Skip to main content

Fairbanks Borough: Administrative Hearing, 2026-11-19

Alaska News • • 41 min

Articles from this transcript

Fairbanks borough hearing officer drops two utility conditions from 17-lot merger

Fairbanks borough's Kellen Spillman dropped two utility easement conditions from a 17 lot merger near Little Harding Lake on the Richardson Highway.

Cover image for article: Fairbanks borough hearing officer drops two utility conditions from 17-lot merger

No audio detected at 0:00

No audio detected at 2:00

No audio detected at 4:00

No audio detected at 6:00

No audio detected at 6:40

No audio detected at 6:50

No audio detected at 7:00

No audio detected at 7:20

No audio detected at 9:20

No audio detected at 11:20

No audio detected at 13:20

No audio detected at 14:30

14:41
Kellen Spillman

We are ready in the chambers. Hi, good morning. Today is the 19th of November. It's 10 o'clock AM. I'd like to call the administrative hearing to order.

14:52
Kellen Spillman

My name is Kellen Spillman. I'm the Director of Community Planning. I will be acting as hearing officer today. This, uh, this hearing may include a number of items, including quick PLATS, grandfather rights, amnesty relief, and administrative variances. Public testimony will be requested as each of those items come up.

15:11
Kellen Spillman

Any action taken at this meeting or result of this meeting may be appealed. Appeal of hearing officer decisions must be submitted in writing to the borough clerk's office. Agenda and meeting audio are posted online at fnsb.gov/meetings.

15:28
Kellen Spillman

Okay, that moves us on to our quasi-judicial portion of the meeting today. We have 3 quick plats. If anyone wishes to participate in those items today, they must take an oath. I'm going to have the clerk administer a group oath, so anyone wishing to participate, please raise your hand. Madam Clerk, could you please read the oath?

15:50
Speaker A

Yes, thank you. I'm going to administer a group oath and take a roll call for your response. Everyone providing testimony under quasi-judicial hearings, please raise your right hand. Do you solemnly affirm that the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Zach Lee?

16:08
Speaker A

I do. Larry Bennett?

16:14
Speaker A

Terry Harriman? I do.

16:19
Speaker A

And your name, sir? John Brady. And you affirm the oath? You affirm the oath? Affirm the oath.

16:26
Kellen Spillman

Yes. Okay. Thank you. Ma'am, do you wish to participate today? Okay.

16:34
Kellen Spillman

Okay, that moves us on to our first item. Madam Clerk, could you please read the first item into the record?

16:43
Speaker A

RP-006-27 Shad Subdivision, a request by Bennett Engineering on behalf of Tony Hawkins and Erin Hawkins to vacate and relocate a public utility easement within Lot 3, Shad Subdivision. The property is located within the Northwest Quarter, Northeast Quarter, Section 14, Township 1 North, Range 2 West, Fairbanks Meridian on Nugget Loop. Staff contact: Zach Lee. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Mr. Bennett, you're acting as the representative, is that correct?

17:16
Kellen Spillman

If you could come forward, please.

17:24
Kellen Spillman

Why don't you try this table? And I saw you take the oath. And once you get settled there, Mr. Bennett, could you just state your name for the record? Yes, my name is F. Lawrence Bennett. Okay, thank you.

17:35
Kellen Spillman

For Bennett Engineering, yeah. Thank you, Mr. Bennett. And Mr. Lee, you're staff on this, correct? Correct. Okay, I saw you both take the oath.

17:44
Kellen Spillman

Uh, Mr. Lee, can we have a staff report please? Yes.

17:54
Zakariah Lee

Okay. All right. Thank you. So again, as previously stated, this request is just to vacate and relocate a public utility easement. And showing now is a 2026 aerial image of the property, which is highlighted in yellow here.

No audio detected at 18:00

18:10
Zakariah Lee

And this is a quick plat because this is a modification, elimination, or reservation of a public utility easement. The request has access on Nugget Loop, which is highlighted green in the graphic over there. And this benefits from applicability as the lots were legally created by plat number 86-91. There's no increase in the number of lots, and this does not create a new violation of the design and public improvement requirements of Title 17 or increase in nonconformity of any lot under this or any other FNSB title. Therefore, it's exempt from the design and public improvement requirements of Title 17.

