Skip to main content

Editorial map (Gemini + Google Maps)

City attorney says Homer council will have its own lawyer in records appeal

by Walter AlaskaNews(40m ago)
2 min readHomer, Alaska

The Homer City Council will have its own lawyer from another law firm for Frank Griswold's public records appeal, City Attorney Max Holmquist wrote in an email Friday, Nov. 13. The email is in a supplemental packet for the council's special meeting Monday, Nov. 16, where the council was set to hear the appeal.

Griswold had written that Holmquist appeared to intend to represent both City Manager Melissa Jacobsen and the City Council at the hearing. He cited the Alaska Bar's rule on lawyers' conflicts of interest and argued that the council, if it wanted legal help, must hire impartial, independent counsel. Holmquist, of the Anchorage firm Jermain, Dunnagan & Owens, replied that afternoon: "The City Council will have independent counsel, from another law firm, to assist with this appeal. I am only representing the City as a party to the appeal."

Griswold wrote back that evening asking how Holmquist learned of the arrangement before he did. "Did you and/or Ms. Jacobsen play a role in selecting who would represent the City Council or engage in ex-parte communications while doing so?" he wrote. The packet does not name the council's lawyer.

The appeal concerns a request Griswold filed Oct. 7, 2025, for records about parking on the paved shoulders of West Bunnell Avenue. City staff first wrote on the form by hand that no records existed, and emails later turned up. A Sept. 15 superior court order found that answer amounted to a denial under city code that should have gone to the council, and dismissed his court appeal, according to the agenda packet. Records in the packet show the city engineer confirmed the city authorized paving areas in front of businesses on Bunnell Avenue, and a change order of $94,989.76 on the Ohlson Lane and West Bunnell Avenue project included $53,855.64 for additional asphalt pavement. Nelson Engineering, the project engineer, said it did not design or endorse the paved shoulder parking.

Griswold also objected to agenda wording that a copy of the council's decision will go to the appellant if the council puts it in writing. "Stating or implying that only the appellant is entitled to receive a copy of the decision is patently ludicrous," he wrote. Citing Alaska Supreme Court rulings, he argued the council owes a written decision with findings of fact and conclusions of law: findings that "bridge the analytical gap between the raw evidence and the ultimate decision."

In an email Monday morning, Griswold raised possible conflicts of interest for any mayor or council member with ties to business owners along West Bunnell Avenue.

The packet does not show the outcome of the hearing. Griswold wrote that city code gives the council 30 days to decide, a deadline he counts as Thursday, Nov. 19.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: City of Homer, City of Homer: City of Homer, General: Supplemental Packet (2026-11-16).