Skip to main content

Frame from "Anchorage Assembly: PlattingBoard: Live" · Photo source

Board clears a Chugiak rental that zoning allowed but a 1979 map note blocked

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews(51m ago)
3 min readChugiak, Alaska

The Anchorage Platting Board on Wednesday cleared the way for a Chugiak homeowner to build a small rental beside his house. The lot's zoning allows such a unit, but a 1979 note on the subdivision's map limited it to single-family homes.

Rick Larson wants to add a detached one-bedroom, one-bath unit on his Chamber Lane lot. The lot's zoning permits accessory dwelling units, a second, smaller home on the same lot, by right, according to the city's staff report.

But the subdivision's recorded map, called a plat, carries a note from 1979: "Lots are restricted to single family dwellings." Changing or removing a plat note takes a Platting Board public hearing, so Larson asked the board to remove it.

He applied in July, with Jennifer Cheri as co-petitioner. City planners reviewed the request, other agencies weighed in and the Planning Department mailed 98 hearing notices to the area. On Wednesday, the board held a public hearing and voted. No one from the public commented or testified.

Before building, he must record a resolution with the state Recorder's Office and show the city proof. Any new building also needs a land use permit.

The Assembly loosened its rules on accessory dwelling units in 2023, and Mayor Suzanne LaFrance has set a goal of 10,000 homes built or rehabilitated in 10 years.

Board member Kevin Cross, a former Assembly member, said he helped write and sponsor that 2023 rule change, and that Larson's plat note directly conflicts with it.

"We make these ordinances and then we can't execute them," Cross said. "It's also ironic that you could build a 12,000-square-foot house on your lot, but you can't have a 3,000-square-foot house with a 900-square-foot unit next to it."

In 1979, plat notes offered protections in the absence of land use rules, and this one limited uses the neighborhood's infrastructure couldn't support then, city planners said. Today's code already sets what can be built on the lot, so removing the note wouldn't reduce protections or add strain beyond that, they found. The lot runs on a well and septic system, and the city's on-site water and wastewater section didn't object.

The fix covers only Larson's lot. Board members asked whether it would reach others bound by the same 1979 plat, and staff said it would not. Cross said he'd like to see the note removed for the whole subdivision.

A draft ordinance requested by LaFrance and tied to her housing goal would let the Planning Department decide plat note changes without a Platting Board hearing, keeping the same approval standards and the right to appeal. The draft doesn't say how neighbors would be notified without a hearing date. The Planning Department has asked the Planning and Zoning Commission to take it up Dec. 14, and the Assembly would have the final say.

Platting Board minutes record four plat note cases earlier this year with no public testimony, all approved unanimously, including an East 43rd Avenue homeowner's request to build a unit over a garage.

Larson told the board he plans to run the unit as a short-term rental. He said he wants the extra income. "I'm getting older and in construction and my body can't do this anymore," he said.

"Nobody seems to have any issues with us doing a small Airbnb," he said of his neighbors.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byLucas Brown

This article is based on a public meeting of Municipality of Anchorage — Anchorage Assembly: PlattingBoard: Live ().

Sources

Based on: View Transcript

This article cites 220 chunks.