Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions: Business meeting to consider the nominations of Mark Priebe
Alaska News • • 35 min
Articles from this transcript
Senate panel votes 12-10 to advance Priebe as Education Department inspector general
Senate panel voted 12-10 to advance Mark Priebe as Education Department inspector general, over claims he retaliated against a federal officer and sought an improper bonus. • Same panel also advanced two other nominees, 12-10 each, over similar objections. • Murkowski's vote on Priebe wasn't recorded. Full Senate still must vote.

No audio detected at 0:00
No audio detected at 2:00
No audio detected at 4:00
No audio detected at 4:10
No audio detected at 6:10
No audio detected at 8:10
No audio detected at 10:10
No audio detected at 12:10
No audio detected at 14:10
No audio detected at 16:10
No audio detected at 17:50
The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions will please come to order. Um, Last night, the White House abandoned a viable confirmation path for Dr. Heidi Overton for FDA, saying that she didn't have the votes to pass, which was pretty odd since there were productive conversations taking place. And I think she would have had the votes to pass out of committee and to pass the full Senate. Personally, my conversations with her convinced me that she would follow the science and push back against decisions that put Americans' life at risk. The other issue was that pro-life senators sought reassurances from the administration regarding the administration's commitment to life issues.
No audio detected at 20:20
They chose not to make such commitments and ultimately withdrew Dr. Overton. Unfortunately, with the limited time left, confirming a permanent FDA commissioner appears to fall to Senate Democrats. I'm sure my colleague doesn't mind that, but, uh, for those of us who on this side We'll also not consider the nomination of Jim O'Neill as acting CDC director. Mr. O'Neill did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements from Secretary Kennedy. His role in the firing of Dr. Susan Menares raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF.
Several members of the committee had concerns regarding this. I like Jim personally, but this time requires leadership and fortitude in standing up for what is right. As for the other nominees, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission needs a general counsel who will enforce federal civil rights laws in an even-handed manner and give all workers the legal representation they deserve. Katherine Eisbach is that person. Her legal experience in private practice, judicial clerkships, and significant pro bono work on behalf of domestic abuse victims will serve her well in the role for which she is nominated.
As Acting General Counsel and Principal Deputy General Counsel of the EEOC, Ms. Eschbach has the experience needed to be successful. Michael Doyle is another qualified nominee. As a member of the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission, he will be tasked with reducing the backlog of cases and improving the timeliness of decisions while serving as a fair and neutral arbiter of disputes between OSHA and employers. He brings with him a valuable 20-plus years of legal experience at the Department of Labor. I also look forward to supporting Mark Privy's nomination to be Inspector General of the Department of Education.
Mark has proven himself capable, as he has been successful as Acting IG for almost a year and brings more than 22 years of experience in auditing, financial management, and government oversight with him. I have full confidence in his ability to combat federal student loan fraud, reform grant oversight, and make the Office of Inspector General more efficient. We held a bipartisan meeting to review concerns raised about Mr. Priby by individuals at OIG. I'm satisfied with his answers and am comfortable with moving forward with his nomination. I now recognize Senator Sanders.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Today we were going to vote on 5 of President Trump's nominees, but as we know, last night the White House pulled down one of them, Heidi Overton. To head the FDA because she did not apparently have the votes. Further, the nomination of Jim O'Neill to be the director of the National Science Foundation has also been pulled down. Uh, we are going to be considering, however, uh, three of President Trump's nominees, and I will be opposing all of them.
No audio detected at 23:30
And let me very briefly tell you why. First, we will be considering, uh, President Trump's nominee to be inspector general of the Department of Education, Mark Prieb. It is my understanding that Mr. Prieb inappropriately retaliated against a career federal law enforcement officer. And what crime did this woman commit? She sent Mr. Prieb an email explaining that he had jeopardized grand jury investigative materials by entering a secure investigative space without authorization or appropriate escort.
Mr. Prieb described that email as, quote unquote, harsh, and subsequently moved her to a position she was not qualified for in a clear act of retaliation. He also told staff to give him a $15,000 retention bonus that he was not eligible for. Mr. Chairman, in my view, this is not the person we should be putting in charge of investigating waste, fraud, and abuse in the Education Department. I also have serious concerns about the nomination of Katherine Eschbach to be general counsel to the EEOC. The EEOC's role is to protect workers from facing harassment and discrimination while they try to earn a living.
But under Chair Andrea Lucas, the agency has decided not to focus on that critical role. The number of merit lawsuits filed by the agency is at an all-time low. And the agency has closed a record number of claims without trying to help workers. In my view, that is not acceptable. I will also oppose Michael Doyle's nomination to be a commissioner on the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission.
