Skip to main content

Kenai Peninsula Borough: Planning Commission, 2026-11-16

Alaska News • • 83 min

Articles from this transcript

Kenai Peninsula Borough plans findings workshop after Anchor Point gravel pit ruling

Alaska Supreme Court upheld the Kenai Peninsula Borough's denial of a gravel pit near Anchor Point, ending an 8 year fight. Borough plans an early 2027 workshop on writing stronger findings.

Cover image for article: Kenai Peninsula Borough plans findings workshop after Anchor Point gravel pit ruling
0:02
Speaker A

Recording in progress.

3:22
Brantley

All right. Good evening. We'll call to order the Kenai Peninsula Borough Planning Commission for November 16th, 2022. June 16th, 2026. Roll call, please.

3:31
Brantley

Whitney. Present. Venuti.

3:36
Speaker C

Here. Slaughter. Here. Morgan. Here.

3:43
Speaker C

Fikes. Here. Epperheimer. Here. Gillum.

3:49
Brantley

Here. And Brantley. Here. A quorum is present. Okay, that brings us to our consent and regular agendas.

3:56
Speaker C

Could we please have the items on the consent agenda read into the record? On tonight's consent agenda, we do have an extension, uh, time extension request for Maddox Subdivision Corbin 2024 replat. There's also 12 plats being granted administrative approval and 4 plats being granted final approval. And we have the minutes from the October 26, 2026 Planning Commission meeting. And those are the items on tonight's consent agenda.

No audio detected at 4:00

4:26
Brantley

Thank you. Is there anyone wishing to comment on any items on the consent agenda?

4:34
Brantley

Okay, with that, I'll entertain a motion to approve the consent and regular agendas. I move to approve the consent and regular agendas. Ask for unanimous. Second. Okay, motion is made.

4:45
Brantley

Any objection to unanimous?

4:48
Brantley

Seeing none, motion passes. And I'll bring us to our new business. Before we do that, if we could please have the hearing procedures read into the record.

5:02
Speaker C

The hearing procedures for Planning Commission public hearings are as follows. Staff will present a report on the item. The chair will ask for the petitioner's presentation to be given by the Petitioner or their representative, they will have 5 minutes. Public testimony on the issue, 3 minutes per person. After testimony is completed, the Planning Commission may follow with questions.

5:24
Speaker C

A person may only testify once on an issue unless questioned by the Planning Commission. Staff may respond to any testimony given, and the Commission may ask staff questions. Rebuttal by the petitioner is allowed to rebut evidence or provide clarification. Clarification, but should not present new testimony or evidence. The chair closes the hearing and no further public comment will be heard.

5:47
Speaker C

The chair entertains a motion and the commission deliberates and makes a decision. All those wishing to testify must wait for recognition by the chair. Each person must begin by stating his or her name and mailing address for the record. All questions will be directed to the chair. Testimony must be kept to the subject at hand and shall not deal with personalities.

6:08
Speaker C

Decor must be maintained at all times, and all testifiers shall be treated with respect. If participating via Zoom, the testifier will need to use the Zoom raised hand feature or press *9 by phone to speak.

6:23
Brantley

Thank you.

6:26
Brantley

So that brings us to Item 1, which is a building setback encroachment permit, KPP File 2026. -106. Staff report, please.

6:42
Speaker G

Purpose as stated in the petition: the house was constructed within the building setback along Buena Vista Street. Buena Vista Street is a platted old lane street and is not developed or connected to any existing roadways. This easement starts and ends nowhere with no connecting points on either end. It has an HEA transformer at both the south and north ends. Existing access to the property is by Hammock Circle to the west, a driveway running northeast from Hammock Circle to which another driveway exists— exits from going east across two properties to get to the subject lot.

7:21
Speaker G

The property is also addressed from Hammock Circle. Hammock Circle connects to the south to Murriah Road, a 60-foot dedication maintained by the borough. Buena Vista Street, a 30-foot dedication or 30-foot half dedication located to the east side of the property, is not developed. The as-built submitted with the application shows a one-story wood-framed house located in the northeast corner of the property. Structure is sitting across the 20-foot building setback line as granted by Lynn Subdivision Willis Addition.

7:54
Speaker G

Number 2, HM-2008-76. The structure is, as shown, is sitting 13.1 feet across the setback at the south, at the south end of the structure and 10.3 feet at the north end of the structure. There are no site distance issues as the Buena Vista Street is not developed.

8:16
Speaker G

With Buena Vista Street not being developed, site distance issues and traffic are not a consideration along this portion portion of road. Buena Vista Street along this stretch of dedication does not connect to any other road dedication at this time. The house was constructed with the building setback along Buena Vista Street. Buena Vista Street is a platted-only street and not developed or connected to any existing roadways. The easement starts and ends nowhere with no connection points at either end.

8:45
Speaker G

It has an HVA transformer at both the south and north ends. The easement starts and ends nowhere with no connection points on either end. It has an HTA transformer. Building Setback Encroachment Permits. The following standards shall be considered for all Building Setback Encroachment Permit applications.

9:06
Speaker G

Staff recommends the Planning Commission select the findings they determine are applicable to the standards and vote on them. Findings 1 through 3. Appear to support Standards 1 and 2. Findings 1 through 3 and 6 appear to support Standard 3. Recommendation: Based on the standards to grant a building setback encroachment permit, staff recommends to grant approval for the portion of structure within the 20-foot building setback as shown on the 2026 as-built survey, subject to the 6 conditions listed.

9:39
Speaker G

End of staff report.

9:44
Brantley

Thank you. Is the applicant or petitioner here to speak on this?

9:53
Brantley

Okay. Anyone from the public wishing to speak on this?

10:00
Slaughter

Seeing none, we'll close public comment and bring it back to the Commission for a motion. I move to adopt Planning Commission Resolution 2026-01. -46, Granting a building setback encroachment permit to a portion of line 20-foot setback for Track D-2B, Lynn Subdivision, Willis Addition Number 2, plat HM-2008-76. Siting findings 1 through 3 in support of Standards 1 and 2, and findings 1 through 3 and 6 in support of Standard 3, also subject to the 6 conditions as set forth in the staff report. Second.

10:38
Brantley

Okay, we have a motion and a second. Is there any discussion?

