Ketchikan: Regular City Council Meeting
Alaska News • • 142 min
Articles from this transcript
Ketchikan council postpones 2027 budget votes as draft misses reserve policy by $600,000
Ketchikan council delayed 2027 budget votes to Nov. 23 after the draft fell $600,000 short of the city's reserve policy.

Ketchikan physician asks City Council to fund an ombudsperson for PeaceHealth complaints
A Ketchikan doctor asked the City Council to fund an independent ombudsperson for PeaceHealth hospital complaints. Council took no action yet.

No audio detected at 0:00
No audio detected at 2:00
No audio detected at 4:00
No audio detected at 6:00
No audio detected at 8:00
YouTube stream.
Hi, Jeff, can you hear us?
No audio detected at 12:00
No audio detected at 14:00
No audio detected at 16:00
No audio detected at 18:00
I'd like to call a special meeting of November 17th. Order, would you please call the roll? Gage. Here. Dick Coose.
Here. Zenge. Here. Bradberry. Here.
Gass. Here. Finnegan. Here. Mr. Strasburg is absent, and Mayor Sivertsen.
Here. Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance.
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
Thank you. The Ketchikan City Council would like to respectfully acknowledge the traditional first people of this land in Ketchikan, the Tongass Tlingit people. Under communications, we have a lay on the table, which is a paper copy of the 2027 budget overview. That brings us down to persons of be heard. Madam Clerk, do we have anybody to speak tonight?
We have one person, Mr. Mark Weaver.
Thank you.
If you like, my name is Mark Weaver, MD, North Tongass Service Area. We learned last week at school board meeting the importance of one vote. One vote swaying the decision on retention of records. I applaud the fact that it passed 4 to 3. I appreciate your one vote, each and every vote.
Appreciate your time and dedication. I ask you to establish a dedicated budget line item for an independent healthcare ombudsperson office within Fund 110, the hospital sales tax fund, under healthcare operations, to the extent legally permissible. The city's 2026 budget already identifies a place for this office. Healthcare operations includes $75,000 for management and consulting services associated with the hospital and its 5-year lease review. I believe you may recognize the need to fund or cost shift professional assistance with this lease.
Residents should not have to bear the burden of obtaining information and pursuing accountability on their own. Based on my review of records requested and produced, most documents required under the lease were not disclosed in a timely fashion. In my experience, transparency concerning operational matters addressed by the lease have also been inadequate. When this lease was signed 5 years ago, the public expected more than compliance on paper. In return for entrusting PeaceHealth with our community-owned hospital, we expected accessible, safe, high-quality, affordable healthcare.
Core services, accountability, transparency. Has PeaceHealth management delivered on that intent and provided this council with timely, sufficient, verifiable evidence to demonstrate lease compliance? An independent healthcare ombudsperson would provide one clearly identified point of contact for patients, families, physicians, nurses, and other caregivers with concerns about PeaceHealth Ketchikan Medical Center. The purpose is to offload the initial handling of citizens' complaints from individual council members and the city manager. The ombudsperson would care— would clarify concerns, gather authorized information, hear all sides, seek resolution, and track responses.
Matters concerning council action would come forward with documentation and recommendations. The Health Care Advisory Committee would remain completely intact, unchanged. This proposal would not change the lease, its terms, or the HAC structure, authority, or function. Lease enforcement decisions would remain with the City Council. PeaceHealth could continue to investigate concerns concurrently, whether received directly from a citizen or referred by the ombuds person with appropriate consent confidentiality agreements and safeguards.
This would be an additional mechanism for transparency and follow-through on ongoing hospital concerns, particularly the expectations established by the lease and the city's enforcement of its provisions. The office must be independent of hospital administrators whose decisions may be reviewed with clear authority and freedom to report findings. Please direct staff to bring forward a dedicated appropriation within Fund 110, confirm its lawful use, and establish a public timetable for opening the office. Include startup funding through an amendment if needed and recurring funding in the 2027 budget. Doing the work of the people means ensuring their concerns receive a fair hearing, documented answer and follow-through.
Please put that responsibility into the budget with funding, independence, and deadline. Please consider these issues during tonight's work session or as you need to be. I'm here to learn. Again, I thank you very much. Thank you.
That brings us down to new business. Item 5, 5A, work session for FY27 budget overview. I have a motion. Your Honor, I move to enter into work session to receive a presentation from the manager's office regarding the FY27 budget. Second.
It has been moved and seconded. Any discussion? Hearing and seeing none, please call the roll.
Gage? Yes. Singhi? Yes. Gass?
Yes. Bradberry? Yes. Finnegan? Yes.
Coose? Yes. Motion passes. Abner. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the council.
First of all, I just wanted to thank all of you. I know that we scheduled time and met, and I gave you an initial overview of the budget in my office one-on-one. I appreciate the time that all of you took to come and meet with me and get that overview. In this public process, it's important that we also get that information out in the public, and I will go into a little bit more depth some things tonight than what we went through in that initial meeting.
I've only got about 150 slides, so we should be done by midnight. I'm just kidding. There's 39 slides, but we do go through the information that's in here. The idea for tonight is kind of a 30,000-foot overview of the budget, how we built it, where it stands, how it compares to previous budgets, and what you can expect in 2027 based on this.
The handout that you have does have these exact same slides, so that if you want to make notes as we're on a specific slide, you could follow along there as well. Is this on your screens? It is. Yes. Except for Judy.
Except for Judy. She can share mine.
Can I get anything? Apparently not. There we go. All right. So tonight, we're going to cover 6 different parts.
First part is where the budget stands. We'll talk about the major funds and where they stand, how we got there, the council direction, additional staff direction, and what changed between the requests that were submitted and the budget that you were— was transmitted to you. We'll talk about how it compares, 6 years of spending, reserves, and staffing. We'll talk a little bit about where the dollars go and what costs staff actually controls and what things they don't necessarily have direct control over. We'll talk about the 2027 as a planning year for utility and enterprise plans, services, and levels of service.
And then we'll talk a little bit about what's ahead. In between each section, I do have a place built in to pause and stop and see if you have any questions after we cover each of those 6 sections.
So the budget that was transmitted to you on November 2nd, Really, what this shows you is, in short, we are $600,000 short of meeting the reserve policy in the general fund, and every other fund meets their reserve policy in the budget that was transmitted.
KPU, as well as the debt service coverage ratio that's required for our bonds and for our loans under KPU. And then on general government, all of our enterprise funds as well all meet their policy reserve based on City Council policy.
So the major funds, general fund, what I'm looking in the— let's see if this Mouse pointer will work. So looking in this column here, um, general fund was $8.8 million as was transmitted to you. The column to the left of that is what was originally submitted, and we'll talk a little bit more about that on future slides when we talk about how we got to here. But what was transmitted, $8.8 million, uh, ending fund balance projected at the end of 2027 versus a required under policy fund balance of $9.4 million, so a little over $600,000 short of meeting that reserve. KPU fund combined with the facilities and infrastructure replacement fund, which is a dedicated fund in KPU, comes in at $19.3 million as transmitted compared to a policy of $12.9 million, so it exceeds it.
By quite a bit, and coverage for the loans are 2.07. And so that's a ratio of the income— the revenue available to pay for debt service versus the amount of debt that we have. We make $2 for every dollar of debt service available still to pay that. Wastewater, 2.35 as transmitted. Policy is 2.32.
Solid waste, 1.59, policy 1.52. Harbor, 1.2, policy 0.59. And port, 42, and policy for that is 5.7.
So what does that mean for the residents? It means that under this budget, all of our services are maintained as they have been this current year. This has no changes in service level currently. All of our positions are kept within departments. Every position is still authorized.
It doesn't anticipate any layoffs in this budget. There's no mill rate change forecast in this budget as transmitted to you. It maintains the 6.6 mills as it has been since 2018. And the utility rates that were discussed in June and the 5-year increases, those are in this budget as it currently sits. There is one revenue measure in the draft budget that you received, and that is the additional 0.5% in-season sales tax increment that was discussed in 2025 but was never adopted.
Any questions on that first part that I can answer? Yes, Riley. So I don't quite know, Susan, maybe a question, just a thought I wanted to put out before we get too far along in this budgeting process. First of all, I appreciate how you broke all this down and that we're taking steps in the right direction. What I hope to do throughout this process is to see what we can do to see what steps would need to be made to not have to do that sales tax increase, at least so we can be presented with that at the end of the budgeting process.
I know you've mentioned, and I think everyone else would agree, that, you know, sometimes in the past we either try to pick out certain things, which I've been told is not advisable, or get to the end and then we go, well, we got to do something to not to do this tax increase. So I want to have that at least as an option on the side. Obviously, we're going to have to cut something to do that, but I'd like to at least look at that as we go forward. So we'll make a note of that. That would be something we— I plan to speak about revenue and taxes during our general government dedicated meeting.
I think that's the next meeting that we have. And so we can definitely talk about those options during that and what that looks like on the revenue side. But as drafted and sent, that's what's currently in here.
