Fairbanks Borough: Platting Board Meeting, 2026-11-18
Alaska News • • 65 min
Articles from this transcript
Fairbanks borough board names alley Kiehl Lane over neighbor's objection
A Kiehl Lane sign has stood at an unnamed Fairbanks-area alley for more than a decade. Now the name is official, over one neighbor's objection.

No audio detected at 2:00
No audio detected at 4:00
No audio detected at 6:00
No audio detected at 8:00
No audio detected at 10:00
No audio detected at 12:00
We're ready in the chambers.
All right. Good evening, everyone. It's almost— it's 6:00 by my watch. The planning board meeting of November 18th, 2026 is called to order at 6:00 precisely. We are here in the Mona Lisa Drexler Assembly Chambers.
Madam Clerk, would you please call the roll? Mr. Brooks? Here. Miss Guthrie? Here.
Mr. Pitney? Present. Mr. Perkins? Here. I don't see Mr. Brannon yet.
Mr. Thatcher? Here.
And I don't see Mr. LeVon yet either. Miss Berman-Williams? Here. You have a quorum. Thank you.
As I said, we are located in the Mona Lisa Drexler Assembly Chambers, which I will note for the record Mr. LeVon is just entering. And there are 3 exits in the chambers: the double doors through which you likely entered and 1 door on side. These are located with, uh, lighted red exit signs. So in the case of an emergency, please use the exit that is closest to you.
It's, uh, in terms of my chair's comments for item C2, I will remind you that immediately following this planning board meeting, we will have a planning board work session wherein we will discuss the platting board's powers as codified in Fairbanks North Star Borough Code Sections 4.84 and Title 17.
And in addition, uh, it's getting dark, and, uh, as I drove here on Phillips Field Road, there was a tow truck trying to pick up a car that had apparently missed the turn. So just be a little bit careful. It's still pretty early, it's still pretty warm. And there are lots of folks who are still learning to drive in the winter. Other than that, I have no comments.
No audio detected at 17:00
Does anyone have any questions? No questions. Staff, would you please introduce yourself?
Yes, Madam Chair, I'm George Stephan, a planning officer with the Department of Community Planning.
Zach Lee, a planning officer with the Department of Community Planning.
I'm Kellen Spillman, I'm the director of Community Planning.
David Bredlie, Public Works Director. Rocky Esposito, Assistant Borough Attorney.
Thank you all. That takes us to item C4 on our agenda, Communications to the Planning Board.
Thank you, Madam Chair. A couple of communications tonight, if I may. I first wanted to thank all of the board members that have expiring seats. We got all of the applications in and really appreciate you being willing to re-up for another term. That does go through the mayor's office and has to be confirmed by the assembly.
So I will keep you posted the best, uh, my ability. That'll be in the next couple of weeks. It'll be, I believe, the December 15th assembly meeting that those appointments are on. The second thing I wanted to mention, um, we are getting a little bit of a head start on our budget process this year. Um, so we are looking at kind of everything, but one of the things we're starting to look at as well are the current user fees.
So we had a pretty, I'd say, significant user fee increase last year for subdivisions and subdivision-related activities. At this time, it's not our intention to propose any major increases this next year after we had that last year, but I just wanted to keep everyone posted on that. Ultimately, it'll be up to the administration and the assembly what those user fees are. And then, I also wanted to mention it's the end of the year, so I know our items are pretty light before the board itself, but our final plats are going crazy a little bit. So all those final plats coming in after your approval are really trying to come in before the end of the year.
And then my final comment is just looking at our upcoming schedule. So our next meeting is going to be December 16th. And we have 2 items for that. Knock on wood, it may be a short meeting. We have 1 road naming file and 1 modification, although that modification is to the particularly large subdivision you saw earlier this year, the borough-initiated subdivision off of the old Ninanna Highway.
And then we're actually just trying to finalize for the January meeting right now And it's January 20th, and right now we only have one subdivision for that, uh, for that meeting. And I believe that concludes my comments, and I'm happy to answer any questions board members may have. Thank you. Are there any questions?