18:47
Zakariah Lee

And here's a closer look at what exactly is changing here. Uh, in red is the PUE being vacated, and in blue is the new proposed PUE.

19:01
Zakariah Lee

We have 7 conditions showing now. Uh, one of those conditions is just revising the PUE graphic. As you can see here, it slightly encroaches into the northern lot boundary. So the final plat will fix that graphic. And then we also have a condition adjusting the flood note due to the changing flood rate insurance maps.

No audio detected at 19:10

19:29
Zakariah Lee

With the conditions and the findings of fact, staff is recommending approval of the subdivision, and that concludes my staff report. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Uh, Mr. Bennett, do you have any questions for Mr. Lee today? I have none, thank you.

19:43
Kellen Spillman

Mr. Lee, my only question, and I didn't see it listed on the plat, how wide is the PUE? Uh, let's see.

20:06
Zakariah Lee

Oops, sorry, sorry, one moment please.

20:13
Kellen Spillman

And I'd be happy to defer this to the applicant as well.

20:23
Zakariah Lee

Yes, unfortunately, I do think I have to defer to the applicant's. Request. Okay,. Thank you.

20:30
Kellen Spillman

Okay, Mr. Bennett, I saw you take the oath. Uh, do you have anything you would like to add to your request? Uh, not really. I just want to thank Zach for a good review. I think it's pretty straightforward.

20:41
F. Lawrence Bennett

Golden Valley moved to poll, And so Golden Valley actually changed their easement, and this follows that. So it basically coordinates with all that's already been done. OK. Same question back to you. How wide is the new PUE?

20:55
Kellen Spillman

The easement itself is 30 feet. 30 Feet? Yes. The easement is 30 feet. Did I understand you correctly?

21:03
F. Lawrence Bennett

OK. Could you please note that on the final plat? Boy, it should be there. We'll make sure it is if it's not. Yeah. Let me look one more time.

21:17
Zakariah Lee

Okay, um, Mr. Hearing Officer, the note number 1 does state that the purpose of this reply is to revise the location of the 30-foot-wide utility easement. Got it. Right, we can draw that on the plat as well. Sure.

No audio detected at 21:20

21:34
Kellen Spillman

Okay,. Sure. Okay. Okay, thank you. Um, I don't have any further questions for you.

21:39
Kellen Spillman

Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to testify on this item? There is no one signed up. Does anyone in the chambers wish to testify on this item? Seeing none, I'd like to close public hearing.

21:51
Kellen Spillman

This appears to be a very simple relocation of a public utility easement. All utility companies were afforded an offer— an opportunity to comment. We received comments from GVEA, and they concurred with the modification. As such, I would like to approve this request with 7 conditions, adopting the staff report and findings of fact A through C. A final plat must be prepared by a registered land surveyor and submitted to the Community Planning Department within 24 months, or preliminary approval becomes void. As with any of our items, this is appealable.

22:26
Kellen Spillman

It must be done so in writing within 10 working days to the Borough Clerk's Office. Appeal forms and additional information are can be obtained through the Borough Clerk's Office. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Bennett. Thank you.

22:40
Speaker A

Madam Clerk, could you please read the next item into the record? SD008-27, Quist Subdivision, a request by Bredes LLC on behalf of Julia Quist to subdivide Tract G, Rosie Creek Subdivision, a total of approximately 154.66 acres into two tracts of approximately 114.67 acres and 40.00 acres. The property is located within Section 11, Township 2 South, Range 3 West, Fairbanks Meridian, on Moose Creek Trail. Staff contact is Zach Lee. Thank you, Madam Clerk.

23:24
Kellen Spillman

Let's see, Mr. Brady, your staff on this, could you come forward?

23:29
Kellen Spillman

Please. And just for the record, I saw Mr. Brady take the oath. Could you please state your name for the record? John Brady. Okay.

23:36
Kellen Spillman

Mr. Lee, your staff on this, correct? Correct. Can we have a staff report please, Mr. Lee? Yes.

23:49
Zakariah Lee

Okay, thank you. So again, as previously stated, this is a request to subdivide one large tract into two. Showing now is a 2026 aerial image of the property and the surrounding area.

