, not one of my doings. Didn't like the way that it was done. Not one of my doing.
I didn't mean to say that. How dare you do that? Not one of my doing.
Nothing over the last 6 months has been of my doing. The last 6 weeks has been nothing of my doing.
I cannot control what people say on social media. I do not control anybody in this community, regardless of what some of the council members believe. I believe that community members need to be heard. I believe that I support, but at the same time, I cannot control anybody, their emotions, their feelings, how they respond on Facebook or social media in general. What social media pages you choose, who decides to come to your council meetings and who doesn't decide, who gets up and speaks in community comments.
I can't— I do not control that, but yet I am being ridiculed for it. I am being judged on what other people's opinions are. My opinion is, I'm sorry you don't like that your community stood up I'm not sorry that the community stood up and said, we hear what you just said. And Mr. Wagner, you are the one who said it. We lost faith in you.
The city has lost faith in you. The community has lost faith in you. And at that meeting, I wasn't even allowed to defend myself, not once. You went into an executive session when I had asked for it to be an open session. I did not get a chance to say, whoa, wait a minute, what What do you mean the community lost faith in me?
And then I'm ridiculed because at the next meeting, in which I was not even in attendance and I did not find out about it until the day before, the community showed up. So please understand that I do follow rules. I know that. I know that there's a difficult part. I've said it before, you know, If it would turn the other way, I'd say let's all get around a table.
Let's yell and scream and leave it sitting on the table and hopefully walk out and go, okay, we're moving in the right direction and we need to do it. And if that's the case and you want to do it, great, schedule a work session. Let's sit right there and scream at each other.
But I can't fix it if you guys don't help me fix it. I can't help with how code is interpreted. I can't help with how, you know, longtime residents feel that I'm not, not helping them. At the same time, longtime residents, I haven't had any of you reach out to me. I haven't had any of you say, here are my concerns.
You've gone to council members.
Not me.
So I just want to say, um, I hope that the council in whole and in general can— we can move forward, you know, mentorship retreat, whatever that looks like, and at the same time understand that I am a municipal administrator, and you are the policymakers, and I follow and go in the direction in which you ask. I will also say to you, Mayor Wagner, that when you say, you know, Jackie promised that she'd sell land, I will tell you exactly what I said, and I've said it for 3 years prior to you and I having the conversation. Man, you know, if the city has land that they don't want to use to trade with the railroad, then let's get it on the market. I would love to do a no foolin' April Fools' we're sellin' property, but I don't get to make those decisions. It would come in front of council, and at the time, council didn't want to hear about selling land.
But what you did ask was for a feasibility study to happen to possible— for possible housing. You approved the feasibility study. So I just want to say again, Mayor Wagner, unless the council as a whole directs the administration to do something, I don't get to make the rules on how that is. I also want to point out that we don't have to do— put anything on the agenda. We do that so we can help continue moving the community forward.
The agenda, you also get to add things, but in municipal government, someone has to create the agenda and someone has to create the projects, and normally it is your administration that does. So I appreciate every single one of you. I value when we are able to talk. I've said it to multiple people, Mr. Pencush, I value when we're able to talk. I value your input.
I value your input, Mr. Denmark. I would love input from you, Mr. Macaltao. Um, Tom, you and I don't always get along, but I also listen. And I listen to Councilmember Loan. I listen to what Councilmember Shen says.
I appreciate, I appreciate Councilmember Borg, but at the same time, I appreciate every single one of you, but you make it extremely difficult to even do my job a lawful way.
Comments. I'm sorry, Mr. Mayor, did you say we're on council comments? Well, we should be, but, um, I don't really see the, the need to separate them right now. Do you still have comments? I mean, uh, Jackie spoke.
Do you have any comments on what she said?
No, not at this time. Thank you.
Maybe one, one thing, Mr. Mayor, and I would ask Councilor Pinquoch to correct me if I'm wrong here, but Um, the city manager, in discussion of the leases, your statement was the administration wasn't involved, not in the code rewrite. Okay, we were not involved in that. I mean, we sat in the room, but we were not involved in the entire discussion. So that was done by legal, uh, and also a couple councilors and an ad hoc committee, correct? Correct.
