Petersburg Borough: Assembly Meeting
Alaska News • • 125 min
Articles from this transcript
Petersburg Assembly rejects $15,000 plowing plan for Papke's Landing roads
Petersburg Assembly voted 7-0 against a $15,000 plan to plow Papke's Landing's private roads. A taxpayer said only Service Area 1 payers should fund plowing.

It's 6 o'clock, Monday, November 16th. Uh, I'd like to call the regular meeting of the Borough of Petersburg Borough Assembly to order. And with that, would the clerk please call the roll? Mayor Lynn. Here.
Vice Mayor Stan Gregor. Here. Member Martin. Here. Member Meucci?
Here. Member Newman? Here. Member Marsh? Here.
Member Valentine? Here. Yeah, for those listening in, we have 6 people here in the chamber, and we have Member Meucci, uh, uh, Zooming in. And with that, we'll move on to the volunteer Pledge of Allegiance.
I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. Thank you.
On tonight's agenda, I have— excuse me— two sets of the regular assembly meeting minutes, one of October 5th, 2026, and one of October 20th, 2026. Do I have a motion to approve those minutes? So moved. Second. Moved by Member Valentine, seconded by Member Marsh.
Are there any changes that Assembly would like to make?
Okay, I'll take both of them. All those in favor of approving the minutes for October 5th and October 20th, say yes. Yes. Okay, with that, I'm going to move on to the approval of the meeting for tonight's agenda. Uh, do I have a motion to approve the, um, the, uh, tonight's agenda?
I move to approve tonight's agenda as is. Okay, second. Been moved by a member, Stan Gregor, seconded by Member Valentine. Any, any changes? Okay, hearing none, would the clerk please, please call the roll on tonight's agenda as presented?
Vice Mayor Stan Gregor. Yes. Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine?
Yes. Member Newman? Yes. Member Marsh? Yes.
Member Meucci? Yes. Mayor Lynn? Yes. And that's approved by all members of the, of the assembly.
I'm going to move on then to the next item here, which tonight we have several public hearings. The first public hearing is for Ordinance 2026-24. An ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on issuance of borough permits for certain data center development. Any public testimony regarding ordinance 2026-24 should be given during this public hearing, and a copy of the ordinance may be found under agenda item 14A. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to talk to the ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on data centers?
Please come forward, state your name and who you represent, and you have 5 minutes. Thank you.
Hi, um, Becky Knight representing myself. Hello, Mayor and assembly members. Becky, Becky Knight here. Thank you for the opportunity to speak on proposed ordinance 202624, establishing a 9-month so-called moratorium on Petersburg Borough data centers. I continue to urge you to amend the ordinance to make it a full 1-year moratorium in the true sense of a, of a moratorium.
As previously noted, as I interpret, the ordinance reads more like a conditional use permit than a moratorium in the defined meaning of the term. That is not to trivialize the 3 conditions that the ordinance recommends in order to operate to be during the so-called moratorium. Rather, on the surface, they seem to be excellent protective measures, but they should accompany other safeguards to which our, our community deems necessary to protect our collective quality of life. We should not gamble that a data center could not possibly be approved prior to the end of the proposed 9 months, whether or not the one envisioned by the Bozeman, Montana developer or another is near approval. If that circumstance occurs, there are no takebacks and will basically render any further regulatory efforts moot, at least for any that can leap the regulatory hurdle in time.
The horse will be effectively out of the barn. In my mind, the question here is to whom is the Bureau acting on behalf of, the data center developers or the interests of the community? No public work session has been undertaken beforehand to assess legitimate concerns of the public. Keep in mind that what is being proposed is not a golf course putting green. It is a potentially hugely impactful and will have irreversible impacts upon our little town.
I'm a great believer in full public input when there may be significant impacts affecting the quality of the human environment. A public workshop enabling two-way interaction and brainstorming would go far, far in your assurance that a full range of potential impacts can be considered. For instance, under Section 4, Review and Recommendations in the Proposed Ordinance A through H, including various items to be reviewed during the proposed 9-month period, include electrical capacity considerations appropriate siting, development, operating, monitoring, and enforcement standards, community quality of life, economic impacts, fire protection, and many other items of concern. However, the list is not exhaustive. For instance, what if Bitcoin mining reared its head, or other data uses not previously envisioned?
And there's probably plenty. I would also like to draw your attention to a thoughtful letter written to the Borough Assembly on October 5th, 2026, by a younger member of the community, Our Future. And I assume it's okay to cite it since it was in the public record. Perhaps you missed it due to the ransomware attack. As I understand, emails were affected, but I encourage you to read or reread the letter in its entirety.
It offers creative thinking on, quote, how to transition away from the price volatility of imported fuels and toward better utilization of our amazing electrical hydropower grid. The author wrote, quote, "We need sufficient electrical energy or sufficient energy to live the types of lives we want to live on our island." For instance, quote, and he— this is the person's quote— "Given our invaluable power supply resource developed and paid for through the generations, we should assess how we want to best utilize it instead of passively sitting back and allowing data centers to come in and take advantage of our inexpensive electrical power. The author cited the expensive fuel skyrocketing completely out of our local control due to federal and global forces, and quote, how to, instead of falling victim to these forces, how we could avoid them by further retrofitting or replacing existing infrastructure with heat pumps and transition the borough to electric vehicles. The author goes on to advocate for special electric rates for data centers since they are an industrial power— power demand that adds no other value to our community via jobs. Why should they reap the benefits of our history of hydro investments?
We should price their power competitively with what they would pay for power down south, or double our residential rate, or something along those lines. These valuable ideas are but that we need to consider as a community during a true moratorium, not after the fact. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony. Is there anybody else who would like to talk to the ordinance 2026-24?
Is there anybody on Zoom? Yes, we have, um, Mary Evans has her hand raised and two others as well. Okay. Yeah, um, Mary, if you're on there, Uh, you have the floor.
All right, I just unmuted. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Perfect. Thank you very much.
Um, my name is Mary Evans, and I'm representing myself. I'm here to voice my support for the passing of the data center ordinance. I don't think that it's enough, but it is a bare minimum and a place to start. I want to take the opportunity to talk for a moment about this industry at large. We keep hearing that we have to build these data centers because AI is the future and we have to just get over it.
And I just want us to really think about, is this really the future? Or is it just 5 companies handing money back and forth and a bubble that's about to pop? If it's so great, then why is Google having to orient around force with its implementation, making access to its search engine in schools contingent upon allowing students access to its AI tools? Why are we seeing AI forced into our critical infrastructure? Like the FAA before its reliability and safety has been proven.
On another note, I keep seeing the argument that opposition to data centers is somehow hypocritical if you're someone who uses the internet. One industry tracking source estimates that in the United States, um, in 2016 there were 376 operating data centers, and in 2026 there are 1,283. With hundreds more under construction and thousands more in various planning stages. Does this sound— does this rapid increase of scale sound like it's for powering your email? It is of my opinion that these developers lack substantial federal oversight and regulation, and the lack of regulation in the tech that these data centers are powering is even more atrocious.
People keep referring to AI as the next Industrial Revolution. Do we need to be reminded what the beginning of the first Industrial Revolution looked like? We are far removed from the Chicago meatpacking industry circa 1900, but we would be remiss to forget what happened there or at Blair Mountain, West Virginia. Unregulated industry was not good for the working class, for the consumer, for public health, for the safety and well-being of children. The labor laws that we have now were quite literally written in blood.
What is our version of this going to be within this new industrial revolution when the leaders of this industry have been given carte blanche from the highest office in this country to literally regulate themselves. My point is that we need to take the act of protecting ourselves very seriously. I strongly believe that if an energy-intensive, non-local industry wants to use our renewable energy, then they should have to pay a competitive rate and not be entitled to preferential treatment. Data centers create minimal permanent jobs within the community, have no products in or out to tax, have no ancillary benefits like truck traffic for gas stations or use of other local businesses. They use local resources to convert energy into bits that are then sent off and don't do anything for the local community.
If we are going to do this, then we need to make this benefit us, not just theoretically. Let's go back to the promises of AI that its leaders tout: a cure for cancer and a socialist utopia. My question is, if this is the ultimate goal, then why are the current most consequential uses of AI autonomous killer drones and other weapons of war, systems of mass surveillance, and the automation of entry-level jobs. Instead of shoehorning new technology into our community based on promises of abundance, like a theoretical 2% savings on our utilities 10 years from now, we need to instead demand changes to our material conditions now. Excess heat generated, distributed to the community, whatever it is, we deserve a measurable economic benefit, not a speculative promise.
'Look at all these great things we could do' is not an acceptable answer. This midterm season, there were at least 41 ballot measures concerning data center restrictions across 10 states. In 40 of those 41 contests, voters sided with greater restrictions on data center development. This is not an isolated concern in Petersburg. Communities across the country are demanding a greater say in what happens to the resources.
My hope is that passing of this ordinance gives breathing room to create a rigorous protective regulatory framework over the next 9 months. Because as it's written, this ordinance leaves the door wide open for hyperscale data centers to set up at only power and lights discretion. It doesn't address a maximum electrical load per facility, a maximum number of facilities, maximum cumulative electrical load from data centers, or a maximum acreage. I desperately hope that moving forward, the Assembly takes their responsibility seriously to act in the best interest of the citizens of Petersburg Not the best interest of SEPA, not the best interests of prospective developers, and not the interest of an industry that may or not deliver on its promises. Your responsibility is to the people who live here, who pay the bills, who depend on these resources, and who will be left living with the consequences of these decisions long after the developers have moved on.
Thank you.
Thank you for your testimony. Is there anybody else, uh, clerk on Zoom that would like to talk? Yes, we have Joshua Adams. Okay, Joshua, you have the floor. Absolutely.
Can you hear me now? My name is Joshua Adams. We can very well. Thank you.
Good. I'd like to talk about— or until September. Yeah, I've been on the Planning Commission for the last year, and we've talked about the data center. Moratorium, but I came here to speak on my own behalf. I can see the wisdom of caution when it comes to untested tech, and I'm— testimonies of the people who are concerned about the proliferation of hyperscalers in Petersburg, and I don't disagree with them.
Ordinances can be a first line of defense against greedy corporate interest. The rampant proliferation of telecommunications towers has taught us what can happen when we are not legally prepared to meet the moment. And I've experienced that on the Commission with the—. Joshua, we lost you there for a bit. Telecommunications towers, the projected to revitalize Ocean Beauty.