No audio detected at 23:50

24:05
Zakariah Lee

And this qualifies as a quick plat because this is a subdivision resulting in four or fewer tracts or lots meeting the access standards of 1756. The subdivision is proposing to turn the parent lot, which is outlined in red, into two lots as shown here. The subdivision has legal access via Rosie Creek Trail, which is a right-of-way created by the parent plat 81-66. And this request is using the large lot exemption to road construction under FNSBC 1756.065A. And that section of code exempts lots 20 acres or larger, do not require constructed road access to or within the subdivision.

No audio detected at 24:10

24:48
Zakariah Lee

It also states the applicant is required to demonstrate to the borough engineer that the proposed access can be constructed practically and economically within the legal access. Uh, this is a previously approved right of way created by a platting action, and based on that, as well as the information provided by the applicant's registered professional on the preliminary plat, that demonstrates practical and economic access. Sorry. So, we have 5 conditions showing now. Condition number 3, amending the flood note.

25:28
Zakariah Lee

With those conditions and the findings of fact, staff is recommending approval of this sub-replat, and that concludes my staff report. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Uh, Mr. Brady, any questions for Mr. Lee today? None at the moment. Thank you very much, Zach, for the, uh, going through this process.

25:42
Kellen Spillman

This one was interesting because it's agricultural, so we had some back and forth through the application process, and I really appreciate—. If you don't mind, let me just ask Mr. Lee some questions, and then I'll get to your testimony, if that's OK. Thank you, sir. Yeah, Mr. Lee, my only question for you— this portion of Rosie Creek Trail is— there's a road there. It just doesn't meet borough standards.

26:08
Kellen Spillman

Is my understanding correct? That is correct, yes. OK. That concludes my questions. And sorry to cut you off there, Mr. Brady. Go ahead with your testimony.

26:18
John Brady

Yeah, um, yeah, there was, uh, because this is agricultural, we did have to go through the DNR approval process, and I believe that was satisfied for both DNR and the borough. And the only question I had, uh, if— is it time for questions? Sure, I can answer only limited questions as the hearing officer, but— I. Understood. We kind of breezed through the 7 recommendations, or I can't remember how many there were.

No audio detected at 26:20

26:53
Kellen Spillman

Would you mind pulling that back up? 5 Recommendations is what I'm showing.

27:04
Kellen Spillman

Number 4, the BFE, would be the only one that I would have some questions on for, for staff, and maybe that's something that we can do after this process, this administrative hearing. But that's, that's the one area I would like a little bit more clarification on. Yeah, and I guess, for the record, I can, I could work with you on that. We have new revised flood insurance rate maps that were just passed by the Assembly, and they go into effect January 8th, 2027, and most of the BFEs in the borough changed, usually for the better. But I'm happy to work with you on that.

27:35
Kellen Spillman

Perfect. Thank you. Okay, um, Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up? Well, let's see, Mr. Luedtke, any questions for Mr. Brady? No questions from staff.

27:44
Kellen Spillman

I don't think I have any questions for you. Well, actually, let me ask you the same question. Uh, condition of the road going to the parcels, it's passable, just not borough standards, is that correct? That is correct, as far as I— let me pull up. I'm looking— I did several cross-sections for the borough engineer.

28:04
John Brady

To satisfy that a road could potentially be built in that right-of-way. And, uh, I believe that it is just outside of borough standards as far as width goes, um, but it can be built in the right-of-way. There is room. Okay, I think that's good enough. Okay, thank you, Mr. Brady.

28:24
Kellen Spillman

Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to testify? No one has signed up. Okay, as such, I'd like to close public testimony. Well, anyone in the chambers? Seeing none, I'd like to co-close public testimony.

28:36
Kellen Spillman

Again, relatively simple 1 into 2 request meets all of the requirements of Title 17. The applicant proved that the road could be constructed in the proposed right-of-way. As such, I'd like to approve this recommend— this request with 5 conditions: adopting the staff report and findings of fact A through D. A final plat must be prepared by a registered land surveyor and submitted to the community planning department within 24 months, or preliminary approval becomes void. As with any of our items, this is appealable. It must be done so in writing to the borough clerk's office within 10 working days of the decision.

No audio detected at 28:40

29:13
Kellen Spillman

Appeal forms may be obtained through the borough clerk's office. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Brady. Madam Clerk, could we please— could you please read the next item into the record? Yes.

