Skip to main content

AI image

Senate advances Kyle Reardon toward confirmation to Alaska's last open federal judgeship

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews
3 min readAlaska

The U.S. Senate voted Friday to advance a nominee for Alaska's last open federal judgeship, a seat empty since its last judge resigned in 2024 over findings that he created a hostile work environment for his law clerks.

If senators confirm the nominee, Anchorage magistrate judge Kyle Reardon, in a vote that could come as soon as Nov. 30, Alaska's three-judge federal trial court would be at full strength for the first time since 2021.

That court hears federal criminal cases in Alaska and federal lawsuits over the state's land and resources, including the Willow oil project and the Ambler Road. For 19 months, Chief Judge Sharon Gleason was its only active judge, with senior judges carrying part of the load, until Judge Aaron Peterson arrived after his confirmation in February.

Every no vote Friday came from a Democrat; on the Judiciary Committee, Democrats had pressed Reardon on who won the 2020 election. Republicans lose their Senate majority in January, and one Republican senator vowed Friday to finish confirming district judges before then.

The seat belonged to Joshua Kindred, whom President Trump appointed in 2020. In May 2024, the Judicial Council of the Ninth Circuit, which handles misconduct complaints against federal judges in Alaska and other Western states, found that Kindred had created a hostile work environment for his law clerks and had an "inappropriately sexualized relationship" with one of them during her clerkship. It also found he received nude photographs from a federal prosecutor who practiced before him, and that he lied to investigators throughout the inquiry.

The council publicly reprimanded Kindred, asked him to resign and told the Judicial Conference, the federal courts' national policymaking body, that his conduct might be grounds for impeachment. He resigned effective July 8, 2024, the day the findings became public.

Defendants in cases he handled sought new trials over his undisclosed conflicts with prosecutors, and several federal judges granted them. The Alaska Supreme Court disbarred him in November 2025.

His departure left the court down two of its three judges; Judge Timothy Burgess had taken senior status, a form of semiretirement, in late 2021, and his seat stayed empty until Peterson's confirmation more than four years later.

Trump picked Reardon in August. He has been a magistrate judge in Anchorage since 2021, after six years as an Army judge advocate and 15 years as a federal prosecutor, seven of them in Alaska.

The Senate voted 55-31 Friday to end debate on his nomination. Sens. Lisa Murkowski and Dan Sullivan were among 49 Republicans voting yes, joined by six Democrats. Murkowski was one of 18 senators who signed the motion to end debate.

The Senate Judiciary Committee sent his nomination to the floor 16-6 on Nov. 10, with four Democrats voting yes. At Reardon's September hearing, Sen. Richard Blumenthal said he would oppose the panel's nominees because they wouldn't say who won the 2020 popular vote.

In written follow-up questions, Sen. Dick Durbin, the committee's top Democrat, asked whether Trump lost the 2020 election. "Pursuant to the procedure established by the 12th Amendment, President Biden received a majority of electoral college votes and served as President from January 20, 2021, until January 20, 2025," Reardon wrote.

Asked by Sen. Alex Padilla about Biden's certified margins in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and four other states, he wrote, "I am not personally familiar with the certified vote counts for any state in the 2020 election." Reardon wrote that he named the certified winner to be "factually accurate, legally precise," and to avoid violating the judicial code of conduct's limits on political activity.

Under an agreement the Senate reached Friday, no debate time remains on the nomination. The majority leader will set the confirmation vote with the Democratic leader, no earlier than Monday, Nov. 30.

Democrats won control of the Senate in this month's election. Sen. James Lankford, R-Okla., said on the floor Friday that "we will not stop until we get all of the district court judges done in this session within November and in December, before January 3."

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: U.S. Senate.