Skip to main content

Kenai Peninsula Borough: Plat Committee, 2026-11-16

Alaska News • • 55 min

Articles from this transcript

Borough plat committee grants preliminary approval to 13-lot Hall Lake subdivision

Kenai Peninsula Borough's Plat Committee approved a 13-lot Hall Lake subdivision despite wetland and septic concerns from residents.

Cover image for article: Borough plat committee grants preliminary approval to 13-lot Hall Lake subdivision

No audio detected at 0:00

2:24
Gillham

Let's call to order the Kenai Peninsula Borough Plat Committee meeting for November 16th, 2026. Can we have roll call, please? Whitney.

2:33
Venuti

Present. Vanuti. Here. Morgan. Here.

2:40
Gillham

And Gillam. Here. A quorum is present. Okay, thank you, Madam Clerk. Now, that's, uh, the approval of the agenda and the consent agenda.

2:49
Speaker D

Um, move to approve the, the agenda, the October 26, 2026 Plat Committee minutes and group plats based on compliance to borough code, adopting and incorporating by reference as Staff Report and Staff Recommendations and request unanimous consent. Okay. Madam Clerk, before we get a second on that, can you read those items into the record, please? Sure. There are the minutes from the October 26th Plat Committee meeting, and there are 3 grouped plats tonight.

3:18
Speaker C

These are considered simple subdivisions and non-controversial, and they are Agenda Item E4, Hawks View Subdivision Number 3, Agenda Item E7, Moose Range Meadows Phase 2 Green Replat, and Agenda Item E8, Torta Acres. And those are the items on tonight's consent agenda. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Can we get a second on that motion, please?

3:46
Venuti

I'll second that.

3:51
Gillham

Is there any discussion on any of the items on the consent agenda?

3:58
Gillham

Hearing none, since we didn't— can we get a roll call vote on that, please? Oh, they did. Okay, I'm sorry, I didn't hear that. Okay, is there any objection? Hearing none, motion passes.

4:10
Speaker C

Okay, that brings us to— we have no unfinished business tonight, so that will bring us to our new business for the evening. Can Madam Clerk, would you please read read the hearing procedures into the record for us. The hearing procedures for PLAC Committee public hearings are as follows: staff will present a report on the item. The chair will ask for the petitioner's presentation to be given by the petitioner or their representative. They will have 5 minutes.

4:38
Speaker C

Public testimony on the issue, 3 minutes per person. After testimony is completed, the PLAC Committee may follow with questions. A person may only testify once on an issue unless questioned by the committee. Staff may respond to any testimony given, and the committee may ask staff questions. Rebuttal by the petitioner is allowed to rebut evidence or provide clarification, but should not present new testimony or evidence.

5:02
Speaker C

The chair closes the hearing and no further public comment will be heard. The chair entertains a motion and the committee deliberates and makes a decision. All those wishing to testify must wait for recognition by the chair. Each person must begin by stating his or her name and mailing address for the record. All questions will be directed to the chair.

5:20
Speaker C

Testimony must be kept to the subject at hand and shall not deal with personalities. Decorum must be maintained at all times, and all testifiers shall be treated with respect. If participating via Zoom, the testifier will need to use the Zoom raised hand feature or press *9 by phone to speak. Thank you, Madam Clerk. That brings us to our first item, Item E1, Bernice Steps, KPV File 2026-079.

5:48
Gillham

Can we have a staff report, please?

5:54
Vincent

Proposed plat will subdivide a 34.94-acre parcel into 20 lots ranging in size from 1.03 acres to 2.12 acres and 3 dedications. The plat is accessed on the north by Ambrun Avenue on both east and west sides with the 60-foot dedications, which are not developed except for along the north side of the plat. On the west is Sevilla Street, a 30-foot dedication intersecting Ambron Avenue in the northwest corner of the plat. Intersecting Sevilla Street from the west is Aromanga Avenue, a 60-foot dedication, and Malita Avenue, also a 60-foot dedication. Amber Avenue, Sevilla Street, and Amber Avenue to Malia Avenue, and Malia Avenue are all borough maintained.

No audio detected at 6:00

6:46
Vincent

The proposed plat is dedicating a 30-foot strip to Amber Avenue for a half dedication and a 30-foot strip to Sevilla Street to complete the 60-foot required dedication. Staff noted in the report here to recommend a 60-foot full dedication of Ambrin, but upon further research, it is found that a different owner owns the property to the north and is rescinding the request for the full dedication of 60-foot and leaving it at the 30-foot request— 30-foot recommended or 30-foot proposed dedication that they show. Also to be dedicated by this plat is Tanalian Tannalian Drive, a 60-foot dedication along an existing road from Sevilla Street to Ambron Avenue. The assessing officer has recommended to change Tannalian Drive to Tannalian Lane. Staff recommends the change also.