I'm not seeing any questions. As always, I appreciate the heads up on what's coming up.
Item C5 on our agenda is citizens' comments, which are limited to 3 minutes. C5A is agenda items not scheduled for public hearing, quasi-judicial hearing, legislative hearing, or appeal. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to speak under item C5A?
No signups.
Is there anyone in the room who would like to give public comments under item C5A?
Seeing no one, if you would like to, you can come here to the public table, but seeing none, I will close comments under item C5A.
And item C5B is items other than those appearing on the agenda. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to speak under item C5B?
I have no signups.
Is there anyone in the room who would like to give public comment on item C5B? Seeing none, public citizens' comments, C5B, are now closed.
C6 is disclosure and statement of conflict of interest for items on the consent agenda, which today consists of the planning board meeting minutes. Does any board member have potential conflicts of interest for items on the consent agenda? Seeing no conflicts, That takes us to item D, approval of the agenda and the consent agenda. Approval of the consent agenda passes all routine items indicated by an asterisk on the agenda. Consent agenda items are not considered separately unless any board member or citizen so requests.
In the event of such a request, the item is returned to the general agenda. Board members, are there any items you'd like to remove from the consent agenda? Seeing none, Madam Clerk, would you please read the consent agenda?
Planning Board meeting minutes from October 21st, 2026. That concludes your consent agenda.
Thank you. I would look for a motion to approve the agenda and consent agenda.
So moved. Second.
Moved by Mr. Brooks and seconded by Mr. Pitney. We'll give Mr. Thatcher a chance next time around. Uh, any discussion?
Uh, seeing none on approving the agenda and consent agenda, Madam Clerk, would you please call the roll? Mr. Brooks?
Yes.
Mr. Pitney?
Yes.
Thatcher? Yes. Miss Guthrie? Yes. Mr. Perkins?
Yes. Mr. LaVon? Yes. And Miss Berman-Williams? Yes.
Would anyone like to change their vote? Seeing none, 7-0. The agenda is approved 7-0. Thank you.
Item F on our agenda is quasi-judicial hearings, and I note that a quorum is physically present in the chambers, so we are allowed to consider quasi-judicial hearing agenda items this evening. Madam Clerk, would you please administer a group oath or affirmation to the parties of all the quasi-judicial hearings, and anyone here who would like to provide interested person testimony.
Yes, I'm going to administer a group oath and take a roll call for your response. Everyone providing testimony this evening under quasi-judicial hearings, please raise your right hand. Do you solemnly affirm that the testimony you're about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?
I'll begin with Mr. Stefan. I do. Uh, Mr. Spillman. I do. Mr. Bradley?
I do.
Mr. Lee? I do. And I have listed here Mr. Keel, Mr. Campbell, Miss Campbell, and Mr. Loftus. That's all I have listed here. Okay.
And you're going to provide interested person testimony later? Okay, so I'll note that you— can you go ahead and say your last, uh, say your name right now for our list?
Last name is Malcolm.
M-A-L-C-O-M. Thank you.
Perfect. Thank you so much.
All right, item F1. On our agenda is NR-001-27, Keele Lane, a request by Curtis Keele to name an unnamed alley located within Parks 16 Mile subdivision to Keele Lane. The alley originates from and courses south from Lawrence Road, west of the Richardson Highway. The alley is within the east half northeast quarter, Section 22 Township 2 South, Range 2 East, Fairbanks Meridian, and the staff contact is Zach Lee. Is the applicant or their representative present?
Apparently not. Um, board members, do you have any potential conflicts of interest or ex parte information to disclose? Mr. Thatcher, is that a hand?
Nope. Nope.
All right, I am not seeing any conflicts of interest or ex parte information. Um, staff, do you have any objections to any board members' participation?
Uh, no objections from staff. No objections.
Thank you.
In that case, uh, that takes us to the staff presentation. All right, thank you very much. So showing now is an aerial image of the property in question highlighted in yellow. This is off Lawrence Road off the old Richardson Highway.