29:24
Speaker A

SD-004-27, Keyhole Subdivision, a reconsideration of SD-004- -27 Keyhole Subdivision, a request by Bendit Engineering on behalf of Terry Wayne Harriman to vacate the interior lot lines between government lots 4, 57 through 64, and 67 through 74, Section 11, Township 6 South, Range 4 East, Fairbanks Meridian, creating one lot of approximately 37.98 acres. The property is located within the Northwest Quarter, Section 11, Township 6 South, Range 4 East, Fairbanks Meridian on the Richardson Highway. The request was originally approved by the administrative hearing officer at the October 22nd, 2026 administrative hearing. Staff contact, Zach Lee. Okay, Mr. Lee, your staff, and let's see, Mr. Bennett and Mr. Harriman, applicant and representative, if you could come forward to the table, please.

No audio detected at 29:30

30:36
Kellen Spillman

Okay, I did see both of you take the oath, but if you just state your names for the record one more time. My name is F. Lawrence Bennett from Bennett Engineering. Terry Harriman. Okay, thank you. Mr. Leake, we have a staff report, please.

30:49
30:53
Kellen Spillman

Well, actually, sorry, one more. Before we get there, I do just want to put on the record that I have had several conversations with Mr. Harriman at the counter. I don't believe any of that raises to the threshold of conflict of interest. Most of them were after the platting action interpreting code. I've also had several additional conversations with Mr. Harriman Alderman about other code enforcement and zoning matters, but I want to put them on the record as ex parte communication.

31:29
Kellen Spillman

But again, none of which I believe, uh, come to the degree of conflict of interest. Uh, Mr. Lee, could you continue with your staff report?

31:41
Zakariah Lee

Yes. So again, as previously stated, this is a request, a request replatting 17 lots into one. And showing now is a 2026 aerial image of the property and the surrounding area. And this is a quick plat because this is a movement or elimination of lot lines resulting in no more than 4 lots. Showing in red are the lot lines being vacated, resulting in 1 lot as shown in blue.

No audio detected at 31:50

32:04
Zakariah Lee

And this request has access via the Richardson Highway, which is highlighted in green. This request also benefits from applicability as the lots were legally created by federal patent number 50-2008-0232.

32:19
Zakariah Lee

There's no increase in the number of lots, and this does not create new violation of the design public improvement requirements of Title 17, nor does it increase the nonconformity of any lot under this or any other FNSB title. Therefore, it is exempt from the design and public improvement requirements of Title 17.

32:39
Zakariah Lee

All right, and staff is currently recommending— so this was approved at the previous administrative hearing with 9 conditions. However, because this request benefits from applicability, we are recommending removal of conditions number 2 and 3. Uh, condition number 2 is requesting 4 standard utility notes. Condition number 3 is requesting a 30-foot PUE north of the— on the— sorry, on the southern property boundary, as well as a 30-foot PUE on the northern property boundary. And we're— recommending removal of these conditions as public utility easements and the reservation thereof fall under 1756.

No audio detected at 32:40

33:21
Zakariah Lee

And because this request benefits from applicability, we cannot— it's exempt from the design and public improvement requirements of 1756.

33:32
Zakariah Lee

So, with the 2 conditions removed, resulting in 7 total conditions, we are recommending approval. And that concludes my staff report. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Mr. Bennett or Mr. Harriman, do you have any questions for Mr. Lee today? I do have a question.

33:49
Terry Wayne Harriman

Okay. I have one question about the GVEA having 30 days. Is that— do they continue to have 30 days from this point forward? Because I'm trying to get this done before the end of the year, and if 30 days presses into late December, that will— this won't be done by the end of the year. Does GBEA have future comment on this project?

No audio detected at 34:00

34:14
Zakariah Lee

So this is just a removal of the two initial conditions. I'd say it's 30 days from the prior approval date, or 30 days from whenever Mr. Bennett has sent it out for their review, at least. So I don't know if Mr. Bennett has already sent it out for review to them. And if they have— if it has been, then I'd say we're well within that 30-day timeframe.

34:47
Terry Wayne Harriman

Yeah, I'm not sure what the answer to my question is. Does GVA have the right to add these back in at some point if they decided to try to put them in? In other words, if somebody in the offices over there at GVA decides they want to press the issue to put easements in, which I don't anticipate they do, I want to know if there's a 30-day clock and when it, when it ends. As Hearing Officer, I'm not permitted to answer questions during the setting. Mr. Lee, if you could maybe take one more attempt to answer the question.

