Skip to main content

Kenai: 2026-11-17 Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting

Alaska News • • 63 min

Articles from this transcript

Kenai planners approve Beaver Loop gravel pit below the water table

Kenai approved a gravel pit below the water table off Beaver Loop Road, with smaller buffers growing the dig area 53%.

Cover image for article: Kenai planners approve Beaver Loop gravel pit below the water table

No audio detected at 2:58

No audio detected at 4:58

8:09
Speaker A

You're on the record.

8:14
Jeanne Keaton

I would like to call the November 17, 2026 Planning and Zoning Commission meeting, special meeting, to order. If you are able, please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance.

8:26
Jeanne Keaton

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

8:43
Speaker A

Clerk, could you please call the roll? Thank you, Chair. Commissioner S. Lee. Present. Commissioner Krause is absent.

8:53
Speaker A

Commissioner Fikes is absent. Commissioner Woodard Here. Vice Chair Douthit is absent. Chair Keeton? Here.

9:04
Speaker A

Commissioner Askin? Here. You have a quorum.

9:10
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you. The approval of the agenda and consent agenda.

9:18
Jeanne Keaton

Motion to approve. Second. Thank you. Are there any objections? Can we ask for unanimous consent?

9:29
Speaker D

Ask consent?

9:32
Jeanne Keaton

Yes. And we don't have any revisions. Okay, great. Could the clerk please read the consent agenda items into the record? Thank you, Chair.

9:43
Jeanne Keaton

The approval of minutes, regular meeting of October 28th, 2026, and that is your consent agenda. Thank you. Are there any public comments on any of the consent agenda items just read by the clerk? Anybody online? There is nobody online.

10:00
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you, sir. Unanimous consent was requested. Are there any objections? Thank you. Hearing no objections, the agenda and consent agenda are approved.

10:16
Jeanne Keaton

Scheduled public comment. We have no scheduled public comment this evening. Unscheduled public comment— is there anybody from the public wishing to speak to anything that is not on the agenda? Are there any attendees remote? There are not.

10:33
Jeanne Keaton

Okay, great. Uh, consideration of PLATS— we have no PLATS for consideration. Public hearings— that brings us to public hearings. The first public hearing before us tonight is Resolution 2026-39, grant granting a conditional use permit for the extraction of natural resources on parcel 490490168. Is there a motion to approve Resolution PZ-2026-39?

11:04
Speaker D

Motion to approve. Thank you. Resolution 26— 2026-39. See, it's not just me. Second.

11:13
Jeanne Keaton

All right. And Director Buettner, can we have the staff report, please? Thank you, Chair Keeton.

11:23
Kevin Buettner

And in a manner to keep this— keep it fairly brief, we did hear this one approximately a month ago. The applicant was not in attendance, so we had to postpone indefinitely, but nothing drastic has changed. So I'm just going to read a little bit over the summary, some highlights over the analysis, and then our recommendation. The applicant has applied for conditional use permit and a variance permit for the construction and operation of a gravel pit and extraction within the setback for the proposed surface extraction of natural resources pursuant to KMC 1420.151 through KMC 1420.157. The applicant is requesting that CUP allow for excavation below the water table, stating it is a common practice in the area and there's active excavation below groundwater at adjacent material sites.

12:11
Kevin Buettner

In conjunction with the conditional use permit, the applicant is requesting a variance to KMC 1420-154A2 regarding buffers to the public rights-of-way and property lines due to the use of adjacent properties as material sites. The variance requested is 50-foot buffer to the northeast, west, and south. This variance will be heard later in this meeting as a separate resolution.

12:33
Kevin Buettner

Oh, our analysis going through KMC 1420-154. Um, each of these findings, uh, all the criteria were met, um, that the application is in substantial compliance with the requirements of the chapter, um, that the boundaries of the proposed excavation at its greatest dimensions, including back slopes, are at least 200 feet from any road or public right-of-way, and at least 150 feet from other surrounding property lines, except that adjoining permitted surface extraction of natural resource sites. Are not required to maintain the above 150-foot excavation between sites. There are two in the packet, there are two different maps. One is for this CUP that shows all of these, and the second one is with the variance application later in, later in this meeting in the packet that will show if the variance is granted what that outline would look like.

13:28
Kevin Buettner

So there are two different versions floating around. The buffer strips between the excavation site and roadways— property lines contain sufficient natural screening to obscure the entire excavation from sight of roadways and inhabited areas. If there is not sufficient natural screening, the site plan must provide for artificial screening.

13:47
Kevin Buettner

The proposed extraction site is north of an adjacent gravel pit and is not visible from Beaver Loop Road. Additionally, there's a tree line creating a natural barrier to the south of both pits. The site plan provided by the applicant shows an existing tree line remaining along the periphery of the property during excavation, which will provide sufficient natural screening. Efficient natural screening of the property.

14:06
Kevin Buettner

The surface extraction is outside of the 1% annual chance flood zone or the 100-year floodplain and the 1/5% or 0.2% annual chance flood zone or the 500-year floodplain and high-hazard coastal areas.

