Frame from "MISC-20260519-1300" · Photo source
Alaska Legislature fails to override veto of pension bill
The Alaska Legislature failed Tuesday to override the governor's veto of a bill that would have restored a defined benefit pension option for public employees and teachers.
The override attempt fell seven votes short of the required two-thirds majority. The joint session voted 33-27 in favor of overriding the veto, but 40 votes were needed to succeed.
House Bill 78 would have given employees in the Public Employees Retirement System and the Teachers Retirement System a choice between a defined benefit pension and the current defined contribution retirement plan. The joint session was called under Article 2, Section 16 of the Alaska Constitution for the sole purpose of considering the veto.
Supporters said the bill was necessary to address Alaska's workforce crisis. They cited high turnover rates among teachers and state troopers.
Rep. Chuck Kopp of Anchorage said teacher turnover in Alaska stands at 29 percent, the highest in the nation. He said the Department of Public Safety has 80 vacancies in sworn positions. Rookie troopers who complete the Public Safety Academy at a cost of over $200,000 often leave after 18 months for states that offer pensions. More than 70 percent of police officers who leave Alaska go to states that offer pensions, he said.
"House Bill 78 is not a retirement bill, Mr. President," Kopp said. "It is a workforce bill, and it is a resource development bill."
Sen. Bill Wielechowski of Anchorage said Alaska has the worst retirement system in the nation because it is the only state where public employees receive neither Social Security nor a pension.
"We have the worst retirement system in the nation. The absolute worst," Wielechowski said. "Why are we the worst? Because we are the only state in the entire country where our public employees get no Social Security and get no pension."
Opponents raised concerns about potential costs to the state. Sen. Bert Stedman of Sitka said the bill would shift costs from municipalities to the state. In fiscal year 2030, the shift would amount to approximately $22 million. Non-state employers' contributions toward the unfunded liability would decrease from $173 million to $151 million under the bill, with the state covering the difference.
Stedman disputed claims that Alaska has a poor retirement system. He said Alaska ranks around 10th or 11th in the country for retirement benefits.
"We have one of the richest retirement systems in the country, not the worst," Stedman said. "Probably around 10th or 11th in the entire country."
Rep. Will Stapp of Fairbanks said the bill would cost more than the current system because it offers better benefits. He said the state would bear the additional costs if the plan required increased employer contributions.
"Better benefits cost more money, Mr. President," Stapp said. "And this bill is probably a better benefit than the current 401 for a lot of employees, but just know the reason it is is because it is going to cost more money."
The bill included risk-sharing provisions designed to prevent unfunded liabilities. If the plan fell below 90 percent funded, employee and employer contributions would increase.
The House voted 21-19 in favor of the override. The Senate voted 12-8 in favor. The combined total of 33 votes fell short of the 40 needed.
"By a vote of 33 yeas and 27 nays, the joint legislative session has failed to override the governor's veto on House Bill 78," Senate President Gary Stevens said.
The failure of the override means Alaska will continue operating under its current defined contribution retirement system for public employees and teachers. The state established the system in 2006 when it closed its previous defined benefit pension plan to new employees.
What did you make of this story? (no account needed)
Made by our human newsroom with AI. How humans and AI work here · Grow with our newsroom · Transcript byLucas Brown
Keep Alaska News free for everyone.
No paywall, ever. Members pay so everyone can read the meetings and records Alaska News covers.
Get Alaska News in your inbox
Create your free account and get the day’s top stories around 6 each morning, in a few minutes’ read.
Top stories, around 6 each morning.
Stories on what you follow, on Sundays.
This article is based on a public meeting of Alaska State Legislature — MISC-20260519-1300.
Earlier in this story
Dunleavy vetoes public pension bill, leaving override as long shot
Gov. Mike Dunleavy vetoed House Bill 78 on Monday, blocking a bill that would have reopened a defined benefit pension option for Alaska public employees and teachers.
The veto came after the Legislature failed to advance a natural gas pipeline bill Dunleavy had sought. The governor had signaled he would consider signing the pension bill as part of a broader agreement that included his gas line legislation. Lawmakers did not pass it in the form or on the timeline he wanted, and the pension veto followed.