And the purpose of this request is to name this alley Keel Lane. So FNSBC 1736-020-A1 requires a petition signed by at least 75% of the adjoining property owners. And 26 out of 31 of these property owners have signed this petition, well over the 75% requirement.
And FNSBC 1736-010C2 states all generally coursing north-south thoroughfares shall be designated as street. Proposed Keel Lane does course north and south. However, staff believes a variance is not required as FNSBC 1736-010D states nothing in this section should be construed so as to prevent the Planning Board from consideration of other tag names. For unique or historical purposes. And a street sign has been in place already designating this road as Keow Lane and has been in place for over a decade.
Showing now is an image of the street sign in question. This imagery is from Google Earth's Street View of September of 2011.
So with that, we have one condition stating that the road sign shall meet the requirements of Title 17 While a road sign is currently already in place, this is just ensuring the sign conforms to DOT standards and will be verified by the applicant.
So with the condition, staff is recommending approval, and that concludes my staff report. Thank you. Board members, do you have questions of staff?
I've got one question. There was a comment from the City of Fairbanks about potential confusion between Keele, spelled K-E-E-L, Street. So earlier this year, the request came before the board renaming Keele Court, spelled K-E-E-L, to Anchor Court. And this came up— this is part of resolving that resolution, resolving that issue. Keele Court was renamed to Anchor Court, and then this alley, which is been unofficially designated as Kiel Lane is just being officially recognized as Kiel Lane.
But there aren't other Kiel either spelling some suffix in the borough? Not to my knowledge. Perhaps someone else has put an unofficial sign up. Yeah.
Okay, thank you.
Any other questions from the board? That was yours too. All right, uh, and there's no applicant here to ask questions of staff, and there's no applicant here to present interested person testimony. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to present testimony?
I do have one signed up, uh, Donna Malcolm.
If you would please join us at the interested person table.
And if you would spell your name and state your name, spell your last name, and state your neighborhood or place of residence for the record, making sure the microphone is turned on.
It's got a green light.
Perfect.
My name is Donna Malcolm, M-A-L-C-O-M. Okay, and your, your address here, this East half northeast one quarter, that is mine.
That is that property there at the very beginning of that road is mine. When that sign went up 10 years ago, I called the borough and they said it would not be officially recognized. And now it looks like you guys are—. Hold on, we've got some more technicalities to take care of before you start in with your testimony. Can we do that first?
Okay, um, I will note for the record that you did take the oath, so that's taken care of. Did you receive a Dear Property Owner letter?
I received it last Friday, uh, Friday after it was sent.
Okay, on Friday.
I did not have a lot of time to—.
Understood. But so we, we get to, we get to check you off as yes, you received a Dear Property Owner letter.
I appreciate that.
All right, now you get 3 minutes. To tell us your story.
So I contested that 10 years ago. The borough said it's not official. Somebody just went out and put that up there. And I said, well, what can I do about it? And you said if I removed it, it would be destruction of property.
Okay, so it's an alley. Why would we name it a lane? And what are the differences between an alley and a lane? Already I have a problem with the traffic that goes up and down there. We have 18-wheelers hauling huge pieces of equipment back and forth, back and forth.
5 O'clock in the morning the other day, I was awoken by it. Okay, so is it— when it gets to be a lane, are they going to be able to force me to give them more property? Because that's been the general consensus of all these people that signed your little petition. The general consensus is they can force me to move my fence closer to my house. Which would give me zero room between the house and the road.
So I am definitely not in favor of naming this Keel Lane. So there are some more reasons. If they want to name it Keel Alley, why not Keel Alley? Why does it have to be changed to a lane? And furthermore, if they really want it to designate something, the people who live on that end of Lawrence Road, not the ones who live He doesn't even live on that lane, okay?
So why should it be named after him? The fact is, other people have done more for this country and for this community than he ever has. Maybe I want to name it to my son who I lost in Iraq. Maybe it should be Sergeant James Worcester Lane, okay? You know, nobody asked me.
Nobody said a word. They just started naming it. Butch Keele acts like he owns it. Curtis Keel, excuse me, that's what it says here, but his name is Butch, acts like he owns that road. He comes and grades it whenever he feels like it.