14:23
Kevin Buettner

Um, it is a current classification for the project location under FEMA's latest floodplain maps dated February 28th, 2025. Is x-ray uniform, which is undefined. The City of Kenai's floodplain administrator has reviewed the application and has no comments. The site plan provides that back slopes be a minimum of 2:1 slope, except for the contiguous working face. Um, the applicant does show that reclamation will be a continuous process, including sloping the sides of the excavation, uh, 2:1 or flatter along buffer zones and inactive work areas, and that a 4-inch minimum topsoil mix, organic cleaning, clearing debris, and seeding to contain erosion.

15:02
Kevin Buettner

Site plan does not provide for excavation below the water table, except where reasonable method of drainage is available at the particular site, or where the proposed future development plans provide for a lake on the site of excavation. Um, final configuration of the site will be similar to most material sites in the area, with ponds forming in areas worked below the water table and haul routes adapting as the site is further developed. The final development plan envisions a lake on site and the reclamation of shorelines. That would allow for houses or RV parking spots around the parking ponded area.

15:36
Kevin Buettner

Uh, the excavation is below the water table. The site is, um, and site is likely to endanger public safety. Site plan shall provide for fencing of the work area. Casual access is not anticipated as the proposed site is rural and surrounded by large tracts of wetlands to the north and other material sites to the east and south. The applicant plans to construct berms as ponds are created during operations to provide or prevent vehicles, equipment, people, or animals from going into the water.

16:02
Kevin Buettner

And staff does not anticipate that the site will present any danger to public safety.

16:08
Kevin Buettner

The proposed use of land after extraction is completed is feasible and realistic and is a use permitted in the zone in which the property is located.

16:19
Kevin Buettner

Applicant estimates the timeframe to be approximately 20 years in total until it's exhausted. A majority of the gravel is located below the water table. The final development will be to reclaim the shorelines of the ponds, establish grass or other vegetation, and construct locations for houses or RV parking sites around the ponded areas. Reclamation will include grading and recontouring back slopes using overburden and topsoil to a condition that allows for reestablishment of natural vegetation. Staff finds that this adequately addresses a feasible and realistic use of the land once extractions of natural resources on the site cease.

16:58
Kevin Buettner

Extraction does not destroy the land for the purpose for which it is zoned. City staff have discussed the importance of ensuring clean water supply in the city, and the applicant will take measures to monitor water levels and be mindful of what is allowed near water and sensitive areas of the landscape. Applicant notes equipment and construction debris will not be disposed of in surface water. They will also plan to seed slopes with plants suitable for Alaska conditions and limit erosion and dust that could affect the landscape.

17:26
Kevin Buettner

As stated in the previous criteria, no permanent structures are planned to be erected, which will leave the parcel vacant and ready for future development. An example of successful reclamation can be found in the Lake Kenai subdivision east of this project along Beaver Loop Road. That the need for the particular natural resources outweighs any detrimental effects the operation may have on surrounding property owners.

17:50
Kevin Buettner

Um, majority of the parcels surrounding the subject lot are also utilized as material extraction sites, and there are no residential properties in the immediate area. The city and its residents will benefit from the additional local gravel resources in this location. Uh, the applicant is the owner of the subject property. Uh, the proposed parcel was recently conditionally sold by the City of Kenai in the 2026 land sale auction to River Resources LLC. The applicant is petitioning on behalf of the owner of the subject property to satisfy a condition of sale.

18:19
Kevin Buettner

And clearing limits shall be delineated on site plan as well as clearly visible on site and shall be inspected by the city planner or designee prior to the application being deemed complete. Submitted site plan adequately clearly shows proposed clearing limits. Prior to application being deemed complete, city staff will meet with the applicant at site to ensure the proposed clearing will align with those submitted on the site plan.

18:41
Kevin Buettner

They also have findings for the conditional use permit that the use is consistent with the purpose of the chapter and purposes and intent of the zoning district. It is in the rural residential zone, pursuant to KMC 1420-080. The intended zone is intended for low-density residential development in an attractive residential, residential environment to prohibit uses which would violate the residential character of of the environment or generate heavy traffic in predominantly residential areas and separate residential structures in order to prevent health hazards and preserve the rural open quality of the environment. Surface extraction is a conditionally permitted use and can be consistent with the intent of the residential zone, especially when the reclaimed property is developed to allow for future residential uses. The proposed extraction is adjacent to existing permitted gravel pits and vacant lots.

19:33
Kevin Buettner

It would not change the character of the neighborhood. This use is consistent with the current development and once reclaimed will meet the purpose and intent of the rural residential zone.

19:43
Kevin Buettner

Value of the adjoining property and neighborhood will not be significantly impaired. Um, Jason, property to the north is undeveloped wetland zone by the City of Kenai and Alaska DNR. Adjoining properties to the east and south are all material sites. Staff does not find that the value of adjoining properties or the neighborhood will be significantly impaired as it aligns with the current uses of the immediate area and existing haul routes off South Baker Street and tracks Horseshoe End, a River Bend subdivision, will meet up and follow existing routes. Uh, proposed uses in harmony with comprehensive plan, uh, classifies the subject property as parks, recreation, open spaces, defined as intended for public recreational facilities as well as undeveloped lands that provide for the conservation of natural scenic resources.