The bill survives only if lawmakers override. The Legislature scheduled a joint session for 1 pm Tuesday to take it up, and an override takes 40 votes from the 60-member Legislature. HB 78 passed the Senate 12-8 and the House 21-19 in late April, a combined 33 votes in favor. If those coalitions hold, the override falls seven votes short.
The bill would have let certain public employees and teachers choose between Alaska's existing defined contribution retirement plans and a defined benefit pension. Under a defined benefit plan, a retiree receives a guaranteed monthly payment based on salary and years of service, with the employer carrying the investment risk. It covered the Public Employees' Retirement System and the Teachers' Retirement System, and gave eligible employees a one-time election to move into the new tier.
Dunleavy wrote in his veto letter that he shares the Legislature's goal of strengthening recruitment and retention in Alaska's public workforce, but that the bill carried unresolved legal, tax, administrative and fiscal problems. Most importantly, he wrote, it would "return long-term investment, actuarial, and unfunded liability risk to the State." Pension obligations run for decades, he added, and the full cost might not surface until years after enactment.
He also tied the veto to the state's revenue debate, writing that a Legislature intending to increase long-term spending obligations has to be prepared to support the long-term revenue to pay for them, through resource development and private-sector growth. Any return to a defined benefit system, he wrote, has to be legally sound, fiscally responsible, administrable, compliant with federal tax law and backed by a durable way to pay for it. HB 78, in his judgment, did not meet that standard.
Supporters have framed the bill as a recruitment and retention tool for public workers, including teachers and public safety employees. Alaska closed its previous defined benefit system to new hires after June 30, 2006, moving new public employees and teachers into defined contribution plans.
The fiscal notes attached to the bill projected what it would cost to run. A Department of Administration note for the Senate Labor and Commerce version put operating costs at about $1.1 million in fiscal 2027 and about $771,200 a year from fiscal 2029 through 2032 for the Division of Retirement and Benefits. A separate 2025 note, citing the state's consulting actuary, projected a net $467 million increase in additional state contributions to the two retirement systems from fiscal 2027 through 2039, assuming future experience matched actuarial assumptions.
Alaska Senate passes bill restoring defined benefit pensions for public workers
The Alaska Senate passed legislation Wednesday to restore a defined benefit pension plan for public employees, marking the first time in 20 years that such a measure cleared both chambers of the Legislature.
House Bill 78 passed the Senate on a 12-8 vote and received House concurrence the following day, sending it to Governor Mike Dunleavy for his signature or veto. The bill would allow state workers, teachers, and municipal employees to choose between a defined benefit pension and the existing defined contribution plan starting July 1, 2027.
"This was the 34th attempt over the last 20 years, and so we are pleased that it was successful, and it was designed to be a very modest and yet secure pension for retirement," said Senator Cathy Giessel, chair of the Senate Resources Committee.
Alaska closed its previous defined benefit pension plans in 2006, moving all new public employees into defined contribution retirement accounts similar to 401(k) plans. Supporters of the change said the state needed to restore pensions to recruit and retain workers in competition with other states and the private sector.
The Senate added floor amendments that moderated the original House version. One amendment gave non-state employers the option to participate in the new pension system rather than requiring it. Another pushed the effective date to July 2027 to give the Division of Retirement and Benefits time to write regulations.
"The effective date has moved out now to July 1st, 2027, and that was in deference to the Division of Retirement and Benefits, who said they would need some time to write the regulations," Giessel said.
The Senate set the employer contribution rate at 22.5 percent through a floor amendment. Non-state employers including municipalities and school districts can opt out of the new system if they choose.
Senator Jesse Kiehl said the bill represents a material improvement for public sector recruitment and service delivery across Alaska.
"This bill really moves the needle. There are no perfect solutions to any complicated problem, but this is a material difference," Kiehl said. "This will make it worlds better and it will genuinely help the public sector, both the state and the cities and the school districts deliver the services Alaskans need more efficiently, more effectively."