Yes, Abby. Just for the general public's knowledge, because I doubt many of them open Budget Finder and go through the budget, what is our starting deficit in the general government budget. Talk about these pretty numbers, but the overall deficit in our budget, like we don't have a balanced budget. It's not at zero.
So what is—. It's not at zero. That's correct. What is the current deficit that we're starting before reviewing? We have some of that on future slides.
I think I'm going to answer that, but Michelle, do you remember what the decrease in the reserve from start to end is for general fund?
She has all the sheets in front of her. I don't have them. I just wanted the public to know where we're starting on our deficit. So we start with a positive fund balance as we close out 2026, and we end with a positive fund balance when we close out 2027, but it does decrease slightly. So it's approximately $1.1 million in the general fund and overall Between all general government funds, it's about $3 million.
In decrease? In a decrease. But that's across all funds. Okay. General government.
So for general funds specifically, about $1.1 million decrease from start to end after revenue and expenses are accounted for.
Thank you. All right. How we got here. So from the June work session to the budget transmitted. The process kind of that we followed is what we're going to talk about next.
So Council met in June, had a work session, discussed budget guidance that you wanted to provide to staff. Resulting from that were a 5% soft cap on department growth, year 2 of the 5-year utility path, 25% reserve policy is maintained, and Finance had recommended a mill rate increase and a sales tax increase for consideration. As you all know, that meeting happened prior to my arrival. I did provide staff some additional direction after I arrived, which was to— on their discretionary portion of their operating budgets to maintain as flat as possible as they began developing those. I asked for written exception memos to any increase over 5%, and those were received and reviewed.
Capital was only approved and moved into the budget if it sustained the system or maintains compliance with law or regulation, and if we can build it in 2027. We sized capital to what each division has shown it can execute, and we put needs before wants with 2027 as a planning year.
So before I arrived, and the capital budget had been presented to Council during one meeting, I believe, or maybe right after I got here, Staff had drafted those, and you saw a presentation on capital budgets. I didn't initially make any changes to that. We left that alone, and that's what is reflected in this first as produced by staff numbers. And then they built their operating budgets as well. When I put the— when we put those together, what those would have resulted in had they been presented as the budget is we would have ended general fund with $3.5 million at the end of 2027, and which would have been a $5 million drawdown instead of the $1.1 that was transmitted to you.
In KPU, we would have drawn $20 million out of that reserve instead of, I think it's $5, and we would have had, we had $158 million capital program with $59 million requested for 2027.
So what we did with capital projects is we resequenced those. We didn't cancel them, but we did resequence them to the things that we knew we just absolutely had to do. And so what you see on the screen here is you've got the different KPU divisions there. The first two bars are electric, then telecom, then water. The gold bar shows you the capital that was initially submitted by staff before we did any editing, so that was a $16.7 million capital budget.
After we went through our process and resequenced and deferred some projects, we have an $8.4 million budget in electric for 2027. That was what was transmitted to council. Telecom submitted $4.2 million capital program, and what was transmitted to the council after our edits was $2.9 million. And water submitted $11 million, and what was transmitted was $9.7 million.
Just double-checking my notes to make sure I don't miss anything.
On the water side, we have approximately $8.5 million worth of loans and $1.2 million worth of operating revenue with no reserve draw for that specific line.
On general government capital, these are broken out into general government excluding the enterprise funds are the first two bars, then port, then wastewater, then harbor. Solid waste is not in here. It's exactly flat across between the two, so you just could have seen two more bars at a level, even level, $0.8 or $800,000.
For '26 and for '27 for solid waste. So general government submitted $16.3 million. What was transmitted to council is $11 million. Port, $16.5 million, transmitted at $11.7 million. Wastewater, $7.5 million, down to $4.8 million.
And Harbor is the one place we actually increased the budget because there were some projects that had not— had been missed being submitted in that initial round that that were needed, so we added 1 or 2 projects there in the harbor. If I may— Yeah. —Mr. Chair. I'm just curious about the edits for the port capital projects, knowing that that's got one of the healthiest balances.
Was this reduction made in view of what what can actually be accomplished for the year as opposed to what could be funded? What can be accomplished, what we absolutely needed to do, and then we've deferred on some things that we think as we do this planning year and try to come up with what we need the port to look like in the future, that we might want to change some of those. And so we don't want to get too far out ahead and do things that maybe don't drive us towards the end goal that we have for that. Fund. So spend the money in the right places versus potentially in the wrong places.
Thanks.
So in addition to resequencing capital, we— after those original budgets were submitted, we did send out secondary round of line item budgets to department heads. Finance and myself and the department heads reviewed those. Line by line, looking at 4 years of actual spending in those, in those line items, and we asked them to make some more adjustments to, to kind of close the gap. So if we're budgeting way over here but we're spending way down here, we just asked to close that gap up some so that we're not budgeting so much above what we're spending. In doing that, we were able to realize $105,000 in savings in the general fund, $98,000 in the general government enterprise funds, and $100,000 in KPU divisions.
And these, these are small amounts, but they were already operating on their discretionary items of trying to keep that flat. So there just wasn't a lot of extra room to trim there.
On personnel, um, personnel is budgeted against our actual staffing experience. So what you see on the, on the chart there is that those gold bars are how much under budget we have been in those previous years. So in 2024, we were $3.3 million, '25, $3.3 million under budget. Our 2026 estimate is $2 million under budget, and in all honesty, oftentimes that estimate is still higher than what's actual, so there's still going to be probably a little bit more there. So looking at those, at those years, the average was around $3 million, and so what we did in this budget is we took a deduction essentially in personnel outside of the departments at the non-departmental level And basically what that means is we're reducing that personnel budget by $1.5 million, the equivalent of about 9 positions, and we're not going to fund that.
So when you look at the department-by-department FTE counts, you'll see all 158 positions, but when you look at the dollar amount that those positions would equate to, you're not going to see that number in the top line of the budget. You're going to see that as a, as a reduction there. And then the way that we're going to manage that is that we'll actively manage the vacancies. We will review every vacancy before it's filled to determine whether the position is still needed and whether any restructuring should take place in that department while we have the vacancy. And in some cases, I may ask a department to hold a vacancy an extra couple of months in order to realize those savings.
But this gets us much closer. Again, we're just closing that gap. We're budgeting here for personnel all the time, but we're spending here. Let's close that gap a little bit, paint a more clear picture, a real picture of where we stand.
So we did use a 50% threshold for this vacancy factor based on that $3 million-ish of average unspent funds. It is— that's a discretionary number, though. That's what the finance director and I felt comfortable saying, that if we use that number, it's achievable. But council could choose to increase or decrease that number if you're not comfortable with that. And that's something that we'll ask you about when we go through general funds.
So we're all— and we're only doing the vacancy factor on the general fund because so much of it is personnel cost. We did not apply a vacancy factor to the KPU side of the budget.
So this shows you the general fund from the $3.5 million, $3.5 million, and that's the ending reserve balance for 2027 as submitted by departments with their original operating budgets and original capital budgets. So how do we get from that to now having $8.8 million, uh, at the end of 2027? The first thing there, improved 2026 projection, is, um, we looked at the 2026 budget and realized we were not booking enough revenue, um, into our 2026 budget for, uh, interest income and some of the taxes that we've been collecting. We've been kind of above where we've been budgeting. And so we trued those up and that's where, where that first $1 million came from.
The second amount came from revenue forecast for 2027. So we realized more revenue in 2026. We also adjusted those numbers for 2027. So it got adjusted in both places. And then we also went through and made sure that every cost that we could allocate to programs like CPV, or to hospital sales tax or to SCMT and the interdepartmental transfers, interdepartmental charges, we made sure that we were doing the right thing there, that we had accurate estimates, and that resulted in another $2.5 million.
The line review, that bar is the $100,000 in the general fund side that those departments doing that second pass through the budget resulted in. That brings us to $7.2 million before the vacancy factor. The vacancy factor, when you round it, comes to about $1.6 million, which gets you to the $8.8 million, and then reserve policy, as you know, is $9.4.
On the KPU side, as we talked about, you've got two charts here. Left chart, the gold bar is the reserve draw as submitted. It was a $20 million draw on reserves, and you see as transmitted, it's a $5.9 million draw on reserves.
The next chart over, the, the last three bars, the ending reserve as submitted was going to be $5.8 million, and now our ending reserve is estimated to be $19.3 million for KPU at the end of 2027, and that's well above the $12.9 million policy— reserve policy.
If we had approved the original submission as it was, we would have been at 1.39 for our debt service coverage versus 2.07 with the what was transmitted, and 1.5 to 2.0 is the range that's required under the policy for debt service.
Questions on that section?
Proceed. Okay. So how does that compare to past years? I'll talk about some spending reserves and staffing history. So here is operating spending from 2022 to 2027.
The navy portion of the bar is general government and the light blue is enterprise funds.
The amounts inside the bar are their group total. So you can see in 2022, we had $27.6 million and $14.3 million, and that's increased by— I thought I had the number here— increased to $23 million or $43 million for the 2027 after the vacancy factor.