20:27
Kevin Buettner

These areas can be used for a variety of passive and active outdoor and indoor sports and recreational activities. Areas that may be suitable for future natural resource development may be included in this category. Location of site minimizes the potential for conflict with neighbors as it fits with the pattern of land use along the north side of Beaver Creek Road. Therefore, staff finds the proposed use would be consistent with the intended purpose of the comprehensive plan. Specifically, goal 2, to provide economic development to support the physical health of Kenai, with objective ED1.

20:58
Kevin Buettner

Promoting projects to create workforce development opportunities. Goal 3, land use, is to develop land use strategies to implement a forward-looking approach to community growth and development. Uh, land objective LU-1, establishing siting and design standards of development is in harmony and scale with surrounding uses. LU-11, where feasible, consolidate access to and between land uses via frontage roads or by shared driveways onto main streets and highways.

21:25
Kevin Buettner

Public services and facilities are adequate to serve the proposed use.

21:31
Kevin Buettner

Um, yes. River Resources members own and operate the 36.14-acre material site immediately south of the subject lot. The parcel will be utilized to access the proposed material site from Beaver Loop Road as well as from South Baker Street. This does not increase the amount of potential conflict points along Beaver Loop Road. Additionally, the applicant will have sufficient sanitation facilities located on site.

21:55
Kevin Buettner

City staff finds that the proposed services and facilities are adequate to serve the proposed use.

22:01
Kevin Buettner

The proposed use will not be harmful to public safety, health, or welfare. Casual access to the property is not anticipated, as it is surrounded by large parcels of similar use and is not situated near any amenities such as fishing, parks, or recreation. The applicant notes that the adequate existing barriers and screening will be utilized. The extraction site will not be a safety concern or visual impairment. The applicant has shown plans for reclamation and will be mindful about materials stored near any water sources.

22:28
Kevin Buettner

Criteria 6, any specific conditions deemed necessary by the Commission to fulfill the above-mentioned conditions should be met by the applicant. Um, these are listed at the end of the report. Staff finds that the proposed conditional use permit for the surface extraction of natural resources on the property described as Lot 1 Bear Creek, Homer, Alaska, Beaverloop Acres, Addition Number 3 subdivision meets the criteria for issuance of a conditional use permit as set forth in subsections E-1 through E-6 of Kenai Municipal Code 142150 and subsections A-1 through A-12 of KMC 142154, and hereby recommends that the Planning and Zoning Commission adopt Resolution PZ-2026-39 approving the conditional use permit subject to the following conditions: 1, any development or use of the property shall comply with all applicable federal, state of Alaska, and city regulations regardless of whether or not the requirements are listed as conditions for the approval of the conditional use permit. 2, That the applicant will properly store fuel, oil, and hazardous materials away from wetlands or other sensitive areas of landscape. 3, The applicant will not store fill materials such as concrete or construction waste in or near areas with an exposed water table.

23:34
Kevin Buettner

4, The applicant will limit noise disturbance and not use compression release engine brakes, or known as Jake brakes. Applicant will adhere to proposed hours of operation, 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM, with the allowance of outside hours being utilized on an as-needed project-specific basis and not ongoing.

23:50
Kevin Buettner

5, The applicant will meet with city staff for onsite inspections when requested.

23:57
Kevin Buettner

6, If there's expansion or change of use for the subject property, a new conditional use permit must be obtained as stated in KMC 1420.150, and permit holder will submit a yearly report between October 1st and December 31st to the Planning and Zoning Department that includes a summary of the onsite activity.

24:19
Kevin Buettner

And that could, could lose my report.

24:43
Speaker F

Sorry, Scott Foster, Soldotna, Alaska, and I'm a member of River Resources LLC, the applicant, or the owner, I should say, and happy to answer any questions you might have. How about you tell us a little bit about the project? Well, it is just north of a material site that we've been operating out of, or I say we, my father's the one that owns it. It's been operating out of it since Bear Creek since I started working 25 years ago. That's basically mined out, and a lot of the gravel for the City of Kenai is coming from farther away.

25:21
Speaker F

So we're really excited to be able to have a material site closer to the City of Kenai and reduce some costs for Kenai residents and projects for the City of Kenai as they come up and be able to develop and be able to do so more economically.

25:39
Jeanne Keaton

Great, thank you. Does anybody from the Commission have any questions for this gentleman?

25:52
Jeanne Keaton

Is there anybody from the general public that would like to speak besides the owner? No. Okay. Are there any remote attendees? There is nobody online.

26:03
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you. Seeing no one or no one else, we will bring this back to the Commission for discussion from the Commission.

26:24
Speaker A

Uh, Clerk, can you please call the roll? Thank you, Chair. Commissioner Krause is absent. Commissioner Fikes is absent. Commissioner Woodard?

26:34
Speaker A

Yes. Vice Chair Douthit is absent. Chair Keeton? Yes. Commissioner Askin?

26:41
Speaker A

Yes. Commissioner Ursley? Yes. There are 4 yes votes. PZ-2026-39 is approved.

26:53
Jeanne Keaton

Okay, please note there's a 15-day period that an aggrieved party can file an appeal with the clerk's office.

27:00
Jeanne Keaton

Moving on to item E2, resolution number PZ2026-40, granting the application for a variance permit to build into the setbacks for expanded extraction of natural resources on parcel 04901068. Is there a motion to approve the resolution? Motion to approve resolution PZ2026-40.