Yes, it was Councilmember, um, or Mayor Dickerson and, uh, Councilmember Pencush that did the majority of that. And then when we got into discussing that ordinance, it was brought up that components of that ordinance that were suggested by the council committee members We're not included. And then that ensued some conversation about that ordinance while we were approving it at the same time. So just, you know, as a little bit of, uh, retort, you know, this, this came up. And, um, I also raised an eyebrow at one of your initial statements, but it's gotten late and I'm old and I, and I didn't make a note vote fast enough.
But just, I guess, a note on communication that it is— it isn't perfect and it doesn't always translate from, you know, preparation to final product. And from where I sit, that lease ordinance still has some work to do at the same time, which I will hope to get back on the agenda some way, which is, well, some way. But anyway, the process did not produce the result that all the people involved had anticipated.
Mr. Mayor, I hate to interrupt. It is 11 o'clock, and according to our code, uh, all meetings, all regular meetings shall promptly adjourn no later than 11 PM unless a majority vote of the council approves a later adjournment.
Do we have to make a motion? Okay, I, I will, uh, uh, I'll make a motion to extend the meeting We have to specify. I thought it was a half hour.
That's not specified. It's not specified. All right, well, let's, uh, let's just go with a half an hour. I'd like the citizens to be able to speak. A second.
Discussion. Madam Clerk, call for roll. Voting on the motion to extend the meeting by 1/2 of an hour. Mr. Shen? Yes.
Mr. Macaltao? Yes. Mr. Pinquoch? No. Mr. Denmark?
Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mrs. Borg. Yeah, I don't know what she wants. Yes.
Mayor Wagner. Yeah, the motion passes and the meeting is extended by 1/2 of an hour.
Uh, Dave or Jamie, do you have anything else, uh, before we get out of, uh, council comments?
Oh well, I guess, uh, we can go to Council.
Are we done then with, uh, the, uh, 23 center managers review?
Well, Mayor, there's one thing I would say is there has been a lot of discussion about a mentorship, and you mentioned that you might make a motion. So you—. Since it doesn't appear that you're going into executive session, or it doesn't— no one's made a motion for executive session, I would just remind you that that was something that some council members expressed an interest in. So if that is direction you want to give as part of your evaluation, it rolls into the sort of formal evaluation recommendation. It doesn't have to be done tonight.
I just wanted to raise it, so if you wanted to do it, you could. Well, I did want to discuss it tonight. I'm, I'm just completely lost track of what path to do it on. I guess I was going to bring it up in council comments, so I would do it here instead of council comments because we don't generally bring action items and council comments. It's sort of your chance to just sort of summarize something and we don't want to action item.
So if you want to move, or even at this point in time, I think I'm just going to move forward. We'll— we can put it on, you know, next meeting's agenda if that's okay. Go ahead. Okay. Yeah, Miss— well, that aside for a moment, um, and especially since City Manager kind of brought up the summary rating as a function of the review, And, you know, that is, you know, the conclusions here are going to be, you know, a working tool going forward, whether we agree with them or not.
Who are the two people who didn't do the review?
I was one.
Okay, um, so regardless, coming out of our review, some counselors have indicated that there's room for improvement in some arenas. Some counselors think that everything is hunky-dory, things as they should be. No change is necessary. The city manager tends to agree with the, with, with that synopsis. Before you engage into an issue of mentorship, the, if there are areas of improvement, they have to be identified and they also have to be identified in a fashion they can be reassessed.
These are all subjective notions. This is not an easy task going forward. So if we're going to— there's going to be any conversation about mentorship, I think we would need to probably workshop and get some of these noted potential areas of improvement. In the summary of the evaluation finding, they were— the assessment were governance alignment, communication effectiveness, stakeholder engagement needed improvement as a function of this review, and council relationships were inconsistent. And they gave a strong assessment for external relations, project delivery, financial stewardship, strategic leadership, and operational performance.
So on those other four—council relationships, stakeholder engagement, communication effectiveness, and governance alignment—if those are the identified areas of improvement, the difficult question is going to be, how are we going to reassess those issues?
Which would then be fodder for conversation in the next review.
If I were reviewing employees, I mean, this would be kind of pro forma, pro forma thinking.