7:50
Vincent

The area was surveyed as Government Lot 2 of Section 15, Township 7 North, Range 12 West. Seward, Meridian, Alaska in 1954 by the Bureau of Land Management. Part of said government lot 2 was platted as Tract A Harwinger Shores KN-2000-8, located up to the east. The Nikiski Advisory Planning Commission did meet on November 12, 2026, and recommended approval. As part of our routine notification process, the subdivision plat was emailed to the affected utility providers For review, the land management officer with HGA has provided comments pertaining to the location of existing electric lines.

8:32
Vincent

Staff recommends the surveyor review the provided comments and modify the preliminary plat to accommodate the request. HGA comments are included in the packet for viewing. The subdivision plat has been reviewed and generally complies with the 2019 Kenai Peninsula Borough Comprehensive Plan. Recommendation: staff recommends grant approval of the preliminary plan subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code. End of staff report.

9:00
Gillham

Thank you, Vincent.

9:03
Gillham

Is there anyone here for the applicant that would like to discuss this matter? Do we have anybody online? OK, no hands. OK, hearing none from the Mr. Burchett, the applicant. We will open it to the general public.

9:19
Gillham

Is there anyone here from the general public that would like to discuss this matter?

9:32
Gillham

Hearing none, let's bring it back to the Committee for a motion.

9:38
Speaker D

Move to grant preliminary approval to release steps based on compliance to the Borough Code and adopting and incorporating by reference staff report and staff recommendations.

9:49
Gillham

Second. Also, can we get a motion on the 60-foot dedication of Ambrium Avenue request?

No audio detected at 9:50

10:00
Gillham

Question— I was—. Go ahead, um, go ahead, Commissioner Morgan.

10:07
Morgan

I thought staff said that we were no longer going to be requesting that. Okay, that's correct. Thank you, Commissioner Morgan.

10:21
Gillham

Okay, then let's regroup here and we will— is there any discussion from the committee for the— on the motion to— on the motion, on the main motion?

10:36
Gillham

Okay, hearing none. We'll bring it— can we have a roll call vote, please?

10:43
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Vanuti? Yes. Morgan?

10:50
Speaker C

Yes. And Gillam? Yes. Motion passes.

10:56
Gillham

That brings us to item E2, Cliff addition to Seward Township Walker replat, KPB file 2025.

11:06
Gillham

-094R1. Can we have a staff report, please?

11:10
Vincent

This plat was previously approved by the plat committee at the meeting of July 14th, 2025. It is returning for approval due to a right-of-way easement being converted to a dedication to the City of Seward, a requirement within the document creating the easement. The dedication required the plat to return as a major revision and needing new approval. The proposed plat will combine 6 parcels and 3 vacations into one tract of size 1.904 acres and 2 pieces of dedication to Chamberlain Road. Proposed plat will have access to Mill Street, Ravina Street, and Chamberlain Road.

11:47
Vincent

First Avenue from the north is not developed at this time and was approved for vacation at the Planning Commission meeting August 28th, 2026 and given consent by the Seward— City of Seward on August 28, 2026. There is also a 20-foot alley running along the west side of the tract off of Mill Street. The plat is proposing the dedication of 2 pieces of Lot 1, Block 9 to fulfill the obligations of the terms of an easement agreement. The plat is also finalizing the vacation of 3 portions of right-of-way as shown on the drawing. 2 Portions of a 20-foot alley, and part of 1st Street.

12:27
Vincent

The portions being requested to vacate are all adjacent to the lots that the applicant owns. The right of entry permit was granted to the City of Seward for portions of Lot 1 adjacent to Chamberlain Road per Book 34, page 897, Seward Recording District. As part of the agreement, the city agreed to support vacation of the alley right-of-way between Lots 1 and 12 through 14, Block 9, and the 1st Avenue right-of-way between Lots 12 through 14, Block 9, and Lots 2 through 6, Block 6, Plat S-3, in the event of the replatting being submitted. The dedication of the two pieces is part of the agreement to the vacation of the right-of-ways. The plat was surveyed as Cliff Addition to the Seward Township in September 1915.

13:18
Vincent

These lots have not been replanted until this time. The plat is located in the City of Seward. On April 28th, 2025, the City of Seward City Council reviewed and approved the vacation of the 3 right-of-ways and the subdivision of the Clift Addition to Seward Township Townsite Walker Replat. City of Seward Resolution 2025-040 is included in the packet, recommended recommending to the Kenai Peninsula Borough approval of said plat. Exceptions requested: A, KBB 20.30.120, street width requirements.