He's gotten so close to my fence I've had to reinforce fence posts. And then his brother has told my next-door neighbor that if I don't want to play along, he'll just get on his dozer and take my fence down. So no, I do not want the name to change. I do not want any of that. Obviously, it's, you know, they've already got enough signatures And as many times as I've called the DOT and I even emailed the DOT, I said, I want to know what the speed limit and what the load limit is on an alley.
Do you know that nobody in this state can tell me what that is? Can any of you tell me what it is?
Should we actually have 18-wheelers going up and down that little lane alley hauling heavy equipment?
That's my— that's, you know, like I said, it originates at the end of my property. I own 2 acres right there off that.
We appreciate you taking the time to come in and bring testimony. Uh, board members, do you have any questions of Ms. Malcolm?
Yes, Mr. Brooks. Did I hear you right? The first time you heard any notice of this was last Friday? Yes, yes, absolutely.
I said I had to have any— if I wanted to do this by phone or by livestream, I would have to have my stuff in by Tuesday. If I get it Friday afternoon, that gives me 2 business days, 2 business days to get it in. So you didn't call the planning department to get any more additional information? No. I didn't.
I called and put my name on the list because I knew I wasn't going to be able to get any paperwork or any whatever together by then.
Other questions from the board? Mr. Pitney? Yeah, um, I'll try to pose this in a question. Um, I'm a little confused. Um, one is we're dealing with the naming of something right now, but right, you're concerned about the traffic on the road.
Do you know if that's a dedicated easement? Or that question. Utility easement. As I bought my house 32 years ago, okay, it was a utility easement then. Matter of fact, you know, I have the actual plot map from back when I bought the house here, and the outlet was supposed to be Ruby Avenue or Ruby Street, whatever it was back there.
But somebody— now it's called Eek. Somebody built across that and shut it off so that they all There was never any traffic. OK. I guess my question—. I mean, informationally, I'm not sure if we're trying to name a path that goes up there or we're naming a dedicated easement.
That's where my confusion is. And I don't know who would answer that, but—. Well, it was definitely an easement. As a matter of fact, right outside my fence is where they laid all the gas pipelines. Well, there's a difference between a PUE, a public utility easement, and a driving easement.
But I'm not sure where we're at, Chair.
Right now we are asking questions of our interested person.
Yeah. Yeah.
Are there any other questions from the board for our interested person, Ms. Malcolm?
Go ahead, Mr. Perkins. I'm curious, why would the large trucks be going up and down that road? It doesn't seem to connect to anything, at least on the map. It connects to Butch Keel's property that he has back there to put all his excavating type equipment. There is a lot of it.
And there's a lot of guys back there that have this equipment and, you know, contractors and this and that and the other thing. Before they closed off Eek, they all went out Eek to Barrow Street. And Barrow is an actual street. So when they started being so much traffic, I called I called right in here to the borough, and that was many years ago, okay? And the traffic got terrible, and they said, well, the railroad decided to close their crossing.
So yeah, that made people have to come up the alley instead. But that is not— there was another area that didn't require going across. And I'm trying to think of what the person's name was. Just a second. So, but they built over on the road, okay, and closed it off.
They built like a shed, barn, whatever. And matter of fact, give me just a second. I'll tell you who that was.
So that traffic connects to this industrial site at the lower left, not to the main highway. It's the private development. Somebody named, the last name Bradley. Is the one that built a shed across the road that would have led to Barrow, and that could have been the outlet for everybody else. When I first bought my house, there was hardly any traffic up and down the alley.
Other questions from the board, uh, to our interested person, ideally about the rename situation right now?
But before we change the name, maybe we should, uh, Somebody should get the information and find out what changes when he makes it a lane instead of an alley. What changes? So we're not actually supposed to debate right now. You, you, you give testimony. I would like question answers.
I understand. Before you leave, staff, do you have any questions for Ms. Malcolm?
No questions from staff.
Okay. Ms. Malcolm, I would recommend that you talk to our staff after we complete this, this portion of what we're doing.
