Fairbanks Borough: Platting Board Work Session, 2026-11-18
Alaska News • • 100 min
Articles from this transcript
Fairbanks board has little room to say no to big subdivisions, chair says
Fairbanks' subdivision board says it has little room to reject big subdivisions that meet the rules, then hears about it at the grocery store.

No audio detected at 0:00
No audio detected at 0:20
No audio detected at 1:40
No audio detected at 3:40
You're not ready yet. All right, all right, everyone. The platting board work session of November 8th, 2026 is called to order at 6:59 PM. We are in the Mona Lisa Drexler Assembly Chambers. Madam Clerk, would you please call the roll?
Mr.— not Mr. Brooks. Mr. Brooks is— excuse me— Mr. Pitney. Here. Miss Guthrie. Here.
Mr. Perkins. Here. I don't see Mr. Brannon. Mr. Thatcher. Here.
Mr. LaVon. Here. My name is Berman Williams. Here. You have a quorum.
Excellent. So the main topic of our agenda for our work session is Item C, Work Session, a presentation by Community Planning Department staff and Legal Department staff on the Planning Board's powers as codified in Fairbanks North Star Borough Code 4.84, which includes the power to recommend changes to Fairbanks North Star Borough Code 4.84 and Fairbanks North Star Borough Code Title 17 to the Borough Assembly. The presentation will be followed by discussion with questions and answers, hopefully. This item is presentation information only and no recommendations to Fairbanks North Starboro code change are requested at this time. To provide a little bit of additional context before our staff report, um, there has been some, uh, informal conversations from some board members where it People have been frustrated about what we are and are not allowed to do as a platting board.
No audio detected at 6:40
We are restricted by Title 17, but sometimes it feels like we are rubber stamps for Title 17. So let's talk about what our role is, what the powers are that are currently in the code, and if there are things we wish we could do. So we'll have a presentation from staff, which I really appreciate them being willing to pull together. And then in this work session is an opportunity for us to have a discussion. And Mr. Pitney, if you want to scooch over here, you're welcome to do so.
You're far away. But you can also stay over there if you want. I get a better angle than everybody from here. All right. Before the staff report, any questions?
All right, let's, let's have a staff report. I'll start it off, and if maybe Madam Clerk could share the screen while I'm speaking. I think Miss Berman-Williams did a good, good job introing this item. I've had several board members come up to me over the last couple of months as well, more with just questions. You know, what does title say?
Can we do this? What if we wanted to do that? What are our powers? So I think a couple of things tonight I think we'd like to to treat this work session as a conversation. So we have a bunch of material prepared, but let's just have a conversation.
If you have questions, something that doesn't make sense, or you have thoughts, you know, let's, uh, let's go through the chair, of course, but, um, we can have this as a conversation. It's a work session. We can work this out rather than just us talk to you and you ask us questions. So the best way I kind of summarize this is how I had to get my mind straight for this is Qualitative versus quantitative. Title 17 is very quantitative, very quantifiable.
It's hard to argue with a lot being— it's either an acre, it's not an acre. The right-of-way is either 22 feet like we saw tonight, or it's not 22 feet. There's a lot of really quantifiable items in Title 17, and there's only a couple of areas, and we're going to talk about them tonight, where, where judgment comes into play, and the Planning Board has some judgment capabilities with certain items. There are other sections of code like Title 18, our zoning ordinance, where almost everything, for example, that the Planning Commission acts on, they're strictly using their judgment. It's not as quantifiable as Title 17, and there's other codes all over the country that you know, mirror one model or the other or something in between.
So I guess the point of the presentation tonight is we want to go through kind of where we are, what's in code, kind of exactly calling out sections. It's going to be a little bit of a tag team effort. George is going to take a lot of the heavy lifting, but David Bredlie is here with our Public Works Department, and Rocky's here, obviously, Mr. Esposito, to talk about the legal side of it. And I think maybe the most interesting section in my mind is getting into the specifics on our special standards and restrictions section we have right in title right now, where judgment is a little more kind of free. And we can go through some examples, and we came up with an example that we don't have an answer to.
I think it'd be a good kind of thing to work through and talk through with the board. So I'm going to turn it over to George or Mr. Steffen to go through some of the background, but Again, I encourage you, if you have questions or want to talk about something, you know, be recognized and let's have a conversation. Super, thank you. Yes, so, Madam Chair and board members, I'll do my best to look up as I'm presenting. Feel free, of course, to interject or ask questions at any time during this.
And so, yeah, first of all, where does this come from? So With the Fairbanks North Star Borough, there's 22 general ordinances, and Title 4 is Boards and Commissions. And so to Chapter 4.84, the Planning Board. So as required by Alaska Statute 2940, the Fairbanks North Star Borough, which is a second-class borough, shall provide for planning, platting, and land use regulations. So the Planning Board is, of course, very important.
No audio detected at 11:40
Providing for platting, right? And so tonight's work session is going to focus on mainly on 4.84020, the powers granted to the Platting Board.
And so what I have here is a list of those powers, and we'll be going into individually each of them so you don't have to try to take in all A through F subsections right now. But this is 4.84020. So we'll start with A.
So the board has the power to approve, disapprove, or return for modification or correction subdivisions, plats, replats filed with the Planning Board. And of course, that has to be pursuant to Alaska statutes and to the subdivision ordinances. And hence where our findings of fact need to come in. And so, approve. In Title 17, if the subdivision meets the requirements of Title 17, the board shall grant preliminary approval, and it's actually called out in 17.12.030.
If the board denies or disapproves an application, the board needs to adopt specific findings of fact and reasons. Well, findings of fact, you'll see, are even recommended by staff, of course, for approval, but especially with disapproval. There needs to be reasons on the record why the request has been denied. And then that last one, so return it, return that application for modification or correction. So what is it that needs to be modified— modified or corrected about the request?
No audio detected at 13:20
And again, findings of fact are necessary. Mr. LeVant, we're gonna— we got a question. Certainly. Yes, uh, maybe you were about to get to this, but I was gonna say, with the return for modification or correction, is that we need to have a finding of fact, or some— a finding of fact that we want answered? Like, how, how broad is that?
And if I'm understanding your question, uh, a finding of fact of why you want it returned versus— and again, could you repeat that? I want to make sure I understand. Yeah, I guess, would we— so a findings of fact needed? Maybe I'll think on this a second. Certainly.
George, I can field this. So especially on quasi-judicial matters, which a major plat is, You need— you do need findings of fact for any sort of dispositive action that you take on it. Just as a matter of administrative law, you have to be able to show that there was some reason, like based on substantial evidence for the decision that you made. So if it lands, you know, if it goes through appeal at the Board of Adjustment and ends up in front of a court, the judge's first question is going to be, can I understand why the body made this decision? And findings of fact are formally what you're setting out as the basis for the decision that you're making.
In the context of returning for modification or correction, George will be getting into some of that. But if, for example, there were conditions that you thought were necessary to impose under Title 17, you could move to impose those at that time, or you could return it for modification and correction to say, "Hey, you know, we need this information to determine the scope of the conditions that we think need to be applied to this application." Yes. Part that kind of hangs me up here is the word shall, because that essentially just makes us interpreters of code. And I have a day job. You guys do this for a living.
And if I'm being honest, you're probably better than I am at interpreting code. This particular code?
Is the next part of your presentation to go into— so I guess I don't understand why, why you need a board for that. I see. I would say, and I'll certainly defer to, uh, Mr. Episito on this, but, um, I would say for one, per Alaska statute, what we need to have regulations for platting, and there needs to be a body that makes those decisions for all subdivision requests. I'd say that first and foremost, just, it has to exist for a second-class borough. Yeah, George is exactly right there.