The last, the last 4 bars there are 2 bars each for 2026 and 2027. So on 2026, this one here, this was what was adopted in the budget, and then this next bar here is where we estimate we will be at the end of 2026. And you can see that's somewhere between there roughly is where we're at for 2027 after we apply the vacancy factor. And you can see that it was not applied to KPU. Those are both still— they're both at $23.4 million.
I'm sorry, can we chime in at this point? Sure. Your Honor. Go ahead. So this is kind of a baffling chart.
Uh, I know inflation and all that, but to go in the, in the course of a few years from 27.6 to 43, 44.8, can you just in simple man's terms break that down where those massive increases are coming from? I mean, just a little bit of everything. I believe it was in 2024 that the compensation increased significantly. Does that— that's what I remember seeing. Michelle, can you add to that at all?
General salary increased 2.5%. Yeah, so that started around 2024. Some, some big changes in compensation is what drives quite a bit of this.
And—. This factors in capital, right? Yes. No, this is just operating. That's just operating.
Insurance has gone up quite a bit over the past couple of years as well, which has driven the recent year changes. This year, the average insurance is up around 10-ish percent.
So the next set of bars here is your capital, and again, navy is your general government spending, blue is enterprise funds.
And, you know, you've heard that there were deferred projects for years. There's— we've We have some capital needs out there, and we have not executed on the capital spend. I didn't put what the adopted numbers were on this one, but historically, we have not spent all of our capital.
For 2027, the budgeted capital is about 29% below what was adopted for 2026 and almost flat with what we actually expect to spend this year.
I talked about our budgets or our— the, the gap that's there. We're budgeting here and, and, uh, spending lower, and that's what this chart is showing you for 2026. The gold bar is what was adopted, the 2026, the light blue bar, is what we estimate will be unspent at the end of the year, so about $3.2 million. And oftentimes between our estimate and the actual, you can even add a little bit more of a, of a difference there. Might make it to $3.3 or $3.4 million.
Our personnel spending has averaged about 11% under budget for 3 years, and most of that has been from vacant positions.
Between the dark blue and the kind of gray-blue bar there, that is just showing you the vacancy factor that I mentioned, so that's where that's been deducted from the budget.
To capture and be closer to what we expect to spend.
So you got two charts here. You got general government on the left. Here's the dividing line. General government on the left, at the end of 2025, the general fund had $11.1 million. End of 2026, we're estimating that we're going to have $9.9 million.
And at the end of 2027, $8.8 million. KPU, including the FNIR fund, you see a similar trend. We're trending down. We're spending more generally than we're bringing in. That's not necessarily— I guess it depends on your definition of deficit spending.
The idea behind our budgeting should normally be that We— some years we'll build up our balances and other years they would go down. And when we have a large capital program that needs to be done, it's not uncommon to see those go down for multiple years in a row. But I think we are seeing a structural problem with our budget where we need to figure out where we want to go and how we're going to get there without continuing to draw down steeply on these fund balances, as you saw As I've kind of presented what was originally submitted, we were going to have a cliff in 2027, and we've reined that back. But we need to build these plans that we're going to talk about in some future slides here so that we know— so that Council can provide some direction on where we're going and what you want to see us doing rather than just shooting from the hip.
Here's your budget of positions from 2018 to 2027, and you can see they were slowly going up through about 2025. In 2026, there were some reductions, um, and in 2027, we do have, uh, 2— 2.75 positions budgeted to add, or at least in the department level budgets, we have 2 positions, 2 FTE equivalents, 1 in KPU, a general labor and electric. They have 1 and they are seeing a lot of work for that position, and 1.75 in general government. And we can— we'll cover in more detail when we talk about those funds what those positions are, what they're going to be for, how we paid for them in this budget. But I wanted to share that information.
And then what you see, the last bar there, the 303, that's what we're actually asking to fund in 2027 by using that vacancy factor.
So when, again, when you look at the department totals, they're going to total to the dark blue bar, the 312, but what we're funding is 303.
Other questions? Yes. Questions? Randy. Yes, so just jotting some notes down.
I know it's an ongoing trend that your charts point out very clearly and simply, which I appreciate, but I mean, just jotting a few numbers down here. In 5 years, our general government funding or spending has increased 63%. 24 Added positions since 2018. And as we say often, our population is stagnating or decreasing, actually, not stagnating. We're losing people.
No audio detected at 55:30
And this has been brought up before, but I think it needs to be brought up again. And it's even more true than it was last year that We can't keep growing government when our taxpayers, ratepayers, property taxpayers, the people who pay all these things, is decreasing. I just think we have to stop increasing our government. It doesn't make any sense to me. So I think maybe going forward we could start looking at— nobody ever likes the word cut, and I don't even necessarily know if that's the right word, but just to bring our size of government to something that's a little more manageable.
And I, I don't want to do it overnight, but I just want to stand in opposition of this trend that we're seeing on these graphs that just goes up, up, up while our population goes down. And every time we increase these things, citizens are paying more. So it's concerning to me. I mean, 63% increase in 5 years. I know that it's wages and insurance and inflation, but That's a massive percentage.
I don't think— It is, and what I'd like to— I don't necessarily disagree with you, but what I want to be able to provide you with are tools that we can plan around and you can establish what services you want to provide because honestly, where we're at right now in the discretionary items, and we have a slide coming up on it, but where we're at in those discretionary items, there's no more room to cut on those. And so in order to further cut, we'll start to impact the services that we provide. And I haven't been able to give you a list of services that we provide at this point where you can say, I don't want a city manager, right? You pick a service that you provide and you decide that you either can't do it or you do it at a different level. And so we pulled the reins way back this year.
I've got outlined, and you're going to see that in upcoming slides here, some plans that we're going to develop this year. And I think that's going to give you the tools that you need to, to point the city in the direction that you as a council want without having to randomly say, well, I want to see 10 positions cut off of that. It's not fair to you to, to have to do that without telling you what that impact is going to be, because if you cut 10 positions or 20 positions or $10 million, fill in the blank with what you want to cut, and I can't tell you what the impact on the community is going to be. You're going to hear about it when we can't provide X service. And so—.
Well, just looking at these charts, I mean, what if we could just say, for example, we want to go back to 2018-level positions? That would be a cut of 24. I mean, and I know it's more complex, I guess, but really it isn't to me. So I don't want to go back and forth too much, but I just— Sure. I'm concerned about this trend.
I will try my best to answer that question as I talk more about the planning and what that will help you be able to do.
So next is, is talking about what can and cannot be cut, where the dollars go, where our costs really are.
So general fund operating dollars, when you just take the operating portion, you remove the capital from it, It's about $36 million. Of that, 77% is personnel, and most of that is controlled by our collective bargaining agreements, the IBEW, the IAFF— sorry, City IBEW, IAFF, PSEA agreements, and then our non-represented, what's in the personnel rules.
Our fixed costs are only 7%. It's insurance, interdepartmental charges, utilities, Council set internal rates like the water rates for the seasonal water rates. That's what's in that 7%. That leaves you just 16% of that $36 million is contracts, supplies, fuel, travel, all of those sorts of things. That's what staff was asked to review line by line, and they cut another $105,000 out of that.
The, the personnel in the fixed is set by by finance based on the information that we have, and department heads don't have any input into those.
And then our capital separately under general fund is about $11 million for 2027, and that's budgeted out of the public works sales tax and CPV and some of our other capital funds rather than the general fund.
And so this is one of the places where really when you look at general fund dollars, the only place we can really cut is either capital or personnel.
KPU operating dollars, uh, again, I pulled out the capital portion because KPU fund does pay capital directly out of it where general fund doesn't, but I wanted you to be able to see apples to apples. And so when we remove that capital portion, um, it's a $51 million operating budget. Of that, 47% is for personnel, 34% on the KPU side is fixed costs, and the difference there is that our purchased power, fuel, um, and interdepartmental charges and pilot are all included in those fixed costs, payment in lieu of taxes. Um, so again, those are things that KPU division managers don't have a lot of control over or any control over. They're set centrally, and so the piece that they have that they can work with is that 19% operating.
And they did manage to trim another $100,000 out of that during that second review.
$21.7 Million of capital on KPU side and $2.8 million of debt service. Which is also paid within the fund, but that was removed just so you could see apples to apples. The KPU personnel share, of course, looks smaller as a percentage, largely due to that fuel, the purchase power, and the pilot costs, which make the ratios look off.
So then, during a couple of our meetings, I had questions about, well, why is KPU's personnel cost so low as a percentage? And so I started thinking about that, and this is the answer to that question for those of you that, that asked.
This is comparing personnel cost per budgeted position on general fund side and KPU side.
The dark blue bar represents the regular wages and benefits. The light blue bar on each is the overtime cost per budgeted position, and then temporary wages per budgeted position. So on the general fund side, for each employee we have, essentially, if we average that across the employees, we budget $175,400 plus $5,700 of overtime plus $3,200 in other temporary wages, um, for a total of $184,300 for each of those 150 budgeted positions. That number is different because It's not 158 because 8 of those positions are council members and they don't really count towards that, so I removed you. On the KPU side, you can see the comparisons: 188, um, for regular wages and benefits, $10,000 for overtime, $500 for temporary wages, for a total of $199,500 per budget employee for times 121.25 budgeted positions.