10:43
Epperheimer

Through the Chair to staff. Sorry, can you hear me? I'm looking at the plat here that's in the packet, and I don't see a building, so it must be a relatively new building. Just for my information, is this something that was built recently? I didn't find that in the packet, or maybe I wasn't looking.

11:03
Epperheimer

As far as the building that, that we're talking about in the setback, do we know if this was a recent build or not? I'm just looking at the picture of the overhead of the, uh, plat— not plat, but overhead of the, uh, like the, the aerial map. It doesn't actually show the building, like it doesn't exist in that. So I'm thinking it must be a recent build. Yeah, it's got to be a recent building.

11:27
Speaker G

Uh, because it doesn't show— it shows up on, uh, page 14, like, on some of our aerial GIS, which is more recent, if you can find them.

11:41
Speaker G

But it's not on some of it's shown, so it's got to be a recent build. Okay, I, I just As a surveyor, I always suggest have your property surveyed. So they obviously didn't, so they just built it assuming— probably not without any boundary limits. That's all I can say. Okay, I appreciate that.

12:16
Epperheimer

I just— it just seems to be a Something that just keeps happening here on more recent builds, and I think we talked about this before, some sort of information. I'm not sure if people understand until after the fact, I think. They just build and— I think we talked about that in the previous meeting. Anyway, it was just my information, just seeing another recent build in the setback. I guess I did include an aerial photo Further down in—.

12:46
Speaker G

Yeah, I see it on page 13 now. Page 13, it does show it, and that would be one of the more recent. I believe these aerial photos are from 2026 in May.

13:07
Epperheimer

What was the question you just said? No, I, I see it in page 13. I appreciate I just— thank you.

13:25
Brantley

Okay, any other further discussion or comments?

13:33
Brantley

Okay, no further discussion. We can take a vote.

13:38
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Benuti?

13:44
Speaker C

Yes. Slaughter? Yes. Morgan?

13:51
Speaker C

Yes. Fikes? Yes. Epperheimer? Yes.

13:57
Speaker C

Gillum? Yes. And Brantley? Yes. Motion passes.

14:05
Brantley

Again, that brings us to Item 2, which is a utility easement vacation. KPP File 2026-092V1. Staff report, please.

14:17
Speaker G

Purpose is stated in the petition, to request the alternate and relocation of the easements associated with the Kiros Avenue right-of-way that has been approved with Tract B2 and B3 of Plat 2025-16.

14:31
Speaker G

Petafoggers Place Subdivision, Kiros Addition. The staff analysis— the utility reviews did not identify any utilities located in the easement proposed for vacation. Future utilities will be located in the proposed new utility located to the north with the Kiros Vacation and relocation to the north end of the new plat, north end of Lot 2B. Associated 10-foot utility easement will be added adjacent to the right-of-way as a standard per KBB code. The future plans for this property are to combine the lots to expand the campground facility.

15:09
Speaker G

With the road and utilities moved to the north end, development will be more convenient for the applicant. The right-of-way vacation of Key Roach Avenue was approved by the Planning Commission at the meeting of September 14th, 2026, and given consent by the KBB Assembly at the meeting of October 6th, 2026. This easement vacation can be finalized with the right-of-way vacation plan when submitted. Recommendation: Based on consideration of the merits as outlined by staff comments and staff findings, staff recommends approval of the utility easement alteration as petitioned, subject to the two conditions listed. End of staff report.

15:52
Brantley

Okay, thank you. Is the petitioner applicant here to speak on this?

16:01
Brantley

Seeing no hands raised— Yes, we are here, but we have nothing to add at the time. Okay, thank you. Is there anyone from the general public wishing to comment on this?

16:17
Brantley

All right. Seeing none, we'll close public comment and bring it back to the Commission for a motion.

16:24
Speaker K

Move to grant the vacation as recommended by staff and based on the means of evaluating public necessity established by KBB 20.65, adopting and incorporating by reference to staff report, staff recommendations, and subject to the two conditions as set forth in the staff report. I'll second.

16:45
Brantley

Okay, we have a motion, a second. Any discussion?

16:57
Brantley

Okay, hearing, seeing none, we can call the vote.

17:03
Speaker C

Whitney? Yes. Benuti?

17:08
Venuti

Yes. Slaughter? Yes. Morgan? Yes.

17:15
Morgan

Fikes? Yes. Epperheimer? Yes. Gillum?

17:20
Brantley

Yes. And Brantley? Yes. Motion passes. All right, that brings us to item 3, which is a right-of-way vacation, KPB file 2026-094V.

17:35
Brantley

Staff report, please.

17:39
Speaker G

The applicant has requested to remove the application from the meeting for further analysis of a road plan in the area. End of staff report.

17:49
Brantley

Okay. Is there anyone wishing to comment on this item?

17:59
Brantley

Okay. Monique, if you would just state your name. Your name and address for the record, please?

18:06
John Benavides

Oh, she went away. We do have Casey. I'm here. No, I'm, I'm sorry, using my wife's tablet. Uh, my name is John Benavides, and Monique and I own the, uh, lot, uh, 30, which borders Windchime Street.

18:28
Brantley

And, um, we, uh—. Do you have a mailing address for the record? That's what we want. I do. Yep, I sure do.

18:36
John Benavides

Uh, it's, uh, 1525 West New River Road, New River, Arizona, 85087.

18:52
John Benavides

OK, thank you. Go ahead and continue. OK, thank you. Like I was saying, that Monique, my wife, and I, we, we own Lot 30, which borders Windchime. And as a property owner in this neighborhood on this street, I'm respectfully asking the board to deny the request to vacate the easement and preserve the existing right-of-way.

19:18
John Benavides

The, uh, you know, I know that, uh, we did meet with Sean over the summer, and we did have our— Casey and I had our properties, uh, we had them surveyed, and our surveyor did find that one of the— that, uh, Sean was encroaching on Casey's property, and that one of the survey markers had been had been moved to make more room for, uh, for where he was encroaching on Casey's property. The surveyor found it. It was a wooden stake that had been moved. When the surveyor found it with his GPS locator, he said, this is in the wrong place. Then he pulled out his, uh, his metal detector and he, he searched around, and about 30 feet away he found the metal rebar, the capped metal rebar, the original one.

