Senate Environment and Public Works: Business meeting to consider pending calendar business.
Alaska News • • 34 min
Articles from this transcript
Senate committee sends EPA air nominee Schwab to full Senate on 10-9 vote
Senate panel voted 10-9 to advance Justin Schwab, Trump's pick to lead EPA's air office, with Alaska Sen. Dan Sullivan voting yes.

No audio detected at 0:00
No audio detected at 2:00
No audio detected at 4:00
No audio detected at 6:00
No audio detected at 6:10
No audio detected at 8:10
No audio detected at 10:10
No audio detected at 10:40
No audio detected at 12:40
No audio detected at 14:40
No audio detected at 15:10
No audio detected at 17:10
No audio detected at 19:10
Good morning, everybody. We are awaiting, I think, one other person, but we're going to go ahead and start so we can move this show along. So, I'm noting the president's— well, the quorum is not here yet, but I'm going to call the business meeting to order. For the information of the members, Ranking Member Whitehouse and I will deliver our opening statements, and once we have sufficient attendance, we will immediately proceed to our roll call. After the votes, members who wish to be recognized to speak can do so.
No audio detected at 22:40
So today we will consider the nomination of Justin Schwab. We had him before the committee last week to be assistant administrator for the Office of Air and Radiation at the Environmental Protection Agency. We are— Mr. Schwab is well qualified and equipped to serve in the role in which he has been nominated. He previously served as general counsel at CEQ and as well as deputy general counsel at the EPA during the first Trump administration. In between the first and second Trump administration, Mr. Schwab founded a law practice in Washington D.C. where he represented regulated entities and provided legal counsel on Clean Air Act and other environmental matters.
Last week we heard from Mr. Schwab on how he plans to use his wealth of experience in environmental law to ensure that the EPA continues to carry out its role in protecting public health and environment consistent with the statutory authority that Congress has provided for the agency. His testimony and answers demonstrated his deep understanding of the Clean Air Act and related programs administered by OAR. Mr. Schwab highlighted the importance of cooperative federalism and recognized the significance of durable and legally defensible regulations. I have confidence that Mr. Schwab will help the agency to fulfill its core mission and reject pushing unlawful regulations that threaten energy affordability and the reliability of our electric grid. I look forward to working with him to strengthen communities across the country.
I urge my colleagues to support Mr. Schwab's nomination. We will also have a roll call vote on a perspective to authorize the relocation of the Department of Energy headquarters. This will allow for the long anticipated disposal of the James V. Forrestal Building. Finally, we will consider 7 prospectuses en bloc from the General Services Agency that concern leases with various Veteran Administration facilities and federal buildings throughout the country. Urge my colleagues to vote to approve these prospectuses.
And with that, I will turn to Ranking Member Whitehouse. I would like to say, um, this may be— I assume we'll have some meetings in December, but as you all know, Senator Whitehouse and I have been working fervently, uh, permitting reform. I want to thank the members of this committee who've been so critical to putting together, I think, a product that we can all be proud of. So it's been a pleasure working with him and Senator Lee and Senator Heinrich on this and their staffs on this very difficult but, I think, monumental and legacy-setting, uh, piece of legislation we're gonna be voting on later today. It has been, uh, terrific working with you, Chairman.
So, uh, thank you very much. Um, with respect to today's business, I have already spoken, uh, earlier when we had the hearing about Mr. Schwab. So I'm not going to take all of you through that again. But suffice it to say that while he may be well qualified, I consider him to be ill motivated with a purpose to undo what it is EPA's statutory responsibility to do. I'll take the opportunity here just to again warn of what I call the great climate insurance collapse.
Which we're seeing both because of wildfire risk and because of flooding risk. And frankly, in Iowa, even because of hail and derecho risk, we're seeing insurance companies leaving markets. We are seeing individuals fired off their insurance policies by companies sending the notice of non-renewal. We are seeing rates leap dramatically. If I remember correctly, Iowa has had a 50% rate jump in the last 5 years with another 30% pending.
And you start with a big number when it's your home insurance policy. So, I think it's coming at us. There are warnings coming from throughout the financial sector by people who couldn't be less green. Jay Powell is about as un-green as you get. And while he was chairman of the Federal Reserve, he testified to the Banking Committee that whole regions of the United States were becoming uninsurable.
Which would make them unmortgageable, which would imperil the solvency of the banking system. We've seen crashes before. I've seen crashes in Rhode Island. We saw the mortgage crash here in 2008. They happen gradually and then suddenly.
