Skip to main content

Editorial map (Gemini + Google Maps)

Alaska Supreme Court says knowingly underreported income can mean backdated child support

by Cale Green · draft by Walter AlaskaNews
3 min readPalmer, Alaska

When a parent paying child support knowingly underreports income, a judge can backdate an increase to before the other parent asked for one, the Alaska Supreme Court ruled Friday.

Usually that isn't allowed. When a parent asks a judge to raise child support, a court rule generally bars increasing what was owed in the months before that request was filed.

"The rule is not intended as a shield to protect parents who have knowingly underreported their income," Justice Dario Borghesan wrote for the court. "Rather, it is intended to ensure children receive the financial support they need."

The case came from a divorce in Palmer. The couple, who have four children, separated in 2022. The father told the court he made about $37,000 a year. A judge set his support at about $700 a month for all four children.

The mother asked the court to throw that order out. She filed a tax form showing he had earned about $184,000 from his own business in 2021, and pay stubs showing he had started a new job in September 2022 paying more than $170,000 a year. At trial, he testified that the salary was $176,000.

Superior Court Judge John C. Cagle in Palmer raised the support to $3,780 a month. He made the increase effective Oct. 1, 2022, around when the father started the new job and months before the mother's request. Turning down the father's bid to sanction the mother's lawyer, Cagle said that if either side had acted in bad faith, it was the father.

The father appealed. He argued that the backdated order broke the rule and that the judge had counted his income twice. The mother didn't take part in the appeal.

The justices disagreed with him on both points. His own testimony and pay stubs, among other evidence, supported the finding that his income from October 2022 on would exceed the $126,000 cap the support formula used at the time, they wrote.

As for the rule, the court said it was adopted to comply with a 1986 federal law meant to stop parents from letting unpaid support pile up and then getting it cut or forgiven. Those concerns aren't at stake in a case like this one, where support went up because the father knowingly underreported his income, the court said.

The justices pointed to their own 2015 ruling upholding a judge's decision to replace a child support order, effective back to the couple's separation, after finding their divorce was a fraudulent attempt to dodge creditors, along with similar decisions in Wisconsin, Illinois, Ohio and West Virginia.

The court also upheld a finding that the father's monthly payments to his parents for a property suited to his business had built up equity the couple shared. It noted that because his parents hold title and weren't part of the case, it's unclear whether they're bound by that ruling, but said no one argued the point on appeal.

Made by our human newsroom with AI. Reviewed by Cale Green. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom ·

Source: Alaska Supreme Court, Alaska Supreme Court: S19251: Doug Bowen v. Deana Ray, f/k/a Deana Bowen (Op. 7838).