The bill gives current employees a 180-day window to opt into the defined benefit plan. New hires would choose between the pension and the defined contribution plan when they start work.
Senate President Gary Stevens said restoring defined benefit pensions had been a top priority for the Senate majority caucus and the House majority for the past four years.
The measure now awaits action from Dunleavy, who has not publicly stated whether he will sign or veto the bill. Kiehl said he hoped the governor would sign it, joking that he would loan Dunleavy a pen in any color except red.
If signed, the Division of Retirement and Benefits will spend the next 14 months developing regulations to implement the new pension option before it takes effect in July 2027.
Alaska House Revives Defined Benefit Pensions in Narrow 21-19 Vote
Alaska House voted 21-19 to restore defined benefit pensions for public employees, citing a 30 percent teacher turnover rate and $140 million in annual overtime costs.
Read this story
The Alaska House of Representatives voted Tuesday to restore defined benefit pensions for public employees, ending a two-decade experiment with defined contribution-only retirement that lawmakers said fueled massive workforce turnover.
The House concurred 21-19 with Senate changes to House Bill 78, which creates a new pension tier for state and municipal workers hired after the effective date. The Senate amendments made the plan more fiscally conservative but added complexity that some members said raised unanswered questions.
The bill now heads to the governor without an effective date clause, which failed 21-19. That means the measure takes effect 90 days after the governor signs it, rather than the delayed January 2027 start the Senate had proposed.
The Senate increased the employer contribution rate for municipalities from 22 percent to 22.5 percent and removed the 12 percent cap on employee contributions. The changes also gave municipalities a six-month window to opt out of the new pension system, a provision that drew sharp criticism from members who said it would create inequities between communities.
"The Senate made this bill structurally more conservative and stronger," the bill's sponsor said. The uncapped employee contribution means workers would pay whatever share is needed to keep the plan funded at 90 percent or higher, though actuaries said that scenario is unlikely.
Opponents warned the state is repeating the mistakes that led to a $7 billion unfunded liability in the early 2000s. "We started out on our existing plan that was closed in 2006 with $15 billion total liabilities," one representative said. "That amount of money today, that liability on the closed plan is over $25 billion."
The debate stretched more than two hours as members wrestled with the fiscal implications and procedural mechanics. Several representatives said they lacked time to consult with school districts and municipalities about the opt-out provision, which locks communities into their choice permanently.
"This plan, as it comes back, costs $467 million over the next 10 years and more," one member said, questioning whether projected savings would offset the additional budget costs.
Supporters said the current system has failed Alaska. The state has the highest teacher turnover rate in the nation at 30 percent, and 72 percent of departing state troopers leave for states offering pensions. Vacancy-driven overtime costs the state $140 million annually.
"I am sick and tired of listening to people in public safety talk about the number of folks that went through academy with them that are gone in four years, five years, because they have been poached by communities out of our state who offer a pension system," one representative said.
The Senate amendments included a freeze provision for employees who move between employers with different retirement systems. If a worker moves from a municipality offering the defined benefit plan to one that opted out, their pension accrual freezes and they begin accruing defined contribution benefits instead. Several members questioned whether this constitutes a benefit diminishment prohibited by the state constitution.
The bill keeps the existing defined contribution plan alive. Employees can choose between the two systems, and those who select the defined benefit option can switch to defined contribution before they vest at five years. The conversion uses an actuarial formula that some members said penalizes workers who change their minds.
Municipalities will have from January 1 through June 30, 2027, to decide whether to participate. Employees then have another six months to elect their retirement option. For municipalities that opt in, the employer contribution rises to 22.5 percent. Those that opt out stay at 22 percent and offer only defined contribution plans.
The bill also addresses non-occupational disability benefits, which the current system lacks. Under the new plan, employees who suffer cancer, stroke, or heart attack off the job would retain healthcare coverage and higher income replacement than the current 40 percent.
The Alaska Railroad Corporation operates a legacy defined benefit pension with 1,150 members that is 96 percent funded, supporters noted, demonstrating that pensions can remain solvent with proper management. The new plan includes multiple safeguards the railroad system lacks, including shared risk between employers and employees.