Oh, did you lose me there? Sorry, where can you hear me now? Is my condition stable? Can you hear me? Much better.
Okay, sorry, I'm a little sketchy here. The projected data center of Mazella, Alaska is part of an integral plan to revitalize Ocean Beauty by repurposing it as a kelp processing plant, and installing a data center is an essential part of that plan. Now, I want to separate the hyperscalers from Mazella, Alaska because this 2-megawatt micro data center is just It's like a pilot for us, and I really want to say that you guys are on the right track, I think, and I'm coming around to your way of seeing this about the moratorium. I just want to say that this is— I'm going to talk about Mozilla Alaska.
Okay, you're cutting out again there, Josh. As a grandfathered in, so I think that— am I cutting out again? Darn it. Okay, well, whatever our misgivings may be about this form of technology, I urge the assembly simply to consider one thing: Mazela, Alaska, ocean beauty at the same time. If we don't take that winning lottery ticket, we face decades of decline.
No audio detected at 15:40
Over the next 30 years, Petersburg faces the loss of possibly a quarter of its population, and that's if fishing remains sustainable, which it won't. The question of the 21st century is not AI but energy and ocean beauty. Along with the data center of Mozilla Alaska, offers us an opportunity to sell our excess electricity. Center at Ocean Beauty proposes to add $2.1 million to Petersburg's coffers in electricity purchases alone. And we could probably haggle on that.
I've, I've listened to the other testimonies. Electricity that is literally spilling over the top of a hydroelectric dam. If we don't use it, we just lose it. And we're not using that electricity now. For decades, Petersburg has searched for a way to be about more than just fishing.
Petersburg has 238 streams in its immediate vicinity, many of which could be outfitted with micro hydro. Data centers would incentivize us to upgrade our antiquated grid to accept net metering, allowing private landowners to install wind, solar, and micro hydro on their properties, which they could sell to the grid, which in turn sells to a data center. The harvest of electricity could become our next economy and an off-ramp away from the just fishing. Um, other communities have experienced the dangers of allowing hyperscalers to infiltrate areas where energy and water are scarce. Contract with Mozilla Alaska to ensure that they will pay for any excess electrical costs incurred through backup generation.
And this was mentioned in previous testimonies, and it's very true. We need to be careful. We need to be savvy about the contract that we, that we sign with Mozilla Alaska. But Mozilla Alaska filed its permit application back in August. That's 3 months ago.
Their claim predates any moratorium that the assembly shall discuss tonight. And maybe data centers are a bad idea for Petersburg. We won't know that until we try one out under controlled circumstances. And Mozilla Alaska has given us just that, the opportunity to have a pilot program, a miniature data, a small, a mini data center. I urge the assembly to grandfather the Ocean Beauty micro data center as planned because we need a good pilot for what could become something really beneficial for our town.
And the other reason, the more obvious reason, is because if we don't, Petersburg could get sued over this. And I'm afraid of what might happen in a situation that involves a lawsuit against Nozella Alaska. And that would be expensive and really lamentable. Joshua, would you— could you wrap it up, please?
I don't know how much of that you got. Yeah, yeah, no, that's really all I had to say. Did you guys catch most of that? Yeah, yeah, I didn't catch the last part of what you said, but I appreciate your testimony. That's good.
I can't hear you. Yeah, that's all. That's it for me. Thank you. Thank you guys for listening.
Okay, thank you. Moving forward, we have one other person. Clerk, is there anyone else on Zoom that would like to speak? Please raise your hand.
Yes, we'd have Dave Beebe. Okay, Dave, you, you've got the floor.
Hi, can you hear me? We can very well, thank you. Yeah, I'm Dave Beebe speaking on behalf of myself, and given the history of the, uh, the overwhelming public opposition to cell tower discussions, uh, as well as data center. Now, these concerns are, are not well represented by the assembly's process, and it is my feeling that this moratorium, which is actually not a moratorium if there's already a permit that it will allow to occur, doesn't even apply to Mozilla's data center.
I think it's important to understand if this history of disregard for public testimony on a local level, maybe as has been already, you know, very clearly articulated by both Becky Knight and Mary Evans, there are many issues here that, as far as I'm concerned at least, would necessitate— before any ordinance language occurs, we need to have a public process by which we have a work session that allows for an actual confirmation of public sentiments about data centers. And, and just as we did prior to the, the cell tower installations, and to, to propose an ordinance that does not take into account a qualification of public sentiments is, like I said, premature. And the other thing that I think, given the importance of of this matter, that we really should have a ballot initiative that concludes without any doubts that there is a majority of people in town that are all for data centers. And I say this realizing that the institutional disregard for public testimony of taxpayer residents Maybe you can reflect on what has been recorded by Ballotpedia, and that is, as of November 14th, 2026, voters had decided 53 of measures that would— ballot measures directly related to data centers. And these measures would either allow or facilitate data center development or limit or prohibit data center development, advise government officials to oppose their development.
I think that this makes a— establishes a very important part of democratic principles to bring this to a public mandate, because as of November 14th, 2026, voters had decided 53 of the measures in 52 cases. That is 98% of decided measures favored limiting data center development, either by approving restrictions or advisory measures opposing development, or by rejecting measures that would have facilitated or otherwise supported development. Now, this is testimony that this is literally the, the national mandate, and, uh, I think given This is from voters who are directly impacted by data center experiences already, that the borough assembly really should weigh very carefully how they proceed from here, because we have this prior national experience to understand the consequences of actual data center development. You got 30 seconds or more, Dave. Go ahead.
I have nothing more to say.
Thank you for your testimony. I much appreciate it. Is there anybody else, clerk, that would like to talk to this ordinance? No, there is no one else on Zoom. Okay, thank you.
Is there anybody else in the audience that would like to talk to Ordinance 2026-24?
Okay, seeing and hearing nobody, I'm going to move on to the second public hearing on tonight's agenda. That's a public hearing on community development block grant application for Petersburg Medical Center's proposed long-term care facility. Public testimony regarding the borough's proposed CDBG application may be provided during this hearing. Resolution application materials are available under agenda item 15B. Is there anybody would like to talk to the Petersburg Medical Center's grant application?
Please come forward, state your name and who you represent.
Good evening, Mayor Lynn and assembly members. For the record, I'm Phil Hofstetter, CEO of Petersburg Medical Center. I'm asking for your support for the Community Development Block Grant application to advance the schematic design for our replacement long-term care building. For background, the Community Development Block Grant is a federal program funded through the Housing and Urban Development, also called HUD, and administered by the state of Alaska. It competitively funds public facilities, housing, planning, and economic development projects that primarily benefit people with low or moderate incomes.
Approximately $2.4 million is expected statewide for this funding, with awards up to $850,000 per community. Municipalities must serve as the applicants. After considering input, the Assembly is being asked to select PMC's Long-Term Care Schematic Design as the borough's project, authorize an application for up to $800,000, and authorize the mayor to sign the application and necessary grant documents if awarded. The state will then determine which applications receive funding. This long-term care schematic follows the phased replacement plan identified in the borough's capital priorities.
As you know, Phase 1 has been site development, Phase 2 the work building, which was just— both are complete. And our next priority is Phase 3, which is the long-term care portion, followed by Phase 4, which is the replacement of the hospital. This grant would build on the investment already made and move the long-term care design forward. Schematic design will help define the building's layout, scope, and costs as we pursue construction funding. The borough would serve as the applicant, with PMC and our grant financial team would handle all the application project administration and coordinate in coordination with the borough.
And the application deadline for this year is December 4th. Welcome your input. And the assembly to approve and ask the assembly to approve the resolution authorizing the application. Thank you. Thank you for testimony, and we'll come back to that under one of the agenda items that follows here.
Thank you. I'm going to move on tonight to the bid awards, and we have one bid award here. PND Engineers, Inc., construction administration and project inspection services for the Scalabae Hallout Project. Staff requests Assembly approval to award a contract to PND Engineers, Inc. for construction administration and project inspection services for the Skow Bay Haulout Project. PND Engineers has submitted a state— statement of qualifications outlining experience and qualification to provide the requested professional services.
The statement of qualifications submitted by PND Engineers, Inc. and a memorandum from the community director Development Director and harbormaster is attached, and I believe there is a suggested motion below on the bid award. If somebody would like to make that motion. Mr. Mayor, I would move to authorize the Borough Manager to execute a professional services contract with PND Engineers, Inc. for construction, administration, and project inspection services for the Sky Bay haulout project, consistent with the recommendation of the Community Development Director Harbor Master. Is there a second? Second.
Okay, been moved by Member Stan Brager, seconded I think both by Member Valentine and Member Marsh. Discussion from the assembly? Okay, Member Martin. So I assume this comes out of that money we accepted a few meetings ago from the federal agencies. If you would like to address that, uh, Harbor Master, I appreciate it.
It sure does. It's a requirement by the federal government that we, um, hire somebody, and prior to hiring, go through a submission of qualifications, which they passed with shining stars. And so we hope that you accept their bid and we can get going on the project.
Was it, was it part of the bid amount, uh, or was there money set aside for this? Yes. Okay, thanks. Okay, other questions? Hearing none, would the court please call the roll on the motion?
Mr. Mayor? Oh, I'm sorry, go ahead there, Member Meucci. I didn't see your hand. Yes, yeah, it's a funny hand anyway. Hey, was there a dollar amount Um, with this hardware there, yes, there is a dollar amount and the number is $894,000, roughly $894,000.
Thank you.
Member Newman. Well, Becky gave us a revised suggested motion for item 6A. And it has the number on there. Okay, you want to—. So I moved to— I'll just, I'll just read it.
I'll just read it. I move to authorize the borough manager to execute a professional services contract with P&D Engineers for construction administration and project inspection for the Skow Bay boat haul-out project in an amount not to exceed $893,603.
Second that. Is that okay with you, Vice Mayor? I'm perfectly fine. We're not changing the, we're not changing the, the theme of it. It's just consistent, really just adding the dollar amount.
So I think, I think it works well with you. Yes, I think so. Who seconded that motion? Great, thanks, James Valentine. Okay, thank you.