No audio detected at 19:40

20:10
John Benavides

And he dug around in the bushes and, and uncovered it. And then he put the stake back where it belonged. Later that same day, Casey and my other son Hunter and I, we all went and we visited Sean. It was an amicable visit. We made arrangements to meet him for the first time, and we pointed out the discrepancy over there.

20:31
John Benavides

He denied that he had moved the stake. And, and, you know, I told him I reminded him that it's a federal offense to move a survey marker. But, um, he did tell us at that point in time that he was going to do everything possible, uh, to stop Casey from, you know, coming up that easement to having access to his property. Um, Casey had— and I had gone down to the, uh, um, to the borough. We talked to the borough about, you know, easement access, and they said we would have easement, no problem.

21:06
John Benavides

We also went to the electric company and the electric company, we got a point of feed for his property and they said they would be coming up that same easement. There's a transformer that's just south of it and they drew on a paper saying, this is where we will bring, you know, services to your property. So granting this, this, uh, this vacation of this easement would, uh, create a hardship for Casey to bring electric to his property. Also, I'm on Windchime as well, and I don't agree with, with giving up, uh, any of the borough's property. It looks like those streets were put there to, uh, you know, by the borough for access to all the properties that are in that area, and I don't think we should be giving it up and setting a precedence for people just to take whatever they want going forward.

22:06
John Benavides

That's what I have to say about that, but I know other people want to talk too, so I appreciate you for listening to me. Thank you very much. Thank you. Anyone else wishing to comment on this?

22:19
Casey Benavides

Okay, go ahead. Just state your name and address, mailing address, for the record, please. Hello everyone, my name is Casey Benavides. My mailing address is 1525 West New River Road, New River, Arizona 85087. I just wanted to take a second, thank you guys for allowing me to speak today.

22:42
Casey Benavides

I, I am the owner of Government Lot 34, which is directly north of Sean Denny's property. And I'm here to formally oppose the request to vacate the portion of Windchime Street right away. The easement is, is meant to provide access to my property and other properties beyond mine. I'd like to address a few notes that have been listed in the petition. The public easement is not currently being used because I've recently acquired this property.

23:17
Casey Benavides

And the right-of-way cannot be cleared for use until a permit has been approved, of which I have already submitted an application through the Kenai Peninsula Borough.

23:29
Casey Benavides

My property also doesn't border suggested other alternative routes like Sam Street, for instance. Like my dad said prior, I— we have met with Homer Electric Association and They notified us of a point of feed to bring electricity to my property from Williams Road that will follow that same, uh, Windchime easement. Now, my primary concern is that vacating this easement could negatively impact my property rights, including limiting access to my land and potentially compromise its future use in development. I have the same right as any other property owner to preserve the ability to access, use, improve, and develop my property. This easement provides an important access connection, and removing it creates a hardship that may be difficult, costly, or even impossible to correct later.

24:33
Casey Benavides

I understand that the applicant may have reasons for wanting to one in wanting the easement to be vacated. However, I believe the interest and rights of all the affected property owners must be considered, not just the convenience or benefit of the party requesting the vacation. I also ask the board to consider the long-term implications of this decision. Once an established easement is vacated, restoring that access may be extremely difficult or impossible. To, to do.

25:08
Casey Benavides

This decision could also affect not only my property rights, but also the rights and opportunities of all the property owners along Windchime Street. I should not have to sacrifice access to my property simply because someone else would prefer that the easement ceases development. Again, I respectfully ask the board to deny this request to vacate the easement and preserve the existing right-of-way that is Windchime Street. All right, thank you again for providing me the opportunity. Yeah, thank you.

25:44
Brantley

Uh, anyone else online wishing to speak?

25:51
Brantley

Okay, so at this time we will close public comment.

25:58
Brantley

That'll bring us to our Plat Committee report.

26:03
Morgan

There were 9 plats put before the Plat Committee tonight, and all plats were approved. Okay, any questions for Commissioner Gillum regarding the Plat Committee?

26:12
Epperheimer

Through the chair, can I, uh, can I just go back to Item 3 for one second? Oh, absolutely. Yeah, I just had a question for staff on this. Um, Will the testimony tonight be part of the record when the application returns to us?

26:42
Epperheimer

It would be. And one follow-up question, will public testimony this might be reopened at the next—. Yes. Okay. Yeah.

26:50
Brantley

All right. For sure. Okay. Thank you.

26:57
Brantley

Okay. Where are we then? Oh, questions for Commissioner Gillum regarding the Flat Committee. And we're not due for another draft. Okay.

27:09
John Benavides

All right. I'm sorry about this. But on that last item, I didn't hear the answer to that. Who is it? Was our—.

27:19
Brantley

This is— sorry, that motion or that item was postponed, so it's not being heard tonight. Okay, because it was on the agenda, we have to open it up to public comment. You will have an opportunity if it does come back. You'll have the opportunity to speak again, or everything that you said tonight will be carried on to the packet for the next, but it was postponed. Thank you so much.

27:48
Brantley

Okay. Now we're on to Item G, which is other items. We have the Beachcomber Supreme Court decision.

28:28
Walker Steinhage

Well, good snowy evening, everyone. For the record, my name is Walker Steinhage. I'm one of the Deputy Borough Attorneys here. I will try to keep this brief, but as Chair Brantley mentioned, I'm here to give a short presentation on a recent Alaska Supreme Court opinion that was issued late last month. It's a case that many of you are probably familiar with.

28:58
Walker Steinhage

Next slide, please.

29:03
Walker Steinhage

So we're going to go through the background and the timeline, talk a little bit about how this got in front of the Supreme Court. We'll talk about the issues that the Supreme Court had to decide, what they held when they issued their opinion, and then most importantly, the takeaway— the takeaways for you as planning commissioners. I anticipate sometime early in the new year we'll be doing a workshop that's going to be a good springboard— or this presentation and the takeaway section will be a good springboard for that workshop in the early new year. And then certainly stand for questions at the end. But if you have questions in the middle of it, don't hesitate to interrupt me.

29:52
Walker Steinhage

And can everybody hear me okay? All right, very good. Next slide, please.

