Skip to main content

AI image

Alaska Supreme Court says sibling presumption covers blood siblings separated by adoption

by Maggie AlaskaNews(8m ago)
2 min readPalmer, Alaska

The Alaska Supreme Court ruled Friday that judges must presume a foster child benefits from keeping a sibling relationship with any blood sibling, even when adoption has legally severed the tie and the two children have never formed a bond.

The opinion vacates a Palmer superior court order and sends a placement fight over a young girl in Office of Children's Services custody back for new proceedings. The court also held the presumption applies at hearings where relatives and family friends challenge an OCS placement denial. Justice Pate wrote the opinion.

OCS took custody of the girl, called Sunny, in July 2023, when she was one month old and had tested positive for methamphetamine. OCS placed her with local foster parents Tina and Ralph Ward, who have no familial relationship with Sunny. Her older biological sister, Brianna, had been placed with Kelly and Brian Randall in Tennessee, where Kelly is a cousin of the girls' father. The Randalls finalized Brianna's adoption in October 2024.

OCS proposed moving Sunny to the Randalls permanently in August 2024. Her mother, Stacy S., opposed the move. Superior Court Judge Kristen C. Stohler blocked the transfer in November 2025. When Kelly asked again, OCS said no and the court denied her a new hearing.

Under state law, OCS must place a child with an adult family member, then a family friend, then a licensed foster home, unless there is good cause otherwise. The superior court found Kelly is a family friend, which gives her a higher placement priority than the Wards.

Stohler found the sisters had no established relationship, so there was nothing to maintain, though she acknowledged separate homes would "likely interfere in their ability to form a sibling relationship."

The Supreme Court called that legal error. The sibling presumption does not require an existing emotional or social relationship, the court held. Requiring one, Pate wrote, would narrow the law, "functionally excluding infants who may not have the capacity to form relationships outside of their immediate caregivers."

Stacy argued the law does not clearly cover siblings separated by adoption. The court rejected that argument.

The Alaska State Legislature added the sibling presumption in 2012. In a 2022 case, the court assumed the presumption reached adopted-away blood siblings without deciding the question, and it has separately said the presumption does not itself require placement in the same household. A presumption can be overcome by contrary evidence, the opinion said, but a court must first apply it.

The justices did not decide where Sunny should live or whether there was good cause to keep her from Kelly. That question returns to Palmer, where the judge must now apply the presumption.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: Alaska Supreme Court, Alaska Supreme Court: S19665, S19745: Kelly R. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family and Community Services, Office of Children's Services, and Stacy S., Kelly R. v. State of Alaska, Department of Family and Communi.