27:28
Jeanne Keaton

26-40. Second. Thank you. Director Buettner, can we have your staff report, please? Thank you, Chair Keeton.

27:35
Kevin Buettner

The applicant is proposing a 100-foot excavation into the 150-foot setback to the north and west, and 150-foot into the 200-foot setback on the east and south property lines adjacent to Ridgeway. This will leave a 50-foot setback on the northeast and west boundaries and 100-foot setback along the southern boundary.

27:58
Kevin Buettner

Pursuant to KMC 1421-80A, the intent of variance permit is to provide relief to the development requirements of KMC 1420 when the literal enforcement would deprive a property owner of the reasonable use of his or her real property. Prior to granting a variance permit, the Commission shall find that all the conditions have been met as set forth in KMC 1421-80C. Variance permit review criteria. Criteria 1, that special conditions or circumstances are present which are peculiar to the land or structures involved, which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the same land use or zoning district. The variance permit is being requested to best utilize resources of the current area.

28:37
Kevin Buettner

The properties adjacent to the east and south are currently permitted material sites, and the property to the north and west are undeveloped wetlands owned by the City of Kenai and Alaska DNR. The special conditions or circumstances have not been caused by actions of the applicant, and such conditions, circumstances do not merely constitute pecuniary hardship or inconvenience. The proposed request is consistent with that of adjoining properties. There are no special conditions or circumstances caused by the actions of the applicant, and the request does not merely constitute a pecuniary hardship or inconvenience.

29:10
Kevin Buettner

Criteria 3: The granting of the variance shall not authorized a use that is not a permitted principal use in the zoning district in which the property is located. Proposed use is conditionally allowed within this current zoning district, subject to obtaining a CUP. The applicant is in the application process of obtaining the CUP in conjunction with the variance request, and the use is appropriate given the surrounding existing material extraction sites adjacent to the subject lot. The variance request does not alter the principal use of the area.

29:38
Kevin Buettner

The granting of variance shall be minimum variance that which will provide for the reasonable use of the land and/or structure. The proposed buffer of 50 feet along the north, east, and west boundaries and 100-foot buffer along the southern boundary would still allow for an adequate divide between sites while allowing for a better utilization of land space. Stated by the applicant, the granting of the variance request is anticipated to expand the usable material site area from 14.65 acres to 22.43 acres, an increase of 53%. The granting of a variance shall not be based upon other nonconforming land uses or structures within the same land use or zoning district. The request variance is not based on other nonconforming land uses or structures within the same land use or zoning district, and will not alter the principal use of the property that is approved with the granting of the CUP.

30:26
Kevin Buettner

Pursuant to Kenai Municipal Code 1420-280, notices of the public hearing for the variance permit were mailed to property owners within a 300-foot periphery of the subject property. City staff published notice of the public hearing in the Peninsula Clarion on November 6th, 2026. Pursuant to KMC 1422-AD-D, no sign was posted on the subject property as there are no improved streets adjacent to the subject property. No public comment has been received at the time of the report, and there are no stated objections. Staff finds that the proposed variance request meets the criteria for issuance of a variance permit as set forth in Kenai Municipal Code 1420-180-C. And hereby recommends that the Planning and Zoning Commission approve the variance permit, subject to the following conditions: the applicant must comply with all federal, state of Alaska, and local regulations, and the applicant must obtain applicable permits and follow all required landscape and site plans prior to beginning construction.

31:16
Jeanne Keaton

That concludes my report. Thank you, Director Buettner. Is there anybody from the general public that would like to speak to Resolution PZ-2026-40?

31:29
Speaker F

Welcome back. Thank you. Scott Foster, Soldotna, Alaska, River Resources member. I'm happy to answer any questions you may have.

31:41
Speaker F

Tell us what you're doing. Well, the 200-foot buffer seems appropriate for, you know, residences or commercial vehicles or, I mean, commercial businesses or even public rights-of-way where there's lots of traffic. But in this situation, I feel the buffer would— it's not necessary, and that in order to reduce the amount of material sites that are needed to supply gravel to the community, that if we expand the usable mining site, that it can reduce the amount of material sites necessary to supply the community with resources like gravel.

32:29
Jeanne Keaton

Sounds good.

32:34
Jeanne Keaton

Anybody have any questions? Great, thank you.

32:45
Jeanne Keaton

Are there anybody, anybody online? There is not. Are you here to speak on this? Nope. Okay, okay.

32:55
Jeanne Keaton

Um, seeing no one or no one else, we will bring this back to the commission. Discussion from the commission?

33:08
Jeanne Keaton

Looks good.

33:13
Speaker A

Um, Clerk, could you please call the roll? Thank you, Chair. Commissioner Fikes is absent. Commissioner Woodard? Yes.

33:22
Speaker A

Vice Chair Douthit is absent. Chair Keeton? Yes. Commissioner Askin? Yes.

33:29
Speaker A

Commissioner Earsley? Yes. Commissioner Krause is absent. You have 4 yes votes. PZ-2026-40 is approved.

33:40
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you, Clerk. Please note there is a 15-day period that an aggrieved party can file an appeal with the Clerk's Office. This moves us on to G, unfinished business. We have no unfinished business. And, uh, H, new business.