So anyway, I don't think we're going to get there tonight other than if there's going to be a conversation about mentorship. I think the parameters of that mentorship would have to be discussed.
Right. Some things with mentorship and on topic of moving forward in a constructive way, you know, it seems like a lot of things that we're getting after is not necessarily quantitative aspects. We are hitting— again, you know, we've stated we're hitting our goals, our objective goals that we've set as a council. However, it seems like we are struggling with things that are more qualitative aspects, you know, whatever you want, communication, um, leadership and stuff. And I guess I want to offer verb this statement is mentorship should probably be organic and not necessarily manufactured.
I don't know if you think about in your life and someone that you value dearly as a mentor that you looked up to, that inspired you, it was probably someone you chose rather than assigned to you. Maybe, maybe they're assigned, but eventually you chose them. You know, we're all, you know, we go to school, we have our teachers, we go to work, we have our bosses and our supervisors. But amongst that, you know, most of us probably choose a select few to be someone we would call our mentors. And so I think there is value in having, um, Jackie have a— or Miss Wilde have a, um, uh, involvement in setting something up, setting something like this up.
I, I think you're right, Victor. And, and, and these are nuanced issues. Yeah, if you look at the breakdown, these are all lean towards this objective. But, and so any progress is, will require an acknowledgement by the city manager that these are areas that require work or improvement. For the exercise to bear any fruit at all.
So how we get there, you know, this, you know, I would ask the city manager, you know, how in these inconsistent or needs improvement issues Does she agree with that assessment?
Um, as I said earlier, you know, I've, I've read the evaluation and, um, and the recommendations that, uh, your HR put in, um, but I also believe that it's twofold, right? If I have a communication, I need your guidance to tell me how or what you request. You know, like you said earlier, in a job evaluation with an employee, you give recommendations, you give goals, and, and I see, you know, regardless of, of how you want to perceive what I believe is a mentor, I have to agree with Council Member Shen. I, I look at you know, Mr. Dillon, I look at his background and I look at what his capabilities are, and I see, you know, an individual that has not only looked at building economic development in very small communities, that has created economic development in very small communities, helped recognized, you know, the governance in small communities, has worked with multiple councils and boards over his lifetime. And I've known Mr. Dillon for quite a long time, and I have always considered him as a mentor.
And when, you know, I'm requested to look for one, I see someone that does have that ability that, you know, like he said this evening, you know, he'd love to sit down and talk to every single council member and community members to be able to help mentor me. And that, to me, that is the first start. Like, you either, you know, we find a mentor through AML that, you know, that meets all of your needs and my needs, but I need an administrative municipal government mentor.
And I believe you do too. And I, I don't disagree. So this will— I just, uh, just off the top of my head, I'm not too interested in having— hiring an old friend to mentor one's self. Um, I will tell you, Mr. Denmark, he is not an old friend. He actually did used to be my employer at one point, and as Mr. Shen said, You know, we look at mentors.
I can look in this room and I see mentors sitting in front of me. I see mentors in the audience, and it is not a friendship thing at this point, and it— and to me it isn't. You, you value people, you learn from people because of the interactions that you've had with them or the interactions that they've had in the communities in which they've worked. I've been in municipal government for over half of my life. Those are the mentors that I work with.
Those are—. They're—. And, you know, they're not friends, they're mentors, they're past bosses, past community leaders. I'll agree, this does have to be somebody in government. So, and how we choose this person will need to be determined.
And Councilmember Dinwark, I do think if you call the Municipal League, you can tell them your criteria that you're looking for mentorship with, so that you get a person in government, but also a person because they have their team. I don't actually, I'm not sure that they can do, but I think that's worth a call because you may be able to tell them these are the areas we're looking for mentorship. We obviously want somebody with experience as a city manager, and they may be able to give you a list of names.
Okay, we only have 15 minutes. So does anybody else have a quick, I guess, council comment? Or I'm sorry, we can— we move on to council comments. Let's go there.
And I'm hoping that everybody said what they had to say in the last hour.
Like Tom says, I'm going to shoot from the hip. Usually I write everything down so I don't stutter. Miss Teri Teri, I know how hard it is to stand in front of people and say what's on your mind. It's very hard to even sit up here and say what's on your mind. I was not at the last meeting.