Critics said the changes shift risk onto employees through uncapped contributions and onto municipalities through higher rates, while the state still bears constitutional obligations it cannot reduce. "Once we make this decision, we cannot change it," one member said. "Something is going to give."
The vote fell largely along caucus lines, with the bipartisan majority supporting concurrence and most minority members opposing. The measure now awaits action from the governor's office.
Senate advances pension bill without updated actuarial analysis
Alaska Senate advanced a major pension overhaul allowing public employees to choose between retirement plan types, but without an updated actuarial analysis of the final bill version.
Read this story
The Alaska Senate advanced a major retirement system overhaul to third reading Tuesday without an updated actuarial analysis of the final bill, relying instead on a legal opinion that last year's analysis meets statutory requirements.
The Senate Finance Committee substitute for House Bill 78 allows certain public employees to choose between defined benefit and defined contribution retirement plans. The bill moved forward after legal counsel ruled that a 2025 actuarial analysis satisfied statutory requirements, even though the final version differs substantially from the version analyzed.
House Bill 78 was introduced in January 2025 to establish a defined benefit retirement option for certain public employees. Alaska's existing defined benefit pension program owes approximately $7 billion in unfunded liabilities and was discontinued in 2006. The bill passed the House on May 12, 2025, and advanced through the Senate Labor and Commerce Committee before reaching Senate Finance. The Senate Finance Committee adopted a committee substitute on April 25, 2026, and advanced it to the Senate floor with a do-pass recommendation.
A senator raised the statutory requirement during floor debate. "Before a bill which would have an effect on the retirement systems of the state is reported to the Rules Committee, there shall be attached to the bill an analysis of the long-term and short-term costs of the state if the bill is adopted, as well as the impact of the bill on the actuarial soundness of the fund," the senator said, reading from Alaska Statute 24.08.036. He withdrew his objection after placing the statute on the record.
A senator noted that legal counsel had issued an opinion allowing the bill to proceed. "We have a letter from our attorneys that should be made available to you, really in consultation with our legal department, that says that we can continue even though we don't have all of the information we want," the senator said.
Another senator said the legal opinion, dated April 23, 2026, concluded that analyses currently attached to the bill are sufficient to meet statutory requirements. The opinion was issued by Megan Wallace, chief counsel of Legislative Legal Services.
A senator expressed concern about the procedural approach while acknowledging the legal opinion's validity. "The concern is always in the past we've wanted the actuarial analysis done by the administration on the final version of the bill. Because as we all know, the initial version of the bill or any version in between the final version could be substantially different, including even title changes," the senator said.
The senator said the literal interpretation of the statute supports proceeding with the existing analysis but suggested future legislators may need to clarify the law. "Because the intent is we've always used for the last 20-some years as we've dealt with this issue, it's the last version of the bill. But with this interpretation, we do meet the actuarial analysis requirement for the discussion to go on. Therefore, go ahead and remove my objection to the adoption," the senator said.
The Finance Committee substitute increases the employer contribution rate from 22 percent to 24 percent for non-state Public Employees Retirement System employers who opt into the defined benefit plan. Employers have three months from the bill's effective date to decide whether to participate. If they opt in, employees have the following three months to elect defined benefits or remain in defined contributions.
The substitute also removes the 12 percent compensation cap for Public Employees Retirement System and Teachers Retirement System employees. It adds a requirement that employees who reach normal retirement age with at least 10 years of service, but fewer than 20 or 25 years, must be active in the system for at least 12 months immediately before applying for retirement to receive medical benefits.
The Senate Finance Committee reported the bill with a do-pass recommendation from Senators Olson and Keele, a do-not-pass recommendation from Senators Steadman, Kaufman, and Cronk, a no-recommendation from Senator Hoffman, and an amend recommendation from Senator Merrick.
The bill will appear on the Senate's next legislative calendar for third reading.
Senate Finance advances pension bill with municipal opt-in provision
The Senate Finance Committee advanced a pension bill on April 24 that lets municipalities choose whether to pay higher rates for the new plan.