I didn't realize there was a second motion. So any other discussion now, Assembly Members? Member Marsh. So we are authorized— this is authorizing up to $893,603, uh, if it If it comes well below that, does that pose a problem, or the balance of that go into the project itself?
Boy, we would sure love it if it came in under, and if it does, then we won't have to spend that. It'll go towards other portions of the project.
Any other questions from Assembly members? The clerk, please call the roll on the amend— the motion. Mayor Lynn? Yes. Member Meucci?
Yes. Member Marsh? Yes. Member Newman? Yes.
Member Valentine? Yes. Member Martin? Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? Yes.
And that passes 7 to 0. I'm going to move on then to persons to be heard related to tonight's agenda. Is there anybody in the audience would like to talk to items related to tonight's agenda? Please come forward, state your name, and you have 5 minutes.
I am Steve Arbor, the utility director, and I apologize for if this comes out not smoothly. I hadn't planned on speaking tonight about this, um, but to go to the moratorium, I, I agree with everybody else that it's not perfect, um, and I agree that there's a lot of mixed emotions and feelings in town. Um, I've talked to people that think it's going to be good to help with rates. I've talked to many that thinks it's bad, and we can have all sorts of public meetings and all that to decide that, but we should do that after we pass this ordinance because what's could very real happen is we end up with generators running 24/7. None of us want that, and none of us want an open-loop system where we're using all our city's water or dumping stuff in.
Um, I, I don't know the right answer. I don't know how we all feel morally and, uh, on the data center issue, but I do know none of us wants generators running 24/7. And that's the purpose of this ordinance in keeping our water clean. Thank you. Thank you for your testimony.
Is there anybody else who would like to talk to items related to tonight's agenda?
Hello, Mayor and assembly members. My name is James Kerr. I'm speaking today as a Service Area 1 taxpayer. Of 610 Sandy Beach Road in opposition to the proposed $15,000 expenditure for snowplowing at Papke's Landing. I'm not opposed to Papke's residents receiving plowing services.
I'm opposed to the borough providing those services without following the borough charter and requiring the benefiting property owners to pay, to pay their fair share. The Petersburg Borough Charter is clear. Section 14.02 identifies road maintenance as a service area power, and Section 14.05 restricts the use of service area tax revenues and establish requirements for using service area resources outside their boundaries. Service Area 1 taxpayers pay an additional property tax specifically for road maintenance and snow removal. Residents outside Service Area 1 do not pay that tax.
Whether the borough uses its own employees and equipment or hires a private contractor, contracting out the work does not eliminate the requirement to comply with borough charter. During the November 2nd assembly meeting, Borough Manager Steve Giesbrecht reportedly acknowledged the borough attorney had previously advised against plowing outside Service Area 1 because of charter restrictions. Has that changed? Has the borough attorney now determined this expenditure is legal. If so, I request that opinion be made available to the public for this before the assembly votes.
The borough was incorporated in 2013. For 13 years, residents outside Service Area 1 have had the opportunity to pursue the creation of a service area to fund additional services they want. Instead, the assembly is considering spending $15,000 to benefit approximately 46 residences at Papke's Landing. When I say 46, this is the number of houses that would receive snow plowing to the end of their driveway, which is the same level of service I receive in Service Area 1. That amounts to $326.09 in proposed expenditures per residence, while Service Area 1 property owners continue paying additional taxes for the same type of service.
If the assembly believes this is fair, then as a Service Area 1 taxpayer, I request the equivalent $326.09 credit towards my property taxes, subject to legal authorization. I also question the assembly's spending priorities. The borough still has no approved union contract and has been unwilling to meet employee wage requests. Yet it is considering spending another $15,000 on snowplowing outside Service Area 1. Why not consider using legally available funds towards closing the gap in employee wages instead?
Finally, I want to remind assembly members that Alaska Statute 29.26.250 allows municipal officers to be recalled for misconduct in office incompetence, or failure to perform prescribed duties. The Alaska Supreme Court's decision in Jones v. Biggs recognized that knowingly violating municipal law while performing official duties can support recall proceedings. If assembly members knowingly approve an expenditure that violates the borough charter, their individual actions can provide grounds for voters to pursue Recall, elected officials are accountable for complying with the law. A majority vote does not give the assembly authority to disregard borough charter. It is time for Petersburg Borough to stop placing an unequal tax burden on Service Area 1 taxpayers and require those receiving additional services to contribute their fair share.
Thank you, James Kerr. Thank you for your testimony. Is there anybody else would like to talk to items related to tonight's agenda? Is there anybody on Zoom? Yes, we do have Dave Beebe with his hand up.
Okay, Dave, go ahead. Hi, my name is David Beebe, speaking on behalf of myself. According to today's borough approval of the minutes of October 5th meeting, and the connected preceding Board of Adjustment meeting, I submitted timely correspondence and testimony which posed questions pertinent to public process, due process, and oaths of office. I would like to remind you I requested a borough response to my correspondence regarding Title Network's applications, and I requested an explanation from the borough how it reconciled bypassing borough regulatory functions while passing ordinances in conflict with those of office, in apparent violations of our constitutional mandates assuring rights to privacy and freedom from unwarranted search and seizures, as well as due process.
By all appearances, such contradictions, if not hypocrisies, bring up issues of our local government being an accessory to enabling ordinance language clearly in conflict with constitutional mandates. Regarding regulatory functions, I provided official federal agency evidence calling into question the applicant's high-speed broadband coverage claims and further expert testimony evidence which validate public concerns about the borough's ordinance language and review process. Regarding the November 2nd assembly meeting, I want to thank a member of the assembly for having taken the time out of his day of that meeting to listen to my concerns and bring it to assembly discussion. On the one hand, it resulted in important assembly discussion with the manager being central to my earlier questions of the integrity of the public process and other democratic principles of our local government. On the other hand, given his honest though disappointing characterization of my concerns as being, quote, abstract and, quote, lofty, the latter defined as proud, aloof, self-important, such slurs validated my concerns for the reigning institutional culture of the Bureau and its actual regard for the public process.
To be clear, the public process is defined as, quote, actions that engage the public in decision-making, allowing them to provide input and influence decisions that affect their lives. This process is essential for ensuring transparency and accountability in governance. Here's the takeaway of that brief discussion. The Bureau has no policy on the public process that is essential to ensuring transparency and accountability in governance. The Bureau has unequivocally and unabashedly admitted arbitrary and capricious disregard for public process, no matter how overwhelming public testimony in opposition to its foregone conclusions are.
The outcome of those questions regarding the Bureau's respect for the public process and that assembly discussion 43 days ago can be characterized in 3 words: nothing, nada, zilch. Thank you for this opportunity to speak. Thank you for testimony. Is there anybody else that would like to talk to items related to tonight's agenda?
Okay, please. Yes.
Yes. Unrelated. Unrelated. No, I, I was about due to go to unrelated here. Okay, but let me, let me finish.
Anybody else unrelated?
Okay, hearing none, I'll move it into unrelated. And then you'll be the first one at the—. Excuse me, I thought we were on unrelated. My apologies. My name is Molly Tybur, and I represent the PMEA, Petersburg Municipal Employee Association.
And the results of the vote are in. They came in on Friday, and they were an overwhelmingly no to support the borough's last, best, and final offer. And we look forward to your next guided steps with this. Thank you. Okay, thank you for your testimony.
Anybody else like to talk to items unrelated to tonight's agenda?
Okay, is there anybody on Zoom? No, there's no one. Okay, thank you. With that, I'm going to move on then. There's nothing tonight under the board commission committee reports.
There's nothing under the consent agenda. And then under report of other officers, the first item under that is the SEPA report. Utility Director Harbour will provide a report on Southeast Alaska Power Agency board meeting held on October 29th, 2026. Meeting notes are attached to this agenda item. Mr. Harbour.
Mayor, thank you.
So we had our regularly scheduled SEPA board meeting October 29th. The beginning of it, we went through some fiscal year '27 budget and long-term planning numbers. This is all draft, and we should see it before the board, I believe, December 2nd. We looked at the 4R Plan, which is our, basically our replacement and maintenance plan. It looks ahead for many years with a strong focus on the next 5 years and major renewal and replacement needs to keep the grid in good condition.
One of the significant items on there is our submarine cables. Um, they're approaching their expected life expectancy, and I think we all remember when we had the one break. Um, so there's a lot of look at that expense, um, and we'll be discussing that in detail in future meetings. Uh, the plan looks at the life expectancy where we're at, how much it's going to cost to replace it, and what we need to have in reserves for it, and how much each individual year we should be adding to those funds so that we can meet the next milestone for funding. We also talked about the board-approved contracts to replace Swan Lake's oil coolers and purchase a transformer for the Ketchikan substation.
These weren't necessarily in this fiscal year, but because of the long lead times we're seeing, we went ahead and approved it now.
The board also directed an executive session for the CEO to work with the prospective contractor that bid on the third turbine to see if we could get a better price.
The board discussed providing rebates to communities for diesel generation required during the recent capital projects. That was brought up by both Petersburg and Rangel, and it's going to be on the agenda. It's not a guaranteed, um, give, and either way, PPL isn't going to be trying to recoup costs from the ratepayers for that. Um, we also suggested this work was that we— they did the shutdown and we had to run diesels was supposed to be done during the planned 2-week shutdown, but because of long lead times, things aren't falling in the right order. And I believe both communities asked that in the future we, we look at these capital projects, and if there's supposed to be downtime, even if the plan is to do it during the annual SEPA shutdown, that maybe we need to budget, uh, money for diesel if it doesn't fall on that window.
Um, and then the board completed the CEO's performance and evaluation and discussed the results with them. Uh, the review was very positive. The board also provided feedback on areas it considered important and discussed goals for the new fiscal year.
Um, Misael Alaska presented a proposal to purchase power from SEPA for a possible data center. Later, during an executive session, the board discussed how much power is available, the roles of SEPA and the local utilities under the power sales agreement, future power development, and load growth. The board, uh, unanimously agreed that we needed a lot more discussion before any decisions or anything come out of that. Um, and upcoming meetings, like I said, December 2nd, and then officers for 2027 will be elected in the first board meeting of 2027.
Any questions for Mr. Harber? Okay, Member Martin. Thanks, Director Harber. There, um, is there a way that you've seen that we can listen to the meetings, uh, or is it just a matter of waiting for the minutes to come out? Um, if you go to the SEPA website and look under the board of directors, it, it shows the upcoming meetings and a Zoom link to listen in.