I was on an airplane rerouted by weather.
I want to begin to— I want to begin by thanking the residents who took the time to attend the October 13th meeting. Yes, I'll say this right now, I did say please, if you support your city manager, come and show your support. We have a lot of support people that don't support her that show up. We want to fill— as council members, we want to fill these seats with the people that we're working for. For.
You are our bosses, the community. So I was very disappointed when families came to me and said about the circus. Residents have since shared with me that they felt dismissed by the remark. As a council, we should take that seriously. The words we use from these seats carry weight.
We cannot encourage the public involvement and then speak about it dismissively when residents express views we might not share. Whittier. Respect for public is a responsibility of this office, regardless of where any of us stand on an issue. If signs left in the chamber needed to be addressed, we could have handled that with a simple housekeeping matter. It should not have been on camera.
We set the tone in this room. We are responsible for the example we set. To the residents who participated, thank you. You don't have to agree with me. To deserve my respect and attention.
This is your community. You should be able to leave these chambers knowing your voice was treated with dignity. That's all I have to say.
I'm sorry, was that council comment, or are we still— okay, okay.
I have a couple quick things, um, Mr. Mayor.
Thank you. Um, first, I would just really encourage other council members to attend, or at least watch some of our planning and zoning in Port and Harbor meetings, especially like we had a really cool planning and zoning meeting last night, and it was really great to see administration and the Planning and Zoning Commission and a resident work together to find what I think is a really fair solution, and to see seeing things in action how they should be.
And I mean, there's lots of other topics in all these meetings as well. They're super important that eventually make their way to council. So being informed on the discussion from the beginning saves us a lot of— well, all of us a lot of time, and it helps. It helps with a lot of understanding.
The second thing is is, um, that I don't want to beat a dead horse. And I would say thank you, Mr. Denmark, for your apology, and I think that does matter as well. So I'm not pointing at a specific member, but there were, you know, multiple comments made in that vein after the October 13th meeting. And just, I think that every single one of us, all 7 of us, um, need to remember that we serve the entire community and we can't create a chaos or have an agenda item, um, on the agenda that the community feels strongly about and then call them clowns or scoff at them when they actually show up and like take the time and have the courage to speak up in front of everybody. Um, that just can't be how we think of and how we treat the—.
Mrs. Loan, I think we lost you.
Okay, anybody else, uh, council comments? Go ahead, Victor.
And I'm going to piggyback on Ms. Borg and Ms. Sloan. Um, several years ago, I went to one of the AML conferences, and there you get to meet council members from all over Alaska, and we did this activity where we got our phones and we plugged in some of our greatest challenges working with communities.
And one of the biggest bubbles that popped up was—. Sorry, I don't know when I cut out, but that's fine—. Was community engagement.
You know, they had issues or challenges with community members showing up, being involved, being educated. But right now, you know, I look out there and these past few months, I'm not seeing that. I'm seeing people out here, you know, speaking up, being loud. I love it, you know. And I want to keep seeing it happen.
Don't just come out here because you're worried about losing something or something is at stake. Like, everything is at stake. Keep coming out here. Be loud. Be obnoxious.
Please. Okay, not, you know, for everything.
It's like, um, and with that, with AML, um, a few weeks, few months ago, I suggested doing like, um, a board retreat, um, and I highly recommend, you know, that we do something like that. I think that would be something that would help with our, our team dynamics and leadership dynamics, um, or trust with each other. AML is a great venue for that. I'll go there. I've been going to Alaska Municipal League Conference for probably a decade now, and you'll see whole dinner tables filled with, you know, other communities and their whole councils up there.
And, you know, I don't know people's schedules, but I highly, highly encourage you, if you can make it work, you know, go to that. And if not, you know, maybe we can come up with something else. I think it's, it's pretty critical. I think it's— we, we need it.
That's all. Thank you.
I'm hoping, uh, to get to citizens' comments, so I'm tentatively asking, does anybody else on the council have anything else to say? We've been talking for over an hour.
All right, hearing none, uh, I'd like to move on to, uh, citizens' comments. And, uh, I'm sorry, but I hope there's not a lot of you. You got, uh, 7 minutes.