Right now, what the planning board is doing is simply deciding, does this traveled piece of road get an official name so that, for example, if there is an emergency on the road, emergency services can figure out where they're supposed to go? So right now, all we're doing is giving the road a formal name so that it has a place that people can find it on a map. The other issues that you're describing are not something that we as the Planning Board can deal with right now, but I am guessing that folks from Community Planning can, uh, sort of talk to you and, and, and talk more about the issues that you're describing.
Okay, works for me. Thank you.
Thank you for coming down and giving testimony. Is there anyone else in the room who would like to provide interested person testimony? On this particular request, naming request. Seeing none, uh, interested person testimony is now closed. Since we don't have an applicant, we don't have an applicant rebuttal, which takes us to board action.
Would anyone like to move anything?
Mr. Thatcher, can you guys put it up on screen?
I move to approve NR001-27, a public road naming request to name an unnamed alley within Park 16 Mile subdivision to Keel Lane. With one condition, adopting 5 findings of fact and the staff report in support of approval. Is there a second? Second. Thank you.
It's been moved by Mr. Thatcher and seconded by Mr. Levan to approve NR001-27. Discussion?
Mr. Perkins.
Discussion on the motion. I'm very sympathetic to Donna Malcolm's issues, but as far as the road naming goes, I don't believe that the road naming is really going to affect anything, and I think all the steps have been followed so far, and it seems it's unfortunate, but I tend to agree with change the name and And then recommend that Donna Malcolm takes this up with community planning, or maybe, maybe the troopers, if there is inappropriate use of the road. But I think the naming is kind of straightforward.
Any other discussion on the motion? Mr. Pitney followed by Mr. Brooks. I'm still confused. I tried to pose it in a question to the lady, but I'm not sure if we're naming a PUE or for naming an established road easement.
Mr. Lee, can you talk about the status of what we're renaming? Yes, it is a dedicated right-of-way, 22.5 feet wide. It was created by the Park 16 Mile subdivision plat. It is right-of-way, not a PUE. Clears that up.
Thank you very much. Mr. Brooks? Just, Mr. Perkins, I think he worded it much better than I would have. I just wish she was known to give him better notice. I don't appreciate her giving last-minute notice, but other than that, what's in the name?
It's been—. The sign's been there 10 years. Um, I don't see—.
I'm sympathetic, but I don't, I don't see any issue Changing or renaming it.
Other discussion? Mr. Perkins?
I don't know, Madam Chair, if it's appropriate to ask staff, but a 22.5-foot easement is— the road easements are typically 50 feet, aren't they? I mean, is that a problem there? This is an alley. It is a right-of-way designed for secondary access, not primary access. Typically, but alleys are defined— a local road would be a 40- to 50-foot-wide right-of-way.
This is defined as an alley.
Okay, and an alley is just a reminder too, this is just discussion in the commission or the board right now.
Can we ask for some more fact findings though? Sure. Can you remind us the width of a Pioneer Road, Mr. Lee? Yeah, roughly. So Pioneer Road, the minimum right-of-way for that is 40 feet.
The physical trafficway width is 16 feet.
Thank you. Back to discussion on the motion before us.
Mr. Pitney. Well, I'm, I'm getting more confused because it appears that the road to that 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 lots to Lot 37-3435, there's a road to there, but the other lots further down have no access other than that red line that's this alley that's 22 feet wide. So apparently to get to those lots, they've got to be using that alley.
Am I—. What is in front of us is, are we going to assign a name to the stripe that was put before us, not really passing judgment on previous platting decisions?
Uh, unfortunately you cannot right now.
On the motion, Mr. Perkins.
Yeah, can we ask Mr. Lee a question? Is that—.
I would prefer we stick to talking about the motion before us, which is to rename this unnamed alley within Park 16 Mile subdivision.
Does the designation alley indicate a, a usage, a width, where you said that, um, the secondary road, primary, and so on?