And any of those meetings can be listened in with the exception of an executive session.
Uh, Member Valentine. Thank you. Um, with, uh, Muzzell Alaska, and they said you had it here, presented a proposal. Is that like to the whole SEPA board? They, they had a presentation to the whole—.
Nothing on hard paper, but just a presentation. Just a presentation. Just a presentation. Thank you. I believe Assemblymember Meucci was Zoomed in for it.
Thank you.
Um, Member Meucci. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Hey, just, I like your report, Steve. Can you kind of give us a little rundown of the proposed data center that he was talking about? And its power generation needs.
I mean, I mean, this is a total different project than what he has planned over at Ocean Beauty, is that correct? I believe he was referring to Ocean Beauty, but I don't want to put words in Mr. Mazzella's mouth, but he was looking at a 2-megawatt to a 5-megawatt to 10-megawatt build-out in a matter of years, which Petersburg Municipal Power and Light cannot support that right now. We don't have that power.
So, okay, thank you. So those power generation needs he was talking about, those are for what he's planning if things work out for the Ocean Beauty project. Thank you. Do you want to— I would add to that is that there's a question, a legal question here that Power cannot be— they cannot provide— SEPA cannot provide power to a particular entity other than the 3 communities. So any, any proposal would have to come to the communities themselves to be able to be dealt with.
No audio detected at 49:40
Yeah, SEPA is a wholesale supplier, not a retail supplier, right? We would lose all our tax benefits, all our— we're not regulated by the state.
Yeah, there's a number of legal questions here. We're still wrestling on that, but it has to come from the communities themselves. Um, other questions? Okay, seeing none, thank you for your report. And I'll move, I'll move on here.
And I think you have the customer communication outreach update. Yeah, so we're at P&PL, uh, we're trying to take some steps to to provide more value to the customers, and one of the things is better information, a greater openness and transparency. Can't get there overnight, but these are some of the tools that, that we're working on right now. In the upcoming week and weeks, you'll see more and more opportunities to sign up for the mass notification system, and what that'll do is when we have an outage, Um, you'll get a notification that we are responding and that it is an outage in the community and not just your house flickering lights. Um, and then once we have a, an idea how long the restoration is going to be, we'll be able to give an update and let you know how long that's going to take, or if there's areas that are going to stay out.
Like, uh, I don't think it was last year, maybe the year before, when we lost the pole there by Jeff Hubbs' house at Nine Mile, that, that was like a 12-hour outage for people beyond that. So it'll give us some opportunities like that. There's a couple ways to sign up, and these will show up on our website, and I'm going to talk to a couple other people and get them up on their websites where you can go to sign up, or you can text this number in here to get there. But if anybody has any technical difficulties signing up, I encourage you to call Power and Light and talk to one of the CSRs, or you can email me and we can get you put in there to get a text. One of the other things, this last week we put in a Skow Bay 2 project site where you can take a peek at the overview of the project, some thinking behind it, the budgets, some pictures.
And just get an idea where we're at in the process. And then shortly, it might be another month before I can do this, I wanna put some educational videos out. I got a library about 6 to 8 that I feel pretty good about right now, but I don't wanna start off where you watch a couple and then you don't hear from me for weeks. And it's everything down to how your bills are figured out, to when the lights are blinking, what that means, uh, just all sorts of information like that. So if you have any ideas for those videos, you can definitely email me with your questions and we'll see what we can do.
So thanks. Questions? Uh, Member Stan Gregor. Yeah, just briefly, Mr. Mayor, not a question, just a thank you to you and your staff for getting that going. I think that is a very useful service for the community, so thank you again.
Other comments, questions from the assembly? No. Thank you for your presentation. I'm going to move on then to the mayor's report. From there, seeking letters of interest.
The letters of interest should be— let me back up. For the Harbor Board, we have one vacant seat, and we have two seats on the Planning Commission until October 2027 municipal election. Letters of interest should be submitted to the clerk at the borough offices located at 12 South Nordic Drive by sending to PO Box Box 329, Petersburg, Alaska 99833, or by emailing to [email protected].
Wishing— the Borough Assembly wishes everyone a happy and healthy Thanksgiving holiday. The last item I have is the Chamber tree lighting event. The Chamber of Commerce will be hosting the tree lighting event on Friday, November 27th, in the Municipal Building parking lot. The Candlelight Parade lineup begins at 5:15 at IGA, and the parade begins at about 5:30. Come and enjoy the fun.
And with that, I'm going to move on. Uh, there's no written manager report, and I'll move on then to unfinished business. Under unfinished business, we have one, one item, and that's Ordinance 2026-24, an ordinance establishing a temporary moratorium on issuance of borough permits for certain, certain data center development. This is the second reading. If approved in 3 readings, the ordinance will establish a temporary moratorium through September 30, 2027, will restrict issuance of borough permits for new data centers and expansions that exceed available PMPL grid capacity, rely on generators for normal operating power other than in cases of PMPL outages or curtailments, or use cooling systems that are not fully self-contained and closed loop.
Ordinance 2026-24 passed on its first reading by a vote of 5 to 1. Do I have a motion to approve Ordinance 2026-24? I would move to approve Ordinance 2026-24 in its second reading. Second. Been moved by Member Stan Gregor, seconded by Member Valentine.
Member Stanton Gregor. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll just kind of briefly say what I said during the first reading for those listening at home. I acknowledge it is not a perfect ordinance, but I think it addresses our biggest vulnerabilities as a community, namely large off-grid, potentially multi-acre sites with diesel generation running, or something Diesel generators running downtown if it was zoned appropriately. I think we can all agree that is not something we want for our community to hear the sound of diesel 24/7.
Um, aside from that, I want to thank Stephan Harbour for his comments. If we want to do something else down the line as we address our power needs or what we want as a community, I think that is fine. I hope we can approve this as is because I think if we can get this across the finish line, Sooner than later. I know for myself it'll give me a sigh of relief regarding the vulnerability of our community, and we can look at a bigger picture view after that. So I hope this passes and we can get this on the books and then move forward.
Thank you. Thank you. Member Valentine. Thank you. Um, yes, this is needed.
Not perfect, we all know, but it is needed. Um, I've been thinking about this a lot, a lot of community input. And, um, the one thing that I've seen so far is that there hasn't been an actual, like, actual permit set in front of us to see. A lot of this is just talk. And then when we had brought this up, Jeff had brought this up, Mr. Meucci brought this up a long time ago to try to stay ahead of it so we can try to stay out of it.
Like the towers kind of snuck up on us. So we wanted to get ahead of it and we had a presentation and all that. Now, we sat through a very long presentation with Carl and Steve when the first proposal came to us about only 2 megawatts. Right. And this 2 megawatt and then having the presentation by Carl and Steve, it didn't— it wasn't bad to me.
2 Megawatts, call it good, boom, that's it, it's done, wash your hands of it. However, over time this has been morphing. Now we're hearing that we want 2, then 4, then 5, then 10, then so on. And so it— you couldn't— he couldn't right now come in and say we want 10 because we couldn't supply that anyways. But I've been— it just— it's, um, and the first person that Mr. Mazzella was working with has now dropped, and we still haven't heard another presentation come in with whoever the new people people are.
And again, we haven't seen a proper permit in front of me, so I want to add all these protections for us, but we haven't seen anything in front of us to actually, like, work with. And I'm kind of just kind of rambling a little bit because this has been just clearly on our brains for a long time.
I think that if it was just 2 megawatts through this moratorium, as we study and do this, I'm not opposed to that, only being 2 megawatts, call it good, that's it. But if it all of a sudden we let them in and then it morphed into 4, then 5, then 10, that is not what the initial permit was. That's not what the community wants. It's not none of that. And it just, it, it, this is morphing into something way bigger than what was originally presented, which is why at least one moratorium to start gives us a breath to like study all the excesses coming, all the talk that's coming.
I'd like to see an actual thing in front of us so we can actually work on something instead of just talk. And so this is good, I like it. I'm kind of rambling a bit, but it is frustrating also being up here to hear all this and move forward and any of that. So thank you. Member Meucci.
Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Um, yeah, I won't be voting for it in this version. Like I said on the last go-round, I think it leaves the door open for future data centers if they're on the grid. And I think if we're going to take a moratorium, we're going to take a real moratorium and kind of stop any kind of additional building permits for any kind of data center, either standalone or on its— or on the, on the the power grid. So I'm going to move to amend the ordinance to make its provisions applicable to all data center development, regardless of whether they utilize closed-loop cooling systems or operate on or off the PMPL electrical grid, and to direct staff to make all necessary changes to the ordinance for inclusion in the meeting packet and public hearing to be scheduled as the city attorney and borough staff tell us what a proper format would be for that.
Thank you.
Clerk, did you catch part of that? Yes, I did. So, the borough attorney recommended that if, if Member Meucci's motion passes, that at the 3rd reading of this ordinance, we can also hold another public hearing. So you could have the public hearing and a 3rd reading, so the public would have a chance to see the amended ordinance. But then we would be— we'd have to vote on that 3rd reading.
We wouldn't have a—. That would be right. It would be at this potentially at the same meeting, the the next meeting after this one, right? Is there a second to Member Meucci's amendment for discussion? Second.
Okay, and second by Member Valentine. Other discussion from assembly members? And Mr. Mayor, can I follow up on that? You may. Yeah, um, you know, I'm doing— I'm putting this forward again because I think, like somebody mentioned earlier, I listened into that that SEPA board meeting thing, and I've been paying attention to the one there at Ocean Beauty, and I, I'm just nervous about the whole thing getting bigger than we originally thought it was going to be.
You know, I've been on record as supporting that, that small data center there at Ocean Beauty, but I'm afraid that by having a moratorium with leaving a door open, it, it kind of leaves us exposed, and I'm trying to figure out what the harm is. I share the, I guess, Steve Harbour's concerns about, but I haven't heard anybody explicitly explain to me that, yeah, the reason we're pushing so hard for this standalone moratorium is because somebody's moving generators into the Ocean Beauty facility. And if that's the case, then that's fine, but, you know, I think it's the Assembly's responsibility to pass good policy, not to do policy based on a looming threat that is out there. I think we need to do what's right at the Assembly level and not worry about what other people are thinking about if we're doing something that is maybe not the most efficient to business, but You know, it was brought up several times that we haven't had a community meeting about it. We haven't heard from the community.