I have the statute in front of me, Alaska Statute 2940.080, says that the assembly, if they want to establish a platting authority, they can do so. And if they do so, It has to be a body that, you know, an administrative official can approve abbreviated PLATs, what we call quick PLATs in our system, but we need an actual sort of constituent body to approve PLATs. Why can't the borough be that body, like staff?
I'm going to jump in and I'm going to say I think part of it is that The citizens of the borough want to know that there are eyes on the actions that borough staff takes.
But that would require that we have some discretion to do something different. I think we're gonna— hopefully we're gonna get to where we have discretion. I mean, I, I agree with you, it is, it is frustrating that when we are given a subdivision to look at, and we're told our job is check this meets the quantitative requirements of Title 17, therefore we shall approve. That's frustrating. I'm hoping that part of what will come out of this discussion are ways in which we are allowed to exercise judgment.
I just add on, I don't want to monopolize time, but I mean, I've seen a lot of— since I've been here Well, not— I wouldn't say a lot, but a handful of subdivision plats where I think I could figure out a better way to do it. But that— those type of things, like, by the time it gets to me, there's— it's too late.
Well, go ahead. Yeah, yeah. Um, when I vote yes or no, I'm voting on what's between my ears. I look at the situation, I read the thing, I listen to the people, and I vote yes or no. OK?
That's how I'm going to vote. I'm a professional engineer, and if I see something that I perceive is going to increase the hazard to the public, I'm not going to vote for it, period. Now, the problem is I can't necessarily relate that— and also, I'm on shaky ground because I haven't done a full investigation. All I'm doing is what I look at here. But if I see something that isn't right, or I think isn't right, I can't vote for it.
Now, how to translate that into a finding of fact, I don't know. But I think you could just say that. The board members thought it was unsafe, period. I don't know why you have to tie that back to a width of a roadway. But there, I think, is the problem.
And I don't really disagree with what's going on here. I'm just pointing out me, and I don't want to be the odd man out and cause trouble. But that's just the way I see the situation and getting cycling all the way back. The reason why we're here is precisely as our chair pointed out, that we're citizens. We're supposed to use our— what's between our ears.
We're supposed to be informed by all this stuff, but that the final thing is a citizen making a judgment. I'm going to suggest— I see you, Rocky, and you can say something which will be helpful, but I would like to get back to a little bit of Mr. Stephan's staff report. May I? Yeah, please. Okay, there's just a few things I want to field.
So first off, for situations where there may be a hazard the public, stay tuned. That's in the presentation. Uh, to answer a few more specific issues, first off, why do we have to have a body instead of just community planning? It's again because statute requires it. I didn't finish reading the sentence, but it says the planning authority may consist of members of the planning commission or of other municipal residents.
The way I read that, it's pretty clear that the Alaska legislature didn't want it to be a creature of borough staff making decisions. And why not? Well, at the end of the day, and this goes to your point, uh, Mr. Perkins, is At the end of the day, you're making decisions about people's disposal of their own private property. They have rights in the use and disposal of their property, in the division of their property. When the government exercises power over that, it has to do so in a way that's not arbitrary and capricious.
There has to be some nexus to a legitimate public good when we impose restrictions on the way that people use things that are privately held.
Go ahead, Mr. Stefan. Thank you. And, and, uh, before I dig right in, you know, so I worked at RCH Surveys for about 5 years before I came over here, and I, I think in answer to the question, so who came into our office? Those folks looking to subdivide, and they relied on our registered professional, uh, Richard Hyron at the time, and any engineer we used for that design. You know, and that design then we understood in the office had to meet Title 17.
And so we submitted an application and that's what really, really drove it. So I think the point there is it's initiated by a member of the public that's looking to subdivide or replat, and they know the first step is to reach out to a licensed professional for that. And so as far as this slide goes, the last one, because we don't hear of it much, return for modification or correction.
You know, we do our best to vet files, and that's why we send out requests to other staff members— Trails, Public Works, our planning zoning folks— just to make sure we're trying to catch everything. But sometimes it doesn't happen. And if a borough— I'm sorry, if a planning board member recognizes that, say in this case, just a hypothetical example, this is a property off of Farmers Loop Road. It happens to have a Category Trail B, Jeff Studdard Sled Dog Trails, in it. Well, supposing during staff review and, and the applicant who needs to write abide by Title 17 missed that there is an existing Category B trail that should— an easement is supposed to be dedicated on the plat to cover that trail.
It needs to be as-built, right? So that 20-foot-wide trail easement is correctly identified and then, uh, platted. And that is required by two portions of our code. But supposing we missed that and a planning board member picked up on it, they use the trails out there. Hey, wait a second, I recognize that.
So as opposed to denying the application, the planning board could return the application when that recognition is made. This needs to be corrected. And I think what's interesting too, depending on the context of, say, how this subdivision lots were laid out, um, it might be appropriate that at that public hearing, the Planning Board couldn't just simply— could just simply impose that condition that you dedicate the trail easement. But that may not be, uh, the appropriate course. You know, that, that might mess up how the lots might be configured.
And so there's a case where the Planning Board could decide to return that application to staff, essentially, and postpone it or take the action of including a condition for that easement dedication. So it was something I was trying to come up with. Well, what— when can this happen? Well, staff can make errors if something is missed. And if you recognize that problem in Title 17— before I go on, any questions or comments?
Then you're just using us as your QC. I mean, I agree that's potentially a good reason, but I mean, QC doesn't seem like enough to justify plating board.
Yeah. That's just my thought. I guess I'm not necessarily— I'm still a little skeptical.
Of what we do or what kind of discretion we have. So I'll wait for the rest of the presentation. But I'm hoping you will get to— sorry, um, supposing we see a subdivision that meets the requirements, the formal requirements of Title 17, but we look at this and we're like, this is a bad idea, right? Yeah. And that's what I'll be, of course, handing it back over to Mr. Spilman.
All right, and that'll be actually subsection D. So I'll get through these others leading up to that pretty quickly because they're a little more common. Perfect. So as far as subsection B, the power to waive the preparation, submission, and recording of lots of subdivisions, if that waiver is allowed by statute. This is something that rarely comes up. In fact, in my 14 years here, I think I've seen one waiver of subdivision.
And there's a reason why. Because this waiver is only a waiver of the final plat. They still need to meet preliminary plat requirements. It still needs to go to the platting board. So all the requirements essentially must be met.
But where you find this happening is with large landowners like the State of Alaska, could be the borough, the University of Alaska. A survey is still required unless the boundaries of the parcel to be created are— can be identified by aliquot parts descriptions, and that each of the resultant parcels are nominally 40 acres or larger. So something that we saw where the waiver process was used was the applicant was the State of Alaska. They created 3 tracts, one of 40 acres, 80 acres, 120 acres, and those could be described by aliquot parts. And so they simply filed a certificate of waiver for irony subdivision.
And why the state pursued that is they were exempt from the typical survey requirements because it met those two criteria: adequate parts description and 40 acres or larger.
Moving on to C, the Planning Board does this all the time. Oh, yes, Mr. Pitney. Well, over the 20-plus years, you heard this from me, and I'll try to form it in a question rather than a suggestion, but I think you guys do an excellent job, uh, and I've seen great changes over the years in personnel, but, and most every time I'm in agreement with you. So the question will be, and you've heard this before, but why do we have to look at corner rounds? And I know it's historical and a lot of you here don't understand it, but Corner roundings to me sound like, you know, it's a done deal.
We've never not done one. It seems like quick plat, you ought to be able to, and we're done with it. I guess the question again is, why do we have to do it? And I'll ask it again in another 5 years. I think, you know, again, back in the private sector, corner roundings were one of the most frustrating things because otherwise it would have met quick plat requirements.