33:55
Jeanne Keaton

That brings us to new business. The first item is Resolution PZ— excuse me— 2026-41, granting a request for the transfer of conditional use permit PZ 97- 24 for a coffee house/restaurant. Is there a motion to approve the conditional use permit transfer? Motion to approve PZ2026-41. Second.

34:23
Kevin Buettner

Thank you. Director Buettner, can we have your staff report, please? Thank you, Chair Keeton. All right, the Planning and Zoning Commission granted a conditional use permit, PZ97-24, to Mario Fano on June 25th, 1997, for a coffee house. The business has been open since 1997 and has changed ownership numerous times, as evidenced by the transfers of the conditional use permit as set forth below.

34:48
Kevin Buettner

On September 8th, 2004, by resolution PZ-0438. December 10th, 2008, by resolution PZ-08-61.

35:01
Kevin Buettner

December 11, 2013, by Resolution PZ1338. On June 8, 2026, it was transferred to Mary S. Dulling, and on October 2017, 2017, transferred to the transferor, Stephen Pfeiffer.

35:22
Kevin Buettner

On October 23, 2026, an application for transfer of conditional use permit was submitted by the transferee Brian Yeager prior to Kenai Municipal Code is set forth below. KMC 1420.150: A conditional use permit is not transferable from one parcel of land to another. Conditional use permits may be transferred from one owner to another for the same use, but if there's a change in use on the property, a new permit must be obtained. KMC 1420.157: No conditional use permit issued hereunder shall be transferred until the proposed Proposed transferee has made the application for transfer in writing filed with the administrative official, which application shall state that he intends to be bound by the plan and statements complained in the application of the permit holder, or shall contain the amendments to the plan his proposed operation would mandate. The Commission shall approve the application for transfer and in doing so amend the site plan statements if such amendments are contained in the application for transfer would have been approved had they been contained in the original application.

36:19
Kevin Buettner

Brian Yeager, the transferee, has indicated he agrees to operate under the terms and conditions of the original conditional use permit PZ97-24. The designation of the use is being updated from coffeehouse to restaurant to current— reflect current zoning and land use terminology. This administrative change does not constitute a change in the approved use of the property or alter the terms and conditions of the original conditional use permit PZ97-24. Staff hereby recommend approval of the transfer of conditional use permit PZ97-24, subject to the following conditions. In development or use of the property shall comply with all applicable federal, state of, state of Alaska and city regulations, regardless of whether or not the requirements are listed as conditions for the approval of the conditional use permit.

37:01
Kevin Buettner

If there is an expansion or change of use in the subject property, new conditional use permit must be obtained, stated in KMC 1420.150. Permit holder will submit a yearly report between October 1st and December 31st to the Planning and Zoning Department. That includes a summary of the onsite activities. And fourth, in accordance with the amendment to the original conditional use permit, no operations may take place from 6:00 PM on Saturdays to 12:00 PM on Sundays. That concludes my report.

37:29
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you, Director.

37:38
Jeanne Keaton

Is there anybody from the public that would like to comment on this?

37:44
Jeanne Keaton

Uh, if you're the owner, we would love to hear from you. Please, hi, push the button so we can record your voice. Thank you. Hi, pleasure to be here. I'm Brian Yeager, owner of Veronica's Cafe and Coffee.

38:03
Brian Yeager

Bought it on October 1st and I've been trying to get it up and running. Gotcha. I'm almost there. My goal is December 1st.

38:16
Brian Yeager

I might even be open before that if everything goes right. But if you have any questions, I do plan on changing hours on it. I did hear about Saturday, 6 p.m. to Sunday noon. For no operations, is that correct? Did I understand that?

38:36
Kevin Buettner

Through the chair, uh, we, we did dig that up when we were looking through the history of this property. I think at the time there were some conflicts between these—. I guess. The. Street with the Russian Church.

38:49
Brian Yeager

Yeah, I would be very willing to work with them in any way I can, um, but I do have a parking lot in the back. If I could see about opening during that time, because I do have plans on making the restaurant— the cafe similar to a restaurant. I want to be open from 7 AM to like 9 AM at night. I want to introduce breakfast and dinner during a short time period of operations. It's not like a full hourly restaurant.

39:23
Brian Yeager

Um, but that is my goal for Veronica's, and I hope that it is welcomed. Do you plan on this being seasonal, or is it going to be year-round?

39:40
Jeanne Keaton

Any questions from the commission?

39:43
Jeanne Keaton

No, that just answers my question. My friend and I tried to go over there several times this summer. It was always closed. So glad to say that it's opening.

39:55
Brian Yeager

Should be open shortly.

40:00
Jeanne Keaton

Okay, uh, are there any other people that would like to comment? Clerk, are there any remote attendees wishing to comment? There are none. Thank you. Would you like to add something?

40:16
Brian Yeager

Red, but hey,. I'm good. Just to let you all know, I'm going to be adding like hot sandwiches right now. I'm going to operate with a lunch menu, but I will be introducing hot sandwiches on the menu, shakes and different things like that during this time. Beautiful, beautiful.

40:33
Jeanne Keaton

Um, anything else?

40:41
Jeanne Keaton

Okay, I really want to get open. We'll see what we can do here. Hang on just a second. All right, uh, seeing no one else, we'll bring this back to the Commission. Discussion from the Commission?