Mr. Mayor, nobody has signed in. Is there anybody in the audience that wishes to speak? Jim?
No, it's—. Thank you all very much for all your work, everybody. I know it's late, I'm gonna make it quick. Uh, this could be like, um, one of the best nights we've had. Or could be not so good.
We could learn a lot from this kind of situation. I know there's, um, a lot of good support for what's going on here and, um, a good comment.
Um, Mr. Denmark, I think, is on the right trail with a whole new process of evaluation. Unfortunately, she has to be right in the middle of it, but I would highly recommend looking at a whole new process of evaluation and training, training for individuals to perform that evaluation as a tool for guiding, guidance and improvement rather than just a scorecard.
I got a lot to say, but I know it's late. Let's do it right. Thank you guys. Thank you very much.
Thanks, Jamie.
Uh, anybody else in the audience? Ross?
It's been a long night. I'll keep it quick. So earlier, um, this evening, uh, Chief brought up, uh, some volunteers We were recognized. Crystal Sea was there. But there's another phone call that was made that night.
I got the harebrained idea to put a pump on a boat. I got the nod from the boss. I made one phone call and in 10 minutes I had a boat under my butt and we were headed towards the fire. So Lazy Otter, if you're here, raise your hand. Where you at?
Thank you.
I don't want anyone like to— it's a thing, some dude calls you and is like, I need your boat and we're going to drive towards a fire. That's not a normal thing, especially that time of the night. And I mean, a lot of people dodge my call, so thank you. All of us, thank you. So I just want— I want people to hear that, like a community member was like, yeah, let's go do some crazy things and go drive towards the fire.
So thank you, Lazy Otter.
Hi, I'll keep this really quick. Um, had thoughts early on when we first talked about the mentorship. Um, and just real quick, I was up here sitting when you guys— well, actually, no, I was listening to that one, but I heard you all ask ask for the city manager to have a mentor, right? And she said, yes, I'll, you know, I will seek out a mentor. And she sought out a mentor, and she had that person, you know, access information to be able to take time and look at past meetings and minutes and come in, take time tonight to come to this meeting.
Um, and, you know, someone that's seemingly really qualified and, uh, all of a sudden you're saying that's unacceptable. And I don't really understand that. I think she did exactly what she was asked to do. And as someone who is sitting back there a lot, I think, you know, I think we can see some miscommunication, some tension, some stuff and confusion that could be resolved by, you know, people proactively looking for solutions. And I think I think it sounds like Jackie's trying to do that, and I think whatever is decided in a mentorship going into the future and however that's decided, that everyone is like on board for making it happen and trying to, you know, not have like barriers come up.
And, you know, the reaction was pretty strong against that, and it seemed like, like that's not really the way to move forward with trying to make things better. So that was just some thoughts I had and wanted to share. But thank you.
I'll try to make this quick. I'm not very good at that, but I, but I'll try. I think we had major takeaways tonight. I think it was a great discussion. The main theme is that we all have room to improve.
The city manager, the city council, the staff, we all have room as humans. We all have room to improve. So if we just commit to doing better every day I think we can get beyond this. I do want to say I happen to know Tim Dillon. I didn't actually know that Jackie was picking Tim Dillon as a mentor, but he— I think he would be fantastic for Whittier for lots of reasons.
I think if you got to know him, talk to him before you make any decisions, but Tim has a special place in his heart for small business development, and I think I've heard that theme with with council members. They want more of that in Whittier. So beyond mentoring Jackie, I think, um, he would bring a great set of skills to the city. I have worked under 22 city managers. I have it on my phone, the list.
Every now and again I pick it out and pull it out and I read the names off the list. And I will say Jackie is by far the hardest working of all of them. Most of them, council members complain they're never in their office, they're never working. She, she's working constantly on these projects, and so she's not perfect. She and I've had our issues.
I work for Jackie. I'm her employee. I won't always say she's my favorite boss I've ever had. Sometimes I'm like, I— where's the door? You know, we have— but because we have this mutual pushing one another and this group here, I'll say the same about all of them.
