Skip to main content

Photo: Rsparks3 via Wikimedia Commons · Photo source · CC0

Petersburg hears testimony on pausing data centers that need more power than it has

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews(23h ago)
4 min readPetersburg, Alaska

The Petersburg Borough Assembly takes public testimony Monday night on a pause that would block borough permits for data centers needing more electricity than the town's utility can supply today.

Under the ordinance, the pause would run through Sept. 30, 2027, for new or expanded data centers that fail any of three tests. They must fit within power Petersburg Municipal Power & Light says it has available now. They can't rely on generators for normal operation. And their cooling must be fully self-contained and closed-loop.

Data centers that pass all three could still get permits.

The Assembly advanced the measure 5-1 on Nov. 2. Monday's hearing is its second of three readings.

Data centers are buildings full of computer servers that run around the clock and have to be kept cool, so they use a lot of electricity. Petersburg's utility buys hydropower from the Southeast Alaska Power Agency, whose grid also serves Wrangell and Ketchikan.

The proposal at the center of Petersburg's debate is small. Developer Andrew Mazzella of Mazzella Alaska and the California firm Greensparc want to put a data center in the former Ocean Beauty cannery, which closed in 2016, using the site's existing 2-megawatt transformer.

In May, the utility's director at the time, Carl Hagerman, told the Assembly the project would bring the utility about $2 million a year and help keep rates stable. He said there was ample power, with a third turbine planned at the agency's Tyee Lake hydro plant in 2027. The company said it was willing to cut back during peak demand.

Residents at that meeting asked what would happen in low-water years, and whether power promised to a data center would be missing when the borough needs it for new housing.

In September, the Planning Commission recommended a one-year pause on data center permits so the borough could write rules for power, water and noise. Mazzella said the project would not survive a year's delay and warned of lawsuits. "A year from now, this is off the table," he said.

The Assembly deadlocked 3-3 on that pause Sept. 21, defeating it. On Oct. 5, members asked for a narrower version, the one now before them.

That night, utility director Stephan Harbour said the cannery site already has power service for 2 megawatts. The substation couldn't carry a bigger load without changes, he said, and those would be the developer's responsibility.

Mayor Bob Lynn, backing the grid limit, said, "There's no way that you're going to have a big data center because of power requirements."

Tara Pavilla, president of Mazzella Alaska, told the Assembly on Nov. 2 that the project is small, uses closed-loop cooling and is already permitted at the state level. She said it would bring the utility revenue, pay for engineering on grid upgrades and could put its waste heat to use.

Others want the borough to go further. Assembly Member Jeff Meucci voted against the ordinance after his amendment to pause all data centers failed 3-3.

Meucci cited a power agency presentation that discussed a data center of 5 to 15 megawatts somewhere on the shared grid. "There's interest to put a bigger data center in on the grid to take up any excess power," he said. He also said, "I am not going to sell my soul for $1 million or $2 million coming out of electrical rates."

Notes from the agency's Oct. 29 board meeting, included in Monday's agenda packet, say Mazzella Alaska proposed buying power from the agency for a possible data center. The board wanted more discussion.

Resident Becky Knight, who has said she opposes any data center anywhere in the borough, said Nov. 2 the measure "reads more like a de facto conditional use permit" than a pause, because data centers that meet its conditions could go ahead. She asked for a ban of at least a year with no exceptions.

Other Alaska towns are writing their own rules. Houston's City Council stopped data center permits for two years in October. Fairbanks North Star Borough Mayor Grier Hopkins has proposed a pause on large data centers through 2027. In Sitka, the Planning Commission recommended banning them in every zone in October; the city's Assembly has the final say.

Some utilities want them. Cordova's electric cooperative is pursuing one to use hydropower it can't sell.

Under Petersburg's ordinance, power counts only if the utility confirms in writing that it is available now. Capacity that depends on future facilities, upgrades, approvals or allocations doesn't count, and neither do generators. Backup generators could run only during a grid outage or when the utility orders a data center to cut its load.

Cooling systems couldn't use evaporative cooling towers or once-through water cooling, or routinely discharge to the environment or a sewer. Dry air cooling would be allowed.

The pause would cover borough building, electrical, plumbing and land use permits. It would take effect as soon as it is adopted and apply even to applications already pending. Mazzella Alaska says it submitted its building permit package Aug. 10. In October, borough officials said they did not have a complete building permit for the project.

The borough manager would report back by June 21, 2027, on the effects of data centers on the environment, the economy, emergency services and the grid, and on what rules the borough might need.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: Petersburg Borough.