So what's set outside of the budget process? The wage adjustments, as we talked about, those are under collective bargaining agreement. Insurance, And those costs that are fed into the city finance works with the insurance folks to adjust those and make good estimates. Internal department charges and the council set internal rates such as the hydrant charge or the restroom water rates.
I will note that the KPU-IBEW agreement that— has been TA'd, comes to the council this week on the 19th, and those costs were not included in this current draft budget. So once we add those, you will see about a $600,000 decrease in the reserve balance for the end of the year once those costs are added.
Questions on any of that?
So 2027, I presented that as a planning year, and the idea is that by planning in 2027, then in 2028 we can build our budgets and we can build our capital program around a defined service defined plans and not just on wants and project lists. So why, why do we need a planning year? We don't really have any current long-range plans. None of our utility divisions have a long-range plan. Our capital requests have been lists for a long time, not sequenced around any plan of where we want to be as a community in future years.
No audio detected at 1:05:30
We're operating on thin margins in our KPU funds, um, electric and telecom, their revenue funds almost no capital from their earnings, um, at the current rates and costs. And on the general government side, you don't have a good definition of what services the city provides and at what level we're providing them. I do have a first draft working with staff, uh, of the services we provide and talk a little bit more about that in, in an upcoming section here. So the idea is the 2027 budget lets us kind of continue at the current levels of service. That was what I asked staff to prepare their budgets based on.
And even the cutting that they did, I said I don't want to see any changes to level of service that we provide right now today. We're going to plan, we'll put those into writing, we'll share those with the council, we'll give you an opportunity to have input on the services we do provide and at what levels. And adoption of the plans, and then we can build around those.
So what kind of plans are we going to work on in 2027? There's a list of them there on electric side generation study, integrated resource plan. You know, should we be putting money into Bailey Generator 1 to rebuild it? It's out of service currently, has been for quite some time. Do we need that?
Should we be putting money into diesel? Should we be putting money into something else? How quickly, when, and how should we spend our bond authority from Proposition 1? If we spend that on the wrong things and they don't get us towards where we need to be in 5 or 10 years, we're just wasting that money, and I don't want to see us do that. Telecom, a strategic and financial plan to help us answer their growth and cable replacement funding, how they're going to be sustainable.
On the water side, a system master plan, some rate study, help us look at usage-based billing for the water department. I think that's the direction that we need to go. Planning for the need potentially in the future for filtration in maybe 10 years. We will probably at some point be required to add filtration, and that's going to be an expensive project. And if we don't start planning for it now, we're going to have another big bill come due when it's eventually required.
Wastewater side, fiscal sustainability study. What rates do we need to carry the disinfection debt coming up, you know, in a few years when we have to have that disinfection fully in place that the council has been talking about and seen presentations on? We talked today during the CLEA meeting about the port and downtown core and a prioritized 5-year capital plan for the port. Really, again, just aligning our capital and our work with where we want to be as a community, what services we want, and what we want to look like down the road. For all the departments, we're doing a services inventory and defining what our service levels are, and then we'll be able to adjust those service levels and the associated revenues and costs that go with that.
And then for all of our enterprise funds, we need to establish a methodology for determining our payment in lieu of taxes. We collect payment in lieu of taxes from our enterprise funds currently, but we don't have a stated basis in place. We really should put that into code so that there's no question as to whether— how we're doing that and what it's based on.
I also think in 2027, we should refresh our cruise passenger impact study. There are probably some costs there that have changed since that was originally done. And by updating that, then we can try to shift more of those eligible costs to CPV or Port Wharfage.
Debbie had a question for you. Okay.
On the service inventory and service levels, you've mentioned multiple times, well, the departments are doing them within the department. Departments. But are you as a city manager looking at your departments and deciding what level of service do we do in general with the department? Right. Are you also doing that?
Because I've only heard about the department side, which quite frankly I'm not more concerned about. I'm more concerned about the general overview versus cutting services in every single department. So the way that's gone so far is it was initially sent out to the departments with some guidance on defining what your services are that you're providing and at what level you're providing them. And they all presented or sent back to me some form of a document stating what services they currently provide, what requires it, or where that requirement comes from, if there is one, and at what level. I've gone through those and added some other thoughts and information, looking at the code, looking at the charter, just reviewing them from what I know about our different departments, and that's back out to departments now for a second review to help me define what it is that we're providing.
So, yes, the answer is I am reviewing those. I am, have put input into those, and we're just working through a process to make sure we've captured everything, that we have the right information on what requires it and at what level, et cetera. To follow up on that, but to like, you're talking about different levels in each department of service, or different levels in each department for services. I'm asking you as a city manager, are you looking at like, we got these 5 departments, when we start looking at what we do need to service and what we don't, or what the priority is of these 5 departments, are you almost ranking your departments as a poll on where do they stand on do we need it or do we not if we ever have to go to the extreme to cut services. Are you analyzing the overall government, not nitpicking each department service level?
So I haven't done any real analysis yet. We're still at the information gathering stage. I do hope to bring that when we bring it to Council with some analysis attached to it of where could we look at adjusting things.
But I need to get all the information first, I think, is the answer to that, and I don't have it all yet. So I want to go— I don't want to dismiss your question, but I want to go to some slides that I have that talk a little bit more about those definitions, and that might help clear this up a little bit too, and maybe I can answer a little bit more on those, or maybe not. The answer is no. It's okay. See, the answer is no, we haven't gone that far yet.
We haven't gotten there yet, no, that is true. So that's all, I'm just, the answer, yeah. Yeah, I got what answer I needed. Okay. For clarification, Abby, you're asking what's an essential service and what is not?
Yes, we're talking about like, this slide here talks about, well, in, what department do I have up here right now? The first tab. Finance. In finance, these are the different services. I'm asking finance versus— what's the next tab on here?
IT. And comparing, okay, you know, in our— in the metrics that you have presented to the department heads, what are those metrics based on departments? As we know, we have some departments that are essential services. People have to have them to that there are other services we have that people don't have to have them to live and to, to have a home and fresh water and electricity. So we have different levels.
And so I'm wondering, as a city manager, your departments are doing that, but are you doing that over the whole government, you know, general government, versus just trying to nitpick services? So that's all I was wondering, and it sounds like we haven't gotten there yet. We, we haven't gotten to the analysis yet, but I think it's even a little bit more complex than that. Um, our, our charter, for example, requires that we have certain things. Um, one of them is an annual audit of our finances.
And so when we are talking about things that are required and not required, we've categorized them into different tiers of what requires them And if a charter requires them, it's not really my place to say we don't have that. I'm going to inform you that this is why we have this service and the mechanism that we can use to change that, which would be a vote of the people in order to change that if that were the item that we were looking at. When we get down to some of the more discretionary things, that's where there will be some room for interpretation and analysis and recommendations to the council.
And actually, it's this slide that starts to talk a little bit more about that because I've alluded to some of this, but I've never really put it up on a screen where you can kind of see, see what it is. So as I mentioned, staff has done an initial draft. We have identified about 190 different services across 18 departments and divisions, and they're kind of organized by what they can, uh, what it takes to change them. So we have these 5 different tiers: 1A, 1B, 2A, 2B, and 3. So 1A being essential things that are required by state or federal law or charter.
It requires the voters to do that, or a state or federal agency or legislature. One example is that annual independent audit. It's under the charter. I can't change the charter. Council can't change the charter.
That has to go to the vote of the people. So if it's required under the charter, it would be classified as a Tier 1A service, and we would know how we could change it, but it's not easily influenced by us. So that's probably not one we'd look at. We continue down. 1B is essential but conditional.
So what does that mean? An example would be emergency medical services. It's not required by any state law or federal regulation that we have an EMS service. The council has established that in city code. But if we do have an EMS service, then we have to comply with state and federal laws that pertain to it.
So there's some conditions there on what that looks like.
2A are things that are just under an agreement. The city and/or the other party together or through withdrawal mechanisms that might be in those agreements can change those. 2B is anything that's established by ordinance, so the council can change that, and there's an example there, street maintenance and snow removal.
And then discretionary are things that have no basis other than council direction, resolution, or staff direction. So, the tiers just describe how service can be changed, not necessarily how important it is.
And that's— we're working on making sure we're classifying each of the services we provide under those different tiers and identifying what requires it, whether it's code, charter, state federal law, et cetera.
So it's a description of the service we provide and at what level, identifies what it takes to change it, and we'll be able to use that as a basis for some discussion on services. So if we take away, in some cases, if we take away X number of positions, what is that going to do? Can we still provide each of these services that are Tier 1A? We can evaluate these changes compared to the services we provide. It's not necessarily a cut list.
It's not an authority to discontinue service by staff. And it's not driving this current budget, but will definitely drive budget in the future.
As I said, it did go back out to staff recently for a review of the edits that I've made to their documents and for feedback and input and filling in some blanks that we have still on some of those documents.
And my hope is to, to bring those to Council department by department during 2027, share with you what services we are currently providing and at what level, and any options where they may not be required, where they're discretionary, so that Council can weigh in on, is that a service that you feel that we should continue to provide, or do we need to modify anything? Do we need to increase service or decrease service?