40:55
Speaker C

Through the Chair, do we have to, um, change the staff recommendation line item number 4, um, with the hours of operation?

41:07
Kevin Buettner

Through the Chair, if the body would like to remove that, I think it's my interpretation from reading back through all of this, that one of the main concerns is the initial parking situation on that, on that parcel would have conflicted when the church was in session. And I think with the rear parking lot on that parcel, I think that's kind of gone away over time, but it is still technically part of the record. So if the Commission would like to recommend removing that restriction, they could, because that would be Um, let me see.

41:46
Kevin Buettner

I just had it too, because pursuant to KMC 1420.157, the Commission could approve the application for transfer and in doing so amend the site plan and statements if those amendments would have been approved had they been contained in the original application. So it is within your prerogative if you'd like to consider it.

42:10
Speaker D

So do we make that as an amendment?

42:13
Speaker D

Okay, I would like to move that we amend, um, recommendation number 4 to, um, not restrict those hours on the 6 PM on Saturday to 12 PM on Sunday.

42:31
42:37
42:43
Speaker C

Okay, uh, Clerk, can you call the roll for the amendment, please? I got one more question. Okay,. Um, when the transfers of the CUP happened in each consecutive year prior, um, to the June 8th, 2016, um, there was a resolution to support that, and that's not noted in the report.

43:06
Kevin Buettner

Uh, that's correct. There were a couple times where they were transferred with an action approval, which does not follow. Um, that's why we're back to resolutions, because resolutions live on in the record. We have the minutes to the meeting, so we know things happen, but, um, tracking those, we were digging them up. So that's why we went with a resolution on this one, to keep everything, and also listing everything in the most recent resolution kind of helps us follow this throughout time.

43:32
Speaker C

Thank you.

43:36
Jeanne Keaton

Clerk, can we call the roll on the amend— on the amendment, please, of number 4? Thank you, Chair, for the amendment. Commissioner Askin? Yes. Commissioner Keeton?

43:48
Speaker A

Yes. Vice Chair Douthit is absent. Commissioner Ursley? Yes. Commissioner Krause is absent.

43:54
Speaker A

Commissioner Fikes is absent. Commissioner Woodard? Yes. There are 4 yes votes for the amendment. The amendment passed.

44:05
Jeanne Keaton

Okay. And on the original PZ-2026-41 as amended, Clerk, could you please call the roll? Thank you, Chair. For PZ-2026-41 amended, Commissioner Woodard. Yes.

44:23
Speaker A

Vice Chair Douthit is absent. Commissioner Keeton? Yes. Commissioner Askin? Yes.

44:29
Speaker A

Commissioner Earsley? Yes. Krause and Fikes are absent. We have 4 yeses. PZ-2026-41 is approved, uh, as amended.

44:43
Brian Yeager

Thank you guys. I hope to see you there, and I'm very excited. Thank you. You're very welcome. Thank you.

44:50
Jeanne Keaton

We are now on to Item H2, action approval recommending City Council remove public purpose designation on Kenai Peninsula Borough parcel number 03906141 to accommodate disposal recommendations in the City of Kenai Land Management Plan. Uh, let's go ahead and open the discussion if anybody Peter Micciche has some comment.

45:21
Speaker D

Couple things. It looks like there's a narrow right-of-way to it. Is that correct? And none of that road has been developed.

45:32
Kevin Buettner

Peter Micciche.

45:41
Jeanne Keaton

Do we have to do a motion first? I might— we do that just so we can open for discussion. Okay, so is there a motion for council recommendation to remove the public person designation— the public purpose designation on parcel number 03906141?

45:59
Speaker D

Motion to approve, uh, recommendation Kenai City Council remove public purpose designation on Kenai Peninsula parcel.

46:13
Jeanne Keaton

03906141. Second. Okay, great. Director Buettner, can we have the staff report, please? Sure.

46:22
Kevin Buettner

Um, so staff report's on page 48. Um, pretty self-explanatory, so I'll probably just jump to the maps to answer the first question we had.

46:32
Kevin Buettner

Um, on page 52 of your packet is the aerial map that has 03906141. There are two small access points to this parcel. None of that has been developed. Spur Drive is not developed in this area. Iliamna to the north on the other side of those, a trail might be calling it generous, but it is not a— it is a right-of-way, but it's not formally developed, is not maintained by the city.

47:04
Kevin Buettner

Um, so we're not intending to replat or anything at this time. If that were to happen in the future, those little access points would probably be distributed somehow during that, um, replat action. Um, but on page 53, uh, I zoomed out just a little bit, and there's another parcel that's about 4.25 acres to the east, which is 0391-3202.

47:32
Kevin Buettner

Um, that is between 4th and 5th Street. Um, we've done some recent replatting where you see Texas Avenue. That's where KPHI has their low-income and senior housing. So you're seeing some multifamily in that area. There's other, uh, multifamily that's going in along Readout.

47:49
Kevin Buettner

And then to the northeast, that kind of surrounds two-thirds of that parcel, is a large 64-acre tract that the city owns that We intend for more probably single, single-family residential, possibly duplexes, some sort of larger development, probably akin to Windhaven, Inlet Woods, something of that style in this general area. So we felt that the— even though we're asking to get rid of the public purpose designation on 6141, we still have a public purpose one on 3202, which is the one to the east. So we wanted to show that we're not trying to just rip a park away. The Parks Master Plan did say that this area is underserved by a park, and I think as this neighborhood develops, that would be a good place for a good-sized park. I'm not gonna call it a central park, but for that neighborhood, it'd be, you know, very centrally located.

