Photo: APK via Wikimedia Commons · Photo source · CC BY 4.0
Justice Department says its Alaska Senate suit is moot and asks court to erase its loss
The Justice Department told a federal appeals court Thursday that its lawsuit over Alaska's U.S. Senate race is moot, because the ballots it wanted set aside were mixed together on Election Day.
The department "reluctantly acknowledges" that there is no longer any way to determine whether votes for Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher who shares the senator's name, were meant for Sen. Dan Sullivan, according to its brief.
It wants the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to throw out the lower court's order and send the case back to be dismissed as moot. That would end the case while erasing the department's loss, rather than leaving the ruling against it standing. Even if the case isn't moot, the department argues, there's at least "a substantial question" about that ruling.
The brief answers Common Cause, the League of Women Voters of Alaska and two voters who joined the case as defendants. In a Nov. 9 motion, they asked the court to uphold the dismissal without full briefing, called the department's legal theory "embarrassing and indefensible" and asked that its lawyers be ordered "to explain why they or their client should not be sanctioned for pursuing a frivolous appeal." The department called that request "overheated" and said sanctions aren't warranted. The court hasn't ruled.
The department sued in October, asking the court to preserve ballots and block certification if the senator lost by fewer votes than Daniel J. Sullivan received. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case Nov. 1, finding the department hadn't shown any order she could give would fix the harm it alleged without compromising the secret ballot. The department appealed the same day.
The scenario it sued over didn't happen. By the Nov. 14 count, Democrat Mary Peltola led the senator by 11,213 votes, more than twice Daniel J. Sullivan's total. She passed 50% of first-choice votes in the Nov. 17 count, and The Associated Press and Alaska News have called the race for her. The state aims to certify the results Nov. 25.
The brief says the voter confusion the department alleged was caused by Daniel J. Sullivan's campaign, "egged on by Peltola's." Peltola's campaign has denied recruiting candidates, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee has denied involvement, and Daniel J. Sullivan has said he entered the race on his own.
The civil case is separate from a federal criminal investigation into the circumstances of Daniel J. Sullivan's candidacy, which U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman confirmed Oct. 30. Heyman wouldn't say who is under investigation or which laws are at issue.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: DOJ moves to end Alaska Senate lawsuit; criminal probe remains unresolved.















Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.