And this is kind of what I was talking about with the different requirements. There's kind of 3 different situations here. The first one, delivered at the floor. So if there's a requirement to do something and it's just fixed, the example being raw water sampling, we have to provide 3 samples a week, which is required under federal rule for unfiltered system, and we deliver 3 per week.
The next example is something where there's delivered above the floor. So a requirement sets a minimum, but then local policy has set something more. Example would be the library open hours. In order to maintain eligibility for state grant, we have to be open 50 hours per week. City policy says we'll be open between 54 and 58 hours a week, and currently the library is open for 56 hours a week.
Week.
So the minimum, because of the grant that we want to have, would be the 50, and, um, but we're delivering above that. So could we in that case cut back to 54 or 50 and have some cost savings potentially, because you're not going to need as many staff to provide it at that 50 hours a week? Um, budget transmittal is an example. The charter requires it 5 weeks before the fiscal year, and council has asked for it on the first meeting in— or first workday in November. Are we providing it above what's required?
Yes, but it's, it's just a way that we can look at different things. And there's tons of examples for all of these. I was trying to get some of the most clear ones on here just to help explain it. And in some cases, there's no level set. The code says that the city provides the service, the budget sets how much.
Example: As talked about on the previous slide, snow and ice response. Code says that we have a streets department, but we budget to staff a 2-person on-call crew from October through April in order to deal with that. And so there's a cost associated with that. Could we have a 1-man crew and do it November 1st to February 30th, 28th? We could, and— but that's something that we can set at a council priority.
You can say and we can change that level of service, or do you want it longer? Is October 15th too late in the year? But those kind of decisions drive budget numbers. And if we cut budget, on the other hand, I should be able to tell you, well, this is where I'm going to have to take this from in order to do it.
And then that one lists the EMS example again. We've already kind of talked through that one.
I do feel that most of what the residents are going to notice are in those second and third columns, the places where we're kind of going above, above what's set.
So in FY28, we'll build those plans, define the level of service, the services and the levels of service. We'll have discussions with Council on those. We'll start to equate for you what those different levels of service cost us and how we can potentially manipulate them. We'll work through our targeted rates for the future as we have the plans that may inform some of our rates that we are on this 5-year plan right now. Not all of those are built around known plans and where we need to be in the future.
We were just trying to not continue to fall behind.
The other thing I've thought about and have— going to work with staff on and potentially bring forward to council is the idea of doing a 2-year budget. A 2-year budget— there's a lot of staff time goes into this whole budget process. If we did a 2-year budget, we could be more efficient with that. We can save some time on the second year. I've talked to some folks in home rule cities that do this currently, and everybody I've talked to loves doing it that way.
What does happen for the, the legal requirements of appropriation is you have a mid-year budget update that happens halfway through where the appropriation for the second year happens. So you develop the budget all in one go for the 2 years. You can make your tweaks and fund it mid-cycle. So it's an idea. It could potentially be more efficient for us.
It could save some staff time. And we'll take a look at it. And if it seems like it's something reasonable, we'll bring it back to council with our thoughts.
Questions on that?
So, Abner, with the— I like the idea of getting like a near-term and long-term plan together, because with that, hopefully we can get into some kind of a levelized payment schedule so we know that we're going to do this much investment in this period of time that we can levelize that and not have the spikes. The peaks and valleys of the budgeting.
Then we know what's coming at us, what revenues have to be, not—. Right. And if we do that, what you'll see potentially is you would see if we were charging a flat revenue that's going to meet it, you will see those those fund balances increase, and then a project happens and they dip a little bit, and then theoretically they should start to go back up again. The next project happens and they dip a little bit because it's very hard to levelize the actual amount you need each year, but you can levelize it through maintaining that fund balance and, and appropriating it to, to do that. Questions?
Not a question, just kind of reiterating what I said earlier, but it ties in because you just mentioned a minute ago something to the effect of that if you— if we want to see things move in the numbers, you need to be able to show us what— the term you're using, level of service to be cut and whatnot. So I know we already talked about, but I just wanted to reiterate again going forward, I would like to see, and I would think this is something you would want, or I guess this is a question. Would you prefer that if we said, Abner, we at the end of this, we want to see what we would need to reduce in order to not have to do that sales tax increase. Is that something where you would want us to find things to scale back on, or is that something that you and your staff want to take on to say, if you don't want the sales tax increase, here are the areas that we think would be most appropriate to reduce. I think that staff should present you with options for what it is that you want to accomplish.
So if the goal is we, we don't want to have the sales tax increase, um, the question to staff would be, how can we accomplish that? And then I would work with staff to give you potentially some other revenue recommendations, but also what we could do to adjust budget in order to not do that. What would be required to to do that and what impact that would have on the services we provide. To me, that's the key. We can't just blindly cut and say, well, yep, I saved $500,000 and then I can't provide fire response.
That's an extreme example. That's not really gonna be impacted by $500,000, right? But I would hate to make a blind cut and then find that we can't provide a service that we really should be providing. Your Honor, would it be allowable to request for forehands to— because if we're going to ask for that information, I'd rather do it tonight than get, you know, a month into this thing. We ask for forehands to see if there's council support to request that the staff bring us back that option or recommendation on how they would go about doing that.
Yeah, we're just in a work session, so there's no motions that come out of this. There is going to be a motion near the end where we're going to open the budgets up for future budget deliberation. There will be. I have heard in the work session the whole idea is to hear what you're asking, and then when we come to those fund level discussions, bring those topics back. So I'm assuming we've written it down and we can bring that back when we have the general fund discussion.
What is the dollar value of the tax that we're talking about? Do you remember what the 0.5 gets us?
It was right around $1 million, I thought, right? That's correct. Part of that calculation incorporates a potential reduction due— for example, fuel right now is high. They're projecting that the cost of fuel is supposed to go down. So when we sell— when local vendors sell fuel, that is taxed and we get the benefit of that tax.
So if that pricing goes down, our revenue will go down. So we didn't budget a full increase of the 0.5 like we did in 2020. 6, We are estimating some reduction in sales tax revenues and then an increase, so about $1 million. But the answer is yes, about $1 million is what that 0.5 brings in, in a seasonal sales tax.
And speaking of taxes and ways to close that gap, that's actually the next slide here. So the general fund gap, the tools to close it for 2027, one option could be a mill rate change.
I know that's not a popular one or one that we're probably interested in pursuing, but again, my job is to bring you what the options are that would do it. That is one. I've talked with all of you about a potential for a visitor impact tax, or I think I was calling it a visitor impact excise previously, but essentially a sales tax on classes of goods and services that are sold mostly during the visitor season. It would be defined by what's sold and not by who buys it. And what you see on the chart there, your half mil rate, I have $0.53 million on this one, but maybe I have the wrong number.
The visitor impact tax that I had in mind, and we'll bring that in the general fund discussion a little bit, is would give you $0.85 million at about 1% and around $2.5 million at a 3%. Again, that is not in this budget. It's something that in the vein of trying to answer your previous question, Council Member Gass, about how to, you know, get more for the industry that drives our community, get more from that, this is part of the response to that. And what I would like to do is bring that in the first quarter of 2027. Fully fleshed out with the details of what that looks like, and I would suggest that we look at using that program to close the gap, uh, for 2027.
Um, $600,000 gap in our reserve for general fund, uh, we've been farther away from it than that in the past, and we can still get by with that. I wouldn't suggest we continue to do it on a regular basis, but I think we can— with the idea that we have a potential solution moving forward, we just need to finish flushing it out. That would be my recommendation.
I'm also— the third item on there is I've had some discussion with the borough, and they've shared some information on the impact of the sales tax cap and what that does. And it does appear that we have some industry that pays much lower realized tax on their goods that are sold than others. And so I'm trying to gather the rest of that information, but I may be bringing something forward to you on that as well.
Abby? In talking about the visitor impacts tax and picking different categories, currently flightseeing tours are not taxed. And flightseeing tours—. I'm wondering Is this going to be equitable amongst everybody, or is there just going to be certain people who get hit with it while others get to fly under a very nice— no pun intended, sorry— go under the radar, don't have to pay it either. And I have heard there might be some ways to get around not being able to tax particularly sightseeing tours.
But I just, I want to throw that out because that is a large amount of revenue that we do not get to participate in. And so I just didn't know if that was a factor in this because this, one of my concerns is it's going to be pick and choose. Just like flightseeing where others have to pay sales tax, they don't. And then this would, again, become that same thing. So certain people are taxing— are being taxed, but a majority of people are not.
So that was my only comment in regards to this sales tax. Similar to the passenger wharfage, there are federal regulations on taxing of flightseeing tours and air operations. And from my research so far, I haven't discussed this one with the attorney yet, but from the research so far, it looks like we cannot tax the flightseeing tours because of those limitations. So there's no impact tax that you can put on it? That's not a sales tax?
Not that I figured out yet on that one specifically.