They're probably like praying for the day that I'll finally get booted out the door. But because we push each other so hard, and I think, you know, we have a lot of conflict internally amongst ourselves because we're always trying to do better and push each other to be better. So I think a lot of this is just inherent in actually how we all interact as a team, and I think we can maybe do better. Maybe we let that spill out to the community more than we should, and I think we will work on that. One of the things I do want to say I was one of the employees that may have been accused of saying, well, if Jackie goes, I go.
I want to, I want to say what I said. What I said was, being part of this team, we have 6 or 7 people that are doing $100 million of grants in 6 years. Yes, I'm constantly saying that out loud, and I'm not patting us on the back. I'm saying We haven't added one employee. We're doing over $100 million of projects in 6 years with just this team.
Just these people right here. These are the people. And what I was saying is the momentum that we have as a team to get this work done, the money in place to get the projects managed, that doesn't happen overnight. In my career, it's maybe happened 3 times, and it takes 10 years to get a team to the point where they are operating on fumes like we seem to be right now. Where it's like people are sprinkling pixie dust on Whittier and great things are happening.
It's not because of any one of us. It's not because we're so awesome and we're so special, but we as a team work really well together. And so what I did probably say is, if Jackie goes, the momentum of the team will be severely impacted, and I don't have enough life left in me to wait 10 more years to— for the momentum And so if that was misconstrued as me threatening somebody that I was going to quit, that's not at all what I mean. I just mean I literally am at the very end of my career. I've spent 37 years doing this job.
37 Years. It's time for me to go. I know you guys will probably be praying for the day, but I want to see these projects done. We are all working as hard as we possibly can. And Jackie's the heart of the team.
And, and, and with your support, your continued cheerleading, you're continuing to, to lead the way. I think we can accomplish everything on your priority list. I pulled up your legislative priorities list from January 2026, 10 months ago. There were 33 projects on that list. We've finished 20 of them.
And there's 13 projects left. The Comp Plan, small business development, the levy, head of the— head of the bay planning, Smitty's Cove launch ramp, the Whittier Levy, Wordabil, and the military history museum. Those are the things that are left on our list from last year. But I won't get into the, the list of the 24 or 20 projects that we completed. It's astounding, and there's better things to come.
So thank you for your support of all of us. We're working hard. And we're all going to commit to doing better. Thank you.
Okay, uh, unfortunately we are out of time unless we do another extension. Um, Mayor, just one thing, can we make sure that we allow and let the public know that our local volleyball team is playing on Friday at 5 o'clock and again on Saturday right here in Whittier. So please come out and support them. I really, you know, it's something to be very, very proud of. So please, please, just at 5 o'clock on Friday and then again on Saturday, two different games.
Thank you. Is there any further business, Mayor? You postponed the executive session on the other executive session from the earlier meeting for the railroad. Yeah, can you just— can someone move to postpone it, you know, to the next meeting, just to— or just push it? We, we just need to do something with it.
The council needs—. How do we—. Okay, so what would be the, the proper way to do this? That I, I don't know if we want to postpone it to the next meeting. So you could just say, can I have a motion to go into executive session on, um, regarding Alaska Railroad, and then nobody makes a motion and then it That's, that's the other way.
We just have to address it because you really—. So I, I can't— Holly, I'm sorry.
Um, Mayor Wagner, you are absolutely correct. I do not think that you want to wait until the next meeting, but I would recommend that, um, maybe we put out a poll to do a spe— another special meeting within the next, you know, week or after, after the Thanksgiving holiday, but some way for us to be able to give you the information that, um, has been obtained. I'm fine. Say it took 15 minutes. Is that, is that all you wanted though?
That's what you said you needed to get it across to us. Yeah, I don't think that you would need more than 15 minutes. Um, I just need to be able to give you an update, and, um, we need to be able to tell you the what, what is, is, um, working out and what is, what the direction is. Okay, I would rather have another meeting because we still do need to discuss the, um, the coaching, mentorship, whatever, um, we want to call it. And, um, there's some explanation that still needs to be done with that.
I don't have the energy or the time right now to do it, but anyway, um, it, it does need to be addressed. So if we could kill both birds with one stone.
Um, you guys going to hate me. You guys just going to send out a doodle poll? I'm going to make a motion to extend the meeting 15 minutes so we can just hear this.