No audio detected at 13:20

13:56
Vincent

Surveyor's discussion: On behalf of AK Lands and the Walker family, I am pleased to submit for a replat of multiple parcels within the Cliff Addition to the Seward Townsite, plat number 3. Our goal is to consolidate several steep and largely inaccessible lots into a single lot that meets single-family residential zoning requirements while addressing the area's extreme topography. So, here's conclusion: we believe the proposed replant and associated right-of-way exceptions serve both private and public interest. Extreme slopes, minimal traffic, and existing infrastructure, along with prior plat exceptions, confirm that strict 60-foot right-of-way compliance is unnecessary. Granting this request allows the property to be reasonably developed without compromising public safety or welfare.

14:45
Vincent

Staff discussion: 2020-2030.120 Street Width Requirements. The minimum right-of-way width of streets shall be 60 feet. Staff reviewed the exception request and recommends granting approval. Staff recommends the committee select the findings they have determined are— they determine are applicable, make additional findings if needed, Tie the findings to the following standards and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committees will make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exception.

15:15
Vincent

Findings 1 through 3 appear to support Standard 1. Findings 4 and 5 appear to support Standard 2. Findings 6 through 8 appear to support Standard 3. Staff recommendation: Place notes on the final plat indicating any exceptions granted to— by the plat committee with the meeting date. Recommendation: Subject to exceptions granted, staff recommends grant approval of the preliminary plan subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code.

15:46
Vincent

End of staff report. Thank you, Vincent.

15:52
Gillham

Um, is there anyone here for the petitioner or the applicant that would like to speak on this matter? Anyone online?

16:02
Gillham

Still no hands. Okay, um, hearing none, we'll close it to the petitioner and open it to the general public for discussion. Is there anyone here from the general public that would like to just to speak on this matter? And no hands. Okay, seeing and hearing none, let's bring it back to the committee for a motion.

16:23
Morgan

I move to grant I move to grant the exception request to KPV 20.30.120 street width requirements, citing findings 1 through 3 in support of Standard 1, findings 4 and 5 in support of Standard 2, and findings 6 through 8 in support of Standard 3. Second.

16:48
Gillham

Is there any discussion amongst the commissioners on this? Matter. Okay, hearing none, are we ready for a roll call vote?

16:59
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Van Nooten?

17:03
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum? Yes.

17:10
Gillham

Motion passes. Okay, that brings us to item E3, College Estates subdivision. 2022 Edition, KPP File 2026— excuse me, that is— I'll correct that. It's College Estates Subdivision 2026 Edition, KPP File 2026-035. Can we have a staff report, please?

17:34
Vincent

The proposed plat will combine an 8.79-acre parcel and a portion of Knackstedt Street and subdivide them into 2 lots of 1 acre 7.797 acres, and in the process will finalize the vacation of a portion of Knackstedt Street and the associated utility easement. The plat currently has legal access from Scholastic Avenue to the north and Knackstedt Street to the east. The plat is finalizing the vacation of a 10.5-foot by 80-foot vacation that was approved by the Planning Commission on August 10th, 2026, and given consent by the assembly on September 1st, 2026. On the drawing, it is noted ROW being vacated by this plat. Staff recommends the note be changed to ROW vacation being finalized by this plat, seen Note 3.

18:26
Vincent

Change in the legend, which with hatching indicates right-of-way proposed for vacation, to indicate right-of-way vacation being finalized this plat. Multiple structures are located on the subject parcel according to available imagery. And KBB assessing data. Once subdivided, 3 small structures will be located on Lot 1B, and all the rest will be on Lot 1A. Staff noticed the septic pipe labeled on the west side outside of Lot 1B.

18:57
Vincent

If this pipe is associated with the system for structures on Lot 1B, the west line needs to be moved to enclose the system by 10 feet. The soil absorption system needs to be 10 feet from property lines. Two cabins located on Lot 1A, including associated septic pipes and well, are depicted on the plat drawing. Cabins are shown into the 20-foot building setback line, and the surveyor has requested an exception to KBB 20.30.240 building setbacks. Hackstead Street was incorporated into the borough's road maintenance program in the 1980s with a width of 50 feet.

19:38
Vincent

This occurred under the Local Service Roads and Trails Program administered by the State of Alaska, which expanded the number of borough-maintained roads. Reducing the width now would conflict with those established standards and the road's existing maintenance status.

19:55
Vincent

Exception requested. A, KBB 20.30.240, building setback requirements. Surveyor's discussion: building setbacks for the two cabins working with the roads department instructions limited the vacation area to within 2 feet north of the cabin and 2 feet south of the cabins. There was still the cabins building setback encroachment. Staff discussion: building setbacks, a minimum 20-foot building setback shall be required for all dedicating Dedicated right-of-ways in subdivisions located outside incorporated cities.