While I support giving this agency a quorum, this is another example of President Trump's failing to follow precedent and asking the Senate to confirm a bipartisan pair of nominees. That tradition of bipartisan pairs ensures that workers are always represented on the commission, and I'm disappointed that we're moving this nomination without a paired Democratic nominee. Bottom line, I will vote no on all three of these nominees and encourage my colleagues to do the same. Thank you. Thank you, Senator Sanders.
Seeing that— Seeing that a quorum is present, I now move to favorably report Mr. Priby's nomination. The clerk should call the roll. I shall be voting yes. Senator Paul. You said you were moving it forward.
No audio detected at 26:10
Yeah. I. Senator Collins. I. Senator Murkowski.
Senator Marshall. Senator Scott. Senator Hawley. Senator Tuberville. Senator Banks.
Senator Houston. Senator Moody. Senator Armstrong. Senator Sanders. No.
Senator Murray. No, by proxy. Senator Baldwin. Senator Murphy. Not voting.
Senator Kaine. Senator Hassan. Senator Hickenlooper. No, by proxy. Senator Markey.
No by proxy. Senator Kim. No by proxy. Senator Blunt Rochester. By proxy.
Senator Alsobrooks. No by proxy. Chairman Cassidy. Aye. I have 12 ayes, 10 nays.
The ayes have it. The nomination is agreed to and will be favorably reported to the Senate. I now move to favorably report Mr. Doyle's nomination. The clerk shall call the roll. Senator Paul.
Aye. Senator Collins. Aye. Senator Lisa Murkowski? Aye.
Senator Marshall? Aye. Senator Scott? Aye. Senator Hawley?
Aye. Senator Tuberville? Aye. Senator Banks? Aye.
Senator Houston? Aye. Senator Moody? No. Senator Armstrong?
Senator Sanders? Nope. Senator Murray? No by proxy. Senator Waldman?
Yes. Senator Murphy? Not voting. Senator Kaine? No.
Senator Hassett? Senator Hickenlooper. No by proxy. Senator Markey. No by proxy.
Senator Kim. No by proxy. Senator Blunt Rochester. No by proxy. Senator Alsobrooks.
No by proxy. Chairman Cassidy. Aye. I have 12 ayes, 10 nays.
The ayes have it. The nomination is agreed to and be favorably reported to the Senate. I now move to favorably report Ms. Eschbach's nomination. The clerk shall call the roll. Senator Paul.
Aye. Senator Tuberville. Aye. Senator Banks. Aye.
Senator Husted. Aye. Senator Moody. Aye. Senator Armstrong.
Aye by proxy. Senator Sanders. No. Senator Murray. No by proxy.
Tammy Baldwin. Senator Baldwin. Senator Murphy. Not voting. Senator Kaine.
Senator Hassan. Senator Hickenlooper. Not— no, by proxy. Senator Markey. By proxy.
Senator Kaine. By proxy. Senator Blunt Rochester. By proxy. Senator Alsobrooks.
No, by proxy. Chairman Cassidy. Aye. I have 12 ayes. 10 Nays.
The ayes have it. The nomination is agreed to and will be favorably reported to the Senate. The Health Committee stands adjourned. Excuse me. I'd like to make just remarks on one of the nominees.
I didn't get. A chance before the vote. I will wait, by the way, for Senator Baldwin to make her remarks on the nominee. And anybody who wishes to wait with me is welcome to. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you for recognizing me. An excellent education for every child is one of the most important investments we can make in the future. And that is why the independence and effectiveness of the Department of Education's Inspector General matter so much. That is also more important now than ever. The Trump administration is working to dismantle the Department of Education despite serious questions about the impact on students, families, schools, and states.
No audio detected at 29:40
Programs previously administered by the Department of Education are now being scattered across the federal government and being administered by multiple federal agencies. How does that help students? How does that help families? It doesn't. Instead, it wastes time, creates confusion, and diverts resources away from the department's core mission.
We need watchdogs who are independent and can follow the facts, conduct investigations, and report their findings without interference. Yet the department has been stonewalling oversight efforts, and the administration is fundamentally undermining the independence of the Office of Inspector General and limiting its ability to do its job. To be clear, as the administration seeks massive changes to the Department of Education, the Trump administration is trying to block independent oversight of what it is doing. I'm raising these concerns today as it relates to the nomination of the Department of Education's Inspector General, but I would be remiss if I didn't note that we're also seeing the Trump administration now attempting to undermine the independence of the Government Accountability Office. I am deeply concerned about the administration's effort to install a partisan leader at GAO.
Congress cannot effectively serve the people that we represent, including the people of Wisconsin and communities across America, if oversight is obstructed. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. And I ask unanimous consent to also enter into the record two letters opposing Ms. Ashbach's nomination. One is from 40 civil rights and worker rights organizations, and the other is from the American Federation of Government Employees. Without objection.
No audio detected at 31:50
No audio detected at 32:10
No audio detected at 32:20
No audio detected at 34:20
No audio detected at 34:40