Does the term alley have a formal designation? I didn't see it in the subdivision ordinance. Mr. Esposito, thank you. Yeah, I can actually weigh in on this because interpreting code, uh, the tag name does not have any real legal effect on the permissible usage of a right-of-way. Really, that's a separate consideration, whether it's called alley, street, road, circle, court.
There are standards for when those terms should be applied. This one departs from those because of the historical usage according to the staff report. But whether it's called lane, whether it's called alley, has no practical effect on the legal standards that apply to the usage of that road.
Other discussion on the motion before us?
Uh, Mr. Levan, I, I think although I wish the applicant had maybe come to be able to give a rebuttal, I don't know that I have an issue with the rename. I will say it looks like we're covered. Yeah, I just don't think that renaming this changes any of the legal realities at this location in terms of how things should be used or this suddenly being able to be used as legal access if someone were to consider subdividing further some of these affected. Plots, so I think it's fine for us to, um, change the name. And I think I'd prefer to have an official named road, and hopefully, um, we can get, um, Donna can get some help on dealing with maybe the alley being used improperly.
But I think it would still be getting used improperly as a lane if that's the case. Other discussion?
As a procedural question for either our attorney or our clerk, if we wanted to postpone this until the next meeting, would we be able to, uh, do so and get more information on how much of a road this is, or would we need to vote the motion down, uh, to get more information. I'm not suggesting that that is a something that we necessarily want to do, but as a process question, could we? Yeah, postponement to a date certain, it's possible. Um, there's kind of a needle-threading effect where under the rules you're supposed to only go to the next meeting, but under the Alaska state laws for the Public Meetings Act or the Open Meetings Act you have to comply with that in terms of notice requirements. So it might be the next meeting, or it might be one following.
Um, it would depend on the timing. I think we're doing agenda setting on Monday, so we could still sneak it in. I'm not suggesting we want to do that, but if we did, could we have additional discussion from staff about this alley? Because we're in the middle of a motion. You would probably need to table the motion, and then you would be able to reopen evidence, essentially.
If you choose to reopen evidence, and if the applicant then shows up at the subsequent meeting, you— there would be some due process considerations you would need to observe. They would have the opportunity— you'd have to give them extra time to speak, even though they've kind of surrendered their time to speak by not showing up tonight. You would have to give them the right to cross-examine staff on their questions, but it's possible. Okay, thank you. So, board, we have a motion in front of us.
We can 100% vote on this motion this evening. The motion is simply to rename an unnamed alley. If you want to do something different, now would be the time to talk about that.
Seeing no hands, is there any other discussion on the motion before us?
I'm not opposed to the renaming of this. I, I just wanted to know that we were renaming something that actually had legal access, and I think that was pointed out to me very clearly that it was. Thank you. Other discussion on the motion?
All right, Madam Clerk, would you please, uh, call the vote on the motion before us, which is to Approve NR001-27, a public road naming request. Mr. Thatcher?
Yes. Mr. Perkins? Yes. Mr. Pitney? Yes.
Mr. Brooks? Yes. Ms. Guthrie? Yes. Mr. LaVon?
Yes.
And Ms. Berman-Williams?
Yes.
Would anyone like to change their vote? Seeing none.
7-0. The motion carries 7-0. This decision may be appealed to the Board of Adjustment by filing a written notice of appeal with the clerk's office within 7 days of the date of the decision. For more information, please contact the clerk's office.
That takes us to the next item on our agenda.
RP-004-27, Endicott Homestead Subdivision. A request by Three Tier Alaska on behalf of Bruce W. and Yevgenia Campbell to replat lots 12 through 16, Tract L, also known as Block L, Endicott Homestead Subdivision into one resultant tract totaling approximately 1.03 acres. The property is located within the Northwest Quarter, Southeast Quarter, Section 13, Township 1 South, Range 1 East, Fairbanks Meridian, on Kendall Avenue, and the staff contact is George Stephan. Is the applicant or their representative present? If so, please come join us up here at the applicant table.
And if you would please state your name, spell your last name, and provide your neighborhood or place of residence for the record. Make sure the little green light is on. It looks like it is. My name is Bruce Campbell, C-A-M-P-B-E-L-L. I live in the Endicott subdivision, and I live on, um, uh, 1883 Kendall Street in North Pole.