Yes, Riley. I'd just like to suggest to the council, and I know As you mentioned, this is, you know, we're not quite here yet, but we're getting there. Uh, there's no easy answer. Nobody likes taxing, but when it comes down to choosing, uh, I really appreciate what you and the attorney and whoever have come up with on this, because in my opinion, this is kind of what the town has been screaming for for quite some time, is how can we get You know, like we heard at our earlier meeting today, there's so many stipulations on what we can use that money for. And they want—.
People feel like we need to get more money out of the visitors and the cruise ship industry to help pay for these increasing costs. And I don't want to overstate it, but this is like the golden goose right here. So I would be much more in favor of doing a tax like this that— and I'll let you speak to the specifics, but that, that is aimed directly at items and activities that are used by the visitors almost exclusively. Not exclusively, but almost. Uh, and right there, you know, 3% come up with $2.56 million.
I'd choose that over increasing the sales tax that everyone pays all day long. So I want to thank you for this, and I think this It's a much more appealing way moving forward that I think we can capture some more revenue for our general fund from our friends in the visitor industry. So thank you for that. But the key is it has to be defined by what's sold and not who's buying it. So if it's a product that's sold and we know that tourism usually buys that, if I go buy it as a local resident, I still must pay the tax on it.
Yes. Can you clarify that? I'm just curious about the flight tour thing. Like, why? Is it because they're buying it on the ships?
The flight seeing tours has to do with the federal regulations around it, is from my understanding. But when we—. But it's a leisure thing. Mm-hmm. But it has to do with— I'd have to bring more information back.
I don't have all the details in front of me right now, but from— that was one of the areas that I was looking close at, and it appeared that it's not possible. So I'd be interested. Yes, Abby. And then I do want to follow up on the third item that you just went over, sales unit sales tax. Um, and it looks like by category, which I guess we do do that for other We do.
We currently have two categories. We have rent and we have everything else. Yeah. So I would definitely look in supporting that sales tax cap by category or the— yeah, the single unit sales tax. I think there are— there's a lot of industries not from here that benefit from that more than our locals do.
So I would definitely— I mean, I'm in support of all of these except for the mill rate. That's the only one I'm not, of course, in favor for. I just want to make sure that, you know, when we define these, we're actually auditing what we're defining instead of going off of what we currently have, because what we currently have is not accurate by any means. And so I would just encourage that we really do this thoughtfully and accordingly, and then also make sure that we're lining up with timing for our local vendors and stores who do operate whatever goods or services you're looking at taxing, to make sure that they can accommodate that instead of hitting another local.
Thank you.
So I did also want to highlight just real briefly the 2028 capital question, and I've mentioned this to you in the individual meetings. The things that we deferred in 2027, the transmitted budget, we just deferred those to 2028. We did not try to add, you know, spread them out over the future years. I think that as we develop these plans, what you're going to see for our 2028 budget when we build it is a lot of, you know, cleaning that up and resequencing that around the plans then. And so when you look at this year's budget right now, what you're going to see in 2028 is that $158 million cliff for the capital program because we did just move them forward one year.
So the plans that we complete will be used to resequence those capital programs in 2028.
I think we've covered most of these already, but just to recap the assumptions and risks in the budget. Again, I have $600,000, but I may have put an old number in here on the 0.5% in-season sales tax increment.
Vacancy factor. Is about $1.6 million. Electric grants, we have budgeted for $3.8 million. Federal and state awards, we do have in, in that specific projects that rely on those funds, they are contingent on that award. So my plan would not be to move those projects forward if we don't receive the grant funding.
Wastewater generators, we've been told that we receive funding, uh, for that, and we're Still waiting the award letter, last I heard. Mentioned the KPU-IBEW agreement is not in the budget currently, so you'll see an update for that after you've adopted it or approved it, assuming you do. And then telecom revenue is about $2 million under the 2026 budget, and we need to address that in part of that strategic and financial planning for telecom. How is it going to be sustainable moving forward?
So the rest of the budget cycle, what does that look like? We've been talking about the meetings working at the fund and policy level. Just a reminder, I do have office hours set aside, noon to 2:00, if anyone wants to talk through more detailed questions, I'm happy to do that. I'm also happy to bring answers that we come across during those discussions back to be put on the record at the budget meeting.
As we go through, but that will allow us to be efficient in these meetings and go through at the fund and policy level. So November 23rd, general fund excluding the enterprises. November 30th will be our enterprise funds on the general government side and CPV discussion. December 3rd— so there was a December 2nd meeting. We have a conflicting meeting.
SEPA's annual meeting is here that day. And so, uh, we have moved the December 2nd meeting will happen starting at 6:00 PM on December 3rd. We're not going to just restrict you to an hour. The plan for that would be we'll start with a special meeting at 6 o'clock. We'll work through until you have to start your regular meeting at 7:00.
And then on that agenda, we'll have a continuation of the work session for you so that we can continue to answer any other questions or go through other presentation. And then the regular agenda items that are necessary on that as well.
December— and that meeting is going to be— we'll also introduce any rate and revenue ordinances that may be required at that meeting to support the budget that we're talking about. December 15th, capital program, be an update on what we moved, what we resequenced, and why, and anything that's changed in the budget up to then, we would we would bring those forward as well, any additional budget updates that we haven't yet presented. And then December 17th would be budget and rate adoption.
We've talked about these things that we're going to be deciding. They'll happen at the meetings that they're associated with, the fund or the program that they're associated with.
And that's what I have, Mr. Mayor, unless there's other questions. Thank you. Yes, Abby. On page 14 of the general government financial overview, it states in there the 2027 budget will require a $5.39 million drawdown of total government reserves is if budgeted costs are realized. So that statement alone would mean that the budget presented is $5.39 million over our total revenues and transfers.
Is that a correct statement? Page 14. Page 14. It's in the financial overview of the transmittal letter. I just want to make sure that I'm reading—.
We did find a couple things that, that were missed in there so far, so it's possible that just didn't get updated from submitted to transmitted. I feel like it would be important that we actually talk about real figures. It's great that our budget, our caps are met and that we're only $600,000 under or something, but I just, when I, I just want to talk about real numbers so that the public who isn't as knowledgeable as us in the room can understand what we're dealing with. The finance director has pulled up that page and can help us.
So Councilmember Bradberry, that number is based on all general government funds, so it's not just the general fund, just to clarify that. So general government side, so the budget—. So that one's including the enterprise funds? That number includes the enterprise funds in general government? In general government, not KPU.
So everything except for KPU. So what we're projecting, we start the year with, which is an estimate because we don't know how we're going to end 2026, but the estimated starting point is $100,946,465.
So before the vacancy factor is added back in, That reduction, that 5.9— sorry, the 5.39 million reflects the reduction, so that includes capital. That includes the reduction through 12/31/2027 before the vacancy factor.
Before the vacancy factor, if everything that's in each department's budget is 100% spent, then it'll be a reduction of reserves of $5.39 million, which is operation—. Which is the combined numbers that I shared tonight, as opposed to where I broke them down individually. For general government, the budget that is submitted is $5.39 $5.39 million over our total revenues and transfers that come in. Look at budget, not what we— starting balance, the budget presented is $5.39 million above. In general government, but not just the general fund.
No, general government. General government reserves. General government side, not KPU. Correct. General government side.
We are $5.39 million over our transfer— our total revenues and transfers with the budget that was so far presented. Yes. Okay, I just point that out because last year we did start at $12 million. Yep. In the statement.
So right there, I do want to applaud that that is a much better, um, number than what we started with. It's still not exactly where I would would like to be. But I do want to make a note for the public that there was a huge movement in reduction from a budget presented last year to this year. So I do want to start there before we start in— to diving into everything. Thank you for that reduction, but we still have quite a bit of work ahead of us as well.
I think every year we balance the budget by using reserves. That's part of the process, and I agree with Abby. We are reducing the amount that we rely on reserves by doing a better job of closing that gap in overspending in our budgets and things that work we can actually produce. But I— yeah, the public does need to know that it's not uncommon for any government, actually the state does it all the time, that they draw out of reserves to make sure that they have a balanced budget by using those reserves. Without those reserves, you're right, we'd be spending in the hole.
I don't understand the term balanced. I would have sworn— I'm not trying to be rude, but doesn't the term a balanced budget mean that you don't have to pull out of reserves? I always thought that's what balanced meant, even or— It's never been the practice as far as I've been here, and that is true. You use the— you use— and the state does it, and I think other and other bodies do it too, but you rely on your reserves to balance your budget because you're not always going to have a fixed revenue that's going to meet all of that. So you get to where you can to provide the services that you have to, and if you do have reserves, that's what they're for.
The other component of that, Mr. Mayor, is that more often your expenses don't line up nice and smooth the way you would want them to. So you have some years you have big expenses, You know, you have a new electric bucket truck and you have a fire truck and you have an ambulance and 3 police cars and then the next year maybe you don't have, you have half of those, right? So those expenses kind of fluctuate a little bit, especially on the large capital items. And so our reserves, the reason we don't want to go down to zero in those accounts is because we need to account for the high years and the low years of budget and over time they should average out. Unfortunately, what we've been seeing is a constant decline, and we're not seeing those up years most— more recently, and we need to get back to where we see some up years mixed in with those down years so that over time it maintains.