30:04
Walker Steinhage

This was a quote that's taken directly from the opinion, and I think it highlights really well what the, what the Commission, uh, did and what the Commission did well. It says, and while Beachcomber asserts that the Commission ignored actual photos and videos of the subject property and surrounding areas that it provided, the record shows that the Commission considered Beachcomber's evidence. The fact that the Commission decided against Beachcomber simply suggests that found the other evidence more convincing. It is not our role— in other words, it's not the Supreme Court's role— to choose between competing inferences or evaluate the strength of the evidence where the record contains substantial evidence to support the Commission's decision. Next slide, please.

31:02
Walker Steinhage

So 2018, Beachcomber applies for a material site club.

31:10
Walker Steinhage

The application is to operate a club on about 27 acres of a 41.27-acre— excuse me, 41.72-acre property that Beachcomber owns down in Anchor Point.

31:30
Walker Steinhage

One thing that came There, that I took notice of in this opinion was something that the court highlighted, that there's a common misconception that there are no— there is no zoning in the borough. You all certainly know differently. And the court noted that there are actually two zoning districts in the borough, a municipal district and a rural district. So of course, because this is an Anchor Point this property at issue was within the rural district.

32:08
Walker Steinhage

In July of 2018, the Planning Commission denied Beachcomber's application.

32:17
Walker Steinhage

Now, many of the sections of code that were at issue in this, in this appeal were subsequently amended by the assembly in 2023 through Ordinance 2022-36. However, the court analyzed this case under the code that was in effect at the time when the adjoining landowner's property— or excuse me, when the adjoining landowner's challenge was brought. So all of the analysis in this case was done either under the code provisions that were not affected by the code change or the old code provisions.

33:06
Walker Steinhage

And under that old code, material site clubs had to meet 6 standards, and 2 of those, minimizing noise and visual impacts on neighboring properties, were really the ones that were at issue here.

33:24
Walker Steinhage

Along with that, the Planning Commission, uh, may require an applicant under the old code to meet 15 conditions, uh, including buffer zones to provide screening from noise and visual disturbances. And so the conditions that affected the 2 standards for noise and visual impacts were at play on this appeal.

33:53
Walker Steinhage

And under that code, only the listed conditions in code could be imposed to meet the standards. And in July of 2018, the Planning Commission denied the application because it believed that the proposed berms or buffers would not minimize noise. As you'll see going forward, a series of appeals and remands followed, all centering on whether the code provisions provided the Planning Commission with the discretion to deny CLEP applications even if they comply with all of the listed conditions.

34:36
Walker Steinhage

So that July of 2018 denial was appealed to a hearing officer and the hearing officer remanded the matter to the Planning Commission.

34:46
Walker Steinhage

That hearing officer interpreted the code to mean that the Planning Commission does not have discretion to deny CLEP applications that comply with all permit conditions. And so the hearing officer remanded so that the Planning Commission could reevaluate the application using the hearing officer's interpretation documentation regarding the Planning Commission's discretion and to issue more robust findings about whether Beachcomber had in fact complied with the conditions.

35:22
Walker Steinhage

So in June of 2019, the Planning Commission, after that direction from the hearing officer, approved the application And again, it was appealed back to the Hearing Officer.

35:42
Walker Steinhage

The Planning Commission had determined that the application did comply with all the permit conditions and therefore, under the Hearing Officer's interpretation of the code, the application then therefore met all of the standards. Next slide, please.

36:08
Walker Steinhage

Second time in front of the hearing officer, the hearing officer affirmed, and so the decision was then appealed to the Superior Court for the first time.

36:21
Walker Steinhage

Judge Gist in the Kenai Superior Court heard the case. And he reversed the hearing officer's decision, and it was again remanded to the Planning Commission.

36:33
Walker Steinhage

Judge Gist interpreted the code to allow the Planning Commission discretion to, quote, deny a club when it finds that the conditions will not satisfy the standards, unquote. And he also remanded so that the Planning Commission could apply the court's interpretation and then make adequate findings.

36:55
Walker Steinhage

Judge Gist also said that if the Planning Commission determined that no con— no con— excuse me, no combination of conditions could adequately minimize visual and noise impacts to the standards set forth, then the Planning Commission had authority to deny the application.

37:18
Walker Steinhage

It was brought back to the Planning Commission in March of 2022, and the Planning Commission denied the application. So Beachcomber appealed again to the hearing officer. In denying the application, the Planning Commission determined the application could not meet the minimum, minimum characterization of noise and visual impacts standards even after imposing all of the permit conditions. And therefore, as a matter of law, the application did not meet at least one of the standards.

37:57
Walker Steinhage

The hearing officer affirmed the Planning Commission's decision, and Beachcomber appealed to the Superior Court. For some reason, and I'm not entirely clear why, but it went to a different Superior Court judge, this time Judge Jonas. And Judge Jonas affirmed not only the Planning Commission's decision but also— excuse me, Judge Jonas affirmed the hearing officer decision, and then the hearing officer decision and Judge Jonas's decision and Judge Gist's decision were appealed to the Supreme Court.

No audio detected at 38:00

38:49
Walker Steinhage

Beachcomber had asked Judge Jonas to revisit Judge Gist's interpretation of code where Judge just had said that the Planning Commission has discretion to deny a permit even if all the conditions are met. He said— Judge Jonas said, quote, lower courts are bound by an appellate judge's decision, and subsequent appeals can't litigate the same issue. Judge Jonas also determined substantial evidence supported the Planning Commission's decision. And so when it got to the Supreme Court, Beachcomber asked the Supreme Court to, as I said, overturn both Superior Court decisions and the Planning Commission's 2022 decision, which had been upheld by the hearing officer, um, which would have left the 2019 approval or granting of the permit in place.

40:00
Walker Steinhage

The neighboring property owners, and there were multiple, the named party— well, they were all named parties, but just for the sake of ease, we'll call the neighboring property owner the Bilbin Group.

40:18
Walker Steinhage

And the, the Bilbin Group asked the Supreme Court, of course, to uphold the Superior Court decisions and the third hearing officer decision.

40:36
Walker Steinhage

KPB took part, um, not fully. KPB's position before the Supreme Court was limited, and it was limited in deference, um, to the Planning Commission's role to enter its decision after careful consideration of all the evidence.

41:01
Walker Steinhage

And so KPB neither supported nor objected to the merits of the Planning Commission's decision. And only addressed any arguments that would have implicated a possible remand, another remand, um, reflected the propriety of the process, or would otherwise impact, uh, KPBs, and particularly the Planning Commission's process or procedure in the future.