Thank you, and I will note for the record that you took the oath earlier. Thank you. Board members, do you have any potential conflicts of interest or ex parte information to disclose?
Seeing none. Applicant and staff, do you have any objections to any board members' participation?
No. No objections.
Thank you.
All right, uh, staff, would you please give your staff report?
Yes, Madam Chair, as soon as that, uh, as soon as it shows up.
Okay, so this request is just off of Badger Road, a couple miles west of the Nordale Road intersection. And a closer view, fairly close to Badger Road. There's Kendall Avenue.
And so, right, the request essentially is to, to create one resultant lot that is the result of vacating all interior lot lines of 5 commonly owned lots. The resultant Lot 12A will be about 1.03 acres, so it exceeds the minimum lot size for GU-1 zoning. And so then it's the question, why, why is this being heard by the Planning Board as opposed to a quick plat application? And it's due to the property history. So this is the case of an unauthorized division of land as far as the parent parcels.
So the last legally created parcels is what you see highlighted in blue. That was Trackdale of Endicott Homestead. Back in 1950 that was created. And so these particular lots as they currently exist are the result of 3 unauthorized division of land, deed splits essentially, that occurred, uh, 1963 through 1965. And the applicant has met all the requirements of Borough Code 1708-100, and that is for the unauthorized division of land to allow them to essentially have a re-plat or alteration of the existing plat.
They've met all the platting requirements for that.
As far as access to the subdivision, that's Kendall Avenue, and I compliment the well-done exhibit for Kendall Avenue that was submitted with the application. Kendall Avenue is an established road that was not previously approved by the borough engineer, so in order for it to be deemed constructed, uh, needs to be adequately drained and of stable material as far as the professional opinion of the borough engineer. And that's based on an August 25th, 2025 inspection. So over a year ago, that was in a pre-application setting. And unfortunately, I did not take photos at the time, but that's when the road was inspected.
Affected. And as shown on the as-built, all the way from Badger Road to the subdivision and even beyond, they've shown that the trafficway width meets or exceeds the 20-foot minimum required by title, as well as it's contained within a 60-foot-wide right-of-way. So Kendall Avenue, for the purpose of this replat, may be deemed constructed.
And this is from Google Maps, I believe a 2011 image. The road is actually in better shape than that. And so staff is recommending approval of Endicott Homestead with the following conditions, essentially a GVA and Northstar commenting. And then condition 3 is just based on the unauthorized division of, of land. Requirements, and essentially describing that tractel, those exterior corners must be shown on the plat.
No audio detected at 56:00
The preliminary plat actually did a pretty good job of that already. The findings are really mainly based on the unauthorized division of land application and requirements, and those have been met, as well as what I described for Kendall Avenue. And that concludes my staff report, Madam Chair. Thank you. Appreciate it.
Board members, do you have questions of staff?
I have a question. Having gone through this process, will Kendall Avenue now be deemed to be constructed, or will be— will it be approved for future things that might happen? It's a great question. So, uh, for the purpose of the length of, uh, length of Kendall Avenue from Badger Road To the point of this as-built, it, it's been deemed constructed by this application, so that, that doesn't have to be repeated for lots that can rely on just this section of Kendall Avenue for subdivision purposes. But this doesn't mean that it's approved in its entirety, just up to the end of Lot 12?
No audio detected at 57:00
That's, that's correct. Um, I would say up to the end of the other side, Lot 16. Yeah, which—. That's—. But right, so just for that portion, uh, that was as-built.
Other questions?
All right, applicant, do you have any questions of staff?
Uh, no, I do not. Thank you.
Thank you. And now it is your turn.
You can present your evidence, testimony, exhibits and/or expert witnesses, or just tell us what you think we should know? This was, as staff stated, a U.S. homestead patent from 1949, platted in 1950. Somewhere between 1950 and 1963 or so, it was transferred from its original owner, Mr. Endicott, to a lady named Eileen Wood, she apparently created in this and elsewhere in the subdivision trailer courts. And the little trailer courts in my case went in and out of ownership. I can find pieces of them.