No audio detected at 35:00

35:20
Zakariah Lee

So if I'm understanding correctly, you're asking if GVEA can press the issue about these easements? And the answer is no, uh, we cannot condition that they— we cannot condition these easements, so it can't happen. The only condition that's relevant to GVEA is that they've had a chance to at least look at it, and that can be solved with just Mr. Bennett here sending out an email today if he has, and then that 30-day clock will immediately begin. If he has already sent that out, then even better. Okay, thank you.

No audio detected at 35:30

No audio detected at 35:40

36:04
F. Lawrence Bennett

Are there any additional questions for Mr. Lee? Just in response to that, Golden Valley has seen it for sure as a preliminary plan, but I'm not sure if that begins the process or not. We will act on this very quickly after today. I think I have a solution. Yeah.

36:21
Kellen Spillman

Okay, uh, Mr. Lee, uh, I'm going to try to phrase this in the form of a question just to kind of tie everything together. So is it correct that this was approved at the last administrative hearing? Um, the issue was the placement of utility easements. That is—. Let me, let me just finish.

36:42
Kellen Spillman

At the time, it appeared, uh, the applicant's representative didn't have issues with the utility easements. But since then, it's came to your attention that the applicant had issues with the utility easements, and in the matter of a quick plat, especially with the dissolution of lot lines, it's not specifically required in title that PUEs can be dedicated as an exaction of the subdivision process. That is correct, yes. Okay, got it. I don't think I have any questions for you.

37:18
F. Lawrence Bennett

So I'm going to now turn the time over to the applicant and the applicant's representative. First of all, again, thank you for the, for a good staff report. I know this has been through a few rounds and that's fine. Um, there, there is one utility easement already on the west side. We're working on that.

37:36
F. Lawrence Bennett

It comes from an old patent and Golden Valley is helping me put that together. So that doesn't appear at this point, but when it says all easements of record will appear that will be on the final plat. I guess that's all I— the only comment I would have. We're working on a temporary benchmark for elevation, and that'll be on the final plat as well, which is one of the conditions here. So, yeah.

38:00
Kellen Spillman

Okay. Mr. Harriman, is there anything you'd like to add to your request? I have nothing to add except for thank you. Thanks, Zach. Okay.

38:08
Kellen Spillman

Thank you both for your testimony. Mr. Lee, do you have any questions? No questions from staff. I don't believe I have— well, I have one question.

38:18
Kellen Spillman

Uh, would it be satisfactory if the GVEA and DOT comment period is changed to 15 days? Great idea. Yeah,. Sure, I guess. Sure.

38:31
Kellen Spillman

Yeah. Okay, thank you. No further questions. They're expecting it anyway, so that'll be fine. Madam Clerk, has anyone signed up to testify on this item?

38:41
Kellen Spillman

No one has signed up. Anyone in the chambers wish to testify? Seeing none, I'd like to close public testimony on this item. As previously mentioned, this is a reconsideration of a previously approved item, Keyhole Subdivision. As such, I would like to amend the original action by approving this request with previous conditions 1 through— previous conditions number 1, amending from 30 days to 15 days for GVEA and DOT to comment on the final plat, and previously approved conditions 4 through 9.

39:27
Kellen Spillman

This would specifically remove originally approved conditions number 2 and number 3 that were approved at the October 22nd, 2026 administrative hearing. Uh, I would also like to adopt the memorandum prepared by Mr. Lee. Staff report and findings of fact A through D is a part of this record. A final plat must be prepared by a registered land surveyor and submitted to the community planning department within 24 months, or preliminary approval becomes void. As with our item, any of our items, this decision is appealable.

40:03
Kellen Spillman

Appeals must be submitted within 10 business days to the clerk's office. More information and forms are available through the clerk's office. Thank you, Mr. Lee. Thank you, Mr. Bennett. Thank you, Mr. Harriman.

40:14
Kellen Spillman

This concludes this request. Thank you, sir. Madam Clerk, I believe this concludes our agenda. Could you confirm, please? Yes, confirmed.

40:23
Kellen Spillman

Okay, as such, I would like to adjourn the administrative hearing at 10:25 AM. Thank you, everyone.

No audio detected at 40:40