41:35
Walker Steinhage

And for those same reasons, uh, the Bureau did not take a position on the correctness of either Judge Gist's decision or Judge Jonas's decision, particularly when it came to, uh, the Superior Court's interpretation of the code provisions, because at that point, um, the Supreme Court court had authority to declare whether the superior court's interpretations were correct or not.

42:12
Walker Steinhage

And then on October 23rd, 2026, the Supreme Court issued its opinion after all the briefing was done. There was no oral argument in this case, so it was decided entirely on the briefings of the parties. Um, and so now we'll launch into, uh, exactly what it was the Supreme Court was asked to decide. Next slide, please.

42:42
Walker Steinhage

The first issue, and this is where the court spent the bulk of its time, um, was whether the Planning Commission had actually had discretion to deny FLEP applications that met all permit conditions under the code provisions in effect at the time. We're not going to spend a whole lot of time on that because, number one, code has changed through that 2023 ordinance.

43:18
Walker Steinhage

Again, when it reaches that level, interpretation of the law is the province of the judicial branch, and we'll discuss that a little bit further later on. Now, you may be sitting there asking yourselves, as I did, why the court didn't simply decide that this issue was moot. Because the code had changed. And it really boils down to money because, um, the outcome would affect attorney's fees. And that's discussed, I think you have the opinion, it's in footnote 18 if you're curious, but doesn't really have any bearing on what we're here for tonight.

44:07
Walker Steinhage

But that's why the code, the So that's why the court didn't just say, look, the code's changed, this is a moot issue.

44:18
Walker Steinhage

Now, more germane for us are the— really the second and the fourth issues. The second issue is whether the Planning Commission considered improper evidence. The third issue Well, let me back up. Beachcomber was arguing that the Planning Commission's decision was not supported by substantial evidence. And you guys are well versed in this.

44:49
Walker Steinhage

It's in our code, but just a refresher that substantial evidence means such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support its conclusion.

45:02
Walker Steinhage

Beachcomber's arguments regarding improper evidence centered around, uh, public sentiment and LiDAR images, and we'll talk about those when we get to the holding.

45:17
Walker Steinhage

Now, this third issue, whether the Planning Commission violated the Administrative Procedure Act, Beachcomber claimed that the APA, Administrative Procedure Act, APA for short, um, had been violated because the Planning Commission had effectively adopted a new regulation when it interpreted the code as giving it discretion, which departed from the Planning Commission's historical interpretation.

45:53
Walker Steinhage

And then finally The last issue that the court had to decide was whether the Planning Commission violated due process.

46:02
Walker Steinhage

Um, there were two procedural due process claims. First, that the Planning Commission did not reopen the record in 2022, and number two, that four of the 11 commissioners did not participate in the vote that denied the application.

46:21
Walker Steinhage

And then there was one substantive due process claim, which they styled as bias, claiming that the Planning Commission became advocates for upset neighbors and was no longer a neutral and unbiased decision maker in 2022. Next slide, please.

46:49
Walker Steinhage

The Supreme Court held that under the old code, Planning Commission did have discretion to deny a CLEP application. Again, we're not going to spend a whole lot of time here, but there is one quote from that section of the opinion that I want to provide you all. And it's this. And while Beachcomber argues that interpreting the code this way gives the commission unfettered discretion to deny permit application for any reason, we observe that the commission is still bound to support any permit denials with written findings demonstrating that its evidence is backed by substantial evidence and that parties have a right to appeal denials and argue that they are not grounded in the code.

47:49
Walker Steinhage

What's important about that is that the court had at that point, um, particularly by 2022, a solid record to look at and understand how and why the Planning Commission reached its decision.

48:09
Walker Steinhage

The second issue, um, the Supreme Court determined that the Planning Commission's review was proper and did not rely on improper evidence.

48:22
Walker Steinhage

The court noted that the Planning Commission had determined that even if all of the conditions were imposed, the application would still not meet the impact standards of minimizing noise and visual impacts on surrounding properties. And that was based upon the, quote, unique amphitheater-like quality of the area, unquote, which would carry sound to neighbors and make berms ineffective.

48:52
Walker Steinhage

So based on that, the court determined that substantial evidence in the record supported the Planning Commission's findings. And the other— excuse me— the other evidence in the record included, and this is a list from the Supreme Court: written and oral testimony from the neighbors, photographs of the property and neighboring properties, topographic maps, and LiDAR images showing the elevation profile of each homeowner's property in relation to its neighbors.

49:30
Walker Steinhage

Regarding the claim that the Planning Commission relied on public sentiment, the court, the court cited the code provision that requires public hearing and that the Planning Commission— or excuse me, that, that the code also allows those wishing to contest a permit to submit evidence and to be heard.

50:02
Walker Steinhage

Furthermore, the Planning Commission may need to consider testimony from neighbors to determine what conditions will effectively minimize noise and visual impacts.

50:19
Walker Steinhage

Another quote from the opinion, um, and it's a bit of a cautionary note. It says a planning board may always take evidence and testimony from community members into account in making its permitting decisions, but it may not rely on neighborhood opposition alone as a reason to deny a permit.

50:44
Walker Steinhage

They cited one or two other cases that, that hold that, and then they reiterated it here in this opinion. So the takeaway there is that, that's, uh, neighborhood testimony can certainly be considered, but that alone is not sufficient to deny a permit. You have have something more.

51:09
Walker Steinhage

In this case, though, the court noted that the record does not suggest the commission gave undue weight to negative community sentiment to make its decision, as the record contains considerable evidence supporting the conclusion that it would be impossible to mitigate the sound and visual impacts of Beachcomber's proposed mine.

51:34
Walker Steinhage

And because of that, the Planning Commission's consideration of public testimony was not improper.

51:44
Walker Steinhage

Regarding whether LiDAR was improperly considered, the court said that the images were directly relevant to the question of whether Beachcomber's application could meet necessary impact standards. And Beachcomber provides no convincing challenge to that theory of relevance.

52:05
Walker Steinhage

Part of that too was that Beachcomber had also relied on LiDAR images, and the court said that that fact that Beachcomber had relied on LiDAR images themselves kind of detracted from Beachcomber's argument.