Fortunately, in our subdivision code, We now have an exemption for corner roundings with certain criteria of the public works engineer and the managing authority waive that requirement, and that the subdivision is not otherwise dedicating road right-of-way. So that's— that has been a step towards improvement to fix that very issue. A former planning officer, Jake Borowski, was really the one who spearheaded that, and that might be Oh, 6 years old when that was codified. So that was one step in correcting that issue. Well, thanks, and I'm sure I'll pound on this again, but I doubt if many people on this board have actually heard us about corner roundings in the past, but it's something we—.
I would hate to say waste time on, but you know what I'm talking about. I do. Thanks. Thank you. And So dedications and vacations, vacations, which you seem to be seeing a lot of this past year.
Yes, this is one of your powers to approve or disapprove dedications and vacations. So I'm going to use the example that relates to something that the board semi-recently acted on back in 2004, Rosebud Subdivision. It's a two-lot subdivision. It was the case where all these small government lots were patented with roadway and utilities. Those are depicted by the dashed lines, but the Feds got one parcel wrong and there is an odd, odd location or placement of that roadway easement.
So therefore, that plat was required to dedicate an extra 20 feet, and the board approved that subdivision including the dedication of the public road. And so what you saw back in September of 2026 is a request for Lot 2 to essentially vacate that small government lot roadway and utility easement, simply because the dedication existed and they wanted to remove that unnecessary encumbrance. So those are examples of when the board can approve dedications and vacations. And this is where I'm going to be turning it over to Mr. Spillman, per your question. And I guess before I dive into this, Mr. Thatcher posed some interesting questions.
And if I may just take a moment to kind of talk through some of the thoughts I had.
I guess one thing I want to state is I'd say 3 out of 4 times we have someone come to the counter, give us a call, and wants to subdivide the property. And I'd say 3 out of 4 times, they either don't go through the— with the process, or it looks very different what they originally propose compared to what comes to you. And a lot of that is us working with the applicant. The last thing we really want to do is bring something to you that you have to adjudicate, bring something to you that, you know, we don't like or the applicant doesn't like, and we have two different positions going through something. But I think it's important to point out at any time, the applicant has the ability, as long as they meet the, like, bare minimum requirements of a subdivision, they can bring something to you whether we agree with it or not.
No audio detected at 30:40
And it's really your purpose. And I think that's an important purpose to really, you know, for lack of a better term, Rocky might scold me here, be the jury in that instance. And really kind of work through that. And I don't think we've seen a big disagreement this year, but we've seen a lot in the past. And these can be important decisions, especially when it comes to publicly dedicated roads, driveway access onto highways, stuff that's not allowable by title.
And George just talked a little bit about vacations. We get vacation requests all the time. These are public roads that belong to the citizens of— of the Fairbanks North Star Borough, private property owners want to take these back. They want them to be private property, and it's a really high threshold to meet. And that's the absolute area you guys need to use your judgment.
That's where you have the ability to use that, that judgment. Well, there was like 3 conditions. I don't remember what all of them are. Like, one of the conditions is this is in the best interest of the public or something like that. And, um, like, that is a little bit subjective, but like most of the tests are not necessarily quantitative, but they're, they're objective.
And I don't know what the— it seems to me like in, in a lot of cases what the What the planning board is for is to protect the public from corrupt borough officials. And if you guys are acting in good faith, then we end up not doing a lot. I'd say it depends. And there's different opinions all the time. And I wish you could see some of these conversations at the counter on these right-of-way vacations that someone wants to take back this public road.
We disagree with it, or maybe there could be something more beneficial offered. But you up there as a collective need to be the judge with that. It shouldn't be me as a government official using that. It should be the representatives of the community, the more legislative branch.
So that's just kind of— and state law contemplates the same thing, especially with public rights of way. That these rights-of-way really belong and are protected for public purpose.
Sorry, I went down a little bit of a rabbit hole there.
And I'm going to talk a little more about variances as well, but I want to draw your attention to this kind of— it's special standards and restrictions. It's right in title. I really encourage you, maybe, you know, doesn't have to be during the meeting. It could be after the meeting. It's a short read.
This is where the platting board has more ability. If something could potentially be a hazard to a person or property or damage to the property outside of the subdivision, there could be additional restrictions or additional conditions put on the applicant. And we've used this a number of times in the past. I'm going to, I'm going to show you a real-world example where um, where we use this, and I'm going to show you a theoretical example that I don't have the answer to, but it could be something to, to talk through. So, Mr. Stephan, could you go to the next slide for me, please?
So this is a real-world example. This was a 24-lot subdivision off of Sheep Creek Road, and the subdivision itself is— the boundaries were shown in red there. And they were dedicating a whole road system. But you see that little kind of short road, and especially the first portion of that short road, it's Gold Flake Avenue. That road already existed.
And it was built to borough standard. And over the years, I don't know how— I'm sure there's a better engineering way of describing this. It was a bad road. It was a very narrow road. It's a very potholed road.
The drainage was horrible. The road was starting to fall apart. The water was getting into the base material of the road. It couldn't— again, not being an engineer— it couldn't support the additional traffic that 24 lots were going to put on that road. So as part of this subdivision process, staff and ultimately the Planning Board, the developer didn't want to upgrade this portion of the road.
It's not explicitly called out in title that they need to upgrade this road. So this was an instance that the special standards clause was utilized, and this developer, as a condition of the subdivision— I'll read it right here— Gold Flake Avenue be upgraded prior to the final plat to restore the surface to 20-foot width and a 3% crown. There were additional kind of engineering requirements. But that was a utilization of these special standards clause. And that, again, wasn't that cut-and-dry requirement right in title.
But using that, the potential of additional hazard being brought up to the traveling public, the folks, you know, buying these lots in this subdivision, that that was a restriction that the platting board had the ability to and did put as a condition of the plat. I mean, can I— so that requirement would then— would be put in the final plat as a condition of approval. And so beyond the final piece of paper, the plat. Yeah. So how it works.
So if the planning board puts that on the prelim, basically the engineer and the surveyor and the applicant go out and, you know, put monuments in, prepare the final plat. But before we will take that final plat down to the recorder's office and record it, David Bredlie and his team have to go out and kind of inspect all the roads in the subdivision. And that would be a portion of the inspection that Gold Flake Avenue was actually upgraded to those standards. And if every one of those conditions aren't met, we won't take the plat and go record it. But you're saying he would go out and he'd have to rebuild the road to that standard before the plat was approved?
Before the final plat was approved? The final plat was approved. Yes. So the only way we would see that— I mean, we don't see all the plats. So the only way we would know to— or we would be given the opportunity to add a special condition is if it went to the planning board to begin with.
This kind of scenario, I assume if you got— you guys would decide to add a special condition and then it would need to go to us for approval? More often than not, the Planning Board has contemplated special conditions in the past. Sometimes they can come up with public testimony, sometimes it could be based on agency comments or reliance on professionals in those industries. But more often than not, at least the special conditions I can recall have been proposed by staff and confirmed by the platting board.
Since you brought up this example, do you happen to know what this was zoned as? I don't remember offhand. Suppose it had been zoned GU-1 like so much of the borough, and instead of 24 lots, they wanted 48 little tiny lots at 20,000 square feet each or whatever it is.
We don't get to talk about zoning, is there a way we can say that's too many lots for this area?
Yeah, potentially. I think it takes some kind of finagling, um, and I think that's going to be one of the points of our next conversation to see if we could get there with kind of what's in code right now. Thanks. So I don't have the answer. I know you've heard that from me a bunch too, because it's just driving me up the wall.
Sorry, I'm just pulling up my code while I'm— and Mr. Stefan, could you go to the next slide, please?