I will second. Take longer than 15.
It's 3:35 in Florida, and so I'm still up, so I'm I'm, I'm up for going through it if you guys are.
Mr. Mayor, you have a motion and a second to extend the meeting by 15 minutes.
Discussion?
Hearing none, uh, I'm for call roll. Voting on the motion to extend the meeting 15 minutes. Mr. Shen. Mr. McAlto? Yes.
Mr. Pincush? Yes. Mr. Mayor? Yes. The motion passes and the meeting is extended 15 minutes.
Would you like to entertain a motion to enter into executive session to discuss the Alaska Railroad Corporation land purchase as per Whittier Municipal Code 2.08.040.
I'll make the motion. No seconds. Discussion?
Mayor, if you don't mind, can I ask legal if they are wanting to stay in this executive session or get out? Oh, I don't care. Just if that— I just don't know if she is like, does she want to get out? She I mean, I would— these are the questions I have. Do you need me, uh, for this executive session?
Then the other thing is we have to be very careful with conflicts of interest when we're addressing any of these issues regarding the railroad and any kind of property acquisition, especially because we have 2 council members that are involved in— that are— that work for an entity that is— and is the one of the parties to leasehold interests and other interests we have with, with the Alaska Railroad. So I just want to make sure, if I am not going to stay here, I am trusting all of you to remember that and to remember that we do not participate in things where we have a substantial financial interest. And on that, I am out, and I trust you.
I will say my contract with you is only seasonal. It's only seasonal, so my, my contract with Hoonah is over as of right now.
So Holly, is— okay, actually I'll direct this at you. Is this just an update? Are we— is there, is there going to be actionable items coming out of this or something? And Mayor, you may go into executive session, for example, and this is why I say I trust you, I'm not trying to be facetious, you may go in and say, wait a minute, I think we're talking about— and I don't know that that will happen, but at any point points as we deal with the exchange, both you and Councilmember Sloan, uh, Councilmember Long. But I, I think that actually with the contract clause that we still want to think about it each time.
That doesn't necessarily mean there's no conflict, so we'll have to talk about it. I think it will foreclose the conflict. Ellie, just be aware, just stay and we'll make sure to get you through after the executive session. I, I think that that is better for everyone. Um, that makes me involved.
We do trust you. There's, there's 6 minutes left of this 15 minutes. Um, I would also, um, Mayor, um, ask that, uh, the finance director, the harbormaster, and the public works director, the assistant city manager, and myself be allowed to stay in your executive session. Everybody can stay.
Voting on the motion to enter into executive session. Mrs. Loan? Yes. Mr. Shen? Yes.
Mr. Pincush? Yes. Mr. McAlto? Yes. Mr. Denmark?
Mrs. Borg? Yes. Mr. Mayor? Yes. The motion passes and council enters into executive session at 11:39 PM.
Mr. Uh, Pincush and Mrs. Loan, I'm going to move you into an executive session uh, a breakout room. Oh my goodness, Mr. Dillon, thank you.
You're welcome. Good night.
No audio detected at 4:32:00
No audio detected at 4:34:00
No audio detected at 4:36:00
No audio detected at 4:38:00
No audio detected at 4:40:00
No audio detected at 4:40:30
Apologies for the, um, silence. I'm going to restart because, uh, we were muted. I apologize. So, uh, motion was made by Mrs. Borg and seconded by Mr. Shen to exit executive session. Voting on the motion to exit David Pinquoch.
Yes. Mrs. Loan. No, no, just kidding. Yes. Mr. Denmark.
Mr. Denmark. Mr. Mayor.
Yes. The motion passes, and council exits executive session at 11:51 PM.
Uh, is there any further business?
No. Be adjourned.
Good night.
No audio detected at 4:42:30
Speakers in this transcript
David Pinquoch
Council Member · Whittier City Council
Jackie C. Wilde
City Manager · City of Whittier
Jamie Loan
Council Member · Whittier City Council
Lori Borg
Council Member · Whittier City Council
Renner Macaltao
Council Member · Whittier City Council
Tom Wagner
Council Member · Whittier City Council
Victor Shen
Council Member · Whittier City Council