We are just saying, okay, well, we're going to do this moratorium and the 7 of us are going to say that it's okay to have a data center on the electrical grid. And I don't get that from the people I've been talking to, and I think we're missing that important part of that. So that's why I'm still, you know, pushing this amendment. Thank you. Okay, thank you.
Other members? Member Newman.
So if this amendment— and he is proposing an amendment, correct? Yeah, then seconded. So if this amendment passes, then there will, at the third reading, there would be another public hearing, and then would only require the third reading, but it would really delay the entire process. Yeah, whatever passes after, after that public, it'll be the third reading. So if, if we pass his and it carries through, then the third reading it would be a moratorium on all data centers.
Yes. Am I correct on that? Yes, that is correct. I'm just asking the question for clarification. Yeah, procedural question.
Yes, thank you. Member Marsh. And that was similar to my question, is that this really— pardon me. Will not delay a moratorium per se if we approve this amendment, because at that third reading we'll take a vote on the amended— if it passes on the amended version. That's correct.
Member Stan Gregor, I'll go first. Oh, okay. Member Valentine, thank you. I'll be voting yes on this because this is kind of exactly what I was trying to get out there, where if we go and we have this 9-month period where we do the study of like, what is 2, what is 4, what is 5, what is 7, what does whatever feel like? If it comes back after saying 2 will be more beneficial than not beneficial, then we know we've done it.
We've done the research. We did 9 months worth of research, as says 2, which was originally presented to us. That says, okay, good. Then we've done that timeframe to be able to do so. And so I like it.
It gives us time, and I will be voting yes. Thank you. Member Stan Gregor. Yeah, just briefly, I said this before.
In terms of good policy, you know, our SEPA members are saying they do not feel threatened or that this moratorium is needed for on-grid stuff. I'd like to thank Director Harbour and Board Chair of SEPA, Lynn, for looking out for the communities of Petersburg, Wrangell, and Ketchikan. And I think the amendment is a solution in search of a problem. I won't be supporting it. I understand why members do, but I, I don't think it's a necessary thing given the protections we already have in place.
My biggest concern was insulating ourselves from off-grid threats to our community, but I will of course follow the will of the Assembly. Thanks.
Member Martin.
Yeah, this is— this has gotten tougher and tougher as time goes on. I'm becoming more open to the full moratorium, but I still think the biggest open door here, as Member Meucci referenced, is diesel generation and diesel bridging. And I am concerned that this amendment— well, it may be possible to approve it, on schedule. It is pretty big change to the motion, and, uh, I don't know if that gives more legal grounds for some kind of illegal harassment, uh, but I have noticed public sentiment is heading in the direction of a full moratorium, so I think I'm going to vote for the amendment.
Anybody else? Any other assembly member? Okay, Member Newman. Yeah, I would like to agree with Assemblymember Meucci that, you know, I, I think that we need to come up with an ordinance that captures the issue in its full scope. Of the issue, because if we don't, there's always the concept of the hydraulic principle and unforeseen consequences.
So I feel like, yeah, we need to put policy before, before action and, and fully consider every possible, um, you know, realization of how this could play out before we start making decisions.
But yeah, Member Marsh, thank you. Um, I will be supporting this amendment, um, because it does seem the original amendment or original motion has a clause for new data centers. And if it's argued that the presentation as it was back in the spring from Mozilla Alaska is, is classified as an existing data center, wherever it is in its process. Um, I think this kind of closes the gap. Now, there's still going to be a ton of work to do in the time period until the moratorium expires.
We can't just put this to bed and say we're good, but we've got to examine every possible, um, scenario so that We can respect public testimony and public opinion. I don't think it's a matter of whether or not I support the data center, and as it was presented at 2 megawatts, I like— Member Valentine was like, that sounds like it's a doable thing, but public sentiment is, is other, is contrary to that. Thank you. Any other member? You know, I didn't know a lot about data centers and how they worked and everything else until we got into this, and I'd have to echo what Utility Director Harber said, is that I've learned a tremendous amount in there.
I don't know everything about these, and the more I, I took about 6 notes here tonight of other things we'd follow up on in discussions we've had about tariffs related to large loads. To give you an example of factors, I had never realized that any kind of a large load has to come back through our local utility. It can't go to SEPA, you know. And I'm—. And I can go on here for about the next 5 minutes on other things.
All these things have raised issues that need to be resolved, and I don't see putting a moratorium on a 2-meg center or so forth right now, really. So I'm gonna— I'm gonna vote against it, uh, but there's still a lot of work to be done, and it's not going to stop because I know that from both Ketchikan and Wrangell's perspective, they're, they're looking at large loads also, whether it be a JAG Center, whether it be the increase in the JAG Center that's in Ketchikan, whether it be dock electrification for new cruise ships in Ketchikan, etc. All of us are going to be looking for power, and all of us are going to be looking for looking to the future of what we can do. So I'm going to vote no, but I intend— I— we have a lot of work ahead of us no matter which way it goes. With that, would the clerk please call the roll?
Mayor Lynn? No. Member Marsh? Yes. Member Martin?
Yes. Vice Mayor Statton Gregor? Member Valentine? Yes. Member Newman?
Yes. Member Meucci? Yes.
Okay, that— the amended motion passes, um, as, as presented with a 5-2 vote, with Member Bob Lynn and Member Stephan Gregor, uh, opposing. And now back to the motion as amended, please. Would you please call roll? Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor. Yes.
Member Martin. Yes. Member Valentine. Yes. Member Newman.
Yes. Member Marsh. Um, yes. Member Meucci. Yes.
Mayor Lynn. Yes. And the amended motion passes 7 to 0. Moving on then from that, um, I'm going to move on to Resolution 2026-31, Resolution of the Petersburg Borough Assembly authorizing submission of a community development grant application. Oh, I— oh, you— excuse me, I did— I skipped one.
I'm getting ahead of myself tonight here, Mr. Mayor. That's good. I saw all along the long detail here, and I think I just skipped over it. And I'll move ordinance 2026-25, backing up an ordinance authorizing the issuance of electric utility revenue bonds of Petersburg Borough Electric Utility in an aggregate principal amount not to exceed $3,315,000 to finance: 1, improvement to the electric utility's Cow Bay standby generation project; and 2, pay incidental costs incurred in connection with carrying out such improvements, and to, to, to pay the costs incidental to financing the project, including providing for a debt service reserve if necessary, and paying the cost of issuance of the bond, all as authorized by Ordinance Number 2026-13 of the Petersburg Assembly and ratified by the borough voters at an election held therein on October 6, 2026, authorizing the pledge of net revenue of the electric utility to pay debt service on the bonds provided for the date, terms, and covenants of bonds, authorizing the sale of the bonds to the Alaska Municipal Bond Bank on the terms and conditions provided in this ordinance, and establishing an effective date And this is the first reading. If approved in 3 readings, Ordinance 2026-25 will authorize the issuance of up to $3,315,000 in electric utility revenue bonds to finance improvements to the Skow Bay Standby Generator Project and related financing costs.
Do I have a motion to approve Ordinance 2026-25? So moved. Second. Moved by Member Stant Gregor, seconded by Member Marsh. Discussion?
I might have, if the utility director would, uh, what, what does this do now when we— does this actually put our generator in place? I know we have it in hand.
So currently we're building the corn shell building around the generator. This will allow us to finish it, doing all the mechanicals, tying all the the coolant lines together, the— pull all the electrical lines, all the, the air to start it and run it, uh, and all the programming. So when we're done with this, we'll have an operational 3.5-megawatt generator.
Martin, yeah, I just wanted to thank Aaron Light for putting all that information up on the borough website. It's very thorough, a lot questions and answers and really good drawings, and I learned a lot. Hopefully you'll have some fresh pictures in the next week or two with walls.
Yeah. Do we have a timeline on this?
So, through the mayor, um, so substantial completion, which they tell me is— well, that's basically everything but your punch list, you know, your little items, is the end of December. So 2026. Yeah. And then, uh, Phase B, I'll be getting the updated quote, so hopefully we're still falling where we need to be for that. Uh, and with the long lead times of a couple pieces of equipment, we're realistically looking mid-2027.
So it should be before next winter, which should be outstanding.
Any other questions? Would the clerk please call the roll on Ordinance 2026-25?
Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine? Yes. Member Newman?
Yes. Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? Yes. Member Marsh? Yes.
Member Meucci? Yes. Mayor Lynn? Yes. And the ordinance 2026-25 passes unanimously.
Now I can move on to where I was. Resolution 2026-31, a resolution of the Petersburg Borough Assembly authorizes submission of a Community Development Block Grant application. If approved, this resolution will authorize the borough to submit an application for up to $800,000 in Alaska Community Development Block Grant funding to support the schematic design of Petersburg Medical Center's proposed new long-term care facility. A memo from PMC, Phil Hofstetter, is attached to this agenda item. Do I have a motion to approve Resolution 2026-31?
I make a motion to approve Resolution 2026-31. Second. Okay, been moved by Member March, seconded by, by Member Martin. Uh, discussion?
Member Stanton Gregor. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll definitely be voting yes on this for many, to me, obvious reasons. I'm glad you're applying for this block grant, Phil.
A new long-term— a new long-term care facility would be great for the community, and let alone just an updated one. As we have an aging population, I hope this grant is acquired because it's going to be very needed in the future. So I'm definitely voting yes.
Any other member? Okay, would the clerk please call the roll?
Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor. Yes. Member Martin.
Member Valentine. Yes. Member Newman. Yes. Member Marsh.
Member Meucci. Yes. Mayor Lynn. Yes. And the approval of Resolution 2026-31 passes unanimously.
Moving on, authorization for the period— for the borough manager to execute a professional services agreement with SafeBuilt LLC for building official program support. The Community and Economic Development Department requests authorization for the borough manager to execute a professional services agreement with SafeBuilt LLC to provide supplemental building inspection and plan review services while the borough's new building official employee completes training and obtains the necessary certifications. Additional information regarding the agreement is provided in the attached memorandum from the Community and Economic Development Director, and there is a suggested motion, uh, under this item. Oh, if somebody would like to make that motion. I move to authorize the borough manager to execute a professional service agreement with SafeBuilt LLC for building inspection, for building inspection and plan review services at the hourly rates established in Exhibit B for a term of 12 months.