20:31
Vincent

Staff reviewed the exception request and recommends granting approval. Staff recommends the committee select the findings they determine are applicable, make additional findings if needed, tie the findings to the following standards, and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committee shall make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exceptions. Exception. Findings 2, 4, and 5 appear to support Standard 1.

20:59
Vincent

Findings 4 and 6 appear to support Standard 2. Findings 2 and 6 appear to support Standard 3. Staff recommendation: place notes on the final plat indicating any exceptions granted by the plat committee with the meeting date. Recommendation: subject to exceptions granted, Staff recommends grant approval of the preliminary plat subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code. End of staff report.

21:27
Gillham

Thank you, Vincent. Is there anyone here for the petitioner or the applicant that would like to speak on this matter?

21:36
Gillham

Okay.

21:38
Gillham

No one online? Okay. All right. Hearing none for the petitioner, let's close it for the petitioner and open it to the general public. Is there anyone here from the general public that would like to speak on this matter?

21:50
Gillham

No one here, no one online. Okay, we'll close it to the general public and bring it back to the Committee for a motion.

22:05
Morgan

Move to grant preliminary approval to College Estates Subdivision 2026 Edition based on compliance to Borough Code and adopting and incorporating by reference the staff report. And staff recommendations.

22:19
Morgan

I'll second that. OK, thank you. Can we— let's— can we have a motion on the exception request? Move to grant the exception request to KPB 20.30.240, Building Setback Requirements, citing findings 2, 4, and 5 in support of Standard 1, findings 4 and 6 in support of Standard 2, and findings 2 and 6 in of Standard 3. I'll second that.

22:47
Gillham

Okay, is there any discussion on the exception request?

22:55
Gillham

Hearing none, can we have a roll call vote, please? Whitney? Yes. Vanuti?

23:03
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum. Yes.

23:12
Gillham

Motion passes. Is there any discussion on the main motion?

23:19
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, can we have a roll call vote, please? Yes.

No audio detected at 23:20

23:37
Speaker C

I'm sorry, I wasn't on— didn't have my mic on. So Whitney? Still yes. Vanuti?

23:45
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum? Yes.

23:52
Gillham

Motion passes. Thank you, Madam Clerk. That brings us to item E5 on the agenda, Cachuta Dole subdivision Caldorwood Replat, KPB File 2026-111. Can we have a staff report, please?

24:08
Vincent

The proposed plat will reconfigure lot lines between two parcels, creating a 1.909-acre lot and a 1.44-acre lot. Access to the plat is by Hope Lamplight Road, a 50-foot state-maintained road on the south. Milky Way Street on the east is a 60-foot developed dedication maintained by the borough, giving access to both lots. Lookaway Street intersects Hope Lamplight Road at the southeast corner of the plat and goes north along the east edge. On the west, giving access to proposed Lot 3A and two lots in the adjacent plat to the west is Cove Circle, an undeveloped 50-foot dedicated cul-de-sac.

No audio detected at 24:10

24:49
Vincent

The Roads Director is requesting an additional 10-foot dedication to bring this road into compliance with KVB 20.30.120 street width requirements of minimum width of streets shall be 60 feet. Staff is in agreement with the Roads Director in the request for the additional 10 feet dedicated to Cove Circle. Staff recommends the server add the additional 10 feet to Cove Circle, blending it to the design currently in place.

25:17
Vincent

KF— the KWF wetlands assessment identifies a small area of the lake wetland being in the— on the west side of the plat. Staff recommends the surveyor review the assessment data and add the wetland information to the drawing as needed. Exceptions requested: A, KVB 20.40.040A, conventional on-site soils absorption systems. Surveyor discussion: The petitioner is requesting an exception to KBB 20.40.040A to not provide a soils report prepared by a registered engineer. Conclusion: given the existing engineered septic system documented suitable soils, favorable topography, and adequate lot size, the requirement for an additional soils report prepared by an engineer is unnecessary.

26:09
Vincent

The petitioner requests approval of this exception. Staff discussion. 20.40.010, Wastewater disposal. All lots within a proposed subdivision in the Kenai Peninsula Borough must meet the following applicable standards of this chapter for wastewater disposal. 20.40.040, Conventional onsite soil absorption systems.

26:33
Vincent

If any lots within a subdivision will utilize conventional onsite soil absorption systems, and are less than 200,000 square feet, the following requirements must be met and submitted to the Planning Director. Staff reviewed the exception request and recommends granting approval. Staff recommends the committee select the findings they determine are applicable, make additional findings if needed, tie the findings to the following standards, and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committee shall make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exception. Findings 1, 2, 4, 6, and 7 appear to support Standard 1.

27:15
Vincent

Findings 1 through 4 and 6 through 8 appear to support Standard 2. Finding 5 appears to support Standard 3. Staff recommendation: place notes on the final plat indicating any exception granted by the plat committee with the meeting date. Recommendation: Subject to exceptions granted, staff recommends granting approval of the preliminary plan subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code. End of staff report.