So this is our theoretical example here, and I'm going to tell you where it really is, and then I'm going to ask you to use your imagination a little bit. This is on College Road. That's, uh, Joy— Joy Elementary, the round building you see there. Let's use our imaginations that that is an elementary school, and that was an elementary school, and there's a large subdivision going in. So just theoretically, that whole tract's being subdivided, uh, it's zoned multi-family, uh, large apartment complexes could go in there.
It could generate a lot of traffic. Mm-hmm. So let's think about this. If they just meet the nuts and bolts requirements of Title 17— excuse me— one of the main traffic generators we have in our community are schools, especially during peak hours of traffic generation. Is this something we think we could get to, for example, I'm not saying necessarily deny, but maybe put a condition on, maybe return to the applicant to do something like a traffic impact analysis.
Really proving what the impact of the development would have on the, on the existing transportation network. Sorry, did you have a question, Mr. Thacher? Well, so you kind of answered a little bit, but you know, like, I'm a roadway engineer or whatever, but like, I don't have enough information in these presentations to make, or time to make, any kind of judgment on Well, what's the traffic demand going to be for this road? And what is the volume— design volume going to be? And if, you know, the pavement is out or whatever.
I mean, it's just too much for these. I mean, the best thing that we as a board could ask for in a scenario like this would be a TIA or another engineering report that says this is what the impact of this road is going to be. Either good or bad. Exactly. I think that's kind of what we're kind of wrestling with here in this theoretical one, that, you know, I wouldn't, I wouldn't want you to, you know, try to off the, off your cuff make decisions with ADTs and levels of service and blah blah blah.
But you as a board, what would you need to do potentially to say, hold on guys, let's, let's think about this a little bit? Could we return this? Could we ask for more information? Um, could we get more information from DOT on, you know, if they approve of, uh, whatever potential development's going in? So I don't know.
I think that, you know, potentially there's a way utilizing that special standards clause. Would you think that really bad traffic would constitute a hazard to persons or property? I mean, that's— it feels like something where special standards and restrictions should apply, but what was listed required hazard, and bad news doesn't look like hazard to me.
You're right. Howie, maybe.
And Rocky, chime in if you have any kind of initial thoughts on this. You're absolutely right. So in terms of, you know, is this going to create traffic that is unpleasant for members of the neighborhood or the community, that really is something that would come up more during the planning permit stage under Title 18, might go to the Planning Commission if it's a conditional use permit for structures or uses that they want to put on these properties. But you may reasonably conclude there might be a hazard here, right? There's a, there's a school pickup and drop-off gets out of control these days.
I don't know, I rode the bus growing up, but people like to pick up and drop off now. Um, you know, there's kids walking around. And so if there's going to be a dramatic increase in the amount of traffic in the vicinity of a school, you might reasonably conclude we need to know if this is going to create a hazard, request something like a traffic impact study to get the information you need to make a determination whether it would be appropriate to impose special standards and restrictions. In practical effect, special standards and restrictions are where, you know, a condition to come— you impose conditions on applications in order to comply with Title 17. Getting to Title 17 compliance in most of these cases is the goal.
Special standards and restrictions is, you know, when you have specific kind of articulable evidence that there's going to be hazard to life or limb or specific kinds of damage enumerated in Title 17, that you would impose extra conditions even though they're not really necessary to comply with the written text of Title 17. But the justification would have to be because we're concerned about some kind of hazard? Correct. The justification for special standards and restrictions are, you know, if the preliminary layout was approved and developed, it would result in a hazard to persons or property Or if you've got evidence that indicates that damage to properties outside the bounds of the subdivision may occur. Could that include potholes on the road?
Ooh, I like that.
Damage— so that second one, the damage provision, is defined somewhat narrowly two paragraphs later. It's impairment of property due to water drainage patterns, impairment of natural water sources, issues from the disposal of waste. Or issues from the disturbance of unstable soils. So the creation of potholes on roads outside of the subdivision, I think, would fall outside of the damage provision. So damage caused by drainage from the subdivision is the primary one?
Yeah, I think generally the damage— there's like two prongs there, right, for special standards and restrictions. So you've got hazard to persons or property. I guess potholes, like, maybe depending on, you know, if you've got like mining trucks that are planning to go through, that might fit in there. But the damage provision is usually going to be if they develop this property as they are showing in the preliminary plat, is it going to— is the physical state of that development going to cause externalities in the surrounding properties? Are they going to be sloughing off water into those properties?
Are they going to be generating a lot of like waste that goes into those properties? Or are they going to be causing like a failure of structural support in the land on the properties. So a while back we looked at that subdivision uphill on Chena Pump, uphill from— what was the elementary school?
Um, dang it, the elementary school on Chena Pump. What was it? Wood River. There was a subdivision right on top of it, and we were looking at, um, I think the drainage easement. I think drainage easement and giving it back.
What do you call it when you give vacation? Vacation. And I— what I remember, I actually spent a long time looking at that one before this, the meeting. But I— what I remember is seeing a lot of evidence that that subdivision was causing a lot of drainage problems on the school, like basically ponding their parking lot.
And, um, I— where I was stuck is, is the vacation of that drainage easement wasn't going to solve or address that problem. But to me, it looked like there needed to be additional drainage provisions to begin with when that, that plat was approved.
Um, I guess what is my point? I think my point is I wish us of the past did a better job, maybe. Well, but also like, but it's frustrating because you see these problems, you're like, man, I'm like adjacent to be able to fix this for the school, but I can't. I think.
No audio detected at 48:00
Go ahead. Well, just a little history on that. That was West Point subdivision, and we approved that many, many years ago. What, what they were just doing there was that they had built it off and they needed a foot, just move the thing over a foot, which really wasn't going to change the drainage any. So I don't think we had much powers over that.
The powers we had were years, years before when we approved West Point subdivision, and it was Wood River School that it did drain on. Well, I looked at that whole area, and there's not like really a drainage plan. It's not clear where the water goes in that whole area. So like, that has actually been one of my kind of observations about borough development, is you have these like puzzle pieces of subdivisions, and there's no like drainage master plan. Like the water is going to go in this channel across all these subdivisions, it's eventually going to go to the Chena.
Instead, it just goes off of the property into like a green space, and no one figures out if that green space can actually hold the water. Like, like big picture, like what's going to happen when all this green space is developed? Where does the water go? Um, So that would be a gripe that I don't know that that is maybe only tangentially relevant to this discussion we're having right now. But sometimes I see those things, but I don't know that, you know, the Planning Board can do much about it by the time these subdivision plats get to us.
That's kind of what I meant with, you know, sometimes I see a better way to do it.
Well, you know, I mean the applicant has already gone through all this work. You guys have gone back and forth looking at a bunch of different options. It's kind of— it's almost like I would feel bad if we sent— you know, even you had mentioned, um, John, uh, well, you can just send it back if you have issues or, you know, you need traffic impact assessment or something. But who knows? I mean, that could just, like, delay their schedule a year because they missed their preliminary plat, and now they have to— they don't get, you know, every— all the ducks in a row for construction the following year.
So it's kind of a big deal too to, like, disapprove something.
I'd say absolutely.
If I, if I may to that, Mr. Thatcher, within that special hazards and restrictions section, for what it's worth, um, so in all cases involving this section, the board, in considering special standards or requiring additional improvements, shall seek recommendations for solutions by professional persons active in the appropriate field. So I guess, I guess my point is, yeah, if sent back, you know, um, in order for the for the board to impose the additional standards and restrictions, right? It's got to have reliance on essentially, uh, credible, uh, folks, professionals active in the field. I don't know if that helps answer the question, but, uh, it perhaps in a quality control sort of way, um, it's got to be based on, on, on something. Yeah, I mean, well, we would send it back saying go get an engineer to look at something, right?