Is there a second?
Been moved by Member Valentine, seconded by Member Newton. Discussion?
Member Marsh. So essentially where we are now, we don't— we're not able to issue building permits, so this would allow that process to continue. I wonder if through the mayor—. That is correct.
Yeah, but it's exciting that we have a potential somebody who's going to get certified and trained. That's great.
Okay, um, Member Meucci. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. So what's the mechanics of getting a building inspector? Does the city manager get a hold of, or somebody get Trinity Development, get a hold of this person, this company, and tell them we need this to be looked at? How, what's the mechanics there?
To the manager, um, through the mayor. Yeah, it's a lot of electronic stuff these days, a lot of pictures on iPhones and pictures of plans electronically sent, and they have people on call that they can pull upon that are certified in Alaska building requirements and rules. And basically, if they have to make a visit, there's room in the contract for that, for them to do that, although most of this is going to be done literally through electronic means. Great, thank you, Steve. Thank you.
Any other questions? Would the clerk please call the roll?
Member Marsh. Yes. Mayor Lynn? Yes. Member Newman?
Yes. Member Valentine? Yes. Member Meucci? Yes.
Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? Yes. Member Martin? Yes.
Approval of the authorization for the manager to execute a professional service agreement with Safe Bill LLC passes unanimously. I'm going to move on to the next item here. Papke's Landing snow removal and street sanding services request for proposals. The assembly will consider directing the Public Works Director to solicit proposals for on-call snow removal and street sanding service for approximately 2.2 miles of private road in the Papke's Landing area south of Petersburg. The proposed services would provide winter maintenance as needed, with a total contract amount not to exceed $15,000.
A draft request for proposal and map identifying those roads to be serviced are attached for the assembly review, and there is a suggested motion below if somebody would like to make that motion.
I'll do it. I move to direct the Public Works Director to solicit proposals for on-call snow removal and street sanding services for approximately 2.2 miles of private roads in Papke's Landing area, with a— with the total contract amount not to exceed $15,000, uh, as outlined in the draft request for proposals in the draft. Sorry, been moved by Member Valentine, seconded by Member Newman. Before we get into, um, I could re— I, I would benefit from this, so if the assembly would like me to recuse myself, I will on, on this.
And you don't get a financial benefit from it? I get no financial benefit other than maybe some snowplowed. I don't have a problem. Do we have to vote? We have to make a motion to, uh, tell him to recuse himself, to tell him to recuse himself.
But if we say, hey, you're good, we don't need to vote that. Yeah, Clerk Regula, do I have that in order? Um, it wouldn't hurt to have the assembly vote officially to allow or disallow the mayor from voting on the topic. I would move to allow the mayor to vote on this topic. Second.
That work? Cool. Thanks, Becky.
Okay, with that, any discussion? Well, other than, you know, I'm at the end of one of those roads and that's all there is. I get snowplowed. So, so do we need to take the vote on that first? Yes, we do.
If clerk would please pull— take the vote. Um, this is voting on whether the mayor should vote on this topic. Correct. Correct. Okay.
Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? Yes. Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine?
Yes. Member Newman? Yes. Member Marsh? Yes.
Member Meucci? Yep. Okay, thank you. Now for the discussion. Member Valentine?
Um, question on this. Um, when we put taxes on the people that live out in Papke's outside of Service Area 1, Is this something that the community votes on and then it is added to them? Like, if we had— if we were to add the tax of snow removal to them, how long would that take? Can you specifically do that?
Like that one little thing? No, there is a mechanism put in the charter that allows for making the change you're talking about, and that's basically forming a service area. So we'd have to create a new service area with new—. The assembly cannot really do that. That has to be done by the people who live out there.
Has to be, yes. This is a— has a unique setup to it, is because during borough formation, um, it was agreed upon, the borough, if that at the time would have been the city, agreed to plow these roads as part of the borough formation. Um, and then several years ago we stopped doing that, and it came back up. Um, it was— Member Valentine brought it up, um, to re-look at that again, and we've had a lot of folks that live out there want it plowed. So that's what the chain of events— so to do the things, you know, if you, if you want to go down the route of having, you know, a service area formed or doing it under the powers of the assembly, that's your call.
If you also might address what we, we did increase the mill rate, uh, off outside of Service Area 1, but not for this, this year. We, I think it was 1.7 mills 1.71. Um, and that's confusing for the folks who live out there. So suddenly they get a tax bill that they have not gotten previously from the borough, and so they assume that was from— for plowing. That's nothing to do with plowing.
It had to do with other services like dispatch, for example, that had not been charged and could have been from the time of borough formation. But the mayor's correct. Those tax bills were not done for this purpose of doing road maintenance. It was basically for other services provided by the borough. Let me add to what the manager said.
When we looked at the charter— and I'll let the finance director jump in here— the charter allows us to charge for certain services. That are outside Service Area 1. The— I think the finance director did an outstanding job of trying to separate what can and what can't be and what was reasonable at this point in time, and that's why— how she came up with that. That did not include the snow plowing, and there's several other mechanisms they could do. They could also create their own road maintenance agreement.
I can't remember the exact terms, but they could do that if they wanted to. But remember, Valentine, I think you have—. Yeah, just purely for discussion's sake.
If—. Okay, so the people that live out in Papke's, they're the ones that have to make the initiative to do exactly what you just said, what is to create a, hey, gathering together, pooling our money, and this is what's going to pay for our snowplowing, right? That's what you just said. Okay. And then, um, I mean, it would probably be quite the headache to own those roads, right?
They would all have to relieve that to us. Is that—. Am I— I'm not sure how we would do that. Okay. Yeah, fair enough.
Fair enough. To be fair, we've never done that here in my tenure where we've taken a private road road and turned it into a borough road. I don't think we've ever done that. Um, King's Row, Jody, was that one?
I can't remember. That may be the one exception, is I think there was some movement around King's Row to make that a borough road, but I'd have to go research that. They did do, right? Member Stan Gregor. Yeah, thanks, Mr. Mayor.
I'll try to be brief. I'll be voting no for a couple of reasons. None of it has to do with $15,000. That is very— the small dollar amount. So it's more about the process.
I've cited this past assembly member several times, but former member Nancy Strand oftentimes harped on the idea of Service areas. Now that was written to the charter for certain services to go through the process to get them.
I don't think this is baked into there, but I wouldn't want to see our Public Works going out there and plowing right now, like especially last winter. I know this doesn't say that in there, but I understand— let me back up— I understand the Police Department going out for public safety related things. There's a human factor to that regardless of what the charter says there. I appreciate them, but I can't let people die. That is not a discretionary thing.
That's human factor, and I would— I want that to keep going. But in terms of snowplowing, I think this has to be a catalyst for starting service area discussions. Community member Kerr spoke to several things, one of them being, you know, service area one subsidizing that. I think that's a valid point. Those are— and there are private roads.
The state does plow the road down to Papke's. I know it doesn't address the private roads, but I don't think it's consistent with what the charter says. I would humbly disagree with the community member's comments about voting for this could be recallable. I don't think about all that, but that's neither here nor there. I'm largely joking.
I'm against it because I don't think it's a good precedent, and I would like to take this opportunity to focus on forming service areas so we can have clear definitions of what services will be provided and what costs there will be. This seems a little arbitrary, I guess, is my point. Thank you.
Yeah, ultimately, I think you have to draw the line somewhere, and the line— the most solid line I can see is back with the ordinance. So I'll be voting no. Member Meucci. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, you know, it brings up a good conversation.
No audio detected at 1:31:00
Jim Kerr's been talking about this in different varieties over the last couple months, and some of that stuff I, you know, I agree with. Uh, you know, I took a road— a drive down those roads down there about 2 weeks ago, and I am pretty darn sure that the ambulance isn't going to be able to get through some of those roads. There are some pretty big potholes. And, uh, but the part that concerns me is that let's say you have an ambulance call out there. I'm just assuming by listening to the conversation and that our pickup point for somebody would be the state highway out there unless we're going to send the police department out there.
I'm just trying to figure out the mechanics of all this. And I guess I'm going to ask Steve the question. So if we vote to do this $15,000 for snowplow removal out there, are we putting ourselves in legal jeopardy?
Um, I'll get around to answering your question, but through the mayor, first part is just to be clear. So we're not supposed to provide police or ambulance service out there either. Those are, as Assemblymember Stenton Gregor said, we've done that forever because these folks are our neighbors and we don't want to hear somebody said, my husband's dying of a heart attack and we say, well, we don't go out there. That's— I suppose legally we could do that. Um, we don't operate that way, and if the assembly orders us to, we would change directions.
But we, we provide police service today at times. If the, if the trooper tells us they're, they're out of pocket and can't get here, um, and need— somebody needs emergency assistance, we will go out there. And the same with ambulance service. We will, we will go out there and we'll, we'll get through the potholes and we'll go to person's house and pick them up and find a way to get them in, into town to the hospital. The question of is it illegal, I, I, Police Chief's probably better at knowing what's legal and illegal than I am.
Um, it'd be a question we'd have to ask our borough attorney. Is to say, what's the, what's the rules on this? I, I believe we've asked her about this specific issue on the snow removal, and she said if the assembly votes to do it, we can do it. That does not mean there aren't repercussions, but, um, she was very open, it sounds like, um, with a couple of assembly members that spoke to her that said, yeah, you guys, if you want to do it, you can. That does not mean you you're immune from a lawsuit though.
That just means that the assembly could do— could vote and say yes, do it.
I guess I'd also add, in the, in the, in the document that went to the Boundary Commission, there is a page in there that shows all the calls that have been made for the last 10 years prior to that for emergency services outside of town. It was, it was an argument for borough formation too, and I'm not arguing for or against it, but it is in there and said it was given then. It's been given for almost 20 years, you know, that we've provided that service. Member Valentine. Thank you.
I brought this up because people on Papke's asked me about it, and it's— this is like, this is one of those hard ones where it's frustrating because It's something that used to happen, right? Things in the past. And then you hear a lot of that in Petersburg. Well, it used to be like this. It used to be like that.
I'm in the travel industry. And so a lot of people are coming from Kupreanof and Papkis of what used to travel used to be like, but it's not the reality of today. And it stinks because I want to be a good neighbor and say yes. Right. But then I think about this.