48:42
Kevin Buettner

So we didn't want to take away one thing without trying to give something else back to the community. So that's why we're asking. This is just gonna help us get in line with the new land management plan. That we're requesting adoption of so that we can move forward is, uh, because the other thing we were thinking about with 6141 is because those lots are so small, um, right now there's no water and sewer in that neighborhood, so this area is just not getting developed. A potential replat in the future could make lots big enough that they could have well and septic, and we might be able to start getting a few, you know, a few houses in that area versus Nothing.

49:20
Kevin Buettner

That's currently in.

49:24
Speaker D

How many acres is that? I didn't see in the list.

49:32
Kevin Buettner

2.32 Acres for the small one, and the one to the east is 4.24, I believe. Just shy of 4.25. Thank you.

49:44
Jeanne Keaton

Anybody else? Any other questions?

49:54
Jeanne Keaton

Is this going to be near the— or sorry, for Director Buettner, is this going to be near the trail that goes from 4th to 5th?

50:06
Kevin Buettner

Uh, no, those are, uh, 4th Avenue, 5th Avenue over by Woodland. This one will be up off Redoubt. Um, closer to where First and Second—. Oh, that goes like. North-south,.

50:17
Jeanne Keaton

Florida, California. Thank you. Um, is there anybody from the general public that would like to speak to council recommendation to remove the public purpose designation on parcel number 03906141?

50:35
Jeanne Keaton

Clerk, is there anybody online? There is not. Okay, seeing no one, we will bring this back to the Commission. Discussion from the Commission?

50:46
Jeanne Keaton

Okay, I, I'll say that I like the idea of putting in public amenities, even if they're not fully, fully developed, like with fancy playgrounds and everything, like we have the one over on 3rd. That's a— or 4th, at the end of 4th. That's a nice little soccer field next to Floatplane Road where the families from the high-density housing there can all collect and have their birthday parties and that kind of stuff. I think it's great that we put places for people to enjoy our summers because they're kind of short. Thank you.

51:19
Jeanne Keaton

Um, would anybody like to do unanimous consent, or would you like me to call it? I'll just, uh, dodo that. I think a park area would be wonderful right in the middle of a neighborhood like that.

51:34
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you. I'd like to request unanimous consent. Second. Okay, are there any objections? Seeing none, um, the motion is— or the— sorry, the council rec— the council recommends to Remove the public purpose designation on parcel number 03906141 is approved.

52:11
Jeanne Keaton

Next, we have item H3, action approval, recommending city— Kenai City Council adopt the 2026 City of Kenai Land Management Plan. Is there a motion to approve the recommendation of adopting the 2026 City of Kenai Land Management Plan?

52:30
Speaker D

Motion to approve the City Council adopt the 2026 City of Kenai Land Management Plan. Second. Director Buettner, can we have your staff report, please?

52:44
Kevin Buettner

In June 2026, we undertook the task of updating our land management inventory and recommendations, which is called our Land Management Plan. There have been land auctions and sales. And some updated data from the Kenai Peninsula that rendered our current land management plan just inaccurate. It just wasn't up to date. There are several recommendations in the land management plan— in that plan that had not been implemented up to this date.

53:10
Kevin Buettner

Some were only completed recently in the past few months. So we felt it was in the best interest of the city to have an accurate representation of all of our lands. So the big things that we did, we updated definitions and the structure of the plan. As a whole, updated maps where we have sold or gained land over time. We updated the tables, and then there's a narrative section for each different portion of this plan.

53:40
Kevin Buettner

So big things that we did: the introduction background, we elaborated on the definitions of what the general fund and the airport fund are, how they are in the city. We changed the retention status to recommendations because we felt, um, this plan should be geared towards potential developers, um, businesses, landowners. Um, and so we wanted to show what the intent was, um, what council's intent was of that. So if they recommended that it be held for a public use for a park or a well or something like that, that that's clearly designated We would track down the legislation that put that in place so that if it were ever to be changed, we know where to look.

54:24
Kevin Buettner

We would also specifically call out if it's available for lease, if it's unavailable because it's currently leased, and whether an option to purchase after development is possible because there are certain lands that we cannot sell that are close to the airport, but then there are some that we can. We also wanted to note where there are potential development opportunities. So maybe the parcel is 10 acres and maybe the entirety isn't suitable for development, but there could be upland portions that could be. There could be— there's one at, I believe, Readout and the Spur. There's a little triangle of land, it gets really narrow, but it's part of a much larger parcel that's zoned recreational.

55:05
Kevin Buettner

So the southern portion may— we may want to keep 'cause we, if we expand the sports complex or something like that, we would want to keep that land. But maybe that triangle would be good for commercial development right there at the corner. So just looking at potential areas where, um, once it's subdivided, it may be able to be opened up. So, um, we did go all the way through. We had 46 maps in the original one.