52:24
Walker Steinhage

One more thing to note before we move on to the— one last thing to note before we move on to the next holding.

52:33
Walker Steinhage

Beachcomber had argued that the Planning Commission ignored actual photos and videos of the subject property and surrounding areas that it provided.

52:44
Walker Steinhage

The court said, quote, The record shows— the record shows that the Commission considered Beachcomber's evidence. The fact that the Commission decided against Beachcomber simply suggests that it found the other evidence more convincing. It is not our role to choose between competing inferences or evaluate the strength of the evidence where the record contains substantial evidence to to support the commission's decision. And that was the quote that we started this presentation with.

53:23
Walker Steinhage

The third issue, the APA issue.

53:31
Walker Steinhage

The Administrative Procedures Act is in-state statute. It's in AS4462330.

53:41
Walker Steinhage

But it applies only to state boards, commissions, and officers that are listed or where another statute expressly invokes the Administrative Procedure Act. So if you guys are worried that there's something, another act that you need to consider, the Planning Commission is not one of the entities that's listed in state statute. Statute. And so the court said, um, neither the borough code nor the statute requiring boroughs to establish planning commissions require the planning commission to comply with the APA. It's about a short paragraph in the opinion, and it boils down to APA doesn't apply to KPV Planning Commission.

54:33
Walker Steinhage

Finally, last issue regarding due process.

54:39
Walker Steinhage

In addressing the procedural due process claims, the court noted that upon Judge Gist's remand, the Planning Commission had already held 4 public hearings and received considerable written and oral testimony, including from Beachcomber, regarding the effectiveness of conditions, um, regarding the effectiveness of the conditions that were at issue throughout the process.

55:08
Walker Steinhage

And as it related to the decision to not reopen the record, the court noted that Beachcomber had opposed reopening the record in 2022, which dampened its argument that it was denied the opportunity to present arguments following Judge Gist's decision. Um, so the court held that, um, there was no due process violation for at that point deciding not to reopen the record because there was already an ample record.

55:42
Walker Steinhage

Regarding the recusal of the four commissioners, um, the court just said Beachcomber didn't identify why, uh, this recusal was harmful, um, and in a footnote, footnote 78, the court gave a shout out to Planning Commission's bylaws where it says, uh, under KPV code, the commission is allowed to adopt its own bylaws to govern the con— conduct of its affairs, and the bylaws require 5 members of the commission to constitute quorum. And in this case, in 2022, 7 commissioners voted on the application.

56:30
Walker Steinhage

Finally, the substantive due process argument regarding bias.

56:38
Walker Steinhage

The court cited a case that says administrative agency personnel are presumed to be honest and impartial until a party shows actual bias or prejudgment. Beachcomber did not meet their burden, and the mere fact that the Planning Commission ruled against Beachcomber does not satisfy the burden of showing lack of impartiality or unbiased it's still a good takeaway. There is a presumption that administrative agency personnel lay boards are impartial and unbiased, but that's something that should be protected, and that's why, you know, we talk about, you know, no ex parte communication communications in quasi-judicial matters, making decisions only on the record before you, et cetera, in these quasi-judicial proceedings.

57:50
Walker Steinhage

Moreover, the Supreme Court said the record showed that the Commission wrestled with the question of whether to grant or deny beach Homer's application throughout the process. And it also noted that some of those who voted to deny the application in 2022 indicated that the decision had been very difficult and that they were voting against the application because of the 2019 Superior Court decision that required them to evaluate whether the conditions could effectively minimize the impacts. And so that was an example of the Planning Commission rightfully taking the law and applying it to the facts, the law as it was interpreted by Judge Gist.

58:39
Walker Steinhage

Next slide, please.

58:45
Walker Steinhage

Takeaways. I'm going to sound like a broken record, but This case really underscores the fact—pun intended—that good factual findings based upon evidence in the record are critical. And then the next step, solid conclusions of law applying the relevant code provisions, again, applying the law to the evidence in the record, the facts are crucial.

59:16
Walker Steinhage

And that's because, third takeaway, both the findings of fact and conclusions of law allow reviewing authorities— in this case, two Superior Court judges, three hearing officers, and then up to the Alaska Supreme Court— it allowed all of those reviewing authorities the ability to review the record that had been developed and then understand how and why the Planning Commission reached its decision. And then finally, we just talked about this, but again, in quasi-judicial matters, Planning Commission must be an impartial and neutral decision maker.

59:58
Walker Steinhage

Next slide.

1:00:01
Walker Steinhage

That is all I have. I am certainly happy to answer questions. I appreciate your time and attention.

1:00:12
Speaker G

This isn't a question, just a comment. I was on the Planning Commission in 2018 and sat there and listened to a lot of testimony, a lot of information, and I stand by that decision we made then, the denial, and I stand by what the Supreme Court said But it's a good, good, good ruling.

1:00:37
Morgan

And I believe Mr. Ruffner was there, and I think Mr. Van Nooten was there, and maybe Miss Morgan were all there in 2018. This is Commissioner Morgan, and yes, I was there through every single step of this. It was excruciating, but I really appreciate presentation tonight. This is helpful, and I look— I'm appreciative having the whole decision here and the footnotes and just really good information.

1:01:09
Morgan

Thank you.

1:01:13
Speaker G

I also was on the commission back when we did this. This is Venuti, and I think we did the right thing. It was a very contentious issue. A lot of input from neighbors, but overall I think that we did the right thing. And so it was good to review what you just showed us.

1:01:44
Speaker G

But I have a fond memory of when I first came to Alaska 50 years ago. Being on the Anchor Point Beach very close to the site and marveling at what a beautiful place it was, how lucky I was to be there.

1:02:08
Speaker N

I too was on the commission back then and I too sat through many of those meetings and in reference to the 4 that weren't there, I do recall that there was testimony testimony brought forward each time we had a testimony or hearing. Everything was brought forward and continued on, so even if they weren't present, their voices were still heard. And so I too agree with all the findings and all the evidence that was before us. It was a tough decision to wrestle with and then to have come back, and I'm very grateful for the presentation tonight to help cement all of those steps that were put in place that led up to this and ultimately, in my opinion, gave us a solid understanding of our role and our skills and our training that we've had to move forward in those decisions. So thank you.

1:03:02
Epperheimer

I got a comment, or I got a question, I suppose.