27:44
Gillham

Thank you, Vincent. Is there anyone here for the petitioner or the applicant that would like to speak on this matter? Jason Young is online. Okay, Jason, would you give your name and address for the record and then go ahead, please? Uh, Jason Young, PO Box Jason Tauriainen, Kasilof.

No audio detected at 27:50

28:00
Speaker G

I am here on behalf of the petitioner and Edge Surveys to answer any questions the chair or committee may have. Okay, thank you. Are there any questions for the speaker?

28:12
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, thank you very much, Jason.

28:18
Gillham

Okay, is there anyone else for the petitioner that would like to speak on this matter?

28:23
Gillham

Hearing none, let's move to the general public. Is there anyone here from the general public that would like to speak on this matter?

28:32
Speaker D

Nope, hearing none. Let's bring it back to the committee for a motion. Move to grant preliminary approval to Kachada Dole subdivision Calderwood replant based on compliance to the Rural Code and adopting and incorporating by reference the staff report and staff recommendations.

No audio detected at 28:40

28:50
Speaker D

Second that. Can we get a motion on the exception request? Move to grant the exception request to KBB 20.40.040A, Conventional Onsite Soils Absorption System, citing findings 1, 2, 4, 6, and 7 in support of Standard 1, findings 1 through 4 and 6 through 8 in support of Standard 2, and finding 5 in support of Standard 3.

29:21
Gillham

I'll second that. Is there any discussion on the exception request?

29:32
Gillham

Hearing none, can we have a roll call vote, please? Whitney? Yes. Vanuti?

29:40
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum? Yes.

29:46
Gillham

Motion passes. Is there any discussion on the main motion?

29:57
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, are we ready for a roll call vote? Whitney? Yes. Benuti?

30:07
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum? Yes.

30:13
Gillham

Motion passes. Okay, thank you, Madam Clerk. That brings us to item E6, Marriott Subdivision Murkis Addition, KPP File 2026-115. Can we have a staff report, please?

30:28
Vincent

The proposed plat will subdivide a 32.687-acre parcel into 13 lots ranging in size from 1.071 acres to 6.146 acres and dedicate 2 right-of-ways. Access to the plat is by Steadman Street on the west and Water Street on the east. Steadman Street is a 60-foot dedication that is currently undeveloped except for a small stretch of 60 feet that turns into a driveway for the property. Water Street is a 66-foot dedication that is developed from Harbin Avenue down to Watersport on the, on the rest of Water Street is not developed. Two dedications are proposed on the plat: Andy Court and Packer Way, both 60-foot wide, both proposed 60 feet wide.

No audio detected at 30:30

31:19
Vincent

Both roads appear to be crossing steep slopes. Staff recommends the surveyor submit plan and profile drawings to the road department for review of extra slope easements may be needed. And the addendum is addressed to the intersection of Andy Court and Steadman Street and Harbin Way. Upon further review and surrounding open projects, once the vacation of Harbin Way is complete to the northwest, the distance between intersections will not be an issue, as was noted previously in the staff report. And then in the comments to be corrected was also the tangents between curves.

31:58
Vincent

And that was further reviewed as compared to the center of the, the roads at those tangents, and those corrections are not needed either. That's for completing KVB 20.30.130. Block length is not compliant on the east side, and the surveyor has requested an exception to 20.30.190. Wetlands are shown on the drawing. With, with the grass hatch.

32:26
Vincent

Kettle Wetlands, most— mostly located on the east side of the plat, are shown. The plat is adjacent to Hall Lake on the south, which the kettle on the east abuts to. A soils report will be required, and an engineer will sign the final plats for lots 1 through 3 and 5 through 12, as the lots are below 200,000 square feet. Comments have been received from the public, and Opposition to the development of this property. Increased traffic and crime are issues in the comment, but the Planning Department reviews Chapter 20 Planning Code, which does not deal with these issues when looking at the plat drawing.

33:04
Vincent

Also, issues with the wetland fill and positioning of the septic systems and wells are noted, along with groundwater issues. These are controlled with the submittals of system— submittals to the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation for their review and approval. The soils reports submitted to the Bureau are only for use to approve the final plat, not for system design. Exceptions requested: A, KBB 20-30-190A, 3-to-1 lot dimensions. Surveyor discussion: Requesting exceptions to 3-to-1 lot dimensions for Lot 4.

33:40
Vincent

20-30-190A lot dimensions, the minimum depth shall be no less than 100 feet and the average depth shall be no greater than 3-to-1 3 times the average width. Staff reviewed the exception request and recommends granting approval. Staff recommends the committee select the findings they determine are applicable, make additional findings if needed, tie the findings to the following standards, and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committee shall make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exception. Findings 1, 3, 4, and 6 appear to support Standard 1.