If we continue down the road we have been on, we will continue to see decline and we'll be at zero, and that will be a problem. Yes, Abby. Um, the other item, and I did mention it to the assistant city manager today, Through all the reports and information we're getting about sales tax, I have asked when was the last time an actual, like, sales tax audit maybe was done to see if we're actually garnering the right amount of sales tax compared— I know— so I just put that out there. I know the assistant city manager is looking into something, but as we talk about increasing our sales tax and things like that. I just wonder, is anybody actually making sure we're getting our money instead of just believing?
I'm just throwing that out there because I think that is something that we as a city need to look at and maybe better refine the categories of how it's collected or things like that and kind of bring it up a little bit into the 21st century and into more of what our community is today versus how it was, you know, decades ago when the categories were placed. So I do want to put that out there because I think that's important because I do think we're walking away from a lot of sales tax from specifically the visitor industry that I am just starting to wonder. And thank you for sharing that. And Shawn and I did have a brief conversation about it, so he shared that with me as well. So we're taking a look at that.
Thank you. Anybody else? Yes, Jeff. I actually have a couple. This first one, though, it sort of rides on conditionals and hypotheticals, so bear with me for a moment.
I understand that we'll consider the Visitor Impact Tax Ordinance in the first quarter of 2027. Am I correct in assuming that if we were to proceed with an ordinance like that, would it be for the coming season or would it be for the following year? I don't know what kind of lead time we would want to give either the industry or businesses who are going to be remitting that tax. The reason I ask is because, you know, if— I know we have asked— Councilmember Gass has asked for staff to present possible alternatives for covering the revenue that we anticipate being necessary by virtue of that 0.5% increase on the seasonal sales tax rate. And what I am trying to determine, at least in terms of strategizing for for this coming budget, if, you know, if staff presented items to us that we decided not to cut and we decided for whatever reason to implement that 0.5% increase in the seasonal sales tax rate, but then in turn implemented this visitor impact tax, would we be in a position that we could repeal that seasonal tax increase in order to cover the necessary revenue by virtue of the visitor impact tax ordinance?
For next year. For me, it's a question about timing. And I think the question of timing, Councilmember Finnegan, would be a Council discussion item during that item. I have heard some feedback that some industry is pre-selling their tickets, for example, through the cruise lines, and if we were to increase it starting tomorrow and they've already pre-sold those tickets, they would have to make up that difference, I believe. So I think it's something we have to consider as we put that together and come back with a recommendation on how and when to implement that as far as timing goes.
I just want to make sure we cover our bills. And Your Honor, if I may have a question on a different topic. Yes, go ahead. Just to the presentation or the comment Dr. Weaver made to us today, and perhaps staff can speak to this now. If you don't have the information handy, I understand.
But I was just curious about the fund that he identified within the— what was it— within the Hospital Sales Tax Fund, within Fund 110. I wondered if there's— if anyone has any knowledge of whether those funds are encumbered or how they've been handled historically. I just— I'm not familiar with it offhand, so I wondered if there was any information about that. And if we don't have it tonight, if you could bring it on another meeting, I'd just be curious to learn. I think that may be a revenue fund potentially.
We have public health as an expense side. I'm not sure if that would be the right fund or not. If it was specific to—.
It would be healthcare.
We would certainly have to look at the code on what it's allowed, what we can use those funds for. And that's in 3. 4.130. But as long as we're— it's a valid expense, the council has the authority to use it for other general purposes. So it's probably allowable.
But we do have under the Public Health Department, we have $105,000, and I believe that's the contract renegotiation or analysis or professional services if we need that. So we don't have an additional budget for an ombudsman, but—. The public health fund would be the place we would establish the expense if we were going to move forward with something like that. Sure. I just wonder what the status of those funds might be, if they might be already encumbered to something or—.
We have $8.5 million in the hospital sales tax. They are not encumbered. Currently, we do have, as we review the lease, there are some shared expenses on the hospital that the city is responsible for covering, and that's the intent of those funds is to be used for that.
So, no, they're not currently encumbered or tied to reserve for anything specific, I guess. Thank you. Yeah, and what's being suggested is that they use the hospital sales tax fund as a funding source for a position if we were to do so. Mr. Chair?
Your Honor? Yes? Speaking to that in the agenda item from May of '26, um, for an ombudsman, would it not be Well, one, I would think that we can take that out of the sales tax from the hospital, but I also think that that could also be— if we were to implement this, at what time would we do that in order to not only budget but also so it correlates with the hospital negotiations? Because I honestly believe that it should not be run by the hospital. Hospital, and it needs to be a position that has no— they have no control over, but they have to be a part of funding it because at the end of the day, they're going to be the ones being investigated.
And two, I think— yeah, I put the— the reason I brought this in May was so that we, we weren't caught with our pants down at the time that we start negotiating, because I honestly don't believe that we would do ourselves a service by not having an ombudsman when it comes to the issues that we as a city or as community members cannot keep fighting. Even with a lease agreement. And I believe you put in a future agenda item request back in May. That's the one I'm referring to, the one from May that had to get put back on your list because it wasn't on your list. Somehow it got dropped, and I apologize for that.
I'm not sure exactly what happened there. I did get some information from staff. They started to look into that. I need to digest it myself, and then I will bring that back to you at a regular council meeting with some more response to that. I apologize that it got dropped.
I mean, a little bit of, um, investigation I've looked into, there's, there's several communities throughout the United States that has these, and they are not run by the state. They are not run by the entities that are being investigated, or they're run by municipalities.
I'll bring that back. Thank you. My concern with an ombudsman is duplicating a state service that's already being provided are the reviews that come under the Department of Health. The state—. Because there is under Department of Health, there's a division that goes in and inspects hospitals and you can make complaints.
When there was a complaint to Peace Health, to the state ombudsman's office, there was an action and a reaction and they corrected the problem. I think having more information about where the patients can go to get this, this service, because it is for the people that are having issues with a health provider. And I don't know if it's the city's job to become the ombudsman for the hospital, in my opinion. There are services in place before that. And I think the analysis that I've seen so far was incomplete.
Mitch will be back next week. I need to talk with him on this and, you know, do we have the authority to even do that? I just don't know. So I definitely will finish the analysis on that and we'll bring it back to Council for further discussion as an agenda item.
Anything else before we come out of work session? Do I have a motion to exit work session and move into City Council, uh, regular session? Your Honor, I move the City Council exit the work session, reconvene into the special meeting. Second. It's been moved and seconded.
Any discussion? Hearing and seeing none, please call the roll. Yes. Finnegan? Yes.
Bradberry? Yes. Zingy? Yes. Coose?
Yes. Gage. Yes. After this moves to Item B, Resolution 26-3042, adopting the budget for the year 2027 appropriations from the general government funds, physical year 2027. Do I have a motion?
Your Honor, I'm just kidding. I move the city council postpone consideration of the draft 2027 general government operating and capital budget until Monday, November 23rd.
Second. Wait, is that the right one? No. No? You should open it.
Oh, I got to read both? You got to read it. Well, we're going to open it first, right? And then discuss it. And then we'll postpone it.
I retract my second. Yeah. Maybe I don't want to open it yet. No. Just kidding.
You think it's going to go away? Maybe I can push it a week. So I have to open it, and then we—. And then we'll discuss it, yes. And then at the end, Once we're done doing that, then we will move it to the next meeting.
Then we'll postpone the—. Because we're not approving it quite yet. Unless you want to, and then that's fine too. Yeah, and then we'd be done. Wouldn't you love that?
Um, okay, so I don't want to read the first one. I'm sorry. Your Honor, I move the City Council approve Resolution Number 26-3042, adopting the budget for the year 2027, appropriating from the general government funds for the fiscal year 2027 and establishing an effective date. Second. It's been moved and seconded.
Any discussion? Hearing and seeing none, please call the roll. Bradberry.
I'm so confused on what I'm supposed to— I don't want to approve this budget, which is—. We're not approving the budget. We're just putting it on the table for discussion like we do with any— Okay. Yes. Just to open it up to discuss, and then at the end we'll postpone it to the next, and then you'll actually approve the budget at the last meeting in December.
But you read the motion, you second, I should— we just discuss and then we move to postpone. I shouldn't have to vote yes or no on the budget today. If the motion on the table is to approve the budget and they vote yes, the budget would be approved and that item will be done. I think there needs to be discussion. There's a motion and a second.
You can have discussion, and then there should be a motion to postpone it. Yeah, there is a motion to postpone it. But that motion hasn't been made. It's the language of the motion is it's—. I read to vote—.
Voting to adopt it, not to discuss it. Oh, I see. So before we can— what we'll do is we'll adopt it. I'm voting no no matter what. Then we'll have all the— like any other motion that we have, right?
So I'm sorry, go ahead.
Yes, yes, your honor, I move to postpone— or I move the city council postpone consideration of the draft 2027 general government operating capital budget until Monday, November 23rd, 2026. Second.
Got caught there. Okay, so then we'll open the budget again for discussion.
