Skip to main content

Photo: United States Senate Photo Office via Wikimedia Commons · Photo source · Public domain

Murkowski and Sullivan vote to confirm Louisiana judge to a federal appeals court

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews(3h ago)
2 min readWashington D.C.

Alaska Sens. Lisa Murkowski and Dan Sullivan voted Tuesday to make Anna St. John, a federal trial judge in Louisiana, a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, a lifetime appointment.

The Senate confirmed her 52-46 along party lines, according to the roll-call record. Every Republican who voted said yes; every Democrat and independent who voted said no. Two senators, a Democrat and a Republican, didn't vote.

Had both Alaska senators voted no and everyone else voted the same way, she still would have been confirmed, 50-48.

Federal appeals courts sit one step below the U.S. Supreme Court. They hear appeals from federal trial courts, and the Supreme Court reviews only a small fraction of their decisions. The Fifth Circuit covers Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. Alaska is in the Ninth Circuit, so St. John won't hear Alaska cases. Under the Constitution, the Senate must confirm every federal judge, and judges serve for life.

St. John will replace Judge Kurt Engelhardt, who is retiring, according to the nomination record.

It's the second time this year the Senate has confirmed her. President Donald Trump nominated her to the federal trial court in New Orleans, and the Senate confirmed her 51-45 in March, also with Murkowski's and Sullivan's votes, according to the March roll call. She has served on that court since April.

Before becoming a judge, St. John was a senior lawyer at the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute's Center for Class Action Fairness, which challenges class-action settlements it considers unfair to consumers. She graduated from Louisiana State University and Columbia Law School.

Attorneys general from 11 states, including Louisiana's Liz Murrill, wrote to the Senate Judiciary Committee in support. They credited her work with returning more than $100 million to consumers and shareholders.

The National Employment Lawyers Association, which represents workers, opposed her. It cited her 2022 testimony to Congress defending arbitration, a private process some employers require workers to use instead of going to court.

The Senate voted 49-26 on Nov. 12 to end debate on her nomination, a step called cloture that sets up a final vote. Both Alaska senators voted yes, according to the cloture record.

The vote came the day after Murkowski and Sullivan helped confirm Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit, 51-46. Alaska's own nominee for its federal trial court, Magistrate Judge Kyle Reardon, was still waiting for a final vote as of Monday.

Sullivan's term ends in January. Alaska News and The Associated Press have called his seat for Democrat Mary Peltola. By the AP's count as of Tuesday, Democrats and two independents who caucus with them will hold 56 seats in the next Senate.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: United States Senate, United States Senate: Senate Vote 265: PN1181-7, Confirmed.