34:20
Vincent

Findings 1 through 4 appear to support Standard 2. Findings 5 and 7 appear to support Standard 3. Exception B, KBB 20.30.170 block length requirements. Surveyor discussion. Question block length requirement exception, particularly on the northern boundary of the subdivision.

34:43
Vincent

Staff discussion. Block requirements: blocks shall not be less than 330 feet or more than 1,320 feet in length. Along arterial streets and state-maintained roads, block lengths shall not be less than 800 feet. Block lengths shall be measured from centerline intersections. Staff reviewed the exception request and recommends granting approval.

35:06
Vincent

Staff recommends committee select the findings they determine are applicable. Make additional findings if needed, tie the findings to the following standards, and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committee shall make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exception. Findings 1, 3, and 4 appear to support Standards 1 and 2. Findings 5 and 6 appear to support Standard 3.

35:33
Vincent

Staff recommends placing notes on the final plat indicating any exceptions granted by the plat committee with the meeting date. Recommendation: subject to exceptions granted, staff recommends grant approval of the preliminary plan subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code. End of staff report. Thank you, Vincent. Is there anyone here for the petitioner or applicant that would like to speak on this matter?

35:58
Gillham

Uh, I would. You can hear me? Okay. Um, can you state your name and your address for the record, please? Cody McClain, 151 Dahlia Circle, Soldotna.

36:09
Cody McClain

I'm here to represent the petitioner, to answer any questions that are technical nature. Could you speak up just a little bit? You're— we can barely hear you.

36:18
Cody McClain

Cody McClain, 151 Dahlia Circle. Is that better? It's a little bit better, but can you get just a little closer? Can you hear? I have no Cody McClain, 151 Dahlia Circle.

No audio detected at 36:20

36:36
Speaker D

That better? I don't really know where my microphone is. Hey Cody, Cody, this is Robert. It starts out really good for like the first 3 words and then it fades off, so I don't know if you're moving away from the microphone when you start talking.

36:53
Speaker G

Uh, yeah. Yeah, sorry guys, I don't know what to do or say here. Um, this is Andrew Hamilton with McClain Consulting, uh, PO Box 468. We're both— Cody and I are representing the applicant. We are available to answer any questions, you know.

37:19
Andrew Hamilton

Um, I'm the land surveyor for the project and I can answer any questions regarding the platting and Cody is available to answer any questions concerning the construction of the roads.

37:30
Gillham

Okay, thank you. Are there any questions for the speaker?

37:35
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, thank you very much, gentlemen. Is there anyone else for the petitioner, the applicant, that would like to speak on this? Okay, hearing none, we'll open it to the general public. Is there anyone from the general public? Oh, hi.

37:53
Gillham

Okay. Heidi, can we have your— are you speaking for the applicant or the general public? Okay. Can we get your name and your address for the record, please? My name is Heidi.

38:07
Gillham

Heidi, hold on just a moment. We've got some feedback.

38:14
Venuti

Okay. Can you go ahead and try again? Can you hear me, Heather? No.

38:20
Speaker C

Are you got a microphone and a phone on? No. No, no, no. Okay, any suggestions for the fix there? Heidi, I see that you are— have called in twice, and so either you've got two windows open, maybe if you close one of those windows that will make it because you have a real bad reverberation and we can't understand you.

38:48
Speaker C

Can you come back?

38:55
Gillham

That's not any better yet. Here, try again. Is that any better? Yes, much better. Thank you.

39:03
Heidi Morrison

Can we get your name and your address for the record and then go ahead? Sure, my name is Heidi Morrison. 1650 Pebble Beach Court, Kenai, Alaska. And I wanted to speak in opposition to approving this plat and the exceptions as noted in the staff report. Um, the Hall Lake has had a history of having relatively large lot sizes until the Murkises subdivision.

39:35
Heidi Morrison

The average lot size has been over 2.5 acres, and the Murkises' continual— or this is their second large purchase of parcels in attempt to subdivide into tiny lots, all that require borough exceptions in the width and depth.

39:58
Heidi Morrison

It's over doubled, it's doubled the amount of lots. On this small lake. And there's several of us lot owners that do not wish to see that amount of development on this lake in the last 18 months. And so this lake does drain into the Kenai River drainage, and there's concerns about, as noted before in the staff report, the septic systems and the, um, how it affects the, uh, the drainage here. So I, I'm going to ask that the assembly not grant the exceptions for the widths and the depths variances that the plat is requiring.

40:54
Gillham

OK, thank you, Heidi. The assembly will be hearing this at a later date. Oh, this is just planning. OK, so that then we'll just be looking at what the code provides for us here. Thank you very much for your comments tonight.

41:13
Gillham

Is there any questions for the speaker?