55:27
Kevin Buettner

Um, due to some land sales, that's dropped to 44. Um, we had some duplicative information in where we had like a quick reference table and then a larger table, and So we reformatted what those tables look like and got rid of one section. So we've actually chopped 40 pages out of this plan but put more information in it. So don't ask me how that happened. I can't tell you.

55:49
Kevin Buettner

But most of it you'll see is just a lot of just restructuring. I do have a printed copy. I had one down here and then took it back upstairs because I wasn't thinking. So if you'd like, give me just a couple minutes, I can go grab a copy for you guys to browse through. That'd be up to you if you At your pleasure.

56:05
Kevin Buettner

Is it available online? It is not available online, only because it was in a draft format. Uh, it's 182 pages, which is why we didn't put it in the packet, because it would have made the packets, uh, quite substantial. But, um, the current draft is up there, and once it's approved, uh, it's going in front of council tomorrow night. It would be published immediately thereafter.

56:27
Jeanne Keaton

Thank you for your report.

56:30
Jeanne Keaton

Um, we made a motion to approve this council recommendation. And is there anybody from the general public that would like to speak to approving this council recommendation of adopting the land management plan? There is nobody online. Okay, thank you, sir. Seeing no one, we will bring this back to the commission.

56:53
Jeanne Keaton

And is there any discussion from the commission?

56:57
Jeanne Keaton

No. Okay, did we request unanimous consent? No. Okay. I'd like to request unanimous consent.

57:05
Jeanne Keaton

Well, thank you. Second. Thank you. Are there any objections? All right, great.

57:13
Jeanne Keaton

The state— the— I'm sorry, Council recommendation of adopting land management plan is approved.

57:27
Kevin Buettner

Reports, Planning Director. Planning Director Buettner, may we have your report, please? Sure. A couple cool things. So last week, before the airline meltdown, I did make it to Chicago and back.

57:40
Kevin Buettner

I was representing the State of Alaska Planning Association chapter. It's for all the chapter presidents, but our president couldn't make it, so she's like, hey, VP, how about you go? And I'm like, I don't know what I'm doing. Um, anyways, it was a, it was a good way to interact with a lot of the chapter presidents from around all 50 states. Um, learned a lot.

58:03
Kevin Buettner

I think there's a lot of stuff that we can bring here to Alaska, but there's a lot that Alaska could teach other areas. Um, my current favorite ones are my new friends in Idaho and Montana and Utah. So I think they'll have some good sharing of ideas throughout that. Our state planning conference is next month on the 7th and 8th. It'll be in conjunction with AML up in Anchorage.

58:26
Kevin Buettner

So if you happen to be at AML, pop in for a session or two. Trying to make it— I think next year we're going to have the commissioner training back up. This is our first one in about 3 years, so trying to get it bite-sized for now, but we're definitely going to have more commissioner training starting next year. So looking forward to that.

58:47
Jeanne Keaton

Excellent. Thank you. Commissioner Fikes is not present. I have no report. Sorry.

58:56
Speaker F

Council Member Kissena, would you like to give us a report? Of course. I was just making a note to thank you tomorrow for representing us. We have to come with a long list of things to show appreciation for because someone always beats you to some of them, and then you have to Still recognize people.

59:19
Speaker F

So I think you've met since— not since our last meeting, but since the one before, so I won't cover that. Let's see here, where did it go?

59:35
Speaker F

Okay, we adopted the 2027 City Council regular meeting schedule. We approved the administration's request to provide comments to the state of Alaska regarding that their preliminary findings for the Kenai Loop Gas Natural Storage Lease. That's a pore space lease. Scheduled a work session to discuss the city's first 5-year strategic plan. That work session is December 16th at 5:00 PM if anyone is interested.

1:00:05
Speaker F

Scheduled a Board of Adjustments appeal for the P&Z Commission's decision to grant a COP for cabin rental at 502 Ash Avenue, and that is going to be on November 30th at 5:30. Um, similarly, we have another appeal on December 1st at 5:30 for the CUP Cabin Rental at 1123 Walnut Avenue. Uh, and then the mayor declared October 2026 as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. And those were kind of the big ones. In case it was missed in the last review, I just wanted to also recognize Chief Teague and his deputy.

1:00:52
Speaker F

They had recently applied for a pretty substantial grant. Let me pull up the notes here because it was, it was pretty impressive that they received just over— well, they received $435,000 in grant funds. And they won out of 1,500 applicants for that, that money. So this is going to be cardiac units, portable ventilators, portable CPR units, ultrasound equipment, infusion pumps for our ambulance service. So in case you hadn't heard that, I just thought that was amazing.

1:01:32
Jeanne Keaton

You know, round that to half a mil in funding that they were able to compete for and get. So So that was a cool piece of news. So yeah, I think that's it for me. Thank you so much. It is encouraging to me as well to see smaller agencies be able to develop the service that they can provide to the community because we're not right next door to major facilities.

1:01:59
Jeanne Keaton

And I think it's important that we have a good air game, right? Being able to get people to the planes that they need to be on to get to the big hospitals. I think that's fantastic. Okay, is there any additional public comment? Are there any members from the public who would wish to address the commission at this time?

1:02:18
Jeanne Keaton

There is nobody online. Thank you, sir. The next meeting notification is December 15th. Please to also notice that this is also on a Tuesday.

Speakers in this transcript