Okay. But my— I'm going to come back to this, like, drainage master plan thing. I think you guys should do them for these subdivisions. Like, you know, you have, like, road master plans. Where is the water going?
How does it get to the Chena? And are we— I don't know, because it's, it's important. It's, it's impo— I think it's impossible to rely on a developer to do that. Work because it's, it's a larger effort, but, um, you know, only tangentially relevant to what we're doing. We see these drainage problems, we can't do anything about it, and it bothers me.
If we had a drainage master— the drainage master plan for the borough, which we do not, and which I'm sure would cost $5 million, $10 million, $20 million? I have no idea. $100,000? I, I don't even know. But let's, let's say magically we had a drainage master plan.
Could one of the requirements for subdivisions be, is it consistent with the drainage master plan? Absolutely. Yeah, especially in other communities, there's like, you know, dozens of check marks you have to— is it consistent with the pedestrian plan? Is it consistent with the parks plan of the community? Are you setting aside enough, you know, in some instances open space for a fire department?
There's lots of requirements in other communities. And would those requirements then be things that would be built into Title 17 that we would check against? Typically that's how it works. So the, I guess, the formal term is exaction. Exaction is not maybe a legal definition, but the planning definition are public improvements required as part of a private development.
So one of our, like a good example of an exaction is we require rights of way to be dedicated. Not all communities do this. Like you can go subdivide in Tok right now and, you know, a lot of times not have to require any rights of way. So that's, you know, a line we've drawn that there has to be a way to get to your subdivision And for the most part, there has to be a constructed way to get to your subdivision. But again, drainage is a big one a lot of communities address, like storm drain systems.
You know, there's lots of different examples, but consistency with the plan or what the approved planned improvements are is typically a requirement in other communities. Do you guys have a, uh, like a kind of discharge permit, like storm drain discharge permit, anything like that? We operate— well, we have a what's called an MS4 permit, Municipal Storm System, and then two other S's I don't remember.
The area it covers is somewhat limited. It has to be— within the urbanized boundary as defined by the census and within a road service area. So if it meets those parameters and it disturbs over an acre, then yes, they have to get a permit from Public Works for discharge. And, and that would be when you actually get the opportunity to decide whether you're okay with where they're discharging their runoff? Correct, yes, we would look at their permanent stormwater plan.
Yes, interesting point. West Point subdivision by Wood River, that was, I think, the number— that was the first MS4 permit we ever issued. Great. I, I think I'm going to suggest that maybe we, uh, continue to discuss water issues later. But maybe there should be a discussion about water planning.
What did you call it, Mr. Thatcher? Drainage. Well, you probably would call it like a stormwater master plan. Yeah. Maybe the mayor should ask the legislature for money to do this, for example.
It's a massive effort. You got to have all your storm drains. You got to coordinate with DOT and the city. And yeah, it's—. But, um, yeah, point taken.
So there are things if we had various plans in place, then we could be testing proposed plots against these requirements.
And I— maybe, Mr. Thatcher, maybe we could follow up after the meeting. I do think that's a really interesting idea. I'd like to— play it off a little bit more. I had a related question. If you go back one slide, you talked about— yeah, so the board could impose more restrictive standards, but often we don't want to impose anything.
We simply want more information right now regarding a particular perhaps hazard, perhaps damage. We want more information. What's our mechanism to do that? Do I understand it now? We have to disapprove what they sent us.
Do we have a mechanism for saying, hey, put this in limbo for a while while we wait for an engineer's report on the traffic? So this really is your mechanism to request that extra information, and it's not, you know, when you make the request, it's not sort of tying your hands to imposing special standards and restrictions, but because of provision in special standards and restrictions that requires the Planning Board to seek— uh, I closed the tab— um, basically to seek expert information about the hazard concern and what special standards and restrictions might remediate that hazard. That would be a justifiable basis for returning an application to the applicant. Is returning the same as rejecting it, or just—. No, it's not the same as rejecting it.
I think Kellan could speak more, I guess, to the procedure in his office of how that goes.
Mr. Stephan, do you mind elaborating on, quote unquote, returning to the applicant?
Well, right, he submitted a preliminary plat. We look at it and say, hey, we need an engineer's opinion on the drainage. It looks bad to us and we want more information. At that point, we return it to him for until we get more information.
Are we allowed to? Mike, your mic on. Mike, that falls under the category of returning for modification or correction. So I guess the procedural would be postpone until next available meeting in order, uh, it in order for the required information to get back to the board. Yeah, I think even— or a motion to return under that provision in 484.020, um, with— you would want findings of fact with it because you would be making what is essentially a dispositive motion.
You're deciding, hey, we're disposing of this application by giving it back to you to come back with corrections, um, or with more information. And it would be— your findings of fact would be sourced in that special standards and restrictions provision. So to work on that hypothetical, we've got a plat before us. We're sketched out about what we think is going to happen to the drainage. We could move to return it for correction with the finding of fact being we're concerned about the drainage and we want more information.
That doesn't sound like a finding of fact exactly. A finding of fact that, you know, based on evidence and testimony, prevent presented, uh, the board believes that there may be, um— let me pull up the special standards and restrictions text because I will always go back to the text. Um, based on evidence and testimony presented, the Planning Board, uh, believes that the preliminary layout, if approved and developed, would result in a hazard to persons or property, um, or damage from, uh, the result of changing the location of natural surface water drainage patterns And another finding of fact that, you know, if the applicant returns with information from a professional, you know, hydrological study or something like that, that the board would be able to, to hear the same preliminary application with that added information. And I guess I can speak— this, this exact situation happened. This was years and years ago.
It was under former Planning Board Chair Merle Jantz. But you had a— it was a large subdivision before the board. And actually, a member of the public came in and said, this drainage plan is— I'm screwing up some facts here. But this drainage plan is bonkers. It doesn't slope this way.
Water doesn't run that way. And the drainage plan was showing something that wasn't actually on the ground. And the planning board— I, again, without having the facts in front of me, delayed or postponed that item to get more information. And lo and behold, the citizen was right. So they looked at it again.
The engineer redid the drainage plan to accurately reflect actually how the water would flow. And that new subdivision was approved that way. And we probably wouldn't have known without that citizen coming forward and saying, this is not how things drain.
Don't you guys have LiDAR for the entire borough? Most of the populated area. This was before LiDAR existed. But do you guys check that, the LiDAR? I'm gonna have Mr.
Bredlie speak. He's— his department's the one that reviews drainage plans. Yeah, we generally check it against LiDAR or contours, whatever information we have. Just say, okay, well, I agree the engineer says it's draining south and LiDAR suggests it drains south type thing. Yeah, and I just—.
Maybe if it adds any comfort, in my 13 years of looking at subdivisions, there's only been one where after the fact there has been complaints about downstream drainage. Um, so, and correct me if I'm wrong, wasn't it years ago we added some stricter language for drainage plans to be required? Right. And I think that did help with a lot of those issues. Might have been 2008 when a big rewrite.
Yep. Yeah, I mean, if I'm being honest, the death borough is going to be able to fork over an onomani with tape to put together some kind of drainage master plan. That's unrealistic.
I could keep talking if you want. You got more slides? I think I have one or two more. Um, and I, I guess this actually does come back very well to Mr. Thatcher's original question. I want to just spend a little bit of time talking about variances because variances are where you absolutely need to use your judgment.
It is so important and I mentioned earlier, you know, 3 out of 4 folks that we talked to early on don't actually take something to you in the same format they had. When we start conversations with folks, I'm generalizing, but a lot of folks don't want to do what Title 17 calls for, putting roads in, lot size, etc. And that's often a question. Well, how do I not do these things? And the answer is variance, but there's very strict criteria and it really all comes back to your judgment.