41:18
Gillham

OK, hearing none. Is there anyone else from the general public that would like to speak on this matter?

41:28
Gillham

Okay. Oh, you're up here. Okay. All right, we'll go ahead. Okay, Megan, go ahead.

41:35
Vincent

Let's get your name and your address for the record and then go ahead. Hi there, Megan Morris, P.O. Box 1302, Sterling. Um, first, thanks for allowing virtual participation for those of us who can't be in town. Um, I am speaking in opposition for Mariette subdivision, Marcus addition.

41:53
Vincent

Um, I— it's worth mentioning that there are unresolved questions about Hall Lake's connection to the Kenai watershed, and as of July 2026, there's a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers wetland investigation underway. Um, I know that the borough sees these wetlands and labels them as kettle wetlands, but we're in the process of currently mapping and investigating that with the Army Corps. Um, so just Worth noting, but to reiterate Heidi's statement, um, and I'm really urging the assembly not to grant the exceptions, variances, or any other special allowances that would enable this proposal to move forward at such great density. Um, Hall Lake is a really small 40-acre lake connected to the Kenai watershed, and it's only about a mile of shoreline total.

42:41
Megan Morris

So we were at 13 lots for a number of years, um, and in the last 18 months with this proposal that you're all reviewing today, it would increase 115% in 18 months. Um, so given that level of cumulative growth, existing development standards, um, and, and also the uncertainty around the classification of wetlands and nearby habitat, um, I would just urge us to take a little bit more time before looking at this plat and approving all the exceptions. And thanks so much for the public comment process.

43:16
Gillham

Okay, thank you, Megan. Are there any questions for the speaker?

43:23
Gillham

Hearing none, thank you very much, Megan. Is there anyone else from the general public that would like to speak on this matter?

43:31
Gillham

Would you like to step up to the microphone right up here? And let's get your name and address for the record.

43:40
Maura Schumacher

Hello there, my name is Maura Schumacher, um, and I live at 39061 Longmere Way, which is also my mailing address. My husband and I are landowners on Hall Lake, um, and I have some concerns with, um, what is being proposed by the Merckes development.

44:04
Maura Schumacher

Um, the planned location for Steadman Road, um, I do believe crosses through surface water that is connected to the lake. I personally, within the past couple of weeks, um, walked the entire outflow of Hall Lake and did confirm that there is surface level connection. Much of it is flowing water to the Kenai River, um, which in my understanding changes the way that we treat wetlands that surround a lake. So I have concerns about the location of the road and it cutting off wetland connections to the lake. Um, I also have concerns with the current activity taking place in a previously subdivided area by the Murkis Company, um, there is clear and active activity of wetland filling on the shoreline adjacent to Hall Lake, um, in the previously subdivided area.

45:11
Maura Schumacher

Um, so I have some concerns about that also taking place on the lots that are being considered for platting at this time.

45:26
Gillham

I think that's all I have. Thank you. Hold on just for a moment, please. I'm going to see if the commissioners have any questions for you. Is there any questions for the speaker, please?

45:38
Gillham

Okay. Hearing none, thank you very much.

45:44
Ben Morris

Okay. Can we get your name and address for the record as well, please? Ben Morris, PO Box 1302, Sterling, Alaska. I'm in opposition of the subdivision as well. I'm a landowner on Hall Lake, just as Maura and other speakers here, and I have concerns with the wetlands and the connection to the Kenai River.

46:05
Ben Morris

With Maura talking about how there is surface water connecting, it's likely that our— the lake is anadromous and the exceptions that are being asked should not be approved. As previously stated too, there are multiple Army Corps claims out right now, as well as a history of pike eradication from ADF&G on this lake. That would not be done if there was no thought of connection to the Kenai River, and we're just asking for waiting to grant exceptions or disincluding exceptions until the Army Corps, Kenai Watershed Forum, and/or ADF&G has completed their assessments.

46:53
Gillham

Okay, thank you. Is there any questions for the speaker?

47:00
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, thank you very much for your comments tonight.

47:06
Gillham

Is there anyone else from the general public that would like to speak?

47:18
Gillham

Okay, that looks like that's it for the evening. Okay, then let's bring it back to the committee for a motion.

47:35
Venuti

I move to grant preliminary approval to Marriott Subdivision Murky's Addition based on compliance with the Borough Code and adopting and incorporating by reference the staff report and staff recommendations. Second. Can we get a motion on Exception Request A?

47:59
Venuti

I move to grant the exception request to KPB 20.30.190A, 3-to-1 lot dimensions for proposed Lot 4, signing findings 1, 3, 4, and 6 in support of Standard 1, findings 1 through 4, in support of Standards 2 and Findings 5 and 7 in support of Standard 3. Second. Is there any discussion on Exception Request A?