I can find a 1973 survey. It was not platted. I couldn't figure out why, except that the guy had to go— poor surveyor, Mr. Bote, had to go to small claims court to get paid. He did not get paid, and so he didn't have a reason to plat it. So here we are.
It has gone— the lots have gone in and out of foreclosure, tax foreclosure. I bought them from y'all, from the borough. Thank you very much. And others did the same. So they've been gone through court process, full deed to the borough.
The borough resold those deeds, and the legal description, in my opinion, is the issue. They did not have a good legal description. They were just merely these tract numbers, or lot numbers within a tract, and some of them inherited meets and bounds descriptions, others did not, which include these. So we are here to complete, We've got the survey going with, with 3Tier, and I really appreciate your time and thoughts on this. So thank you.
Thank you. Board members, do you have any questions of the applicant?
All right, no questions apparently. Staff, do you have any questions of the applicant?
None. No questions.
Are there any people— okay, so, uh, yeah, this is the time to ask the applicant questions.
Are there any interested people who have signed up to present testimony?
I have no signups.
All right. Is there anyone in the room who would like to provide interested person testimony? Seeing none, interested person testimony is closed.
All right. And I actually can ask you if you would be willing to return to the audience for our deliberations. That just means go back to your seat.
Oh yes, thank you.
Thank you.
Um, board, I'm looking for a motion. Mr. Levan, I move to approve RP-004-27, Endicott Homestead Subdivision, with the 3 conditions, adopting the 6 findings of fact and the staff report in support of approval. Second. Been moved by Mr. Levan and seconded by— was it Mr. Pitney?
Mr. Pitney— to approve RP-004-27, the Endicott Homestead Subdivision, etc. Uh, discussion? Mr. Levan? Uh, yeah, this seems like a pretty easy one. I don't think I actually was on the planning board before we had, um, this ordinance in place to be able to deal with these unauthorized subdivisions, but I think it's great to get everything a little bit easier for both our owners in the borough and future owners.
Other discussion or debate or comments?
Seeing none, Madam Clerk, would you please call the vote on approving RP-004-27?
Miss Guthrie? Yes. Mr. Brooks? Yes. Mr. Perkins?
Yes. Mr. Pitney? Yes. Mr. Thatcher? Yes.
Mr. LaVon? Yes. And Ms. Berman-Williams? Yes. Would anyone like to change their vote?
Seeing none—. 7-0. The motion carries 7-0. This decision may be appealed to the Board of Adjustment by filing a written notice of appeal with the clerk's office within 7 days of the date of the decision. For more information, please contact the clerk's office.
All right, that concludes our quasi-judicial hearings, and, uh, we have no public hearings or legislative hearings this evening. So that takes us to Item H of our main planning board meeting: excuse absent members. Board members, the next regular planning board meeting is scheduled for December 16th, 2026. Do you need to excuse any absences?
Apparently everyone is going to be here in December. Um, that takes us to item I, board members' comments or communications. And I will remind you, this is no debating or discussion, comments only. And I'm going to start by reminding you that we have a work session right after this meeting concludes. Other comments?
Mr. Pitney. I'd just like to wish everybody a Happy Thanksgiving. It's coming up here in a couple weeks, so thank you. Mr. Brooks, because I have total lack of cognizance of time, I have 3 kids I gotta go feed and they gotta do homework and I have to leave.
I'm sorry, we'll miss you.
Other, uh, other comments? Mr. Levan, I mean, this is a little bit out to the void, but I guess I, I do really appreciate when we have, um, people that are bringing in their issues for us to hear come to these meetings because it does make it a little bit simpler for us to get the full story the first time. Any other comments from board members?
All right, I will echo Mr. Pitney's Wishes that everyone has a, uh, good Thanksgiving, and the Planning Board meeting of November 18th, 2026 is adjourned at 6:48 PM. Let's.
No audio detected at 1:04:20
No audio detected at 1:04:40