And folks try to, you know, manipulate this all different ways over the years, but the most used criteria for variance is the requirement is impractical or unnecessary due to specific circumstances. Or conditions of the subdivision. There's nothing quantifiable about that. That's very qualitative, and that's where we need you as the board to make these decisions. Everyone else has to follow by these rules.
Is there really something so unique about this circumstance that this requirement, whatever it is, putting a road, the geometry of the road, the intersecting angle of the road. And again, a lot of that comes back to public health safety and welfare. I've seen a lot of those same variances that we've approved, and, you know, people say it's impractical, whatever. But I mean, most the time it is practical, it's just amount of money that it's going to cost to do it. And I mean, that's been— so then for us, it's like the question is, well, Like, how much, how much, how much do we want?
Are we going to require them to invest? And then, and then in my mind, it's also balancing that against, um, you know, like trying to get more housing in, in the borough and not making it so hard that people stop trying to develop here. But I agree, like, some of these, those same, you know, the impractical language, it's like, well, it's a bit of a stretch. And that's why— and that's why we need, honestly, 9 different opinions making this decision. It shouldn't be— you know, I approve a lot of plats during these admin hearings, and they're like as simple as they come.
One lot into two, vacating a lot line. I, as a government official, shouldn't be the only gatekeeper with is it impractical or unnecessary. That's where we really should rely on the judgment of 9 citizens of this community to be making these decisions. So you'll see a lot of times, like, you know, we bring you a lot of variances. I think it's something like 30, a little over 30% of our subdivisions have variances.
There are unique situations, they're great uses for variances. But back to those initial conversations, there's a lot of folks that just don't want to do the requirements of Title 17. So it's really trying to find out where that line is. And, you know, for lack of better— you guys are the line.
Just adding really quickly, in total agreement with everything Kellan just said, going back to administrative law, if somebody's going to be challenging a decision that you've made with regard to a variance, again, the core analysis of court is going to do is, was this decision arbitrary and capricious? And having a group of people agree on it, just like Kellen said, when you're doing something that's kind of a gut check, like, is this impractical or unnecessary? It's the fact that you are agreeing based on specific facts that are presented to you and then making specific factual findings that insulate that use of government power from a legal challenge. Um, so, you know, again, at the end of the day, we as we sit here in, in our official capacities, we are acting as an arm of the government, telling people what they can and can't do with their property, um, and what they are entitled to is a due process where their decision maker is making a fair decision based on facts in the record, um, and they're making that decision in a way that is reasonable and rational and not arbitrary. So what you're saying is if we say no, we need to have the 9 people tell us volunteers that said they agreed to the no, so we don't get sued.
I'm speaking specifically in the context of a variance, and really there it's more of a yes, because when you approve a variance, you're telling a person, hey, this provision of law that applies to everybody else in the borough for this application doesn't apply to you. You're free from it. And in order to guard against favoritism, against graft, against any kind of impropriety, it's helpful to have a citizen board that can exercise that judgment, especially where it's qualitative, rather than, as Kellen said, just one member of staff doing it. But it could be a 4-5 decision. Our vote could be 4 to 5.
It could. There's no requirement for a unanimous jury here. You didn't call us a jury, but I think that the fact that we observe and whatever we do at a level with the public testimony, that we're, we're capable of doing that. That's the thing that people like us can do that AI couldn't do, probably. For now.
For now. So I, I understand the role of the Planning Board in variances and in approving dissolution and approval— I've forgotten the right words— of rights of way. But I do want to go back to the big subdivisions where our job is does it check the requirements of Title 17? You know, there's a— there's been a decision that says these subdivisions can be handled by quick plat, but if they're big enough, they have to go to the platting board. And yet it feels like the platting board, except in saying a really big subdivision may not be consistent with health and safety, doesn't have a lot of discretion in saying, yeah, we 100% think 22 lots in a GU subdivision is a great idea.
You want to talk about that some more? Sure, thanks. You're, you're right, there are not a lot of tools right now. The tools are only under that really, that, that special, special standards clause that we just looked at. And in your kind of just theoretical example, I think it'd be hard to pull the right tool out of what is in that section.
So I think it would be hard if you met every single requirement in Title 17. You know, we as a borough, and by that I mean the assembly, has approved the subdivision laws, and if you meet them, you get to go forward, other than if it's the special standards clause. So obviously, like any of our other codes, like our zoning code, we amend somewhat regularly. The subdivision code could be amended as well. There's a process for that.
I believe that's my final slide there, George. It was just an example of variance. Do you want to—. We can skip that. That's fine.
Um, Title 4. So the, the platting board does have the ability to recommend changes, modifications, or revisions to the title. That's right there. It's a little bit different than Planning Commission. Planning Commission actually has the ability to sponsor an ordinance.
Platting Board has the ability to recommend, uh, modifications right to the Borough Assembly. So we were just talking earlier about kind of how that would happen in In my time, I just can't recall any, you know, the board using this offhand other than ordinances being referred to the board by the assembly. But I believe this could happen a number of different ways. It would have to be voted on the board. So just, you know, brainstorming some ideas during comments.
At the end of the meeting, we have comments. So a planning board member could say, I'd like some changes to Title 17. I'd like to request something on the next agenda. So that could be a process. We'd put it on the new agenda, it'd be under new business.
So anything like this would have to be noticed, so it could meet agenda setting. Any board member could approach staff about something, or any board member— probably what's most appropriate is approaching the chair prior to agenda setting and getting something on the, on the next agenda. So as long as it's publicly noticed, acted on, and I'd encourage maybe if you're thinking about something like this, work through either Rocky or our staff to maybe get some of your thoughts out so that we get the right advertisement there. I think it'd be hard to just say changes to subdivision code. There'd have to maybe be a little more specificity to that.
I'm starting to talk about things outside of my bailiwick here. So Rocky, if you want to add. Yeah, I agree 100%. 100%. Just a few little curlicues on that.
Yeah, I think just changes to subdivision code probably doesn't meet the standard for specificity that we tend to require for our open meetings notices. So we would want to get more specific than that. The only small little asterisk I would put there is if, you know, if members of the board do want to propose changes or propose a work session for changes, you know, if 3 of you meet to talk about that, that's fine. But if 3 of you meet to talk about that and then you email the chair about it, suddenly we have an Open Meetings Act violation. At the end of the day, is it probably cured by how— holding a public meeting on the topic?
Yes, but I can't advise you to violate the Open Meetings Act. So, you know, bear that in mind. You can, you can, in any number, you can come to me or you can email the clerk's office or you can email Kellan, um, and we can help you sort of whittle down what you're trying to accomplish so that we we can get it effectively onto an upcoming agenda. How does staff initiate title changes? You just write the proposed language and send it to assembly, or how we typically do that?
So we've done very small changes and very large changes, so it has to be an ordinance. So we will usually have an idea of something that needs to either be fixed or improved, like actually the corner is a good example. The board kept seeing all these plats for corner roundings. And you guys hated it. We hated it.
The surveyors hated it. It would add months to bringing these little corner roundings before you. So we had an idea, former platting officer, like, hey, let's exempt corner roundings if it's a small subdivision and the borough engineer agrees to it. The managing authority of the roadway agrees to it, we can just exempt corner roundings. But it takes a code change.
So we brought that idea to the mayor. He was fully on board with that. We drafted an ordinance with the help of legal. It was referred to you guys, voted on by the assembly, and ultimately, you know, set into law now. Did the planning board vote on it to recommend it, or—.
I believe that one it did, yeah. So it seems like that would be, I mean, useful to get through the assembly of the Planning Board. As far as I can remember, every single thing, at least in my time here, as far as I can remember, every single item that the administration's proposed, any changes to subdivision code, have been before this body for a recommendation. It's not required in code. I've seen one, at least one assembly-sponsored ordinance that they chose not to bring to this body.