And where does the line get drawn if one of those roads were to extend another 1,000 feet because more people wanted to buy and extend? Are those people all of a sudden now prioritized in the snow plowing as well, even though they're the ones that own the road? It, it's— there's an internal struggle of, I just want to help my, my neighbors. And, okay, I could see where this can be a bit much, and maybe what, uh, Member Scott Newman Gregor was saying, create another service area, and we can really nick all these. Now, that will take a lot of time, um, but anyways, this is just what's going through my head currently.
Thank you.
Member Meucci. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I agree with James. And I think, you know, if we don't pass this, I think we need to have a real good conversation or let those folks know out at PAPGS that they need to come to the table here and try and help us figure out how we can get them the services that they'd like. And they might not like everything that's part of it, but yeah, I agree.
I get the exposure here. And I probably won't be voting to support this. Thank you. Thank you. I also will not be supporting this.
The charter language, I haven't found it written out, but I trust as it was presented by Mr. Kerr, it was accurate. So because the language specifically says not that the roads won't be plowed out there, I think we need to stick to that. I also agree with other assembly members who have said that this might be the impetus to, um, get a conversation going.
Any other assembly members?
Would the clerk please call the roll?
Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? No. Member Martin? No. Member Valentine?
No. Member Newman? No. Member Marsh? Member Meucci?
No. Mayor Lynn? No. And that, the, to plow the Papke's Road, fails 7 to 0. Moving on, appointment to the Southeast Alaska Power Agency Board of Directors for 2027 of one voting member and one alternate member for calendar year 2027.
The Petersburg Pittsburgh is entitled to 1 voting member seat, 1 alternate seat on the SEPA Board of Directors. Letters of interest have been submitted from, from the mayor and Stephan Harbour, and without objection, I would point myself as the voting member and Stephan Harbour as the alternate, my alternate. Let me make a motion to direct Public Works Director to solicit— I'm sorry, let me get the right one. Um, sorry. Thank you.
Appointment to the Southeast Alaska Power Agency Board of Directors for 2027 of one voting member, Mayor Lynn, and one alternate member, Director Stephan Harbour. I would second that.
Motion.
Please call the roll. Mr. Mayor, can I just ask a question? Sure. Hey, I had some questions. There later on about the SEPA board members, and maybe we can just— well, we're here, maybe we can just— maybe you can help me understand how this all works.
So as a SEPA board member, is a SEPA board member representing the communities or the organization, the SEPA organization? Mr. Mayor, if I may? Okay, we have a point of order here. Oh, go ahead. Member Stanton Gregor, it appears that we are voting solely on the appointment of 2 people to the board, not the inner workings of SEPA.
So it strikes me as out of order. If you'd like to suspend the rules, of course, since you're the chair, and pursue that thread now, you may, of course. Or we can wait for it in discussion. That's fine with me, Mr. Mayor. I just didn't— trying to keep the meeting moving along.
Okay, I'm gonna— I'll continue. I'll take Member Stan Gregor's advice. And, uh, there is a motion on the table. If the clerk would please call the roll. Member Marsh?
Yes. Member Meucci? Yes. Mayor Lynn? Yes.
Vice Mayor Scott Newman? Yes. Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine?
Yes. Member Newman? Yes. That passes unanimously. Moving on to Item F, rescheduling of the December 2nd 2026 Municipal Land Entitlement Work Session.
At the November 2nd, 2026 meeting, the Assembly scheduled a land management work session for December 2nd, 2026. Due to a scheduling conflict, the mayor is requesting that the work session is rescheduled. The Assembly is asked to, to select a date from one of the following options: Wednesday, January 13th, Thursday, January 14th, Wednesday, January 20th or Friday, January 22nd. Is there a preference?
Or would somebody like to make a motion with a suggested date? Might be a good idea. I would propose to schedule— reschedule the December 2nd, 2026 Municipal Land Entitlement work session to Thursday, January 14th, 2027. Second. Moved and seconded.
Does that— I will ask for discussion here, but does that work for everybody? January 14th. I'll just chime in. It may or may not for me, but, uh, yeah, I don't know, but I can't attend. I will.
I'm a little unsure, but I will go with that anyways. Going up. March, would you like to propose a time? Yes, thank you. Uh, noon?
No, um, didn't we have a 9 AM? Start. Thank you. 9 AM. Thank you.
Okay, propose 9 AM January 14th. I can make it now. All right, with that, would the clerk please call the roll on the motion for the meeting on January 14th at 9:00 AM? Vice Mayor Sten Gregor? Yes.
Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine? Yes. Member Newman?
Yes. Member Marsh? Member Meucci? Yes. Mayor Lynn?
Yes. And that, uh, the meeting is now rescheduled for January 14th at 9:00 AM. Moving on, their consideration of calling a special assembly meeting on November 30th, 2026. Staff recommends calling a special assembly meeting on November 30th, 2026 to allow for the second reading of the bond authorization Ordinance 2026-25. The third reading and potential final adoption would take place at the rescheduled December 14, 2026 regular assembly meeting.
The special meeting will follow the borough's regular assembly meeting format and maintain the customary 2-week interval between meetings. Um, and there is a suggested motion below that if somebody would like to make that or an alternative.
I move to request the mayor call a special assembly meeting on November— for November 30th, 2026, pursuant to Petersburg Borough Code Section 3.08110, to consider the second reading of the bond authorization ordinance and other borough business identified in the special meeting agenda.
I've been moved by Member Stan Gregor, seconded by Member Newman. Member Valentine. If we have— thank you. If we have another meeting November 30th, does that like an open public one like this, or is it just to move this? It's just like— go ahead, please.
Yes, thank you, Member Valentine. This is to— it's a regular assembly meeting. The agenda will be basically the same as a regular assembly meeting, so we'll conduct other business which will be indicated on my public notice for that meeting. So include the second reading of that bond ordinance and a public hearing as well for the bond ordinance. Right, then would we also would have one for December 7th?
No, actually December 7th, that meeting had been moved to the 14th because the clerks will be gone to a conference in Anchorage. So December 14th. OK, so we're kind of still on Reg, we're not. Okay. Yeah.
Yes. Yes. Okay. Member Stephan Harbour. Um, in theory, that's scheduled for a noon meeting.
Correct. And that's up to the assembly. I would be, uh, I know for myself, uh, I'd be much more likely to make the meeting that particular day if anyone had interest in the evening meeting. I'm okay either way. Just, uh, people are interested in 6 PM.
I know I could be there. I'm cool either way. I want to hear from you guys. Marshall. Member Marsh, are you—.
6 PM works. Would that also be that the December 14th meeting is noon or 6? That would be at noon.
Okay. Um, yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I'm fine with this 6 o'clock meeting. That's great. Thank you.
Okay.
Uh, Member Martin. Would the 3rd reading of the moratorium happen at this special meeting? Uh, yes, that, that is correct, and a public hearing for that as well. I just, I hope you run it by our council that, uh, these slightly irregular happenings regarding the moratorium with that substantial amendment, now a special meeting, uh, make sure that's all going to work. And I'm be happy to extend it a very short time if it would make it more solid, less open to challenge, I guess.
Yeah, the Assembly certainly could schedule that 3rd reading of the moratorium ordinance to December 14th.
Not on that right now though, right? Correct. Picking the date for the meeting, we're not on that right now. Uh, yeah, we'll come back to this. Nice morning.
Thank you.
6 PM work for folks? Yeah, yeah, good. All right, okay, the clerk, please call the roll on changing the meeting to 6 PM on December 14th. Oh yeah, not December. Yeah, this is November 30th, 6 PM.
Okay. Jeigh Stanton Gregor. Yes. Member Marsh. Yes.
Member Martin. Yes. Member Jeigh Stanton Gregor. Yes. Member Valentine.
Yes. Mayor Lynn. Yes. Member Newman. Yes.
Okay, that passes 6 to 0. And now moving on, consideration of canceling the December 21st, 2026 regular assembly meeting in conjunction with proposed November 30th special assembly meeting and the rescheduled December 14th regular meeting, staff recommends canceling the December 21st, 2026 regular meeting. This will avoid holding two regular meetings one week apart and maintain approximately two-week intervals between assembly meetings. So moved. Second.
Okay, it's been moved and seconded. Any discussion on canceling a meeting?
I don't hear any discussion, so would the clerk please call the roll?
Member Martin? Yes. Member Valentine? Yes. Member Newman?
Yes. Member Marsh? Member Meucci? Yes. Mayor Lynn?
Yes. Vice Mayor Stanton Gregor? Yes. Okay, before we move on, I have a question. That December 21st regular assembly meeting is canceled by that— since we're in the communications, um, the communication received are in our are part of the packet.
And I'll move on then to assembly discussion items. Under that, we have the first item was Southeast Alaska Power Agency Board recommendations. This item was just requested by Member Mushey to discuss the process for selecting representatives to Southeast Board seats, the term of office, and the qualifications and roles of the board members. So the SEPA Bylaws related to selecting board members are attached to this agenda item. Member Meucci.
Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I was just curious, you know, listening in on some of these meetings, so the SEPA board members, they are charged with overseeing the SEPA project. So are the representatives that are picked by the communities, are they Is there focus on the SEPA organization, or are they bringing the local knowledge that they have from being the mayor or the electrical superintendent to that board to help them with decisions? I'll address that, I guess, a couple different ways. In the other two communities, the mayor selects who is on the SEPA board.
In Petersburg, we've always done it through the assembly.
Um, the— in the other communities, the— particularly, uh, the utility director in some cases has been on, in other cases not. It's sometimes it's been, um, the mayor and assembly members, and most of the time it's been the mayor and, uh, and either an assembly member and/or the utility director. Right now, it's the— generally is the mayor. Well, the mayor and the utility director in each of the other two communities is on the— are on the board. Sometimes they're there as alternates, and then sometimes, depending on how that fifth seat revolves, sometimes as a voting member.
Okay, great. And so if there is a decision being made by SEPA that affects the community, does that go back? Do the representatives go back to the communities to kind of gauge how the communities are feeling or the assembly is feeling, or how does that relationship work? Can I say something, Mr. Mayor? You may.
Yeah. So it's a dance because our, as a board member, your fiduciary responsibility is to that board. You're there for SEPA's well-being. But you're going to use your influence and, and your knowledge of, of your community to help make good decisions for all the communities. Is that a proper way of saying it, Mr. Mayor?