Read this story
The Alaska Senate Finance Committee voted 5-2 on April 24 to advance a bill creating a new defined benefit pension option for public employees, but only after adopting an amendment that lets municipalities choose whether to participate.
The committee approved House Bill 78 with an amendment requiring non-state employers to decide between July 1 and Sept. 30, 2026, whether to offer the new pension tier to their employees. The change came after testimony from local government leaders who said the bill's proposed increase in the employer contribution cap from 22 percent to 24 percent would strain local budgets already facing deficits and rising costs.
The bill creates a new defined benefit retirement tier and allows certain current employees in the defined contribution system to convert to the new pension plan. Alaska closed its pension system to new hires in 2006 and moved to defined contribution accounts. Supporters say the change is needed to recruit and retain teachers, troopers and other public workers who now leave Alaska for states offering traditional pensions.
Several city managers and mayors testified that the proposed increase in the employer contribution cap would create significant budget pressures.
John Leach, municipal administrator for Sitka, said the increase would cost his community between $400,000 and $500,000 annually. Sitka entered budget planning with a $900,000 deficit and already eliminated two positions to close the gap.
"A cap increase of this magnitude would force us to cut four to five additional positions from a workforce already operating below minimum staffing levels," Leach said.
Beth Weldon, mayor of Juneau, said the change would cost her city roughly $1 million per year and the school district another $300,000. She asked the committee to preserve the existing 22 percent cap that has been in place since 2006.
"That framework grew out of difficult decisions made in 2005 and 2006, when the Legislature closed the defined benefit system to new hires," Weldon said. "Local governments across Alaska, including Juneau, have planned their budgets for nearly two decades based on the 22 percent employer cap."
Weldon said Juneau supports creating a defined benefit option to help recruit and retain employees, but asked that legacy costs remain a state responsibility. She said the city would accept a higher cap for the new tier only if existing tiers remain at 22 percent.
Nils Andreassen, executive director of the Alaska Municipal League, said housing authorities would pay $600,000 more statewide under the amendment, and school districts would face $7 million in additional costs. He said some employers would have to reduce health insurance benefits or cut positions to absorb the increase.
"The only way to take into account the condition of employers and the variability is to give them choice," Andreassen said.
Lori Strickland, city manager of Bethel, said increasing the employer contribution rate while other retirement changes are being considered makes it difficult for municipalities to understand and plan for long-term financial impacts. She asked the Legislature to provide municipalities flexibility to opt in or out based on their specific needs.
John Hargis, superintendent of the Lower Yukon School District, testified in support of the underlying bill. He said rural Alaska faces constant teacher turnover because the state cannot compete with other states offering pensions.
"Since the pension was eliminated in 2006, we have seen a consistent pattern. Educators come for a few years and then they leave, and when we ask why, the answer is clear. Alaska is not competitive for a long-term career without a defined benefit," Hargis said.
He said hundreds of teaching positions remain unfilled statewide. The lack of a pension makes it difficult to attract experienced educators to remote communities.
The committee adopted Amendment 1, sponsored by Sen. Bert Stedman, which requires non-state employers to decide between July 1 and Sept. 30, 2026, whether to offer the new defined benefit plan to their employees. Employers who opt in would contribute at a rate of 24 percent of base salaries for employees who participate in the new plan.
Employees of participating employers would have from Oct. 1, 2026, to Jan. 1, 2027, to decide whether to convert to the defined benefit plan. State employees currently in the defined contribution plan would have from July 1, 2026, to Jan. 1, 2027, to make that decision.
Sen. Lyman Hoffman, who co-chairs the committee, said the opt-in approach gives municipalities flexibility to decide whether they can afford the additional benefits.
"By opting in, I think it reverses the role so that it gives much more flexibility for those communities to make this decision whether or not they can actually afford the additional benefits that are being offered to their employees," Hoffman said.
Sen. Jesse Kiehl objected to the amendment. He raised concerns about how the opt-in structure would work for public safety employees who move between state and municipal employers.
"How would this work for a state trooper who is being recruited by their local municipality, but that municipality has opted out?" Kiehl asked.