They chose to bring it right to the assembly. But everything I can think of, at least that came from staff, has came to this body for a recommendation. And actually, Mr. Pitney remembers a big one. We spent a long time on this, that unauthorized division of land thing, like we saw one tonight. That was a big process and ultimately came to this board for recommendations.
And if I remember correctly, this board had some tweaks they wanted to see, some amendments they wanted to see with that ordinance. So why can't we just gripe to you guys about it, figure out the specifics that said it's us to—. You, you absolutely can, but you're running the risk of if the mayor doesn't agree with it, or, you know, ultimately if the mayor doesn't agree with it, that, uh, it wouldn't come to be. I actually give you a good example. So the Chena Riverfront Commission, they have the same ability.
They can recommend code changes to the assembly and the mayor. So they had a public meeting. They voted on this. They actually recommended changes to the subdivision code. What they were seeing is subdivisions right on rivers.
Mm-hmm. Not to get too into the specifics, but rivers move, as we know, particularly if you're on the outer bend of a river. So they saw a big subdivision right on the outer bend of a river and said, guys, what are you doing? This river is going to move 50 feet in the next 50 years. You're going to lose half of these lots.
So they wanted a provision written into the subdivision code. They didn't know how or where it would go, but they want— they basically said the planning board should be able to use better discretion when it comes to these. To be able to look at lot size, lot placement. Specifically, they were looking at the depth of the lot. So they brought that to the assembly.
They brought that to the mayor. And ultimately, none of those members chose to sponsor an ordinance to implement that change. But again, I personally, I still think that's a good idea. But that's kind of the process to go through to get that incorporated.
So can we have a discussion right now about if we, in our dream world, what changes we'd like to see to Title 17? Just a chat? I better defer to the attorney here.
Uh, I think discussion kept to perhaps you know, what would we want to workshop at another work session, something like that. Yeah, yeah, is, is within the scope of what we've noticed. If we get too far into the weeds of specific changes, I think we start to escape what was actually noticed to the public for this meeting.
Are there things people would like to bring up in your dream world that we might want to revisit at future agenda? I mean, you've heard what's on my agenda, and I don't know how to— my agenda, my dream world is giving us more control over being able to approve or disapprove really big subdivisions that look like they're residential that are in the guise of GU-1.
I can talk about my dream world, right? We didn't notice, not dream world. In my dream world, there would be an ordinance that says if you're fixing to take a lot and subdivide it into a ton of little bitty lots that look residential, that you have to rezone to reflect that residential character. There's a lot of distance between that and an ordinance because there's a lot of edge cases that you would want to sort out. But that's the one thing that is just driving me up the wall.
I second that.
Sounds like a good topic for a work session.
Other things in your dream world that would make your job as a planning board member more palatable? Mr. Pitney. I don't think this takes us— it's not rocket science and it doesn't take a big change of Title 17, but One thing I would like to see, and you've heard me suggest this in the past, our names are out here and the public doesn't know you a whole lot. They see us and they see us in Safeway or Foodland. I don't have Foodland anymore, but Fred Meyer's or something, or on the street, or they can look it up online and call us.
So we're kind of out front on some of these things. And we vote 9-nothing. That makes all the sense in the world, but it doesn't make the sense to them, or, or they're not even here and they don't like what goes on and they get a hold of us. And we really can't talk about this for 7 days until there's a possibility of the appeal process going through. So what I'm asking is, I would like to really see where the communication to us was, the 7 days are up, there was no appeal, you can talk to people, or There was an appeal.
Keep your mouth shut until we get this resolved. I'd really like to see that happen. Do you get people that stalk you? What's that? People come and talk to you about this often?
Oh yeah. Well, I've been around a little while, but yeah. No, they say, hey, what, you know, you guys voted 9-nothing. Do you have any idea what you're doing? Da da da da da da da.
And then you say, well, I really can't talk about this, but if we knew on day 8 that there was no appeal, then we could, you know, pacify them a little bit. Just a suggestion. I'd like to see— I'd like to see the communication better to each board member that we could go ahead and start talking to people.
Seems pretty straightforward. Other dreams? I have a—. Go ahead. A small one on the preliminary plat.
Now, I, I just— on an example, the one we have today at Now this is here, I hereby certify subdivision plat has been found to comply with the regulations, etc. That's normally there and it usually has a surveyor, sometimes engineer seal that's unsigned. And so it's not a sealed because the signature is not there. But that way I know when I'm reading that who said that. Otherwise I've got a statement, I don't know who said it.
And I look over here at the initials on the drawing and and try to figure it out. But I'd rather see the seal without a signature for an undertaking like that, that I know who did it, who signed it, who's saying that, just for my own whatever. And I think most of them have that, but this one, from time to time, they don't. And then I always ask, why don't they? So that's something I think would just be an internal procedure with you folks.
That's a change in the ordinance or code or anything.
Any other discussion, comments, things you want to bring up, questions, things you're still wondering about? My biggest thing is it's not always obvious where— when and where we have the ability to make— have a little bit of discretion and when we don't. Like this discussion about the street thing. Oh, maybe we're not allowed to talk about it, but— or the street name. But, you know, I mean, it seemed kind of— I, I could see how a different board, because we're all pretty rational, might— that discussion might go off the, off the, uh, reservation a little bit and go down different rabbit holes that we shouldn't be going down if we're deciding on a street name.
Um, I don't know how to resolve that question, but, but just when I'm making these decisions, sometimes I have a hard time knowing, no, this is just a case where we need to interpret the existing code, or this is a case where the existing code gives us a little bit of discretion to make a decision if we have the tools that we need to do it, or we're aware of the tools that we— I don't know how to resolve that, but maybe it's experience. Yeah, and I would always encourage you, if you know, if there's a doubt in your mind about that, you have the opportunity to ask me, you know, if there's a question about it. I will note that my personal style, I think, for advising public meetings is to have kind of a light touch. I think I think the public has vested you with judgment where it has, so I try not to intervene with my own judgment calls. And I try to, you know, give you as much room to run legally as you are allowed to have.
But if there's any question about, you know, whether you would be crossing the line to ask something or to make a certain decision, feel free to ask me. During the meeting or after? Well, after is probably too late. So yeah, you can always say that you have a question for legal counsel if it's It's a question that you would prefer to ask privately for any reason, you could ask for an at ease and, you know, it's not a violation of the Open Meetings Act for me to speak privately with you, especially in the context of giving legal advice. But I'm also happy if we've got questions, let's just, let's just ask them.
Questions about? What are we allowed to do? What, what, yeah, what are we allowed to do? Are we allowed to give it a different name? Are we allowed to not name it?
You know, what, what, what are the parameters of what we're allowed to do right now?
We don't know if we don't ask.
Mr. Thatcher and Ms. Berman-Williams, I mean, I hate to create more work for ourselves, and these guys are about to tackle me, but, uh, you know, in thinking of what are your options, what is the planning board allowed to do, you know perhaps even within existing code, have that maybe a little more obvious or visible in the staff report and even a section on that, the Planning Board, you know, comment. If you could do that, that would be amazing. Certainly, because, you know, you could tell where, through vetting a file and all that, has it met all the requirements? Of course, that's what we're looking at out of fairness to the applicant. I will certainly get with staff on that, but I, I'm understanding your question is what I'm saying.
And, and now to actually how to make that happen, we'll discuss of course with, uh, Mr. Spillman on that. I mean, there might be cases where you don't actually want to write that down on paper too, but it could be like threading the needle a little bit to figure out how to say that, but in a staff report to where you're still appearing neutral. I guess is what I'm trying to say. But that would help if you could figure out how to do that. And it may just be approved, deny, or, you know, what you've heard tonight.