Yes, um, each of us have a little bit different systems, either with, with generation, with power, with transmission, and so forth. And so I will come back— having utility director on there to help guide, you know, what can and can't be done within some reality is extremely important in my mind. One, and then I would also go back that the role, sometimes the role that you're serving in there, you're serving three communities, not just Petersburg. And sometimes some of those issues are not in our best interest, but then you're looking at it from the standpoint that You'll vote to see what represents what brings all three SEPA forward in terms of being able to provide stability and power to all three communities. And that's the way it's always operated.
So sometimes your role is exactly the same, sometimes, but you're representing three communities when you're sitting on that board. Great, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I appreciate the clarification. Okay, now I'll move on unless somebody else has questions. I'll move on here to the housing status update and proposed January work session.
And this discussion item was also requested by Member Meucci. Discussion regarding the current status of borough housing initiatives and projects, including a proposed borough assembly work session in January 2027. Identify potential topics for the work session and suggested areas of focus. And I'll turn that back to you, Member Meucci. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor.
You know, we've had conversations on and off over the last couple months about whether or not we needed to sit down and talk about housing statuses in Petersburg, and I know there's been at least one member who's interested, and I was just curious if there was any interest in putting a work session together for some time in January, um, to talk about housing and, you know, come up with a list of potential topics to talk about at the work session.
Member Valentine. Um, not that I'm against this, uh, Member Meucci, I just have a quick question to, uh, Clerk Regula or the manager. Um, didn't we already have a couple other meetings in January as well? We just moved one to the 14th, a work session. Didn't we move another one in January as well, or did we move that to like February?
Uh, in January on the 6th, there's the fire props, um, work session. So we have 2 work sessions scheduled for January 8th, so, uh, thus far, plus 2 meetings. Plus 2 meetings. Are you opposed to, uh, a member— Meucci, is there any reason why it has to be January? Nope.
Okay, so, okay, and there's no voting thing anyways right now, so probably not January for me. But I would like to have this discussion. Yes. Yep.
Member Martin. Yeah, I'm still in support of a task force. I mean, we don't, we don't have to do this ourselves as the Assembly. We could, we can spin this off to another group. There was a lot of energy in that room a year ago or 10 months ago, and I think a lot of people there would be happy to take it from here and generate ideas.
So, uh, and bring them to us so we could, uh, sort of work it into our normal schedule. So I still support a task force.
I guess I have a question then for the manager. Is it—. If you had a—. If you had a group, or if we had a follow-up on that, that's going to require considerable work from staff. Do we have staff that has the time available to do this?
Um, to answer your question, I'm not sure. We also have the issue of this whole Title 19 and related to subdivision ordinances and platting authority that we've got to get started on. That's something the assembly talked about as well. So I'm not exactly sure. I mean, Liz is on vacation right now, and clearly this falls in her realm.
Donna could be a big help of this, but she's just learning. So I think having a housing group to do stuff in theory makes some sense, would take some work off of— but you're going to have to have staff there to take notes and kind of keep everybody heading in the right direction. And I, I can't answer that right now. I mean, a member—. Stan Gregor.
Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just briefly, so that's something that we could Since we're not doing this in January anyway, you could follow up with us, like, as we move along in December, early January, in terms of availability options, etc. Meaning we don't, uh, hammer that out. Could it be helpful if, you know, sounds like there's a couple of assembly members, including, um, Assemblymember Meucci, that have some ideas? It would be helpful to put those down in writing that I could then run by a few people and say, would you be interested in talking to me?
Because that's, that's part of the challenge too, is getting people interested that have—. No, there's multiple things in place as well. We're talking about doing a task force. That's obviously an action item down the line, and that's not just a work session, that's an action-based thing. But anyway, that answers my question, John.
Thank you. We were going to do that, then I would also suggest that they send what they really want that task force to do. I think that's critically important. I think we made a mistake the last time with our task force. We didn't We didn't narrow it in.
We left it open, and we didn't— in my opinion, we didn't collect— we didn't accomplish what we really, really should be doing.
Anything else on this, Member Meucci? No, thank you, Mr. Mayor.
Okay, Southeast Alaska Shellfish— I'll get it— yeah, right, yeah, and Otter Initiative discussion again. Was that requested by Member Meucci? Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Hey, I saw this on some social platform, and I know we're all pretty familiar with the shellfish and the otters in Southeast, and it sounds like Grangell's taking the lead here on putting together a discussion panel. And there's this site here that I've listed, and I think there was a picture in the packet.
If you want to sign up for it to be included on the distribution list, I think it'd be worthwhile. I'm planning to attend via teleconference just to kind of hear what the issues are, but I think we've talked about it a lot, and I think this is going to be an opportunity for us to weigh in on how Petersburg feels about it. So I just thought I'd throw it out there for you. Thank you.
I talked with the mayor and the manager in Rangel a week ago or a couple weeks ago, and they wanted financial help. And I asked them to put together what, what this group was to accomplish and to send what they were asking for to me. And I mentioned it at the last meeting, but I haven't received anything yet to see, to see exactly where they're going or what they intended. And I would still dearly like to see you know, where they see this ending up. And I, and I did, I asked the manager again in Wrangle, you know, for the details, and so far I have not received them.
Okay, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Moving on then, long-term planning for Petersburg Fire Department Emergency Services. This item was requested by Bob Lynn, and the reason I put this on there is that one of the things we've talked about since a number of us have been on the assembly for a long period of time is— and we talked a little bit earlier about service areas and other things— but I think it's time when we have the session on with the fire department and looking— excuse me— what we might want to do in the future, you know, what I think there needs to be added to that, a discussion related to what we want for, you know, services on this island. Do we want other, other, you know, housing, other caches for, for emergency services?
Do we want to— originally when the borough was formed, there was a proposal to put a fire station at Papke's. That's fallen, you know, and I'm not arguing for or against, but I think it's time we retake a look at this as part of that, our next next session. And I've talked to Aaron about this a number of times, and he's in agreement that we, that we need to look, look to the future a little bit. Not saying we're going to buy it today, but you know, where do we want to go? What, what do we really want?
What's the, what's the assembly's pleasure? Anyhow, if it's okay, I would like that added as part of that next work session.
Assembly can change or add anything else they want to add to that if they would like. Member Martin. No, I think that's good. Interest is high right now, so that's good.
Okay, Assemblymember comments. Does any Assemblymember have comments to make? Member Martin. Yeah, I'm reminded, um, The holding area issue, uh, that was an important part of the wireless ordinance. You know, the everything outside service area one is still totally without any borough influence.
So I know we have a staffing load problem there, and that you're right to bring that up about the housing work session too. But we, we just got to go ahead and do something, and it's going to be the same with the data center moratorium or ordinance that we come up with. That's just wide open out there. That's where I'd be looking if I were an evil tech bro. So I really want to see us come up with a way to make that happen.
And yeah, as far as, um, fire department work session, there's been some grumbling that January is a long way off. I, I guess I'm somewhat reassured by not much would be happening in the winter anyway. So, um, but we really need to take that seriously, and I, I think we are. I just think it was perceived as a kick-it-down-the-road-a-long-way type of move. So thanks.
Member Meucci. Yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Hey, um, I, we heard earlier that the union negotiations had— or the union, um, had voted down the, the contract. What's— can somebody tell me what the next step is?
Or—. Um, this is Steve through the mayor. So the next step, we've in the process of notifying the union, um, that we will be implementing our last best final offer. Um, I believe it's the end of November, be effective the end of December. And so end of December.
And we're moving— we're going to be moving forward. That notice to the union will go out. Okay, Becky, take this over. I'm not going to fill in blank. Yes, well, we responded to the union letting us know that the vote on the contract failed, and we're still at impasse, but the borough will be implementing last best final.
And, um, and going from there.
Thank you, uh, Member Valentine. Uh, just real quick, I wanted to echo to, uh, what, uh, Member, uh, Martin was saying, um, that also if with like the whole service area talk, um, to also know that if mental health is going to actually do something too, now we have a whole nother district. Kind of area to deal with as well. So I'm not— I'm kind of in on that, you know, talking about like what makes moves here. Thank you.
I'll go back to something the manager said. We need to deal with Title 19 and taking platting in the field. That has to me, in my mind, that has to be one of our priorities for the future here, and that's going to take quite a bit of work to do this.
Any other comments from assembly members? Okay, I have a quick comment just to let the assembly know about scheduling for that 3rd reading of the moratorium ordinance. And then the mayor can direct me to do whichever option, but one option would be to put it on the special meeting dated November 30th, but I would just need to know ahead of time. To put it at the next meeting in December. We're only going to have one meeting in December, which would be the 14th at noon.
So that would be potentially the public hearing and third reading. So just wanted to let everyone know that, you know, direct the clerk to—. I don't see, I don't see any advantages of putting it off if the wording, if it can be put on the agenda. Myself. Okay.
Yeah, if we can move forward, please. Any recognition from assembly members? Yes, please. Okay. Member Stan Gregor.
I would like to recognize state champion swimmer Cyrus Hulebek, freshman in high school. Big accomplishment, accomplishment in getting a state title this year. I'm really happy for him, really proud of him. He's a great kid. And so nice work, Cyrus.
Keep after it, man. Okay, thank you. Member Martin. Yeah, I just want to recognize Irene Littleton for years directing the Marbles Plays. I enjoyed the last one, and I guess this was her final effort, and I really appreciate her over the years.
Any other recognition from assembly members? All right, do I have a motion to adjourn? Moved. Hey, second. Second.
All those in favor say aye. Aye. Meeting is adjourned.
Speakers in this transcript
Bob Lynn
Mayor · Petersburg Borough
Bob Martin
Assembly Member · Petersburg Borough Assembly
James Kerr
Chief of Police · Petersburg Police Department
James Valentine
Assembly Member · Petersburg Borough Assembly
Jeff Meucci
Assembly Member · Petersburg Borough Assembly
Jeigh Stanton Gregor
Assembly Member · Petersburg Borough Assembly
Joshua Adams
Phil Hofstetter
Petersburg Medical Center
Scott Newman
Assembly Member · Petersburg Borough Assembly
Stephan Harbour
Steve Giesbrecht
Borough Manager · Petersburg Borough