1:03:08
Epperheimer

One of the things that I've— Or would you agree that, uh, on when we comment or make statements on the record that we are— that we approve, or how we feel about that, making those statements other than just voting, do you suppose those comments help the case when it's being reviewed?

1:03:34
Walker Steinhage

Through the chair, Commissioner Eppenheimer. I think what this, this opinion highlights, whether it is written or oral findings, that is certainly helpful if those findings are tied to what has been presented in the record, whether it's in the packet or during public testimony.

1:04:04
Brantley

You know, explaining, you know, what— well, I think an excellent example of this was, um, yep, the portion, the, the portion where it talked about the amphitheater, uh, quality of the area. And the fact that any combination of conditions couldn't minimize the impact of noise and visual disturbances. And the nature of that area, that amphitheater-like nature, had been presented to the Commission through various ways. And so tying what was heard and seen in the record to the, uh, the decision that based on that these standards cannot be met. Um, that's ultimately what, uh, what drove, I think, a good portion of the court's decision regarding whether there was substantial evidence and whether and how the Planning Commission reached the decision that it did.

No audio detected at 1:05:00

1:05:33
Walker Steinhage

Um, because, you know, a simple yes or no or something that's not tied to the record evidence that's in front of the Commission doesn't really help the reviewing authority in understanding what you all are thinking as fact-finders. So yeah, I would, I would say, Commissioner, comments that are, that are, that are tied to the evidence and tied to what's been presented in the packet or public testimony, that's, that's crucial.

1:06:10
Walker Steinhage

So, and the only other thing I would say is it really does need to be be tied to that.

1:06:18
Walker Steinhage

Um, like the court said, it was obvious from the record that the many commissioners that made the decision struggled with it, but ultimately they understood their duty to take, take the law and apply it to the facts. And that meant potentially setting aside, you know, personal feelings and, and in applying what the code requires. So that's really the touchstone here is, you know, what does the code require and what facts in the record support that or don't support that.

1:07:04
Walker Steinhage

Personal feelings, concerns, that can potentially tip into the bias territory and erode that presumption that Planning Commissioners are unbiased, impartial decision makers. I know Robert, or Mr. Ruffner, speaks about this a lot, but when you're sitting in a quasi-judicial hearing, you are sitting as judges. And so just like we expect those with— who wear black robes, whether it's the Superior Court or the Supreme Court, to be neutral and unbiased decision makers, that's the commission's role in quasi-judicial matters.

No audio detected at 1:07:20

1:08:03
Brantley

Any further comments?

1:08:07
Brantley

Or one thing I think this really highlights is how important standards are and how well-written they need to be and how specific they need to be, or non-specific depending on the intent of the code. But how it comes down down to— and you're trying to meet those, being very careful on how you word them so that we can work off of them.

1:08:34
Brantley

It should be interesting. You said after the new year you guys are coming back for a presentation kind of based on the new code and how this applies to it, or— Thank you, Chair Brantley. It'll be a broader It'll be a broader discussion, a workshop on making findings of fact and conclusions of law. Okay.

1:09:00
Walker Steinhage

But part and parcel with that is you have, you got to have some exercises to look at. So maybe we'll, maybe we'll look at some some material site examples if there aren't anything pending before the Commission at that time. But it's going to be a broader, hopefully broader, more broadly applicable workshop.

1:09:32
Walker Steinhage

And, you know, just because the code changed here, the mechanics really the sausage making that you all did under the old code is still applicable. It's the assembly's role to tell us, you know, this is the code, and then it's up to the Commission to apply that. Again, take that and apply it to the facts. When Judge Gist, when, when the first hearing officer said, uh, Planning Commission has no discretion, that's, that's the law of the case at that point. So that's the interpretation you apply when there's a higher court that comes in and says, no, there is discretion, here's how it should operate.

1:10:27
Brantley

That's the law of the case, and then it's the Planning Commission's job to apply it accordingly.

1:10:33
Walker Steinhage

Hypothetically speaking, if the Supreme Court had differed with that interpretation, it could have remanded it and said, here's how you're to apply it.

1:10:46
Walker Steinhage

So everyone has their role.

1:10:49
Walker Steinhage

You know, the legislature makes, as you all know very well, legislature makes the law at the state level, and hear the Assembly enacts code and, and then it's up to bodies like you all to apply it to what's presented to you at these hearings.

1:11:13
Brantley

All right, uh, thank you very much.

1:11:17
Morgan

This is Commissioner Morgan. Yeah, go ahead, Commissioner Morgan. I wondered what I— if I missed it, was a date mentioned, or is that still up in the air as to when this workshop will occur.

1:11:30
Walker Steinhage

Through the chair, Commissioner Morgan, we're targeting early in the new year, but I don't think anybody has their schedules out yet, figured quite that far out yet. So I would say that would be to be determined. Excuse me. Okay, if possible, I will try to be there in person.

1:11:55
Brantley

Thank you, Commissioner Morgan. Alrighty, that brings us to presentations and public comments not appearing on tonight's agenda. No public? Okay. Director's comments.

1:12:12
Robert Ruffner

Good evening. I do have a couple. So first, I want to start with, uh, with, um, Thanking Councilor Steinlager for walking us through this. I think that was really good. I mean, last time you saw this was 4.5 years ago, so there was a lot of money, time, and effort spent since the last time you saw this to get to where we are.

1:12:39
Robert Ruffner

So I think that was an excellent presentation, just a reminder of the importance of what you all do as the quasi-judges in these cases, and, and also the rest of the staff that prepares these reports for you, um, and who serves as a clerk over there to, you know, make sure that the record is complete, and that we have legal counsel here, um, to kind of help us make sure that we follow those. So it, it does take a full team to, to make that happen. So Again, thank you for doing that, Walker. Next, just a couple things that came up tonight that I'll just touch on briefly. So setbacks, you know, we have these exceptions come up all the time and it's a perpetual thing.

1:13:26
Robert Ruffner

I spent a fair amount of time thinking about it. Short of us enacting some sort of building permit requirement to really let people know that You need to get that survey before you put something in close to the property line. I think we're going to continue to see them. We can do some education, and we do with the surveyors in particular, but the private landowners, it's pretty difficult to reach the full cross-section of the population that knows that— well, they might think we live in a completely unzoned area. We do live in a large portion of the borough is in that rural unrestricted.