48:39
Gillham

Hearing none, can we have a roll call vote on Exception Request A? Whitney.

48:49
Speaker C

Yes. Benuti?

48:54
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum? Yes.

49:02
Speaker C

Motion passes.

49:08
Gillham

Can I get a motion on Exception Request B?

49:14
Venuti

I move to grant the exception request to KPB 20.30.170 block length requirements, citing findings 1, 3, and 4 in support of standards 1 and 2, and finding 6— excuse me, 5 and 6— in support of standard 3. Second. Is there any discussion on exception request B?

49:40
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, can we have a roll call vote on Exception Request B?

49:54
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Venuti?

49:58
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan? Yes. And Gillum?

50:05
Gillham

Yes. Motion passes. Is there any discussion on the main motion?

50:15
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, can we have a roll call vote on the main motion?

50:23
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Vanuti?

50:28
Venuti

Yes.

50:30
Speaker C

Morgan? Yes. And Gilliam? Yes. Motion passes.

50:37
Gillham

Okay, thank you. Um, thank you for coming in tonight, um, for your comments. We do appreciate you coming in. Okay, thank you. Okay, that brings us to our next item of business.

50:48
Gillham

That will be item E9, Foggy Hollow, KPV file 2026-053.

50:55
Gillham

Can we have a staff report, please?

51:00
Vincent

The preliminary plat Hangarville Hollow, KBB 2026-053, was conditionally approved at the July 20th, 2026 plat committee meeting. The subdivision name was changed to Foggy Hollow per KBB request. A final submittal has been submitted and reviewed by— at this time, the surveyor has submitted and an exception request for KVB 20.40.040, conventional onsite soils absorption systems. Exceptions requested, KVB 20.40.040, conventional onsite soil absorption system surveyor discussion. We request an exception to KVB 20.40.040 for Lot 5, which will be the combination of remnants from the original aliquot parcels, which are being cut off by the dedication of North Fork Road right-of-way.

51:54
Vincent

Staff discussion for 20.40.010, Wastewater Disposal. All lots within a proposed subdivision in the Kenai Peninsula Borough must meet the following applicable standards of this chapter for wastewater disposal. Staff reviewed the exception requests and recommends granting approval. Staff recommends committee select the findings they determine are applicable, make additional findings if needed, tie the findings to the following standards, and vote on the exception in a separate motion. The committees will make findings of fact meeting the following standards before granting any exception.

No audio detected at 52:00

52:29
Vincent

Standards 1 through 3 and 6 appear to support Standard 1. Findings 4 through 6 appear to support Standard 2. Finding 6 and 7 appear to support Standard 3. Staff recommends placing notes on the final plat indicating any exceptions granted by the plat committee with the meeting date. With the granting of this exception to no soils report and the statement there will be no uses that will generate wastewater, staff recommends the wastewater disposal note in KBB 20.40.080B shall be also placed on the final plat.

No audio detected at 52:50

53:05
Gillham

Recommendations, subject to exceptions granted, staff recommends grant approval of the preliminary plat subject to staff recommendations and compliance with KBB code. End of staff report. Thank you, Vincent. This is for the exception request only. Let's see, is there anyone here for the petitioner or the applicant that would like to speak on this matter?

53:32
Gillham

Okay, hearing none, let's close it to the petitioner or applicant and open it to the general public. Is there anyone here from the general public that would like to speak on this?

53:43
Gillham

No one present. Okay, we'll close this comment to the general public and bring it back to the committee for a motion. Move to grant the exception request to KBB 20.40.040.

53:55
Speaker D

Conventional onsite soil absorption systems, citing findings 1 through 3 and 6 in support of Standard 1, findings 4 through 6 in support of Standard 2, and findings 6 and 7 in support of Standard 3. Second.

No audio detected at 54:00

54:12
Gillham

Okay, thank you. Is there any discussion on the exception request?

54:17
Gillham

Hearing none, can we have a roll call vote, please?

54:22
Speaker D

Whitney? Yes. Benuti?

54:26
Speaker C

Yes. Morgan?

54:30
Speaker C

Yes. And Gillum? Yes. Motion passes. Thank you, Madam Clerk.

54:36
Gillham

That brings us to item F on the agenda. Um, this gives you the opportunity for any public comments on items not appearing on the agenda. Is there anyone here that would like to speak on items that were not appearing on the agenda tonight.

54:51
Gillham

No one online? Okay, that brings us to the adjournment. Can we have a motion to adjourn? Move to adjourn. Okay, so ordered.

55:00
Speaker C

Um, do we need some time to switch over to the Planning Commission? No, I think I can switch it around in time. We'll just leave this, um, meeting open, this Zoom meeting open. So, so, and Planning Commission meeting will start at 7:30.

Speakers in this transcript