I think we are well into gradually, and I think we'll find that suddenly is very painful. And so putting people into positions of responsibility who pretend that climate risk is not even a real thing when the entire insurance industry has built its planning around, yes, it is a real thing and we need to pay attention to it, I think is a real problem. So I strongly urge my colleagues to vote no on Mr. Schwab. As to the GSA prospectus, the Department of Energy move into the LBJ Education Building, I view as part of the larger strategy of Project 2025 to try to dismember the Department of Education. So until we get that resolved, I would like to urge my colleagues to vote no on that prospectus.
And if I may, Madam Chairman, I'd like to put into the record and an attachment to my remarks a letter from the National Education Association regarding the prospectus. Without objection. Thank you very much. Does anybody have any other comments or they wish to say? We're going to wait and hold for Senator Sullivan.
Does anybody have any? Senator Lummis. I want to thank you and Senator Whitehouse for working together so hard on permitting. It's something that we all know is affecting our ability as a country just to get things done, to have the type of infrastructure that this country needs in the 21st century. And the fact that you two continue to work together in a bipartisan manner to bring this to a vote in the Senate after the election is really marvelous.
No audio detected at 28:30
No audio detected at 28:40
I worked so hard on a bill that I thought was bipartisan that fell to a partisan vote just in early September. And, you know, I know how much work goes into keeping a bill this significant and this important to our country bipartisan. And you did it. And my compliments to both of you.
Thank you.
All right. Thank you. And I ask senators to hold their remarks, but I now notice the— I now note the presence of quorum. So I will call up Presidential Nomination 1366-5, Justin Schwab of the District of Columbia to be an Assistant Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency. I move to approve and report the nomination Favorably.
Is there a second? Second. Call the roll. Miss Alsa— Miss Alsa-Brix. No, but also Brooks is no by proxy.
Miss Blunt Rochester, also. No by proxy. Mr. Bozeman. Mr. Kramer. Yes.
Mr. Curtis. Yes. Miss Graham. Mr. Houston. Yes.
Mr. Kelly. No. Ms. Lummis. Aye. Mr. Markey.
No by proxy. Mr. Merkley. No by proxy. Mr. Padilla. No by proxy.
Mr. Ricketts. Aye. Mr. Sanders. No by proxy. Mr. Schiff.
No by proxy. Mr. Sullivan. Aye. Mr. Whitehouse. No.
Mr. Wicker. Yay. Madam Chairman. I— Aye. The clerk will report the yeas and nays.
Madam Chairman, the yeas are 10 and the nays are 9. With that, the nominee is reported, and we will now move to the GSA resolutions. We're going to call one up, and then hopefully the others can be voice voted. I now call up a committee resolution on GSA fiscal year 2026 optimization program prospectus, number POP-001-2023.
-26, Which authorizes the relocation of the Department of Energy's headquarters and allows for the long-anticipated disposal of the James B. Forrestal Building. I move to approve the resolution. Is there a second? Yes. Clerk will call the roll.
Ms. Alsobrooks.
She is no by proxy. Ms. Blunt Rochester. Also no by proxy. Mr. Bozman. Mr. Kramer.
Yes. Mr. Curtis. Yes. Ms. Graham. Yes.
Mr. Husted. Aye. Mr. Kelly. No. Ms. Lummis.
Aye. Mr. Markey. No, by proxy. Mr. Merkley. No, by proxy.
Mr. Padilla. No, by proxy. Mr. Ricketts. Aye. Mr. Sanders.
No by proxy. Mr. Schiff. No by proxy. Mr. Sullivan. Aye.
Mr. Whitehouse. No. Mr. Wicker. Madam Chairman. Aye.
Clerk will report the yeas and nays. Madam Chairman, the yeas are 10 and the nays are 9. With that, the resolution is approved. Finally, the ranking member and I have agreed to consider the remaining committee resolutions before us en bloc by voice vote. I move to consider 7 committee resolutions to approve prospectuses From the General Services Administration.
Is there a second? Second. All those in favor say aye. Aye. All those opposed say nay.
Opinion of the chair, the ayes have it. And with that, the resolutions are approved. And I note the presence of a quorum. Thank you again to all the members for being here this morning. I appreciate it.
I will now recognize any members that wish to speak.
With that, this meeting is adjourned. Thank you. Good work. So one thing that— what are we going to do? Well, during the first half.
No audio detected at 33:10
No audio detected at 33:20