So when we're in regular business, regardless of what it is, if it's approving a dump truck or whatever it is, you have to put a motion on the table in order to discuss it. So the first motion is to put it on the table. It's not to approve it, it's to put it on the table. We don't vote to approve it until on the 17th. We put it on the table we postpone it each meeting until we get to the 17th where the final vote happens.
And that's procedurally how you have to put this on. If we don't have a motion on table, we can't discuss it. Yes, don't we usually do the motion, put it on the table, then go into work session? Is it—. Did we kind of do that backwards?
No, the work session was just on the transmittal, right? Right. No, I understand. I just was curious. Now Wrong.
Every, every budget that we've put before, we've made a motion, right, for the budget to open it up, and that's how you open and put it on the table. Is that right? Yeah, this is historically how we have done this, and this is the same. We're not accepting it. Yeah, we're putting it on the table for discussion.
Yeah, but you can have an item onto the table without voting on it as long as you have a first somebody reads it and seconds it, it's on the table. So then, then if we want to say yes or no, we can vote, but then we can also postpone, which is what we need to do, which is what we just did without voting on the actual budget. So that's where the confusion is. And I also said yes, I agree. We don't need to have a vote, but we need to now vote on the postponement.
Unless we have a motion. So we've had a motion and a second to put it on the table. Yes. Correct. We haven't voted on it.
So now it's the vote for—. I did a motion to postpone. It was seconded. Discussion. And then we had discussion, and whenever you're ready, you can call for a vote on the postponement.
Yeah. I have a piece of discussion. I would just like to add to make everybody feel a little better. Every year we struggle just as much figuring this out. It's the same repeat every year, so I look forward to the same confusion next.
So we had a motion put on table that was seconded, and we also had a motion to postpone the consideration of the draft budget until November 23rd. So a vote on the postponement. Got it. Okay. Coose?
Yes. Zingy?
Gage? Yes. Bradberry? Yes. Finnegan?
Yes. Gass? Yes. Thank you. Moves us on to Item C, Resolution 26-3043, adopting the budget for the year 2020, appropriating from the Ketchikan Public Utility Enterprise Fund for the fiscal year 2027.
Your Honor? Yes. I move the City Council postpone consideration of the draft 2027 Ketchikan Public Utilities operating and capital budget until Monday, November 23rd, 2026. Thank you. And move and second.
Any discussion? That's the wrong motion. We just did it the wrong way. It's the only one I have. No, oh, didn't put it on the table.
It's the largest—. No, there's no motion here to put it on the table. There is. There is. 26 I'll do it.
You got to do C first. Okay, for the first motion. All right, I rescind the second. I need to stop doing large—. So start with the first motion under C.
Okay, I move the city council approve resolution number 26-3043, adopting the budget for the year 2026, appropriating for the city public utilities enterprise fund for the fiscal year 2027, and establishing a effective date. Is there a second? Second. The motion is on the table. Do I have another motion?
Your Honor? Yes. I move the city council postpone consideration of the draft 2027 Ketchikan Public Utilities operating and capital budget until Monday, November 23rd, 2026. Second. Been moved and seconded.
We're voting on the postponement consideration on November 23rd.
Okay. Zingy? Yes. Finnegan? Yes.
Gass? Yes. Coose? Yes. Bradberry?
Yes. Gage? Yes.
Thank you very much. The motion to postpone is passed. Bring this to mayor and council comments. Abby, what do you have for And on the spot tonight. Let's see.
So the one thing I wanted to say is, well, I said it earlier. Thank you for bringing a budget that's not as out of whack as last year. We're making headway, and I'm grateful to see that. But a common theme throughout the presentation today and in conversations I've had with staff is we keep saying, well, the only way to cut costs is by cutting services and levels of services. And I don't necessarily think in today's world that is completely accurate.
Um, I—. It's also mentioned that personnel, we can't cut personnel or we're cutting bodies. And I again don't think that is, is necessarily the only way we cut personnel. I think, and I, I have had conversations with the city manager, is We don't utilize systems and programs to help offset the cost of personnel. For instance, there might be a program that we can— and I'm sorry, Finance Department, you use a lot of programs, so it's easy.
So Finance Department, like, they have a program that maybe is working or that would work for them that might be $40,000 a year that might save an FTE position. Then there is cost savings in that. We do have a vacancy, so then maybe we don't need to hire somebody at a full salary of $800,000 plus benefit, or $80,000. I wish we all made that. $80,000 Plus benefits, maybe we can offset it by instituting a program.
The only reason I bring this up is I— we're just super archaic in our our government in terms of systems and we just, we waste a lot of people's time that is very valuable and they have skills way beyond the task that we are asking. And so I think that is an area where we can save and also possibly make our staff's life a lot easier. So when we talk about cuts, I don't want to just focus on that threat, because I feel like tonight was really threatening. We have to cut this if we want to save any money. And I just think we need to think bigger and that we have vacancies.
So let's see if we can fill those vacancies with cheaper options that work and maybe even work better than fulfilling or trying to train somebody and spend all that time and hope they stay, you know, long term. So I just want us to really think outside the box. There's a lot of possibilities in the world that could to help solve the problems of personnel issues. Thank you, Abby.
Janalee. I think I know what the issue is with this, and I really appreciate it. I'm sure that some of us probably need larger print, but maybe it's the cutting off of— maybe we can go back to the smaller print. Of the— on the agendas, because it's like I'm reading and I'm going, where's the date? Half the dates cut off on the end, so I don't know if that's why we're skipping over.
But otherwise, I appreciate all the work that's gone into the budget, and today was a long day, I guess we could say.
Yes, I just want to thank Abner and the staff for what they presented this evening. And, uh, after today's meeting, this is kind of a breath of fresh air.
Yeah, nothing, Your Honor. Riley? Uh, kind of follow what Abby said on some of this stuff, and, and Again, I want to thank Abner and the staff for laying this out in an understandable manner, and I think those graphs just speak for themselves. We've had tremendous increases in the last 5, 6, 7, 8 years, whatever it is. 63% Total increase in spending in general government over 5 years, 24 added positions since 2018.
$1.8 Million in 2018. So that tells me, and I know in some ways, like in the last couple of years, if I remember, we've been in a situation where, well, we've got to add IT, well, tons of spending, but staff too, because in the tech world. But I think we're starting to come full circle on that where we might even see the other side of that coin where technology is getting so advanced You know, maybe instead of increasing our IT so much, maybe we can be more efficient with some technology. So that's just a small example I thought of. I think with a decreasing population, we could take reasonable steps to stop increasing our government and maybe even scale back to what it was, you know, slowly.
So I think there's room there for that. And again— visitor impact thing. I'm sure, you know, I have to be fair. If I'm a person who owns a business that's affected by this, I'm probably not going to be too happy. But I think this gets us to a goal of how can we stop increasing costs on our residents.
By and large, as Abner said, you know, if I go into a trinket shop and buy a I don't want to say anything specific, but buy a tourism-related item, I'm going to have to pay the tax on it. But by and large, this is going to be mostly paid by our visitors. So I'm very excited about that. I'd like to hear some community feedback. I welcome feedback from, you know, people who own those types of businesses also.
But I think that's a good step going forward. So, forward to this budget. Thanks. Here, Ryan. Jack.
Thanks, Your Honor. I'll reiterate some of the points that have already been made. I really appreciate the sort of 30,000-foot view and overarching analysis of the budget as a whole. And I like the concept of 2027 as a planning year, especially if we're able to implement some of these shifts in the way that we approach the budget in the years going forward. And I also want to thank all staff who are involved in the enormous task of literally physically putting this huge budget, these binders together.
I know it's no small thing. And then only indirectly related to budget, I do want to say I think we're all probably relieved to see a respite from these howling winds that we've seen over the last couple of weeks. I know a fair number of our city staff members work outside all of the time. I have no idea what kind of effort has gone in through KPU Electric Division to keep the power on, to keep the lights on. I am amazed at how well things have held up considering the conditions that people have been working through over the last couple of weeks.
And I think we're all ready for a little break from that weather. So thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. You just jinxed us. I'd like to thank staff also for their presentation.
I think the transmittal and the chance to meet with the manager one-on-one to discuss the theory behind how this came about and, and why we're doing the things we're doing. I appreciate that we're starting in a better position than we've started in, I don't know, the last how many years, and we're actually looking at the cost of service and the service that we provide. And, you know, the community can all, you know, let us know what services that are needed and maybe what services Services aren't, so we can go through that process. Or what level of service? I think that we— they need all the services, but what level of services are we giving?
I'm looking for innovative ideas, as Abby had mentioned, in regards to any way that we can help ourselves out and use technology to reduce the cost to the city. But the reality of it is a lot of stuff we do is comes on. Somebody has to be up there working with the wires in a windstorm. But how we purchase that equipment, how we maintain it and stuff, there might be some options there that we can do.
And thank the council for all their input during this transmittal. It's been interesting to hear all the ideas that we have. Happy to see everybody so engaged. So looking forward to the next council— or the next budget meetings and making progress on this. So with that, do I have a motion to adjourn?
Motion to adjourn.
Is there a mover and seconder? Are there any opposed? Hearing and seeing none, we'll stand.