1:14:03
Robert Ruffner

So, um, yeah, that's what I think, that's what it is. Um, next I wanted to touch on wetlands, and I want to be a little careful here because, you know, we did, we did hear wetlands came up tonight, and that could be appealed. So I don't want to talk about the specifics at all, but just in general, um, the, the borough, um, has pretty limited, um, authority over any wetlands. Um, We do a very, a long time ago, and I was definitely involved in this, we recognized that there was an educational component that needed to get out there. So we do publish on our GIS wetlands that were done, were drawn with some scientists that were working for a nonprofit organization.

1:14:52
Robert Ruffner

They've been up for, I don't know, getting close to probably 15 to 20 years, something like that, that those have been up there. And those, those are largely up there for educational purposes, but they have worked their way into code in a couple of spots. One of them is in the gravel pit ordinance where we do consider those wetlands when we talk about setbacks and staying away from water and not, not having impacts on those. And then Secondly, and not directly, but in the 2118, which is the Take Care of the Salmon Code, the Habitat Protection Ordinance, we do pay attention to them there, but they're not explicitly written into the code.

No audio detected at 1:15:00

1:15:42
Robert Ruffner

Wetlands are the purview of the federal government. I mean, they are the regulatory body that governs those. And so some discussion that came up was, you know, things may be changing because there may be a connection to the river. So I'll just touch on a couple of things that have happened in the past, I don't know, 5 to 10 years at the United States Supreme Court, and the reason that there was discussion about whether there's a connection to another water body because the Corps, the US Army Corps of Engineers will evaluate and regulate wetlands if and only if under these two cases, the Sackett and Rapano's case, if there is a surface water connection to a navigable water body. So isolated wetlands that don't have a connect— don't have a surface water connection are largely outside of the Corps' present interpretation on what they will regulate or not.

1:16:53
Robert Ruffner

So that's why we might have heard some of that. So again, I think that the salient point that I just want to drive home is that we have very limited say in wetlands in the borough. And they really are in the domain of the federal government. So next, I want to talk a little bit about, or just mention that in the mayor's packet meeting today, it did come up that the clerk is going to submit for recommendation to get our steward seat filled. So we did have an applicant that had just moved into the sewer district, needed to go through a couple of steps to formally demonstrate that she was, was living within the city limits and that voter registration had been filed for in that.

No audio detected at 1:17:20

1:17:45
Robert Ruffner

Those are the two, two requirements for that, that seat. So we, so we should have a, should have a sewer commission commissioner that'll go to the assembly for approval in the, in the near future.

1:17:59
Robert Ruffner

Um, next I want to congratulate Mayor Whitney, and I'll let him have a story there about how voting is important and how they count. Um, and then last but not least, I don't really know where they are in the assembly on certifying the election. I just, I didn't catch it at the last meeting, but Regardless, we do have our new Assembly member Lisa McDonnell in the audience tonight, and so she represents Assembly District 1, so that's the Kalifornsky, Kalifornsky Beach area. So thanks for coming and attending tonight. And that's all.

No audio detected at 1:18:00

1:18:43
Robert Ruffner

I think I covered all my notes, so I'm happy to answer any questions if there are any. Any questions for Director?

1:18:52
Brantley

Um, I have one question. I know we was a couple, 4 or 5 meetings back, we brought up the encroachment permits. We talked about potentially seeing if the mayor wanted to do any kind of educational, like, radio ad or something. Yes, we can get a hold of the surveyors, but there's a lot of building sites going on that aren't— they're not using surveyors. And, or, or we— a couple years ago we talked about increased fines, just even if it gets approved, a mandatory fine so that it stings a little bit for the next time, or some, some way of— or changing, potentially changing code, changing the standards to make it harder to get it, or I don't know.

1:19:37
Robert Ruffner

But yeah, I, I certainly can bring that up again with, uh, with the mayor and see if we want to, you know, do something a little bit more. I mean, I know that it was a few years ago that somebody got bit pretty hard. They built a house across the line and we did say, you know, you got to fix that. And so either require them to replat, but in not all cases is it possible. But I certainly will bring it back up and see if see if there's something that we want to take action on.

No audio detected at 1:19:40

1:20:15
Slaughter

Okay, well, that'll bring us to Commissioner's comments. Commissioner Slaughter. Just want to say thanks to staff, and Walker, thanks for that presentation. Really is helpful. With that, I hope even the Commissioners online, if you guys can as much as possible come to the next meeting as my annual little gift going away goes, you'll get something nice.

1:20:37
Slaughter

And with that, I hope everyone has a great Thanksgiving, and we'll see you next time. Commissioner Eberheimer.

1:20:49
Epperheimer

I don't— I don't have anything to add tonight.

1:20:53
Brantley

Commissioner Venuti.

1:20:58
Venuti

Interesting meeting. Um, hope you all have a great Thanksgiving, that you have lots to be thankful for, and thank you all for serving tonight. Thank you. Commissioner Whitney.

1:21:14
Brantley

I have a great Thanksgiving. Uh, thanks for the presentation on the Supreme Court ruling. Um, I read through that and it was a very interesting 27-page document. And, um, after this last election, I don't think I'm ever going to live down the results of that. I'll be hearing that for probably the next 20 years.

1:21:36
Speaker C

Commissioner Fikes. Congratulations, Mr. Whitney, and no further comments. Commissioner Morgan.

1:21:47
Morgan

Yes, congratulations, Mayor Whitney, and if anyone thinks their vote doesn't count, they need to talk to you.

1:21:56
Gillum

Commissioner Gillum. I just want to thank the staff. They're always— their work always makes us look good up here. And thank you for the presentation. That was very good.

1:22:06
Gillum

And congratulations, Mayor Whitney. That is proof positive that every vote is important. And I'd like to encourage that. And congratulations to the assembly member, Lisa McDonald, for the Kalifornsky District. She'll do a good job for us out there.

1:22:22
Brantley

And everyone have a good evening and have a happy Thanksgiving and safe travels home. All right, everyone drive safe in the new snow we got. And with that, I'll entertain a motion to adjourn. So moved. So ordered.

1:22:35
Brantley

Good night.

1:22:42
Speaker C

Got some extra if you want.

Speakers in this transcript