Kiehl maintained his objection and forced a roll call vote. The committee voted 5-2 to adopt the amendment. Sens. Cronk, Kaufman, Hoffman, Olson and Stedman voted yes. Sens. Kiehl and Merrick voted no.
Before the final vote on the amended bill, Stedman noted that state statute requires an analysis of long-term and short-term costs to the state and the impact on the actuarial soundness of the fund before a bill affecting retirement systems is reported to the Rules Committee.
Sen. Mike Kaufman raised concerns about the long-term obligations the bill creates.
"It puts a framework into statute that future legislators can incrementally sweeten up because of political pressure to make the system more beneficial for the recipients," Kaufman said. "That is a big hazard that is easy to fall into."
Kaufman said the bill creates guaranteed payments without guaranteed income and noted that another bill, Senate Bill 55, directly addresses the retirement gap for public employees.
The committee then voted 5-2 to advance the amended bill to the Senate Rules Committee. Sens. Kiehl, Merrick, Hoffman, Olson and Stedman voted yes. Sens. Cronk and Kaufman voted no.
According to committee discussion, the state currently pays more than $200 million annually to cover the difference between the 22 percent employer cap and the actual cost of the existing pension system. The current employer rate is approximately 27.5 percent.
The bill now moves to the Senate Rules Committee.
Senate panel advances retirement bill despite $400M cost shift concern
Senate Finance Committee advanced a retirement bill that would shift nearly $400 million in unfunded costs from municipalities to the state, rejecting an amendment that would have prevented the shift.
Read this story
The Senate Finance Committee advanced a major retirement reform bill Tuesday despite warnings it could shift nearly $400 million in unfunded liability costs from municipalities to the state over 13 years.
House Bill 78 would create a new defined benefit retirement option for public employees after years of operating under a defined contribution system. But actuarial analysis shows the bill would transfer $394.5 million in unfunded liability costs from 148 non-state PERS employers to Alaska state government between 2027 and 2039.
Sen. Bert Stedman proposed an amendment to raise the municipal contribution cap from 22 percent to 24 percent of payroll to prevent the cost shift. The amendment failed on a 6-1 vote, with only Stedman supporting it.
"If Amendment 1 is not adopted, if the bill is left the way it is, is it proper for the state of Alaska to pick up the cost of implementing the new tier for all the other 148 PERS employers?" Stedman asked during committee discussion.
Actuary David Kirshner from Arthur J. Gallagher explained that increasing the cap from 22 percent to 24 percent would increase non-state employer contributions by about $417 million while decreasing additional state contributions by about $403 million.
"The only way to achieve the goal of maintaining the status quo is essentially that over the 13-year period that we are looking at through FY39 to keep the additional state contributions roughly where they are currently," Kirshner said.
Sen. Jesse Kiehl opposed the amendment, arguing that the bill would bring offsetting benefits not captured in fiscal projections. "We have tremendous turnover costs," Kiehl said. "When you net it all out, we are not going to see an increased cost here to the state." Kiehl contended that improved employee retention under a defined benefit system would reduce recruitment and training expenses that currently burden state agencies due to high turnover rates.
Kiehl noted that raising the municipal contribution cap would increase costs for local governments regardless of whether actuarial assumptions prove correct. "It is sales tax dollars and it is property tax dollars," he said.
The committee approved two other amendments. One removed a 12 percent ceiling on adjustable employee contribution rates to prevent underfunding. Stedman supported removing the cap as a safeguard against creating unfunded liabilities.
"By removing this cap would give the Alaska Retirement Management board tools necessary," said committee chair Sen. Lyman Hoffman.
Another amendment failed that would have raised the retirement age from 60 to 65 for all employees except public safety personnel. Sen. Forrest Dunbar proposed the change to help ensure plan solvency, but it was rejected.
The bill creates a hybrid retirement system that would allow new public employees to choose between defined contribution and defined benefit options. Current projections show 149 PERS employers statewide, with roughly equal payrolls of about $1.4 billion each between state and non-state employers.
Committee members set the bill aside after considering amendments, with no immediate timeline announced for final action.














Comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.