I don't know that— out of fairness then as well for the applicant, have they met Title 17? So I need to be careful on what we can do. Certainly more of a discussion. In this particular case, you guys had presented this board on the name, and that was about all. And, you know, uh, that lady comes up and talks and brings in a bunch of different factors that, um, had she not come up, we wouldn't have even considered.
And, um, but it also kind of— what am I trying to say—. It, it I, I, I'm getting kind of queasy. Okay, because we're in our 7 days of she can appeal here, or somebody can appeal.
The applicant maybe, who's not gonna.
But the point is, is there's sometimes like stuff that comes up. Yeah, yeah, keep it, keep it on stuff that comes up.
Eleanor, you had a question? No, I want to tell you, I think the staff is— Bob. What? What's that? You're good.
Go ahead. I'm good. Oh, thank you. I'm good. I haven't been told I'm good in a long time.
But I really think we have a great staff here. The reports are excellent. The materials altogether. The legal advice is good. Our chairperson is excellent.
But sometimes we should disagree. We should have little disagreements and ask questions and so on. But I'm absolutely delighted with these people I have to work with here. Thank you. Now you can go, Eleanor.
No, you're absolutely OK. I guess I— maybe just as a note for myself, I think doing some research on what codes are in place in other boroughs—. Obviously, we're unique in Fairbanks, Alaska. But what other boroughs allow their boards in terms of agency and discretion might also be something that I look into after this meeting, especially if we're going to have a future work session on this, because I think that, yeah, it's, it's always good to look at what other, what other, whether that's a borough or county or other places, are doing when it comes to this kind of stuff. So just as more of a note than anything else, my original question was, are you aware of any other boroughs or locations that allow their planning boards more discretion when it comes to approving or disapproving subdivisions?
Let's talk more. Yes, absolutely. And it really depends. Every community is a little different. Matsue is set up similar to us.
And I'd maybe argue their planning board has less discretion. Than this board. Uh, the Kenai Peninsula Borough, they're also the platting authority for their whole area. Um, they have a very quantifiable title, and most of the Kenai Peninsula doesn't have zoning unless it's a home rule city. Anchorage is entirely different and interesting.
They have what's called a unified development code, so it's one code that governs subdivisions and zoning. And it's their planning commission that acts on everything. So they don't have a planning board. It's actually planning commission that does all the differences there.
Every community's set up a little diff— sometimes there's little differences, sometimes there's big differences. I wouldn't say we're a big outlier on one side or the other for, you know, many things. But we could talk more about kind of specific ideas. Anchorage, for example, has a lot more— their commission acting on things has a lot more ability to utilize those, I guess, I guess qualitative factors as opposed to the quantitative ones we've talked tonight. But that might be a good idea for a work session as well.
And that's things we do try to do Like, for example, when we were doing our big road standard change— oh, that must have been 8 years ago now— we did significant research and presented the board and the assembly with what all the different requirements were for those different municipalities as well, to see where we are. Thank you. A segue on that, uh, to answer your, your question, we used to send 2 people from the planning board down in February to meeting. And it was usually in Anchorage where all the municipalities came together. And it was some great interface time that we got to see how they actually did things throughout the state.
And one of the big ones— and I was going to discuss this a little earlier and let it go— but a big one I heard come up multiple times. And they get a lot more rain in Anchorage and the bowl area. But we have snowmelt in the spring. But it was drainage, drainage, drainage. That was the biggest thing that they always discussed.
So maybe we could work it where we get a couple people from the board each year to go back to that February meeting, if they still have it. But that would answer your question, Eleanor, or I guess Miss Guthrie, wherever you are.
If I may, Madam Chair. Go ahead, please. I love that idea. Unfortunately, and I'm somewhat of a member of the organization now, that was run through the American Planning Association Alaska chapter. They've not had an annual conference since COVID We are doing our first one this year, and I'd say it's a mini, mini conference, but we're trying to get back on that, uh, that same path.
I also, I attended every single one of those trainings you're talking about. I found them very useful to just talk to other board members and commission members around the state and see exactly what they're dealing with as well.
Other comments?
Go ahead. Um, this one, uh, might be a little off topic, but I don't think too much, um, since it's going through and just went in front of planning. I guess I haven't taken a look at it to see if there's as much, but in the Regional Comprehensive Plan updates, are there any recommendations or areas that, you know, maybe we're expecting staff or the borough or otherwise to push us in different directions or potential changes down the line? Yes. Yes, there's some recommended changes in the comp plan to our subdivision code and our subdivision process.
And actually, our road plan that we did— oh, this is probably 3 or 4 years ago now. Mr. Pitney can speak to it— also had several, I'd say, moderate to significant changes with the subdivision code as well. So there have not been ordinances coming forward through those, but ultimately that is our intention, is to implement those planning efforts.
One of which is— sorry, if I may continue— one of those is what Miss Berman-Williams mentioned earlier about larger subdivisions ultimately being looked at for zoning as well, not just the subdivision process. That is in the comprehensive plan.
Well, I hope we'll see it soon.
Any other comments?
Go ahead, yeah. I, I guess the, the only— it, and it's much more of a comment. I, I do I personally feel like with the hazards and dangers aspects, the special standards, we do have more discretion than we've exercised. I think it's just a threshold of effort to exercise that. And I guess I'll say, personally, in some of these instances that have come up, I don't see the need to exercise that and haven't, but I do think I would question how much needs to change versus how many of these issues mostly have to do with us being, personal opinion, overly zoned as GU1, and that can cause a lot of use conflicts even in terms of like what we see in our opinion on a potential use of a property.
Right there with you. So if you, as you go contemplate— you're done with your slides, right? Okay. If, if as we, we cogitate and digest what we've talked about this evening, you have specific recommendations, concerns, or questions that you want to address at a future work session, you can tell me. I, I do have the capability of checking my Boards and Commissions email now with the new setup.
For a while I couldn't access it, but it's working now really well for me. Or you can talk to our clerk Or you can talk to Rocky. Um, yeah, and we can continue having conversations. We'll try to schedule work sessions, uh, if we have them after planning board meetings that look like they're going to be short. Axel, um, I just realized I had another question that I didn't get to yet.
Um, when we're talking about the instance of potentially like putting something back for additional information, if in our packet, for instance, in agency and utility review, there was an agency or utility that hadn't answered and we felt like that would be relevant information to us, would that be something we could have as, as a finding or to throw it back? Like, for instance, maybe in our hypothetical example there, we wanted DOT's opinion on how roads might be affected. Potentially, for sure. And I think the example you gave is a good example of when that would be appropriate. It really does have to be rooted in you having had some fact that was adduced that gives you a concern that there would be a special hazard created by the subdivision.
So if it's just that, you know, GVEA didn't comment on it, and you're like, man, I wonder what GVEA thinks about this. That's not really good enough. It's not a carte blanche to, you know, send it back and say, hey, we need more information. I need, you know, the street you grew up on and your mom's maiden name, password to your email. You don't get to ask for that.
But if you think there is some concern about the increased traffic impacts of that subdivision causing a specific hazard to children walking across the street to and from the school, absolutely asking for, you know, saying, hey, I'd love to hear what DOT has to say about this, could be part and parcel of that inquiry.
We had one a while ago where we didn't have spot elevations, and that was making people queasy. And we could have sent that back. And in fact, I think we did. Yeah, it was one of our great meetings. And I think that was related.
Specifically to water drainage concerns. Yeah, I think so. Yeah, it's great.
Anything else before we let people go home?
Hey, I appreciate everybody's hard work. I appreciate staff pulling together these slides. Um, I think it was a good conversation. We can keep having conversations if we want to.
But not every month. No, no thank you. Uh, the Planning Board work session meeting of November 18th, 2026 is adjourned at 8:32. Thanks everybody.
No audio detected at 1:39:20