AI image
Alaska Supreme Court says sibling presumption covers blood siblings separated by adoption
The Alaska Supreme Court ruled Friday that when judges review where a foster child should live, they must start from the presumption that keeping a relationship with a brother or sister is in the child's best interest, even if the sibling was adopted by another family and the two have no established relationship.
The decision settles a question the court had left open: whether a blood sibling still counts after adoption cuts the legal tie. It does, the justices said, and the siblings don't need an established relationship for the presumption to apply.
Requiring a relationship first would make the presumption much narrower, Justice Jude Pate wrote for the court, "functionally excluding infants" who may not be able to form relationships beyond the people caring for them. It could also discriminate against older siblings whose developmental disabilities might impair their ability to form relationships, he wrote.
The ruling came in a dispute over where a young girl in state custody should live: with the Alaska foster family she was placed with as a baby, or in Tennessee with the family that adopted her older sister.
The Office of Children's Services took the girl into its care in July 2023, when she was a month old, and placed her with local foster parents who aren't related to her. OCS had taken custody of her older sister about a year before she was born. The sister has lived since 2023 in Tennessee with a cousin of the girls' father and her family, who adopted her in October 2024.
In August 2024, OCS proposed moving the younger girl to Tennessee permanently. The agency set up weekly video calls and in-person visits to prepare her; three visits took place. Her mother opposed the move, and the mother and foster parents resisted the visits.
In November 2025, Superior Court Judge Kristen Stohler in Palmer blocked the move, finding clear and convincing evidence that it would be against the girl's best interests, and denied the relative's petition to adopt her. The judge didn't apply the sibling presumption, reasoning that the sisters hadn't established a relationship, so there was nothing to maintain. The judge acknowledged that living apart would "likely interfere in their ability to form a sibling relationship" but found that didn't outweigh the other factors, including the girl's bond with her foster family.
Less than two weeks later, the Tennessee relative asked OCS directly to place the girl with her. The agency said no, pointing to the judge's ruling, and the judge denied her request for a new hearing for the same reasons.
The Supreme Court threw out that denial and sent the relative's request back to Palmer, saying the judge should have applied the presumption. It didn't rule on the earlier order blocking OCS's proposed move, and it didn't decide where the girl should live. A presumption can be overcome by other evidence, the court said, but a judge has to start with it. The Palmer court must now decide, with the presumption in place, whether there is good cause to pass over the relative, and the justices noted that circumstances may have changed during the appeal. The girl is now about 3.
Alaska law tells OCS where to look first when it places a child: an adult family member, then a family friend who meets foster licensing requirements, then a licensed foster home, unless there's clear and convincing evidence of good cause to do otherwise. The Palmer judge found the Tennessee relative counts as a family friend, based on her distant family tie and friendship with the girl's father, which puts her ahead of the foster parents in that order. When OCS turns down a family member or family friend, that person can ask a judge to review the decision, and OCS has to prove it had good cause by clear and convincing evidence. Friday's ruling says the sibling presumption applies at those hearings, too.
The Legislature added the presumption in 2012. It says a court "shall recognize a presumption that maintenance of a sibling relationship, including with a sibling who is related by blood, marriage, or adoption through one parent, is in a child's best interest." The Supreme Court has said it isn't a preference for placing siblings together. It covers their relationship more broadly, including but not limited to sharing a home. A separate law requires OCS to try to keep siblings together if they were living in the same home when the state took custody, but it didn't apply here because the sisters weren't living together when OCS took the younger girl.
In 2022, the court assumed the presumption covered siblings separated by adoption without deciding it. In this case, the girl's mother argued the presumption didn't clearly cover the sisters, pointing to a provision on OCS records that spells out that an adopted-away sibling remains a sibling, language the presumption lacks. The justices rejected that, saying the words "related by blood" make clear which siblings count and that the records provision's definition applies only to that provision.
OCS, which had proposed the move, didn't take part in the appeal. The mother was represented by the state Public Defender Agency and the Tennessee relative by Northern Justice Project, an Anchorage law firm.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
Source: Alaska Supreme Court, Alaska Supreme Court: S19665, S19745: Kelly R. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family and Community Services, Office of Children's Services, and Stacy S., Kelly R. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family and Communi.













Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.